Running Through The Battlefield | 1917 (2019) | Screen Bites

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 бер 2023
  • Will (George MacKay) makes a desperate run through the battlefield in order to deliver an order to Colonel Mackenzie to stop off the attack.
    1917 (2019): Sam Mendes, the Oscar®-winning director of Spectre and American Beauty, brings his singular vision to this World War I epic. At the height of the First World War, two young British soldiers, Schofield (Captain Fantastic's George MacKay) and Blake (Game of Thrones' Dean-Charles Chapman), are given a seemingly impossible mission. In a race against time, they must cross enemy territory and deliver a message that will stop a deadly attack on hundreds of soldiers-Blake's own brother among them.
    Own 1917 now on Digital, Blu-ray & DVD:
    www.uphe.com/movies/1917
    Welcome to Screen Bites. The ultimate place for cross overs, mashups, clips, trailers, exclusives behind the scenes, singalongs and so much more! There's nowhere else like this for film fans on UA-cam.
    Don't forget to subscribe at / @screenbites
    #worldwar1 #warfilm #georgemackay #colinfirth #Deancharleschapman
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 255

  • @markf5609
    @markf5609 5 місяців тому +142

    Admire the NCO at 2:18, at least he is willing to listen to what Schofield has to say and shows earnest concern for his safety.

    • @derpythespy
      @derpythespy 2 місяці тому +14

      that's not an NCO. if you look at his sleeves, he is a Lieutenant. notice one stripe with two diamonds (forgot proper terms for it)
      it's even more astonishing that an officer is caring for schofield, who is not even on his regiment

    • @henrypollock7987
      @henrypollock7987 Місяць тому +2

      @@derpythespythe mateship increases 10000% when the lads were preparing to go over the top together all the had was each other to rely on 😢

  • @zenosebeth4173
    @zenosebeth4173 Рік тому +463

    The first guy that tripped Schofield when they were going over the top didn't get up lol

    • @TheFBI911
      @TheFBI911 Рік тому +55

      friendly fire 💀

    • @emandummie
      @emandummie 11 місяців тому +16

      I was looking at that to

    • @North29TH
      @North29TH 11 місяців тому +90

      It is a better way to blend in with the dead really. Not everyone wants to die in the front.

    • @jonathanliu505
      @jonathanliu505 11 місяців тому +88

      I like to think he got knocked down and decided it was a good enough hit to get knocked out, and so he just decided to play unconscious.
      In regards to the actor, he was probably an extra, plus this was a one-shot scene where the messenger wasn't supposed to run into anyone. He probably decided just not moving was the best way to not mess up the scene.

    • @johnnk3256
      @johnnk3256 10 місяців тому +42

      Will wasn't meant to run into anyone when running. The extra didn't know what to do, so he just stayed down. And since the shot could only be done once, they kept it in the movie.

  • @paragjyotideka1246
    @paragjyotideka1246 8 місяців тому +134

    Cameraman: I forgot to press record.

    • @DB-rl6ql
      @DB-rl6ql 5 місяців тому +2

      Is this scene a single shot

    • @paragjyotideka1246
      @paragjyotideka1246 5 місяців тому +4

      @@DB-rl6ql yes.

    • @simunator
      @simunator 3 місяці тому +4

      ​@@DB-rl6qlno. there's really sly cuts sprinkled throughout

    • @taiezer9585
      @taiezer9585 Місяць тому +1

      ☠️

    • @haisee1671
      @haisee1671 22 дні тому +3

      The running part was single shot i watch it in behind the scenes.

  • @kacperprzylucki2091
    @kacperprzylucki2091 2 місяці тому +51

    The captain at 2:10 shouting HOLD FAST to encourage the men always gives me goosebumps

    • @nickyoude2694
      @nickyoude2694 2 місяці тому +4

      He's a sergeant. He has the tree stripes on his arm.

    • @Eusoik
      @Eusoik 2 місяці тому +1

      I thought he was saying HOLD FIRM

    • @SpaceMissile
      @SpaceMissile Місяць тому +2

      he really gave that his all 👏

  • @iraklismakridis704
    @iraklismakridis704 8 місяців тому +103

    The 'no, no no no no' of the officer, reminds me of the same exact words Bilbo Baggins said when Thorin died.

