WHO'S VIEWS HEADLINES: RTD TAKING THE P**SS?/GRANT IS CANON?/GATWA COMIC CON/MOFFAT's JOY/DOCTORWHO

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 вер 2024
  • Discussing the issues making the headlines which effect the Doctor Who world ...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 51

  • @CHIGGY118
    @CHIGGY118 2 місяці тому +14

    Disgusting the charges for autographs and photos. I remember queuing at Longleat in 83 and getting signed postcards of Troughton and Sarah Sutton. Anthony Ainley also gave me his signature and all the other guests were happily signing autograph books.
    I would never pay for anyone's autograph.
    I've still got lots of signed pics from actors and actresses by simply writing to them.
    Today it's just a cynical money grabbing racket.

    • @WhosViews
      @WhosViews  2 місяці тому +4

      It certainly is and I think it rather sad. No wonder their egos are uncontrollable.

  • @lolfzbf
    @lolfzbf 2 місяці тому +12

    They'd need to pay me to ask for his autograph 😂

  • @grahamdawson-lg5mq
    @grahamdawson-lg5mq 2 місяці тому +6

    JKR. An amazing woman.

  • @codyw1
    @codyw1 2 місяці тому +9

    If RTD is trying to annoy by messing with canon, I'm afraid the joke's on him as I don't regard anything post-89 as canon anyway. It's all fan-fic, and more latterly, spite-fic. The only canon worth a damn is the original series. So he can do what he likes, though I think that, for a supposed successful professional, he does come across more as a pathetic loser and attention seeking child than anything else. "Look at me! Look at me!" No thanks Rusty, I've just eaten. :D

  • @steveader
    @steveader 2 місяці тому +8

    Comic con events nowadays are robbing fans blind. I used to get autos for 10 and £20. Hammer stars, Classic Dr Who stars. As recently as 2017.
    The rates now are ludicrously over priced.
    And remember, this is a show that wants to attract a young audience .... a very rich young audience obviously.

    • @nevillewatkins4997
      @nevillewatkins4997 2 місяці тому +6

      Free, in my day.

    • @codyw1
      @codyw1 2 місяці тому +5

      I've got a book sent by a friend in the early 90s with a lot of Who autographs in it. Don't think it cost him a dime.

    • @WhosViews
      @WhosViews  2 місяці тому +3

      Excellent point!

    • @steveader
      @steveader 2 місяці тому +3

      I've certainly got a handful of autos for free, a Tom Baker book signing and individual Who star events for example. At multi star cons I would always expect to pay for an auto of a chosen celeb, but prices now are shocking. And to be charging those prices for ONE person. These major events are a day out for a lot of youngsters and £125 used to be about the budget for a whole day, not so long ago. Shame 😞

    • @julieanngoodwin30
      @julieanngoodwin30 Місяць тому +2

      I miss the old Manopticon events of the mid nineties.

  • @mudcrab3420
    @mudcrab3420 Місяць тому +2

    Speaking of Death to the Daleks in my head canon the 'Dalek Vision' parts where we were looking out of the eye stalks were that 'manual backup' method of vision.
    Remember the Evil City was sucking out all the power so probably affected the vision as well as the gun. So the little mutant was forced to climb up the casing and physically putting its eye on the other end of the vision tube.
    Probably.
    Been my head canon at any rate.

  • @ShaunCryer
    @ShaunCryer 2 місяці тому +8

    I blame Moffat for all the gender changing rubbish. Moffat has a lot to answer for, another limited hack. Davis, Moffat and Chibnel AKA Larry, Curly and Mo.

    • @joshuajoshua2732
      @joshuajoshua2732 2 місяці тому +2

      The gender swap personally doesn't bother me because the Doctor is an alien anyway I can accept that but if this was James Bond different situation but I do blame Moffat for another reason like messing up with the Doctor's incarnation numbers like retconning in an unknown incarnation like The War Doctor as great as an actor John Hurt was it should had been Paul McGann and have him regenerate into Eccleston and it would had felt like a true continuation then further making the meta-crisis Doctor a regeneration if it wasn't for that the Fugitive Doctor or the Timeless Doctors would never had happened and they wouldn't had retconned in the Shalka Doctor the showrunners have mucked the show up far too much they need to find a showrunner with better care and whose not a fan.

