So, Andrew, it looks like it might be time to consider what to do for your subscriber no. 20,000... May I suggest something about tomatoes? You know, to keep with the tradition... 😂 Aka Run BTS episode 31 😁: ua-cam.com/video/OwgbF0OqPD4/v-deo.html Or just the tomato part: ua-cam.com/video/thleMGobncc/v-deo.html
Namjoons rap in Look Here is so iconic and I was looking forward to Caitlin's reaction and she didn't disappoint! I squeal inside every time I hear it too 😅
Andrew that segway to the sponsor was smooth like butter. Also Caitlin calling RM expression hey girl had me dying!! I enjoyed watching you guys react to this! This is truly a masterpiece and a new amazing video. Thanks for another amazing reaction again guys! CFA
Wings is such a masterpiece, its whole album "You Never Walk Alone" is a masterpiece to be honest. Caitlin is all of us when RM says "Whats poppin girl" hahaha
I knew Hobi wouldn't stay in that chair long. RM's rapid-fire rapping in Look Here was all it took 4:21. (Hey, Andrew, for your spreadsheet: Ugh! Ugh! Ugh! Outro: Tear, Outro: Tear, Outro: Tear, Blue Side, Blue Side, Blue Side, Blue Side...😉)
Caitlin is such a happy pill. All these songs specially Outro:wings, Pied Piper and Ugh are such fun songs but the lyrics are so deep. U should listen to these songs separately focusing on the lyrics and music production. I just watched PTD Seoul concert online and it was so fun. M justbwondering what they would do differently in Las Vegas concerts. Looking forward to next Friday(or earlier if u decide to surprise us). Take care...both of u.
@@AndrewBergSax Andrew are you going to go to the Global theatre live viewing? PTD on Stage being streamed to theatres all over the world... they'll do delayed viewing for your timezone so you wont have to get up in the middle of the night!
Watching this made me so happy just seeing my boys smile and having fun, it also showed me why I loved all the songs that they performed. Also Jimin was defo the pies piper during the performance as he just hypnotized me and I couldn't keep my eyes of off him (also I might be biased saying that as he is my ult bias)
PS. The band was live but not on screen T-T , they are Ghost band, the same in the npr and the BBC Radio 1 performances. Most of the bandmates have instagram (more active) and twitter. And the drummer has a yt channel and he used to post videos from the concerts waaay back. Names: docskim (he has the cutest little daughter, keyboard, producer), blackswanz (guitar), khan drummer (his social media accts include the drummer! XD), ki_wook (bass)
Thank you!! I actually didn't realize it was a live band for this set! I assumed they just had the band record it so the guys could sing over a track. That's awesome! And also explains how fluidly the guys could talk and then start singing the next song
@@AngelaSealana Thanks T-T I love the shoutouts to the band. They are incredible (as our bangtannies are)! And Mr Son but he wasn't involved in those Tae moves afaik XD :*
Welcome back Caitlin!! I'm so happy to see you all better - your face through this entire thing is actually bringing me more joy than the original video and that is saying A LOT.💜
@@AndrewBergSax Hehe, sorry about that - it was a bit outdated 😄Not that I can recognize myself much in that tiny circle, so that makes two of us😜Anyway, I'm so excited for this, I totally messed up on the poll but it was worth it!Have the most amazing evening you guys, and much love to the puppies☺
Andrew and Caitlin great reaction! The guys chose the perfect songs for their medley through the years of BTS. It is always fun to see the joy you two have watching our boys .😁 Caitlin's love for RM and Jimin brings me happiness! 😊 Andrew pointing out the interesting or unique musical choices and techniques is a must! But seeing him fanboy out is my happy place.😊 Journey on... 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
There is so much for you guys to discover still! I can't wait! Like BTS has no bad songs! Each one is it's own little jem. Looking forward to Caitlin squeeing over the members singing lol!
Glad Caitlin is feeling better! The rap line really does adjust their voices to the style of the song. Suga has mentioned that he doesn't really draw a line between rapping and singing. They all just have such wonderful voice control!
I’m new here but I find it funnily endearing that you can tell he’s a teacher with that “master spreadsheet” of his and I couldn’t stop laughing and being shocked at that being the first time I’ve ever seen anyone do something like this for BTS 😂 points and many thumbs up from me! Imma be watching more videos for the sheer dedication you guys have 😭
I'm so glad you reacted to the version with subs!! Basically none of us did that, we just watched it when it came out LOL. Also, you will soon learn that outros can be some of the absolute best songs in BTS's entire discography. I mean, "Outro: Tear", hello? Anyways, this was so fun and healing to watch lol thank you so much :D CFA
Caitlin’s pure unadulterated joy in all of these reactions, but in this one in particular, manages to bring a smile to my face as much as BTS does! I can’t wait for y’all to react to their earlier works!
Miss you Caitlin! so glad seeing you both enjoyed it so much. Hope you get to see the BTS 2021 Festa Army Playlist as well. Love that too! Its them singing parts of each of their solo songs, mostly songs that are not in their albums but only uploaded on Soundcloud.
