Either way.... it's very clear to me that back in those days, all people just wanted kids to listen and do what the hell they were told!! Almost all stories seem to be "misbehaving" children/adolescents and how they get dead after not listening to some extent hahhaa
Lol I used to watch the cartoon series as a kid with my mom and I would get so frustrated!!! Every episode he's looking for his dad and they always just miss each other!
@@mary-janereallynotsarah684aren't you glad screenwriting has gotten better since then? I remember getting really frustrated with some of the more inane series of past decades where it was clear those in charge didn't care enough about consistency or about the characters having a realistic level of intelligence/decency and of deus ex machinas NOT looking like deus ex machinas (or at least not being frustrating to the audience). A really good modern example where improbable situations are made to look perfectly planned and the deus ex machinas are actually not frustrating in my opinion is the Miraculous: Tales of Ladybug And Cat Noir series. They seem to have thought of all the things that would frustrate the fans and written around them and somehow things feel satisfying and don't feel forced!
I remember watching a TV movie adaptation of Pinocchio, where he's saved by the Blue Fairy before he's hanged by the Fox and Cat, but eventually Pinocchio finds them again, they convince him to bury the coins and water them with water from a nearby beach, but when Pinocchio returns, the coins have been dug up. I remember this TV movie having Bob Hoskins in it and a combination of English and Italian actors.
The original author hated children and delighted in ways of torturing Pinocchio, it was only because his editor forced him to create a happy ending that we got one
Funny thing is most (at least modern) writers tend to torture characters they like, not the ones they despise... I mean the despised characters doesn't end well too, but not in the way Pinocchio did.
@@a.w.4708As an OC-person and role-player, I can confirm that we all love shitting on our favourite children while a lot of us simp for them at the same time.
True that I read in as a kid. And it scared me very much. The original Hans Christian Anderson's tales like The Little Match Girl is a tragic tale. Didn't get the moral of the story.
This actually makes so much sense to me because Pinocchio has always felt like a collection of different stories that teach Pinocchio morales and I felt even more strongly about that with Del Toro’s version, glad to see that his first death in the movie too was at least a nod to the original
Let's be real. Pinocchio is just disturbing. I was terrified of the movie as a kid (and still kind of am, that donky scene is so creepy) and disneys one is supposed to be the nice version
That's what I was thinking too! He was clearly gonna fall for it. I thought the fox was just gonna use his cleverness but nope he just tries to mug him like a crackhead on the subway
I've read the book as a child and I loved it. It was action heavy and the amount of shit Pinocchio goes through make you sympatize with him much more than in Disney version. I've also never thought the morale is not to disobey the adults... More to trust the right people and be prepared for world being harsh. At the end Pinocchio wins not because of obedience, but because of caring for his father, both in heroic and mundane yet mature way.
Glad to see someone making sense between so many misinformation comments. Even people saying Collodi hated kids... Nowadays everyone believes all the crap they see randomly on the internet... Such a sad society we live in
Actually it doesn't end there, it's a common misconseption due to the fact that it was the last scene of the newspaper comic section of pinocchio, but then the author decides to continue the story writing the book
Pinocchio isn't the only character Disney softened for the modern audience. All the Grimm Brothers' characters they used were softened as well. The funny thing about the Grimm Brothers' is that they modified the stories for their audiences, too.
The original tales are better fit in to horror category, often full of bloodshed and gory details. I think in that time those weren't very scary like now.
There was a Soviet re-write of Pinocchio called "The golden key, or the adventures of Burattino", the part about the fox and cat telling the protagonist about planting the five golden coins, later planning to steal them, made it into the rewrite. They also attacked Burattino posing as masked highwaymen, torturing him for the money. Eventually they hung him, but by his ankles, because he previously swallowed the coins and they were planning for the coins to fall out of his mouth.
