Another beautifully made video like always. If you don't hit at least 100k at the end of the year, people are gonna realise how much they missed out on.
Nice video. Imo, Dutch is in a way the main character of the total RDR franchise. The major thing he felt regret for was Arthur’s death, and he sought redemption in not only killing Micah, but giving the Blackwater money to John and then in RDR1 passing on multiple chances to kill John. Why? Arthur’s last wishes and some of his final words “John made it, he’s the only one”. Just as much as killing Micah was revenge for Arthur (and himself), giving John the money and never killing John later was redemptive by helping Arthur’s final wish along. I never felt Dutch was crazy. He was just a narcissist who got stroked just right by the wrong guy. He did what he could for John as a means of amends, but in the end he only knew one game and that’s what he kept playing. He knew he was doomed in RDR1, he was just riding out the string. This is why he’s the main character as he embodies an obsolete age.
Well done, couldn´t get through the 1st minute before pausing to listen to Johnnys full version uninterrupted before continuing this video 😅 Awsome choice btw.
I still don’t really want to think that dutch truly was a villain, i would rather believe that the world turned him into the uncaring psychopath we see in RDR1 rather than that being who he always was
It was most likely the death of Annabelle that turned him into that. Shit part about games and shows is that since they aren't real, the only things that ever happens is what the devs think of and show, y'know? They should have shed more light on this, though maybe they didn't as to keep it ambiguous
7:32 I don't think this is a really accurate description of what happened. Hosea has two talks about how he met Dutch ua-cam.com/video/fBZG38hlXB8/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/RdncOvIEY6I/v-deo.html Hosea tried o rob Dutch and Dutch made a fool of him. But nice vid. Always happy for more Dutch content when people acknowledge Dutch is a deeply complex, nuanced character.
Ngl the start just made me want to skip to where the character analysis started. Taking those out may help in getting views, as for a moment I thought this was gonna be a 12 minute montage of the games
@@ClaytonTheCracker Well in my opinion, the intro is really well done and sets the mood. Fitting from my point of view... Shorten anything just to get straight to the point, does not make art, nor a good book, nor a good movie, nor a good video, nor a good song, or anything better at all. If you'd skipped it, because of that intro, just because you thought it wasn't worth your time, sry that's just like your own damn fault. And a creator, or an artist, who just create to make people happy and doing things in their favor, like for example to get more views and likes, will in the end loose their creative individuallity. Just my sole opinion. I watched your videos, because of the well done intros of your videos and was even more happy, that you did a splendid job on the analysis of Dutch Van der Linde, too!
@@mrm1987 my complaint is it's so long that I didn't think it was gonna be a character analysis, I thought it was gonna end up being a montage of all the story beats that somehow was 12 minutes
@@ClaytonTheCracker Yes, you allready mentioned that before. By repeating an argument, doesn't make it better... Beside of that, It is a delicate matter of a subjects preference. I wrote my answer in that exact way, because I thought it is so offensive to tell a creator to shorten something they created, just because someone (in that case) you thought it would be something different, while only watching like the first minutes. It's kind of like you read the first twenty pages of a book, not intrigued by it, you put it away, only to find out, that after those 20 pages, the story takes a different turn and would turn into a beautiful story. And therefore asking the author to simply erase those first 20 pages, because you thought it would be something different. I hope I could make you understand, why I find that exact reason of you so kind of offensive!?
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Another beautifully made video like always. If you don't hit at least 100k at the end of the year, people are gonna realise how much they missed out on.
well said.
sorry for the super long intro guys, but you gotta admit, it was pretty dope 😂
Yeah that intro was🔥
It was should make a video on Arthur cause the intro would go crazy
That intro 🔥
It sucked worst idiotic
Best intro I ever saw
Nice video. Imo, Dutch is in a way the main character of the total RDR franchise. The major thing he felt regret for was Arthur’s death, and he sought redemption in not only killing Micah, but giving the Blackwater money to John and then in RDR1 passing on multiple chances to kill John. Why? Arthur’s last wishes and some of his final words “John made it, he’s the only one”. Just as much as killing Micah was revenge for Arthur (and himself), giving John the money and never killing John later was redemptive by helping Arthur’s final wish along.