    • @Rare_Spore_Fan
      @Rare_Spore_Fan 4 місяці тому +1

      YESS I WAS THINKING THE SAME THING

  • @Special17782
    @Special17782 Рік тому +354

    Couple of fun facts about this epic scene.
    1. At 3:19 you see 3 random solders in full uniform ahead of the advancing lines with no guns. They were the camera operators that were following schofiled through the trench and then climbed the trench and mounted the camera onto a vehicle for the running scene. They couldn’t get out of shot quickly enough so Sam Mendez decided to blend them in to the advancing soldiers as soldiers themselves.
    2. When Schofield collided with the running soldiers this was accidental and wasn’t meant to happen. But as the scene was filmed in one take they couldn’t stop rolling so he just had to get up and keep running.

    • @davisjones7137
      @davisjones7137 Рік тому +12

      Those cameramen have guns so can't really tell. Nice oner

    • @Special17782
      @Special17782 Рік тому +19

      I’ve watched the scene several times. The 3 guys at the front that randomly come into shot do not have rifles from what I can see

    • @FSBMateus
      @FSBMateus Рік тому +3

      @@Special17782 i could see it too, three guys without guns at the front, but even then by the time he started to make a run for it, they were far away from him or the moving truck

    • @examplenameyoutube
      @examplenameyoutube 11 місяців тому +19

      The soldiers that he collided with didn’t know what to do. You can see that one soldier keeps laying after he fell and the second one is hesitating and staying there taking his helm.

    • @Shregurun93
      @Shregurun93 8 місяців тому +9

      I like how the soldier that collided with him decided to stay on the ground xD

  • @marconeevaristoaraujopaima710
    @marconeevaristoaraujopaima710 11 місяців тому +248

    This scene gives me goosebumps.

    • @Tay._._.
      @Tay._._. 7 місяців тому +1

      What scares me most is when the Germans first discovered tanks, the hard way.

    • @IloveBrawlStars420
      @IloveBrawlStars420 6 місяців тому

      @@Tay._._.the British did in ww1

    • @Tay._._.
      @Tay._._. 6 місяців тому

      @@IloveBrawlStars420 yea I know

    • @LockdLoaded619
      @LockdLoaded619 5 місяців тому

      This movie also sucked. British war films should not try and compete with American ones.

    • @abc-oq7dt
      @abc-oq7dt 4 місяці тому +1

      ​@@LockdLoaded619how does it compete?

  • @ethantran3765
    @ethantran3765 Рік тому +180

    i love how it ends with Benedict Cumberbacht saying that lmfao. 😂 😂 😂

    • @sonyashort5824
      @sonyashort5824 8 місяців тому +3

      He dies in the end😅😅😅

  • @rudysaints9826
    @rudysaints9826 6 місяців тому +49

    Whenever I go running, the last stretch is always a reenactment of this scene

  • @chasehedges6775
    @chasehedges6775 Рік тому +155

    Best scene in the whole entire film

    • @davisjones7137
      @davisjones7137 Рік тому

      This is the only scene I've watched so far from this film

    • @nicolelawless9942
      @nicolelawless9942 3 місяці тому

      I’ve wanted to see this movie just for this incredible scene but I ended up really liking it

  • @Prophet12
    @Prophet12 11 місяців тому +186

    One of the best scenes in cinema history.

  • @bionicg2040
    @bionicg2040 11 місяців тому +82

    Just realized the Captain at 1:22 is shell shocked that is why he is unresponsive to scholfield.

    • @JPerry-jw9ik
      @JPerry-jw9ik 11 місяців тому +8

      Nope. He was just being a coward.