@@jpomales5546 heh, no. The tale ended with them using the golden key to unlock a secret door to a puppet theatre where Buratino/ Pinocchio and his friends started working honestly (as opposed to what Carabas-Barabas - the main villain - wanted). I'm guessing you already know this story and just want to poke me because of the current politic situation. It's fine, I don't support Russia either, just sharing something relevant to the topic. 🤷🏻♂️
There's a pretty self explanatory reason why so many old stories have such brutal endings. And it's simply because the times they were written in were brutal and unfair themselves. Death was never far away or out of the mind.
I used to have a hardbound, damn near coffee table book sized copy of the unedited Pinocchio, and damn was it dark. The illustrations were phenomenal though, in a creepy way.
Read the book when I was a kid before I ever saw the whole movie. I loved it, it was so interesting and imaginative, the main character learns so much, a lot of it the hard way. My favorite character was the turquoise blue fairy, who shows up in unexpected places. Kudos to the grocery store chain that sold classic children's books, a series with one every week, and to my mom for buying them for us.
Every time I watch one of your episodes I just tell my mom about it and share my shock/wonder or disgust of the original story. When she heard about the original Pinocchio story, she was shocked because it ended so abruptly (I was just as shocked). Also, I really appreciate all the hard work and dedication you and your team put into researching for these videos and uploading them! I also wanted to ask if you’ve ever heard of the old Egyptian practice of offering young beautiful girls to the gods by throwing them in the Nile river? I don’t know whether there is research or anything covering this. I’ve heard it from my mom (we’re Egyptian) and it’s something her teachers covered at history lessons. I think it’s very interesting and could make for an interesting video, if there is enough credible information available of course!
@@ModernMedusa Yes, I only said that it was an old Egyptian practice not a fictional story. It is history but there are actually also some superstitions and stories about this. There are some stories about these sacrificed women dragging people into the water to have them suffer the same fate.
@@miniaturejayhawk8702 I think you have been misinformed. First of all, I never made any mention of me being a descendant of theirs. Also, I was born to and raised by Egyptians but I no longer live there. Secondly, old Egyptians never went extinct they share dna with many Egyptians. Just because we do not have the exact same religion and culture as they used to does not mean that they went extinct. Remember that humans marry from anyone from any culture and background, which means that we still share the same dna and that they did not go extinct. Your argument is untrue, because you cannot say that old Europeans or Asians went extinct because their culture is no longer being preserved and followed. They can still have descendants who live centuries after them. I only wanted to share something I found interesting and thought would make a good topic for a video. But the only thing I have received in return for wanting to share my interest is unsolicited opinions on things I didn’t even mention or imply. I simply think it is quite sad that one cannot share their ideas without being targeted by others who wish to dampen their mood or get triggered by nothing at all. I simply mentioned my nationality to establish the basis that we are deeply educated and influenced by the culture of our ancestors. If this statement is not to your liking I would simply ask what the OP was trying to imply and then share my thoughts on this only if OP is willing to listen. Unsolicited and unasked for opinions are simply to be kept to oneself and unvoiced. Remember that your words can cause damage and can make you seem bad if they are used wrongly. However, I wish you all the best. Have a good day/night.
@@mysteriousmissf9877I AM SORRY THAT SOMEONE IS TRIPPING OVER YOUR SUGGESTION - I THINK IT'S A GREAT IDEA.I LOVE LEARNING ABOUT DIFFERENT CULTURES' & THEIR PRACTICES'. PEOPLE TODAY, MOST OF THEM UNFORTUNATELY, ARE JUST JUMPING ON OTHERS' FOR ABSOLUTELY NO REASON!!!! BUT, IT'S ALL BEEN FORETOLD IN THE BIBLE & FROM EVERYTHING THAT HAS BEEN HAPPENING & YOU CAN FEEL IT IN THE AIR- WE SEEM TO BE AT THE END TIMES'.IT STATES IN THE BIBLE " THAT WHAT ONCE WAS CONSIDERED BAD, WILL NOW BE CONSIDERED GOOD & WHAT WAS ONCE CONDIDERED GOOG- WILL NOW BE CONSIDERED BAD!!!!😢😢 THAT'S JUST ONE TINY EXAMPLE, BUT ONE THAT TRULY IS ASTONISHINGLY PLAYING OUT DAY BY DAY WITH SOMETHING ELSE, ONCE CONSIDERED BAD, IS NOW GOOD!!!!🥺🤦 MAY GOD BLESS ALL, MAY WE ALL STAND STRONG TOGETHER IN FAITH MANY PRAYERSNLUV WWG1WGA WWG1WGA WWG1WGA 👼👼✝️✝️🙏🙏🕊️🕊️🌹🌹💝💝👑🥰🙏🙏
As a child, pinocchio haunted me. That was the disney story. Then i watched another, i cant remember where it was made, that traumatized me in my childhood. They planted him, he grew as a tree. God, he suffered.
