1917 - Calling Off the Attack Scene
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 тра 2022
- In a heart-wrenching and pivotal scene from the epic war film 1917, Schofield, played by the brilliant George MacKay, finally reaches his destination after a harrowing journey through the trenches and battlefields of World War I. Desperate to deliver a crucial message that could save the lives of 1,600 men, including his friend's brother, Schofield forces his way into a meeting with the commanding officer, Colonel Mackenzie, portrayed by the incomparable Benedict Cumberbatch. As Mackenzie reads the urgent orders from high command, a flicker of resignation crosses his face, and he reluctantly makes the decision to call off the impending attack. With the mission accomplished but his heart heavy, Schofield musters the courage to inquire about the whereabouts of Lieutenant Joseph Blake, the younger brother of his fallen comrade, Tom.
Subscribe to Binge More: tinyurl.com/bingesociety
1917 is a gripping and immersive war drama that follows the perilous journey of two young British soldiers, Schofield and Blake (Dean-Charles Chapman), tasked with delivering a critical message deep within enemy territory. Set against the backdrop of the First World War, the film unfolds in real-time, as the two men navigate the treacherous landscape of the Western Front, facing unimaginable dangers and confronting the horrors of war at every turn. As they race against time to prevent a disastrous offensive that could claim countless lives, Schofield and Blake must rely on their wits, courage, and the bonds of friendship to see them through. Directed with stunning visual prowess by Sam Mendes and filmed to appear as one continuous shot, 1917 is a technical marvel that immerses viewers in the visceral reality of war, capturing the chaos, camaraderie, and sacrifice of those who fought on the front lines. With its powerful performances, masterful cinematography, and emotionally resonant storytelling, 1917 stands as a testament to the resilience of the human spirit in the face of unimaginable adversity.
BINGE MORE: • 1917: Run across the l...
Credits: © 2019 Universal Pictures. 1917.
AVAILABLE FOR RENT OR BUY 1917: amzn.to/39E2wHe
#BingeSociety #1917 #Battlefield
Subscribe: bit.ly/3aVlqJm
BINGE MORE:
The Fast & The Furious Tokyo Drift - Winner gets me: bit.ly/3b3Dstn
Minions - The Ultimate weapon: bit.ly/3DUX5QK
Anaconda - Live bait: bit.ly/3aNFE7V
Ghost Rider -Jail fight: bit.ly/3lQC6bi
The Grudge 3 - The wrong make-out spot: bit.ly/3n2a8Zz
Child’s Play 2 - I will kill you!: bit.ly/3lRc6N5
Equalizer 2 - Two kinds of pain: bit.ly/3vphmdO
ABOUT BINGE SOCIETY:
Binge Society brings you the best of your favorite movies and TV shows! Here you will find iconic scenes, moments, and lines from all the films, characters, celebrities, and actors you love. As movie fans, we give you content we know you will enjoy!
FOLLOW BINGE SOCIETY
Facebook: / bingesociety
Instagram: / binge_society
TikTok: / bingesociety
Twitter: / binge_society - Розваги
"Now fuck off, Lance Corporal."
Most realistic line of the movie.
The English are very good at that. lol
I laughed so hard in theater when he said that. I felt that line personally as a former Lance.
To be fair to the Commander, he’s got probably one of the toughest jobs ever. Forced to send young men to their deaths time and again by high command, he sees an opportunity for a decisive victory, and end the war swiftly, only to be told he has to stop.
This was the attitude of many of the local commanders in the war, especially by this stage, everyone was just tired, 3 years of grinding pointless fighting, over the same exact territory, back and forth, for three years. High Command by contrast, were very disconnected from it all, usually several miles from the front lines, they rarely saw what the men on the ground went through.
Black Adder parodies this very well, with a scene of a High Marshal sweeping army figures off a large map table. Now while realistically the High Commanders were likely not THAT callous, it IS a good representation of what was happening. To High Command, the war was pieces and lines on a map… while to the local commanders, it was men’s lives by the THOUSANDS.
The Commanders attitude here is 100% accurate, certainly if I was in his shoes, and some Lance Corporal arrived as I was on the verge of a decisive victory (in my mind at least), and said I needed to call off the attack, I’d be pissed too.
@@commandercritic9036 Homie you're reading into it way too much
B
Mackenzie wasn't a bloodthirsty glory hound. He'd been fighting the war since 1914. He'd seen his men get killed and maimed. He just wanted the damn war to be over and thought he had a chance to make it happen.
I’ve never seen the movie but I doubt His victory wouldn’t have ended the war, his victory would have most likely just won a single battle in the war and would have just moved the goal post closer
@@AJ___USA same beliefs some commanders had when they wanted to end WW2 by christmas 1944 only for the war to extend to 1945
@@AJ___USA true, but many on both sides believed that if they could achieve breakthrough in one place, crack the trenchline (not just the first layer of trenches, but the entire network), they would be able to keep pushing because the enemy wouldn't have the positions that caused the war to bog down, and wouldn't have time to dig in as deeply.
a colonel fighting the war? now that's something new. You meant "sending people to die a meanless death", then yes
@@WeissWhite If it was 1914 or 1915 then maybe but Colonel's aren't born Colonel's, a Colonel in 1917, fought their way to the top, they know what war and death are, they've experienced it, for three bloody years, and they've undoubtably lost many friends.