    • @OninDynamics
      @OninDynamics 11 місяців тому +91

      @@JPerry-jw9ik pov: you're a higher-ranking officer in 1915

    • @hemmingscable
      @hemmingscable 10 місяців тому

      fear of dying going into combat

    • @popcornpictures1825
      @popcornpictures1825 9 місяців тому +2

      keep watching in the background a few seconds later and he gets blown up before he gets chance to go over the top

    • @gyrow1684
      @gyrow1684 9 місяців тому +26

      @@JPerry-jw9ik How can you be so senseless? Do you even know how nightmarish it is to be there?

  • @bugra320
    @bugra320 4 місяці тому +13

    3:22 The other man died by colliding with the actor. RIP

  • @squaresphere2864
    @squaresphere2864 5 місяців тому +19

    A jaw dropping scene. My Grandad did this at the second battle of Ypres and then 1St July 1916 at the Somme. True bravery.

  • @spatrk6634
    @spatrk6634 Рік тому +38

    just sitting in that line waiting to get hit by artillery shell hoping it kills you on impact on not just tears your limbs off

    • @Yayaloy9
      @Yayaloy9 Рік тому +8

      Artillery aint likely to directly land inside the trench but yes very scary and dreadful.

  • @tele7222
    @tele7222 8 місяців тому +44

    03:21 my man just stayed on the ground 💀

    • @boobiegaming
      @boobiegaming 4 місяці тому +2

      bro died 💀

    • @tele7222
      @tele7222 4 місяці тому

      @@boobiegaming 😭

    • @temito6923
      @temito6923 Місяць тому +1

      Gta v npc's be like:

    • @MatTechSwahili
      @MatTechSwahili 27 днів тому +2

      I'd play dead too instead of charging into a mine field

    • @tobeslmao
      @tobeslmao 13 днів тому

      @@MatTechSwahiliartillery is a lot more likely to land on you if you’re laying still

  • @jasonbrosnan8770
    @jasonbrosnan8770 5 місяців тому +19

    It's hard to believe that this scene was done in one take

    • @fauxbro1983
      @fauxbro1983 5 місяців тому +4

      it wasn't, but it was made to look that way

    • @dmitryogrady2004
      @dmitryogrady2004 4 місяці тому +4

      The whole movie was done that way. (Made to look like one take). But I'm sure this one scene was all one take.

    • @tropicturtle9021
      @tropicturtle9021 Місяць тому +2

      @@fauxbro1983 this scene actually was just one take. In fact the soldier bumping into people wasn’t scripted, he just actually ran into some extras while he was running and they kept it in because the scene would have been too difficult to reshoot.

    • @barrskog85
      @barrskog85 Місяць тому

      @@tropicturtle9021 It's cut at 4:06.

    • @Whoami691
      @Whoami691 19 годин тому

      ​@@fauxbro1983 The entire move was done in 3 shots. there were only 2 times the camera stopped rolling in the entire film.

  • @jamie8731
    @jamie8731 19 днів тому +1

    "The first wave" upsets me.
    They were such brave boys... We will never be as brave as them...
    THEY WERE THE BEST GENERATION TO EVER WALK OUR PLANET

  • @MarranoPrince
    @MarranoPrince 5 місяців тому +13

    You cannot draw breath throughout this scene, it is that intense.

    • @nicolelawless9942
      @nicolelawless9942 3 дні тому

      Especially in theatres, I actually collapsed from exhaustion after that scene and everyone helped me out when it was all over. Me and my grandmother reunited with the same audience in February 2020 for our second viewing and I didn’t faint. Post 2020 was the best

  • @user-jg1ij4hu9q
    @user-jg1ij4hu9q 3 місяці тому +12

    0:23 Michael Jibson who plays Lieutenant Hutton in this scene was the face model and voice actor for Wilson, Clyde Blackburn's sidekick in Battlefield 1's War Story, "Friends in High Places".
    Edit: He also played Lyle Porter in Flyboys, all of three take place in WW1 and all take place in the year 1917. Convenient.

  • @michaelthompson252
    @michaelthompson252 6 днів тому

    Love the orchestra drop when he runs onto the front line @ 0:53

  • @xwxgamerxwx
    @xwxgamerxwx 3 місяці тому +7

    3:06 running starts

  • @rocktorrocks
    @rocktorrocks 11 місяців тому +43

    Who the F are those guards outside the bunker not letting a dude with obvious urgent official orders in to the room. A dude comes with an official letter with clear urgency and you just shut them down?