Born in the '70 in germany. I remember listening to cassette tapes with the original story. Same with the original Brother Grimm stories. I also remember how the stepsisters in cinderalla cut pieces of their feet off to fit in the shoe.
Gotta read this book. Part of what i liked about the Disney film and fairytales in general was how it seemed anything could happen. There was just much creativity. Also I've heard the book is comically dark.
@@rhiannongreen2642The Peter Pan writer had a brother that died when he was young and Peter Pan is based on this tragedy. A boy who never grows up. So sad. I lost a sister in infancy.
Convinces Pinocchio to bury his gold in a field Goes to rob him on his way to the field instead of just waiting for him to leave and digging up his gold *But you didn't have to cut me off-*
Yeah, I liked Jiminy Cricket. He was there to help Pinocchio. I like the way he said that if he needed him, he should, "Give a little whistle and always let your conscience be your guide." That was the only thing I really liked about the whole movie.
There actually are a few screen adaptations that are pretty close to the book. For example 1978 animated version, 2012 italian animated version, 2019 italian live action version…..
'Cause he's a puppet. Puppets only move if you pull its string. He's hung on a tree by a string no one's pulling, so he's not moving. One could say that the wishes of parents are that their children live without bondage (strings of poverty & servitude), but there are people who do what they can to force one to only be able to live in bondage (strings of poverty & servitude) & once they've gotten out of you all they want or at least all they can get, they leave you like Pinocchio.
@@ilsignorpierpaolo5164 Looked earlier as it was animation. The only female voice was that of the Blue Fairy. It is an UA-cam upload. Don't remember the people who did the voices, unfortunately.
People were viscious back in fairy tale times. We had an old book of Bedtime stories from the 1920s, and virtually every story ended with the kids getting beaten and/or sent to bed without dinner.
I know it would've been too dark but it would've been cool if they kept this in but when the fox and cat leave Pinnocio wakes up and goes "oh yeah im made of wood" and just climbs down lol.
When I was a kid, my neighbour gifted me a book with Pinocchio original story, and it never scarred me the part where he got hanged because I didn't know till that point what that meant. I learned from the book the word "hanged" (Sorry for my bad grammar, I'm Italian)
Pinocchio cannot die from choking or strangulation. He stopped breathing when his tree was cut down. He only started breathing again when he became human and blood pumped through his veins instead of sap.
Pinocchio was a puppet, then became a real life boy or something with no strings attached, then on the end there was a string or rope attached to him. Great story, the author Guillermo del Toro is very magnificent and creative on his craft
If I remember correctly, in the Russian version called "Buratino" thay have animated all of that (except of the bitten off paw of course). IDK BTW, I watched that cartoon like 10 years ago.
The original stories disney repurposed were often done by authors like the Grimm Brothers who did not like happy endings. They were about rape, murder and other gruesome topics and almost never had a happy ending
🚨 watch the FULL breakdown of Pinocchio's Messed Up Origins! ua-cam.com/video/bGtweb0OS5g/v-deo.html
Not true the part regarding Pinocchio biting off the Cat's hand.
@@dandycrow2821ok no one cares
@@LO1S_853 I do because I'm Italian and I know Pinocchio, jacka**.
