Sufficient evidence now exists on Balakot air strikes to come to a logical conclusion | ep 129

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 бер 2019
  • In this episode of Cut the Clutter, Shekhar Gupta talks about the Balakot air strikes and why we can now come to a logical conclusion on what happened
    Connect with ThePrint
    » Subscribe to ThePrint : bit.ly/SubscribeToThePrint
    » Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
    » Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
    » Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
    » Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,6 тис.

  • @ThePrintIndia
    @ThePrintIndia  3 роки тому +12

    We count on good people to pay for good journalism. Please subscribe to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/ This includes the link for subscription from overseas too.

    • @msraju-dk7px
      @msraju-dk7px 2 роки тому +1

      Go and get it from that stupid George soros

    • @Mumbai1961
      @Mumbai1961 2 роки тому +1

      Not worth it..... Utterly biased

    • @kpklym3753
      @kpklym3753 2 роки тому

      Fuckk ogg

    • @welcomeuser8150
      @welcomeuser8150 13 днів тому +1

      You idiots a 🇺🇸democracy helped Pakistan with F16.

  • @klasgroup
    @klasgroup 5 років тому +277

    On 3 occasions reporters of Reuters were not allowed to visit the spot in Balakot, enough evidence that bombings did happen

    • @Friends4ever3373
      @Friends4ever3373 5 років тому +25

      Abey bhikariyon...pehle F16 use karne ka hisaab do....apne baap America ko ...jo tumhari kabhi bhi le leta hai...teil laga kar rakho ga#nd par...tumhara asli baap India!!

    • @theunknown9123
      @theunknown9123 5 років тому

      @@abdulqudussaggu3222 Do you even know that the bomb ghat were used were spice 2000 laser guided bombs that can e fired 60 km away from the target and which is impossible to miss. So if india had to blownsome trees , then there are more trees in INDIA than pakistan , why would India risk billions of dollars worth of military equipment? Think for urself..India has even provided pakistan and all the other countries with dossier with enough supporting evidence and photographs of the inside of that terrorist training facilities which were taken by RAW agents....indian, american, and Israeli flags were printed on steps so that the Terrorists would feel good on stepping on them....man there are more than enough proof...my fingers would start to hurt if i continue to write

    • @afaqh2356
      @afaqh2356 5 років тому +5

      Indian forces were not able to provide satellite images of the target.
      While Australian images show it intact, so all bombs missed the target.

    • @theunknown9123
      @theunknown9123 5 років тому +10

      @@afaqh2356 abey.....australian images were taken afer many days when pakistani army had already patched the roof....while indian satellite images were taken just hours after the attack cleary shows three holes in the roof...as it confirms india's usage of SPICE2000 bombs which are segregation bomb(i.e. Bunker Buster bombs) which doesn't destroy the entire target but penetrates through the surface and explodes inside the premise...just watch the "the print" video on this topic.

    • @afaqh2356
      @afaqh2356 5 років тому +5

      @@theunknown9123
      Sir, You do not have knowledge of armaments.
      If a bomb explodes in a house, it will not cause just a hole, it will result in no house at all.
      Bunker busters are used on bomb proof bunkers.
      No one uses these against normal houses.
      Also see the wikipedia. SPICE 2000 is not a bomb, but a guidance system, that is fixed to an ordiniary bomb to guide it.

  • @ashwinisidhanti660
    @ashwinisidhanti660 5 років тому +472

    My faith in Indian defense increased to many folds. What they said is what the evidence say. Great job Indian army. Proud of you. Keep us safe 👍

    • @simransidhu3444
      @simransidhu3444 5 років тому +2

      ashwini sidhanti, Rahul Gandhi SOLVED Kashmir and PREDICTED Pulwama Tragedy (1-Min Video): facebook.com/2299102823691105/posts/2299109723690415/

    • @shabayaba123
      @shabayaba123 5 років тому +11

      The internationally recognised version of events is the Pakistani one

    • @anuragadhikari9623
      @anuragadhikari9623 5 років тому +19

      @@shabayaba123 only pakistani media approves that

    • @Xadil123
      @Xadil123 5 років тому +1

      Hahahaha chutia admi Badgam main apna hi helicopter chod diya tum logo nay lol

    • @rabimaharana4117
      @rabimaharana4117 5 років тому +7

      @@Xadil123 jehadi 🤣🤣🤣🤣 India k nagatives sochte raho 😂😂😂😂
      Idhhar india super power banchuka hain..
      Apna dekh pehele
      Chinese kabza karnewale hain
      Mullo ko gaand main danda ghusa ghusa k karza asul Karega
      😂😂😂😂😂Phir ayoge baap k pass

  • @parthap2944
    @parthap2944 5 років тому +288

    Denial is the Usual Thing - Pakistan Denied any Involvement of 26/11 , later Nawaz Shariff confirmed it

    • @ChaudhryAzeem
      @ChaudhryAzeem 5 років тому +5

      And now when even US has completed its countdown of F16 and found no missing jet what now?

    • @imranmehmood3191
      @imranmehmood3191 5 років тому +13

      and thats why he is in jail now.bcz of his wrong statements

    • @ChaudhryAzeem
      @ChaudhryAzeem 5 років тому +7

      I guess now we can put all this modi drama aside and enjoy what we do with each other's stuff music movie etc

    • @jambunathan43
      @jambunathan43 5 років тому +19

      @@ChaudhryAzeem,NO US DEFENCE PERSONAL NOR GOVT but a group of journos, just as in India gave a report. like you said to the extent IO have read. Please give me details .

    • @ChaudhryAzeem
      @ChaudhryAzeem 5 років тому

      @SO What so why indians didn't come forward to claim it at international foram?

  • @rahuldunakhe8189
    @rahuldunakhe8189 5 років тому +394

    When we can shoot down a satellite moving at 7.5 km per second from the surface of the earth..dont you think its stupid to even think we can miss a stationary object..

    • @shabayaba123
      @shabayaba123 5 років тому +24

      You can't shoot things that fight back though. Shoot your own aircraft down in the process. Lacking in meaningful capability

    • @aravindns7339
      @aravindns7339 5 років тому +19

      Listen to his reason in the beginning - "these are hi tech things. Some error is possible". It's a Spice 2000 with error margin of 3 metres. And his reason is "hi tech things may have errors". And then says "I'm no tech expert...". Can it get any more contradictory?

