This is not a method, or a solution. It's a palliative. A tortuous path that requires time and work, in external software, to overcome a chronic lack of twinmotion.
Thanks for the tutorial but this is a workaround of a problem. As I'm working in Revit I love it paired with Twinmotion but I never have time to spend for additional modeling just to make the grass look good. I need my model with one surface and one material to do the trick. That is why I kindly encourage TM developers to make grass more user friendly as additional modeling time is not worth it or possible in a professional environment. I can't speak for other but I suspect that other architects using BIM programs have the same feeling about it.
YES! im sure lots of people have the same issue, i think both Lumion and D5 have better solutions for grass in this regard.. if i where to use another software other than Twinmotion for rendering, i would go with D5 (i ditched TM almost a year ago for things like these..
There can be simply a built in way to do this without geometry, 1. choose geometry 2. click scatter 3. drag 1 detail grass and 1 regular grass 4. choose detail grass and click checkbox ''only use in borders'' 5. choose regular grass and click ''offset from borders according to distance between assets center to its external bounding box limits 6. choosing both and clicking on surface to scatter, it will scatter long regular grass to internal parts while filling borders with detail grass So, No even need to invent new method for scattering system, applying this to current scatter system can even fix it.
@@cristianvalenghi896 Oh sorry, what I mean is currently there is no implementation like that, but it would be easy for them to make it happen without rewriting a scatter system. I just try to give ideas to developers :D
Well explained, with the necessary and important details (cm) and easy to follow and understand. Thank you! I hope you will continue to create many more such tutorials.
Good Tute but really just need Twinmotion to add an option for edge detection to replace with border grass with collision detection, OR even a simpler implementation, calc a bounding box of the grass patches being instanced and allow collision but dont allow the bounding box to extend passed the mesh bounds it is being applied to
I imagine they will eventually add that after a few more years of development. I've been using Twinmotion since 2019 and they only recently added fabrics with transparency which is something I have desperately needed since my work involves a lot of drape for events that I design. They have been slow to add desperately needed features but they do add them eventually and it does get better every year.
@@Moskeeto We could do translucency before we just had to start with translucent materials. A pain I know. This particular one is the main reason to use TM for me, so it'd be nice if we didnt have to zone out our borders. Would also mention we are losing features. We used to be able to save grass groupings to library...I know this because I still have it in my library and it still works!
@@rabbittdesign8482 Well, I used to use glass materials which didn't allow for normal mapped textures. I also used to use styrofoam materials which only helped light shine through but didn't have any sort of opacity slider. Now the new fabric materials achieve exactly what I have been needing.
because this video is made by a popular twinmotion user and then dubbed by a twinmotion voice actor. Old video tutorials with French person was actual twinmotion tutorial with twinmotion company worker probably. So thats why he didnt present these ones.
Great tutorial, but they should really sort this out, couldn't the actual physical model of grass axis auto detect an edge and shift to the far right/left and then have a rule that it should aways 'face' inward from the edge, surely a simple thing to code and execute with a check box?
When Twinmotion users found out that LUMION and D5 RENDER next door have 1-click smart 3d grass material.They'll find this tutorial is so ridiculous.For a simple grass effect, but to do such a complex thing in sketchup uh...😅
Really good tutorial! Until a better 3d grass tool comes 😜 Also in next tutorial, how did you do the ivy leaves on the wall? I was unable to paint leaves on vertical surfaces..
it would be nice if TM could detect borders of different materials and adjust the grass accordingly instead of me having to bend my archicad model to all kinds of weird borders and offsets.
Not sure if learning twinmotion is worth it and a waste of time... I just tried D5 and everything there is so easy and faster to do. And it even runs faster... What only keeps me from switching is the Lumen feature which provides a good fast result.
Very odd - -I have matched you move for move and i dont get the same result. Grass still looks trash and the grass scatter is growing through the stones. Wonder what im doing wrong or what is different
I get some of the criticism around this being a workaround, but I quite like it. I don't think it's too much additional effort to get a really good result. Great video.
So basically what you are proposing is to solve this issue previously during the modelling stage and then scattering two types of grass on two different objects.... So far the solution must come from the user. Not good at all. It's a nice workaround but you definitely should improve edge detection for this type of situations.