Either way.... it's very clear to me that back in those days, all people just wanted kids to listen and do what the hell they were told!! Almost all stories seem to be "misbehaving" children/adolescents and how they get dead after not listening to some extent hahhaa
Damn that’s kinda poetic if you think about it the song “I got no strings to hold me down” and in his final moments a string held him up
🤯😱🫡 GREAT observation!
lol 😂
Dang 😮 u savage
Damn. Nice observation.
so creepy
Fans: "That's a fucked up way to end a story"
Author: "Fine I'll torture the puppet for 20 more chapters
Lol I used to watch the cartoon series as a kid with my mom and I would get so frustrated!!! Every episode he's looking for his dad and they always just miss each other!
@@mary-janereallynotsarah684aren't you glad screenwriting has gotten better since then?
I remember getting really frustrated with some of the more inane series of past decades where it was clear those in charge didn't care enough about consistency or about the characters having a realistic level of intelligence/decency and of deus ex machinas NOT looking like deus ex machinas (or at least not being frustrating to the audience).
A really good modern example where improbable situations are made to look perfectly planned and the deus ex machinas are actually not frustrating in my opinion is the Miraculous: Tales of Ladybug And Cat Noir series. They seem to have thought of all the things that would frustrate the fans and written around them and somehow things feel satisfying and don't feel forced!
@@curiousnerdkittehwhat’s a deus ex machina
@@curiousnerdkitteh with the way MLB is going downhill,especially with that ending,I don't think it deserves any praises 😬
The woke gets scared of everything, and I think that includes you
The thieves are NOT very smart, they coulda just dug up the coins after Pinocchio buried them 💀
Yeah, bunch of idiots😂😂
Exactly!!
I remember watching a TV movie adaptation of Pinocchio, where he's saved by the Blue Fairy before he's hanged by the Fox and Cat, but eventually Pinocchio finds them again, they convince him to bury the coins and water them with water from a nearby beach, but when Pinocchio returns, the coins have been dug up.
I remember this TV movie having Bob Hoskins in it and a combination of English and Italian actors.
Most thieves aren’t
Author: this is the canon ending
Fans: nah imma do my own thing
Fanfiction summarised
Disney: Well gonna do our own version
Fans: "You can't end it there! How the heck would a puppet die from hanging?"
Also me.
How would a puppet live if he wasn't hung?
@@chitlitlah I see what you mean, and it is clever, but: this is Pinocchio and it is kind of his entire thing.
That he’s a lying 🤥 son of a bitch lol 😂
Sorry 😞 couldn’t help it
The original author hated children and delighted in ways of torturing Pinocchio, it was only because his editor forced him to create a happy ending that we got one
Funny thing is most (at least modern) writers tend to torture characters they like, not the ones they despise... I mean the despised characters doesn't end well too, but not in the way Pinocchio did.
@@a.w.4708kill your darlings is the writing trope
For once I actually appreciate editors
His little booger picking stinky ass was a kid too.
@@a.w.4708As an OC-person and role-player, I can confirm that we all love shitting on our favourite children while a lot of us simp for them at the same time.
People don't realize that these stories weren't cutesy tales to tell a lesson. They were cautionary tales for kids to not do stupid shit.
True that I read in as a kid. And it scared me very much. The original Hans Christian Anderson's tales like The Little Match Girl is a tragic tale. Didn't get the moral of the story.
This actually makes so much sense to me because Pinocchio has always felt like a collection of different stories that teach Pinocchio morales and I felt even more strongly about that with Del Toro’s version, glad to see that his first death in the movie too was at least a nod to the original
Let's be real. Pinocchio is just disturbing. I was terrified of the movie as a kid (and still kind of am, that donky scene is so creepy) and disneys one is supposed to be the nice version
Tell me about it me and you both
Omg i was tooo, that and bambi
Exactly and once they leave "pleasure island" they dont come back as boys. Its about child sex trafficking imo
Yeah don't watch the live action version its worst
Tell me about it, im Italian and grew up with the tale uncensored, it was supposed to teach kids to not disobey their parents
Well the author is said to have really hated kids and made it plain
Nobody that has actually "grown up" likes "kids/lids" I hate to tell ya
@@Wonderful-lz2mqlids?