    • @tdpro3607
      @tdpro3607 9 місяців тому +11

      the meat grinder must go on

    • @malachiomeletoe4320
      @malachiomeletoe4320 6 місяців тому +1

      Those guards stopped the only line of communication they had

    • @patrikmalory
      @patrikmalory 6 місяців тому +16

      Because those trenches were full of young people who wanted to stay alive. I think there were many young lads trying to do everything to avoid being killed. Maybe they thought he was just an another "coward" trying to fool them. And you cant just let everyone enter command room just because he says something about a letter.

    • @Berserker3624
      @Berserker3624 6 місяців тому

      ⁠@@patrikmalorynope it was just bad writing, unless that coward wants to get shot a week later for treason they wouldn’t have bothered and that’s assuming the ofificer doesn’t just shoot him himself

    • @ES-gv6xl
      @ES-gv6xl 2 місяці тому

      British army executed hundreds of its own soldiers for insubordination

  • @furicd446
    @furicd446 29 днів тому +1

    Merci pour cet extrait. J'adore ce film. Je l'ai vu plusieurs fois. Respect pour tous ces hommes ❤🙏

  • @COOL.GUY.SO.COOOOOOOOOL
    @COOL.GUY.SO.COOOOOOOOOL 7 місяців тому +1

    i love when they all say who are you

  • @jorgevaccari2374
    @jorgevaccari2374 Рік тому +1

    Perfect resume!!!!!

  • @rstein926
    @rstein926 Місяць тому +1

    I cannot imagine the very fact that the moment you leave the trenches, you are literally on a suicide mission.
    You are either going to get killed or wounded at literally any second.

  • @ewanc1
    @ewanc1 9 місяців тому +17

    Despite that we know it was a trap and that the Germans were counting on the British attacking, you could be forgiven for thinking the attack was going well and that the first wave had been somewhat successful in that the left flank had reached the German line and had fired signal flares which they were only supposed to do once they had taken their objective i.e. the German trenches. The Colonel thought he had the Germans on the run and wanted to make a decisive breakthrough which the Allies had spent the last 3 years trying and failing to do at great cost, something that the Colonel most likely witnessed and hated seeing. You can see why the Colonel was reluctant to stop the attack now that he had the opportunity (his belief that the Germans were on the run) and the flexibility (with the phone lines being down and no-one to countermand his orders) to attack and hopefully make a breakthrough and maybe, just maybe, end the war.

    • @rstein926
      @rstein926 Місяць тому +1

      The Germans moving to the Hindenburg line wasn't really a trap. The Germans moved there in an attempt to prevent further losses, having suffered too many losses at Verdun & the Somme. However it didn't obviously mean the British and French didn't fight them there.
      And even if they did win, the war wouldn't end automatically. It is far more complicated than that. When a side loses they would have to come to an agreement with the victors on signing the treaty's which would take time.
      Germany very nearly won in 1918 with the Spring Offensive as they made their biggest move since 1914 until the Americans intervened and Germany being outnumbered and no match against the 'freshness' of the Americans who were fitter due to arriving in 1917 knew they lost and had no alternative but to surrender, thus causing the birth of the infamous Treaty of Versailles in November 1918 as terms took months to be official.

  • @isaacjones748
    @isaacjones748 Місяць тому

    I know those trips were accidents but they so add to the feeling of the scene

  • @ckok7792
    @ckok7792 3 дні тому

    I know the story isn’t real but the premise is. Be that as it may, it still made me cry watching the heroic scene of him running

  • @benquinneyiii7941
    @benquinneyiii7941 9 місяців тому

    Clear and distinct ideas

  • @Thomason-xv4kp
    @Thomason-xv4kp 7 днів тому

    Me when they find out school is ending earlier and my mom's car is waiting for me:

  • @brndnwilks
    @brndnwilks 5 місяців тому +1

    That's the bravest man in fictional cinema.

