Shellac - Dude Incredible ALBUM REVIEW

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 сер 2024
  • Listen: • Shellac - Dude Incredible
    The new Shellac album is decent, but falls disappointingly short of the reaction "Dude, incredible!"
    More rock reviews: bit.ly/1odjtw5
    Subscribe: bit.ly/1pBqGCN
    Official site: theneedledrop.com
    TND Twitter: / theneedledrop
    TND Facebook: / theneedledrop
    Support TND: theneedledrop.com/support
    FAV TRACKS: DUDE INCREDIBLE, RIDING BIKES, THE PEOPLE'S MICROPHONE, ALL THE SURVEYORS
    LEAST FAV TRACK: MAYOR / SURVEYOR
    SHELLAC - DUDE INCREDIBLE / 2014 / TOUCH AND GO / POST-HARDCORE, MATH ROCK, NOISE ROCK
    6/10
    Y'all know this is just my opinion, right? What did you think of this album? Love it? Hate it? Why? What should I review next, eh?

КОМЕНТАРІ • 284

  • @ericseguin8941
    @ericseguin8941 9 років тому +125

    AND THEY WERE SQUIRRELS.... REAL SQUIRRELS... THIS ISN'T SOME KIND OF METAPHOR, GODDAMN! THIS IS REAL...

    • @ericseguin8941
      @ericseguin8941 7 років тому

      R u seriously trolling me for an awesome comment!? Dude Incredible~!

    • @golden-sun
      @golden-sun 7 років тому

      Eric Séguin whats the reference? Hit me wit it baby

    • @aryasuri9421
      @aryasuri9421 5 років тому +7

      @@golden-sun Squirrel Song off the album 1000 Hurts

    • @WH0R3mones1
      @WH0R3mones1 5 років тому +22

      This is a saaaaaaaaad fucking song

    • @playstationskate345
      @playstationskate345 5 років тому +8

      Faintly Like be lucky if i don't BUST OUT CRYIN!

  • @blobmarlis6180
    @blobmarlis6180 9 років тому +74

    No way is this album worth a 6/10. 'Tis an 8/10 at least.

  • @asinglebraincell6584
    @asinglebraincell6584 4 роки тому +27

    I kinda want to hear Steve Albini produce a Death Grips record.

  • @kennyfairneny9048
    @kennyfairneny9048 9 років тому +31

    this album hits the fucking spot for me honestly

  • @AnonymousAccount514
    @AnonymousAccount514 2 місяці тому +5

    RIP Steve

  • @juicykisses78
    @juicykisses78 8 років тому +40

    This shit's good what r u talkingbout mang

  • @LightStorm33
    @LightStorm33 9 років тому +51

    You have given 99% of the albums in the past couple months 6/10

    • @LightStorm33
      @LightStorm33 9 років тому

      ***** I know im just pointing it out

    • @raoulduke2924
      @raoulduke2924 9 років тому +8

      Uncommon Nasa, Perfume Genius, Yung Lean, Bus Driver, Julian Casablancas, FKA Twigs, Mick Jenkins... I guess these albums don't count..... It should also be of note that if Anthony doesn't find something enjoyable he often won't even review it hence the Y U No review videos. And I don't see what your point is about him giving 6/10 more often that other scores. What IS your point?

    • @pieroscaruffi7429
      @pieroscaruffi7429 9 років тому +2

      Raoul Duke An observation need not have a point.

    • @MFMEME
      @MFMEME 9 років тому

      Raoul Duke "Yung Lean"
      Fantano loved Unknown Memory?

    • @TheMightyMills
      @TheMightyMills 9 років тому

      it's not his fault this has been a shitty year for music.

  • @Icantdothatrightnow
    @Icantdothatrightnow 8 років тому +41

    I honestly think Dude Incredible is Albini's best musical effort, not just as Shellac but as a musician.

    • @TheRavenEffect88
      @TheRavenEffect88 8 років тому +9

      Have you heard Atomizer? As much of a fan as I am of Steve's work post Big Black. I don't know of anything that has topped that albums.

