It's because its not quite right. It is a bit more complicated than that. He's not taking into account how these forces vary along the length of the beam. There are actual equations that involve the position (x) that generate the actual curves instead of arbitrary lines he drew.
@@armandmatossian2081 The equations are represented by the graphical method. Split the beam and do the analytical method and you will find the same results. At the end of the day, the relationship between sheer and moments is an integral so what he does here to skip doing the cut and check method of moment drawing is correct. The integral of a flat line is a triangle as the area increases linearly with distance. The integral of a slope is a curve etc. People should learn both methods as they are equally applicable.
*** THANK YOU* I was genuinely having fun learning this and it makes *SOOOO MUCH SENSE NOW!* Order of the lines? *GENIUS!* Ski slope analogy? *BRILLIANT!* I was rethinking choosing engineering not too long ago, but you've rekindled my love for it again. I'm out of the darkness and can once again see the beauty that is engineering. *Thank you,* Mr. Hanson. Really thank you.
Dr. Hanson, You hands down have THE BEST explanations for me to grasp the concept. I've been coming back to your videos as I progress throughout my education. Thank you so much for taking time out of your busy schedule to assist students from all over the world. You have truly made an impact in more lives than you know, and we're so dang blessed to have amazing people like you helping to make successful engineers!
Thanks, Jeff. I am a Civil Engineer working for 7 years and I learned a few things that I should have when I was in College. They never taught like this.
Sir your style of teaching is so interactive and effective,you're doing a good job unlike cold profs who only dictate the lesson like robots.Keep up the good work!
Never stop teaching! You're excellent! (Why am I paying for a bored professor to teach me statics when I could literally watch you and learn so much more?)
you saved my life due. was stuck at the which type to choose like at 16:40 and was searching for a method for hours. you explained that crucial part with ease that most videos skiped . thanks
Thank you for explaining this so straight forward and simply. So many professors suffer from not being able to do that. You kept on the current subject and didn't speed up to fly through anything. You spent the time needed to fully explain and justify all steps you showed. Thank you again!
Thank you so much! I'm sharing this video with all of my classmates. With all of the remote learning happening right now, my professors are pretty unorganized and the lectures are unclear. I learned more in 19 minutes with you compared to hours that ive spent looking through the textbook and notes trying to figure out the missing pieces. Thanks again!
This is my second time watching this video in a span of 4 years and this is so incredible. You are the best. We need professors like this gentleman in school.
I have a professor that took two weeks to barely teach a class this stuff and I just come to you and learn it in twenty minutes better. Thanks professor
I’ve just gotta say I’ve been watching your videos for two years now and the way you teach is extraordinary. I bet you’d make Richard Feynman himself proud. Thanks from Australia!
Doing refresher stuff for my PE in structural. Focusing on reinforced concrete (have been using programs that do this for me and other engineers, but know I will need to do these diagrams myself) and am absolutely loving this. Bam! Wooop! Love how you do that. Keeps it interesting and it is obvious you like doing it. Thanks a bunch for the refresher!
Cannot express how much this series has helped me out, the explanations you provide are magnitudes more comprehensive and understandable than my actual professor. Major thanks!!
this man is amazing. I was lost before I watched this and now I am very confident in my ability to do this. The way he described this concept is superior to anything else I have seen. Truly amazing.
thanks. I was struggling going over the explanations in "Form and Forces". This made it so easy to understand and I was even laughing out loud at our ski slope explanation. This was super helpful. So happy to have taken the time to watch through it.
This is the best video series ever, I watch these videos before my lectures so I know what my professor is talking about. I truly appreciate these videos, thank you Jeff!
Just 5 days after my statics exam you publish this :(. Good thing i passed statics with a solid B thanks to your videos. Awesome teacher. Awesome channel.
I really love when someone can master in his profession, no matter what that profession is, even it's something not seem so exciting like teaching a class. If you can explain thing like this you have my respect.