    • @sajjadhussain9724
      @sajjadhussain9724 5 років тому +8

      Hahaha u can but u shit bricks when that stationary object can rip ur holes apart!!! If india is an unstoppable force, pakistan is an unmovable object!!!

    • @hellothere848
      @hellothere848 5 років тому +4

      SO ASAT testing proves Balakot strike.. Kya logic hai

    • @DeepakSharmaDPK
      @DeepakSharmaDPK 5 років тому +26

      9/11 mastermind was captured from Pakistan. We don't need to expose them everybody knows already.

  • @MuhammadAli-rd4ys
    @MuhammadAli-rd4ys 4 роки тому +52

    No one can stop me from loving Indians. Indians are brave and cut through propoganda. More strength to you Sir.

    • @radhasade
      @radhasade 4 місяці тому

      Your Buzdil Army even denied 93000 army open surrender against India in 1971 hence lying now on Bakakot Air strike is quite usual for you ...😂😂

    • @rustyshackleford9877
      @rustyshackleford9877 4 місяці тому

      You from Pakistan?

  • @nrusimha11
    @nrusimha11 4 роки тому +27

    Very nice analysis, particularly about the F-16 shoot down.

    • @munibowais
      @munibowais 2 роки тому

      You should watch the video posted six days after this video by this same guy.
      ua-cam.com/video/zCSsYdaW-1E/v-deo.html

  • @paragjyotideka1246
    @paragjyotideka1246 5 років тому +98

    Congratulations for having your name on ED chargesheet!

    • @nikhil-zz6mr
      @nikhil-zz6mr 5 років тому +1

      Was looking for this comment.. 😋

    • @sourav7162
      @sourav7162 4 роки тому +9

      Because he has exposed the UPA scam

  • @nkbrahm6826
    @nkbrahm6826 5 років тому +136

    It's been more than a month now.. why has Pak not allowed international media on ground zero at balakote till date?? Why is the cleaning up taking place so long

    • @Shubhampatel0777
      @Shubhampatel0777 5 років тому +13

      @@hyder404 because nothing of that happened in India that's y India didnt got any images or videos regarding to your claims

    • @Shubhampatel0777
      @Shubhampatel0777 5 років тому +8

      @@hyder404 and international media didnt claimed pak as Victors and terrorist can control foreign media to hide all their hidden terrorist activities , these channels like aljazeera airs from Kuwait-Qatar they gets terrorist funding from oil and pak can do anything to change all the statements to hide their terrorist activity

    • @Shubhampatel0777
      @Shubhampatel0777 5 років тому +6

      @@hyder404 and BBC also took interviews of some people in balakot they all told that bombs are dropped and they heard a loud noise they were very much scared and there was a lot of damage, even news are coming that some Pakistani retired officers are also dead in the airstrike who were giving trainings to these terrorists and after the airstrike the whole area was covered up by Pakistani army in just 2-3 hours and they called ambulance and they took mobile phones of all the people and they decomposed all the bodies and asif ghafoor tweeted just the images of some fallen pine trees on internet

    • @perxada
      @perxada 5 років тому +7

      I have a gift for u on April 5
      U.S Foreign policy Magazine's report on indian claim of F.16 Shoot down

    • @umjain2007
      @umjain2007 5 років тому +18

      @@perxada I have a return gift for you that Pentagon clarifies that there was no such audit conducted. You are habitual liars who has a history of lies like osama bin laden, kargil which you accepted after 10 years, mumbai attack are to quote few. Why foreign media is not allowed to go inside the facility. ?

  • @udayrathod3786
    @udayrathod3786 5 років тому +138

    Modi claim such strike than questioning him makes sense but when Airforce chief claims it there should not be any questions.

    • @MK-lh3xd
      @MK-lh3xd 5 років тому +6

      Why not?

    • @aravindns7339
      @aravindns7339 5 років тому +23

      @@MK-lh3xd Bcz unlike politician Modi, a serving chief's name will be smeared forever in history if he lies like a politician. This is equivalent to some people in US claiming 9/11 was an insider job to attack Afg.

    • @nr2811
      @nr2811 5 років тому +3

      @@MK-lh3xd
      because first of all they are not an elected body so if u have anything against them file a complaint like a regular citizen. other than that from thier track record i would say they have earned some trust.

    • @udayrathod3786
      @udayrathod3786 5 років тому +2

      @Johny walker you don't understand my point. You can question politician modi for his claim but to question air chief or PM over an announcement about a national security issue which gives our enemy an advantage and also a easy platform to manipulate people of our nation is definitely not a good idea. Did anyone question indira gandhi that were there 90000 soldiers who surrendered exactly 90k not some up or down. Did you asked footage for veer Hamid that how he distroyed tanks or Major Vikram Batra that did he killed enemy before hr died? You are not asking questions because you care for truth or ethics you are doing it because you hate modi and felt insecure that the old government whose boots you arr licking now where not able to make such brave decision and instead of learning from it you want to defame him bug you don't realise that by doing that you are defaming not just Army but entire nation. Improve your logic

    • @anandixitin
      @anandixitin 5 років тому +3

      Air Force and Army are above questions? Looks like ordinary people have learnt nothing from military dictatorships around the world.

  • @alkoxy
    @alkoxy 5 років тому +26

    Sir I cannot thank you enough for doing these videos. Everybody sees the news, fake, real and ridiculous. How to interpret the news is something that nobody is taught and a skill that everybody needs. Thank you for your service !

    • @munibowais
      @munibowais 2 роки тому

      You should watch the video posted six days after this video by this same guy.
      ua-cam.com/video/zCSsYdaW-1E/v-deo.html

  • @dipakdasgupta2527
    @dipakdasgupta2527 4 роки тому +39

    Pakistan PM Imran Khan himself admitted that some major damage has been done at Balacot. He told India trying to do something more dangerous than Balacot.
    Whatever lies Pakistan may say but it's a fact that an F 16 was shot down and they lost a pilot. Initially they said they captured 2 pilots but later they said they captured 1 pilot. So where is the 2nd pilot?

