It's sort of a sideways question. I'm really interested in this Winckelmann character and if there are differences between art historians and art critics. Did the two jobs start as one and split? Are they still the same? Is there a pantheon of art historians and critics who are major players in developing the art history canon? Is there an art history canon? Thank you for making my lunch breaks so educational!
Angelina, glad you enjoy the videos! These are some great questions. Although there is certainly some overlap, art historians generally are looking at the context and meaning around art pieces, movements, and periods whereas critics are strictly analyzing whether one piece is good or not. For example, Winckelmann was studying ancient Roman and Greek art in historical context and finding meaning that was applied to Neoclassicism. I'm sure he acted as a "critic" at times in deciding what made that art good, but he was doing so in a more historical context. Here's a good article on famous art historians: blog.academyart.edu/7-famous-art-historians-who-changed-the-field/ Some of these historians are also considered critics. In regards to art history canon, there doesn't seem to be a well established canon. Generally historians will agree on important literature within art history, and art history books often have the same important artworks related to movements or periods. But there is not a well-defined art history canon. Literature and important artworks will differ quite a bit depending on who you talk to within art history. Hope this helps!
Every time I read a chapter in my art history book, I then go and watch your video on the subject which has helped me TREMENDOUSLY and given me SO MUCH more understanding
hi great video. if it's really ornate but features classical designs like ionic columns and scenes from greek mythology is it neoclassical or rococco or baroque? thanks./ ps theres a video i did earlier on here im trying to figure out if i incorrectly called it neoclassical.
Thanks 😊 Yes, I'm planning to get to symbolist art. It's difficult to pick my content as there are so many great movements, artists, and artworks throughout history!
Yes! It was painted during the height of Neoclassicism. The subject matter, the tight/clean brushstrokes, and the colors make it very much Neoclasical.
@@ArtHistorywithAlder thank you for the quick response, you seriously made me happy. The painting is based on the odyssey, could this also be a characteristic that I can use to motivate my answer to the question “what style does it belong to, how can you tell and name the features of the particular style that caused you to come to your decision”
@@user-nn5rp7jw2h yes, not specifically because of the Odyssey story itself, but because the Odyssey is a part of Greek myth and culture. Neoclassists returned to these Greek and Roman morals and ideas, so they often used or portrayed their stories in art.
@@ArtHistorywithAlder thank you ❤️ I am working on a report about artwork based on the Odyssey for school. You really helped me I will now continue with the information you shared. I might have other questions later on :)
What questions or comments do you have about the Neoclassical art period?
It's sort of a sideways question. I'm really interested in this Winckelmann character and if there are differences between art historians and art critics. Did the two jobs start as one and split? Are they still the same? Is there a pantheon of art historians and critics who are major players in developing the art history canon? Is there an art history canon?
Thank you for making my lunch breaks so educational!
Angelina, glad you enjoy the videos! These are some great questions.
Although there is certainly some overlap, art historians generally are looking at the context and meaning around art pieces, movements, and periods whereas critics are strictly analyzing whether one piece is good or not. For example, Winckelmann was studying ancient Roman and Greek art in historical context and finding meaning that was applied to Neoclassicism. I'm sure he acted as a "critic" at times in deciding what made that art good, but he was doing so in a more historical context.
Here's a good article on famous art historians: blog.academyart.edu/7-famous-art-historians-who-changed-the-field/
Some of these historians are also considered critics.
In regards to art history canon, there doesn't seem to be a well established canon. Generally historians will agree on important literature within art history, and art history books often have the same important artworks related to movements or periods. But there is not a well-defined art history canon. Literature and important artworks will differ quite a bit depending on who you talk to within art history.
Hope this helps!
Who else was sent here by your art teacher 👇
you explain stuff so well! if i score well on my exam, most of the credit would go to you.
Thanks, best of luck on your exam!
Every time I read a chapter in my art history book, I then go and watch your video on the subject which has helped me TREMENDOUSLY and given me SO MUCH more understanding
Thanks so much for sharing! Glad my videos have been helpful 😊
hi great video. if it's really ornate but features classical designs like ionic columns and scenes from greek mythology is it neoclassical or rococco or baroque? thanks./ ps theres a video i did earlier on here im trying to figure out if i incorrectly called it neoclassical.
corinthian columns i mean
Hey Alder I want to know about the classical styles used by palladio and in doge's castle in Venice where they Neoclassical, romanesque or what?
What are the visible Neoclassic or Romantic characteristics of the artwork?
This was a wonderful refresher. Thank you for this video.
Well I hate it. I like rococo and baroque way more you know how they say: dululu is the sololo😂
Why aren't you uploading video in history
So glad I found this channel! Recently got into art history with zero background in it
thanks you help me
Good
This period's art is the pinnacle of human art. After this it was all downhill.
how is neoclassicism different form renaissance as both deals with revival of classical antiquity art ?
What is your favourite and most significant painting from the neoclassical period ?
Very clear and understandable overview. For someone just getting into Art History this is very informative thank you.
have you considered doing an overview of symbolist art ? I like these history videos.
Thanks 😊 Yes, I'm planning to get to symbolist art. It's difficult to pick my content as there are so many great movements, artists, and artworks throughout history!
well done bro i am ready for next exam at my teacher mihailo
Excellent video! Thank you!
We can't hear yr voice properly
Ypu ate bor used to hearing the human voice naturally, unenhanced.I can hear her fine
Nice ❤ (Leo)
I just started today! I have an exam on Tuesday. It doesn't seem too frightening after this. THANK YOU SO MUCH
Great to hear, and good luck on your exam!
Such a great work i hope u all the best .and accept my sincere thanks from Egypt Reham 💓🤩 please continue that. عمل متقن ورائع
Thank you! I will definitely continue. In fact, I'm currently working on an Ancient Egyptian Art video 😊. Should be published next week!
Wow better explanation 😊❤
wow art history is so cool !!
Thanks for this great summary. My favourite neoclassical art is from Frederick Leighton.
is the painting Helen Recognizing Telemachus by Jean-Jacques Lagrenée also neoclassical art?
Yes! It was painted during the height of Neoclassicism. The subject matter, the tight/clean brushstrokes, and the colors make it very much Neoclasical.
@@ArtHistorywithAlder thank you for the quick response, you seriously made me happy. The painting is based on the odyssey, could this also be a characteristic that I can use to motivate my answer to the question “what style does it belong to, how can you tell and name the features of the particular style that caused you to come to your decision”
@@user-nn5rp7jw2h yes, not specifically because of the Odyssey story itself, but because the Odyssey is a part of Greek myth and culture. Neoclassists returned to these Greek and Roman morals and ideas, so they often used or portrayed their stories in art.
@@ArtHistorywithAlder thank you ❤️ I am working on a report about artwork based on the Odyssey for school. You really helped me I will now continue with the information you shared. I might have other questions later on :)
what style does the painting Penelope and the Suitors by John William Waterhouse belong to?
Dear Alder, thank you for this very interesting video. My students and me absolutely loved it. Wish you all the best.