pied piper is a song telling armys to study and to not be too obsessed with bts, but we all choose to ignore it 😂 ugh is about the misuse of anger, a “pure” emotion that should be used for important things (like protests against injustice) instead of being wasted as hate comments on the internet telepathy was written during the quarantine and is a song basically telling armys that bts and armys are always together telepathically even if they can’t see each other in person i love you guys’ energy ! can’t wait for the albums’ reaction. i hope you will pay a lot of attention to the lyrics, they are always very beautiful, deep or simply iconic :) since you liked the rapline rapping over korean sounding music, i would heavily recommend ‘ddaeng’. it’s a diss track released for festa 2018 for free on soundcloud. the amount of play words in it is astounding, RM even uses 7 different uses of the word ‘ddaeng’ in his verse !! thanks for the reaction ! 💜
Hi. Firstly, I love the way you have placed emphasis on our boys i.e. focusing the bigger screen on our boys instead of yourselves, unlike other reactors who focus the bigger screen on themselves. I see you, I see the love you have for them, I see the way their music moves you. Spot on comments too. Just keep doing what you're doing. My 1st time watching you and I'm already a fan. Btw, I'm a 55 year-old Army mom with 2 BTS Army daughters and a very cool 68 year-old Army husband. 💜
I don't know how many times i have already watched this reaction, my brain is a bit mushy... but here we go! First of all, so good to see you again Caitlin! Oohhh those Tteokbokki look so good! 😋 Caitlin's reaction to "what's poppin girl" is wonderful. And when you two were laughing about that again during the livestream yesterday, I internally screamed because I knew where episode 11 would go 😁 And sidenote, everytime i hear RM going off in Look Here i get nervious, because that song is notoriously difficult to master in the Rhythm Hive game, and i've been stuck on a level with it for months 😣 But it's such a groove! So I can't give up on it 💪 "Outro:Wings... this is the outro to an album!? this is intens!" ... erm... yeah, that's one way to describe the entire album 😅 you already know a couple of the songs, but there's still more to come. And they have performed this song quite a lot in recent years, they seem to love performing it just as much as we love hearing it. Pied Piper, what can I say? the theme song of ARMYs? them just flexing on us how they can draw us in, the power they hold over us? yeah. And of course, the vocal control, just casually, sitting down crosslegged, my diaphragm would be protesting and throw in the towel if i ever tried anything like that. Harmonized rapping: YES! 🤩 There are more instances where they do that, of course. The ability to not only play with intricate rhythms and rhymes, but also stay in key and sometimes create melodies was also one of the reasons why I was drawn to their rapping more than (most) other rappers i have typically heard onthe radio. 🤭 Ugh - "getting serious" yeah 😅 the vibe definitely switched up in their performance, and also in the lyrics. It'll be interesting to see the full reaction to this, also with the explanation attached, because this is once again one of those with lots of references and cultural aspects hidden in the lyrics, even if it doesn't appear to at first glance maybe. 16:35 Caitlin giggling over the background action: yeah 😁 this would be a classic video where you have to watch it at least 8 times, once for the overview and then 7 times to focus on each member, because they're all going off to do some random things 😁 and we love them for it. Thank you so much for this entertaining watch! 💜 🥕 CFA
Hahaha I think this is your longest comment yet! 😂 "What's poppin girl" will make an appearance again soon.... 👀 I really want to react to Outro: Wings soon! That one was awesome and I need to hear it again. Guitars, harmonized rapping?! So good. And I need to listen to a rap line song!!! Idk if it will be UGH, Ddaeng, or Outro: Tear, but I'll do one of them soon!
@@AndrewBergSax apparently i had a lot of thoughts 😅 Outro Wings will be wonderful! And no matter which one you pick, all of these rapline songs are excellent. Outro:Tear is very emotional, Ddaeng is another example of them using traditional instruments and very clever lyrics, And Ugh is another one of those "it's not a BTS album if there is not a song about societal issues" (loosely quoting Suga, i believe).
Oh I saw my name on the comments Authors spreadsheet! Mom, I'm on Andrew's video!!!!! I don't comment a lot but I'm here watching every video you release, and as I always say on twitter (when someone asks me) you are one of "my fave bts reactors ever"!!!
Your reaction was so much fun to watch! Thank you! I highly recommend 'Dimple' + 'Pied Piper' live from the 5th Muster: Magic Shop Concert in Seoul in 2019! It's an eye and ear candy!
Great suggestion, I have to add that Caitlin may need some smelling salts for this after seeing her reaction to RM's "What's poppin', girl?", just a warning, lol. 😄
PS: Telepathy was written by Suga (Yoongi) in his typical way (30 min) during the pandemic and talking about ARMY since we couldn't see each other (esp we see them, but they couldn't see us). It ties up with his line in Life goes on ("between me and you things hasn't changed") and that was used in today's concert in Seoul T-T (at the entrance, they give army/the audience a banner to show at a set time during the concert, you can see it in the guys OT7 tweet after the concert or JHope's instagram) ^^
This is just a perfect little polished jewel of a music box! It makes me happy every time I watch it or see someone else watch it for the first time (got to show it to my sister-in-law and niece who introduced *me* to BTS -- sweet sweet vindication!). This was where I first heard Outro:Wings and Pied Piper and pretty much sat up straight in my chair and hit replay a couple dozen times. :D Your spreadsheet is awesome, you organizational nerd, you! I have never, ever, in my entire life, made a spreadsheet or chart to keep track of a current obsession ::stuffs papers back in drawer, minimizes windows:: Color-coded conditional formatting? Never heard of her!
the intros and outros of BTS albums are ALWAYS amazing!!! they don't do things halfway, their albums are full of bangers literally from beginning to end. so glad you reacted to this!! can't wait 'til you start doing album reviews! is gonna be so fun :)
omg i almost cackled out loud when you actually showed what your spreadsheet looks like! I LOVE IT as someone who has a (probably ridiculous) number of spreadsheets for pretty much any sort of information i need to organize, i applaud your use of spreadsheet for bts songs 🤣 also this reaction is just all smiles for me~ it's awesome to see you two enjoying this little trip through their discography! outro wings (which is basically the full version of interlude wings which was the last track of the wings album) was already fantastic AND THEN HOPEKOOK WENT AND DID THAT HARMONY IN LIVE PERFORMANCES AND ALL I COULD DO WAS SCREAM WITH IMMENSE JOY ps - the BE album is just pronounced "be" ^^
Hahaha I love spreadsheets so much 😅 I literally only showed like half of what I have in there 🙈 I can't wait to hear the full version of Outro: Wings!! And thank you for the pronunciation! I made an assumption because of it being in all caps!