    • @asadgul2322
      @asadgul2322 4 роки тому +1

      Think about logically how your Army count 300 or 500 Men in night from plane how plane stand in air without changing direction if they can count 300 to 500 men whey they did not take any screenshoot of proof.How you can belief this Your army said that we threw 1000 kg bomb why that place not destroyed

    • @naueenmukhtar2243
      @naueenmukhtar2243 4 роки тому +1

      Listen again he said IAF damaged some trees. Why don't u read western media. They always supports u. But read what they are writing. Also hear what western commentators are saying. USA has clearly said, Pakistan did not loose any F 16. How did Abhinandan shot F 16, by winking at it. As all the 4 missile were found attached with his aircrafts wings.

    • @naueenmukhtar2243
      @naueenmukhtar2243 4 роки тому

      @Pichkalu Pappita
      If any person was killed by u. Then your crop commander and your COAS would not have been alive today

    • @naueenmukhtar2243
      @naueenmukhtar2243 4 роки тому

      @Jancy Varghese only one part is missing. I thought when a missile is fired, it goes as a complete missile not in parts. Anyways, read the statements of western expert's, reports. Who believe that all missiles are present and accounted for.
      Also. Major mafia people visited the site. Read their reports too. They found not sign of damage or repairs done to it.

    • @robocop8477
      @robocop8477 3 роки тому

      @@asadgul2322 www.outlookindia.com/website/story/india-news-balakot-airstrike-ntro-report-confirms-300-active-mobile-links-in-jem-camp-area/326514 , this is how we knew, imdia gave all proofs but pakistan media is lying to you.

  • @stankitzz
    @stankitzz 5 років тому +93

    comes to toes, jumps slightly, goes back and repeat

  • @RAFAAAAAA
    @RAFAAAAAA 5 років тому +16

    Seen enough of your journalistic acumen for the past many years now to believe your analysis on this subject ...Thanks for that.

  • @piyushkant6550
    @piyushkant6550 5 років тому +37

    Their Claim On Two Pilot being Cought Convinently Establishes The Fact that They Lost One F16 . Like You Can't Go Wrong In Counting When There Are Only Two Pilot To Count.

    • @ElBadriano
      @ElBadriano 5 років тому +2

      That’s because the captured pilot is an Israeli. If they accept that, it’s a bigger problem from them domestically than internationally.

    • @ritwikojha6792
      @ritwikojha6792 5 років тому +13

      @@ElBadriano That makes zero sense. What the hell is an Israeli doing, flying over PoJK? And even if that's true, PAF pilots just salvoing their AMRAAMs can't hope to beat Israeli F-16 pilots. Their offensive packages were headed to the Army's 16 Corps HQ in Nagrota, but couldn't even get close - trapped in BVR combat with IAF Su-30MKIs (which have RVV-AE missiles that match the AMRAAMs). I don't believe for a second that an Israeli pilot was here in the first place, and I don't believe that PAF could take him down if he were. Even Wingco Abhinandan's MiG went down only after he set off in chase of the PAF F-16, and got away from his wingmen. The Israeli pilot story is a vanity project for the uniformed terrorists of GHQ Rawalpindi.

    • @stormyzvox2185
      @stormyzvox2185 5 років тому +7

      ElBadriano
      Hahaha always blame the Jews

    • @Xadil123
      @Xadil123 5 років тому

      Very convenient indeed LOLLLLLLL ..

    • @meditation8480
      @meditation8480 3 роки тому

      @@ElBadriano that was a fake news
      Dumbo just google once

  • @sasidharankarthikeyan3798
    @sasidharankarthikeyan3798 5 років тому +16

    You can question media and government claims; not trigonometry.

  • @nitantkumar2711
    @nitantkumar2711 5 років тому +4

    Salute to Indian armed forces for their bravery.
    Also to the NDA for showing political willpower and giving the go ahead for such an operation.

  • @sadenb
    @sadenb 5 років тому +143

    We are proud of our IAF and army. We are proud of the current government for having the political will to make conventional weapons relevant again

    • @sultanmahmood6396
      @sultanmahmood6396 5 років тому +1

      Modi media coup fizzling out in election campaign because BJP Party Constitute a Huge Pile of Dog Excrement. devoid of integrity, morality & truthfulness & has forever discredited itself as a source of objective rule particularly after Balakot, demonetization/covert offsets deals @PDubey101 @timesofindia ua-cam.com/video/OjyzaQ2Y5Us/v-deo.html … Unexploded Israeli bomb still needs to be removed for security & when the site is safe to inter we will invite you but until then you will have to put your index finger in your rear orifice & wait 4 another few weeks.@PDubey101 @timesofindia ua-cam.com/video/gpYvTmn5QG8/v-deo.html … The Center for PAF Progress is out with a new videos ratcheting up pressure on Modi to stop dragging his feet over tax returns ua-cam.com/video/BOfY2iYcawI/v-deo.html

    • @sultanmahmood6396
      @sultanmahmood6396 5 років тому +1

      @Satanic Verses fix Pak economy? Your ignorance doesn't surprise me at all" because unlike Pakistan where no one asleep hungry" 7000 men women and children die of hunger every day allover India and their corpses are being eaten by dogs and cats. That's why historically intelligent people don't take Indians seriously.

    • @tvf813
      @tvf813 5 років тому

      you should be proud of one thing that your media and your government has earned you an insult and immense shame.

    • @NASArealworld
      @NASArealworld 5 років тому

      sanch Sanchayan shuker manao abhinandan wapis de diya 🙂

    • @avishkarbagul8447
      @avishkarbagul8447 5 років тому +1

      ALI SHAIR .....de diya nahi dena padaa..

  • @supdasaaf
    @supdasaaf 5 років тому +5

    Exactly. Fantastic analysis.

  • @firozosman
    @firozosman 5 років тому +41

    In war, truth is the first casualty.
    Aeschylus

    • @Freerider1502
      @Freerider1502 4 роки тому +6

      Islam is always in war - hence farthest away from truth

    • @zarqoonali7705
      @zarqoonali7705 3 роки тому +1

      BUT ON 27 FEB IT WAS A SU 30 MKI

    • @firozosman
      @firozosman 3 роки тому

      @@Freerider1502 then there's this random bhakt moron who's got his head up his butt, hating on others

    • @anilksingh1974
      @anilksingh1974 3 роки тому +1

      @@zarqoonali7705 Where is the second Pilot who was captured and in the hospital?

