Gears of War EVERY CARMINE DEATH (Gears 1 to Gears 5)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 вер 2024
- Gears of War EVERY CARMINE DEATH (Gears 1 to Gears 5)
Contact me on:
Twitter: @KingAbzTV / kingabzgaming
Instagram: @KingAbzTV www.instagram....
Discord: / discord
Xbox: KingAbzYT
Welcome back to another Gears of war video. In this video I'm going to be showing cutscenes of every Gears of war Carmine death including Gears of war 2 Benjamin Carmine's death, Gears 5 Lizzie Carmine's death and more :( The carmine family consists of Gears of War Anthony Carmine, Gears of War Benjamin Carmine, Gears of War Clayton Carmine, a fourth Carmine brother, Gears of War Gary Carmine and Gears of War Lizzie Carmine!
Thanks for watching! More to come! Check out my other content too!
The Gears of War CARMINE FAMILY Explained | Gears of War Lore
• Video
Outro Music by: TheFatRat - Xenogenesis
/ thisisthefatrat
Tasty Records: / tastynetwork
Xenogenesis: • TheFatRat - Xenogenesi...
THE GAMES I PLAY:
Gears 5 Content:
• Gears 5 Fan Made Trail...
Black Ops 4 Content:
• CALL OF DUTY BLACK OPS...
FIFA 19 Content:
• FIFA 19 Pro Clubs BEST...
Forza Horizon 4 Content:
• Forza Horizon 4 Drift ...
Fortnite content:
• Fortnite HIDE AND SEEK...
Gears Of War 4 Content:
• Gears of War 4
Gta 5 Content:
• Playlist
#kingabz #gears5 #gearsofwar #gearsofwar5 - Ігри
The Gears of War CARMINE FAMILY Explained | Gears of War Lore
ua-cam.com/video/-751fe8QOGI/v-deo.html
"So why are you the only Carmine who's alive?"
Clayton: I'm built different.
He ate all of the Flintstones gummies
Buzzwords
@@firefox309 lmfao
it's because everytime a carmine dies, clayton gets more powerful.
Fun fact I can’t remember if it was Benjamin or Clayton but one of the two before there game came out there was a poll ran by buying avatar shirts to either keep him alive or kill them and we’ll if it was Clayton he lived if it was Benjamin he got wrecked lmaoo
Dom:Oh my god!They killed Carmine!
Marcus:You bastards!
Or Cole and that other guy
Dom : Carmine ga shinda !!
Marcus : Kono hito de nashi !
Just imagining Marcus saying that is so good
Lmao
May clayton eventually find peace!
Ben's death always felt like the guys were ignoring him while he was being attacked until they realized it was Ben. As if they would have left any other gear to die. I always get mad when I see his death because he coulda have been saved so easily but he had to die and they did it in a way that felt way too scripted to be young man with future dies painfully.
True but even if they shot the monster a couple seconds before his stomach was still ripped open so he would of died regardless. 😢
Dude I agree 100%. It almost took 10 full seconds for one of them to start shooting. You can blame it on bad scene writing, but if we take it for cannon, it definitely appeared like they were gonna stand by and watch a fellow human get eaten to death by those locusts.
R.I.P. all the carmines
I think Lizzie's death was more tragic. The fact James tried to save her and failed made it more tragic than it is...
Nah Bens
That is understandable. Ben's death was tragic because I cried when he died when I played the mission.
I agree that Lizzies death was tragic,but Ben's death will always be a bit more heartbreaking for me cause,marcus promised him that they would see the surface again,and he never did,plus liz died quickly,ben was being ripped apart while he was still alive and his final words were so sad to hear the first time.
@@deegomez8813 and when he fell in the worms mouth you he the worry in his Marcus’s voice
Ok I know it's sad but this is technically a running gag in the series because in each game they introduced a member of the Carmine family and then proceed to kill him off at some point in the game.
Except Gears of War 3, and Judgment
But true very true
@@elininja2130 yeah but Judgment was a prequel and 3 was a vote that saved Clayton which is why he even got to see his niece die, they are honoring the vote
They're like the Waterfall family in Futurama
Anthony died to a jammed gun ( but mainly because he forgot how important cover was) and Lizzie died to a jammed door and to JD's use of the Hammer
Lizzie and the other Carmine from 4 just felt like poorly done “fan” service… they literally served no other purpose then to die.