I just got a bass ukulele and my 9 year old kid stole it (he's already a bass guitar player) and found the tab for Telepathy, and started playing it, and noticed that the verse drop is the only real bridge, but the bass line is the same throughout ... and besides the intro, the bass tab only has like 8 bars? And we were marvelling at the composition; it's easily my favourite song on BE, and I love it so much, and I never found it boring or 'sameish' -- the bass line is sensational -- and yet it's the same 8 bars all the way through 🤯 It's really wild to get a glimpse under the hood of some of these songs, is my point, and your reactions help us do that. So thanks! And I loved your reaction to Festa Room. Festa and Muster are rare opportunities for ARMY to hear some of BTS's older repertoire because many of them rarely show up on concert setlist. Look Here, Like, Pied Piper. Swoon! Ooh look, I wrote a novel 🤣
You guys are too cute! You had me laughing right along with you! I love this Festa Live because it showcases what they can do with their voices and showcases their personalities. I like this version with the subtitles of their conversation as well as the lyrics. Thanks again for another great and fun reaction!💜💜
this is my first time getting to read captions of their little comments in between songs so thank you for going that extra step. I was laughing without the captions but now im laughing all over again😂 I loved this! you both look so invested and excited, barely able to contain how happy you are just watching them which I definitely relate to💜 I have seen this Festa Room Live sooo many times because it’s just that good tbh. I would recommend to anyone just starting BTS. you see their personality, relationships, live voices and sneak peek into the discography. great video and great reaction☺️👏🏾
OMG you need to react to Blue and Gray. It's so beautiful and has a very thoughtful message. I LOVE it and I hope you will too. The MTV performance is killer!
Outro: wings is MY SONG!!! I listened to it everyday for a month, it's just that good!! They also performed it in yesterday's concert too, i was so happy. They know we love that song lol
What the heck? That spreadsheet is the most impressive thing I've ever seen from a reaction channel. That's so amazingly detailed. I mean this is my first video I've seen from you guys and the reaction itself was super fun and cute but now I'm extra impressed by the behind the scenes work you put in. Great job putting what you learnt on Skillshare to work.
Thank you!! I'm definitely proud of that spreadsheet 😂 As soon as I started reacting to BTS and had hundreds of comments requesting I react to certain songs, I knew I needed to try and get organized. Glad you enjoyed the video!
It must be very nice husband and wife have a same interest and enjoying it together. Love seeing such joyful faces and having fun while doing reaction.
Wow, you are so prepared and knowledgable about the videos you're reacting to! That spreadsheet is really cool. Also love the subtle way the frame around your video lights up when you guys talk!
Oh man-I think you two would LOVE ‘Ugh!’ I’d recommend a lyric video, their live performance for ‘Map of the soul ONE’ then the explanation video from DKDKTV. It’s such a good song to dive into for deeper meaning. As always, LOVE your reactions and going down the rabbit hole with you two 💜
That spread sheet is EPIC! Respect. I can tell you off top, the second song, the one RM starts off with "What's popin' girl?" Is called "Look here." It is one of their most underrated songs but its on my BTS Top 10! Which is hard to pick! Because it friggin SLLLAPPS! And the harmonies are 😘👌 It's a perfect driving song! It'll get you in a great mood in 10 seconds! Its on "Dark & Wild" one of their best albums for sure!
Yay Caitlin! This is my favorite way to show folks the variety of b-sides they have had. So many kinds of music they try. Also they are such spazs and so chaotic we love it! I love love love the spreadsheet I have never loved something more. You were made to be Army the most organized of fandoms and great way to slip in the Skillshare link, I didn’t even mind. Absolutely brighten my day.
LOVE this reaction! This is one of my favourite videos ever! Pied Piper is a fantastic song for you to react to. Usually people pair it with Dimple and it works really well - there's a double performance of Dimple+Pied Piper that will blow your mind! Your spreadsheet is *chefs kiss* I love all your videos and I love it when Caitlyn joins, you guys bounce off each other in such a lovely way! I love the way she surmises things and comes up with the funniest things - a 60s bachelor pad 😅 so perfect!
I actually trade off a little bit for the livestreams! I do 10am PST some weeks and 8pm PST other weeks! I tried to make it so everyone has a chance to be there!
What's popping, Caitlin?? I need Caitlin's laughtrack in my life. I'm glad she's back and feeling better! 💜 BTS B-side songs are amazing! I'm so glad you're reacting to this now and I can't wait till you react to each individual songs! And also that sponsor plug was smooth like butter. ;D CFA
Kudos for the clever way you led into your advertisement... (I don't know how else to say it--- but it was much smoother/ less awkward than I've seen on other channels.) love your enthusiasm.
Welcome back Caitlin! This video is so fun and I've probably watched it too many times lol. Definitely recommend Agust D, Daechitwa, UGH!, Cypher 4, Outro: Tear for rap songs. Other songs that are really good if you haven't heard them before are 134340, Let Go, Magic Shop, Fly to my Room, Paradise, Dis-ease, Love Maze, Answer: Love Myself ad so many more, I can't remember all but these are all really good. Outro: Wings is one of my favorites and same I'm amazed that it's an outro song💜😀
Hahaha got to get those votes in for the spreadsheet! 😂 Thanks for the recommendations and I can let you know that one of those for sure is coming up in the next few weeks!
You've heard one of my top 10 BTS songs, "Outro: Wings"!!!! 🥲 I LOVE IT!! You both are back together on camera and it was so much fun watching your reaction, I had little tears in the corners of my eyes 😄💜 I am seriously looking forward to hearing your thoughts on all the gems in BTS' B-sides. Dare I say this video made my day!? CFA
Hahaha I'm so glad you liked it 😊 I'm excited for more b-sides too! And I feel like I need to move Outro: Wings up the list possibly because I want to listen to it on my own 😂
Yay! Glad to see Caitlin back! Hope you are feeling better. And don't get us all wrong, Andrew, we love you as much ;) So, now that you are open to maybe less title tracks... I suggest: Rain!!!!!! (and maybe all intros and outros XD, up to you, but they are THAT good!), Autumn Leaves, Am I wrong? (relevant once again, now the conservatives have won in yesterday's elections in SK -___-)
@@AndrewBergSax Haha, I just wanted to enter the excel file :P but you can do polls too and actually select the less voted to surprise us, or the middle one hahaha Take care!! ^^
No one I know personally is ARMY so it's so fun watching BTS with you. I'm also getting really excited about going to a live viewing in the cinema of their concert in Seoul on Saturday! Maybe I'll get to know some ARMY there...🤞 Anyways, I love that you both get as excited as I get about BTS!