Jajaja he wants them to feel fear
I think all fairytale writers maybe wanted to scare kids. Scare them into staying home and obeying parents?
@@Wonderful-lz2mqlmao kind of sad that you think that. maybe you've been disappointed a lot.
Bro went full circle with the, "ain't no strings on me"
The original author hated children so much that any punishment that he had Pinocchio go through was because he thought kids were troublesome brats
Why didn’t they just wait and watch then dig the gold up? 😅
No witnesses?
Cat and fox are smart animals but they aren't that smart because they are still beasts, and beasts prefer a good story
That's what I was thinking too! He was clearly gonna fall for it. I thought the fox was just gonna use his cleverness but nope he just tries to mug him like a crackhead on the subway
@@cainmathewson1857 lol
I’m saying 😂
I've read the book as a child and I loved it. It was action heavy and the amount of shit Pinocchio goes through make you sympatize with him much more than in Disney version. I've also never thought the morale is not to disobey the adults... More to trust the right people and be prepared for world being harsh. At the end Pinocchio wins not because of obedience, but because of caring for his father, both in heroic and mundane yet mature way.
He wins while hanging from a tree????
@@gemini4lyfe3001😂
Carlo Collodi was writing short stories in the local paper... this was not the ending of the story, but the end of one chapter...
Glad to see someone making sense between so many misinformation comments. Even people saying Collodi hated kids... Nowadays everyone believes all the crap they see randomly on the internet... Such a sad society we live in
The disguised cat and fox are frightening. Then when it cuts to Pinocchio hanging it really pulls at your heart strings.
Yea got me thinking something bad was about to happen to the puppet when the white hooded dudes with knives were after him 😂
Actually it doesn't end there, it's a common misconseption due to the fact that it was the last scene of the newspaper comic section of pinocchio, but then the author decides to continue the story writing the book
Forced *
I'm sure I looked at the book and Pinocchio is saved by a fairy?
I know Jiminey Cricket gets killed and is somehow resurrected.
@@Cheepchipsable yeah, pinocchio gets saved by the blue fairy and cured by the cricket
Pinocchio isn't the only character Disney softened for the modern audience. All the Grimm Brothers' characters they used were softened as well. The funny thing about the Grimm Brothers' is that they modified the stories for their audiences, too.
I would love to see a lice action Horror or thriller movies haded on the original Grim fairy tales
The original tales are better fit in to horror category, often full of bloodshed and gory details. I think in that time those weren't very scary like now.
Yeah, in Cinderella, the stepsisters had to cut off part of their foot just to put on the slipper
So, originally, Pinocchio ends with the saddest puppet show in history.
That was a cautionary tale, and then Pinocchio became a money maker.
There was a Soviet re-write of Pinocchio called "The golden key, or the adventures of Burattino", the part about the fox and cat telling the protagonist about planting the five golden coins, later planning to steal them, made it into the rewrite. They also attacked Burattino posing as masked highwaymen, torturing him for the money. Eventually they hung him, but by his ankles, because he previously swallowed the coins and they were planning for the coins to fall out of his mouth.
I will never forget "Burattino".
How can i forget this, help
Let me guess then they used his corpse to make a barrel for vodka. Wonderful. Russia never disappoints.
@@jpomales5546 no, actually. It was still set in Italy.
@@georgeoldsterd8994 oh okay. How about a cask of Amontillado then
@@jpomales5546 heh, no. The tale ended with them using the golden key to unlock a secret door to a puppet theatre where Buratino/ Pinocchio and his friends started working honestly (as opposed to what Carabas-Barabas - the main villain - wanted). I'm guessing you already know this story and just want to poke me because of the current politic situation. It's fine, I don't support Russia either, just sharing something relevant to the topic. 🤷🏻♂️
There's a pretty self explanatory reason why so many old stories have such brutal endings. And it's simply because the times they were written in were brutal and unfair themselves. Death was never far away or out of the mind.