  • @KIWOONGLEE
    @KIWOONGLEE 9 місяців тому +11

    We can see real infantry soldier's destiny in front of same people.

  • @jorgevaccari2374
    @jorgevaccari2374 Рік тому

    Excelent video!!!!!!!

  • @srajalbansal7112
    @srajalbansal7112 Місяць тому

    Cinematic Achievement.

  • @Sabroe_ffs
    @Sabroe_ffs 11 місяців тому +11

    3:20 where did those soldiers all the way to the left come from?

    • @Mdude181
      @Mdude181 11 місяців тому +19

      They were cameramen accidentally in the shot as you can see they don't even have guns

    • @apratimroy
      @apratimroy 9 місяців тому +9

      @@Mdude181 , right, I saw in a video that they were put in costume since there was no way to keep them out of the shot (once the truck with the camera rig took the camera from them and started moving), and that they were delighted to get extra pay as extras for that day's shooting.

  • @timsparks1858
    @timsparks1858 11 місяців тому +6

    The sad situation for all infantry in the Great War. The Tank and Aircraft were in their infancy not ready to free the men from the trenches and No Man's Land to give "fighting" chance. It would be another 21 years and another world War to change all that.

    • @Calh92
      @Calh92 8 місяців тому

      The 100 days offensive in 1918 ended trench warfare

  • @sasinonraksa4357
    @sasinonraksa4357 Рік тому +13

    Im not gona lie my school when we have sports day me and my friend will be like this

  • @MB-ub5ns
    @MB-ub5ns 4 місяці тому

    Run Forrest, Run!

  • @redt8311
    @redt8311 9 місяців тому +27

    It’s crazy to think Jack Marston had to go through this solely because he just had to choose revenge and kill Edgar Ross. If he hadn’t done that the government would not of declared him a suspect in Edgar Ross’s death, forcing him to go on the run, falling in with a small gang of outlaws. Few years he got captured and had to take a deal with Archer Fordham to fight in World War I as his sentence as opposed to sitting in prison for life or hanging. At least Archer was a man of his word, and when Jack got back, he was officially declared a freeman by the US government with the right documents to prove it. Then went on to live a happy life in peace and died a successful old rancher who also had a few best selling books.

  • @iceysuhn5503
    @iceysuhn5503 2 місяці тому

    0:57 I wish a BF1 match would start like this

  • @sousasv4432
    @sousasv4432 6 місяців тому +1

    3:13 I downloaded Battlefield 1 again just because of this scene XD

    • @CodeUK93
      @CodeUK93 3 місяці тому

      Nothing beats a good old breakthrough charge!

    • @venomfoxgames
      @venomfoxgames 3 місяці тому

      BF1 is still the best!

  • @aniket7151
    @aniket7151 5 місяців тому

    How i keep moving in life even i get slammed so many times ❤

  • @mr.rich-low-pitch6570
    @mr.rich-low-pitch6570 5 місяців тому

    3:23 Did that guy he bump into just straight up die from tripping?

  • @the_jones528
    @the_jones528 7 місяців тому

    This was fucking CRAZY

  • @oceanistoosmall
    @oceanistoosmall Рік тому +11

    I think more bomb VFX were meant for the scene as you can see some soldiers falling to go the ground for no reason

  • @believeintheheroic
    @believeintheheroic 11 місяців тому +12

    This was a perfect movie

  • @Winslowclips
    @Winslowclips 2 місяці тому

    how did you still not get copyright

  • @nalaglagnaanghel6496
    @nalaglagnaanghel6496 6 місяців тому +1

    Title?

  • @unknownfugitive225
    @unknownfugitive225 3 місяці тому

    Bro got knocked out cold (3:21 - 3:25).

  • @AWMulholland99
    @AWMulholland99 Місяць тому

    Don't worry young men, this scene is as real as the war istelf !

  • @snow-3878
    @snow-3878 8 місяців тому +1

    “your so special your be on the front lines” denerosity

  • @matvangogh
    @matvangogh 4 місяці тому

    Scofield pays it forward...... Tom Blake saves his friend Scofields life ........ and in turn..... Scofield ends up saving his brothers Joes life!

