He seems so sweet! I got my dad to physically read the hunger games trilogy (around when the movie came out) & he audiobooked six of crows, crooked kingdom and the entire hp series!
Zoe's relationship with her father is absolutely precious and I always enjoy his appearances in her videos. I really hope Zoe picks up some of his favourites one day too, I have a feeling she'll appreciate Discworld at least!
every once in a while I come back here. She was a piece of my life and I miss her. Totally understand her, and I think she will never make content again... but you know... hope dies last. We miss you Zoë❤️🩹
So I'm stopping the video at 14 and a half minutes to comment this: OMG I COMPLETELY AGREE WITH ZOE'S DAD! It's not a proper series if each story doesn't end in itself, and one larger story continues through the three books. Its actually just one story broken up into three parts. I really had a problem with the ending of Truly Devious for the very same reason, it was too incomplete.
I agree, every book needs to have a beginning, middle, and an end. They have to have a story in their own right that starts and ends within the confines of the pages, it should never drag on to the next book. It's like if the first Harry Potter book ended before they got to the philosopher's stone, and you had to wait until the sequel for Harry to meet Quirrell/Voldemort.
In the book I also felt like the answers to the mystery just fell right in her lap. Like she would dork around, then poke around, and finally she knew the answer. Just annoyed me.
Lemme just say that Zoe was the person who helped me discover my love for books. Her recs videos were always the ones that I jumped to back then and helped me to discover booktube . I hope she is well and I really wish her the best.
Loved it! Your dad is always mentioning older mistery or sci-fi novels that you don't know, you should switch it around and do a video where he controls your reading week or even a month so you're able to get through more books :)
@George not sure, but she did post a video at some point about coming back and everything, but she must have removed it or privated it... so i think she just decided to move on to other things, or maybe she just needed more time. either way, WE MISS HER!!!
For anyone worrying about her, I bet she just needs a break from the stress of social media. She updated on Goodreads early April, so it hasn't been months without a word. We all miss her, but she will come back when she's ready. ❤
Do whatever you need to do that's best for you Zoe. Your physical/mental health is much more important than UA-cam and even if you just want to move on with your life, thank you for the joy you've brought to me with your content and I'd love more, but I just wish you the best in your future endeavours, whatever they may be and I'm sure your other followers do too!
Zoe got me into reading and I've read so many books because of her. It's become part of my life looking back in it now. Hoping one day she will find the courage to make another video.
If you’re reading this, Zoe, I just want to say you have all the qualities to become a great UA-camr. You’re charismatic, genuine, and make us feel like home every time c: I just hope you’re doing okay, and wish you the best in everything!
I made a comment over a year ago, and came back to check randomly out of thought. I always liked your energy and videos, I really hope you post again one day. :(
Yeah, I'm here to still watching her old videos. I unsubscribed though not because I didn't like her content, but because she just hasn't posted. And I've been a subscriber since 2016. P.S. do any of you guys remember her posting an update video last summer of 2020 or am I tripping? Because I think she deleted it. Let me know.
Someone said on another book tubers page that she messaged one of zoes friends on here and they said that she is fine, she doesn't want to post anymore
Zoe's Dad and Zoe videos are my some of my favorite because yall play off each other so well and I feel like we all learn as a result. This was a cute thing to do on yalls vacation
Someone said on another book tubers page that she messaged one of zoes friends on here and they said that she is fine, she doesn't want to post anymore
I just got addicted to this channel and to see that she doesn't post anymore is really sad...and a little weird. I hope all is well for her and that she'll be back soon.
I wanted to watch some readathons just today in fact just now and you post this video!! My heart is content and also I’ve never been this early to any of your videos
I 100% agree with zoe's dad on truly devious. even if your book is part of a series, the story in one book should still be satisfying even though there's a larger narrative. otherwise it's just frustrating!
