Lollar Tele Sets #1 - 52 vs A3 vs Vintage vs Royal T in 1 Telecaster! Shootout / Alnico Pickup

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 128

  • @kendallfrombensoniteproduc7113
    @kendallfrombensoniteproduc7113 3 роки тому +36

    This is exactly how a pickup demo should be done. Thank you for setting the standard.

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому

      Thanks Kendall!

    • @aleksifradet1654
      @aleksifradet1654 3 роки тому

      @@haskitt Agreed. Great job man. Nice folky playing too. There isn’t enough of that on UA-cam. Cheers!

    • @4CloudySky
      @4CloudySky 3 роки тому

      ​@@haskitt Can you provide your input on SD Antiquity pickups? Are they lack something compare to Lollars? I'm asking this because I'm a HUGE fan of their Antiquity PAF, so naturally I wanted to go with them in my Pincaster build. Those PAF are really something special cause I tried several boutique ones like BKP The Mules. Also, what do you think about using LP 50's wiring in a Tele? Yes, apparently you can do that! Btw I have 50's wiring on both of my Gibson inspired guitars (Heritage H-150 and old Japan-made Navigator ES 335 ommage) and it is truly great way to improve not only your tone in general, but also control over it. I'm able to go clean to mean with just a flick of a switch, without touching my amp at all, and it works perfectly with ampsims too (like Scuffham S-Gear). If you are interested in this, just drop me an email, i will send you some clips and I also could provide some valuable tech info regarding 50's wiring, cause there are some :)

  • @ryanlayton3868
    @ryanlayton3868 2 роки тому +15

    I got the A3s because of this video and I’ve never been happier with my sound. They’re incredibly clear and articulate without being abrasive.

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  2 роки тому +1

      Awesome… I’m sure I’ll have the A3 set in another build sometime!

  • @iamanovercomer3253
    @iamanovercomer3253 21 день тому +2

    All sounds the same on internet. The only true way to get a clearer sound is to be there in person. All of them sounded good 👍

  • @julianmatthews2668
    @julianmatthews2668 3 роки тому +19

    It was the Vintage set for me almost every time... they all sounded great though. Great demo, thank you.

  • @davidderose1242
    @davidderose1242 2 роки тому +5

    Just perfect, Scott. Very thoughtful presentation. All styles -- clean, over driven and dirty; neck, middle and bridge positions. Who could ask for more? Both the A3's and 52's should work for me as I play those wonderful jazz standards of past decades. Brought a smile to my face when you ventured into "Red Sails In the Sunset" during your demos. Thanks for making my decision a LOT easier!

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  2 роки тому +1

      Thanks David! Were you hearing “Red Sails in The Sunset” at the picked Jazz part?? That section was actually the Bridge section of “Nearness of You”… I’m inspired to learn Red Sails now though!

  • @jongonzalez6917
    @jongonzalez6917 3 роки тому +7

    Excellent video! Honestly, I could live with any of those sets. They all sound so good. Thanks for putting this together.

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому

      you're welcome - and yeah not a bad set in the bunch.

  • @charvelgaming2975
    @charvelgaming2975 Рік тому +3

    Great demo. I love this format to compare the various sets. The 52 sounds great all around. Thinking of updating my classic vibe to those.

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  Рік тому +1

      Thanks - Love my 52s… I’ve had them since I did this video!

  • @pr0f477
    @pr0f477 Рік тому +3

    A3 vs Vintage neck:
    strum:
    A3: 1:36
    Vintage 2:01
    OD lead :
    A3 : 4:07
    Vintage: 4:38
    Clean fingerstyle :
    A3: 7:08
    Vintage: 7:30
    Blues/Jazz picked :
    A3: 13:33
    Vintage: 14:09

  • @TylerFoleyAudio
    @TylerFoleyAudio Рік тому +1

    Man, the A3's sounded KILLER. So even and had a really nice push to them...

  • @trevdickson
    @trevdickson 2 роки тому +3

    Wow, the 52's are sooo dynamic and responsive. Liked the A3 as well but they're a little "quacky" for me at times. Just ordered a set of the 52's to put in a chambered ash tele I'm building, thanks to this great comparison video! Thank you!

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  2 роки тому +2

      You’re welcome, glad it helped! Yeah, definitely a harder edge to the A3s that can get some quack… Really cool but has to be something you want IMO.

  • @alexwoods5132
    @alexwoods5132 2 роки тому +2

    Thanks for this mini series. I love the vintage’s tones the most, easily sound closest to the lower output sounds I look for in pickups to let your amp and fingers do a lot of talking.