Bravo sir! This is the most clear presentation I have seen on screwtoob. I had two college professors that taught statics and steel framing the way you do back in the early 90s.
"Hey man, if it helps you remember how to do these graphs, then I'll sing to you, I don't care." THESE SENTENCES ARE SO MEANINGFUL FOR ME, THANK YOU MR. HANSON
My native language is spanish, I am listening your video meanwhile I am at work doing my tasks and I really can get every concept that you explain on the video, good job professor!
Thank u for pointing out where the forces going at each point. Putting yr finger at wt point then other finger showing what direction really helped me. Yr the only person Ive seen on youtube to do it this logical way 👍
Bro, I was smiling the entire time because of how simple you made it to understand, like where have u been. I just wish I discovered ur videos earlier.
For whatever reason I had so much trouble with this topic, this video helps SO much! Especially the order of lines and the slow to fast thing, those were some of the main points of confusion for me. Thank you!
It really helps when lecturers state the relationships, how to set up the solution diagram/s for the interaction of those relationships and then how to solve the problem/question. I’ll be adopting the three levelled diagram when calculating the shear-bending diagram. Thanks Jeff.
if some of you dont know, these videos are remakes. Bless this man for not only giving us all this help but also updating the video even though he didnt have to
Thank you, you are better than my teacher. I wasted an entire day trying to understand, and in minutes you were able to make me understand very well by the way i am non english speaker
amen to everyone's comments. if only all engineering profs were like Jeff Hanson. school would be easier and more fun. i hope this channel is helping him rake in the big bucks
I enjoy these diagrams, but have struggled with some of the finer details since college. Now studying for my PE exam 6 years later - glad I found your videos. Thanks
woww i have been struggling these things for like days and just 3 minutes into your video am learning every concept..you such a wonderful lecture with a great personality i wish our lecture was like you.thank you
I was stressed out about being able to finish my mechanics MCQ paper on time but this method saved me and helped me to get an A+. Very thankful for your teaching sir!
Oh man! That was excellent! C student here…long time engineer with PE license. Been a long time! Great refresher, understand it better than I ever have!
Weeee lovee your singing and pretty much yourr self, please keep acting the way you are! It helps us forget hard times and it also makes us laugh and at the same time make learning more entertaining! I am very thankful for this channel and to you forever!!!
Commeted when i had 5 min left of the video, but i got to say it again. This stuff is truly amazing. Your attitude trough out the video made me smile and made it fun learing. Thank you!!
This was an amazing video. Easy to understand and entertaining. Thought i watched like 5 min, but i had watched 15min. Usually its the oppsite. You are truly a great teacher
You're so awesome! I missed a few lectures and couldn't keep up because they were long and the lectures method was more complex but I watched your videos and everything made sense in less than an hour. Your tips and tricks are the best! I enjoy watching your videos. Thank you!
Dr jeff is the best so far. ive watched a lot of yt teachers and Dr jeff is number one . the jokes and funny moments during lecture really make me love engineering.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
this man's explanations are clearer than clear water.
certified goat.
I was just about to say that; until I read your comment😂😂
@@dyota2277 😂😂😂 bro ur taking 242 rn?
these videos are remakes of older statics videos. he didnt need to remake but he did. what a goat
I was watching some videos on my native language and I understood them way less than this legend
I think so to you !
Just 7 minutes into the video and I just can’t help smiling and appreciating this man. Such a great teacher with likeable personality.
I read your comment at 7:20 with the same exact expression in mind hehe some teachers have a gift to teach, and others are just there to try...
The Order of the Lines is brilliant! No one explains it that simply.
exactly bro HAHA. All our professor's saying is to memorize things, not understand. Unlike the lessons of Prf. Jeff
It's because its not quite right. It is a bit more complicated than that. He's not taking into account how these forces vary along the length of the beam. There are actual equations that involve the position (x) that generate the actual curves instead of arbitrary lines he drew.
