PlayStation 2 vs. PCSX2 - Which is BEST for 4K Gaming? (RetroTINK 4K vs. Emulator 2024)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 310

  • @jronco2
    @jronco2 4 місяці тому +135

    dbz 3 is 480p hold triangle and x while booting

    • @unsimpleoledor7219
      @unsimpleoledor7219 2 місяці тому +3

      It is, but when you activate 480p, the performance (fps) is reduced and the color range is also reduced, giving a less vivid image.

  • @Manic_Panic
    @Manic_Panic 4 місяці тому +83

    You know, you don't have to upscale if you don't want to. PCSX2 has an option called "software mode" on the renderer selector that pretty much provides the PS2 experience. Though, I recommend to keep anti-blur on just to make the games look a bit cleaner than real hardware... and the no-interlacing patches too of course.

    • @HollowRick
      @HollowRick 2 місяці тому +9

      I thought that too I would have been more interested to see a comparison at native res Which handles motion adaptive de interlacing better

  • @BlackPanthaa
    @BlackPanthaa 4 місяці тому +113

    oh my god I have been looking for Champions of Norrath for YEARS AND YEARS. I played a demo disc and it's one of the games I didn't know the name of. I will be back in a few weeks... bless you I LOVE YOU

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому +13

      Huzzah!

    • @Will-qd2km
      @Will-qd2km 4 місяці тому +11

      there is also a sequel called "Call to Arms"

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому +16

      Champions Return to Arms

    • @Will-qd2km
      @Will-qd2km 4 місяці тому +7

      @@lostsaves my bad, been awhile, I was big into EverQuest so I really enjoyed those games

    • @ItsTacosDude
      @ItsTacosDude 4 місяці тому +2

      If only you mentioned it even a single time in any of your videos I could have told you exactly what you were looking for!

  • @CreativeMindsAudio
    @CreativeMindsAudio 4 місяці тому +17

    i love how it really shows where the emulator shines and a reason to keep the OG hardware.

  • @ivibs1984
    @ivibs1984 4 місяці тому +18

    Gotta leave a second comment. Ive been playing around with PCSX2 and I think the sweet spot in settings are 720P Resolution + Scanline filter. I feel like that gives the best combination of improved clarity but leaves just enough blur to hide all the visual artifacts that a standard defination CRT would hide. If you see this comment I am curious to know what you think of those settings.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому +3

      I'm just not a fan of the built-in CRT emulation at all. Been digging into Reshade CRT emulation off and on, but if I'm going to go through that effort, I'm just going to play on a real CRT lol

    • @saidevpappu
      @saidevpappu 3 місяці тому +1

      Thanks i followed, for san andreas. I like the taste. Some games look like watching spiderman into the verse with high quality. :have a great day.

    • @ivibs1984
      @ivibs1984 3 місяці тому

      @@lostsaves I have no experience with reshade. What is the visual difference between it and the scanline filter?

  • @abdullaal-naimi9075
    @abdullaal-naimi9075 4 місяці тому +10

    Generally speaking, stylized games like Jak and Daxter, Spyro, and Crash Bandicoot benefit the most from emulator enhancements. Zelda Windwaker looks like a complete remaster just by bumping the render resolution. The cartoon/cellshaded style lends itself nicely to upscaling.

  • @slamjamtime202
    @slamjamtime202 4 місяці тому +6

    I appreciate the opinions here, I am of the same mind. In the late 2000s I was playing PS2 games in 4k with my i7 950 CPU and it was truly amazing, Kingdom Hearts games in particular look very clean in 4k. Over the years I just find that playing games on their native systems more often than not gives the best experience. Older textures look so much better at low resolutions, it gives the illusion of way more detail being there than their actually is and you lose that magic when you upscale for most games.

  • @TechnicalGamingChannel
    @TechnicalGamingChannel 4 місяці тому +20

    I think the light trails in midnight club are intended to emulate how blown highlights would trail on ancient handicams

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому +3

      I don’t mind it in the real game, it just doesn’t look right in PCSX2

    • @wowbobwowmusic
      @wowbobwowmusic 4 місяці тому +1

      Why not just emulate the game in the original resolution if the light trails look bad in 4k?

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому

      Because 4K wasn’t the specific cause

    • @nixnix22
      @nixnix22 4 місяці тому +1

      what about leaving motion blur on and keeping res at 4k?

    • @infernokazama
      @infernokazama 3 місяці тому +1

      @@lostsaves Although not a fix, but a workaround to fix the streetlights is to quickly press F9 to enter Software Mode and back again to the Renderer of your choice completely eliminates this issue. You have to do it each time you enter a race or to into cruise around the map, but it does indeed fix the issue of the street lights trailing. I will admit that is honestly the one thing holding it back from becoming better to play on PCSX2.

  • @BBKDRAGOON
    @BBKDRAGOON 4 місяці тому +22

    Absolutely incredible videos lately dude, loving these!

  • @yadspi
    @yadspi 4 місяці тому +10

    I'm weird, I put the games in 720p, no widescreen and in my mind they look the way I remember them, crunchy but not blurry/aliased so I play this way.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому +2

      Sounds like a solid way to go!