I dont think she is gonna return and that's ok. I could be wrong but Hayley mentioned that she's a teacher now. She's been on and off of UA-cam and she is in a new chapter in her life
@@shitfieldsflyingv8354 Thank God I thought I was the only one who remembered that. It was August of 2020. I don't know why she deleted it because I forgot what she said in the video and didn't specify it she would permanently leave youtube.
I think I speak for all of us when I say 'we miss you zoe' please come back, we love watching you and we miss your funny personality, please zoe, come back or at least let us know you're okay, xxx
Just looked you up on UA-cam again since middle school, I am a college freshman now. I just wanted to say that your channel got me into reading and I'm so thankful for it! I hope you are doing well
Hey everyone, I think we should stop commenting about where she is, I know you may concerned but she wouldn’t leave take these breaks for any old reason. She probably needs it :) social media can be very toxic💓💓💓 anyways we love your content 😀
Guys I think she is fine. She has plenty of friends in the booktube community, Im sure if something happened to her they would know about it and would have said something. She's definitely just done with making videos.
2 Readbyzoe video’s in 2 weeks!? It’s a blessing from our booktube gods! Hi Zoe, glad you’re back! Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year to you and your family!❤️
Zoe!! You don’t know how happy I was to wake up to see you had posted a new video!!! I loved seeing your dad reading what you’d picked for him - it’s always a lovely addition when he’s in your vids too! I agree with others who’ve commented that it would be awesome to have you both switch places and for you to read some of his picks!! Thanks for posting today 💕🤗✨
Did you get your love for books from your dad or did he get it from you? Either way, this is the most beautiful family & reader relationship on the planet. 😭 It’s like book club x1,000. We need a Zoe’s Dad booktube.
You have the father every reader wants.
She has the father every PERSON wants
@@tiaan_vd_merwe0392 Yes I totally agree!
every person/reader *NEEDS*
my mom is the same way with reading , not my dad but just as good
He seems so sweet! I got my dad to physically read the hunger games trilogy (around when the movie came out) & he audiobooked six of crows, crooked kingdom and the entire hp series!
Your dad should control what you read for a week too! That would be very interesting (:
Mara I second this!
Yeah I third this
I fourth! I think this would be so awesome!!!
I would love that sm!!
i fifth this
Now you have to read your Dad's 5 star books!!!!
Yess!
@@jessicablack I hope she sees this!!
OMG yes Zoe plz👏🏻👏🏻💃🏻💃🏻
Let’s make this the top comment!!!!!
Yes, pls!
Zoe’s Dad was named “Zoe’s Dad” straight from his birth.
haha
😂
Zoe's relationship with her father is absolutely precious and I always enjoy his appearances in her videos. I really hope Zoe picks up some of his favourites one day too, I have a feeling she'll appreciate Discworld at least!
Couldn’t agree more 🧡
It's been almost 4 years 😔 Miss you so much, girl.
Your dad seems like the nicest and sweetest person ever
Okay, but when are we getting an official readbydad channel 😂
ReadathonbyDad XD
*readbyzoë's dad
every once in a while I come back here. She was a piece of my life and I miss her. Totally understand her, and I think she will never make content again... but you know... hope dies last. We miss you Zoë❤️🩹
What happened?
What happened to her
what happened? i miss zoe…
@@gabrielleporter553 I think she quit
Has anybody heard fron Zoe i miss her on youtube
Petition for Zoe’s dad to start a booktube channel!
I would sign it!
Yass
Sheesh it's been 2 years and I still check to see if shes uploaded
Me too ❤
Same here 💔
Same. I miss Zoe so much. I hope she's ok out there. ❤
Same
Same
So I'm stopping the video at 14 and a half minutes to comment this: OMG I COMPLETELY AGREE WITH ZOE'S DAD! It's not a proper series if each story doesn't end in itself, and one larger story continues through the three books. Its actually just one story broken up into three parts.
I really had a problem with the ending of Truly Devious for the very same reason, it was too incomplete.