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  2 роки тому +1

      Glad it helped! I especially love the middle sound on that vintage set.

  • @luizfloripa
    @luizfloripa Рік тому +1

    out of this world review. simply fantastic job!

  • @wilsondunlap
    @wilsondunlap 3 роки тому +4

    Gotta say, one of the things I really appreciate about the Special T bridge is that its high output makes the neck + bridge position sound waaaaay better. I had a normal 7.2K stock Fender bridge in there before, and with a 6.3K Royal T in the bridge, the middle positions sounded really quacky and funky, which isn't what I'm going for most of the time.
    I put a Special T in the bridge that read 8.3K on my multimeter, and the in between position sounds more like the neck + bridge on position on something like a Les Paul. Really, really beautiful.
    They Royal T neck is really, really excellent on its own, btw. It sounds way more like a Strat than the demos I watched made me think it would. The John Frusciante sort of Strat, not the Lethal Weapon soundtrack sort of Strat.

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому

      Agreed, a more powerful bridge gets a really sweet middle. For a Tele I really do like the quacky in general but yeah that Royal T gets finicky with the vintage in there for a fussy quack. I'm definitely doing the Royal with the special in the next video... Maybe I'll do it with the J-Street as well. Haha, lethal weapon stratty...

    • @peterosipov400
      @peterosipov400 3 роки тому

      Lethal Weapon OST strat courtesy of Eric Clapton :)

    • @oranjuly
      @oranjuly 3 роки тому

      😂

    • @MrBallynally2
      @MrBallynally2 Місяць тому

      I couldnt make the Royal T work w my vintage bridge. As a matter of fact the Royal T neck pickup in the end didnt work for me. It didnt deliver what i hoped for being a great combination of tele and strat. It fell in between the cracks..

  • @jorditoTX94
    @jorditoTX94 2 роки тому +2

    That Vintage/Royal T combo sounds tops.

  • @jasonhelms9410
    @jasonhelms9410 2 роки тому +2

    I put the Vintage(bridge) and special T(neck) in mine, and I love em, exactly what I was wanting

  • @cgavin1
    @cgavin1 2 роки тому +3

    I'm a total convert to A3 in Fenders. Re-wound some Gibsn P90's with A3 recently and they are also equally bursting with overtones and all those yummy extra frequencies you just don't get from A5 and A2.

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  2 роки тому +1

      Yeah I’m intrigued by A3. Ultimately I liked the roundness of the A2 on these lollars but the A3 were a close second.

  • @jasonwerner214
    @jasonwerner214 8 місяців тому

    Excellent Comparison. So helpful! Thank you so much!!

  • @petersparker
    @petersparker 3 роки тому +2

    Thanks for doing this! Appreciate the time and work put into it. Very cool! Been debating the Royal T, and it was great to hear it against these other tones. Think I'm still leaning that way... I think...

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому

      Glad you enjoyed it! What bridge pickup?

  • @claudehopper9813
    @claudehopper9813 Рік тому

    Great demo with cool chord changes , i got a cool partscaster that needs something special for PU.s

  • @Awrange
    @Awrange Рік тому

    THIS is how it's done. Thank you!

  • @mattchilled
    @mattchilled 3 роки тому +1

    Great video's I've seen them both on the telecaster Lollar pickups. The A3, 52 & Super were the 3 pickups that stood out to me & was also impressed with the Royal T from the 2 video's. Thanks for sharing I'll have to pickup a bridge & neck Lollar pickup maybe A3 bridge & 52 neck.

  • @hobiecat901
    @hobiecat901 5 місяців тому +1

    I liked all but leaned to the A3 slightly.

  • @4CloudySky
    @4CloudySky 3 роки тому +1

    Maan, that was super helpful. I guess I'm gonna go for 52 set, it's so transparent :)

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому

      They’re so fun to play with Fingers especially! Really special pickups. Cheers

    • @4CloudySky
      @4CloudySky 3 роки тому

      @@haskitt I'm so sorry for reposting my comment but I'm really looking forward for your input on this. "Can you provide your input on SD Antiquity pickups? Are they lack something compare to Lollars? I'm asking this because I'm a HUGE fan of their Antiquity PAF, so naturally I wanted to go with them in my Pincaster build. Those PAF are really something special cause I tried several boutique ones like BKP The Mules. Also, what do you think about using LP 50's wiring in a Tele? Yes, apparently you can do that! Btw I have 50's wiring on both of my Gibson inspired guitars (Heritage H-150 and old Japan-made Navigator ES 335 ommage) and it is truly great way to improve not only your tone in general, but also control over it. I'm able to go clean to mean with just a flick of a switch, without touching my amp at all, and it works perfectly with ampsims too (like Scuffham S-Gear). If you are interested in this, just drop me an email, i will send you some clips and I also could provide some valuable tech info regarding 50's wiring, cause there are some :)"

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому

      @@4CloudySky hey, I saw this initially but it’s not in my queue for some reason. I have an antiquity 1 set I want to compare this summer against the 52s (Bridge is A2 like the 52). Anyhow, a few years back I compared the two antiquity necks to a Fender American standard neck, Honestly wasn’t overwhelmed with either, and ended up with a lollar Charlie Christian set in that guitar.