    • @anilksingh1974
      @anilksingh1974 3 роки тому +1

      @@firozosman first tell us Where is the second Pilot who was captured and was in the hospital?

  • @kmrao06
    @kmrao06 5 років тому +22

    What is relevant is for the first time Indian Political establishment under Modiji has shown some spine and displayed guts to hit back Pakistan. Secondly, it has made clear to Pakistan that it would not be business as usual and in case of any repeat , there will be consequences.

    • @yourpapa6641
      @yourpapa6641 2 роки тому

      Guess what Pak did early morning at 9 clock?

    • @yourpapa6641
      @yourpapa6641 2 роки тому

      @@reminiscence4142 well begging from Saudis makes sense but India going on its knees and begging the Chinese AIIB bank for money and aid makes no sense... especially when they are pulling Indian chaddi down in Ladakh.

    • @Dogeplayd
      @Dogeplayd 2 роки тому

      @@yourpapa6641 Educate Yourself. AIIB is not a Chinese bank! You are right, India did take a loan from AIIB. There is no country in the world that does not take loans , but it takes exceptional levels of economic mismanagement and desperation to go to IMF (21 times) and hand over the autonomy of the central bank (SBP) to IMF, present a mini budget just to satisfy IMF, beg the Saudis who give 3 Billion (which can't be used and must be returned within 72 hours if asked for and other humiliating conditions!!) just to beef up forex reserves - All of this for IMF to release a tranche of just 1 billion! - By the way is the IMF releasing the 1 billion anytime soon? Maybe you should try the 'Chinese AIIB bank' as well :)

    • @yourpapa6641
      @yourpapa6641 2 роки тому

      @@Dogeplayd A desperate nation which was given free lunch by US in the name of USAID for 66 years. Who gets 66 YEARS of free aid and too for not doing anything? India takes the trophy. As if begging for oxygen wasn't enough you had to sell national assets like Air India and BPCL (to be sold) for cents to overcome Modis 'thali bajao' campaign that only lead to a new Delta virus originating from India. Its a shame that a country has to borrow $6 Billion (twice borrowed) from WB and ADB just in 2019 in the name of fighting Covid and blab about a failed $5 trillion economy that tanked for the past 2 years and adding more poverty (Highest in South Asia, 25 million beggers added in just 2021 alone). Whats more shameful is the AIIB bank that is funded more than 60% by China so yes the money borrowed is mostly Chinese money. At least Pakistan is reaching out to its allies for loans unlike getting loan money from a country thats humiliating India in Ladakh as we speak. With no shame its no wonder your debt to GDP, deficit and corruption index is higher then a smaller country like Pakistan. I know for someone like you who only reads Republic news which gets sources from pigeons flown from 100th floor of Serena Hotel, had you known that in West all central banks are autonomous while your own central bank is sold its independence in 2018 and too not by any dictation from outside you would've saved yourself some shame and leftover non-existent dignity.
      www.google.com/amp/s/amp.dw.com/en/is-indias-central-bank-still-independent/a-50390038

    • @Dogeplayd
      @Dogeplayd 2 роки тому

      @@yourpapa6641 While every single thing you have mentioned is factually incorrect, I will go into refuting just two points- AIIB funded more than 60% by China ? Have a check on their website. The contribution is around 25% , India’s contribution around 8%. All other countries combined contribution around 67%. So it’s not a Chinese bank where funding contribution from outside China is 75%.
      Corruption index transparency international ranking, please check their website: India -86, Pakistan - 124. Nothing to be proud off, both have got to do a lot better.
      For those who understand economics management - Air India was sold to Tatas as part of disinvestment strategy and it was in the works for a long time as it was a white elephant.
      India getting USAID for 66 years? Whatever you are smoking get off it and get a real education!
      Sorry, I have no patience to factually refute all the other points you made,

  • @pranjaldas6661
    @pranjaldas6661 5 років тому +34

    Conclusion , Mission achieved.

    • @SohailMirza
      @SohailMirza 3 роки тому

      lol..you acheived your target but the data you had was old data...also two planes went down one of them was Israel plane

    • @pradeep-sz2bf
      @pradeep-sz2bf 3 роки тому +1

      @@SohailMirza why can't you tell another plane was Russia or French etc.

    • @SohailMirza
      @SohailMirza 3 роки тому

      @@pradeep-sz2bfre word your question..dont understand

    • @pradeep-sz2bf
      @pradeep-sz2bf 3 роки тому

      @@SohailMirza Israel plane ???😂😂

    • @SohailMirza
      @SohailMirza 3 роки тому

      Sorry to coming across like a idiot ..if you have sense rephrase the question.. if you just want to laugh listen to Modi

  • @KaushalKumar-zx8ls
    @KaushalKumar-zx8ls 5 років тому +16

    Has democracy given you the right to accuse the govt for conpirining to kill crpf personal

    • @mehwishahmed9361
      @mehwishahmed9361 4 роки тому

      Indian Modi is involved in CPR killing.

    • @akhilsharma413
      @akhilsharma413 3 роки тому +2

      @@mehwishahmed9361 Ohh really then I will say that Imran Khan is Conspiring against Paxtan with the help of Generall Bajwa to break Paxtan into 5 nations and the nations are
      Sindhistan
      Balochistan
      Khalistan
      Azaad kashmir(Meanwhile later on Bharat will merge them).
      then itself Paxtan.

  • @Vikram.uniyal
    @Vikram.uniyal 5 років тому +12

    Gupta ji you have choosen wrong subject today, i wish to watch you interviewing Sonia and asking about Dosa,Idli, saas Bahu relations and many more about Sonia -Indira.