    • @yadspi
      @yadspi 4 місяці тому +3

      @@lostsaves yeah, I didn't like playing on PCSX2 because it felt heavier (input latency) than my real PS2 but found out you just need to choose 0 on frames to buffer and set it to hard GPU sync, it needs a beefier PC but feels exactly as a real PS2 that way.

    • @gabrielgomez-bg2ln
      @gabrielgomez-bg2ln 2 місяці тому

      How do I configure this? In which part of the emulator? ​@@yadspi

  • @jg2722
    @jg2722 24 дні тому +3

    1:45 thats just the nostalgia talking bro. I love how the PCSX2 makes everything run and look better. Cant beat that. All you gotta do is get some mountain dew and doritos, and customize your room to get that same early 2000s feel. Old game posters, movie posters, and band posters. The only difference now is that we are adults and got bills. That being said i only use my ds lite to play ds games because of the dual screens. But for other consoles i use emulators on pc or retro devices for upscaling and improving performance.

  • @jbalazer
    @jbalazer 4 місяці тому +6

    When deinterlacing doesn't work right in PCSX2, try changing the deinterlacing field order (top field first or bottom field first). In some of your examples it looked like the fields were getting swapped.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому +5

      Thanks for this! A bit embarrassed that I didn't check this, but also strange that it's happening at all. Top field first should only be used by HD sources, and it's odd for specific games to utilize it. That being said, I did try it and it fixed Tekken 5, though the MA deinterlacer still holds up VERY poorly compared to that of the Framemeister/RetroTINKs. Still disappointed in the implementation, but it certainly fixes it here. Soul Calibur II was not fixed by this, unfortunately.

    • @yadspi
      @yadspi 4 місяці тому +1

      ​@@lostsaves SC2 doesn't exist outside the GameCube and Link 😂

  • @conza1989
    @conza1989 3 місяці тому +5

    Great comparisons, but it’s all really subjective, I see all the PCSX2 stuff and think ‘no comparison that’s way cleaner and better’, but I do get the look of the shimmering/distortion/black pixel darkening adds a mood or texture to some of the games here

  • @SK91NO
    @SK91NO 4 місяці тому +12

    CRTs probably do the original hardware more justice, they can really smooth out the low res elements, I never really liked the mismatched look of high resolution combined with low res textures, and sometimes models. It's a really variable thing but despite that there's still a significant amount of detail that can be brought up by up-rendering in models, it's a weird thing.
    A few of these games (as mentioned with ultimate alliance) have ports/remasters better on that hardware like
    SoulCalibur II pulling 720p (albeit at 4:3 only) on Xbox (and it's remaster for PS3/360)
    MK Armageddon also pulling 720p on Xbox
    GOW games and their PS3 remasters
    and Katamari Damacy with it's Switch/PS4/Xbox/PC remaster
    Just Cause and it's advanced PC/360 release
    Tomb Raider Anniversary with 360 and PC ports
    Budokai 3 on 360/PS3 (without it's original soundtrack, you can mod it in if you have what's necessary though)
    and on the note of Budokai 3, that does support 480p natively if you hold △ and X on boot.
    Lastly there's a few games where no-interlacing patches exist but weren't used, I don't know if PCSX2 just include them or if they're stuck on the forum but yeah, nice vid.

  • @Gr00t
    @Gr00t 4 місяці тому +5

    What are your opinions on older PC games say pre 2005 being played on a CRT monitor vs a modern display? Currently playing through Dark Forces 1 and my CRT monitor bit the dust mid playthrough so i swapped to my main PC and am playing it on an OLED. Man did it ever feel and look better on the CRT. Crazy how 320x200 85FPS on the CRT feels better than 1440p 240FPS on the OLED.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому +1

      A lot of them definitely feel better on a CRT. CRT masks help hide the graphics and make them feel a lot more real

  • @GambitX37
    @GambitX37 Місяць тому +2

    You seem biased towards original hardware. Emulation is literally always better because it's not limited by the hardware, keeps improving over time, has WAY more options, etc. In the Midnight Club example you could have just chose options (like leaving motion blur on) to make it more authentic.

  • @biggie01taws6
    @biggie01taws6 4 місяці тому +31

    I can't vouch for the RetroTINK 4K since I don't have one, but I'm pretty satisfied with PCSX2. It's really convenient to be able to access over 1200 PS2 titles on my 5tb external hard drive at the drop of a hat, on my PC, with the emulator upscaled to 3x or 4x native resolution. I also have an original PS2 fat and a 1tb hard drive in the expansion bay with a FCMB memory card & OPL connected to my tv with a "PS2 to HDMI" connector. While it's definitely better than the native connection, it's still not that good. I'd like to have the RetroTINK 4K but with it being $750, I'd have to take out a small loan lol. I'll just stick with the emulator and my PS2 fat set up for now lol. Good comparison video though!👍

    • @RedEyedDRAG00N
      @RedEyedDRAG00N Місяць тому

      Thief

    • @leorelic
      @leorelic Місяць тому

      @@RedEyedDRAG00N what? the system is no longer sold and its games are no longer sold , who did they steal from to become a thief? you living in 2000s my dude?

    • @RedEyedDRAG00N
      @RedEyedDRAG00N Місяць тому

      @@leorelic 1200 ISOs tells me he is a thief.