@@armandmatossian2081 The equations are represented by the graphical method. Split the beam and do the analytical method and you will find the same results. At the end of the day, the relationship between sheer and moments is an integral so what he does here to skip doing the cut and check method of moment drawing is correct. The integral of a flat line is a triangle as the area increases linearly with distance. The integral of a slope is a curve etc. People should learn both methods as they are equally applicable.
@@JeronimoStilton14people often skip theory, thats why they unaware of schwedler theorem
Dude I have never felt love like this before you make it much understandeble than my books been struggling with this for a week
*** THANK YOU* I was genuinely having fun learning this and it makes *SOOOO MUCH SENSE NOW!* Order of the lines? *GENIUS!* Ski slope analogy? *BRILLIANT!* I was rethinking choosing engineering not too long ago, but you've rekindled my love for it again. I'm out of the darkness and can once again see the beauty that is engineering. *Thank you,* Mr. Hanson. Really thank you.
Best proffesor ever , i didn’t understand anything from 30hours at uni but understand anything in 19 minutes :)
Absolutely
You are such an amazing professor, every teacher should learn from you
This man is such a phenomenal teacher. He explains things so well. Most professors couldn't explain the difference between an elephant and a rock.
Both grey and heavy ... 🤣
i feel so lucky that these videos exist while i am learning civil engineering. thanks so much, jeff.
Finally I found the correct channel. Thanks for sharing that valuable information. Greetings from Peru.
Dr. Hanson,
You hands down have THE BEST explanations for me to grasp the concept. I've been coming back to your videos as I progress throughout my education. Thank you so much for taking time out of your busy schedule to assist students from all over the world. You have truly made an impact in more lives than you know, and we're so dang blessed to have amazing people like you helping to make successful engineers!
Thanks, Jeff. I am a Civil Engineer working for 7 years and I learned a few things that I should have when I was in College. They never taught like this.
Mine they caught me a formula v(x) and m(x)
I pray your wife makes you your favorite food everyday in your life
Hahahah.
It is good
Hahaha yeah he deserve that
ROFL...🤣🤣🤣
That woman better do her job .
ahahhahahahah
Sir your style of teaching is so interactive and effective,you're doing a good job unlike cold profs who only dictate the lesson like robots.Keep up the good work!
I need a bonding moment after all this statics.
painschamp
Never stop teaching! You're excellent! (Why am I paying for a bored professor to teach me statics when I could literally watch you and learn so much more?)
you saved my life due. was stuck at the which type to choose like at 16:40 and was searching for a method for hours. you explained that crucial part with ease that most videos skiped . thanks
Thank you for explaining this so straight forward and simply. So many professors suffer from not being able to do that. You kept on the current subject and didn't speed up to fly through anything. You spent the time needed to fully explain and justify all steps you showed. Thank you again!
Hey man, you're the reason I'm passing statics this semester. thank you for all your videos!
Thank you so much! I'm sharing this video with all of my classmates. With all of the remote learning happening right now, my professors are pretty unorganized and the lectures are unclear. I learned more in 19 minutes with you compared to hours that ive spent looking through the textbook and notes trying to figure out the missing pieces. Thanks again!
This is my second time watching this video in a span of 4 years and this is so incredible. You are the best. We need professors like this gentleman in school.
I have a professor that took two weeks to barely teach a class this stuff and I just come to you and learn it in twenty minutes better. Thanks professor
I’ve just gotta say I’ve been watching your videos for two years now and the way you teach is extraordinary. I bet you’d make Richard Feynman himself proud. Thanks from Australia!
Doing refresher stuff for my PE in structural. Focusing on reinforced concrete (have been using programs that do this for me and other engineers, but know I will need to do these diagrams myself) and am absolutely loving this.
Bam! Wooop! Love how you do that. Keeps it interesting and it is obvious you like doing it. Thanks a bunch for the refresher!
Cannot express how much this series has helped me out, the explanations you provide are magnitudes more comprehensive and understandable than my actual professor. Major thanks!!