  • @ishangoyalpec
    @ishangoyalpec 5 років тому +19

    Thanks for the dispassionate and detailed analysis. One thing I believe you should add is a huge shout out to Indian Government and Armed Forces because 1) During the whole incident, they did not rush out to provide half-baked facts. 2) It turns out that everything they said was complete truth without omission or exaggeration.
    I say this because at no point was a number claimed by the government on the number of terrorists killed. Secondly, they acknowledged that one of their planes went down and the pilot was missing. Lastly, they claimed to have shot down one Pakistani F-16 based on certain evidence. As someone who was extremely worried about my side furnishing wrong or embellished arguments, this makes me very proud.

    • @munibowais
      @munibowais 2 роки тому +1

      You should watch the video posted six days after this video by this same guy.
      ua-cam.com/video/zCSsYdaW-1E/v-deo.html

    • @advaitdubey8983
      @advaitdubey8983 2 роки тому +2

      Same pinch brother.
      This is 2022 and i was still worried going through the Wikipedia page and numerous reports by Australian think tanks and other reports.
      I for a moment literally got disheartened.
      But i am so proud and relieved today.

  • @sandeepsingh-lp4mf
    @sandeepsingh-lp4mf 5 років тому +3

    Great summary of events

  • @lensviewbykaushik
    @lensviewbykaushik 5 років тому +1

    Excellent

  • @GauravNabh
    @GauravNabh 5 років тому +2

    Super analysis. Mr Shekhar Gupta a lot of respect for you and your team for this analysis

  • @praneetchatterjee7563
    @praneetchatterjee7563 5 років тому +78

    Its our bad fate ...that some journalists...like Sagarika Ghosh...Rana Ayub and Rajdeep...sides with pm rather than our pm...
    Yes it is their freedom...but what they praised imran is only becuz of blind modi hatred...its unfortunate....

    • @praneetchatterjee7563
      @praneetchatterjee7563 5 років тому +6

      Test86 One4 its not wrong to be anti modi....its a democracy....everybody has their preference....
      But these journos brought down indias reputation only for modi hatred

  • @maha5
    @maha5 5 років тому +8

    Have you went on foreign tour during UPA rule ? Has govt paid for traveling, Black Label, food etc ??

  • @darshandoshi905
    @darshandoshi905 5 років тому +1

    Sir please tell us what the result of the IAF strikes at Muzzafarabad and Chakothi was, because no one is discussing those. It is very surprising that while we are investigating the Balakot strike in such detail, everyone seems to have forgotten about the strikes at other 2 places.

  • @bharatbhagyabidhata5187
    @bharatbhagyabidhata5187 5 років тому +57

    Thanks but no thanks. I would take IAF chief's word over your words any day.

  • @MrVijeshmon
    @MrVijeshmon 5 років тому +5

    Good video. Long live democracy. Job well done Air force and thanks to my govt for standing with us and taking tough decisions like this.

    • @wicky1446
      @wicky1446 5 років тому

      Ask Kashmiries what kind of democracy it is.

    • @MrVijeshmon
      @MrVijeshmon 5 років тому

      @@wicky1446 Namaste..Our Kashmiri brothers and Sisters have suffered a lot. So as many defense personal in the region. People and govt both have to work towards building a nation or a state.

  • @MadhusudhanKoodige
    @MadhusudhanKoodige 5 років тому +12

    Shekar, an interesting analysis. I'd like to point out about the helicopter incident in our side of kashmir where 6 airmen succumbed, if my memory serves right. Any information on them? Was this conveniently forgotten or was it an inadvertent mistake? We would like to know your assessment of that situation, now that we seem to get past the war hysteria and jingoism.

  • @TheAmandeeparya
    @TheAmandeeparya 5 років тому +1

    beautifully explained.. Thumbs up

  • @shreepadbhat9739
    @shreepadbhat9739 5 років тому

    Well Done Shekhar Ji - RESPECTS!

  • @bhushanshukla786
    @bhushanshukla786 5 років тому +14

    when I saw this video Augusta westland scam clicked in my mind

    • @sushilasthana1969
      @sushilasthana1969 5 років тому +1

      Recently Christian Michael gave the name of this Traitor and Despicable Journalist SHEKHAR GUPTA who took Rs 50 crores to go along other crook FAMily to order Choppers from Augusta Westland. This guy is a scum bag and a blot on honest journalism.

    • @sourav7162
      @sourav7162 4 роки тому

      @@sushilasthana1969 you are a clutter to the world. He has exposed the Augusta scam. Go fuck yourself. Scamgressi chamcha chutiye

  • @sanatbhate
    @sanatbhate 5 років тому +30

    Thank you Mr. Gupta - full marks for this episode of yours.
    In a democracy it is good to question government and/or armed forces....but, it is equally important that such questioning is NOT done while the operations are still on. This kind of shallow questioning, political heckling can only be helping enemy's narrative. None of the major democratic countries or people themselves have tolerated such protests (and please do not quote Anglo-French adventure in Suez or the Vietnam war... we all know that those are not the correct examples).
    Our politicians and media of all colours/hues lack maturity, sensibilites and military operational understanding.

    • @wpjobsuk
      @wpjobsuk Рік тому

      he thinks he is somebody and he can dictate whatever bullshit he think which is correct.

    • @asdasdasdqwe123
      @asdasdasdqwe123 Рік тому

      well said.

  • @karls9879
    @karls9879 5 років тому

    Amazing narrative! very methodical

  • @11547able
    @11547able 5 років тому +17

    This is one of those rare moments when Shekhar Gupta has impressed us with an accuate, well substantiated piece of journalism! kudos, and hope this continues, especially on matters military.

  • @umermohammad612
    @umermohammad612 5 років тому +4

    Good one. I would like to hear from you about the chopper crash as well.

    • @capybara6807
      @capybara6807 5 років тому

      It was crashed very at a place very far from the borders.

    • @umermohammad612
      @umermohammad612 5 років тому

      m.economictimes.com/news/defence/budgam-indian-missile-fired-before-mi17-v5-chopper-crash/articleshow/68623744.cms

  • @priyamawasthi6254
    @priyamawasthi6254 3 роки тому +3

    When there is freedom to raise questions, there is also assumption that answers will be accepted once they are satisfactorily available but politicians don't do that.

  • @rajatmodi4766
    @rajatmodi4766 2 роки тому

    Excellent coverage, very insightful!