    • @RedEyedDRAG00N
      @RedEyedDRAG00N Місяць тому

      @@leorelic So ima just pretend I didnt buy a PS2 in 2021 and havent been buying games because according to you, they arent being sold.

    • @leorelic
      @leorelic Місяць тому +2

      ​@@RedEyedDRAG00N dawg 1200 ISOS of a system no longer sold in an official capacity. sure on a technicality its still piracy but no one , not ONE person gives a shit about that. hell even law doesn't care about that.
      no one is saying you should pretend you didn't buy a PS2 in 2021 or its games , but i am saying you did not buy that when Sony was selling it officially. it is no longer a system manufactured OR sold by Sony. they are no longer games published and sold by Sony. you BOUGHT them from a third party that is not Sony. it is literally abandonware. no company out there is currently making and selling legit new PS2 games. and guess what , PS3 is the same.
      so no , he is not a thief , he is a preservationist of history who refuses to pay 2 or 3 sometimes 4 times the price of a game for a legit copy off of a third party seller where the safety of the games or consoles are not guaranteed.

  • @tonson5214
    @tonson5214 Місяць тому

    I'm so glad you covered some of these games that made my childhood. Thank you.

  • @brobocop8293
    @brobocop8293 3 місяці тому +3

    why not do both ? run the ps2 emulator through a tink 4k with mask and scanlines emulation... i do this now with batocera and a real crt and you get the best of both worlds... higher model resolutions and cleaner visuals fed back through 240p.... it looks incredible.

    • @HollowRick
      @HollowRick 2 місяці тому

      I'd be really curious to see how that looks I hope he sees this comment and does a video on it in the future

  • @ilfaraone91
    @ilfaraone91 2 місяці тому

    Champions RTA is so underrated, i still love it to this day

  • @otakuuniteda.s.2882
    @otakuuniteda.s.2882 4 місяці тому +14

    PS2 on PS3 is still king!

    • @ineedandrenaline
      @ineedandrenaline 3 місяці тому +10

      Definitely not

    • @leorelic
      @leorelic Місяць тому

      absolutely not lmao , its partly unaccessible incredibly expensive hardware which can die fast , at that point with its costs+repair cost in case it dies , you would rather get an actual PS2 with an upscaler or a freaking low-tier to mid-tier gaming PC that can handle PS2 emulation just fine. even Steam Deck can do that.

    • @ineedandrenaline
      @ineedandrenaline Місяць тому +3

      @@leorelic hell a $300 mini pc will give you 1080p-1440p on most games on PCSX2

    • @leorelic
      @leorelic Місяць тому

      @@ineedandrenaline yes it does.

    • @otakuuniteda.s.2882
      @otakuuniteda.s.2882 Місяць тому

      @@leorelic My PS3 60gb is still going very strong. I had to replace the cmos battery, but other than that I have never had any issues.

  • @kylespevak6781
    @kylespevak6781 3 місяці тому

    3:00 This was one of the few games that i have dropped frames on emulator

  • @Ia-iu6pc
    @Ia-iu6pc 4 місяці тому +1

    Geniune question as you talk a lot of some games looking better on crt (i agree) then why do this comparassion with a upscaler for modern tvs? Like if it is for that why not using a nice crt shader on pc like crt royale?

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому +3

      Good question! I do plan on exploring good CRT shaders in future videos. I don’t like the CRT filters in PCSX2 specifically (and was trying to keep this to built in stuff) and most people who didn’t grow up with them don’t prefer the CRT look in general these days either

  • @MatWilson2612
    @MatWilson2612 4 місяці тому +3

    Man - I'm so torn now.. Love the video but the decision is as clear as mud lol.
    I have an Original Xbox, PS2 and Xbox 360.
    I've been set on getting an OSSC Pro (Xbox 360 upscaling) and I currently have an Electron Sheperd HDMI adapter.
    It's just such a tough idea - I can either get a HDMI mod for the Xbox and get a nice clean 480p signal and be done - then I've only got a handful of games that I'd need to emulate or play on PS2 without an upscaler (GTA VCS, GT4 and the Getaway).

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому +1

      Get the OSSC!!!

    • @MatWilson2612
      @MatWilson2612 Місяць тому

      @@lostsaves I did! It's decent for sure

  • @chris08091
    @chris08091 4 місяці тому +1

    Really amazing video, good to see

  • @Aletdownofstate
    @Aletdownofstate 4 місяці тому +2

    Great video! I'd be interested in seeing more comparisons like this for PS2 games and perhaps even GameCube/Dolphin comparisons if you ever made them.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому +1

      Thanks for the idea!