  • @DoctorHowTV
    @DoctorHowTV 2 місяці тому +6

    Ah, Moffat is writing the Xmas show... to answer my own question, I don't think the companion will be zapped. They'd be foolish to close the door on a popular actress who might return one day.

    • @WhosViews
      @WhosViews  2 місяці тому +5

      They can do it and still bring her back though.

  • @markpostgate2551
    @markpostgate2551 Місяць тому +2

    We may not have had wokeness in the 80s but we did have political correctness, for example, Michael Grade took exception to a BBC xmas season i-dent that depicted three snowman, complaining "why are there no snowwomen".
    I would say that what we are calling "woke" is for the most part the "intersectional feminism" that was heavily propagandised around 2012-2014. It's not true to say there was nothing like it in the 80s, Ben Elton killed Benny Hill's career by accusing him of contributing to a culture of sexual assault.
    It is a lot worse now. There was a period between the late 90s until about 2012, during which political correctness really lost it's power, and then it resurged with a vengeance around 2012.
    What made 80s identity politics fairly mild in comparison, is it usually represented a minority (the exception is possibly feminism where women are of course a majority, but not by a significant margin) which meant that they could never go so far as to totally alienate the outgroup because the outgroup outnumbered them. But with intersectionalism the opponent is a minority made up of the intersections of the majorities.
    And the so-called "translesbians" are actually heterosexual men (most probably white) managing to opt out of being part of the dreaded intersection of majorities.
    Eddie Izzard did a joke about this in the early 90s that proved so prophetic given his trajectory. The bit he did was about being a white middle class male heterosexual in a left wing bookshop and feeling increasingly guilty as each section designated by different branches of identity politics made him one of the bad guys - the punchline was "then I think 'thank god I am a transvestite'". He is saying the quiet part out loud there; admitting that being a member of a victim group is advantageous emotionally because it offers an escape or reprieve from viewing oneself as the oppressor. He is also admitting he suffered a lot od guilt for his innate characteristics.

  • @michaelhallett4110
    @michaelhallett4110 2 місяці тому +3

    Hi everyone. I'm gutted I missed this live!! I didn't get any notification 😢 I would have had lots of my rants to add on all last nights topics. Thank you all again. Mx

    • @WhosViews
      @WhosViews  2 місяці тому +1

      Thanks Michael, so sorry you didn't get a notification. It's like people being unsubscribed... very odd!!

    • @michaelhallett4110
      @michaelhallett4110 2 місяці тому +2

      @@WhosViews I think it because the ever seeing eye,doesn't like are community chats. There right, we are wrong. Am truly gutted I missed last night,but thank you guys,and everyone. Mx

    • @WhosViews
      @WhosViews  2 місяці тому +1

      @@michaelhallett4110 Keep an eye on our facebook mate - Who's Views - I announce new shows on there too

  • @mattendspiel9341
    @mattendspiel9341 2 місяці тому +5

    This is not being hateful but I refuse point blank to bend the knee to the reality deniers. I doubt JKR and JD have any hate towards the T, in spite of the obvious homophobia and misogyny.
    James was an excellent Master and it is such a shame how he was treated.

    • @WhosViews
      @WhosViews  2 місяці тому +1

      This is why we are branded 'ists', 'phobes', 'ots' .. as we will not comply. They try to shame us into following their obsessive cult dicates. They are all truly insane.

  • @meddlingfunk7962
    @meddlingfunk7962 Місяць тому +1

    Great show ,JT,Ian &Paul. I really wish people would actually read what JK has said ( like that student was asked to do by the teacher). Tranter was just showing how rich and bourgeois she is,with the virtue signalling tweet,if that's her number one priority from this government
    JK is going to be very busy with this new government with some of the characters in this cabinet.

    • @WhosViews
      @WhosViews  Місяць тому

      As I say in the show, I think we are in for trouble as they try to enforce ideology and fantast and various theories onto us.

