It will not come back. We have other radio telescopes that can do what Arecibo could do. So why spend a 100 million dollars on rebuilding Arecibo when you can just use a different telescope? I very much LOVED Arecibo. In my teens I had dedicated PCs crunching data from Arecibo for SETI at home. We need to let her go and move on. She gone mate.
There will never be another quite like it, the information gathered, to this day, still being filtered. There are so many more instruments currently existing on this turtle on the back of four elephants etc, that are functioning and adding to the Astronomy zeitgeist. edit: i got the analogy wrong, but i stand by it.
Hang on a moment, the reason BLC1 was conciderd a possible ET signal was that it "passed the wiggle test" this guy is saying it didn't, something doesn't add up. Here, 🤔😱
I remember melting a CPU with SETI at home. I set up a machine as a dedicated SETI box. I set SETI@Home to like 100% CPU usage and the PC died after 72 hours. I made another box and set the CPU usage to like 75% and that one lasted for ages. My room sounded like a server room lol.
Interesting de-bunking. I was taken in by the 'hullabaloo' initially - but quickly had doubts. The hallmark of the quality of Event Horizon is that you avoid sensationalism.
John, you have the best content ever. But when are you going to upload to Spotify again? The Ads absolutely ruin the UA-cam experience. Thanks so much for everything you do 🙏
8 billion people making 8 billion wild guesses. The only known true fact is that John Michael Godier has the most beautiful sounding voice in the known universe.
Just had a curious thought; with the Arecibo ‘message’ being so tight and so, so powerful what did/could it have done to the instruments & systems of any plane or satellite happening to fly into the beam? Or was it timed so precisely as to avoid any effect?
What evidence is there at the wild signal was a satellite? I've never heard that before and everything I've ever read makes it pretty clear that it most certainly was not a satellite
Good explanation, though I am getting tired of the misattribution of the Copernicus Principle as it pertains to close civilizations. Its logically unsound and lacks data.
I feel like either you are right and this argument is beneath you or you are misinformed because SETI and all the other gatekeepers of new info have to adhere to the same standard rules that they don’t disclose ANY info about contact without going through the full process. In which case they are just doing what they agreed to do until it’s ready to be disclosed.
Why would a much more advance species want to talk to us? I see advanced species study us like we study chimpanzees....but I don't think we have anything they truly want or need from us.
human would absolutely love to talk to any "lower" species if we could. it would be the dream of many scientists. entomologists dedicate their lives to studying ants. do you really think they wouldn't love to talk to them if they could? and if you could invent tech that allowed humans to talk to their cats or dogs, you'd be the first trillionaire.
I consider myself in the JMG camp. However, I listened to what Simon Holland said, and he didn't say anything extraordinary. In fact, he sounded very conservative. I'm trying to understand what the controversy is about.
He claimed that BLC-1 was one of five or more signals found in SETI@Home data, it isn't. He claimed a scientist at Astron emailed him audio of BLC-1 which showed a doppler shift, when in fact the audio was made by an artist who wanted to visualize a FRB. There's many, many, more claims that have since been walked back or disregarded. He's also said that John doesn't understand the current state of SETI and what is happening in the field, I'll leave that to all of you to judge. - Ross
interference is why i wholeheartedly advocate for a telescope to be mounted on the dark side of the moon or onto a nearby asteroid, the farther the better and im all for it, if i had the money id build one there myself
Isn’t this guy American? Think the additional work was done in Europe. Home seti work out of Italy and the additional observation from the Netherlands wasn't it. Sounds like the US is behind in this..
I’ve been 1st a bunch of times. Was great initially but now when it happens I just feel kinda empty. Like I won at life but realised the price wasn’t worth the sacrifice. Probably how pop stars feel after a concert.
One day we’re gonna ring up sum aliens and be like “yo give us some knowledge” and the response will be “ayo get rid of them nukes and maybe we will”, then bam. We’re stuck again.
Ok all you Europeans Europes doing its own thing so concentrate on that as far as SETI stuff goes, we all know the yanks mainstream msg "nothing to see here" lol 😅😂
Does anybody else get super excited when the show starts.
It’s like a movie
Bring back Aracebo
It will not come back. We have other radio telescopes that can do what Arecibo could do. So why spend a 100 million dollars on rebuilding Arecibo when you can just use a different telescope? I very much LOVED Arecibo. In my teens I had dedicated PCs crunching data from Arecibo for SETI at home. We need to let her go and move on. She gone mate.
@@carmattvidz4426 yeah. looking at the info the solar craft are providing is just maddeningly scary and yet it's so neat.
There will never be another quite like it, the information gathered, to this day, still being filtered.
There are so many more instruments currently existing on this turtle on the back of four elephants etc, that are functioning and adding to the Astronomy zeitgeist.
edit: i got the analogy wrong, but i stand by it.
Bring it back for another James Bond Fight Scene.
Hang on a moment, the reason BLC1 was conciderd a possible ET signal was that it "passed the wiggle test" this guy is saying it didn't, something doesn't add up. Here, 🤔😱
Conciderd?
It's as real as it gets. Musk and Zuckerberg have money in on this. It's fucking happening baby!!!!!
@@daggers101 I did concider that but desided against it
@@daggers101 You guys both focus on the wrong thing, he made a good point, oh sorry poind.
Engrush is a hoerd langage.
I remember melting a CPU with SETI at home. I set up a machine as a dedicated SETI box. I set SETI@Home to like 100% CPU usage and the PC died after 72 hours. I made another box and set the CPU usage to like 75% and that one lasted for ages. My room sounded like a server room lol.
What I know is that after they explained BLC1 they’ve discovered a red shift which eliminates the interference explanation.