“We like bullying this family and making you wonder how there are any left”
Ben has always been my favorite Carmine by far but man did Lizzies death hit hard
On the plus side, we've got them all now in Gears 5
Seeing the Carmine scene in gears 3, that showed he survived was so badass to me
when I played Lizzie was my favourite character even though I barely knew her I was heartbroken when she just died 😭
I refuse to believe the Carmine in 4 is dead, kind of a BS way to kill him off, he could of easily survived.
Oh my gosh the my killed carmine!
You :::::::s!”
Anthony Carmine reporting for duty Sargent Fenix
The second one was my favorite carmine
I personally feel that gart did not die when he was hit by the ball, he possibly survived because he rather pushed it, rather, he was captured by the swarm and then died, or maybe not.
Is the Hivebuster mode set before or after the game? Cause hes one of the playables in that, he even gets a special skin for it
Either way, not a difficult death to retcon if they wanted to bring him back as a surprise later.
"Every carmine death" clay carmine up here
My favorite is Clayton Carmine, I really hope Gary comes back in Gears 6
I wish Bennie got to live he is my 2nd favorite Gears Character
THE AMOUNT OF LIKES FOR THE AMOUNT OF RESPECT WE HAVE TO THE CARMINE FAMILY FOR LITERALLY GIVING THEIR LIFES TO AAVE OUR WORLD IN ANOTHER DIMENSION 😤 💪💪🤣🥺🥺🥺
Love you Ben
I was hoping the lineage would continue passed 5 but then she died…… i don’t think there are anymore Carmines young enough to continue it…..
Clayton is very much alive and Gary is very much alive
Nah Gary dead
Yeah he is ded
0:56 BRUH
Every death I hold back my tears
The last word Gears of war 1st carmine said was See
NOTHING BAD EVER HAPPENS TO THE CARMINES...... *WOOOAAAAAAHHHHHH*
Why did ALL of them have to die
You wanna know something ironic? Before E-day the Carmine family ran a life insurance company.
Yep but the office man was a asshole and stopped giving my carmine family assurance and now my whole family is dead
@@kylecarmine6810 sorry man guess he was an asshole
So they were the manlys?
@@kylecarmine6810 long time know see huh
The irony hurts
I love the throwback to Anthony's death in Gears 5. If you fail a reload sequence as Lizzie, she says "I think I lost an uncle this way". Since his gun kept jamming.
Bro I never noticed that😭
I know she said that but I never thought of it like that
Same with the other Carmines, if their guns jam they say the exact same line as Anthony
And in 2 he mentions to Dom about not wearing a helmet. Dom says because he won't see sniper so good. Boom, Carmine dies by Sniper round. Great attention to detail.
Wow that’s tough (well in a sentimental kinda way)
Honestly though the whole carmine shit is sad and they were always my favorites
Same The 1st one was automatically my favorite and then he Died then we had a second one He dies and I the 3rd one's gone ( I'm still playing) But it made me really sad
Me to
@UCacOktwrd1QQHRLwsScOGLg don’t complain to much about Anthony dying ben is literally just Anthony but if he wasn’t such a dumb fuck and got up
Same they was tied with Dom for me as my favorites and it was sad when I seen all them get killed off in back to back games
@@KingTae24 tais deaths caught me so off guard because i was kid when that scene happened and i thought he got brainwashed to shoot himself but i later realized he was tortured
They really did Gary Carmine low by just having him there to keep the gag going.
I heard he survived
Jalobster Man Gary is dead
@@brandonphelps631 I wish we had more carmine alive tho
@Jalobster Man sadly the only Carmines that Alive are Clayton and the unidentified brother
@@brandonphelps631 I hope we see him in 6 thatd be nice to see another carmine in the same game
Clayton reigns supreme as the carmine who refused to die
Gears 6 might be his time to die
Fourth Carmine's death should be a fan choice just like Clayton
Clayton Carmine will never die
@@dronroc4587 Damn right
Ess Dron Roc no i am
Big ups for Benjamin. I really was bummed out when he died. In honor of him I only used his avatar in Horde mode.
Same its my favourite
Same here bro✊️
Me too.
Lizzie did no deserves that death. She was actually pretty cool and a competent character for her short screen time there.