  • @cackoocacho1629
    @cackoocacho1629 4 місяці тому +4

    Nice video with some cool examples of comparisons. Only one thing I would agrue back, is that you can play on pcsx2 at original PS2 resolution, which will solve many graphics anomalies that are caused due to upscaling.
    Worse comes to worse, you can play at original PS2 resolution with software rendering instead, which increases the accuracy to impressive levels. Team this up with some nicely tweaked filters, and well, you have a pretty convincing replacement for actual hardware. 🤷‍♂
    I do still have many original consoles, but, when it comes to PS2, I do use PCSX2 a lot, simply for convenience and practicality. 🍻

  • @David-id2ks
    @David-id2ks 26 днів тому +1

    I feel like youre leaving out the fact that you need to often change settings in the emulator in order to get games working right. Nothing beats a console + retrotink, especially if playing on an OLED.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  26 днів тому

      Well part of the point of this was with the 2.0 update to PCSX2, most of those are handled automatically now. There were maybe 2 games here where I still had to tinker and I did note them.
      But also my entire opinion part of the video made it very clear that getting an authentic experience is easiest with original PS2, definitely didn’t leave that out lol

  • @MakesToast
    @MakesToast 2 місяці тому

    how did you enter the settings ingame at 9:45 please, cant find that button

  • @chhandobhihbhushan2742
    @chhandobhihbhushan2742 4 місяці тому +3

    Ironically, playing gt4 on PS2 using small tv feels better than at 1080p with pcsx2 and that's mainly because it hides imperfections through blurry graphics and smaller display. 4k textures are too sharp and cars feel very slightly blocky due to it.
    But it's easier to play on pcsx2 than to set up the tv and aging PS2 for me

    • @bluetooth2677
      @bluetooth2677 4 місяці тому +1

      Funny that you mention that. I use a 720p TV for playing PS3 games. To be honest, having Edge smoothing on, when playing on the original hardware looks almost the same as when emulating it. I'm the kind of person who uses both original hardware and emulation."

    • @chhandobhihbhushan2742
      @chhandobhihbhushan2742 4 місяці тому +1

      @@bluetooth2677I think PS3 emulation is fine and that's mainly due games still looking decent. Imo I just like a little bit of smoothening, not too much otherwise it ruins the details.

    • @bluetooth2677
      @bluetooth2677 4 місяці тому +1

      @@chhandobhihbhushan2742 Agree, PS3 emulator is fine. But there still a lot of issues with it. But if you don't have a good PC, using 720 TV does wonders for PS3/360 games. Because most only support 720p resolution.

  • @ookiiokonomiyaki
    @ookiiokonomiyaki 3 місяці тому

    What about the input lag in the emulator? I'd heard it is impossible to solve the input lag problem in ps2 emulator.

  • @ennymusicofficial
    @ennymusicofficial 3 місяці тому

    I've been waiting for a video like this! 😊

  • @Auroclock
    @Auroclock 3 місяці тому

    Have you tried using SpecialK or ReShade to inject HDR into PCSX2? Obviously HDR is not accurate but I've found it helps a lot for older games!

  • @Alianger
    @Alianger Місяць тому

    What about button pressure sensitivity on PCSX2?

  • @c0nd3mnd22
    @c0nd3mnd22 2 місяці тому

    Would've loved to see PCSX2 running at the game's original resolution added to the comparison as well. A lot of your complaints stem from the game running at "too high" of a resolution making the lack of detail in some games stick out more (not sure I agree with that, but that's why a comparison would've been nice).

  • @cobywalker3922
    @cobywalker3922 4 місяці тому +2

    Excellent video and excellent points. The conclusion I came to was one you didn't consider actually. I think playing the games on the emulator with the native 480i / 480p renderer with a CRT filter is the way to go. That way everything looks as it was intended but you get a crystal clear image. Also the PS2 native renderer in PCSX2 is very accurate to PS2 however the hardware renderer is NOT as accurate and does not support as many features. This is why some of the Silent Hill games for example look perfect with the PCSX2 software renderer but are missing effects with the hardware renderer.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому +1

      According to the devs, software rendering shouldn’t make any difference after the 2.0 update & using Vulkan.
      I do actually agree that on many cases using native res is the best (which is why you see me experimenting with it in some games) and I like outputting that to a VGA CRT. I don’t really enjoy the CRT filters in PCSX2 at all, though, and I hope someone contributes better ones eventually.

  • @PC-ONE
    @PC-ONE 3 місяці тому

    Did you downscale the PS2 resolution? I don't think the games looked as bad on PS2 as I'm seeing them in your video.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  3 місяці тому +1

      No? Upscaled 4k using the RetroTINK 4K & WobblingPixels’ profiles

  • @christopherhalo
    @christopherhalo 3 місяці тому

    cool video dude, i recently got a ps2 and crt (og xbox as when i was a kid) and im really excited to play all the games i can

  • @Bartacolips
    @Bartacolips 2 місяці тому

    I still can't get hd texture packs to work in pcsx2... Any advice??

  • @iPat6G
    @iPat6G 4 місяці тому

    Did you run your PCSX2 games through a big 4K TV when comparing? I find that while the graphics might look better on the emulator, the playing experience is much better on a big TV screen vs. small computer screen.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому +1

      Yes a 48” OLED

  • @MLWJ1993
    @MLWJ1993 3 місяці тому +1

    PCSX2 ought to have the same option as Dolphin does, where I can opt to choose the native output resolution with 8x SSAA applied to get rid of the horrid shimmering.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  3 місяці тому +1

      That’d be amazing TBH

  • @SensatoKuro
    @SensatoKuro 4 місяці тому

    Great job, incredible video!

  • @MaloryHovell
    @MaloryHovell 3 місяці тому +1

    5:29 the wall became invisible in 2002, still unknown technology to fromsoftware and blizzard.

