Great video! One clarification: at 3:20, "whereas other women who lived at the same time, their genetic lineage didn't survive"... stated this way, that is not strictly true. Other women who lived at the same time as Mitochondrial Eve may still have ancestors alive today, just not in a direct unbroken female line. For example, they might have a male descendant somewhere who linked up with one of Mitochondrial Eve's female descendants.
I feel like, most modern family tree studies disregard the polygamy practices that happened for the longest in human history. Not to mention, close relatives marriages. Like between somebody with the first cousin. We need to apply those factors as well to avoid inaccuracy.
I didn't understand well the difference between the "most recent genealogical ancestor" and the other two most recent ancestors. What does make the most recent genealogical ancestor different from the Mitochondrial Eve and the Y-Chromosome Adam? Thank you
mt-Eve and Y-Adam are genetic ancestors, the genealogical ancestor isn't genetic at all, it's simply when everyone's family trees essentially meet and overlap.
@@celtichistorydecoded Thank you so much, let me see if I understood it well: Would it be when all family trees meet again after they split as a result of the first migrations from Eastern Africa? I mean, if all human beings descend from some original community (family) which evolved first in East Africa, our family trees would start all at that point and, then, they would split in many branches which overlaped later in the 1st milleniun BC. That's how I visualize it. However, this visualization makes me wonder how native American family trees could then overlap with Eurasian, African and Australian family trees back then; I would expect this to happen in the 19th century, after the British colonization of Australia. I'm still confused, sorry 😅
Thanks for sharing this. I find this topic, as well as the topic of historical linguistics very fascinating. Regarding the autosomal MRCA of all living humans, I find it very interesting that such a person or persons is estimated to have only lived 2-3 thousand years ago. It also fits in with my current theory that there was a real Adam & Eve, who were obviously not the 1st humans, who could have lived even further back than that, who were prolific, and whose lineages survived, who could easily be a shared ancestral couple to all living humans. They may only make up a small and variable percentage of our total dna, which would include all others who lived around the same time as this possible 'Adam & Eve' around the world, who would also contribute to our dna, to varying percentages depending on where in the world most of our ancestors resided at that time in world history. I could indeed see everyone in the world being descended from the same common ancestors at some point in history, with the various races having a much higher or lower percentage of that pool of ancient humans from one part of the world vs another, giving rise to the different racial characteristics of modern humans, along with random mutations, natural selection, and 'chance' of the 50-50 genetic split during human conception - all of those playing a part.
Britain And Ireland --- Commercial Sea Kelp Farming For Iodine Aquaculture is grossly underdeveloped in Ireland and is a potential goldmine. Iodine in Sea Kelp is essential for pregnant women and children's growing brains. Rice Fields In China And Calorie Production Per Unit Area Rice fields produce more than twice as many calories per unit area than wheat. A diet based upon rice can sustain life however with acute nutritional deficiencies. Thus due to nutritional deficiencies the brain will not develop to its full potential. Specifically a lack of Iodine and lack of fat soluble Vitamins results in underdevelopment of the brain. Sea Weed and Sea Kelp are an essential part of the diet in many countries in the Northern Hemisphere for example Japan and Korea and Taiwan and China and Hong Kong and Singapore. Specifically the Chinese population place vast emphasis on Sea Vegetables due to their Iodine content for pregnant women and children's growing brains. Western Europe correlate the coastal countries and regions and innovation and scientific, technological and economic development this is primarily due to the Iodine in the diet from sea vegetables for example Sea Weed and Sea Kelp. Iodine in the diet specifically for pregnant women and children's growing brains goes a long way to explaining national mean IQ statistics and historic economic development and economic dominance of some countries over others. The importance of Iodine in the diet has been forgotten in the West and specifically for pregnant women and children's growing brains. Commercial farming of Sea Kelp is a potential gold mine in Western Europe especially in the countries with an Atlantic coastline for example Ireland and Britain and Norway and Portugal and Spain. Baffles me how the importance of Iodine Salt in the diet has been forgotten. Increasing Iodine in the diet for pregnant women and children's growing brains will in theory increase mean IQ and increase economic competiveness further down the road. The Chinese are well aware of this fact and it explains one of the reasons why the Chinese and Taiwan and Hong Kong and Singapore economies are so efficient and competitive. Long overdue Europe and the West develops their commercial Sea Kelp Farming Industry to increase the Iodine Salt supply in the food chain specifically for pregnant women and children's growing brans. Comments welcome
Another point is that East Asians exhibit the highest expression of the “warrior” COMT gene as well, but because the culture is so regimented that warrior gene becomes a net positive in regards to focus and drive, you don’t get the aggression as much as in other groups. Maybe higher levels of iodine, improving focus, is the mechanism to explain that? I’m not a scientist - just an interested person speculating.