  • @iguzman3064
    @iguzman3064 8 місяців тому +2

    To me its criminal this didn't win best picture

  • @lohengrinoath9906
    @lohengrinoath9906 10 місяців тому +1

    RELEASE THE SARDUKAR!

  • @noticiasucrania2023
    @noticiasucrania2023 5 місяців тому

    Quando se assiste a filmagens da época, observa-se que os filmes não passam nem 1% da realidade...

    • @MLVL312
      @MLVL312 4 місяці тому

      .?????

  • @adlergizinski7234
    @adlergizinski7234 4 місяці тому

    WAR IS SUPER

  • @nikitarathore5467
    @nikitarathore5467 3 місяці тому +2

    pure cinematic experience in this era of barbie movie

  • @dah1ia6
    @dah1ia6 10 місяців тому +1

    4:51

  • @arthurdacruzmascarenhasgar963
    @arthurdacruzmascarenhasgar963 11 місяців тому +9

    For me this movie was very inspiring! Although it is a bit slow with few action scenes

  • @Idrisbach
    @Idrisbach 5 місяців тому

    And the best bit? Because nobody significant would have seen it properly, because it averted a disaster rather than created a victory, Schofield would probably receive for this action..... nothing. Just the way it goes.

  • @dh3279
    @dh3279 2 місяці тому

    Amazing film!

  • @karenbrown1097
    @karenbrown1097 3 місяці тому +1

    All those brilliant young men dead. Now look wot we've got

  • @NapoleonBonapartet
    @NapoleonBonapartet 3 місяці тому +2

    1:36 I don’t understand this A part of the movie

    • @RflexShter
      @RflexShter Місяць тому +1

      If ur referring to the soldier who couldn’t speak and was hysterical , I can only imagine it was a very common occurrence these men arnt killers they are everyday folk exposed to extreme horrors and expected to keep a level head , no surprise that a lot couldn’t I know I couldn’t

    • @NapoleonBonapartet
      @NapoleonBonapartet Місяць тому

      @@RflexShter thanks

  • @joshua5343
    @joshua5343 9 місяців тому +2

    2Timothy:
    7. I have fought the good fight, I have finished the race, I have kept the faith. 8. Now there is in store for me the crown of righteousness, which the Lord, the righteous Judge, will award to me on that day -- and not only to me, but also to all who have longed for his appearing.

  • @MrTemwa
    @MrTemwa Місяць тому +1

    Why the lance corporal should join the charge

  • @colin8696908
    @colin8696908 11 місяців тому +19

    Not a prefect movie but still miles above "All quite on the western front." Which insists on throwing every ww1 cliché at you.

    • @trevinoel8738
      @trevinoel8738 11 місяців тому +22

      Imo both are good. This movie is great in its storytelling and direction. All Quiet On the Western Front is great in its anti war message. Sure it had clichés, but it’s cause it showed Paul over the duration of the war, to finally kill him at the most pointless time to illustrate an anti war message

    • @mintheman7
      @mintheman7 11 місяців тому +18

      I don't think they are considered cliches when the book first came out in 1930

  • @SarahClarke-fm8ys
    @SarahClarke-fm8ys Місяць тому

    Dare you to look at 3:22

  • @user-sm6ov8hj1p
    @user-sm6ov8hj1p 6 місяців тому

    🇯🇵日本わふんかのくになので、とてもこわいです

  • @honnebombll
    @honnebombll 9 місяців тому

    Why didnt he use the other side of the trench?

    • @ewanc1
      @ewanc1 8 місяців тому +5

      Because it's steep-sided and there are other trenches intersecting the front line which connect the front line to the rear lines (if there are any). Going over the top was the only way to get a clear run without having to jump over/climb into and out of other trenches. Schofield, as an experienced soldier, would have known this.

  • @user-uq9qb4jh4n
    @user-uq9qb4jh4n 2 місяці тому

    I love thes men 😍😍😍😍

  • @jamessalvatore7054
    @jamessalvatore7054 8 місяців тому

    Not enough focus on the fact that this was 1 ....cut.
    1 single cut .....