    • @Icantdothatrightnow
      @Icantdothatrightnow 8 років тому +5

      Wrath99 Atomizer just doesn't do it for me personally. I've listened to it extensively and I'm still waiting for it to grow on me more than it has. I much prefer Songs About Fucking as far as Big Black albums go.

    • @peteradams136
      @peteradams136 6 років тому +1

      I agree, and I am old, I remember when Atomizer, etc came out. This is better. Atomizer can be a strong second.

    • @peteradams8151
      @peteradams8151 6 років тому

      I grew up with Big Black being the band in Chicago, but this album tops all of it

    • @vesuvius1968
      @vesuvius1968 5 років тому +9

      Two Nuns and a Pack Mule fucking shreds. Just Got Paid is my favorite cover ever

  • @pelodelperro
    @pelodelperro 9 років тому +36

    GODFLESH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @oskarpetureinarsson3880
    @oskarpetureinarsson3880 9 років тому +16

    One of Shellac's best and therefore one of the best albums of the year. Much leaner than their messy Excellent Italian Greyhound. I guess a Godflesh review is comin' up...

  • @porcelina5834
    @porcelina5834 2 роки тому +4

    The youtube algorithm has a sick sense of humor; this was recommended to me when I discovered that Shellac's entire discography has vanished from spotify. And the fact that Anthony gave this a 6/10 was just adding salt to the wound.

  • @user-pn1zs6df7r
    @user-pn1zs6df7r 11 місяців тому +2

    I think we can all agree that this is one of his poorly aged reviews. This record is a banger of a late career output.

  • @Acquiex
    @Acquiex 9 років тому +6

    1:42 - 1:58
    Haha Anthony, did you forget to choose which one of those two takes you liked better?

  • @jeffreybarton1297
    @jeffreybarton1297 Рік тому +3

    The more I listen to this album, the more I think it's one of their best. 8 out of 10.

  • @DruideStick
    @DruideStick 9 років тому +5

    but this isn't flying lotus

  • @agingcomfortably
    @agingcomfortably 8 років тому +5

    I thought Surveyors was fucking hilarious

  • @wirechase
    @wirechase 9 років тому

    Recent subscriber. Man, I love your reviews and your videos on your vinyl collection. Keep up the good work!

  • @user-lh2uu3tl8b
    @user-lh2uu3tl8b 9 років тому +2

    i didn't think "mayor/ surveyor" was half baked. i think is a really awesome interlude song. i would be so psyched to write a guitar riff that sick. and the bass part is really cool how it compliments the guitar.

  • @dragline78
    @dragline78 9 років тому +2

    Glad you reviewed it! It's not Action Park, or 1000 Hurts, but it's an improvement over Excellent Italian Greyhound, which felt really flat to me, although it sounded much better live. I enjoyed this album a lot. I don't think Shellac are really into reinventing themselves - they do what they do, on their own terms, when they feel motivated to do it. I'm happy they still feel like making music and sharing it. *cough*Fugazi*cough* And All the Surveyors has enough Albini vitriol to keep me going for a while!

  • @Theraulespinosa
    @Theraulespinosa 9 років тому +6

    I love this new Shallac album!! Do more reviews of band like this!

    • @playstationskate345
      @playstationskate345 5 років тому +3

      hey man this is an old comment, but if you like albums like this, you should check out "Songs about Fucking" by Big Black, "Goat" by The Jesus Lizard, and "New Plastic Ideas" by Unwound

  • @Aubry92
    @Aubry92 9 років тому +1

    Between 5:35 and 5:36, did anyone notice when Anthony said "expecting," his head appeared to jerk back so instantaneously that it seemed like he cut like maybe a half-seconds-worth of content in between the displacement of where his head was and where it ended up? Like, I get that there's an editing process to these videos, but have they always been that subtly beautiful all the time? 'Cuz he still utters the word so fluidly, it makes me wonder if that's how the human body has always seemed to work. Creeped out.

