What can I say except a big thank you to you Sherv. I appreciated you sharing these Coltrane albums that I was completely unaware of before. Top notch presentation as well~ Rob/Boston
The only one I can check in with is Selflessness but this was a cool run through. I do love the version Alice does with Charlie Haden and Pranesh Khan on the Berkeley bootleg from 72. That one is quite lush.
Hey again Sherv, Good to see you back. For sure, always nice being inspired by talks with friends, indeed...one of our favorite ones... 🙂Coltrane with Dolphy...sounds almost overwhelming in the best way. Am reminded that I've meant to replace my own copy of My Favorite Things. I really want to hear that one with Alice and Pharaoh and Offering...actually anything with Roy Haynes sparks my interest as well...A very nice cozy hangout as always here. 🙂 Glad to see you, again. -Carm
yeah, the Coltrane Dolphy combo can take ones breath away... l hope there's more of them together in the vaults to be put out... the live at the Vanguard Again might be right up your street Carm....
l don't think he did much, was on a couple of Alice records and a few other things but fell off the scene, maybe due to health reasons? it still baffles me that he died in 76
Shervin, Jim may be getting older, but he's also getting wiser. He deserves another Hendrix tee- shirt for inspiring this video. The Grateful Dead have so many easily available live recordings. I always found it interesting to talk to Deadheads about their favorite live version of a Dead tune. Their long strange trip makes it more fun, was it a version from the 60's, the 70's, the 80's , or the 90's. Coltrane's live performance career was of course, much shorter, so I never thought about Jim's Question.The version on ''Offering'' is also my top choice, Alice's piano is amazing and the sole bass player, Sonny Johnson gives a nice long solo intro to the song. The ''One Down, One Up'' version comes in at number two, Tyner and Jones create their own separate magic together, and with the full group as well!
once again l realize l missed some stuff during this.. l failed to mention Sonny Thompson on offering and didn't say anything about Alice's piano playing.... if l was talking to a deadhead l would ask what's your favorite live version of Stella Blue... and dammit that One Up One Down is really starting to bug me, like the one that got away
@@juliusjabbar1011 Shervin, the bass player, Sonny Johnson was Dewey Johnson's brother. I assume Coltrane chose Sonny because he was friendly with Dewey. ''Stella Blue'', live from Lexington, April,21, 1978.
@@michaelvalentini4869 l got my Sonny's confused... neither of the Johnsons recorded much. Dewey is on the Rashied Ali Live at Slugs album that was put out recently and a Paul Bley ESP, that's all l know of from him... Sonny l have no idea what else he's on... l'll try to find the 1978 stella blue, it must be on a Dick's Picks
@@juliusjabbar1011 Shervin, Dewey plays on Coltrane's ''Ascension'' recording. That ''Stella Blue'' is on my ''So Many Roads'' box set, the last 3 minutes feature a majestic solo from Garcia. It's on you-tube.
Imagine how good of a sax player you had to be so people still talk about Trane after all these years and also being black and a heroin junkie not interfearing....Julius you are a Trane expert i guess and you truly love his music without caring about the hype that's around it....haha Live Again has a great cover photo....i have a great comp to recommend in case you don't have it is called "Red hot on Impulse".... Take care.....
@@hippydjkit9913 Trane got off the smack and lived clean his last ten years... though he started to eat candy so much his teeth got bad ha... l remember seeing that Red Hot on lmpulse on cd, is there an lp?!? thank you for the appreciation Kit....
I've never been that won over by Coltrane's version of My Favorite Things. I probably prefer the more mellow Kenny Burrell version. Actually I don't mind the Julie Andrew's version either. But you know, different strokes...
What can I say except a big thank you to you Sherv. I appreciated you sharing these Coltrane albums that I was completely unaware of before. Top notch presentation as well~
Rob/Boston
hi Rob, l'm glad you got something out of these records... hope all is well...
The only one I can check in with is Selflessness but this was a cool run through. I do love the version Alice does with Charlie Haden and Pranesh Khan on the Berkeley bootleg from 72. That one is quite lush.
@@seekingathread dom, somehow l missed the berkeley bootleg. l also dig Ra's quartet version of the song on one of those horo titles.