WOW! Some people are just desperate for attention, eh? lol Interesting video. I've always been so curious about human history and how everyone got everywhere. Thanks. 🍁
If a people lived in tribe and only bred with others in that tribe then the genetics of their ancestors would not be lost because they would be preserving the genetics within the tribe.
What do you make of the Wisdom Panel TV advert's claim? That a certain dog is "22% Staffordshire Pitbull and has a genetic marker that means he's prone to overeating".🐶 Don't we ALL have that 'genetic marker'? 🤔 Like him, we're all pretty much mongrels. But is our greediness due to ancestors from The Potteries? (Possibly a type of Beaker People? Corded Wear or not? Identified by their LARGE beakers, for BIG portions.)
Question Adam and Eve had children. There was no other humans on earth at the time. Adam and Eve children must've procreated so what does that make mankind.
@user-adoyle123 At the very start of the video he said Genetic Adam and Eve didn't live at the same time. That might be a clue. You're transforming a statement into a question. Your statement is factually incorrect. If you're trying to suggest humans are highly inbred, well no doubt a bit of inbreeding went on, but not at the foundational level like you allude to. Perhaps get some basic but sound book on anthropology.
200-300,000 years ago??! Human history only goes back 5-6,000 years. The most widely distributed book in history, the Bible, gives a generation by generation account of Jesus Christ’s ancestry. You may view this for yourself in Luke 3:23-38. There it lists 76 persons: from Jesus Christ back to Adam. A number of those listed lived much longer than people do today. For instance Adam: 930 years (Genesis 5:5) Methuselah: 969 (Genesis 5:27) Noah: 950 years (Genesis 9:29) After the Flood of Noah’s day, lifespans shortened significantly. Abraham 175 years (Genesis 25:7) Sarah 127 years (Genesis 23:1) Moses 120 years (Deuteronomy 34:7) Many Bible scholars believe that humans began with Adam and Eve in the fertile crescent of the Middle East, some 6,000 years ago.
Thanks for watching! Please let me know your thoughts below...
This is the clearest, most concise way I’ve heard this complex concept explained. Thanks brother, appreciate everything you’re doing.
Thanks
Great video! One clarification: at 3:20, "whereas other women who lived at the same time, their genetic lineage didn't survive"... stated this way, that is not strictly true. Other women who lived at the same time as Mitochondrial Eve may still have ancestors alive today, just not in a direct unbroken female line. For example, they might have a male descendant somewhere who linked up with one of Mitochondrial Eve's female descendants.
The mitochondria are the powerhouse of the cell ❤
Super explanation. Thank you
Thank you
I feel like, most modern family tree studies disregard the polygamy practices that happened for the longest in human history.
Not to mention, close relatives marriages. Like between somebody with the first cousin.
We need to apply those factors as well to avoid inaccuracy.
My brain needs this explained with pictures 😅 I think I get it
As always, thank you for the lesson.
Thanks
Thank you for all your videos. You explain everything so well. I can finally wrap my head around genetics thanks to you.
Great Video!
how much % of the Y cromosome is recombinating?