  • @playstationskate345
    @playstationskate345 5 років тому +3

    old fantano comment sections weren't that pretty either but it's refreshing as hell to not see "nice review anthony but ~insert racist/homophobic epitaph/dark scenario here~" and other types of memes.

  • @xTheOxx
    @xTheOxx 9 років тому +6

    Hand over hand over hand over hand over

  • @dannyxuco
    @dannyxuco 9 років тому +2

    I'm a big fan of theirs, I say 7.5, I'm glad you reviewed it. "Riding Bikes" is my favorite although "All The Surveyors" is great too, "Who walks the kings road?, Who walks the kings road? Fuck the King!", hilarious.

  • @Weifs
    @Weifs 9 років тому +10

    Dudethany Increditano

  • @charlieturner6938
    @charlieturner6938 9 років тому +3

    Anthony. I've seen you wearing that shirt. I want that shirt, bro. I want to wear it. Help me out.
    Also, people calling Shellac "new music that no one has ever heard of" is splitting my sides just a little.
    Keep up the good work!

    • @HerbaceousM8
      @HerbaceousM8 9 років тому

      never heard of them here. i live in western Canada

  • @tMatt5M
    @tMatt5M 9 років тому +8

    Edgey shirt

  • @kallekristensen6067
    @kallekristensen6067 9 років тому +14

    FLYING LOTUS.

    • @icytides
      @icytides 9 років тому

      Kalle kristensen I'm sensing it's either gonna be a something-6 or a light 9. If it's the former then that would be the weakest review of the album to come out anywhere so far

    • @kallekristensen6067
      @kallekristensen6067 9 років тому

      tomujio True, he's probaly gonna continue his 6-rating streak tbh, it's actually pretty impressive how many albums that have gotten a 6-rating this year, good job Fantanatanandan.

    • @heymynamesbrett
      @heymynamesbrett 9 років тому

      Kalle kristensen He called it FlyLo's "Bitches Brew" so I'm guessing he will give it a completely positive review

    • @MattMacdonald1989
      @MattMacdonald1989 9 років тому

      Brett Rys It's super fucking jazzy. I am definitely diggin' it.

    • @RayasNegroOvejas
      @RayasNegroOvejas 9 років тому +1

      Matt Macdonald As someone who loves jazz, I didn't think that it was "super fucking jazz" at all on my first listen. Cosmograma have moments that's jazzier. But I will obviously listen again, so I will see then.

  • @RobotJQ
    @RobotJQ 9 років тому

    Thanks for bringing this album to my attention, Mr. Concierto.

  • @JimDarkmagicThe4th
    @JimDarkmagicThe4th 6 років тому +1

    I love that you have in on the kill taker in background. That being an album Albini initually produced, but both Fugazi and Albini agreed his style didnt fit their sound.

  • @NadaCero
    @NadaCero 9 років тому +8

    Trollthany 6Tano

  • @sirspookington
    @sirspookington 9 років тому +3

    woah, detracting from the album for "muffled vocals" yet the vocals on "At Action Park" don't sound "muffled" to you? song of the minerals is one of my favorite songs and i still can't make out what the fuck bob says after feldspar, the vocals are definitely "muffled" on AAP, but AAP is amazing either way.

  • @LA-nx4fv
    @LA-nx4fv 9 років тому +1

    The new Zola Jesus album : "Taiga" .
    Hee hee.
    I'm also very excited for "Blue" (Iamamiwhoami)

  • @OnlyToZo
    @OnlyToZo 9 років тому +1

    will you review the new orange goblin album, back from the abyss ?

  • @sodomywithsaws1
    @sodomywithsaws1 9 років тому +4

    HEY ANTHONY HOW ABOUT PICKING A NUMBER BESIDES 6 FOR ONCE. JESUS CHRIST

    • @usernameof5
      @usernameof5 9 років тому

      He gave the new Perfume Genius album an 8 a few days ago.