Breakfast content (in the UK) a rare treat
@@davidbailey453 So is breakfast, For some!
Interesting de-bunking. I was taken in by the 'hullabaloo' initially - but quickly had doubts. The hallmark of the quality of Event Horizon is that you avoid sensationalism.
Here we go!
John and team thankyou for the upload!!!!
Right on right on right on got me a fresh cup of coffee and hunkering down to give a listen
SETI at home was all over my university back in the day.
Well thats BLC1 wrapped up. Thanks team
Lol
You would think so right....but unfortunately you can't convince a true believer even with proof or evidence.
Omg, Omg, omg, we found another planet that also watches the Simpsons. 50 years later, oooops that was our signal.
Lmfaooo
I thought they recently figured out what the WOW signal was.
It's not the consensus yet.
@ ok, thank you.
It is nothing. Alien talk grift as usual
Bring back SETI@Home! 🛸👽
The truth is in the trenches, not on the General's maps.
John, you have the best content ever. But when are you going to upload to Spotify again? The Ads absolutely ruin the UA-cam experience. Thanks so much for everything you do 🙏
Dont get it twisted though luv JMG and Isaac they're my regular content never miss a show tbf🙂
alright, alright, alright!
Lets dream some lightspeed dreams into space ...❤
Grtz johny geerts
Let's go!!!
8 billion people making 8 billion wild guesses. The only known true fact is that John Michael Godier has the most beautiful sounding voice in the known universe.
Like a rattling lawn mower
@@isitme1234😂
@@DrNat1 Listen to the beginning😂 dadda daaannn
@@DrNat1 0:47 😂
@@isitme1234 😂😂 brilliant 😂
Why is this still a controversy?
David Getty worked at Microsoft in REDMOND… not Seattle.
Just had a curious thought; with the Arecibo ‘message’ being so tight and so, so powerful what did/could it have done to the instruments & systems of any plane or satellite happening to fly into the beam? Or was it timed so precisely as to avoid any effect?
Your girl sounded like a drunk Liverpudlian in her intro.
What evidence is there at the wild signal was a satellite? I've never heard that before and everything I've ever read makes it pretty clear that it most certainly was not a satellite
Good explanation, though I am getting tired of the misattribution of the Copernicus Principle as it pertains to close civilizations. Its logically unsound and lacks data.
How many craters on the back side of the moon would we need to land in to turn the entire moon in to a radio lens?
I feel like either you are right and this argument is beneath you or you are misinformed because SETI and all the other gatekeepers of new info have to adhere to the same standard rules that they don’t disclose ANY info about contact without going through the full process. In which case they are just doing what they agreed to do until it’s ready to be disclosed.
Nice
Why would a much more advance species want to talk to us? I see advanced species study us like we study chimpanzees....but I don't think we have anything they truly want or need from us.
Pets,everyone loves a good pet.
If chimps started building forges and cities we would be studying them...
@@BladeValant546 We evolved from the southern ape. We are the chimps that built the cities.
human would absolutely love to talk to any "lower" species if we could. it would be the dream of many scientists. entomologists dedicate their lives to studying ants. do you really think they wouldn't love to talk to them if they could? and if you could invent tech that allowed humans to talk to their cats or dogs, you'd be the first trillionaire.
@@notmyproblem88 We're talking to you so I guess you are correct.
The background music is annoying and distracts some of us from the guest and host dialog
Mr Simon Holland is effectively making a mess of nearly all space related topics.
I consider myself in the JMG camp. However, I listened to what Simon Holland said, and he didn't say anything extraordinary. In fact, he sounded very conservative. I'm trying to understand what the controversy is about.
He claimed that BLC-1 was one of five or more signals found in SETI@Home data, it isn't. He claimed a scientist at Astron emailed him audio of BLC-1 which showed a doppler shift, when in fact the audio was made by an artist who wanted to visualize a FRB. There's many, many, more claims that have since been walked back or disregarded. He's also said that John doesn't understand the current state of SETI and what is happening in the field, I'll leave that to all of you to judge. - Ross
Simon Holland has gone quiet
@EventHorizonShow Yikes! Now that you mention it, I recall him talking about phone calls with mysterious "sources".
@genx7006 Either that or he's just embarrassed.
interference is why i wholeheartedly advocate for a telescope to be mounted on the dark side of the moon or onto a nearby asteroid, the farther the better and im all for it, if i had the money id build one there myself
Isn’t this guy American? Think the additional work was done in Europe. Home seti work out of Italy and the additional observation from the Netherlands wasn't it.
Sounds like the US is behind in this..
He was part of breakthrough listen and he works internationally with many seti scientists.
The US does not classify everything though.
What are you saying?
@@EventHorizonShowgibberish. He’s speaking gibberish.
Methinks he doth protest too much!
1st!
One day I'll get a 1st
I’ve been 1st a bunch of times. Was great initially but now when it happens I just feel kinda empty. Like I won at life but realised the price wasn’t worth the sacrifice.
Probably how pop stars feel after a concert.
hahaha yeah, go to the back side of the moon and see what you find:) Anyone who mentions the "early" universe, has no business in science, period:)
It was [insert deity here]
@@brick6347 BTW, post Roman Christianity has been utterly debunked as well:)
@@brick6347 The guy who flew to the moon on a winged horse.
One day we’re gonna ring up sum aliens and be like “yo give us some knowledge” and the response will be “ayo get rid of them nukes and maybe we will”, then bam. We’re stuck again.
Ok all you Europeans Europes doing its own thing so concentrate on that as far as SETI stuff goes, we all know the yanks mainstream msg "nothing to see here" lol 😅😂