If we had more Jeff Hanson, there would never be shortage of engineers in this country. Thank you Dr. Professor
Jump by Van Halen, what a classic. I'm 20 but I love the 80's glad this professor has a good taste of music. Caught that reference! 11:13
this man is amazing. I was lost before I watched this and now I am very confident in my ability to do this. The way he described this concept is superior to anything else I have seen. Truly amazing.
thanks. I was struggling going over the explanations in "Form and Forces". This made it so easy to understand and I was even laughing out loud at our ski slope explanation. This was super helpful. So happy to have taken the time to watch through it.
This is the best video series ever, I watch these videos before my lectures so I know what my professor is talking about. I truly appreciate these videos, thank you Jeff!
Just 5 days after my statics exam you publish this :(. Good thing i passed statics with a solid B thanks to your videos. Awesome teacher. Awesome channel.
I was trying to revisit (relearn) my student days over 40 years ago and I find Dr Hanson's teaching superb.
Prof Hanson, I have no doubt that your purpose on earth is to impart knowledge. One can't ask for more explanation. Thank you!
None of my professors have ever explained anything this clear. Thank you 🙏
1 million views and you deserve it!
From Van Halen to John Denver! Perfect! I’m 59 (BSME 93), and find myself remembering this!
Dr. Hanson excellent job!
I really love when someone can master in his profession, no matter what that profession is, even it's something not seem so exciting like teaching a class. If you can explain thing like this you have my respect.
Minute 13-13:32 had me cracking up. Thanks for making learning this so fun!
Bravo sir! This is the most clear presentation I have seen on screwtoob. I had two college professors that taught statics and steel framing the way you do back in the early 90s.
"Hey man, if it helps you remember how to do these graphs, then I'll sing to you, I don't care." THESE SENTENCES ARE SO MEANINGFUL FOR ME, THANK YOU MR. HANSON
Dr. Hanson, you make these courses so much fun!🤗 You are much appreciated across the globe. Thank you so much🙏
Jeff Hanson for President 🤝
My native language is spanish, I am listening your video meanwhile I am at work doing my tasks and I really can get every concept that you explain on the video, good job professor!
Thank u for pointing out where the forces going at each point. Putting yr finger at wt point then other finger showing what direction really helped me. Yr the only person Ive seen on youtube to do it this logical way 👍
This video helped me so much! I have had three professors teach me this concept, and I finally learned it in this video. You did an amazing job!
Bro, I was smiling the entire time because of how simple you made it to understand, like where have u been. I just wish I discovered ur videos earlier.
Im an engineer, and your explanation helped me to understand better this approach in a simpler way. Appreciate it Jeff!! Im subscribing.
For whatever reason I had so much trouble with this topic, this video helps SO much! Especially the order of lines and the slow to fast thing, those were some of the main points of confusion for me. Thank you!
I can't thank you enough i wouldn't have done great in the course without your videos.
It really helps when lecturers state the relationships, how to set up the solution diagram/s for the interaction of those relationships and then how to solve the problem/question.
I’ll be adopting the three levelled diagram when calculating the shear-bending diagram.
Thanks Jeff.
This 20min vids is so Helpful. It makes so easy than understanding a book for about a day...
Dr. Hanson thank you so much! I will be watching all your series from now on!
This man saves me before every test and exam! He explains it amazingly!
hope every teacher is as good as you teach ! im enjoying the sound effects and the singing haha learning is fun
he is one of the coolest tutors , I have ever seen on youtube. Great explanation
Thank you Jeff, I came to this video for mechanics of materials and am now back again for structual analysis
Truly THE goat
if some of you dont know, these videos are remakes. Bless this man for not only giving us all this help but also updating the video even though he didnt have to
The man who made me love statics. Big respects.
ive been struggling on these for the past week and this video made it click instantly. thank you so much!
I wish I have instructors like him in my uni ... he makes everything fun and clear to understand!
My strength of material teacher spent 2 mins explaining this and moved on like everyone understood it or smthn...ur the best ❤
Watched it again a year later for my FE exam. Thank you so much! this is so far the best FE/PE exam video I've ever watched.