I love that you have a spreadsheet. Just shows how heavily invested you are now with BTS. Just like me! Btw, Caitlin is very pretty in this vid. I love your channel, I can’t stop watching you two!💜 Borahae!
Thanks for the recommendations!! Also nice profile picture! Princess Mononoke is one of my favorite movies 😀 (sorry if I've already commented this before... I get excited to see Ghibli stuff!)
This was such a fun reaction, guys! Festa Room Live is one if my favorite performances, a great glimpse into their artistry, talent, versatility and personalities in such a short time! They've made great music right from the start, looking forward to your reactions to the full songs from this performance as well as songs from earlier albums.
Loved this reaction! your excitement made this so fun - especially Caitlin squeeeing over our boys!!! For your spreadsheet Andrew - Dimple & Pied Piper - I think both of you would enjoy the 5th muster live performance. BTW that was the smoothest transition to Skillshare sponsor and back to the vid - nice job!
The first 1,000 people to use this link will get a 1 month free trial of Skillshare: skl.sh/andrewberg03221
ty
ua-cam.com/channels/l5qkorhLuO30KaB-gJoknA.html
So, Andrew, it looks like it might be time to consider what to do for your subscriber no. 20,000... May I suggest something about tomatoes? You know, to keep with the tradition... 😂
Aka Run BTS episode 31 😁: ua-cam.com/video/OwgbF0OqPD4/v-deo.html
Or just the tomato part:
ua-cam.com/video/thleMGobncc/v-deo.html
Can you guys react to ARMYPEDIA (similar to this Festa video)I will be so glad 💗 as your subscriber. Please 😅💜
LOL Caitlin’s reaction to RM’s “what’s poppin girl” 😂💜
Hahaha 💀
soooo relatable !!!
She did hold herself way better than I did 😂💜
@@martamenendezgonzalez6486 Tell me about it😂😂
😂
"what's poppin' girl"... Caitlin blushing brighter than her shirt is all of us. 😆
Also, Caitlin, so glad you're feeling better!
Hahaha this comment needs 100 Likes
@@AndrewBergSax 250+ likes right now. Needs 500 now 😂💜
I have the exact same reaction to that line 😂
Namjoons rap in Look Here is so iconic and I was looking forward to Caitlin's reaction and she didn't disappoint! I squeal inside every time I hear it too 😅
Hahaha her squeals are becoming a staple of every reaction 😂
The way Caitlin screams each time RM does something cute is so relatable hahaha i love your reactions!
Hahaha thank you!
Caitlin saying RM looks like Ryan Gosling with his "hey girl" made me laugh out loud so hard! Because it's TRUEEEEEE!!!!
Who’s Ryan?
@@rikhmjustsomeguywithmousta4971 He's an actor
RM: "Hey girl - don't forget to study real hard for your exams"
Fr!!!
Why is no one talking about the master spreadsheet!!!???? It blew my mind 💜
Hahaha I'm very proud of it 😂 and I probably only showed half of what I have in there
@@AndrewBergSax Wow!!! I have no words
I was searching for comments about this lol
This is dedication!
Seriously it’s so impressive ahhhh!!!!
Yeah, It also blew my mind 🤣 10 👍 for Andrew 💜
Andrew that segway to the sponsor was smooth like butter. Also Caitlin calling RM expression hey girl had me dying!! I enjoyed watching you guys react to this! This is truly a masterpiece and a new amazing video. Thanks for another amazing reaction again guys!
CFA
Thank you! Caitlin was truly hilarious in this video 😂
@@AndrewBergSax yess! and her reaction was so relatable omg
Jimin’s oh ah oh ah in Pied Piper is so good. He perfectly fits for this part
V makes me really laugh in this, with his loud intro speeches! They are so entertaining and of course, they sound amazing.
Haha yes, I so agree!
And his happy wavy dance is just adorable. 🤭
Wings is such a masterpiece, its whole album "You Never Walk Alone" is a masterpiece to be honest. Caitlin is all of us when RM says "Whats poppin girl" hahaha
I knew Hobi wouldn't stay in that chair long. RM's rapid-fire rapping in Look Here was all it took 4:21. (Hey, Andrew, for your spreadsheet: Ugh! Ugh! Ugh! Outro: Tear, Outro: Tear, Outro: Tear, Blue Side, Blue Side, Blue Side, Blue Side...😉)
Hahahahahahhahaha I'm honestly shocked nobody had thought of this sooner 😂
Caitlin is such a happy pill. All these songs specially Outro:wings, Pied Piper and Ugh are such fun songs but the lyrics are so deep. U should listen to these songs separately focusing on the lyrics and music production.
I just watched PTD Seoul concert online and it was so fun. M justbwondering what they would do differently in Las Vegas concerts.
Looking forward to next Friday(or earlier if u decide to surprise us).
Take care...both of u.
Yes, a lot of these songs will get their own reactions! I'm so jealous I wasn't able to watch the concert! It was the middle of the night for me 😭
@@AndrewBergSax Andrew are you going to go to the Global theatre live viewing? PTD on Stage being streamed to theatres all over the world... they'll do delayed viewing for your timezone so you wont have to get up in the middle of the night!
Pied Piper😏
@Indigo P I'm not going to unfortunately! I kind of dropped the ball with planning and they're all sold out around me now
Watching this made me so happy just seeing my boys smile and having fun, it also showed me why I loved all the songs that they performed.