Very little, that's the idea, it's somewhat stable over a very long period of time, meaning we can trace it back far into history
I didn't understand well the difference between the "most recent genealogical ancestor" and the other two most recent ancestors. What does make the most recent genealogical ancestor different from the Mitochondrial Eve and the Y-Chromosome Adam? Thank you
mt-Eve and Y-Adam are genetic ancestors, the genealogical ancestor isn't genetic at all, it's simply when everyone's family trees essentially meet and overlap.
@@celtichistorydecoded Thank you so much, let me see if I understood it well: Would it be when all family trees meet again after they split as a result of the first migrations from Eastern Africa? I mean, if all human beings descend from some original community (family) which evolved first in East Africa, our family trees would start all at that point and, then, they would split in many branches which overlaped later in the 1st milleniun BC. That's how I visualize it. However, this visualization makes me wonder how native American family trees could then overlap with Eurasian, African and Australian family trees back then; I would expect this to happen in the 19th century, after the British colonization of Australia. I'm still confused, sorry 😅
MtDNA Eve and Y Adam it is a conventional form for the representation of our ancestors.
Both they were part of a larger group with same genetic.
Essentially, Mito eve/Y Adam = our MRCAs
Thanks for sharing this. I find this topic, as well as the topic of historical linguistics very fascinating. Regarding the autosomal MRCA of all living humans, I find it very interesting that such a person or persons is estimated to have only lived 2-3 thousand years ago.
It also fits in with my current theory that there was a real Adam & Eve, who were obviously not the 1st humans, who could have lived even further back than that, who were prolific, and whose lineages survived, who could easily be a shared ancestral couple to all living humans. They may only make up a small and variable percentage of our total dna, which would include all others who lived around the same time as this possible 'Adam & Eve' around the world, who would also contribute to our dna, to varying percentages depending on where in the world most of our ancestors resided at that time in world history.
I could indeed see everyone in the world being descended from the same common ancestors at some point in history, with the various races having a much higher or lower percentage of that pool of ancient humans from one part of the world vs another, giving rise to the different racial characteristics of modern humans, along with random mutations, natural selection, and 'chance' of the 50-50 genetic split during human conception - all of those playing a part.
Britain And Ireland --- Commercial Sea Kelp Farming For Iodine
Aquaculture is grossly underdeveloped in Ireland and is a potential goldmine.
Iodine in Sea Kelp is essential for pregnant women and children's growing brains.
Rice Fields In China And Calorie Production Per Unit Area
Rice fields produce more than twice as many calories per unit area than wheat.
A diet based upon rice can sustain life however with acute nutritional deficiencies.
Thus due to nutritional deficiencies the brain will not develop to its full potential.
Specifically a lack of Iodine and lack of fat soluble Vitamins results in underdevelopment of the brain.
Sea Weed and Sea Kelp are an essential part of the diet in many countries in the Northern Hemisphere for example Japan and Korea and Taiwan and China and Hong Kong and Singapore.
Specifically the Chinese population place vast emphasis on Sea Vegetables due to their Iodine content for pregnant women and children's growing brains.
Western Europe correlate the coastal countries and regions and innovation and scientific, technological and economic development this is primarily due to the Iodine in the diet from sea vegetables for example Sea Weed and Sea Kelp.
Iodine in the diet specifically for pregnant women and children's growing brains goes a long way to explaining national mean IQ statistics and historic economic development and economic dominance of some countries over others.
The importance of Iodine in the diet has been forgotten in the West and specifically for pregnant women and children's growing brains.
Commercial farming of Sea Kelp is a potential gold mine in Western Europe especially in the countries with an Atlantic coastline for example Ireland and Britain and Norway and Portugal and Spain.
Baffles me how the importance of Iodine Salt in the diet has been forgotten.
Increasing Iodine in the diet for pregnant women and children's growing brains will in theory increase mean IQ and increase economic competiveness further down the road.
The Chinese are well aware of this fact and it explains one of the reasons why the Chinese and Taiwan and Hong Kong and Singapore economies are so efficient and competitive.