  • @rakesh-iw9wh
    @rakesh-iw9wh 2 роки тому

    Mr GUPTA. You are the best journalist around

  • @naveenthomas6873
    @naveenthomas6873 5 років тому +7

    Sekhar sir thanks for these video series... It's pretty interesting... Got me interested in politics...
    Please this question that I have... Is a coalition govt of regional parties India's answer to the anti defection law because now they can defect against and debate seriously on the bill as they just have to maintain the party's side and not the coalition's side?
    I couldn't find an answer anywhere else..

  • @pardeeptandon6730
    @pardeeptandon6730 4 роки тому +4

    The next day after balakot an Indian helicopter was also shot down by friendly fire. And India had to scramble planes from as far as Gawalier to counter the Pakistan air attack. After all our WC who was shot down took off from Gawalier. It also implies all our airbases north of Gawalier were not enough to counter the Pakistani counter attack in broad day light.

    • @mayureshrasam1708
      @mayureshrasam1708 Рік тому

      no i dont thing we have base in Srinagar he became first to respond

  • @user-wh5nj8uz5v
    @user-wh5nj8uz5v 5 років тому

    Can we take a second to feel proud to live in this great democracy.....

  • @sameervittala4073
    @sameervittala4073 5 років тому +1

    Very objective assessment Shekar ji

  • @saifkashmiri2981
    @saifkashmiri2981 5 років тому +3

    why foreign media including reuters denied permission by pak authorities to visit the site thrice in first 10 days

  • @sandysrini
    @sandysrini 5 років тому +30

    I trust what our Air Chief Marshall says...they have hit the targets

    • @tvf813
      @tvf813 5 років тому

      do you believe in illusions. looks like it :D

    • @munibowais
      @munibowais 2 роки тому

      You should watch the video posted six days after this video by this same guy.
      ua-cam.com/video/zCSsYdaW-1E/v-deo.html

  • @reel_man
    @reel_man 3 роки тому

    Sir. Your journalism is true and nonoffensive. You don't give assumptions or take offense but simply you look for actions.

  • @amrit12343
    @amrit12343 4 роки тому

    Fresh to see not so biased media even on youtube

  • @deepakkt08
    @deepakkt08 5 років тому +12

    Good, for whatever reason, you have started behaving like an unbiased journalist. Thank you Shekhar 🙏

  • @nehaht
    @nehaht 5 років тому +7

    What about looking at the big picture? I choose to look at a few takeaways in this case:
    1. We have exercised our political will to go deep inside Pakistan and send a strong message about the consequences of messing with us.
    2. Previously, when we even thought to exercise such an action, we used to be slapped with sanctions. This time we had laid enough of diplomatic groundwork that after this event, we had the support of all the democratic countries.
    3. This is about terrorism. Not about Pakistan the country. Pakistani foreign policies for India, however, stand in the way of the common goal of fight against terror. It is becoming more and more evident what Pakistan is all about. It makes me very happy that during this skirmish, the Pakistani generals, continued to embarrass themselves by making self-contradicting statements. It is in Pakistan’s national interest to stop fooling its citizenry by calling their war-mongering towards India “standing up to big bad bully India”.
    4. This skirmish has raised questions about our arsenal. It has definitely exposed our need for more modern air-crafts and state of the art technology. I hope the current govt or whoever comes in next does the right thing and strengthens our armed forces.
    I have utmost faith in our armed forces. They make us strong, and because of them we enjoy our freedom. We owe a lot to them and those who question their integrity owe an apology as well. Jai Hind 🇮🇳

  • @shantanujain6376
    @shantanujain6376 3 роки тому +2

    I fail to understand how 2000 pound bomb casings failed to destroy the structures.
    I mean what sort of concrete did they even use on those structures lol

    • @Raptor-22
      @Raptor-22 2 роки тому +2

      They are not designed to blow structures. It’s a contained explosion. It does the damage from within. For example the Brahmos has very high Kinetic energy that can be devastating and cause a lot of destruction. Completely different type of explosion. Israel are true experts when it comes to these kind of bombs. They use them often against Hamas.

  • @ritushukla9284
    @ritushukla9284 5 років тому +1

    They are in perrenial denial mode. They denied even assassination of benazir bhotto saying she died of hitting her head on the car roof , when the whole world knows she was shot.

  • @NiceRoadTrucker
    @NiceRoadTrucker 5 років тому +5

    Not a word on the F-16 downing!

    • @NiceRoadTrucker
      @NiceRoadTrucker 2 роки тому

      @@soheil527 yes and Bajwa has the steadiest legs in DHA Pindi

  • @nitinsingh-vn7is
    @nitinsingh-vn7is 4 роки тому +4

    With ur experience it seems , u r the best fighter pilot India has 🤣🤣🤣

  • @alandope8733
    @alandope8733 2 роки тому +2

    Very good analysis sir in my theory of what I saw in the images that their is four holes in the roof of the building and a massive dark smudge on the northern side of the complex and it looks like there was and explosion there because it looks like a crater and the four holes in that roof definitely look like four bombs went and failed to detonate or they fixed the building

  • @rajeevshaarma1880
    @rajeevshaarma1880 4 роки тому

    Brilliantly analysed.

  • @ritushukla9284
    @ritushukla9284 5 років тому +14

    This guy's name has come as an accused in Augusta case

  • @jeeteshdwivedi3841
    @jeeteshdwivedi3841 5 років тому +6

    Pak now admits that they used f 16 in dog fight on 27th February

    • @tvf813
      @tvf813 5 років тому +1

      would you mind showing me where has pakistan admitted to use f16s. if you have a video pls share with everyone. if not then i will show you what india media has failed to prove. ok. thanks

    • @mateen1979
      @mateen1979 5 років тому +1

      USA has proved no F16 has been lost

    • @meditation8480
      @meditation8480 3 роки тому

      @@tvf813 there is something called google

    • @meditation8480
      @meditation8480 3 роки тому +1

      @@mateen1979 read washinhton dc post

    • @fmartin59
      @fmartin59 4 місяці тому

      @@mateen1979nope. Try again

  • @premlatasharma9426
    @premlatasharma9426 5 років тому +1

    Doubts are good. But suspicion is sickness.
    !!