Also Jimin was defo the pies piper during the performance as he just hypnotized me and I couldn't keep my eyes of off him (also I might be biased saying that as he is my ult bias)
I agree! I was smiling the whole time watching this! So much fun
PS. The band was live but not on screen T-T , they are Ghost band, the same in the npr and the BBC Radio 1 performances. Most of the bandmates have instagram (more active) and twitter. And the drummer has a yt channel and he used to post videos from the concerts waaay back.
Names: docskim (he has the cutest little daughter, keyboard, producer), blackswanz (guitar), khan drummer (his social media accts include the drummer! XD), ki_wook (bass)
Voting up this comment so more people appreciate 👍🏻💜
Thank you!! I actually didn't realize it was a live band for this set! I assumed they just had the band record it so the guys could sing over a track. That's awesome! And also explains how fluidly the guys could talk and then start singing the next song
@@AngelaSealana Thanks T-T I love the shoutouts to the band. They are incredible (as our bangtannies are)!
And Mr Son but he wasn't involved in those Tae moves afaik XD
:*
@@AndrewBergSax Someone (docskim?) posted about it back... then, ish? But since he deleted all his posts I cannot be sure.
Caitlyn reaction is literally me esp during ugh and RM's look here 😆😆
Hahaha I knew she wouldn't be alone in that 😂
Welcome back Caitlin!! I'm so happy to see you all better - your face through this entire thing is actually bringing me more joy than the original video and that is saying A LOT.💜
That's so nice!! 🥺
Also you changed your profile picture! I almost didn't recognize you 😂
@@AndrewBergSax Hehe, sorry about that - it was a bit outdated 😄Not that I can recognize myself much in that tiny circle, so that makes two of us😜Anyway, I'm so excited for this, I totally messed up on the poll but it was worth it!Have the most amazing evening you guys, and much love to the puppies☺
I just love the way Caitlin giggles!!!
Really loved your reaction guys!!!💜💜💜
Thank you!! She was in ultimate giggle mode this video 😂
Andrew and Caitlin great reaction! The guys chose the perfect songs for their medley through the years of BTS. It is always fun to see the joy you two have watching our boys .😁
Caitlin's love for RM and Jimin brings me happiness!
😊
Andrew pointing out the interesting or unique musical choices and techniques is a must! But seeing him fanboy out is my happy place.😊
Journey on...
💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Hahaha thank you so much!! This medley was awesome and now I really want to hear the full version of all of these songs!!! 💜
There is so much for you guys to discover still! I can't wait! Like BTS has no bad songs! Each one is it's own little jem. Looking forward to Caitlin squeeing over the members singing lol!
I'm so excited too!!! 😀
Glad Caitlin is feeling better!
The rap line really does adjust their voices to the style of the song. Suga has mentioned that he doesn't really draw a line between rapping and singing. They all just have such wonderful voice control!
I’m new here but I find it funnily endearing that you can tell he’s a teacher with that “master spreadsheet” of his and I couldn’t stop laughing and being shocked at that being the first time I’ve ever seen anyone do something like this for BTS 😂 points and many thumbs up from me! Imma be watching more videos for the sheer dedication you guys have 😭
Thank you so much! I definitely went all in and started that spreadsheet really early. And now I just keep adding more and more to it 😀
This is definitely one of the videos you gotta rewatch to see the background chaos 😂
YES!! Just right now when the video came out I noticed V just holding a chair for like a minute straight and I was just laughing so hard 😂
Andrew, I seriously respect your spreadsheet skills. High respect. That's so so cool. Also, Wings is an Outro and an Interlude actually.
I'm so glad you reacted to the version with subs!! Basically none of us did that, we just watched it when it came out LOL. Also, you will soon learn that outros can be some of the absolute best songs in BTS's entire discography. I mean, "Outro: Tear", hello? Anyways, this was so fun and healing to watch lol thank you so much :D CFA
I love your wife’s reactions…her giggling is so infectious. Borahae guys.
Caitlin’s pure unadulterated joy in all of these reactions, but in this one in particular, manages to bring a smile to my face as much as BTS does! I can’t wait for y’all to react to their earlier works!
Haha thank you!! The earlier stuff is coming!
Miss you Caitlin! so glad seeing you both enjoyed it so much. Hope you get to see the BTS 2021 Festa Army Playlist as well. Love that too! Its them singing parts of each of their solo songs, mostly songs that are not in their albums but only uploaded on Soundcloud.
Oh that's awesome! I'll have to check that out!
pied piper is a song telling armys to study and to not be too obsessed with bts, but we all choose to ignore it 😂
ugh is about the misuse of anger, a “pure” emotion that should be used for important things (like protests against injustice) instead of being wasted as hate comments on the internet
telepathy was written during the quarantine and is a song basically telling armys that bts and armys are always together telepathically even if they can’t see each other in person
i love you guys’ energy ! can’t wait for the albums’ reaction. i hope you will pay a lot of attention to the lyrics, they are always very beautiful, deep or simply iconic :)
since you liked the rapline rapping over korean sounding music, i would heavily recommend ‘ddaeng’. it’s a diss track released for festa 2018 for free on soundcloud. the amount of play words in it is astounding, RM even uses 7 different uses of the word ‘ddaeng’ in his verse !!
thanks for the reaction ! 💜
Caitlin getting the giggles during joon's verse in look here is highly relatable
Hi. Firstly, I love the way you have placed emphasis on our boys i.e. focusing the bigger screen on our boys instead of yourselves, unlike other reactors who focus the bigger screen on themselves. I see you, I see the love you have for them, I see the way their music moves you. Spot on comments too. Just keep doing what you're doing. My 1st time watching you and I'm already a fan. Btw, I'm a 55 year-old Army mom with 2 BTS Army daughters and a very cool 68 year-old Army husband. 💜
I don't know how many times i have already watched this reaction, my brain is a bit mushy... but here we go!
First of all, so good to see you again Caitlin!