I used to have a hardbound, damn near coffee table book sized copy of the unedited Pinocchio, and damn was it dark. The illustrations were phenomenal though, in a creepy way.
Read the book when I was a kid before I ever saw the whole movie. I loved it, it was so interesting and imaginative, the main character learns so much, a lot of it the hard way. My favorite character was the turquoise blue fairy, who shows up in unexpected places. Kudos to the grocery store chain that sold classic children's books, a series with one every week, and to my mom for buying them for us.
That’s cool. Wish I had that… of course most of us have our own little cool bits about our childhoods… even the mostly crummy ones.
I never knew this but i have always had a gross feeling watching the movie even as a kid.
You make those vibes seem real don’t remind me
Man he was the Peter Parker of his time.
Tolstoy: Let me introduce myself
Every time I watch one of your episodes I just tell my mom about it and share my shock/wonder or disgust of the original story. When she heard about the original Pinocchio story, she was shocked because it ended so abruptly (I was just as shocked).
Also, I really appreciate all the hard work and dedication you and your team put into researching for these videos and uploading them!
I also wanted to ask if you’ve ever heard of the old Egyptian practice of offering young beautiful girls to the gods by throwing them in the Nile river? I don’t know whether there is research or anything covering this. I’ve heard it from my mom (we’re Egyptian) and it’s something her teachers covered at history lessons. I think it’s very interesting and could make for an interesting video, if there is enough credible information available of course!
Pretty sure that's just straight up history and not a story, I could be wrong 😂
@@ModernMedusa Yes, I only said that it was an old Egyptian practice not a fictional story. It is history but there are actually also some superstitions and stories about this.
There are some stories about these sacrificed women dragging people into the water to have them suffer the same fate.
"We're egyptian"
Living in egypt doesnt not make you a descendant of ancient egyptians lol. They all went extinct long ago.
@@miniaturejayhawk8702 I think you have been misinformed. First of all, I never made any mention of me being a descendant of theirs. Also, I was born to and raised by Egyptians but I no longer live there.
Secondly, old Egyptians never went extinct they share dna with many Egyptians. Just because we do not have the exact same religion and culture as they used to does not mean that they went extinct. Remember that humans marry from anyone from any culture and background, which means that we still share the same dna and that they did not go extinct.
Your argument is untrue, because you cannot say that old Europeans or Asians went extinct because their culture is no longer being preserved and followed. They can still have descendants who live centuries after them.
I only wanted to share something I found interesting and thought would make a good topic for a video. But the only thing I have received in return for wanting to share my interest is unsolicited opinions on things I didn’t even mention or imply. I simply think it is quite sad that one cannot share their ideas without being targeted by others who wish to dampen their mood or get triggered by nothing at all. I simply mentioned my nationality to establish the basis that we are deeply educated and influenced by the culture of our ancestors. If this statement is not to your liking I would simply ask what the OP was trying to imply and then share my thoughts on this only if OP is willing to listen. Unsolicited and unasked for opinions are simply to be kept to oneself and unvoiced. Remember that your words can cause damage and can make you seem bad if they are used wrongly. However, I wish you all the best. Have a good day/night.
@@mysteriousmissf9877I AM SORRY THAT SOMEONE IS TRIPPING OVER YOUR SUGGESTION - I THINK IT'S A GREAT IDEA.I LOVE LEARNING ABOUT DIFFERENT CULTURES' & THEIR PRACTICES'. PEOPLE TODAY, MOST OF THEM UNFORTUNATELY, ARE JUST JUMPING ON OTHERS' FOR ABSOLUTELY NO REASON!!!! BUT, IT'S ALL BEEN FORETOLD IN THE BIBLE & FROM EVERYTHING THAT HAS BEEN HAPPENING & YOU CAN FEEL IT IN THE AIR- WE SEEM TO BE AT THE END TIMES'.IT STATES IN THE BIBLE " THAT WHAT ONCE WAS CONSIDERED BAD, WILL NOW BE CONSIDERED GOOD & WHAT WAS ONCE CONDIDERED GOOG- WILL NOW BE CONSIDERED BAD!!!!😢😢 THAT'S JUST ONE TINY EXAMPLE, BUT ONE THAT TRULY IS ASTONISHINGLY PLAYING OUT DAY BY DAY WITH SOMETHING ELSE, ONCE CONSIDERED BAD, IS NOW GOOD!!!!🥺🤦 MAY GOD BLESS ALL, MAY WE ALL STAND STRONG TOGETHER IN FAITH MANY PRAYERSNLUV WWG1WGA WWG1WGA WWG1WGA 👼👼✝️✝️🙏🙏🕊️🕊️🌹🌹💝💝👑🥰🙏🙏
As a child, pinocchio haunted me. That was the disney story. Then i watched another, i cant remember where it was made, that traumatized me in my childhood. They planted him, he grew as a tree. God, he suffered.