  • @LynneHobday1
    @LynneHobday1 2 місяці тому +2

    Great show as always... didn't make the live unfortunately. I may give the Christmas special a butcher's... due to Moffat writing it. And you never know, it could be Doctor-lite.😅

    • @WhosViews
      @WhosViews  2 місяці тому +1

      Hiya Lynne, thats a good point! It may be more about Joy than The Doctor .... hmmmmm...

    • @LynneHobday1
      @LynneHobday1 2 місяці тому

      @@WhosViews We can only hope😁

  • @ShaunCryer
    @ShaunCryer 2 місяці тому +4

    Sorry to go on, missed the show due to work, and I do like to express the odd opinion; but just what were these people fans of? That's what I'd like to know? Viewed objectively, I struggle to believe we all watched the same brilliance, and yet this is their interpretation of it? It just messes with my mind that something so bad, could come from something so good

  • @ShaunCryer
    @ShaunCryer 2 місяці тому +5

    As for the alleged fan, please do continue to report. That is one smug 'sick-o-fan-tic' runt. It's not often I get vindictive, with the exception of Davis, Moffat, Chibnell, Gatwa, Tenant, Tranter, and others too numerous to mention, but all connected to a certain TV show, I used to love... Hang on, did I say I was rarely vindictive? Maybe I was wrong. Anyway at least the fan has finally found a way of providing entertainment. That sounds awful... but I mean every word.

    • @WhosViews
      @WhosViews  2 місяці тому +1

      Thanks Shaun, we will deffo be keeping an eye on this story as it progresses!

  • @darrenhale2351
    @darrenhale2351 Місяць тому +1

    Have Gatwa there to do a firesale of Merchandise.

  • @SRogerson91
    @SRogerson91 Місяць тому +1

    JT have you seen how much Gatwa is charging at London Comic Con in November this year?

  • @DAVID-ITFC
    @DAVID-ITFC 2 місяці тому +1

    How can anybody say JK simply hates men??? Her most famous work centred around a boy hero (-who, at least until more recent times I understand have tended to grow up to be men), or maybe it was a typo error and she really meant the character to be Harriet Potter?😁

  • @Java_Bean_Studios
    @Java_Bean_Studios Місяць тому +1

    Great show lads!

  • @mudcrab3420
    @mudcrab3420 Місяць тому +1

    Oooo! I got name dropped! :)
    Now I need to go back and see what cool comment I actually wrote :P

  • @markpostgate2551
    @markpostgate2551 Місяць тому +1

    I think this story about including the Shalka Doctor for fun is a cover story. I think it will turn out it is The Great Intelligence.

    • @WhosViews
      @WhosViews  Місяць тому

      I don't. I think they just taking the p.

    • @markpostgate2551
      @markpostgate2551 Місяць тому +1

      @@WhosViews
      I just wouldn't believe a word he says about anything.

  • @user-or3oe4cq6m
    @user-or3oe4cq6m Місяць тому +3

    I'm having fun not watching Doctor Who anymore.

    • @WhosViews
      @WhosViews  Місяць тому +1

      Its sad to hear this isn't it? More and more of us are switching it off as they try depserately to find their mythological desired audience. Sad days.

    • @neddystark3351
      @neddystark3351 Місяць тому +2

      Same here! Let me know when RTD and Bad Wolf have gone.

    • @WhosViews
      @WhosViews  Місяць тому

      @@neddystark3351 Hopefully in a few years!

  • @TheTruthIsUpThere
    @TheTruthIsUpThere Місяць тому +1

    Late to the party (again) 😂 Excellent show. Suspect you’re right about NG being out of contract. There will be no 3rd Disney season.

    • @WhosViews
      @WhosViews  Місяць тому +1

      I think there will be a third series, don't get me wrong. I'm not bothered about Disney involvement, they shouldn't be allowed anywhere near Who as far as I am concerned! It will be Bad Wolf though and sadly, they are also an issue here.

    • @TheTruthIsUpThere
      @TheTruthIsUpThere Місяць тому

      @@WhosViews You’re probably right - am glad of your optimism 😁 I keep thinking about Mrs Flood’s comment about how the Doctor’s story ends in terror. It feels like foreshadowing of a regeneration coming, ala “he will knock four times” and “your song is ending” etc. it’s very RTD when he’s building up to someone leaving.