Oohhh those Tteokbokki look so good! 😋
Caitlin's reaction to "what's poppin girl" is wonderful. And when you two were laughing about that again during the livestream yesterday, I internally screamed because I knew where episode 11 would go 😁
And sidenote, everytime i hear RM going off in Look Here i get nervious, because that song is notoriously difficult to master in the Rhythm Hive game, and i've been stuck on a level with it for months 😣
But it's such a groove! So I can't give up on it 💪
"Outro:Wings... this is the outro to an album!? this is intens!" ... erm... yeah, that's one way to describe the entire album 😅 you already know a couple of the songs, but there's still more to come.
And they have performed this song quite a lot in recent years, they seem to love performing it just as much as we love hearing it.
Pied Piper, what can I say? the theme song of ARMYs? them just flexing on us how they can draw us in, the power they hold over us? yeah. And of course, the vocal control, just casually, sitting down crosslegged, my diaphragm would be protesting and throw in the towel if i ever tried anything like that.
Harmonized rapping: YES! 🤩
There are more instances where they do that, of course. The ability to not only play with intricate rhythms and rhymes, but also stay in key and sometimes create melodies was also one of the reasons why I was drawn to their rapping more than (most) other rappers i have typically heard onthe radio. 🤭
Ugh - "getting serious" yeah 😅 the vibe definitely switched up in their performance, and also in the lyrics. It'll be interesting to see the full reaction to this, also with the explanation attached, because this is once again one of those with lots of references and cultural aspects hidden in the lyrics, even if it doesn't appear to at first glance maybe.
16:35 Caitlin giggling over the background action: yeah 😁 this would be a classic video where you have to watch it at least 8 times, once for the overview and then 7 times to focus on each member, because they're all going off to do some random things 😁 and we love them for it.
Thank you so much for this entertaining watch! 💜
🥕 CFA
Hahaha I think this is your longest comment yet! 😂
"What's poppin girl" will make an appearance again soon.... 👀
I really want to react to Outro: Wings soon! That one was awesome and I need to hear it again. Guitars, harmonized rapping?! So good.
And I need to listen to a rap line song!!! Idk if it will be UGH, Ddaeng, or Outro: Tear, but I'll do one of them soon!
@@AndrewBergSax apparently i had a lot of thoughts 😅
Outro Wings will be wonderful!
And no matter which one you pick, all of these rapline songs are excellent.
Outro:Tear is very emotional,
Ddaeng is another example of them using traditional instruments and very clever lyrics,
And Ugh is another one of those "it's not a BTS album if there is not a song about societal issues" (loosely quoting Suga, i believe).
Oh I saw my name on the comments Authors spreadsheet!
Mom, I'm on Andrew's video!!!!!
I don't comment a lot but I'm here watching every video you release, and as I always say on twitter (when someone asks me) you are one of "my fave bts reactors ever"!!!
Thank you so much!! If you saw your name then you must've been one of the first people to comment on my first BTS video!! 🤩
Your reaction was so much fun to watch! Thank you! I highly recommend 'Dimple' + 'Pied Piper' live from the 5th Muster: Magic Shop Concert in Seoul in 2019! It's an eye and ear candy!
Great suggestion, I have to add that Caitlin may need some smelling salts for this after seeing her reaction to RM's "What's poppin', girl?", just a warning, lol. 😄
I need a Caitlin in my life!
Hahaha well you'll get to see her once a week or so for 20 minutes 😂
PS: Telepathy was written by Suga (Yoongi) in his typical way (30 min) during the pandemic and talking about ARMY since we couldn't see each other (esp we see them, but they couldn't see us). It ties up with his line in Life goes on ("between me and you things hasn't changed") and that was used in today's concert in Seoul T-T (at the entrance, they give army/the audience a banner to show at a set time during the concert, you can see it in the guys OT7 tweet after the concert or JHope's instagram) ^^
This is just a perfect little polished jewel of a music box! It makes me happy every time I watch it or see someone else watch it for the first time (got to show it to my sister-in-law and niece who introduced *me* to BTS -- sweet sweet vindication!). This was where I first heard Outro:Wings and Pied Piper and pretty much sat up straight in my chair and hit replay a couple dozen times. :D
Your spreadsheet is awesome, you organizational nerd, you! I have never, ever, in my entire life, made a spreadsheet or chart to keep track of a current obsession ::stuffs papers back in drawer, minimizes windows:: Color-coded conditional formatting? Never heard of her!
Comment award 🏆
Hahaha "organizational nerd" is extremely accurate 😅
Hahaha. Oh, boy. You just called me out on my organization systems.
the intros and outros of BTS albums are ALWAYS amazing!!! they don't do things halfway, their albums are full of bangers literally from beginning to end.
so glad you reacted to this!! can't wait 'til you start doing album reviews! is gonna be so fun :)
Yes, I'm really excited!!
Watching you two is an immediate bust of serotonin. My cheeks hurt of how big my smile was. Thank you!!
omg i almost cackled out loud when you actually showed what your spreadsheet looks like! I LOVE IT
as someone who has a (probably ridiculous) number of spreadsheets for pretty much any sort of information i need to organize, i applaud your use of spreadsheet for bts songs 🤣
also this reaction is just all smiles for me~ it's awesome to see you two enjoying this little trip through their discography!
outro wings (which is basically the full version of interlude wings which was the last track of the wings album) was already fantastic AND THEN HOPEKOOK WENT AND DID THAT HARMONY IN LIVE PERFORMANCES AND ALL I COULD DO WAS SCREAM WITH IMMENSE JOY
ps - the BE album is just pronounced "be" ^^
Hahaha I love spreadsheets so much 😅 I literally only showed like half of what I have in there 🙈
I can't wait to hear the full version of Outro: Wings!!
And thank you for the pronunciation! I made an assumption because of it being in all caps!