  • @xndoeable
    @xndoeable 9 років тому

    im excited for your FlyLo's album review. (if you review it!) For some reason i get the impression you'll either give it something average like a strong 6 or you'll love it and give it like a strong 8

  • @nickelcityrider5431
    @nickelcityrider5431 9 років тому

    Anthony, love your reviews. Big fan. Could you please review the new Aaron Freeman album: Freeman? Thanks for your consideration.

  • @Dan_Coffeeman97
    @Dan_Coffeeman97 9 років тому +3

    Kayo Dot - Coffins on Io!
    It's up for streaming, aswell.

  • @MaTaNhy
    @MaTaNhy 9 років тому +2

    the best album of this year.
    you crazy fantano, you need to get in the mod and give it a few more listens.

  • @AdolfStalin
    @AdolfStalin 6 років тому

    nice Fugazi record in the background

  • @HerbaceousM8
    @HerbaceousM8 9 років тому +1

    album: Caribou's Our Love.
    also: Electric Wizard's latest

  • @redshaftedflicker
    @redshaftedflicker 9 років тому

    At Action Park, "a pretty significant album." You were born about the time that AAP came out.

    • @DadaPoopoo
      @DadaPoopoo 7 років тому +1

      redshaftedflicker That's a really good point. Thanks for sharing!

  • @1985cactus
    @1985cactus 9 років тому +2

    Strong 6? The fuck does this dude smokes? This is the best Shellac album and easily the best album of the year!

    • @1985cactus
      @1985cactus 9 років тому +3

      Wulbulbul Lubbubwublub
      maybe even twice, he doesn't remember

    • @AlbinWest
      @AlbinWest 9 років тому

      1985cactus so... this is better than 1000 Hurts?

    • @1985cactus
      @1985cactus 9 років тому +2

      AlbinWest
      For me definitely. It has no bad songs, song that make you wanna push the "next song button". It is perfection from the first to the last second. And the sound of the drums never sounded so good.

    • @o.binwheelie9733
      @o.binwheelie9733 8 років тому

      I swear I've met you on UA-cam before

  • @AnonymousAccount514
    @AnonymousAccount514 4 роки тому +2

    You should do “At Action Park”

  • @OileabhearMacAodh
    @OileabhearMacAodh 9 років тому

    Hey Antony are you going to give the new primordial album a listen? It's been a while since you have reviewed an irish band

  • @MrMattaiusify
    @MrMattaiusify 9 років тому +1

    When will the Alt - J review be out? :)
    Really enjoy your content btw :D

  • @quentinmcbullwinkle9805
    @quentinmcbullwinkle9805 9 років тому

    Eggthony - Do you write raps?

  • @sunsetsoverlavenderfields
    @sunsetsoverlavenderfields 9 років тому

    Mayor/Surveyor was the only track I was a bit disappointed in. I've had at least one riff from the album stuck in my head each day since release though. I don't think it's just a continuation of their style though. It's not a huge departure, but a lot of the riffs seem much more melodic and groovy this time around.

  • @stremboi2531
    @stremboi2531 9 років тому

    Where did you get that nice t-shirt, Anthony?

  • @Cudder17
    @Cudder17 9 років тому +1

    where the fuck is that flying lotus review

  • @kinggg376
    @kinggg376 9 років тому +3

    Review Godflesh, tony!

  • @Bakutakamine
    @Bakutakamine 9 років тому +1

    HA you ran out! You've done Symphony Concerto before! I remember cuz it was my favorite xD I knew this day would come

  • @zeromono3280
    @zeromono3280 9 років тому +2

    review VHS Head's trademark ribbons of gold please

  • @paulboggan
    @paulboggan 9 років тому +1

    Antony. On first listen i was... meh. Its a good shellac record. On the subsequent listens ive found it impossible to remove from my cd player.....
    As all their albums its greatness comes with repeated listens...
    Love it

  • @Cykelpump33
    @Cykelpump33 9 років тому +6

    Review You're Dead!!! Much better then that crappy Aphex Twin album!