Thank you, you are better than my teacher. I wasted an entire day trying to understand, and in minutes you were able to make me understand very well by the way i am non english speaker
Sir you are an absolute legend, I've watched a few videos on this topic but couldn't understand them. You explain it so well. Thank you.
amen to everyone's comments. if only all engineering profs were like Jeff Hanson. school would be easier and more fun. i hope this channel is helping him rake in the big bucks
first guy on Earth who makes learning fun .....Thank You Sir!
I enjoy these diagrams, but have struggled with some of the finer details since college. Now studying for my PE exam 6 years later - glad I found your videos. Thanks
woww i have been struggling these things for like days and just 3 minutes into your video am learning every concept..you such a wonderful lecture with a great personality i wish our lecture was like you.thank you
I was stressed out about being able to finish my mechanics MCQ paper on time but this method saved me and helped me to get an A+. Very thankful for your teaching sir!
Thanks for the video. You've really helped me understand Shear/Moments diagrams more now.
Oh man! That was excellent! C student here…long time engineer with PE license. Been a long time! Great refresher, understand it better than I ever have!
I've an exam tomorrow and you helped me alot ❤
I cant thank you enough. You made me understand something so fast that my lecturers couldn’t teach me in months…
Weeee lovee your singing and pretty much yourr self, please keep acting the way you are! It helps us forget hard times and it also makes us laugh and at the same time make learning more entertaining! I am very thankful for this channel and to you forever!!!
Commeted when i had 5 min left of the video, but i got to say it again. This stuff is truly amazing. Your attitude trough out the video made me smile and made it fun learing. Thank you!!
You are an amazing teacher. Keep up the good work.
thanks for singlehandedly getting me through my statics class I had to take online thanks to covid. I got a A-. You're a real one.
I love this man. I can't help but to laugh at all his silly, but hilarious, comments. Thanks a lot professor ❤
This was an amazing video. Easy to understand and entertaining. Thought i watched like 5 min, but i had watched 15min. Usually its the oppsite. You are truly a great teacher
I wish I had a teacher like you back I was in school .
I have never enjoyed Statics class like this before. Thank you very much sir!
Thank you so much Dr. 19 min and clarified every single thing
Cracked me up with computer noises during the calculation. The best teacher I have SEEN IN YEARS!
You're so awesome! I missed a few lectures and couldn't keep up because they were long and the lectures method was more complex but I watched your videos and everything made sense in less than an hour. Your tips and tricks are the best! I enjoy watching your videos. Thank you!
Studying for the NCARB ARE's. This is the best explanation of shear and moment I've seen. Thanks!
Thank you Jeff. You made my civil engineering degree so much easier where lecturer's are too useless to explain competently
ive actually found the jackpot with these lessons. thank you
Professor Hanson, this Shear Moment Diagram explanation is excellent. The Graphic Method makes this lecture easy to follow.
I am 6 minutes into the video and you have already helped more than my mech e mat teacher. Thank you!
Dr jeff is the best so far. ive watched a lot of yt teachers and Dr jeff is number one . the jokes and funny moments during lecture really make me love engineering.
DUDE!!! I was struggling so much and you made this so crystal clear you are my new favourite human!
It is impossible to ask for a better explanation than this!
you are the best teacher in the world, every word you explain is etching on my mind involuntarily, thank yooou
This man is single handedly saving my college career
u are the best teacher i found - better than those who i pay every semester
Eddie Van Halen and John Denver zeroin' out some shear moments on the ski slope. BEST. VIDEO. EVER.
omg!!! you are a perfect teacher.thanks from Turkey
NO TO SKIP ADS TO THIS MAN BECAUSE HE DESERVE IT PERIOD
You are simply the best teacher on Earth. I love the creativity that you put in your videos, keep going like this professor!
This video was amusing, thanks Dr. Jeff you're genuinly an amazing person.