Okay…that transition into the skillshare ad was actually amazing 😂😂
😎
I just got a bass ukulele and my 9 year old kid stole it (he's already a bass guitar player) and found the tab for Telepathy, and started playing it, and noticed that the verse drop is the only real bridge, but the bass line is the same throughout ... and besides the intro, the bass tab only has like 8 bars? And we were marvelling at the composition; it's easily my favourite song on BE, and I love it so much, and I never found it boring or 'sameish' -- the bass line is sensational -- and yet it's the same 8 bars all the way through 🤯 It's really wild to get a glimpse under the hood of some of these songs, is my point, and your reactions help us do that. So thanks! And I loved your reaction to Festa Room. Festa and Muster are rare opportunities for ARMY to hear some of BTS's older repertoire because many of them rarely show up on concert setlist. Look Here, Like, Pied Piper. Swoon! Ooh look, I wrote a novel 🤣
You guys are too cute! You had me laughing right along with you! I love this Festa Live because it showcases what they can do with their voices and showcases their personalities. I like this version with the subtitles of their conversation as well as the lyrics. Thanks again for another great and fun reaction!💜💜
this is my first time getting to read captions of their little comments in between songs so thank you for going that extra step. I was laughing without the captions but now im laughing all over again😂 I loved this! you both look so invested and excited, barely able to contain how happy you are just watching them which I definitely relate to💜 I have seen this Festa Room Live sooo many times because it’s just that good tbh. I would recommend to anyone just starting BTS. you see their personality, relationships, live voices and sneak peek into the discography. great video and great reaction☺️👏🏾
OMG you need to react to Blue and Gray. It's so beautiful and has a very thoughtful message. I LOVE it and I hope you will too. The MTV performance is killer!
You guys are ALL OF US!!! I just canʻt! Love the genuine love and appreciation you both have for them
Caitlin completely losing it is me 100%
Hahaha I had a feeling I'd be seeing comments like this today 😂
Man, Caitlin is such a joy! Her squeals represents armys so well.
Also, that ad plug was smooth 😅
Was it smooth like butter? 🧈😂
@@AndrewBergSax you got it ☺️
7:56 I love the spreedsheet! 😍 If I wasn't subriscribed, I would now.
Hahahaha I appreciate that 😀
Outro: wings is MY SONG!!! I listened to it everyday for a month, it's just that good!! They also performed it in yesterday's concert too, i was so happy. They know we love that song lol
Rm's iconic line what's poppin girl hahahahahahha always got me!
What the heck? That spreadsheet is the most impressive thing I've ever seen from a reaction channel. That's so amazingly detailed. I mean this is my first video I've seen from you guys and the reaction itself was super fun and cute but now I'm extra impressed by the behind the scenes work you put in. Great job putting what you learnt on Skillshare to work.
Thank you!! I'm definitely proud of that spreadsheet 😂 As soon as I started reacting to BTS and had hundreds of comments requesting I react to certain songs, I knew I needed to try and get organized. Glad you enjoyed the video!
@@AndrewBergSax I thought my tv show spreadsheet was impressive. Now I'm inspired to up my game lol
Absolutely love your reactions! Caitlin, the screeches and cackling are me too 😂
It must be very nice husband and wife have a same interest and enjoying it together. Love seeing such joyful faces and having fun while doing reaction.
Wow, you are so prepared and knowledgable about the videos you're reacting to! That spreadsheet is really cool. Also love the subtle way the frame around your video lights up when you guys talk!
Thank you so much! I started doing the purple light when we talked on one video and I loved it so much, I had to keep it! 😊
2:33 whats poppin girl, Im glad im not the only one that feels that way🥰🥰😂😂
can we just talk about how impressive this man’s spread sheet was?
🤩
This is so much fun watching, Caitlyn's reaction is so on point. I love how she's fangirling so much like suuuper relatable..🤣
Borahae💜
Caitlin all giddy is one of my favorite things ever
Oh man-I think you two would LOVE ‘Ugh!’ I’d recommend a lyric video, their live performance for ‘Map of the soul ONE’ then the explanation video from DKDKTV. It’s such a good song to dive into for deeper meaning.
As always, LOVE your reactions and going down the rabbit hole with you two 💜
DKDKTV is the best isn’t it… 💜
That spread sheet is EPIC! Respect.
I can tell you off top, the second song, the one RM starts off with "What's popin' girl?" Is called "Look here." It is one of their most underrated songs but its on my BTS Top 10! Which is hard to pick!
Because it friggin SLLLAPPS!
And the harmonies are 😘👌
It's a perfect driving song! It'll get you in a great mood in 10 seconds! Its on "Dark & Wild" one of their best albums for sure!
caitlin almost crying when rm says whats popping girl is honestly the most relatable thing ever 😭😭
Outro: Wings is one of my favorite songs, it's so much fun to see live.
Yay Caitlin! This is my favorite way to show folks the variety of b-sides they have had. So many kinds of music they try. Also they are such spazs and so chaotic we love it! I love love love the spreadsheet I have never loved something more. You were made to be Army the most organized of fandoms and great way to slip in the Skillshare link, I didn’t even mind. Absolutely brighten my day.
LOVE this reaction! This is one of my favourite videos ever! Pied Piper is a fantastic song for you to react to. Usually people pair it with Dimple and it works really well - there's a double performance of Dimple+Pied Piper that will blow your mind! Your spreadsheet is *chefs kiss* I love all your videos and I love it when Caitlyn joins, you guys bounce off each other in such a lovely way! I love the way she surmises things and comes up with the funniest things - a 60s bachelor pad 😅 so perfect!
Sad I can never make it to your live streams cause I'm in the opposite time zone but I love that you do them! True Army in the making
I actually trade off a little bit for the livestreams! I do 10am PST some weeks and 8pm PST other weeks! I tried to make it so everyone has a chance to be there!
As a new army i really enjoy this performance bcs i didn't know they had songs like "Like" or that RM rap, songs on the early days
I completely agree! I can't wait to get to their earlier albums now!
What's popping, Caitlin?? I need Caitlin's laughtrack in my life. I'm glad she's back and feeling better! 💜
BTS B-side songs are amazing! I'm so glad you're reacting to this now and I can't wait till you react to each individual songs!