One really neat thing about this movie: the two leads are played by actors who were virtually unknown to the general audience, but has a load of minor characters played big big Hollywood names, Colin Firth, Mark Strong, Benedict Cumberbatch. This lends them an immediate sense of gravitas as characters, and it immediately makes you take them seriously.
Old Hollywood was loaded with 'character actors' you would see pop up in one movie after another. They added something to the movie....
It's also always a little bit of a spoiler when it starts off showing the main character as a big name. You KNOW they aren't going to die at least until the climax.
Not only that, but in this exact scene the whole vibe of, "And who the hell are you...?" hits harder.
I think it's safe to say that half the civilized world has seen Dean-Charles Chapman play the King. Whether they connect the dots is another matter.
All those minor characters played by recognizable actors were officers. It was deliberate to grant a gravitas to the officers in the movie who definitely stood out to the enlisted men at the time.
He was absolutely right though. The generals would call off attacks one day, only for them to go over the top the next. It really goes to show that despite the insane journey that lead our main character through to here was basically pointless. The men he saved that day would likely die tomorrow at the orders of the man who saved them.
Yeah, the british were probably the worst at this. So, so many young men sent into machine guns, for no gain.
@@TzunSu Um, and what's the alternative? You have to advance the front somehow. The issue was that in 1914 defensive technology had outstripped that of the offense. In other words, there was no way to conduct an offensive without suffering huge casualties.
Also, Machine guns weren't even the #1 cause of casualties in WWI, Artillery was.
@@TzunSu Nonsense. The British Army was incredibly tactically innovative- hence why the war was won by the BEF on the Western Front in 1918.
@@henrypulleine8750 yes but innovative doesn’t mean success rate 100% of the time. Solutions didn’t fall into their hands every time they needed it. So yes, often times, large offensives could’ve resulted in mass casualties.
@@taoliu3949 Not knowing too much about history or military tactics, my layman guess would be not to attack (at least not en masse). Hold the lines and know that every German/Austrian attack is costing them tenfold of what it is costing you. Keep shelling and perhaps order some smaller scale saboteur attacks when the opportunity presents itself. Let the enemy run out of supplies and money, and then either attack, or try to negotiate.
Dr. Strange did not see the future on this one.
he just found out the other team knew geometry, so he had to call off his attack.
Haha he needed proof from a letter!
watch another fucking movie oh my god
That’s why he’s not the sorcerer supreme
He did see the future, and he had to play the long game. You know, like dying knowing that he'd be revived.
If you pay close attention at 1:00 you can hear one of the soldier yell "twenty second". The order to stand down is declared by the major at 1:19. ONE second before the charge. If that's not tension idk what is
Unfortunately in the movie, I dont think it’ll be 1:19.
@@ahiptothehop4077 It was one take, so it was exactly one second short of the 20 seconds. The movie portrayed that quite well.
@@qui3041
Ah fair point
Wow good notice
Incredible catch there. I never would have heard that if not for this comment. INSANE.
I think the most tragic thing about this movie is how ultimately irrelevant this was when one takes the whole war into consideration. The movie is amazing, very epic and it portrays how two men save thousands of lives. But then you remember this was just one battle on one front of a war that raged for four years and where millions died. The movie shows how tremendous their deed was while, with the context, making the sheer scope of the whole war become unimaginable to us.
Blake sadly died and Schofield realised he had to do it without him. He kept going and I’m glad he made it
It is also sad to think that, after all he had done, “Fuck Off” was the respond he got.
And considering that the movie is very clearly summer “1917” and the war famously went on until fall 1918. That’s over a full year of suffering even after this potential break through which just shows how far from victory the Entente was at the time.
Very well said.
Yes, it was perhaps most completely pointless in the grand scheme of the war, but most of us are not nihilists, so we should all understand the true value & worth of their efforts; without this oppressing context of meaninglessness, if he died along with 10 other helpers supporting him along the way trying to & successfully saving all these people, the weight of the loss would still be just as eclipsed in the final calculation of the morality of the operation
That advice the officer gave Schofield earlier in the movie to “make sure there are witnesses when you deliver the letter” was spot on. As we can see here, MacKenzie would have almost certainly dismissed Schofield without hesitation (letter or no letter) had there been nobody else with him in the room at the time.
“Some men just want the fight”
@@mckenzie.latham91 You obviously missed something really fkin important in this scene.
@@joelbackman4389it's what Mark Oliver's character said to Schofield when he told him to have witnesses
@@mckenzie.latham91hell yeah bro get his ass
this is kind of why i was upset that the whole conflict between him and mackenzie lasted a moment, and was really not as engaging as it could have been. The set up by the officer earlier in the movie made it seem like this would be THE conflict in the third act of the film. Not a last pebble in the road, which is what this scene kind of felt like.
Me watching this movie: "Whoa. This is incredible. The way it's edited to make it look like one continuous shot is amazing. The sets and effects are spot-on, and... Hey! Is that Benedict Cumberbatch?"
its a very short role for Cumberbatch but man does he play it well :)
@@Rex1987 And Mark Strong is the guy who tells him, "Make sure Mackenzie READS the letter."
The TV Moriarty is in it as well. And Rob stark.