I agree, every book needs to have a beginning, middle, and an end. They have to have a story in their own right that starts and ends within the confines of the pages, it should never drag on to the next book. It's like if the first Harry Potter book ended before they got to the philosopher's stone, and you had to wait until the sequel for Harry to meet Quirrell/Voldemort.
@@Tay-wj9et EXACTLY.
Same
In the book I also felt like the answers to the mystery just fell right in her lap. Like she would dork around, then poke around, and finally she knew the answer. Just annoyed me.
I agree too! Didn’t like the ending at all
Lemme just say that Zoe was the person who helped me discover my love for books. Her recs videos were always the ones that I jumped to back then and helped me to discover booktube . I hope she is well and I really wish her the best.
Loved it! Your dad is always mentioning older mistery or sci-fi novels that you don't know, you should switch it around and do a video where he controls your reading week or even a month so you're able to get through more books :)
Don’t worry guys, Zoe still updates on Goodreads. I hope she is okay! Maybe she’s just busy. We miss you Zoe!
Do you know what happened she hasn’t been posting in a year?
@@madi8460 I do not.😔 She’s probably just busy.
omg I was getting worried..I hope she's okay. *sighs*
@@madi8460 Zoe is in grad school right now and its probably very time consuming.
@George not sure, but she did post a video at some point about coming back and everything, but she must have removed it or privated it... so i think she just decided to move on to other things, or maybe she just needed more time. either way, WE MISS HER!!!
For anyone worrying about her, I bet she just needs a break from the stress of social media. She updated on Goodreads early April, so it hasn't been months without a word. We all miss her, but she will come back when she's ready. ❤
@Farrah Acosta there is a link in her bio
Do whatever you need to do that's best for you Zoe. Your physical/mental health is much more important than UA-cam and even if you just want to move on with your life, thank you for the joy you've brought to me with your content and I'd love more, but I just wish you the best in your future endeavours, whatever they may be and I'm sure your other followers do too!
I think everyone agrees
yesss ❤
i miss zoe literally a comfort book tuber
I hope you’re doing good Zoe. Rewatching your videos is my favorite
I'm not going to get up 8 it was after I
girly we miss you so damn much. I've been watching you since I was like 14 and I'm turning 21 this year. hope you're okay
Its been 5 years and I still watch your videos. I hope youre doing well, Zoe❤
Can't believe it's already been 2 years since we last saw her
Fr
Yeah. Does anyone know if she’s okay?
@@EllaMorgan1031 I wanna know that too
It’s been 4 years since she’s last uploaded. I hope she’s doing okay
Zoe got me into reading and I've read so many books because of her. It's become part of my life looking back in it now. Hoping one day she will find the courage to make another video.
Do you know why she stopped posting?
@@NovaKestis no why
If you’re reading this, Zoe, I just want to say you have all the qualities to become a great UA-camr. You’re charismatic, genuine, and make us feel like home every time c: I just hope you’re doing okay, and wish you the best in everything!
It is absolutely sweet and beautiful to watch both of you. You are so lucky to have each other. Take care of you.
Can’t believe it’s been 2 years, the book tube community needs your bright light back :) stay well
EVERY VIDEO WITH YOUR DAD IS GOLD
I miss her videos 🥹💗
it's been 3 years and I am still here. I hope she and her loved ones are well.
I made a comment over a year ago, and came back to check randomly out of thought. I always liked your energy and videos, I really hope you post again one day. :(
Yeah, I'm here to still watching her old videos. I unsubscribed though not because I didn't like her content, but because she just hasn't posted. And I've been a subscriber since 2016.
P.S. do any of you guys remember her posting an update video last summer of 2020 or am I tripping? Because I think she deleted it. Let me know.