I never felt Dutch was crazy. He was just a narcissist who got stroked just right by the wrong guy. He did what he could for John as a means of amends, but in the end he only knew one game and that’s what he kept playing. He knew he was doomed in RDR1, he was just riding out the string. This is why he’s the main character as he embodies an obsolete age.
Beautifully sad can't say I disagree don't think anyone can
Well done, couldn´t get through the 1st minute before pausing to listen to Johnnys full version uninterrupted before continuing this video 😅 Awsome choice btw.
Subscribed, god what a beautiful channel. It’s red dead redemption stories that keeps me going , but this feels like I’m watching movies!
Great video as always fellas
that intro is the best edit on yt not lying
Great video as always 👍
The opening is awesome
That too long video you can clip but looking fire bro keep doing this style
Great work
You guys are so underrated
I still don’t really want to think that dutch truly was a villain, i would rather believe that the world turned him into the uncaring psychopath we see in RDR1 rather than that being who he always was
It was most likely the death of Annabelle that turned him into that. Shit part about games and shows is that since they aren't real, the only things that ever happens is what the devs think of and show, y'know? They should have shed more light on this, though maybe they didn't as to keep it ambiguous
Finally now we can get more moneh congrats
John wait did you kill Ross?
Hi again John 👋
@@Threegun3316 DONKEY
Great Videoo
7:29 the song pls
Oh, know I get the approach you guys wanted. Went full Holden Ford in the dm lol.
3:20 is hilarious
Masterclass
You should do a morality video on Rockstar protagonist and how they can write morally conflicted characters
Except for Trevor he's got a nut job
thats actually a really good idea, thanks!
Music???
Underated
Dont give em to much fame
It was good but it need to be a little longer
Im gonna need that intro song🗣️🗣️🥵🥵
7:32 I don't think this is a really accurate description of what happened. Hosea has two talks about how he met Dutch ua-cam.com/video/fBZG38hlXB8/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/RdncOvIEY6I/v-deo.html
Hosea tried o rob Dutch and Dutch made a fool of him.
But nice vid. Always happy for more Dutch content when people acknowledge Dutch is a deeply complex, nuanced character.
Hey Liam or Mason can one of you put the discord link as a pined comment so people can join
links in the description
Maam der lind gang
Little intro
Ngl the start just made me want to skip to where the character analysis started. Taking those out may help in getting views, as for a moment I thought this was gonna be a 12 minute montage of the games
noted
A heart within the first 2 minutes! Take notes anyone who sees this, guy stays on top of things, thanks for the heart
@@ClaytonTheCracker Well in my opinion, the intro is really well done and sets the mood.
Fitting from my point of view...
Shorten anything just to get straight to the point, does not make art, nor
a good book, nor
a good movie, nor
a good video, nor
a good song,
or anything better at all.
If you'd skipped it, because of that intro,
just because you thought it wasn't worth your time,
sry that's just like your own damn fault.
And a creator, or an artist, who just create to make people happy and doing things in their favor,
like for example to get more views and likes,
will in the end loose their creative individuallity.
Just my sole opinion.
I watched your videos, because of the well done intros of your videos and was even more happy, that you did a splendid job on the analysis of Dutch Van der Linde, too!
@@mrm1987 my complaint is it's so long that I didn't think it was gonna be a character analysis, I thought it was gonna end up being a montage of all the story beats that somehow was 12 minutes
@@ClaytonTheCracker Yes, you allready mentioned that before.
By repeating an argument, doesn't make it better...
Beside of that, It is a delicate matter of a subjects preference.
I wrote my answer in that exact way, because I thought it is so offensive to tell a creator to shorten something they created, just because someone (in that case) you thought it would be something different, while only watching like the first minutes.
It's kind of like you read the first twenty pages of a book, not intrigued by it, you put it away, only to find out, that after those 20 pages, the story takes a different turn and would turn into a beautiful story. And therefore asking the author to simply erase those first 20 pages, because you thought it would be something different.
I hope I could make you understand, why I find that exact reason of you so kind of offensive!?
isn't it van der linde??
too many spaces, looks ugly in titles like that plus ive seen it spelt both ways
@@zonkers. It's actually Vandalism.
@@zonkers. Lol, someones name looks ugly so you write it wrong?
@@fallefel8132 well heres the magic of UA-cam. you can make your own video of dutch and you can spell his name how ever you want. aint that something
Imagine i was pinned again lmaooo