No, that's Benhilly Sundersquatch
Dr. Strange must be on a day off I guess
"Hope is a dangerous thing"
damn, that is a good quote
As well as, "Fuck off, Lance Corporal."
"Remember, Red, hope is a good thing, maybe the best of things, and no good thing ever dies."
-The Shawshank Redemption
@@Engine919 damn it I was going to say the same thing in the comments from the Shawshank redemption
"Hope is the first step on the road of disappointment"
@@Engine919 That came from a guy who got molested every day
2:27 : So underrated and powerful: as a veteran Major, Hepburn waits for Schofield to give him a moment of peace and humanity, no salute, no ranks, just a sincere humane "well done lad" telling Schofield that he sees not only the uniform. but the individual human being.
And he could see that that human being had been through 7 different layers of shit to get there. He needed the break. I'm so glad I went see this movie in theaters.
Good old Pete Sutcliffe 😄
As a former enlisted, there’s a distinct respect to be formed for officers that make personal gestures despite the difference in rank and years in service.
I think it's also to soften up the "fuck off" that his boss just said and acknowledge what Schofield did.
@@spectralassassin6030 me too, saw this in theater and the cinematography is just jaw dropping
Loved this plot twist - you're led to believe the Colonel Mackenzie is one of those old school soldiers who wants glory regardless of the cost or losses to his men but in fact he's a veteran who's seen too much senseless slaughter firsthand and just wanted the war to end but realises the commands on both sides are stubborn, illogical and uncaring to the suffering "there's only one way this war ends - last man standing". He wanted so desperately to end it with one attack but realised the cycle would continue "hope is a dangerous thing". Love how you only really see his scar until the camera pans close after he's read the letter and called off the attack. He's just as broken and suffered as much as the others around him. Brilliant scene in a brilliant movie.
Thank you for putting it together.
I disagree...he wasn't blood thirsty but just tired of the war...saw a chance to end it...he said a letter would come week later to attack...most likely it did...he just wanted the end and saw the attack as one ...
@@nonofyourbuzyness2824 That's exactly what he said
@kentpaper958 my bad I just realized yes spot on
I don’t think it’s a plot twist… it’s just realism
Cumberbatch does such a good job at playing an intimidating character. You can really feel his presence in the room.
Yes, the intimacy is quite intense.
Quite intimate he was
Especially when he moaned "Now f*ck off, Lance Corporal" in his ears, it was intimate as hell.
I disagree completely, he looks like a cartoon
*intimidating**
I never thought I would breathe such relief at a simple line like "Stand them down."
But then he told a nugget of truth. In WWI, there is never a permanent "stand down" until the end if the war. There is only the next order to attack, which could come literally the next day, hell the next hour.
I could hardly breathe after the movie and it was a horrible feeling to experience. It felt I lost someone that I loved but I didn’t lose my great grandfather after the Second World War luckily he survived. I miss him even though I was born a year after he died in 2001. It’s 21 years this year 😭
1917 - 2001 ❤️
@@nicolelawless3199 I hope he lived a great and full life. May he rest in peace.
@@youssefgergis7360
Thanks, I never got to meet him but I do love him because he survived the Second World War and he was married to my Nana for 46 years
Schofield will most likely get told off by his RSM for losing his rifle and kit when he gets back to his battalion. He doesn't appear to be wounded sufficiently to escape that.
Losing your rifle could lead to a charge of "casting your weapons away" and raised a suspicion of desertion or cowardice.
@@stevekaczynski3793 I think the fact he successfully delivered the message as ordered would counteract any accusations of cowardice, as it’s obvious he continued on to deliver the message on time despite loosing his only means of defending himself effectively
I expect there are a lot of rifles laying about that he could take back with him...
Sad but true, he might just go back to the front lines once he recovers a bit.... sheesh war can be cruel, meat grinder.
@@Swarm509 Yes, there would be. But every man is issued a specifically numbered rifle, it is recorded in the Battalion orderly files. If that rifle is 'lost', it has to be reported to the Regimental Quartermaster and an indent filed for a replacement. The amount of paperwork a single company could generate was mind-numbing
I like the small details on Colonel Mackenzie's uniform, his campaign and medal ribbons worn on the right of chest tell a unique story; he was a veteran of the 2nd Anglo-Boer War in South Africa as he was awarded the King's South Africa and Queen's South Africa medals, along with a Distinguished Service Order Medal, and the King George V Coronation Medal. He was more than likely in South Africa from 1899-1902 (Queen's South Africa), and after 1902 (King's South Africa Medal). A character such as this saw action when the water-cooled machinegun was still a new concept to the battlefield. I just find subtle designs like this all the more interesting when they're implemented into historical films.
The real 2nd Devons were almost wiped out in 1918 at the 3rd Battle of Aisne. The Regiment was awarded the Bois des Buttes Battle Honour and awarded the French Croix de Guerre for their actions. It is still worn on the uniform of its successor Regiment The RIFLES Regiment.
Impressive knowledge
0:33 the atmosphere drooped when schofield said "they planned this sir" changed the colonels mind from hope of ending the war to dire and utter realization that he had been played was amazing and all the soilders hearing the attack was off while schofield was running through the trench must have been petrified with a choice attack or dont
And further despair upon knowing that they are going to send those men to die anyway tomorrow, fully knowing that they're walking into a deathtrap.