  • @xt6997
    @xt6997 Місяць тому

    Wonder if ps2 games have the same issue with older pc games when upscaled where a better resolution only makes these games look more outdated.

  • @BlackWingGenesis
    @BlackWingGenesis Місяць тому

    Does this new version pcsx2 still have input lag?

  • @alejandrooro9932
    @alejandrooro9932 3 місяці тому

    great content!

  • @flamingmonkey7712
    @flamingmonkey7712 2 місяці тому

    Since the thumbnail is God of War 2, I have to say I don't understand why people choose rpcs3 over pcsx2 for the first two God of War games. On pcsx2 you can save stats and load pretty much any second while on RPCS3 you can only load you save stat before you load the game.

  • @David_Banner
    @David_Banner 4 місяці тому

    Run it all on PCSX2 and add crt/scanline shaders externally. Not the same as the console, but close and possibly the best of both worlds?

  • @598gh
    @598gh 3 місяці тому

    As someone who has been using software emulation for the past 13 years. I'll give the edge to the original hardware. The main reason is basically accuracy and input lag, bot of which are hugely lacking in this particular emulator. I'd rather play DMC3 on a real PS2 for example, because of the hard to time royal guard and other mechanics that require good timing. Doing it on PCSX2 is much harder because of that and felt unplayable sometimes because I'm so used to the original's latancy compared to emulation. That's only one game, not counting many others.

  • @Destroyersoul-e9x
    @Destroyersoul-e9x 4 місяці тому +11

    Not only you get a more consistent image with real hardware through a CRT TV, but also no input lag or very little input lag compared to playing with PCSX2 which has got a lot of input lag, like 2 or 3 frames, some games have 5 frames which is unbearable and makes fighting games very hard to play.
    When i tried a real PS2 through a CRT TV i was impressed with the no input lag, today with modern LCDs and emulators you dont get the same experience.
    If someone wants to go the emulation rute but still wants a "retro" feel, get a Raspberry PI and connect it to a CRT TV.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому +4

      CRTs for life!

    • @Destroyersoul-e9x
      @Destroyersoul-e9x 4 місяці тому +1

      @@lostsaves Agreed buddy.

    • @samuelbanya
      @samuelbanya 4 місяці тому

      A Pi has the same amount of input lag and can't play PS2. It would still be emulating and isn't an FPGA solution so it would still have input lag.
      Even if you somehow got a Pi 5 connected to a CRT by soldering the right pad, it still is emulating.
      The only way around it is with a modded PS2 with FreeMcBoot plus OPL Loader

    • @Destroyersoul-e9x
      @Destroyersoul-e9x 4 місяці тому

      @@samuelbanya I know this. But connected to a CRT you wil still have less input lag compared to a LCD, and also you can use run ahead.
      Yeah cant play PS2 that is the bad part really.

  • @jupsilvam
    @jupsilvam 2 місяці тому

    When I was 10 years old I had a PS2 and I never knew how to take advantage of the catalog, because I was very stupid, and I didn't know any English and many games were in English, now I want to take advantage of it and without a doubt the emulator looks infinitely superior

  • @impheris
    @impheris 4 місяці тому

    5:30 the issues with soul calibur II and III were fixed years ago buddy, you need to manually fix the sprites if i remember correctly that is in "manual hardware fixes"

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому

      PCSX2 already ships with a sprite fix for the game, which enables automatically and checking the "manual hardware fixes" box disables it. That fix fixes the old issues I described, but does not fix the newer deinterlacing issues I showcased.

  • @Yagami2027
    @Yagami2027 4 місяці тому +1

    If you don't mind getting it from Sailing the Seven Seas, you should be able to get Champions of Norrath CD quality soundtrack from places like Soulseek. You might have to go a little deeper to find it in high quality.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому +2

      Yeah I think I have a copy, I just like having the real thing

  • @Mr.Ditkovich.
    @Mr.Ditkovich. 4 місяці тому

    I really wish I could play LOTR Two Towers at 60fps. Why is it not possible to fix that?

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому

      Might be at some point. The GameCube version was coded for 60FPS, but the cutscenes look terrible compressed for the much smaller disc

  • @ShdwDnutProductions
    @ShdwDnutProductions 2 місяці тому

    It's interesting that you put Jak 3 in this video - pretty soon the definitive way to play it will be natively on PC, just like Jak and Daxter: TPL and Jak II. Have you seen OpenGOAL?

  • @Huginja
    @Huginja 4 місяці тому

    One huge benefit (for me) is overclocking of the cpu
    It increases the framerate in some games to the intended 30/60 fps
    Lots of games stutter on OG hardware
    It also applies to duckstation and PS1, especially the classic tomb raider games where framerates dip into the high 10s

  • @marioionion2
    @marioionion2 3 місяці тому

    9:36 down there is written tekken 5 instead of budokai 3

  • @douglassmith9445
    @douglassmith9445 3 місяці тому

    I’m a little confused. Why are you comparing 480p + rt4k to PCSX2? Shouldn’t it be 4k with rt4k compared to PCSX2? The higher resolutions you are getting with PCSX2 look like what I would’ve imagined with the rtk4 which is why I’m saying this.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  3 місяці тому