  • @noodlezhp
    @noodlezhp 7 місяців тому

    Why couldn't they dig a straight line then dig it sideways

    • @danyleon4870
      @danyleon4870 6 місяців тому +1

      Lesson learned about zig zag defensive trench

  • @maxsoon1097
    @maxsoon1097 11 місяців тому +1

    I have ordered to tell you to stopped the attack. Whereas the soldiers been slaughtered outside. Boom, kaboom.

  • @IQ-XMEN
    @IQ-XMEN 4 місяці тому

    One man can save thousands of lives if you would just listen.

  • @ultimathule1000
    @ultimathule1000 25 днів тому +1

    Why there is a black soldier at 0:58, when there were no black soldiers fighting in Europe?

    • @Lego_hq_21
      @Lego_hq_21 21 день тому

      Britain did have colonies in Africa

  • @timothy1949
    @timothy1949 8 місяців тому +3

    running through a perfectly fine green field in front of soldiers charging towards invisible enemies 2km away, I wonder what would happen if he decided do his same little running BEHIND their own fucking trench instead of running in front of. but hey, this is one of the most realistic war movies ever, this is wt the boys would have done.

    • @Berserker3624
      @Berserker3624 6 місяців тому

      After pounding there lines with artillery and then advancing with artillery as cover, those lads had more brains than just ‘clog their machine guns with our blood’

    • @Calh92
      @Calh92 2 місяці тому

      Because there would be a network of support trenches in the way you genius, as he's making his way through the trench you can see soldiers moving in and out of them

  • @TheStapleGunKid
    @TheStapleGunKid 11 місяців тому +4

    Seriously why is he running in front of the trenches? All he had to do was run behind the trenches and it would be a lot easier. He wouldn't have all those men in the way.

    • @beendoneagain
      @beendoneagain 10 місяців тому +3

      Are you trying to wreck this movie?

    • @Attaboy98
      @Attaboy98 10 місяців тому +10

      I guess the cut behind the trench was steep vertical, he won't be able to climb and in tense situation to get to the Colonel , he chose the other side

    • @timsparks1858
      @timsparks1858 10 місяців тому +3

      In the real WW1 a soldier on both sides couldn't do that especially from a Frontline trench. Rifles and Machine Guns had a average maximum range of 600- 800 yards.
      Many trench lines of both sides were much closer than that. A accurate depiction from a movie was with Daniel Craig in it some years ago.

    • @KazeHorse
      @KazeHorse 8 місяців тому +1

      Well there was no gps or signs to follow back then on the front line - my guess is the messengers had to go to the front and ask the soldiers stationed there on where to go and how to find who they need to find.

    • @timsparks1858
      @timsparks1858 8 місяців тому

      Runners knew where to go. They were attached to the Frontline units. It was their regular job. They knew to stay in and run in the trenches to protect themselves from enemy fire.Outside the trench line was a long way back.

  • @SpeakMusic25
    @SpeakMusic25 4 місяці тому

    😢😭

  • @kawaito_pixel
    @kawaito_pixel 9 місяців тому

    Perlukah gambaran yang jelas..

  • @saqqara6361
    @saqqara6361 11 місяців тому +4

    The movie was great, for me mainly because of the one-shot camera style...Great.
    That scene could have become epic but they failed....
    One can see that all are running according to camera movement and not by a general assault
    why was that tackle @ 03:20 that lethal?
    impacts @ 03:35 did strange damage...all are jumping..

  • @mohdnizlanbinmohdnasirmedi8683
    @mohdnizlanbinmohdnasirmedi8683 3 місяці тому

    I wonder why he didn't run on the other side of the trench.

    • @Calh92
      @Calh92 2 місяці тому

      You would have support tenches to try and get over

  • @JamesNames-yo3ou
    @JamesNames-yo3ou Місяць тому

    Did humans bleed in 1917?

  • @user-kc9rp3oj7s
    @user-kc9rp3oj7s 3 місяці тому

    What?