It still hurts to see her go like that 😭
Anthony was competent. It's just what happens to Carmines
@@tym2083 No its just what happens when the writers what to keep a characters internal conflict going and give meaning to a purposeless schism like the the protest shooting that we never saw lol
Shortest to Longest Lifespan of the Carmines:
Gary Carmine (1 Chapter)
Lizzie Carmine (2 Chapters)
Anthony Carmine (4 Chapters)
Benjamin Carmine (13 Chapters)
Clayton Carmine (2 Games)
Benjamin lasted longer than I thought.
Tbf Ben also was described as seeing more action in his 1st day than most gears see in their career
@@sirunfunny8042 Gary didn't die.
@@Aztekaspia well yeah, I don't think I said that?
@@sirunfunny8042 Sorry I meant to answer the first comment lmao I didn't notice I tagged you, sorry
@@Aztekaspia oh ok, confused me for a sec
Liz: "You used me... for PLOT DEVELOPMENT! ...That wasn't very nice."
SpongeBob
SpongeBob:You used me for land development that wasn't very nice.
Better than anyone else she was related to
@@Laxteen10 Tell that to Gary, they used him to keep the gag going with nothing for him.
They did lizzie dirty
Old baird looks like adam fenix
In gears 4 i actually thought it was adam fenix in the opening cutscene. Like a flashback of him somehow keeping up with the outside world.
Adam Fenix just straight up looks like a clone of Walter white
I said the same thing
I’m pretty sure they did that on purpose, since they’re both scientists and engineers.
The power of a lab coat
Bet yall regret to vote to keep clayton alive now dont tah, he got so old he got to see his niece die to the curse his family has gotten.
I voted to keep him alive too 😟 he’s been through a lot
King Abz same here
Don't regret it at all
@@KingAbzTV he deserved it. If they all died the carmine's wouldn't mean anything. As long as he's there as the one who survived, the carmine legacy lives on. I voted to keep him alive obviously.
Even if he did die, Lizzie was going to die anyway.
1:04 You know, they really could have been a *sliiiiight* bit quicker getting the bugs off Benjamin here, considering he was literally screaming in agony as he was being eaten alive. Baird doesn't even take a GLANCE at him either.
Baird was just dozing off at some flesh sculptures while his comrade is getting torn apart by parasites
Ben was the best, I almost tear up when he says "tell my family I love em"
Benjamin and Lizzie's deaths hit hard bro
I know right 😭also if you liked this video be sure to subscribe for everything Gears!
Lizzie made me sad, saw it coming & couldn’t do anything about it.
RIP to the fallen Carmines 😭 and also we don’t know if Gary Carmine is confirmed as dead after he was knocked off the turret in the cog attack, he survived till the swarm attack but we don’t know what happened after, hence he’s included in this list
I can tell that Gary is dead because we haven't seen him in the campaing at the beginning
Murió siendo raptado por los raptores igual que los forasteros incluido Will
I do my cousin Gary hid I saw him in the window when the swarm attacked
You can find Gary's body in the hive surrounded by dead juries, he survived the battle, got dragged to the hive where Marcus was and died in battle.
Went out like a badass
@@Veachie No his body is in the hive confirming he died later also zombie Kait is a thing but she hasn't died yet.
Debunked; skin packs are not good enough evidence to be considered canon.
Guys remember the other carmines in that one Gears trailer Detcher, Franklin, the one that got hit by a train, and the one that got chopped up into pieces. He always loved animals
Torque Bow tag 😩😩
Lost his keys in a pool of imolsion
Non canon but I loved every bit of it 🤧
Uhhh, Y they always be killing Carmines tho 😫it’s so sad
No one ever talks about Alicia Valera she was cool too 😭
Plot twist! We find out Clayton was adopted in gears 6!
That would make sense
The curse of the carmines : every carmine born a carmine will die
WRONG!
Sighs, when will the Carmine's have peace, all there is left is Clayton, Clayton suffered so much 😭 I just hope there is another young Carmine left to get the family back in business lol, and show the legacy and hero
Well Lizzie was his girlfriend Carmine but she died Carmine lost his girlfriend that’s sad yet he still acts in such a badass way the Clayton does not talk about it even at the end when Carmine says look not gonna lie it’s it’s real ugly out ther
@@jonathanoxlade4252 Lizzie is Clayton's niece
What about the fourth Carmine brother?