      I think you are confused. The RT4K is scaling to 4K.
      I was stating that the PS2 itself was outputting 480i/p to the Tink

    • @douglassmith9445
      @douglassmith9445 3 місяці тому

      @@lostsaves if that is the case, the rt4k doesn’t seem anywhere near as good as the price tag suggests

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  3 місяці тому

      It is an incredible scaler and beats anything on the market, even in the professional broadcast industry.
      But it can’t change the internal rendering resolution of games lol
      If I compared native 480 output from PCSX2, they would look nearly identical (which is what you want)

  • @WoZYtaZ83071
    @WoZYtaZ83071 2 місяці тому

    I remebmer that there where games with progressive mode(deinterlaced) when you was useing component video output, and to run game with progressive mode you had to hold some button when PS2 was starting reading dvd disc

  • @WithoutNumbers
    @WithoutNumbers 4 місяці тому

    This console and games on it were designed to work in tandem with older TVs. To simulate a picture of that time you need one of the CRT variants of ReShade effect, then advantage will always be with PCSX2 in my opinion, but you still need a powerful PC fo 4K gaming in 60 fps.

    • @WithoutNumbers
      @WithoutNumbers 4 місяці тому

      Retro Crisis channel can help understand that.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому

      CRT emulation doesn’t make up for the inaccuracies or outright errors, which is what this was focused on. RetroTINK also has great CRT emulation - it just isn’t used here because it doesn’t look good in videos at all

    • @WithoutNumbers
      @WithoutNumbers 4 місяці тому

      ​@@lostsaves I see and agreed with it. Not all of them looks goon on PC or have working fixes. So for a fair comparison, I think it also makes sense to compare only games that don’t have the obvious errors you showed, and simply ignore the rest as defective. That's exactly what I did with Haunting Ground until I found a solution of all problems. Of course one effect like CRT_Lotus.fx, CRT-Guest-Advanced.fx or BadBloomPS2.fx doesn't compensate for all features and artefacts of different games on PCSX2 in comparison with original console PS2 on CRT TV, but it would be interesting to see realistic view of final image of old time in comparison with the capabilities of programs available on a PC for understanding maximum of possible authentic reflection on modern screens. Judging by UA-cam, no one wants to deal with this, probably due to the lack of opportunities, the presence of a professional camera and a room that gives the right lighting conditions for this type of shooting, but yes, with 3D graphics everything can be different depending on some resolution and other factors like pinched UA-cam video. In any cace you did great work, I learned a lot of new things for myself, thanks.

    • @WithoutNumbers
      @WithoutNumbers 4 місяці тому

      This might be intresting too:
      RetroRGB - Why Retro Consoles Need A Scaler
      Macho Nacho Productions - I Made A PS2 So ADVANCED, It’s Basically A PS3

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому +1

      My own review of the RetroGEM is shouted out in that MachoNacho video lol..

  • @chaosvii4605
    @chaosvii4605 4 місяці тому +16

    CRT with a ps2. No other option

    • @MaI2Me
      @MaI2Me 2 місяці тому

      💯

    • @leorelic
      @leorelic Місяць тому

      i have both and i still prefer certain games on PCSX2 especially with all the modding capabilities it offers as well as HD Textures sometimes (example : Persona 3 FES)

    • @chaosvii4605
      @chaosvii4605 Місяць тому

      @@leorelic You should use PCSX2 on a CRT for the ultimate experience

    • @leorelic
      @leorelic Місяць тому

      @@chaosvii4605 god damn 😂nah i'm good i have an actual PS2 that works just fine. but PCSX2 for anything not CRT

    • @chaosvii4605
      @chaosvii4605 Місяць тому

      @ your loss, high red textures with crt scan lines is peak

  • @fatjawns3671
    @fatjawns3671 3 місяці тому

    Never played the silent hill series but I think those are the kinda games that would look better in their original art style as well with no resolution scaling/anti aliasing or filtering

  • @darkjoker7731
    @darkjoker7731 20 днів тому

    How powerfull pc support PCX2 Emulator?

  • @rafimokhtar278Pizza
    @rafimokhtar278Pizza 18 днів тому

    Can u play it normally with a keyboard and a mouse?

  • @luketa8831
    @luketa8831 Місяць тому

    really impressive!

  • @Dronetothetop
    @Dronetothetop 29 днів тому

    You don’t ever use the CRT shaders?

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  29 днів тому

      They’re not good

    • @Dronetothetop
      @Dronetothetop 29 днів тому

      @@lostsaves On RT4K

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  29 днів тому

      On the RetroTink, I do! But they look horrible in videos so I don’t really show it in videos.

  • @borisov_dev
    @borisov_dev 2 місяці тому +1

    Dunno, I prefer how real PS2 looks in 90% of your examples

    • @nelAjamZ
      @nelAjamZ Місяць тому

      I agree original is original... Ps3 on Hdmi looks way better than any Pc emulator.