"Admiral! We have enemy ships in Sector 3-7!"
"It's a trap!"
Knowing that first wave that charged is most likely dead is chilling. Yeah it sucks you couldn’t save them, but you just saved an entire army from being wiped out.
They would have won. All this did waa prolong the war
Yea, they get to die another day
@@ohno6528 at least the rest of the boys didn't get slaugthered like pigs stuck on barbed wire
nonsense they were not even that far away from the trenches when recalled most of them likely returned and lived to fight another day. They wouldn't have even reached the enemy line of guns yet. He arrived just in time.
@@dbz9393 They actually did reach the enemy line. Right before this scene, as the two guards are holding Schofield back, a soldier walks into the HQ and announced "Colonel! We've seen flares, the men on the left flank have reached the German lines."
The look on L.C. Schofield's face when the attack gets called off...it's almost like he can't believe it worked.
I remember yelling “THANK GOD!” and everyone looks at me with emotion
I remember in the cinema seeing this for the first time, I was SO relieved when he said "stand them down" ! Thought for all the world that he was going to proceed with the attack !
So was I, I was 17 at the time it came out and now I just turned 20 yesterday
Name of the movie
@@reyrosas5527 1917
Somebody else commented this, but I really do think this is just so incredible. At 1:00 you can faintly hear somebody outside yell "20 seconds", (as in 20 seconds before they start the attack). Then precisely 19 seconds later, the order to stand down is given. 1 second short of an attack that would have killed them all. Wow.
except it's not 1:00, it's 0:58 which makes it not 19 seconds but 21 seconds, thus making your comment and the comment of that other person pointless.
🤡
@@FridayFroths lol. You received justified criticism and you're so thin skinned that you can't even admit you're wrong? Lmao. Now i suggest you go back to the video, play it at 1:00 and try to hear anything there. Then play it at 0:58 and hear the actual line. Then do some math between 1:19 and 0:58 and see if your nice theory still holds.
It was also probably added in post, so it wasn't live.
@@hoarder1919 Doesn't matter, it's still great attention to detail. The attack wouldn't have any momentum, they're still going to stand down barely in time. If anything this makes it more realistic and believable.
1917 is both an excellent war film, and an excellent cinematic experience.
A great colour palette, combined with one continuous cinematic shot; makes for one of my favourite films of all time.
The British chain of command was woefully inflexible in ww1 (it carried into ww2). I feel for Mckenzie in this respect. The British came so close to major breakthroughs in 1916 and 17 but the chain of command didn’t allow for more junior officers to make decisions on the ground that could press an advantage. When initial objectives were meet, they were ordered to await further instructions that would kill offensive momentum in its tracks (keeping up momentum is key).
This was in direct contrast to the German chain of command. Which allowed for junior officers and even NCOs to use initiative and press advantages. This meant when the British were making progress and then stopped (due to the lack of flexibility), the Germans acted. Able to shore up defences and organise local counter attacks. I often feel it is a big ‘what if’ had the British been able to press advantages on the ground (the battle of Cambri in 1917 is a key example of this fatal flaw)
Russians have kept that tradition to this day.
@@InspiriumESOO I heard that the Ukrainian army had these flaws too, according to the foreign volunteers who returned. Saying they could have gain more advantages if not forced to wait further instructions. But honestly, nowadays armies rather be curious than daring.
While true, soldiers following orders could’ve brought the Germans victory a month into ww1. Had one of the German generals of the right wing not moved ahead and defied orders, there would be no opening gap, no battle of the Marne, and potentially, a German victory against France about a month into the war
@@caseblue2232 I've heard the exact opposite.
@@mykeplays912 That's the natural risk in allowing command flexibility. Sometimes they make a bad call. Overall, though, the military history of Prussia, and then the German Empire, shows that widely having a flexible command is a net positive.
One of the things that people tend to forget about a scene like this is that Lance Cpl. Schofield was actually more likely to survive the war than Colonel Mackenzie. The odds of being killed as an ordinary soldier were about 1 in 10, while the odds of being killed as an officer were closer to 1 in 5 or 6. In fact, 232 British *generals* were killed or wounded in action, about 19% of those who served at that rank. The Prime Minister's son died fighting as an officer, and so did 24 members of the House of Lords. At one point in 1915, three division commanders out of about 40 were killed in one week, prompting the HQ to issue orders that senior (Corps and Division) commanders should not place themselves so directly in the line of fire when commanding, because they were actually running low and there wasn't enough time to train up new ones. And casualty rates for field and company grade officers like Mackenzie were even higher...
It’s been long understood in the army, one good battle could see vast advancement of rank during war time, long standing morbid joke, if we make it to the end of this battle we all might be generals
I know it was shown in the Audie Murphy movie, where the lower enlisted joked that being promoted was almost a death sentence.
Well, British officers dont duck. Right?
Officers need to stand and shout in order to give orders, especially when rounds are flying. Normally ppl who stand and shout tend to get hit.
I remember a line in the game Companybof Heroes where a German commander remarked somewhere along the lines that British Officers were pompous, but will almost always lead from the front and in the thick with the men. Given the courage Britain fields from time to time, I'm inclined to believe.