Long overdue Europe and the West develops their commercial Sea Kelp Farming Industry to increase the Iodine Salt supply in the food chain specifically for pregnant women and children's growing brans.
Comments welcome
Another point is that East Asians exhibit the highest expression of the “warrior” COMT gene as well, but because the culture is so regimented that warrior gene becomes a net positive in regards to focus and drive, you don’t get the aggression as much as in other groups. Maybe higher levels of iodine, improving focus, is the mechanism to explain that?
I’m not a scientist - just an interested person speculating.
WOW! Some people are just desperate for attention, eh? lol Interesting video. I've always been so curious about human history and how everyone got everywhere. Thanks. 🍁
RUDDY , means to blush
Damn you beat me to it, also to show blood in the face. 👍
Fascinating information but please could you speak a little more slowly to allow time to 'hear'.
Hit the CC button for captions
@@celtichistorydecoded Thank you, I didn't know that..
@@pachebal and he has actually provided some rather than rely on UA-cam's ability to understand his voice.
Your speaking of Noah and his wife, there were many people at that time,
Not All are human being
LOL whut ?
Hey bro can u do a video on the jatt people of punjab
If a people lived in tribe and only bred with others in that tribe then the genetics of their ancestors would not be lost because they would be preserving the genetics within the tribe.
What do you make of the Wisdom Panel TV advert's claim? That a certain dog is "22% Staffordshire Pitbull and has a genetic marker that means he's prone to overeating".🐶
Don't we ALL have that 'genetic marker'? 🤔
Like him, we're all pretty much mongrels. But is our greediness due to ancestors from The Potteries? (Possibly a type of Beaker People? Corded Wear or not? Identified by their LARGE beakers, for BIG portions.)
No. The Londoners originated from the North Sea, the Devons originated from the Celtic Sea.
It was whales and seals that carried the English to land.
From r1a are b and j
🆘🤗✝️ look these words up individually
Who was the navel giving ancestor of both..?!?..😅😊🧐😆🤓
We was in every nation! Until the Nephilim invaded
The older y is r1a
So. Many mitocondrials explain the simios
Different mother
Not Adam and Eva!
Ask and Embla are their names❤❤❤❤❤❤
Ok
WHITE 💡 BRIGHT LIGHT SHINE ✨ 😊
Question Adam and Eve had children. There was no other humans on earth at the time. Adam and Eve children must've procreated so what does that make mankind.
@user-adoyle123
At the very start of the video he said Genetic Adam and Eve didn't live at the same time. That might be a clue.
You're transforming a statement into a question. Your statement is factually incorrect. If you're trying to suggest humans are highly inbred, well no doubt a bit of inbreeding went on, but not at the foundational level like you allude to. Perhaps get some basic but sound book on anthropology.
AFAIK mythology doesn't influence genetics.
That’s not a German, that’s a Hispanic
You were told to protect your NATIONS and not mix 😡
Whit?
200-300,000 years ago??!
Human history only goes back 5-6,000 years.
The most widely distributed book in history, the Bible, gives a generation by generation account of Jesus Christ’s ancestry.
You may view this for yourself in Luke 3:23-38.
There it lists 76 persons: from Jesus Christ back to Adam.
A number of those listed lived much longer than people do today. For instance Adam: 930 years (Genesis 5:5)
Methuselah: 969 (Genesis 5:27)
Noah: 950 years (Genesis 9:29)
After the Flood of Noah’s day, lifespans shortened significantly.
Abraham 175 years (Genesis 25:7)
Sarah 127 years (Genesis 23:1)
Moses 120 years (Deuteronomy 34:7)
Many Bible scholars believe that humans began with Adam and Eve in the fertile crescent of the Middle East, some 6,000 years ago.
Lol 😂
AFAIK mythology doesn't influence genetics.
DARKNESS
What happened to all European nations, Ukraine, European nation, Russia, America, Australia, and Canada what happened to our family?😡
THERE IS ONLY ONE NATION AND IT IS CALLED HUMANITY, THE REST IS NAZI DELUSIONS