Ew
Born in the '70 in germany. I remember listening to cassette tapes with the original story. Same with the original Brother Grimm stories. I also remember how the stepsisters in cinderalla cut pieces of their feet off to fit in the shoe.
I love how my school just casually gave us this specific version of the story to kids that were 7yrs old, And then they wonder why we’re fucked up.
Gotta read this book. Part of what i liked about the Disney film and fairytales in general was how it seemed anything could happen. There was just much creativity. Also I've heard the book is comically dark.
LOL, stolen from original authors no doubt.
I thought he died cause his wood neck snapped when he was hung lol
To be honest Pinocchio in the original story deserves everything he gets
I read the books Pinocchio and it was frightening as I was very young at the time.
The original author didn't like kids.
Better than the Peter Pan author 👀
@@rhiannongreen2642The Peter Pan writer had a brother that died when he was young and Peter Pan is based on this tragedy. A boy who never grows up. So sad. I lost a sister in infancy.
Honestly the uncut messed up origins of Pinocchio is my favorite video of yours
Convinces Pinocchio to bury his gold in a field
Goes to rob him on his way to the field instead of just waiting for him to leave and digging up his gold
*But you didn't have to cut me off-*
Even the Disney's "nicer" version probably kept lot of kids off cigarettes
Another movie that freaked me out as a kid, but oddly, i really liked it still? I think it's b/c i was obssessed with Jiminey Cricket.
Yeah, I liked Jiminy Cricket. He was there to help Pinocchio. I like the way he said that if he needed him, he should, "Give a little whistle and always let your conscience be your guide." That was the only thing I really liked about the whole movie.
He was hung but couldn't die
*hanged
Author: **makes a dark ending**
Fans: “Nuh uh”
“There are no strings on me”
That’s painfully ironic
In Russian adaptation movie a fox and a cat actually hang Pinocchio on the tree, but to make him puke the gold he ate, so they couldn't steal them
Ngl the live action scene with the children turning into donkeys was more terrifying than this
A Pinocchio movie based on the original book would be outrageous
There actually are a few screen adaptations that are pretty close to the book. For example 1978 animated version, 2012 italian animated version, 2019 italian live action version…..
wait you probably meant the original version of the book that ends with Pinocchio dead
I am stupid
I remember reading this on a book a long time ago. Now I know it wasn't a dream lol
You can't hang a wooden puppet...successfully.
I always wondered how a hanging killed a kid made of wood
'Cause he's a puppet. Puppets only move if you pull its string. He's hung on a tree by a string no one's pulling, so he's not moving.
One could say that the wishes of parents are that their children live without bondage (strings of poverty & servitude), but there are people who do what they can to force one to only be able to live in bondage (strings of poverty & servitude) & once they've gotten out of you all they want or at least all they can get, they leave you like Pinocchio.
@@19Pyrus70*hanged
We need a horror version Pinocchio
It's already a horror 🤣
A quote from veggietales:
"That's still wasn't a very good way to end a story."
"Well what do you want? A big musical number?"