Oh thank god you censored “bastards”. For a moment I thought this was a movie about war.
Inglorious B******s
Ah fackoff... YT censors...
There's something to be said about 2:40, when Schofield tells the Major, "I was sent here with his brother," and the Major just says, "...Ah." Seeing only Schofield there, he immediately knows that Blake's brother didn't make it.
I love how much they leave unsaid, as both of them would know exactly the reality of the war and the current circumstances they find themselves in. The Major tells him to check the casualty clearing unit, "otherwise..." and we all know what the "otherwise..." means...
One thing I appreciate about this scene is that you get a sense that Benedict Cumberbatch's character isn't exactly the bloodthirsty general he's infamous for. I think this scene reveals that the general just strives for some sort of finality, hoping for glory. It's almost like he just wants it to be over one way or another.
I think it plays on the British propaganda that proposed “the war will be over by Christmas”. Mackenzie would have most likely been reassured by Army Command that the fighting would be estimated for a few months providing he follows orders. And here he is 3 years later, watched countless soldiers under his command run out of a trench and never come back or died right before his eyes and he’s still receiving the same bullshit orders. It’s a great character development that shows how exhausted those on the front were and how quickly the command was willing to pass off their own Colonels as crazed lunatics.
"Mackenzie, I've come to bargain."
0:43 When he heard that you can tell he'd been grappling with that theory for a long while
I do love how this film doesn't rely on the tired old trope of Lions Led By Donkeys. Mackenzie's attack is logical according to both information available to him and his training as an officer.
If anyone is interested, just read 'Forgotten voices of the great war' by Max Arthur. Collected recorded anecdotes of those who were there (on both sides) and put into print. In chronological orded of the battles fought!. Sobering to say the least. Lest we forget.
Thank you for the public service announcement! My mother and I both really enjoy learning about history. We know much about the war in Europe during WW2, but we don't know much about WW1 or the war in the Pacific. This book looks like it will be an excellent resource for WW1!
Do you happen to know of any similar books about the war in the Pacific?
@@ginnyjones7120 Unfortunately no.
@@robleary3353 Okay. Thanks for letting me know and for recommending the first book.
After looking into it, I found a similar book about WW2 by the same author. It's supposed to have the accounts of people from all sides.
Read the best book on WW1, Storm of Steel, as well, absolute gold
@@MFDOOOOM Thanks for the recommendation!
Cumberbatch's voice in the movie theater had a booming and resounding command in his tone, absolutely nailed this minor role
Mackenzie saying “last man standing” perfectly sums up World War I
Ironically, this is true but also led to WW2. Because in the end, atleast at the westfront...everyone was still standing. Sure, Germany knew they couldn't win anymore, but the army was still there and could have fought on for months. Which is one reason why Hitlers propaganda worked so well - the german middle-class had a huge problem understanding why Germany "lost the war". The army wasn't beaten, the Entente never entered german territory and Russia was crushed and forced into a humiliating peace. Why would you surrender?
@@ottokarl5427 that is very true
Or any war, really.
@@ottokarl5427 They surrendered because they were starving internally and externally and if the war were to draw out until the "real" end, germany was destined to lose. Why ask silly questions you can easily find the answer to?
It was, and that my friend is a very important detail, a rhethorical question. Or rather, it was a question the extreme right-winged propaganda asked the german people. And the answer was always "we had to surrender because socialists and jews stabbed our victorious army in the back!"
Because even though the Kaiserreich had like 15% of its population in the field, it apparently never settled in completly back at home how bad the army was about to lose if the wars continues just a few more months.
I really loved how there was very little attaboys given to the Lance cpl
He just saved thousands of lives and is treated as: that's your job, now get back to it.
The only recognition he got was a "well done", and knowing the times that's probably all he ever got.
Look on the bright side:…Um…uh…If he’s lucky, he might also get _another_ worthless medal he can sell for some booze again! 😅
Cultural context matters. The colonel sharing his private thoughts and then genuinely addressing him regarding his wounds is a huge act of respect. Same with the sincere “well done lad” from the Major.
And now adults complain about not having their kid awarded a participation trophy when they lost lol
That's how the British military functions. It IS his job. Every medal on a British chest is for exceptional service, in contrast to an American chest, which is for completing a course. Hyperbole is frowned upon in UK military.
I feel so bad for Capt Blackadder, Capt Darling, Lt George, and Pvt Baldrick. They are the first to go over the top, if only the order come a bit sooner they would've survived😭
Poor guys, if only they have a cunning plan to escape😭
@@meitynajoan5553 It would have to be as cunning as a fox that has just been made Professior of Cunning at Oxford university
Never should have shot that pigeon
@@timmyp34 wdym? They didn't recieve any messages and Capt Blackadder definitely did not shot the plump-breasted pigeon
Fun fact: this movie was based on the Battle of Poelcappelle, a part of the larger Third Battle of Ypres, which proved to be somewhat of a pyrrhic victory for the British, and resulted in staggering casualties for both sides. The reason for the British getting credit for the victory is that, at this time of the war, Germany was sustaining losses it couldn’t afford, and men they couldn’t replace, while Britain and the allies could (especially with the US now entering the war). Col. McKenzie, who is fictional, was 100% right, he’s seen this play out all before, and you could understand his frustration, as I’m sure many commanders felt during this war. I’m sure there were several times, on either side, a commander would see an opportunity, only for it to get halted by command, and then told to advance hours or days later, when the opportunity was no longer there. I can’t blame him, and that’s one of the inherent disadvantages of a centralized command structure, which was still the orthodoxy of military doctrine at the time.