  • @charlierumoldboi3939
    @charlierumoldboi3939 3 місяці тому

    What lovely clean trenches, and no duckboards, no ladders, dug outs, no barbed wire, no shell holes etc. No man's land like a bloody bowling green. Absolute bollocks, historically inaccuate at every level. Shite!!!

    • @Calh92
      @Calh92 2 місяці тому

      Its a new battlefield, the German's have just pulled back to the Hindenburg line.
      Its more inaccurate to believe every field in France and Belguim was shelled before any fighting got there.

  • @user-sm6ov8hj1p
    @user-sm6ov8hj1p 6 місяців тому

    あらそはないことがたいせつです😊

  • @user-sm6ov8hj1p
    @user-sm6ov8hj1p 6 місяців тому

    怖いことでつらいですよね
    🇯🇵日本わへいはです✨人は死ぬうんめいなので、生きるのはむずいとおもいます
    国と荒らしても人が死ぬだけですよね。

  • @Thekennel177
    @Thekennel177 4 місяці тому

    How does a large artillery shell explode feet from men and those men don’t splatter across the ground? Total BS.

  • @Grandizer8989
    @Grandizer8989 11 місяців тому +9

    I don’t get how clean the battlefield is. No craters, rotting bodies, dead horses, spent canisters… it does a disservice to the men who saw action in WW1

    • @johnnk3256
      @johnnk3256 10 місяців тому +29

      This was a new line created by the Germans after retreating from no man's land. The British troops dug that trench at that distance practically over night as they caught up to the new German line. That's why its so pristine.

    • @bkjeong4302
      @bkjeong4302 9 місяців тому +7

      Did you not watch the first half hour of the movie?!

    • @Grandizer8989
      @Grandizer8989 9 місяців тому

      @@bkjeong4302 I’m talking about this battlefield

    • @ewanc1
      @ewanc1 8 місяців тому +10

      @@Grandizer8989It's a new battlefield. The Germans had withdrawn and the 2nd Devons were advancing towards the Germans' new line. The reason why the field is so pristine is that this ground hadn't been fought over/shelled for 3 years hence the lack of bodies/shell holes/barbed wire etc.

    • @joblessmf420
      @joblessmf420 8 місяців тому +10

      ​​@@Grandizer8989It's explained at the start of the movie. Just watch the whole movie. They spent a large part of the movie going through no man's land that looked exactly like what you just described. Nothing here does a disservice to anyone.

  • @user-ew8jd9lb6z
    @user-ew8jd9lb6z 10 місяців тому

    2023

  • @MarcKershaw
    @MarcKershaw Місяць тому

    Terrible tactics

  • @user-qx3lx2sl1f
    @user-qx3lx2sl1f 10 місяців тому +1

    bill collector found him

  • @Saleh-Alslimany
    @Saleh-Alslimany 7 місяців тому

    me running from feminists office after I asked for the Man in charge

  • @ahmad987456321
    @ahmad987456321 2 місяці тому

    peace is made by warriors plz dont forget these souls

  • @greglyons2526
    @greglyons2526 5 місяців тому

    Kinda unrealistic

  • @sudhirbumbariya8103
    @sudhirbumbariya8103 11 місяців тому +1

    Movie name???

    • @gyorgylitvai1478
      @gyorgylitvai1478 11 місяців тому +1

      1917

    • @johntregon9307
      @johntregon9307 11 місяців тому +4

      I know it's set in 1917 but what's the film called?

    • @Blacloud
      @Blacloud 11 місяців тому +3

      @@johntregon9307 The film is called "1917". That's the title.

    • @apratimroy
      @apratimroy 9 місяців тому +3

      @@johntregon9307 2019, as in the video title.

    • @f.r.y5857
      @f.r.y5857 9 місяців тому

      _1917_

  • @carloseduardodospassosferr1536
    @carloseduardodospassosferr1536 3 місяці тому

    Um dos piores filmes de guerra q eu já vi...

  • @willmart8066
    @willmart8066 3 місяці тому +3

    In this scene we can clearly see patriarchy exercising its male privileges in the history of humanity.

  • @switzerlandful
    @switzerlandful 9 місяців тому

    They are white with the plains andwith the justiceQ