  • @bhuvangrover3092
    @bhuvangrover3092 5 років тому

    Superbly summarised

  • @mohanmenon1300
    @mohanmenon1300 5 років тому +26

    300 cell phones became silent on the Pakistani side - meaning at least 250 Jihadis Kaput !

    • @garchagu
      @garchagu 5 років тому +1

      many Jihadis may not have cell phones the number may be more.

    • @abdlsy
      @abdlsy 5 років тому

      Each of them had two cell phones per person you are right

    • @reset6391
      @reset6391 5 років тому +3

      How did the govt detect 300 phones were they all Jio phones?

    • @tvf813
      @tvf813 5 років тому +5

      Keep crying jokers. No one cares what you say. The whole world accepts what Pakistan is saying. Because Pakistanis only speak when they have proofs as no one believes the old crackheads made up stories which basically are trying to do a cover up by delusively lying to their own people. You guys just need to know the facts by doing your own research as its available online everywhere. India is just been in the state of denial and Modi is making a fool out of people trying to play dirty politics to get some votes to save his seat in the elections. Wake up..! Please.

    • @preciousunique6650
      @preciousunique6650 5 років тому +2

      @@tvf813 Oh that's why the UAE and Good Islamic countries respects Indian PM Modi and Indian Foreign minister Sushma Ji.. Your statement itself proofs that Pakistan is a heap of shit and dumb zombies. You are the real foolish and mad people who claims whole world as foolish.. definite that's the real attribute of a true mad country like Pakistan.. Tum log wo billi k Tarah ho jo aankh band kr k doodh peeti hai aur sochti rehti hai ki koi nahi dekh raha kisi ko nahi pata.. rofl.. Do your analysis right way terroristan - pakistan

  • @username5537
    @username5537 5 років тому +19

    This has become my favourite show on UA-cam! Wonderful analysis as usual.

    • @ThePrintIndia
      @ThePrintIndia  5 років тому +2

      Your feedback is valuable to us. Keep watching ThePrint's UA-cam channel.

  • @RAFAAAAAA
    @RAFAAAAAA 5 років тому

    Well done 👍🏻

  • @milansharma7522
    @milansharma7522 5 років тому

    Very clear explanation..

  • @SuperMan-if8sp
    @SuperMan-if8sp 5 років тому +3

    Sir my simple question is to you that...why they are not allowed any media their..if something happens in India you pupils want media in their..

  • @ranaswarajsinh4524
    @ranaswarajsinh4524 5 років тому +2

    By watching Comrade Gupta It shows that how confused all #Left are. At one instance he is saying our democracy is best compare to dictatorship practised in Pakistan, and at the same time he is suggesting to "...take all passion out..." even the patriotic passion, what could be more hilarious than this. But he can have a passion of his own, the passion of impatience.

  • @sicario684
    @sicario684 4 роки тому +1

    Sir can you explaine me why Indian air force used standoff weapon as GP BOMB ?!

  • @nitindoshi2157
    @nitindoshi2157 5 років тому

    thanks a lot it was informative

  • @shailendrayadav5310
    @shailendrayadav5310 5 років тому +8

    You and Other forien institution analysis Barakot to prove it was miss.
    But not saying anything that Pakistani not allowed any one to visit those buildings. Why? And not talking that Balakot strike matter not number.

    • @2003rehmaniqbal
      @2003rehmaniqbal 5 років тому

      hamid mir the pak journlist visited the place after the few hours ..... see the video

    • @doncorleone3901
      @doncorleone3901 5 років тому +1

      He did not say it was a miss. Did u even watch till the end? He confirms IAF version

    • @Madhav782
      @Madhav782 5 років тому +1

      pehle pura video dekh

  • @guna177
    @guna177 5 років тому +6

    Mr. Shekhar Gupta you sound and look confused. Also one of the F-16 fighter pilot is dead as confirmed K K Nahwar

  • @sibilslife
    @sibilslife 2 роки тому

    Good journalism sir..big salute

  • @gr7184
    @gr7184 5 років тому +1

    Good Analysis..

  • @ramprasadkothari7542
    @ramprasadkothari7542 4 роки тому +4

    Mr Gupta when u are going to be neutral your tilting against government is sugar coated

  • @sanjayshirsat7866
    @sanjayshirsat7866 5 років тому +3

    Ek f 16 girya,
    kitna liya lokheed Martin sae?

  • @shivajivythi7307
    @shivajivythi7307 2 роки тому

    Thank you shekar sir

  • @achalkumarpassi103
    @achalkumarpassi103 5 років тому

    Mr shakar you explain the theory with much explanation we appreciate it

  • @SharkFishSF
    @SharkFishSF 5 років тому +30

    He's too old and spent, good bye Shaky, India will never forget you for your good bad journalism.

    • @hindiroots
      @hindiroots 5 років тому +1

      Secret Admirer - you should not be a critisizer

    • @arijeetdatta25596387
      @arijeetdatta25596387 5 років тому +1

      His name is now coming up in the Augusta charge sheet

    • @rohinidevi7454
      @rohinidevi7454 5 років тому

      Arijeet Datta what’s that?

    • @Sangwan421
      @Sangwan421 5 років тому +2

      Being old is a state of maturity with experience and not a symbol of loss of mental balance ....mental loss can happen at any age...just like yours.

    • @MargaretTCGangteManashe
      @MargaretTCGangteManashe 5 років тому

      @@Sangwan421 - wellsaid

  • @Shiva-pu8nb
    @Shiva-pu8nb 5 років тому +7

    Yes I would even question the army ,air Force, Indian Navy

    • @Shiva-pu8nb
      @Shiva-pu8nb 5 років тому +1

      @@nko0nko0 44 soldiers died no enquiry report came out who is responsible for security breach or negligence, it is similar negligence to kandhaar plane hijacke ,for such corruption why no one is in jail ?,why all defaulters are on run ? Why Even after air strike attacks on soldiers have not reduced?

    • @SuperRagala
      @SuperRagala 5 років тому +2

      @@Shiva-pu8nb lol.... surgical strike is not solution but it is a statement that the cost of engaging with India will heavy. What do you want to do? Should be sit idle like we did after Mumbai attack?
      Attack on soldier convey happed by suicide attacker. Should the stop compete traffic when they make troop movement?
      When raising questions, atleast raise some valid ones.