    • @clanderdrums
      @clanderdrums 9 років тому +1

      You're Dead is so awesome, but Aphex Twin's new album was pretty cool too. Just not his best by any means.

    • @Acquiex
      @Acquiex 9 років тому

      Christian Molander
      Yeah not his best, but I still enjoy it more than You're Dead

  • @icytides
    @icytides 9 років тому +1

    Anthony i know that cosmogramma grew on you like it did with everyone else, so make sure you give the new flylo an incredibly good listen before assigning that bad boy jazz fusion masterwork a score

  • @bdtcomedy2
    @bdtcomedy2 9 років тому

    Bass Drum Of Death came out with a new album today called "Rip This." I only heard of them because they performed with MellowHype on FuelTV. Will you do a review on that?

  • @shPEKtro
    @shPEKtro 9 років тому

    Vince Staples - Hell Can Wait

  • @themachineeatsitself
    @themachineeatsitself 8 років тому

    I agree with you 100%. I just wish the band had put in one big song to sorta anchor the album down, as they attempted to do with the title track. Either way. Not bad.

  • @DJILLWITHERS
    @DJILLWITHERS 9 років тому

    What should you review next you ask? Art Official Age and Plectrum Electrum.

  • @CheckAvailabilityYo
    @CheckAvailabilityYo 4 місяці тому +1

    Not enough fan service for Fantanno.

  • @underneonloneliness2
    @underneonloneliness2 9 років тому +7

    Review weezers new album

  • @jvsc7876
    @jvsc7876 3 роки тому +1

    What is you opinion on Don Caballero ?

  • @KoopaFuhrer
    @KoopaFuhrer 9 років тому +12

    Kauai and Stn Mtn by childish gambino

    • @Krossytetsuo
      @Krossytetsuo 9 років тому +4

      Why? He doesn't like Gambino.

    • @thebekg2050
      @thebekg2050 9 років тому

      Kris Kross He'll still review it. He reviewed his other stuff.

    • @StudioScarecrow
      @StudioScarecrow 9 років тому

      Why would you want to see him say the same thing he's said about Gambino fifty times already? Especially while reviewing a release that's not nearly as good as Because the Internet (which I loved, btw)?

    • @pieroscaruffi7429
      @pieroscaruffi7429 9 років тому

      Leavemealoneabout Usingmyname Hot onions

    • @KoopaFuhrer
      @KoopaFuhrer 9 років тому +1

      Leavemealoneabout Usingmyname Because the internet is a master piece

  • @ChibiChihiro
    @ChibiChihiro 9 років тому

    Could you review the new drum"s Album that came out in mid September.

  • @jonahellert7460
    @jonahellert7460 9 років тому

    This has everything a good review should have, one of needledrop's best so far. All points valid. I like the album alot more though, the songs are very unpredictable. Vocals are so far back they remind me of Kyuss.

  • @ElianCepero
    @ElianCepero 9 років тому +1

    Vince staples- hell can wait

  • @shortmorgan_
    @shortmorgan_ 9 років тому

    you gotta gotta review You're Dead! and Vince Staples new EP

  • @regisgw
    @regisgw 9 років тому +1

    Is the altj review coming Symphony?

  • @jacobb978
    @jacobb978 6 років тому +1

    HAMBURGER HAMBURGER HAMBURGER HAMBURGER

  • @ThatGuyNamedTim
    @ThatGuyNamedTim 9 років тому

    Will you review the You+Me record?

  • @kmmk292929
    @kmmk292929 6 років тому

    can you review Omni's album, Multi-Task, or Deluxe

  • @Josbi
    @Josbi 9 років тому +2

    review that new gambino mixtape fantano... you know you want to

    • @derrickd3226
      @derrickd3226 9 років тому +2

      You can already see the light 3 coming.