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому

      @@4CloudySky ua-cam.com/video/KTaKSQb0P-Y/v-deo.html

    • @4CloudySky
      @4CloudySky 3 роки тому

      ​@@haskitt That's invaluable information, thank you! Unfortunately I don't have a budget to do a direct comparison between those two. I'm gonna go with Lollar 52 just to be safe. Anyway my pinecaster parts are still in their way to Russia and I'm trying to learn how to French polish a guitar, I'm gonna go with shellac :)

  • @hi_fi_lo
    @hi_fi_lo 4 місяці тому

    Love this video. The comments prove that tone os subjective, bc I didn't have a clear winner but a clear loser in the vintage set, which others seem to love. That's the beauty of gear!!! 🙂

  • @haveatomato
    @haveatomato 3 роки тому +1

    Great review, this was really helpful!

  • @ShaneBakerTV
    @ShaneBakerTV Рік тому

    I agree with you 100%. By the way, amazing job on your comparison

  • @michaelpaul3916
    @michaelpaul3916 3 роки тому +1

    Just ordered the A3 set because of this video. Thanks for helping me decide on pickups. This was bar none the best comparison I could find on Lollar pickups.

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому

      Glad I could help! Love those A3s.

  • @pharmerdavid1432
    @pharmerdavid1432 Рік тому +1

    Old video, but FWIW if anyone sees this: the Vintera road worn telecaster I bought used came with a Duncan La Brea bridge pickup (AlNiCo 4) and Lollar Royal-T neck pickup. They balance well together, and the La Brea may be my favorite bridge telecaster pickup, it's very musical sounding to me. The Royal-T (AlNiCo 5) sounds more like a strat than tele prehaps, and I know some players used to put strat pickups in the neck position on telecasters (they are a little larger, so enlarging is needed). I like a good telecaster neck pickup that still has the twang of a telecaster, like the pickups on my Shijie telecasters. They seller included the original pickups with the deal, which are supposedly pretty hot, like the Tex/Mex they used to use perhaps?

  • @jaco_h5013
    @jaco_h5013 Рік тому +1

    Great video 👍 i am trying to find a telecaster bridge thats close to the jimmy page led zeppelin 1 sound and have heard that the lollar vintage T is close in sound would you say this is accurate as you have heard this pickup in person ?

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  Рік тому

      Man, really hard to say! So many variables between him recording that and us hearing it, and I don’t really know how hot the wind/mags were on his Tele pups. I really go for what Pickup inspires me the most, rather than comparison to guitar tones from my favorite records.

  • @pablorodriguezperez992
    @pablorodriguezperez992 3 роки тому

    Amazing comparison, thanks a lot!

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому

      Glad you liked it, cheers!

  • @HappyChillmore
    @HappyChillmore 6 місяців тому

    Nice demo

  • @tadoverbaugh2190
    @tadoverbaugh2190 3 роки тому

    Fantastic video! Thank you.

  • @gertzpalma
    @gertzpalma Рік тому +1

    THANKS, SCOTT! ... A3

  • @johncollier6303
    @johncollier6303 2 місяці тому

    Gotta say, for me 52 bridge, Vintage Neck. Great demo

  • @MelodyCarroll-rx8tk
    @MelodyCarroll-rx8tk 10 місяців тому

    Question- I understood your issue with the Vintage T neck and bridge not complementing one another as far as volume or output. Would you advise me to not combine the Vintage T bridge with the 52 neck? I mean, would that widen the divide even further? I need answers because I'm stressing out about which combo to put in my tele.

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  10 місяців тому

      Honestly that combo sounds good to me! I think teles are always a little better when the bridge is a little hotter than the neck or at least close to it. The 52 neck I think would give the vintage bridge a little illusion of boost.

    • @MelodyCarroll-rx8tk
      @MelodyCarroll-rx8tk 10 місяців тому

      ​@@haskitt Thank you for your help here. I value your opinion and I know how much you like those 52s! Thanks!

  • @robotmeister009
    @robotmeister009 3 роки тому

    Great demo. God bless.