    • @Shiva-pu8nb
      @Shiva-pu8nb 5 років тому

      @@SuperRagala wow what a valid reply by such equipped with such a profound information and insight, and fool like me was thinking there were traces where the van was acquired from ,from where the attacker got explosive who are helping in the transition of the dynamite , how the suicide attacker got the information about the movement of the convey , but in one line you have summed it up simple it was a suicide attack and no further inquiries . great reply .....lol

    • @SuperRagala
      @SuperRagala 5 років тому

      @@Shiva-pu8nb have you not read the news? 23 Men were arrested in links with attack. Your sarcasm without substance has fallen flat.

    • @Shiva-pu8nb
      @Shiva-pu8nb 5 років тому

      @@SuperRagala yes I havent, share the link and any arrest in Kashmir valley can be linked to any attack if the government wants , still arrest doesn't answer who supplies the information about the transition of the convey . Who arranged the car and dynamite and from where.

  • @Anmol_Thakur888
    @Anmol_Thakur888 5 років тому

    The article he is referring to at 6:15 ,can any body direct me to it? i can not find it.

  • @ashitdas2915
    @ashitdas2915 5 років тому

    Well said sir

  • @vvikram8562
    @vvikram8562 5 років тому +3

    Another aircraft was Sukhoi 30 which had 2 pilots. According to this (1 + 2) Pakistan's first statement was correct and 2 and 3 statements for Modi government were only for face shaving.

    • @Paulanubav
      @Paulanubav 5 місяців тому

      What proof Pakistan have that they shot A Su 30 mki and we have proof of f 16 shot down and First Pakistan claimed that They have captured 2 pilot if one is mig 21 pilot and another su 30 mki pilot then Why Pakistan didn't reveal the ID of that 2nd pilot and why they later on changed their claim that they have only one pilot that is Abhinandan Varthaman And if Pakistan really shot down any Su 30 mki and it crashed in India occupied Jammu and Kashmir then Its not possible to hide this crash because Local people leaving there must know about the crash of su 30 mki like they know about the crash of mi 17 helicopter on that day but that day only mi 17 helicopter crashed and no other aircraft crash was recorded .

  • @manojsinha1276
    @manojsinha1276 5 років тому +28

    This baldi is most corrupt anchor. His name has come in Augusta Westland helicopter deal.

    • @dhamugohil8034
      @dhamugohil8034 5 років тому

      @Manoj Sinha ..
      दिग्विजयसिंह: आतंकवाद का कोई धर्म नहीं है ..
      मुसलीम: तुम JAISA चूतिया का सहारा है दोस्तो ..

    • @saghirmohammed9735
      @saghirmohammed9735 5 років тому

      How the biggest haramee world has seen since Hitler modi-impotent gandu pm.

    • @saghirmohammed9735
      @saghirmohammed9735 5 років тому

      @@dhamugohil8034 you lot gonna be jahill all your life india is cursed milk yes been confirmed by the USA and West your own alleys and a legend of lies us midi and his india

    • @dhamugohil8034
      @dhamugohil8034 5 років тому

      @Saghir Mohammed you’ve proved that you’re soovar ki aulad ..

    • @dhamugohil8034
      @dhamugohil8034 5 років тому

      @Saghir Mohammed mashaaaaalah, reward of 72 Dayans awaits you in Jannat ..

  • @jayanthkashyap4467
    @jayanthkashyap4467 4 роки тому

    very nicely done

  • @communicate.anshul
    @communicate.anshul 2 роки тому +1

    No one is questioning whether strike happened or not, even Pak is not denying it. Question is around 300 number which neither any politician has any evidence on nor you talked about. Hence I would say NO, we still dont have anything sufficient enough to claim it as a win

  • @arsigs7090
    @arsigs7090 5 років тому +4

    You have totally confused the issue....you will cover every view point that undones the Indian military success... wake up and remove your curtains.. the sun has shone bright

  • @librielibri2745
    @librielibri2745 5 років тому +7

    I don't know why but I feel all of this is done in poor taste. Sounds more like an undercover Congress spokesperson apologising

    • @manishpant516
      @manishpant516 5 років тому

      This guy was not a formal Congress channel :). This is a confused channel but let them have the liberty.

    • @shantanus80
      @shantanus80 5 років тому +1

      its just a neutral channel

  • @RajeshYadav-kg9ts
    @RajeshYadav-kg9ts 5 років тому

    We are proud of our Indian forces

  • @SanketGarg63
    @SanketGarg63 5 років тому +1

    there is nothing wrong in asking questions but when authorities answer your questions with data and you still doubt them then there is nothing any one can do to convince you and put to rest the questions raised..

  • @bibhu9413
    @bibhu9413 5 років тому +2

    Looking at this person, I'm sure he could not even imagine taking action against pakistan like our iaf did. Then why does he is analysing an attack on the basis of doubt.

  • @coolking8264
    @coolking8264 3 роки тому +3

    I am watching this video after 1.9 years of the incident.
    I am a right winger nationalist.
    We love our country and our defence however truth should be shown to the people without twisting.
    Good analysis !!

  • @firstmanagement1
    @firstmanagement1 5 років тому +1

    We in Pakistan believe that there is no need to destroy India, Modijee is doing a great job at it.

  • @vispelliarmus
    @vispelliarmus 2 роки тому

    Thank you :)

  • @TameTusker
    @TameTusker 5 років тому +6

    He talks with his hands and the tongue and lips emphasize?😊😎😊❤😊

  • @sunilkokrady9063
    @sunilkokrady9063 5 років тому +8

    I also have right to ask a question Sir. Who is paying you to ask such silly questions.

  • @AkshayBAKAYA
    @AkshayBAKAYA 5 років тому

    Have you run your story by independent analysts ? Like Nathan Ruser (ASPI) ? Or Vipin Narang (MIT) ? What do they say ? I'm sure you can contact them easily and discuss the finer points.

  • @chinmayumarji
    @chinmayumarji 4 роки тому +1

    Thanks for all the wonderful Cut the clutters. Please make one on "what makes democracies stronger than the dictatorships."