Pinocchio was VERY DARK and we didn't even know it back then. Lol
Something about the original creepier versions of these stories almost feels…better in a way, less goofy and more of an actual story
Are we just gonna forget that one of the original version included Pinocchio Killing Jimminy Cricket
I think the readers just called cap on how a puppet without lungs was supposed to die by hanging
You can watch the animated version from Italy which includes everything. It's good 😊
The 1972 version with Ciccio Ingrassia, Franco Franchi, Gina Lollobrigida, Nino Manfredi and Vittorio de Sica?
@@ilsignorpierpaolo5164
Looked earlier as it was animation. The only female voice was that of the Blue Fairy. It is an UA-cam upload. Don't remember the people who did the voices, unfortunately.
Not even gonna mention lampwicks horrific transformation that is him crying for his mother and screaming in pain
When a puppet moves it usually means it's haunted. Which is why Pinocchio frightened me as a kid. Demon puppet
Pinochle was a huge nightmare for children.
Bro for real said sneak attack like it was Skyrim
People were viscious back in fairy tale times. We had an old book of Bedtime stories from the 1920s, and virtually every story ended with the kids getting beaten and/or sent to bed without dinner.
I know it would've been too dark but it would've been cool if they kept this in but when the fox and cat leave Pinnocio wakes up and goes "oh yeah im made of wood" and just climbs down lol.
Disney: Yeah, this'll make a good kids movie.
Thanks for keeping the time happy and the sunshine flowing guy.
Yep as a child my grannie had the OG Pinocchio book and I remember this!
The thing I noticed about the live action is it stays more to the story of this one instead of the Disney cartoon
The donkey sequence and Winnie the Poohs LSD psychosis scared the hell out of me!
As a kid, the transformation to the donkey terrified me! And i know not the only one!
I mean Pinocchio really said: "Damn it bruh what the hell dude"
They really said "this isn't cannon" lmao
looking at these drawings it felt like a mercy kill
"There are no strings on me!!!"
Yeah idk about that one bud
Nhaa, this was the first use of a cliffhanger.
the first guy to avoid getting cancelled
I knew this already
i tought pinocchio was already known 100% by everyone
This is literally the Hollywood machine
This explains why the story feels like it’s rambling with no plot. Guy made it up as he went!😂
This version would be sick as a movie
I read the original Pinocchio in elementary school,I loved it,my classmates..did not..
The cat and fox could’ve just waited for Pinocchio to bury the gold then come back and dig it up…
I’m so stoked to play the Pinocchio game “Lies of P”.
Oh the irony of a stringless puppet being strung up.
When I was a kid, my neighbour gifted me a book with Pinocchio original story, and it never scarred me the part where he got hanged because I didn't know till that point what that meant. I learned from the book the word "hanged"
(Sorry for my bad grammar, I'm Italian)
He’s like “Whata? You no like ah the ending?
At first, I thought Pinocchio would survive being hanged. I mean, he is made of wood.
Disney wasn't having that... They wanted an island of bad little boys.
"No dude. This sucks." The fans probably
They also wanted to take the puppet to pleasure island. And the bad guy says “they won’t be coming back as boys”
I'd like to think his final thoughts were peaceful, afterall he came full circle.
Pinocchio cannot die from choking or strangulation. He stopped breathing when his tree was cut down. He only started breathing again when he became human and blood pumped through his veins instead of sap.
Transformation into the donkey finally hit me, they were going to become child laborers
Pinocchio was a puppet, then became a real life boy or something with no strings attached, then on the end there was a string or rope attached to him. Great story, the author Guillermo del Toro is very magnificent and creative on his craft
That original ending is what I like to call, how life be sometimes.
OG pinnochio is wild 💀💀
That escalated quickly
If I remember correctly, in the Russian version called "Buratino" thay have animated all of that (except of the bitten off paw of course).
IDK BTW, I watched that cartoon like 10 years ago.
The original stories disney repurposed were often done by authors like the Grimm Brothers who did not like happy endings. They were about rape, murder and other gruesome topics and almost never had a happy ending
There is just no reason for these old stories to end so horrifically lmao
Got wood?
Wow, Pinocchio is HUNG