As some else has said better than I will here, this is not productive way to add 3D grass. Lumion handles it so much better, effectively using 3D as a drag and drop material. Worse still if you need to refresh the existing geometry or add more to it, there's always a risk that they grass you've spent hours placing to begin with just goes! I appreciate that maybe there will be situations where you don't necessarily want full dense coverage, but I think of plenty more times where I've wanted that then when I haven't... There's not much I don't like about twinmotion but this is often quite the dealbreaker.
This is not a method, or a solution. It's a palliative. A tortuous path that requires time and work, in external software, to overcome a chronic lack of twinmotion.
Exactly! Twinmotion needs to improve the way grass is applied and controlled. This feels like a workaround and not a method, like you said.
Thanks for the tutorial but this is a workaround of a problem. As I'm working in Revit I love it paired with Twinmotion but I never have time to spend for additional modeling just to make the grass look good. I need my model with one surface and one material to do the trick. That is why I kindly encourage TM developers to make grass more user friendly as additional modeling time is not worth it or possible in a professional environment. I can't speak for other but I suspect that other architects using BIM programs have the same feeling about it.
YES! im sure lots of people have the same issue, i think both Lumion and D5 have better solutions for grass in this regard.. if i where to use another software other than Twinmotion for rendering, i would go with D5 (i ditched TM almost a year ago for things like these..
There can be simply a built in way to do this without geometry,
1. choose geometry
2. click scatter
3. drag 1 detail grass and 1 regular grass
4. choose detail grass and click checkbox ''only use in borders''
5. choose regular grass and click ''offset from borders according to distance between assets center to its external bounding box limits
6. choosing both and clicking on surface to scatter, it will scatter long regular grass to internal parts while filling borders with detail grass
So, No even need to invent new method for scattering system, applying this to current scatter system can even fix it.
I can't see the checkboxes. Can you maybe help?
@@cristianvalenghi896 Oh sorry, what I mean is currently there is no implementation like that, but it would be easy for them to make it happen without rewriting a scatter system. I just try to give ideas to developers :D
At last after 2 years I know how make nice detailed grass) Thank you, and please do more tutorials!
This seems insanely convoluted and its nice you can do this, but the fact that we have to is insane.
Well explained, with the necessary and important details (cm) and easy to follow and understand. Thank you! I hope you will continue to create many more such tutorials.
Good Tute but really just need Twinmotion to add an option for edge detection to replace with border grass with collision detection, OR even a simpler implementation, calc a bounding box of the grass patches being instanced and allow collision but dont allow the bounding box to extend passed the mesh bounds it is being applied to
I imagine they will eventually add that after a few more years of development. I've been using Twinmotion since 2019 and they only recently added fabrics with transparency which is something I have desperately needed since my work involves a lot of drape for events that I design. They have been slow to add desperately needed features but they do add them eventually and it does get better every year.
@@Moskeeto We could do translucency before we just had to start with translucent materials. A pain I know.
This particular one is the main reason to use TM for me, so it'd be nice if we didnt have to zone out our borders.
Would also mention we are losing features. We used to be able to save grass groupings to library...I know this because I still have it in my library and it still works!
@@rabbittdesign8482 Well, I used to use glass materials which didn't allow for normal mapped textures. I also used to use styrofoam materials which only helped light shine through but didn't have any sort of opacity slider. Now the new fabric materials achieve exactly what I have been needing.
Awesome!
thank you so much for the tutorial!
Amazing Tip!!! Good Job!!!
very helpful, thanks
Great video!
great tutorial ! I hope in the future updates we can also use 3d grass
Amazing... as always :)
Wow !!! thanks !!
muito bom! obrigado!
Прекрасно!
wow this is amazing
We need a Blender Twinmotion direct link plug-in
Awesome
It would be useful to be able to apply a similar technique for gravel or stone paths.
Super
Good thing is that the narrator is now a native English speaker, way to go
😄
because this video is made by a popular twinmotion user and then dubbed by a twinmotion voice actor. Old video tutorials with French person was actual twinmotion tutorial with twinmotion company worker probably. So thats why he didnt present these ones.