  • @23SourGirl
    @23SourGirl 9 років тому

    Maybe I just didn't look hard enough, but have you reviewed any albums by ...And You Will Know Us By The Trail Of Dead? I agree with your assessments that Dude Incredible and Coffins On Io are two underwhelming albums from incredible bands (Shellac and Kayo Dot respectively), but I want to know if you also agree that ...Trail Of Dead's new album IX is a similar case of a great band releasing a a meh album.

  • @xxxWolFangxxx
    @xxxWolFangxxx 9 років тому

    Review Electric Wizard, Liturgy, and Nachtmystium! Gotta catch up on yo metal son

  • @Dabxgunna21
    @Dabxgunna21 9 років тому +1

    Review Vince Staples- Hell Can Wait EP

  • @SamShadow93
    @SamShadow93 9 років тому

    Godflesh - A World Lit Only by Fire

  • @Hotsauceonmy
    @Hotsauceonmy 9 років тому

    Where's the reviews for You're Dead, Wonder Where We Land, and STNMTN/ Kauai. (It's cool if you don't do Gambino, I don't need my heart broken)

  • @TomasLNannestad
    @TomasLNannestad 9 років тому

    Dude! Incredible album rewiew! (Had to do that cx )

  • @CunningCondor
    @CunningCondor 7 років тому

    Is it "Sh'lack" or "Shellack"?

  • @AndTheMonster
    @AndTheMonster 9 років тому +1

    Single Mothers - Negative Qualities, but only review it if you listen to their self-titled 4 track ep first.

  • @DevinreviewsUK
    @DevinreviewsUK 9 років тому +1

    Please don't overlook the new SBTRKT record.
    also check out a band called hate fuck, I think you might dig it, lo-fi, super gnarly grindy post-hardcore

  • @aka_jr
    @aka_jr 9 років тому

    Hey Anthony, I imagine you're going to do the new Flying Lotus album, but what's your quick two cents on it before you post the video? I can't stop listening to Coronus, the Terminator and Dead Man's Tetris xD

  • @metalsabatico
    @metalsabatico 9 років тому +2

    You're Dead when? also why didn't you review Electric Balloon by Ava Luna?

  • @jjs8426
    @jjs8426 5 років тому +1

    Nah you're wrong my guy but feel free to think what you want :)

  • @redmenacetv
    @redmenacetv 6 років тому +1

    Hamburger, hamburger, hamburger, hamburger.

  • @angelcardenas8412
    @angelcardenas8412 9 років тому

    Midnight No Mercy for Mayhem

  • @emilkari3719
    @emilkari3719 9 років тому

    PLOWING INTO THE FIELD OF LOVE!!

  • @navigatingmadness180
    @navigatingmadness180 9 років тому +2

    You're Dead! and Wonder Where We Land pleeeeease!

  • @subterracollecter
    @subterracollecter 9 років тому

    Still waiting for the new Alt J review.

  • @romuhhh
    @romuhhh 9 років тому

    Review Vince Staples - Hell can wait

  • @SpeedyOrtiz700
    @SpeedyOrtiz700 9 років тому +1

    Weezer- Everything Will Be Alright In The End

  • @CreepyPixelGuy
    @CreepyPixelGuy 9 років тому +2

    Plez review Flying Lotus' new album :)

  • @emiliocontreras2841
    @emiliocontreras2841 4 роки тому

    Cmon anthony. You know you love this thing more than you did.

  • @arkhitekton1
    @arkhitekton1 9 років тому

    i enjoyed this album a lot more than i expected but the vocals do sound a little recessed, kind of a bummer

  • @krampster2
    @krampster2 9 років тому

    Ohhhh, he said the 'f' word!
    That's fucking crazy.

  • @guycomments
    @guycomments 9 років тому

    Shellac is still alive?

  • @terrysilvester4720
    @terrysilvester4720 9 років тому +3

    Iceage, weezer, alt j pleaseee

  • @skeletalmesh9872
    @skeletalmesh9872 9 років тому

    Oh. I thought it was pronounced "shee-lack".
    The moar you know.

  • @noslen2010
    @noslen2010 9 років тому +1

    HELL CAN WAIT BY VINCENT STAPLES