  • @guitarjules8173
    @guitarjules8173 Рік тому

    I also liked the 52 best in your particular tele fwiw.

  • @mikeaustin4138
    @mikeaustin4138 Рік тому

    52 and A3 were my favorites. I want to put these in my G&L ASAT Classic S, so I'll need to find a compatible Strat middle pickup...

  • @jakemiller936
    @jakemiller936 9 місяців тому

    For the bridge pickups, are they staggered or flat pole pieces?

  • @francislalonde7843
    @francislalonde7843 6 місяців тому

    What do you think about the special T bridge and a 52 neck or a set of 52?

  • @zettepix2009
    @zettepix2009 2 роки тому

    Thanks for the excellent review. With video 2 I was all for the vintage neck but here I see it is dark. Would an a3 in the neck and special t in the bridge make sense or the output is too different?

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  2 роки тому +1

      I would like that combo.., I typically like my Bridge to be hotter/thicker than the Neck anyhow. Those A3 pickups cut nicely though, so should be an interesting combo!

  • @joshcarter617
    @joshcarter617 2 роки тому +1

    This video has now cost me my second pair of Lollars.

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  2 роки тому +1

      Ha, nice! What two pairs?

    • @joshcarter617
      @joshcarter617 2 роки тому

      @@haskitt this time it’s the A3 pair. The first time around it was from the other video and I got a Special T bridge and Vintage neck. That combo is so sweet

  • @stavrou0
    @stavrou0 3 роки тому

    Scott - thanks for putting this vid together. its super helpful. I play blues, jazz and fingerstyle, rock. I need a pickup with no icepick when I pick hard under overdrive. I currently have a set of TexSpecials.. and they sound great at low volumes.. but crank up the amp.. and ice pick city.. I was thinking about 52s or A3s but also... what do you think about a 52 neck with an A3 bridge? any suggestions ?

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому

      I think that combination would work… Honestly I hear less ice pick in the 52, but as I’m sure you realize it depends on the rig! But yeah, I would go for the A3 or the 52 for sure. Cheers!

  • @ironman1290
    @ironman1290 3 роки тому

    Which one of these pickups do you think would sound the best alongside a Lollar low wind Regal wide range humbucker???

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  2 роки тому

      J street or special

  • @artneue
    @artneue Рік тому

    I liked the sound of the Vintage the most :) But I prefer a jazzier tone.

  • @ohpotatoesandmolasses
    @ohpotatoesandmolasses 3 роки тому +4

    The Vintage in the neck is just too rounded/fat. I vote 52s, too.

  • @daveandrew7014
    @daveandrew7014 3 роки тому +3

    Hmm Alnico III wins for me on all occasion. It cuts all the mud and unnecessarily warmth in the mix. It's like miking an amp with a 57. The rest sounds more like SM7B.

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому

      Agreed, except for the A3... That really is a no nonsense cut monster. I still prefer the A2, but didn’t expect to like A3 as much. Cheers!

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому

      Just realized you said Alnico III, i misread as Alnico II. I think I hadn’t put my glasses on yet! So yeah, your assessment makes total sense to me. I just like the warmth in the 52 (A2).

    • @smoochie3331
      @smoochie3331 3 роки тому

      I bought A3 months ago. I also have Ron Ellis pickups. I haven’t made up my mind which one would be in my Danocaster.

  • @superelectic45
    @superelectic45 Рік тому

    The more I hear the A3's the more I like them. They're less scooped than the Vintage (which sound exactly how most Teles sound) and easier on the ear. The 52's I found a bit too mid rangey.

  • @MrBallynally2
    @MrBallynally2 Місяць тому

    My preference: 52, then A3, then Vintage then Royal T.

  • @cobowe
    @cobowe Рік тому +1

    A3 bridge is perfect for Gilmour and Andy Summers

  • @benink5690
    @benink5690 2 роки тому

    52 Bridge is nice a fat! Vintage just sounds vintage. I like those too

  • @rtbmusic1135
    @rtbmusic1135 2 роки тому

    Just wondering which pots and caps are in that guitar, and if you like a treble bleed?

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  2 роки тому

      250k CTS pots, orange drop .047 uf… I go back and forth about treble bleeds but I don’t think this setup had one. Recently I like single coils without a bleed so a little less volume tames brightness. Cheers!

  • @henrod27
    @henrod27 3 роки тому

    What were the pickup height Measurment you had on these tele pickup set ? Please and thank you

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому

      I’ll check and let you know this weekend!

  • @AhrenField
    @AhrenField 2 роки тому

    Were your A3's bridge pole pieces staggered or flat? Thanks!