Very good video and when will be the next video for flower? I cannot wait....
Helpful! (Never enough SKP extensions/plugins 🤣)
they definitely have a deeeeep menu and a lot on screen :)
Great tutorial, but they should really sort this out, couldn't the actual physical model of grass axis auto detect an edge and shift to the far right/left and then have a rule that it should aways 'face' inward from the edge, surely a simple thing to code and execute with a check box?
very nice but we NEED SMART GRASS
When Twinmotion users found out that LUMION and D5 RENDER next door have 1-click smart 3d grass material.They'll find this tutorial is so ridiculous.For a simple grass effect, but to do such a complex thing in sketchup uh...😅
Better you can make autocut by elements or one click like in Lumion
U should fix grass scaling if U trying less than 50% downscale it’s doing to growing under landscape
❤️❤️❤️
Great ! I would like to know how you created those amazing ivy on the walls.
There will be tutorial about ivy in next weeks.
Really good tutorial!
Until a better 3d grass tool comes 😜
Also in next tutorial, how did you do the ivy leaves on the wall? I was unable to paint leaves on vertical surfaces..
You need to add features like in Forest Pack for 3ds max, that automatically cuts edges.
it would be nice if TM could detect borders of different materials and adjust the grass accordingly instead of me having to bend my archicad model to all kinds of weird borders and offsets.
quero vê animação DMX no twinmotion! será que teremos algum dia?
thanks!
instead of adding several times, maybe a density slider or something like thaat?
yes thats all I want
Can I download this scene to try it ?... could you put the link ?-- pls
Great tutorial, How was the ivy on the walls made in twinmotion?
There will be tutorial about ivy in next weeks.
can you make tutorial about rendering without Path tracer but still looks good? especially interior scenes. Thanks
Good tutorial, I am a fan of TM, but TM needs smart grass. I use anyher program you simply apply the grass i second later..... grass, simple
Just seems so far from D5… Their latest vid sent shivers down my spine, and then we get this for TM…
Not sure if learning twinmotion is worth it and a waste of time... I just tried D5 and everything there is so easy and faster to do. And it even runs faster... What only keeps me from switching is the Lumen feature which provides a good fast result.
Devs going to do anything, but NOT 3d grass textures, bruh...
For what?
@@EL.-SO for making grass in one click, instead making 3 types of surface, 3 different scattering with own specific settings etc.
@@joevega7558 it's on the roadmap as a high priority
Amen
coughs in lumion
poderia disponibilizar o arquivo
Faut il améliorer l'outil ou soumettre l'utilisateur ?
When is the fur material coming to twinmotion?
Very odd - -I have matched you move for move and i dont get the same result. Grass still looks trash and the grass scatter is growing through the stones. Wonder what im doing wrong or what is different
I get some of the criticism around this being a workaround, but I quite like it. I don't think it's too much additional effort to get a really good result. Great video.
model link please
It’s a workaround, and looks ok, but, it shouldn’t have to be like this in the year 2024
So basically what you are proposing is to solve this issue previously during the modelling stage and then scattering two types of grass on two different objects.... So far the solution must come from the user. Not good at all. It's a nice workaround but you definitely should improve edge detection for this type of situations.
alembic import ...
And PLEASE add cut lawn grass 🤯
My GPU: Nuh uh... don't try
As some else has said better than I will here, this is not productive way to add 3D grass. Lumion handles it so much better, effectively using 3D as a drag and drop material. Worse still if you need to refresh the existing geometry or add more to it, there's always a risk that they grass you've spent hours placing to begin with just goes!
I appreciate that maybe there will be situations where you don't necessarily want full dense coverage, but I think of plenty more times where I've wanted that then when I haven't...
There's not much I don't like about twinmotion but this is often quite the dealbreaker.
where is our beloved french accent?))
this is a dubbed video, original video is posted by a popular TM user, then TM put in official channel by dubbing it :D Thats why
pain in the ass tutorial. you want 1 or 2 clicks not change your 3d model. d5/lumion beat TM
modelling 3 surface for 1 grass...joke!:D
It’s super silly approach this year
Time to shift🫡
wonderful