And also that sponsor plug was smooth like butter. ;D
CFA
Hahaha 🧈 I'm really excited for some of these b-sides 😀
hopekook harmonization in outro wings changed my life
You both are the cutest couple. And absolutely love your reactions. Looking forward to seeing more.
Thank you!!
Kudos for the clever way you led into your advertisement... (I don't know how else to say it--- but it was much smoother/ less awkward than I've seen on other channels.)
love your enthusiasm.
Haha thank you! 😊
It's so funny when you know what they were talking about in between the songs 😂💜 hi Caitlin!
I agree!! I'm so glad we chose to use the Bangtan Subs version!
Hi! 💜
This was pure joy. Thank you Caitlin and Andrew!
my dude made a excel, mad respect.
Caitlin, welcome back
Hahaha I go a little hyper organized for this stuff 😅
Caitlin's giggles Re adorable!
Caitlin that pink top looks great on you.
Thank you!
Welcome back Caitlin! This video is so fun and I've probably watched it too many times lol. Definitely recommend Agust D, Daechitwa, UGH!, Cypher 4, Outro: Tear for rap songs. Other songs that are really good if you haven't heard them before are 134340, Let Go, Magic Shop, Fly to my Room, Paradise, Dis-ease, Love Maze, Answer: Love Myself ad so many more, I can't remember all but these are all really good. Outro: Wings is one of my favorites and same I'm amazed that it's an outro song💜😀
Hahaha got to get those votes in for the spreadsheet! 😂 Thanks for the recommendations and I can let you know that one of those for sure is coming up in the next few weeks!
this performance is soooo good! loved your reaction!! cautlin’s cheeks must hurt from smiling.
Hahaha she actually did tell me they hurt after we finished 😂
You've heard one of my top 10 BTS songs, "Outro: Wings"!!!! 🥲 I LOVE IT!! You both are back together on camera and it was so much fun watching your reaction, I had little tears in the corners of my eyes 😄💜 I am seriously looking forward to hearing your thoughts on all the gems in BTS' B-sides. Dare I say this video made my day!?
CFA
Hahaha I'm so glad you liked it 😊 I'm excited for more b-sides too! And I feel like I need to move Outro: Wings up the list possibly because I want to listen to it on my own 😂
Yay! Glad to see Caitlin back! Hope you are feeling better.
And don't get us all wrong, Andrew, we love you as much ;)
So, now that you are open to maybe less title tracks... I suggest: Rain!!!!!! (and maybe all intros and outros XD, up to you, but they are THAT good!), Autumn Leaves, Am I wrong? (relevant once again, now the conservatives have won in yesterday's elections in SK -___-)
Haha thanks for the recommendations! I definitely plan on doing less title tracks and also some of their earlier songs soon!
@@AndrewBergSax Haha, I just wanted to enter the excel file :P but you can do polls too and actually select the less voted to surprise us, or the middle one hahaha
Take care!! ^^
Watching the concert this morning and this now, perfect 💜💜💜
I didn't get to see the concert because it was the middle of the night 😭
the spreadsheet! omg! A for effort!
🤩
I miss Caitlin's energy, it's so infectious!!! This whole video put a smile on my face, thank you 💜
💜
No one I know personally is ARMY so it's so fun watching BTS with you. I'm also getting really excited about going to a live viewing in the cinema of their concert in Seoul on Saturday! Maybe I'll get to know some ARMY there...🤞 Anyways, I love that you both get as excited as I get about BTS!
omg, those key chains are so cuuuuuute 😍
Yay Caitlin! So glad you're feeling better.
Caitlin's reactions are just so cute, I love her 😂💜 I really enjoyed watching this with both of you 😄
Omg that spreadsheet that's amazing!! I bet that helps you keep track of everything!! It's difficult to do on your own haha
I listened to RM saying what popping girl and his rap after over and over 😍😍😍😍💜💜💜😂
Hahahaha 😂
RM's charm compared to Ryan Gosling's "hey girl" meme... somehow everything clicked together in my head as soon as she said that! 😂 it's sooo accurate
7:45-8:23 OMG genius!
Hahahaha thank you 😀 I'm proud of my spreadsheet 😂
i missed Caitlin bc she's hilarious. u make a great duo to watch xDDD
I love that you have a spreadsheet. Just shows how heavily invested you are now with BTS. Just like me! Btw, Caitlin is very pretty in this vid. I love your channel, I can’t stop watching you two!💜 Borahae!
I am impressed about your spreadsheet!!! Wow!!! That is so organized and a seal of a true army💜💜
would love you to react to the dark & wild album its one of their best!! also the full version of ugh with the lyrics explained its a masterpiece!
Thanks for the recommendations!!
Also nice profile picture! Princess Mononoke is one of my favorite movies 😀 (sorry if I've already commented this before... I get excited to see Ghibli stuff!)
@@AndrewBergSax hehe thanks 💜 as a ghibli nerd, totally get it!
This was such a fun reaction, guys! Festa Room Live is one if my favorite performances, a great glimpse into their artistry, talent, versatility and personalities in such a short time!
They've made great music right from the start, looking forward to your reactions to the full songs from this performance as well as songs from earlier albums.
You were so cute during the whole video, it was so cool 😆
Welcome back Caitlin. So glad that you are doing good. BTW, great reaction!💜😊
Loved this reaction! your excitement made this so fun - especially Caitlin squeeeing over our boys!!! For your spreadsheet Andrew - Dimple & Pied Piper - I think both of you would enjoy the 5th muster live performance. BTW that was the smoothest transition to Skillshare sponsor and back to the vid - nice job!
Thanks for the recommendations and I really appreciate that! I was proud of that transition when I did it 😂
Ah, you mentioned rapping over traditional music, I will once again recommend Daechwita 👀😂
Yes!!! I need to watch that!
It seems that Caitlin is a minimoni girl too.
Thank you for the reaction, guys!