What a great rabbit hole....Sherv!! I know what I will be listening to this weekend! Hope you are well!! ...Larry
yah, and there must be a few more l don't know about... enjoy the listenings
The version on Afro Blue Impressions came straight to mind for me.
that was probably the first live version l got, it is a great one
Hey again Sherv, Good to see you back. For sure, always nice being inspired by talks with friends, indeed...one of our favorite ones... 🙂Coltrane with Dolphy...sounds almost overwhelming in the best way. Am reminded that I've meant to replace my own copy of My Favorite Things. I really want to hear that one with Alice and Pharaoh and Offering...actually anything with Roy Haynes sparks my interest as well...A very nice cozy hangout as always here. 🙂 Glad to see you, again. -Carm
yeah, the Coltrane Dolphy combo can take ones breath away... l hope there's more of them together in the vaults to be put out... the live at the Vanguard Again might be right up your street Carm....
always a pleasure to watch your videos. Thank you for sharing part of your vast collection.
thanks Tony, hope all is well your way....
@@juliusjabbar1011 i’m leaving the!! dream
Hey Sherv -- another great jazz video, your channel should have a LOT more subs. I always learn something from your jazz takes, well done, sir.
hi Dave, thanks for the words but l'm fine with where the channel is at, glad you enjoyed
Thanks for the answer dude. This makes me realize, I’ve never fully understood what Garrison did post-Coltrane
l don't think he did much, was on a couple of Alice records and a few other things but fell off the scene, maybe due to health reasons? it still baffles me that he died in 76
Fantastic presentation! I always learn something new.. please keep making videos.
thanks so much... l might be back soon
Wonderful analysis of a piece of music. Now I need to do that
thanks for the appreciation
What is this jamming piano joint? Hot fire
Tyner Echoes of a Friend
Shervin, Jim may be getting older, but he's also getting wiser. He deserves another Hendrix tee- shirt for inspiring this video. The Grateful Dead have so many easily available live recordings. I always found it interesting to talk to Deadheads about their favorite live version of a Dead tune. Their long strange trip makes it more fun, was it a version from the 60's, the 70's, the 80's , or the 90's. Coltrane's live performance career was of course, much shorter, so I never thought about Jim's Question.The version on ''Offering'' is also my top choice, Alice's piano is amazing and the sole bass player, Sonny Johnson gives a nice long solo intro to the song. The ''One Down, One Up'' version comes in at number two, Tyner and Jones create their own separate magic together, and with the full group as well!
once again l realize l missed some stuff during this.. l failed to mention Sonny Thompson on offering and didn't say anything about Alice's piano playing.... if l was talking to a deadhead l would ask what's your favorite live version of Stella Blue... and dammit that One Up One Down is really starting to bug me, like the one that got away
@@juliusjabbar1011 Shervin, the bass player, Sonny Johnson was Dewey Johnson's brother. I assume Coltrane chose Sonny because he was friendly with Dewey. ''Stella Blue'', live from Lexington, April,21, 1978.
@@michaelvalentini4869 l got my Sonny's confused... neither of the Johnsons recorded much. Dewey is on the Rashied Ali Live at Slugs album that was put out recently and a Paul Bley ESP, that's all l know of from him... Sonny l have no idea what else he's on... l'll try to find the 1978 stella blue, it must be on a Dick's Picks
@@juliusjabbar1011 Shervin, Dewey plays on Coltrane's ''Ascension'' recording. That ''Stella Blue'' is on my ''So Many Roads'' box set, the last 3 minutes feature a majestic solo from Garcia. It's on you-tube.
@@michaelvalentini4869 l meant to say other than Ascension, man l'm off today. l should put on my lone Sonny Thompson lp then call it a day.
Imagine how good of a sax player you had to be so people still talk about Trane after all these years and also being black and a heroin junkie not interfearing....Julius you are a Trane expert i guess and you truly love his music without caring about the hype that's around it....haha Live Again has a great cover photo....i have a great comp to recommend in case you don't have it is called "Red hot on Impulse".... Take care.....
@@hippydjkit9913 Trane got off the smack and lived clean his last ten years... though he started to eat candy so much his teeth got bad ha...
l remember seeing that Red Hot on lmpulse on cd, is there an lp?!?
thank you for the appreciation Kit....
Yes double lp....beautiful....
I've never been that won over by Coltrane's version of My Favorite Things. I probably prefer the more mellow Kenny Burrell version. Actually I don't mind the Julie Andrew's version either. But you know, different strokes...
that's understandable Dave, not everything is for everyone. if you dig Burrell doing MFT check out Grant Green's take on it, l'm sure it's on utube