0:53 One subtle detail I just noticed: the Colonel's eyes are well lit as he looks at Schofield. The moment he tilts his head down and opens up the letter, the upper half of his face is shrouded in darkness -- as if the very contents of the letter seeped into his eyes to warn him of what lay ahead. It's beautiful imagery like this that got the movie nominated for so many Oscars.
I love the way Cumberbatch delivers the line "Stand them down." That is the face and voice of a man who realized he was seconds away from killing every man under his command.
Somewhere in there after the attack is called off is a Peaky Blinder named Tommy Shelby saying “No fighting !No Fighting! NO FUCKING FIGHTING!!!!
No sniffing petrol
@@yeyonge No sucking, faking petrol out of their fakin cars eyy
@@filipdendis7988 Then he points to just one guy and just nods and keeps yelling at everyone else.
Then seconds after the butler gets bullied by Tommy and Arthur throws a carrot at him.
Despite his role in imitation game (great movie but grossly inaccurate) Cumberbatch nails every role he's in no matter how big or small.
Immitation game is one hughe Proaganda fro Brits. In Poland its deamed as fantasy
@@qzg7857 Thankfully no one cares or listens to what Poland thinks
No one cares.
@@ac2244 youre mad cause someone cares and you dont
True
This scene must really hit home for soldiers. Imagine going through everything this soldier went through, only to be told to "f*ck off" at the end of it all. The brutal realities of war.
This was an amazing movie that I really enjoyed watching in theater. I watched it with my grandpa who was a vietnam war veteran so it holds a special place in my heart. The 1 take approach to the movie has its cons but it really made me feel like I was with the characters and made it very easy for me to imagine I was apart of the story the whole way. It also showed that all this emotion rollercoaster we watch is only a day and a half in a small section of a global 4 year war.
What did your grandpa think of it?
I love this movie. Watching it in the cinema, I have never felt so gripped and on the edge of my seat since, maybe… ‘Captain Phillips’.
Time has never moved so well in a movie than 1917. Real time and single frame shot (mostly) and time being the ultimate objective. Mendes's finest film and easily his most personal.
My great-grandfather was 28 when WW1 started in 1914, but he already lived here in Argentina after coming from Spain. One of his brothers, though, fought for the Republicans in the 1930s in the Spanish Civil War, and I can see the exhaustion from this young man's face in the letters (few letters) that my great-grandfather's brother sent him from Spain. He then became a Maqui but died in the 1960s in France. War is horrible. Terrible to see the situation of the world in terms of war.
repent unto God
This movie was a masterpiece the tension and everything was just amazing plus the war sceans being incredible this movie is 100 percent 1 of my top tens
This is for the ones that say this movie is not emotional because it has almost no dialogues. With the right atmosphere, just a few lines are enough to be touching.
A key point to remember about the British in WW1 is that they were on the offensive at this point. The Germans had purposefully dug in their trench line so that the British trenches would flood and they would be well equipped for the long haul knowing full well that they had no intention of advancing anytime soon. British trenches were muddy, disease ridden temporary footholds, and if the British were not constantly launching offensives then they would be taking many times more casualties to disease than the Germans, which was not sustainable. This led to British and French high command ordering near suicidal offensives constantly, as staying put was also a likely death for the soldiers
German losses were even less sustainable.
One issue that historians had with this movie was the fact that MacKenzie was advancing without support from field guns. They never would’ve done that in WWI.
Never dismiss orders from those higher up completely. While it is true that from up high they can't see the details those on the ground can see, it is also true that those on the ground cant see the larger movements those up high can. We all make the best decisions we can with what information we have, but one person can't know everything. Together, though, we can get damn close.
Benedict Cumberbatch has a gravitas that few actors can muster.
There’s only on way this war ends: last bank standing.
Such is every imperialist war.
So true
You can see the sheer anger in Mackenzie’s face when he read it
I love how the commanding officer isn't depicted as some spoiled aristocratic rich boy who cares nothing for his men, as the common stereotype of WWI British officers goes. This guy is clearly a hardened veteran who's seen a lifetime of war and cares as much for his men as any other soldier.
Spectacular courage from Lance Corporal Schofield.
Just a little FYI British army doctorine was so strict that this colonel would've likely been ordered back to headquarters and put on a firing line. Deviation from the doctorine was punished absolutely even up to the 2nd world war. One thing must be noted however the reason the colonel required runners is because they were the highest ranks to be in frontline trenches. Field commanders like division commanders were back at hq usually.
The thing I found most unlikely in that film is that anyone would give a single fuck about 1600 men after 3 years of throwing millions into the grinder.
Hence why they sent one private and his mate to maybe deliver the message if they aren’t shot, step on a landmine, fall into a pit and break their leg, drown, get struck by artillery, captured by the enemy, gassed without a mask, or just plain desert.
1600 is a lot of lives to just throw away for no reason
Despite the reputation people weren't throwing away lives in WW1. It is just pretty hard to take prepared enemy positions without suffering massive casualties.