@@jonathanoxlade4252 Um Lizzie Carmine is Clayton's niece. This isn't Arkansas.
Clayton still has D. Carmine, the fourth brother that Ben mentioned. He fathered Lizzie after all.
Clayton was always my favorite cuz of his attitude
So I’m glad he didn’t die
He's alive?
El Cocaino yes indeed
Back before gears 3 was released, fans got to vote on whether or not he lived
@@Thegreatone100 I remember that I'm so glad I voted for him to live
@@Thegreatone100 really? Thats cool
Gears 1 - Anthony's death, sniper shot him in the head, death relatively painless as he instantly died
Gears 2 - Ben's death, first fell out of a helicopter into a giant worms mouth, then said worms uhh... creatures started eating him alive by removing his intestines and probably lungs along with breaking his ribcage and multiple other bones, then dragged into acidic things all while being coincious and he still manages to say "tell my brothers and my mother I love them"
Gears 5 - Lizzies death, Hammer of Dawn instantly killed, terrifying for her final moments but her death is physically painless
I think we all know who had the worst death. In my opinion Ben was the best Carmine despite him not having a whole lot of military training. All the moments leading up to his death from the start of the game make it a lot sadder than at first glance. He's put out on the front lines of the hospital to defend it with his life, gets too scared and hides indoors where Marcus finds him, then he gets sent off course in his grind lift where he is the only survivor of his squad, where Marcus once again finds him and saves him, then he wants to pay back the debt by holding the locust off while everyone else board the heli, but ends up costing them important time and ultimately his own life. God its so sad
I gotta carry on the Benjamin legacy.
@@benjamintherogue2421 hey brother I tried man
😢😢😢
RIP to all the fallen Carmines
Rip to me
@AnthonyCarmine2000 God bless you Anthony and your fallen siblings.
I just recently replayed all 5 Gears games and I just wanna say, I'm glad people put some respect on Ben Carmine's name in this comment section.
For being as much of a rookie as he was, Ben was a Grub killing machine. On about 3 separate occasions he managed to be the last man standing after Grub attacks left entire units he was apart of dead.
And ironically, given how his brother Anthony died, he was a very competent marksman and consistently murdered things for me with that Longshot of his up until his death.
As for Lizzie, she was the best waifu in that game. Shame she died so fast, she had potential to be the next Clayton Carmine. Or at the very least if she had lived longer she could've made as much of an impact as Ben. (Though she made a pretty big impact for only being in 2 chapters, though that might just be because of how emotional her death is.)
I really liked B. Carmine, and was glad he got a bit of a send off in Gears 2, as i thought they were going to just give him an unceremonious death of being swallowed by the worm.
Ben was my favorite! Kid was a fucking Beast even though he acted scared. He was always the first to push in my game saves on Gears 2.
😭
Ik bro but he always carrying around a sniper in close quarters combat🤣
@@ubadubs4123 So? I run sniper close combat too, because just like the AI, I hit those.
@@II-bt3sg yeah a person can do that but we are talking about a bot not just a bot a rookie bot
The only time I saw him using that sniper was him beating someone to death with it
@@ubadubs4123 Then your not talking about Ben. Ben was the one that runs in with a sniper and does kill. He wasn't a "rookie bot". Yes he was the rookie character, but he actually did more killing than Dom did.
Haven't played past 3, but that "peaceful protestor" bit was cringe. I can see why people panned the sequels.
Yeah Gears 4/5’s story aren’t great imo. But 5’s story does have an amazing act where you learn about the Locust origins.
That was brilliantly done but apart from that pretty forgettable for the most part.
How was that cringe? Shooting protesters is not ok at all. Also gears 4/5 stories are good many people are too attached to nostalgia to acknowledge this
read the books that came out for the series
GoW 4's story is too self-contained and leads to nothing. All I got out of it is "Oh no the locust are back! Also weird mutations? Are the locust people?".
Then again I haven't played GoW 3... but still, the story ends too abruptly IMO. And the new cast can be insufferable.
@@migueeeelet let me explain something in GoW3 the locust are more like ants they have a Queen and they are commanded to do what they do you later then kill the Queen and after that they stop?? But I guess there back now
I'm still bettin Gary didn't die, no proof 🤷🏾♂️. Plus it should of been in a cutscene form if so
watch my recent video and you shall see ;)
The whole time Benjamin was being brutally eaten alive Baird was just looking around in awe
Ben will always be my favorite even though Clayton is arguably the most badass character in the series in my opinion, that being said ben and lizzies deaths make me tear up every time and im not even ashamed to admit it
its cole noob!