  • @neorickio
    @neorickio 4 місяці тому

    it would be cool to see a comparison of pcsx2 vs retrotink 4k, everything on native resolution :)

  • @ianabreu3360
    @ianabreu3360 4 місяці тому

    After PCSX2 received the 2.0 update i don't need to worry about the original hardware anymore, and MNC 3 it's ok for me, i dont get distracted because of the light trails, it's always in there even in PS2 with a CRT panel, i aways seen it back in the days

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому +2

      The trails existing weren’t the problem. Of course they’re there on the original. The problem were that they were rendered completely incorrectly and almost detached from the light sources. They stand out instead of blending into the intended aesthetic

  • @MoonOvIce
    @MoonOvIce 2 місяці тому

    Just cause was originally developed as a 360 game first, all the other versions are ports (even the PC version), inferior, and are running in different graphics api and even engine. I owned the 360 version and later tried the PC demo back then, and a friend had the PS2 version and holy shit, what a massive difference.
    Same thing with NFSP Most Wanted. The PC version was a port from the og Xbox and PS2, the 360 version was the "definitive" version.

  • @cd8815
    @cd8815 Місяць тому

    Urgh honestly I was ready to pull the trigger on the Retrotink 4K and I think it is an extremely good choice for 2D consoles and maybe the GameCube or other progressive scan output consoles but for the PS2 in particular it really does not look good, I think the only options for tolerable image quality for the PS2 is basically PCSX2 or a CRT. I agree with everything you say about the barren look of certain games in PCSX2 but I don't think the Retrotink 4K is a solution to that, that satisfyingly noisy quality to an image that is missing in emulators seem to still only be presented properly in interpolated video by a CRT :(

  • @Kaos1989
    @Kaos1989 3 місяці тому

    The way I play PS2 games on my oled is using xbox series s in dev mode with the xbox fork of pcsx2 called xbsx2 which is then hooked up to a retrotink 4k. You get a 1080p HD PS2 experience upscaled to 4k with scanlines with the retrotink 4k.

  • @arianamirgholami9555
    @arianamirgholami9555 2 місяці тому

    I think deinterlace on auto should be the better option but I don't understand any of them so ..
    Also you can change textures on some games with pcsx2
    Few days ago I played crash of titans on both pcsx2 emulator and xbox360 emulator I was amazed that ps2 looked better while having much better frame rates

  • @HumanManufactured
    @HumanManufactured 4 місяці тому

    Most games actually have the option to disable interlacing in the patches tab. Also just play in software mode if you don't want any bugs.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому

      Most games do not. As very clearly stated at the start of the video, those were used where available.

  • @harryshuman9637
    @harryshuman9637 3 місяці тому

    Community patches and texture mods alone make the emulation worth it.
    Persona 3 FES Community Mod Pack is THE way to play Persona 3.

  • @IcedEarth1231
    @IcedEarth1231 2 місяці тому

    A bit of a dis-service to PCSX2 by not running a comparison through software mode. You would find that everything will look the same if not a bit better due to digital output on PC as opposed to analogue on PS2. Also, running the latest "stable" version is never recommended as PCSX2 is set up for rolling releases, stable is really only put up to preserve a period of time where the team hit a milestone. I would like it if you ran this test again but in software mode or in hardware mode using no resolution scaling so you might also get other effects (texture filtering options, texture replacements). Cool vid regardless I do like seeing these comparisons against real hardware.

  • @mohamedsohaib4277
    @mohamedsohaib4277 3 місяці тому

    What is the specs needed to run pcx2

  • @pooya4434
    @pooya4434 2 місяці тому +2

    All of them looked better on the emulator

  • @HithereJimHerald
    @HithereJimHerald 2 місяці тому

    Ratchet Size matters was kind of a poor pick imo, being a PSP game originally and really not great looking overall. The three original games hold up so much better and look great on both OG hardware and PCSX2

  • @SuperDwango
    @SuperDwango 4 місяці тому +1

    Soul caliber 2 on emu looks like it's vibrating. 😅

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому +1

      Too much caffeine

  • @aex2170
    @aex2170 4 місяці тому

    Why compare original PS2 at 480p while real resolution are 720p?

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому

      Well that’s just not true lol. Most PS2 games do not run higher than 480p, with plenty being locked to 480i.
      There are no PS2 games that can natively output 720p. The only one that can do HD at all is GT4, which can output in 1080i - but that’s still rendering at 540p resolution and splitting up the fields, anyway.

    • @ArdaU
      @ArdaU 2 місяці тому

      @@lostsaves actually you can force 1080i for most of the games in the opl settings but most of the time it looks worse than 480p, 1080i looks so sharp that it hurts my eyes because of that I am using forced 480p in the opl settings if the game doesn't support progressive scan

  • @エルデンリング-隻狼
    @エルデンリング-隻狼 4 місяці тому

    If input latency were not a problem, image priors would not be a problem for emulators for me. But the problem with emulators is unfortunately input latency. That's why original hardware is always better. I hope one day an fpga hardware will be made that can emulate ps2.

  • @ColtPython02
    @ColtPython02 3 місяці тому

    3:42 Rule of Rose on a PAL PS2 don't think the same.

  • @ZachlikesMetal
    @ZachlikesMetal Місяць тому

    PCSX2 is way better but it does have its flaws in certain games but I still got my Modded PS2 for backup.