This is one of my absolute favourite war movies.
I was hooked from the first moment and was amazed at how this story was laid out and filmed.
It's also impressive how well of a movie this was, despite their low budget
i wouldnt really call this film low budget with that 90 million price tag, but i totally get why you could think that with the camerawork (one-shot illusion, one camera)
Both the UK King and German Kaiser are first cousins in opposite sides.
Also the Russian Tsar was their cousin.
all purely political marriages for diplomatic reasons. no meaning behind it
Queen Victoria was their grandmother right?
yes, they made a 1-dollar bet to see who had the best military.
@@nkristianschmidt”no balls”
I honestly thought that he was going to go ahead despite the orders, I was so relieved when he called the attack off.
So was I, I’ll never forget everyone helping me because I was in a right emotional state
I was in sophomore year of my engineering degree in pune when this masterpiece hit cinemas in pre covid 2020 or late 2019 (I guess), one of the best pieces of cinema I ever saw, pure delight
How beautifully they have shot this scene without any cut👌❤️
The continuos shot keeps the tension through out the movie.
I love this scene. Cumberpatches character at first seems like a heartless commander. but he only hesitates once he realises pushing forward might be more dangerous for his men. thats the tipping point. he dosent mind ignoring orders, but he cares about his men, ending this war as soon as possible and saving as many of the mas he can. brilliant writing.
I love how the scar on his eye is obscured by shadow until the closeup when he gives the order to call of the attack. You get to see that he's not just a heartless robot, and that he's lost as much in the war as anyone but is just desperate for it to end.
Great film! But when I was watching this part I kept thinking "Didn't he swim in a river for a considerable amount of time? Why didn't the ink get blurred and why doesn't the letter appears to show any water damage at all?"
Pretty sure there was a point where he put the letter in a metal case.
The fact that Mackenzie was almost ready & willing to disobey orders just so he could go head to head with the Germans in a fight for which he was sending young men into really says a lot
Partially, but seeing it from his perspective, he probably has seen many young men die and incompetence in the British leadership. He views this as a way to end the war. “They will only have us attack at dawn again tomorrow.” shows that he has distrust in the British tactics. He views this push as a sacrifice to prevent more men from dying (and as a way to personal glory). It’s the insanity of the cycle of “One more push to break the line” that made this war so horrific.
I think it's more like "they'll have us attack the enemy some other time anyway, so why wait to die then let's just get it over with as quick as possible".
this is a trench warfare not some conventional warfare in Afghanistan, if germans perpared on their line. the allied would just send more men to weaken their defenses. This is from 1917 which somehow makes MacKenzie right..the command would just order him the next day or the next to attack.
@@Jupiter.141 Afghanistan wasn’t conventional warfare, it was an asymmetrical Counter Insurgency. Trench warfare WAS conventional warfare for the time period.
@@Jupiter.141 Trench Warfare IS conventional warfare, Afghanistan (for the Taliban) was guerilla warfare while the coalition employed counter insurgency operations. The Russian Invasion of Ukraine is MODERN conventional warfare for now, as I write this comment and u see the possibly horrendous casualties that war has brought upon on military personnel.
What a cameo performance by BC. Plays the pompous senior officer so well...
0:36 I love how they freeze and listen when he mentions it’s a trap.
Experienced Commanders like them probably knew of the possibility that it was a trap, and their intuition jolts them to attention when he says the German’s planned it
Benedict Cumberbatch is the spectacular actor, he actually looked like someone who lives in decade of 1910 here
"Hope is a dangerous thing". That quote hits different, as someone who studies history and war, I can tell you that is true. Hope can raise armies or cause them to fall, lead men to victory, or defeat, lead men to do great things, or horrible things. Sun Tzu said "Appear weak when you are strong and strong when you are weak". "Hence the art of war is the art of deception"
After 1917 I never hoped for anything because of how powerful Mackenzie’s words were
@@nicolelawless3199 shouldn't not hope, it's a tool, just like anything else.
1:54 “There is only one way this War Ends Last Man Standing” I don’t know why but it always reminds me of Game of Thrones😮😮🤔🤔
Colonel McKenzie is so pigheaeded that he couldn't take 4 seconds out of busy day to read a letter from his general.
There’s really no point. It’s fucking WWl, sending thousands of men to the gutter was just a typical Tuesday. Calling off an attack only to send them back out there the next day by the same general. Scofield saved 1600 lives for one day, they’re dead anyway. You could even see it as an act of mercy in a way. Those men have lived in piss-poor condition with disease, rats and probably fucked up mentally from all the shelling and carcasses. Canceling the attack just means them suffering for an extra day. If the attack commenced, at least those men are living in the land of salvation with god.
Would the letter even be readable at this point? considering the fact It was covered in Blake‘s blood and Schofield swam with it in the Sensee river.
I loved this film. For me it was the carefully managed pace and silence for the most part, interrupted by madness and murder.