@@123_matthew1 I heard that she uploaded 2 update videos but deleted them
Someone said on another book tubers page that she messaged one of zoes friends on here and they said that she is fine, she doesn't want to post anymore
@@123_matthew1 Hi, not sure about that one, but she deleted the halloween themed readathon :'(
Miss this girl right here 👆🏼 hoping one day she comes back 💕💕💕
Zoe's Dad and Zoe videos are my some of my favorite because yall play off each other so well and I feel like we all learn as a result. This was a cute thing to do on yalls vacation
Patiently waiting for Zoe to upload again. I miss the readathons you do..
I agree, me too 😔💔
Maaan imagine having this kind of relationship with your dad
Samuel M I KNOW
Girl where are youuuu we miss you and your videos and your dad :( I really hope you're all doing okay
Someone said on another book tubers page that she messaged one of zoes friends on here and they said that she is fine, she doesn't want to post anymore
@@misswhite2171 who did say that?
@@acerina141 clockwork_reads told the girl that.
I miss her so much, she was so motivating and inspiring for me … Waiting for you Zoë
I think she’s done with the internet. Her Twitter account says she no longer uses it Twitter and she has deleted all of her tweets
I just got addicted to this channel and to see that she doesn't post anymore is really sad...and a little weird. I hope all is well for her and that she'll be back soon.
Ikr I started watching her a few years ago and show has slowly been delaying some of her videos, and hasn’t posted for over a year now
We love and miss you Zoe! I hope you're taking a well-deserved mental health break and are being kind to your amazing self!!
Your dad is so cool, mine doesn’t read at all. The only reason I got him to read the hunger games series is because he lost a bet to me 😂
I love the relationship you and your dad have! How cool that y’all are both readers with similar tastes, every readers dream!
I wanted to watch some readathons just today in fact just now and you post this video!! My heart is content and also I’ve never been this early to any of your videos
It’s been 4 years, 😢 hope she and her family r well 💖 I miss so much her videos 😢😢😢
I love how easy going your dad is and how willing he was to read all these books! The Tea Dragon Society even! How great!
You could pop up on our UA-cam with a new video tomorrow and we’d always come back, old friend. Miss you! ❤️
I love your dad he seems so sweet ahhh
Your dad is so precious omg!
your dad is literally one of my favourite people on this earth no joke lol
You have a precious relationship with your father.
ZOE HAS POSTED A VIDEO! MUST THROW EVERYTHING DOWN!
Literally me 🤣
I miss her so much rn.
especially now :/
@@CDNL. yeah I just thought of her!(
Yeah me too 😫
wait is she done with yt forever?!
Me too 💔
I love seeing the relationship you have with you father it's so heart warming and special you're very lucky 😊💜
I 100% agree with zoe's dad on truly devious. even if your book is part of a series, the story in one book should still be satisfying even though there's a larger narrative. otherwise it's just frustrating!
I think it'd be really cool if you read all of your dad's favourites.
I also love sharing books with my dad! I’d love to see a follow up of this video where your dad chooses books for you to read!
You really made my teen years, I hope you’re doing well ❤
I remember this video was 3 months ago then 5 months then 6 months and now i see 1 year ago we miss you Zoe
it's soon going to be two years
I remember when she uploaded it! I was like Yay, a new video! It's gonna complete two years now...
Hi Zoe, I hope everything is fine. Just wanted to say we all miss you, please take care.
Your dad is so wholesome and this is already adorable💖💖
this is actually the sweetest thing
I dont think she is gonna return and that's ok. I could be wrong but Hayley mentioned that she's a teacher now. She's been on and off of UA-cam and she is in a new chapter in her life
@Patricia-xw3ns it was in a q&a
@@Alittlebitofeverything29 What video specifically did she mention it?"
@@teresaeskra it was years ago. Can't remember specifically just know if was aq&a
ms girl really said 'I did it once and ill do it again.'