  • @larrymorgan3858
    @larrymorgan3858 4 місяці тому +2

    I prefer to upscale to 1080p but I use the crt filter personally

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому +1

      I do not like the CRT filters built into PCSX2 at all. They’re the bare minimum, lazy-implemented masks that don’t interact with the source material.
      There’s some great GLSL crt shaders and the ones in reshade are pretty good, but the PCSX2 ones really disappoint me

    • @bobbyharris2270
      @bobbyharris2270 4 місяці тому +1

      @@lostsaves reshade is trash tho i don't like something that i need to run in the background that slows down the pc more

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому

      Any sort of post processing CRT emulation will add additional processing load lol

    • @larrymorgan3858
      @larrymorgan3858 4 місяці тому

      @@lostsaves I don't get the lol its my opinion maybe you need a better pc I do agree though they need better CRT shaders but that's what I prefer.

    • @Destroyersoul-e9x
      @Destroyersoul-e9x 4 місяці тому

      @@larrymorgan3858 CRT filters are a joke. they look NOTHING like a real CRT. Most of those who create TV shaders have no clue how a real CRT really looks like.
      The closest one i tried was Koko Aio from the Retroarch shaders, try it out, even though i think PCSX2 is not updated on Retroarch.

  • @thechugg4372
    @thechugg4372 2 місяці тому +1

    Bro please turn on software mode and stop complaining thanks. Thats what I do.

  • @KidTonyGaming
    @KidTonyGaming 14 днів тому

    TLDW; Play on OG hardware if you like the blurry shit render distance the devs had to cover up on the PS2, play on Emulator if all you care about is crispy visuals and gameplay.
    THOUGH there are some games you can't upscale on Emulator due to ps2 hardware you have to play at native 480, or you get weird ghosting and black bars, that's nothing the emulator can do to fix.

  • @guyverunit45
    @guyverunit45 4 місяці тому +1

    Crt filters baby!

  • @F3NIKS.
    @F3NIKS. 2 місяці тому

    Спасибо за видео дружище , чисто ленту листал и обнаружил твое видео , я никогда не скачивал Эмуляторы но после этого видео обязательно попробую ❤

  • @NPC999
    @NPC999 4 місяці тому

    Good vid

  • @GacMan47
    @GacMan47 4 місяці тому

    Idk what's going on here, but I don't get these weird issues on a Steam Deck. May be pushing it to higher resolution issues.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому

      I mean, I very clearly noted that I was trying other resolutions when o had deinterlacing issues. PCSX2’s deinterlacer has always needed work, the MA option is very new to it too
      You’re going to notice this far less easily on the tiny SD 800p screen compared to a big 4k monitor/TV lol

  • @NanoNutrino
    @NanoNutrino 2 місяці тому

    I paid $90 for an xbox key for Soulcalibur 2 HD Online. It was delisted, but you can gt it for PS3 emulator

  • @boarMcberry
    @boarMcberry 3 місяці тому

    imo might be best to make comparison for games that don't have their PC port counterpart, since would be just better playing on PC instead of through emulations, regardless on latest console/mobile phone emulators or not.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  3 місяці тому +1

      Most of these games did not have PC releases…

    • @boarMcberry
      @boarMcberry 3 місяці тому

      true, but still... much better exclude those having PC ports. From your lists:
      original PC ports:
      Just Cause - all series
      Marvel - Ultimate Alliance 1 & 2
      All Tomb Raider series that got console releases, excluding non consoles.
      Devil May Cry 3, the 1st DMC PC ports, while 1 & 2 would later on get HD remaster port instead more than decade later. DMC3 & beyond got their original PC ports.
      PC HD remaster:
      Katamari Damacy

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  3 місяці тому

      Or I can include games that were core to the PS2 experience for many people and people would be curious how they compare.

  • @rapturefuturistics1975
    @rapturefuturistics1975 3 місяці тому

    By playing "on original hardware" I think you mean playing on CRT (or with CRT filter) with original resolution and settings, even on emulator. That's how I play.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  3 місяці тому +1

      I mean, that’s clearly not what I meant since the video was very clearly about using a scaler on a normal TV, but I do discuss and advocate for CRTs all the time. That’s just not what this video was about and thus not what I meant.

  • @EnglishOrthodox
    @EnglishOrthodox 26 днів тому +1

    pcsx2 is honestly peak

  • @Trevurie
    @Trevurie 4 місяці тому

    You should use integer scaling for a uniform render.

    • @lostsaves
      @lostsaves  4 місяці тому

      I prefer filling the screen. Plus integer isn’t always best for 3D games.
      Unfortunately PCSX2 doesn’t have the capabilities to integer scale to the closest even % and interpolate from there like the scalers can

  • @barebarekun161
    @barebarekun161 2 місяці тому

    Just googled for RetroTINK 4K....they can keep it, $750 they asking makes PS5 Pro price suddenly seem quite reasonable.
    No thanks but I'll be sticking with PCSX2.

  • @Melo675xvcn
    @Melo675xvcn 3 місяці тому +1

    How about horrendous input lag at pcsx2.That emulator was and always will be trash.

  • @madmax2069
    @madmax2069 3 місяці тому

    Those aftermarket PS2 shells would be nice if they had the PS logo on them like the original does (I understand why they don't). But i guess i can just get a bottom as thats the only part on my phat PS2 that has any damage.

  • @rochester3
    @rochester3 Місяць тому

    ATV Offroad Fury 2 got patch update fix