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  2 роки тому +1

      All these pickups were flat pole - cheers!

  • @Cry4her
    @Cry4her Рік тому

    I like the A3 and the 52s the most.
    A3 seems like the more versatile choice while the 52s rocks the OD section.
    Clean strumming section: A3 is the winner by having the least amount of annoying high pitch overtones.
    Od section: 52 is the winner by having the best respons to OD. The most distinct attack that quickly turns into a soft mellow sustain.
    There is no way I can pick a favourite between these two pickups...

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  Рік тому +1

      Interesting… this comment makes me want to listen through again to hear the A3! I went with the 52 set, have had since, but I was def between the two.

    • @cobowe
      @cobowe Рік тому

      I have the 52
      I Should've bout the A3!

  • @jannatinkarlen8702
    @jannatinkarlen8702 3 роки тому +1

    is that warmoth neck ?

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  2 роки тому

      Yep! 59 roundback vintage modern.

  • @szabinho26
    @szabinho26 Рік тому

    The best neck pickup is the Royal

  • @4CloudySky
    @4CloudySky 3 роки тому

    Lol. Btw, I did the choice BEFORE watching the Recap part.

  • @terryozburn4417
    @terryozburn4417 2 роки тому

    I think Vintage #1, 52 #2. Awesome Demo, can’t go wrong with any of these Lollar pups. Thanks for an awesome video!!!

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  2 роки тому

      agreed - They’re all great. thanks!

  • @ellisfarrier
    @ellisfarrier 3 роки тому

    Fantastic demo.
    Is the overdriven rhythm an actual song? It's awesome.

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому

      Thanks Shane! It’s actually a riff I wrote to demo pickups… it’s a pretty fun way to get song starters, by having specific goals for styles and sounds. Cheers!

    • @ellisfarrier
      @ellisfarrier 3 роки тому

      @@haskitt Thanks for the reply!
      Based on your demo I bought the 52 pick ups.
      Will update when installed.

  • @dangitdan9938
    @dangitdan9938 3 роки тому

    Vintage FTW!

  • @lewisdanderson
    @lewisdanderson Рік тому

    And that's how you demo pickups.

  • @bigtsshackfestival9563
    @bigtsshackfestival9563 3 роки тому

    Is that a Nash tele ?

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому +2

      That Tele is a guitar mill swamp ash body (finished by BloomDoom finishes) with a warmoth neck.

  • @nathansterrett3054
    @nathansterrett3054 3 роки тому

    What's the name of the A3 set?

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому

      Actually just Alnico 3!

    • @nathansterrett3054
      @nathansterrett3054 3 роки тому

      @@haskitt Oh. Gotcha. Thanks. They sound great.

  • @ryanewalters
    @ryanewalters 3 роки тому

    52 for me, im getting that in the bridge and a p-90 in the neck because i can ; }

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому

      What P90 are you thinking? Even though the 52 bridge and a good p90 neck are my two go-to sounds, I have trouble with them in the same guitar because of the output difference.

    • @ryanewalters
      @ryanewalters 3 роки тому

      @@haskitt Doesn't matter the way I use them. I"ll use the 52 for a song then use the P-90 for another song. Just for drastic guitar sound differences. I play weird chords and rhythm guitar with very few solos. If I do i don't switch pickups.

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому

      @@ryanewalters ah nice - not sure at what point I became so obsessed with pickups being matched in volume but it definitely limits my options!

    • @ryanewalters
      @ryanewalters 3 роки тому

      @@haskitt It depends on your angle. It could be a positive. When your doing a lead, switch to your P-90 and its like a boost and an overdrive. There are no rules in music. Mine as well make your own.

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  3 роки тому

      @@ryanewalters well said!

  • @alafenetre81
    @alafenetre81 Рік тому

    All the PUs sound so similar, I don't see the point of having one or the other.

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  Рік тому +1

      If you’re happy with your Tele sound and don’t hear a difference there’s no need to dive in. Personally I had originally bought the Special set and wasn’t happy with them… too stiff. Getting the 52 set completely changed how I approach my Tele with my hands and on my amp.

  • @jimmy5634
    @jimmy5634 2 роки тому

    If I had another Tele, it would have the A3’s in it.

    • @haskitt
      @haskitt  2 роки тому +1

      Not a week goes by I don’t say this very thing to myself!

    • @jimmy5634
      @jimmy5634 Місяць тому

      I ended up swapping out the bridge in one of my Teles for a “Holy Grail” with A3’s by Rob Di Stefano of Cavaliers pickups.
      It’s very, very good.