Your Dad is the absolute SWEETEST! I just adore him
Guys chill she’s alive and well. She’s been active on Twitter and instagram. But please upload
Thanks for telling, I don’t have Twitter 🙏
Deepika Chandra no problem
I am concerned now because she has been gone for over a year now
She did post some videos then she deleted them :(
I'm really concerned too
@@shitfieldsflyingv8354 Thank God I thought I was the only one who remembered that. It was August of 2020. I don't know why she deleted it because I forgot what she said in the video and didn't specify it she would permanently leave youtube.
@@123_matthew1 I just remember she said she got rid of her Harry Potter merch, but I don't remember the rest of the video neither...
I think I speak for all of us when I say 'we miss you zoe' please come back, we love watching you and we miss your funny personality, please zoe, come back or at least let us know you're okay, xxx
i miss your uploads zoe i hope youre doing well! just gonna keep rewatching 24 hour readathons for now
Hope you're okay, Zoe! Can't wait for you to be back but take your time
Just looked you up on UA-cam again since middle school, I am a college freshman now. I just wanted to say that your channel got me into reading and I'm so thankful for it! I hope you are doing well
Hey everyone, I think we should stop commenting about where she is, I know you may concerned but she wouldn’t leave take these breaks for any old reason. She probably needs it :) social media can be very toxic💓💓💓 anyways we love your content 😀
it does show how much her viewers care for her!! she really is the sweetest booktuber, i hope she comes back to yt when she’s ready 🧚🏽♀️
When I see your Dad, I miss mine so much, but I'm also so happy for you two! Your relationship is so precious! I love to see that in your videos
SHES BACK FOR MORE.... ITS ZOE!!!!
Guys I think she is fine. She has plenty of friends in the booktube community, Im sure if something happened to her they would know about it and would have said something. She's definitely just done with making videos.
I agree with your dad on the dystopian comment
where are you
we miss you and your smile
i hope every thing is right
love you
I would LOVE to see your dad's journey through the whole twilight series! I know it wld be incredible! Xo
I miss you Zoe❤ I hope she is Okay.
2 Readbyzoe video’s in 2 weeks!? It’s a blessing from our booktube gods! Hi Zoe, glad you’re back! Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year to you and your family!❤️
We miss you Zoe 😭
Who wants Zoe to do a valentine's edition Read-a-thon
o god. he just makes me smile. i love yalls energy its so.. fairy tale. the relationship a lot of people dream of having with their father i love it
Your dad is sooo nice
I miss you every now and then, Zoe. I hope you're doing well ❤️
Miss you Zoe! Wherever you are and whatever you are doing, hope you are well and happy!!😊😊
Zoe’s dad losing his glasses a few seconds in had me doing a double take!
Love these two 😍
Zoe!! You don’t know how happy I was to wake up to see you had posted a new video!!! I loved seeing your dad reading what you’d picked for him - it’s always a lovely addition when he’s in your vids too! I agree with others who’ve commented that it would be awesome to have you both switch places and for you to read some of his picks!! Thanks for posting today 💕🤗✨
She took down 2 of her other videos... hope she’s okay
Me too!
Did you get your love for books from your dad or did he get it from you? Either way, this is the most beautiful family & reader relationship on the planet. 😭 It’s like book club x1,000.
We need a Zoe’s Dad booktube.
Returned to see if she’s uploaded
i love your relationship so much, your videos with him make me miss my dad 😭 treasure him zoe he's great
Girlll!! Come back!! Loved ur videos❤🎉❤
Your dad is a hoot and your guy's relationship is so cute and hilarious!!
Such a wholesome video. We miss you, Zoe ❤️
They are so happy and genuine that I catch myself smiling during the video! She’s my favorite booktuber right now.
I MISS U ZOE!!!
Missing your videos. Hope all is well
Zoe: Well, you’re a tab bit older than I am.
Zoe’s dad: I hope so!🤣
I miss you sm, Zoe☹️ I hope you are having a good life❤❤❤
Today I randomly had a dream she posted a new video lol, it had a blue thumbnail and i think she was dressed as a witch
I miss you, Zoe. Hopefully, you are doing well. Please take good care!