It honestly portrays war really well in that regard. You're doing a whole lot of nothing for some time, then maybe you're doing something, but all of that changes when chaos descends from nowhere and you find yourself dead or dying in a matter of moments
It’s interesting to hear the Germans discuss how they view the British. They’re both a Germanic people and found many similarities in common with one another. Many said they would’ve preferred fighting together against the French
Yeah I totally agree. Maybe even on a subconscious level, but during their fighting in WW2, I’ve heard a lot of stories of compassion between the two
Even in ww2 it wasn’t the germans intention to fight the British. In Hitler’s book, he wishes of an alliance with Britain and her Royal navy. Theres even a recount from a Hitler staff that he saw the British as very similar to germans and did not like the idea of having to invade (I forgot the guys name). Obviously that goes out the window once Britain shows they have no intention of ending things by bombing Berlin.
Just imagine, Britain and Germany against France Russia and America. It would certainly be an interesting war.
@@MsPaintMr my money on axis, german are one good ally away to win, if uk sided with the germans usa would remain neutral.
The French are Germannic too though. France got its name from the Franks, a Germannic tribe. They're certainly not the Celtic Gauls of old.
the subtle head tilts of Benedict were amazing, the details make the difference for A-list actors from the rest.
Ah, I remember watching this masterpiece in the cinema. There were two girls who were constantly chatting with each other, completely uninterested in the movie. They left an hour or so into the movie.
I would have just stood up and slapped the shit out of them . How dare they disrespect the people who lost their lives and loved ones on the battlefield !
Prove it
@@kirbynavideno3382 its really not that hard to believe u spaz😂😂
@@kirbynavideno3382 Prove what? You've never seen someone walk out of a cinema before? What do you expect him to do, take time out of his immersion in the movie to video two girls leaving the cinema?
Saw a bunch of people Leave the cinema when I went and saw anti-christ on the big screen. Done it with the Movie the Merry Gentleman myself. I was eighteen at the time and I feel looking back that I didn't give the movie a fair chance, but I just couldn't get into at the time. It happens.
If they're not interested in the film, why'd they bothered to see it in theaters?
Such a great movie! It was haunting and beautiful. I thought about it for at least a week after I saw it.
So did I and I had my first dreams about 1917 the same night. The dreams have successfully come back
Name of the movie
"Major..."
"Yes sir?"
"Stand them down."
I love this scene, it is so intense. You can feel the tension and desperation.
The scene where you're finally allowed to breath. This was an amazing film.
Based on how fast people in films read letters, makes me always realize how slow of a reader I am!
you are right, when they get a letter, they understand it in like 2 seconds
I still cant believe the entire movie was done in 3 shots.
Sam Mendes' style reminds me of Fred Zinneman's elaborateness and tastefulness particularly in background score.
I never thought Dr. Strange was a British general.😆😆😆
And an ambiguously gay cowboy in his spare time.
One of the most nerve-wrecking scenes in the history of cinema.
The job of the runners in WW1 was fraught with danger. A good reference is that of James Towers who was awarded the Victoria Cross for his amazing courage as a runner.
Everything about this scene is just PERFECT
Wish more movies would hold longer shots on actors and the action like in this clip and not just as a gimmick.
"Hope is a dangerous thing"..hit me hard😮💨
Such a tense scene.
"Theres only one way this war ends"
Last man standing.
In reality it ended with one side pretty much walking off the battlefield.
That made me cry, I grieved so much throughout the amazing movie that I nearly collapsed in grief. Everyone helped me when it was over
only one way to defeat thanos
I think the Kaiser and the King should duel.
Once upon a time I was of the same rank (but not age) as the Lance Corporal here was.
Now I’m older than the Colonel here.
Oh where does the time go?
Into the past.
George Mackay is about 31 now
@@nicolelawless3199 Oh so he played a Lance Corporal at 27? I take it back. We were about the same age in the same rank equivalent then.
@@Ryan_Christopher
Yes he did. I honestly thought George was slightly older than that
very well structured / played sequence shot
Just imagine if they had just even text messaging back then , this whole movie would not be needed.
There is reason the movie called 1917
They could have dropped the message via airplane though.
@@bojandolinar1535 And risk the Germans finding the letter? No way man
@@Drelofs They risked the same by sending those two men, no? I would argue the risk is even bigger. And it didn't contain very sensitive info, just that they knew what Germans are up to.
@Generic Cracker 2001 That sounds like a good reason to not even try.
I spent the end of the movie thinking he would arrive and the dispatches would be destroyed from the water. Earlier on we see him putting papers into a tin which I suspected was foreshadowing and partly him being pragmatic and contingency planning for incase he got wet. I dunno if a tin would be water tight though. Going even further back when he first got the orders in the envelope I remember thinking well I fucking hope that is at least wax coated for some water resistance but why aren't they immediately mandating he store it properly rather than trusting in his own competency to do the obvious? (officers will make sure as you're always below them in their eyes).
British WWI officers were frequently incompetent, especially with regards to practical matters. They may have not even thought about the orders getting wet, and it was only the squaddie that would actually think of that.
No problem, he used a ball point pen, I am sure...
Why was "Bastards" censored? Is this elementary school
because there are actually child who watch this in youtube
The thumbnail made me realize the commander was Benedict Cumberbatch. I didn't even notice while watching the movie.
I was just thinking of this scene today. Weird how I just so happen to get it recommended.
Fun fact:
Last movie I seen at the theatre before the world turned upside down with Covid.
Great movie 🍿
Same. Still haven't been to the cinema since then.
@@Samuel-ut7mj
I haven’t been since Black Widow which was an amazing movie