Gary' death was offscreen. He survived the COG attack and was taken by the Swarm and was turned into a Juvie and possibly killed by the player.
No, he was killed during the attack. The Coalition themselves have confirmed that
And tbf I'd rather have him dead because of the COG then him turning into a juvie
@@jimbo5147 My comment is irrelevant now. TC confirmed he was killed by the DeeBee DropPod and the "Gary Carmine's" in the background are just fillers for unnamed Outsiders
How u Kno?
Lizzie is really cool female character shame she still has Carmine Curse. unlike her uncle Clayton.
Gear 6 Clayton finally at peace
(or another Carmine)
All the signs were there that she would get killed off.. they showed her off, like how badass she was. She’s a carmine in a gears game… yet I was still caught off guard by it
I refuse to believe that Gary is dead even with the zombie skin in gears 4 considering JD, Del, and Kait all had one but never died.
The second death broke me
TLOU2 you might like this video then :) ua-cam.com/video/WovnjwsZGgg/v-deo.html
For gears 6, I believe Clayton is gonna die and the new carmine will take his place
He needs to live
If he does die it better be in a badass way
the new carmine might be the mysterious D.carmine
my guest the D might be for these names Desmond,David,Dennis,Dylon or Dean
What's your name pick for the mysterious D.carmine?
If Clayton dies it legit needs to be a last stand cutscene where he gets hurt in a way that reflects the deaths of other carmines. Like he gets shot by a sniper and doesn't die, gets partially eaten by a ticker, get slammed with a big object, gets singed by the hammer of dawn, and just keeps fighting through pure hate and tenacity until he finally succumbs to his wounds that are reflective of how each of his family members died. I want that man to go out in a blaze of fucking glory dieing from pure exhaustion on hill pilled high with dead grubs. That is THE ONLY way ill accept his death.
@@nicholasprutzman9915 EXACTLY
"the door..it won't open, it's jammed!" missed opportunity there XD
Flashbacks
This family has saving private ryan levels of bad luck
I don't consider this "Gary" Carmine to be an actual member of the Carmine family. The Carmines were a military family. Full COG, through and through. A Carmine joining the Outcasts would never happen, not if Clayton (and later Elizabeth) was still in the COG. The Carmine family would never split themselves like that; their family ties and traditions were far too strong to be shaken.
Therefore, I believe this "Gary" is just someone who shared the same last name, no blood relation. No, I don't care what the Wiki says, shut up.
Renerade no one knows tbh, Gary is probably a cousin not a brother, since there’s 4 and the last one remains unknown
@@dr.fizzzics7300 Oh, I suppose there's some truth to that.
Hmph.
Renerade yea since Gary is too young to have Lizzy since she’s in her 20’s by gears 5
James Vaughan I mean that’s a nice theory cause they both were born in the same year, but then again Clayton never states that he had a nephew only a niece which was lizzy
Gary was getting shit on by the family
And they know who he is
He's more likely a cousin but he was raised by the outsiders
My theory: Gary is a cousin of the carmine family and was getting shit on by the family so hard he ran away
Then he joined the outsiders and settled there till he..well....died
I remember playing through gears 3, and seeing Clayton's helmet there on the beach next to a body. I was so sad, only to see him pick it up moments later, that was the best moment in gaming for me at that point in my life.
I hate how they treated carmine
I felt so bad for Ben, his last moments were him thinking of his family, he was in lots of pain after those bugs but at least he wasnt alone:(
Rest In Peace Brave Carmine😭 you fought valiantly and brave. Just like Clone Troopers fighting for the grand army of the republic and died trying. A moment of silence.
the carmines were my favorite characters in the games..except for 5 but i love their personalities i hate that they kill them off so early in the games
Rip Carmine’s❤️❤️
Everybody gangsta till the next gears game , Carmine does not die
Save Clayton and the New Carmine for GEARS 6 SAVE THEM BOTH
The Carmine family is literally the Zeppili family from JoJo's Bizarre Adventure. Every member is destined to die just for having the same last name, and for no other reason other than it being a running gag.
Sheesh, at least let there be another Carmine that deserved to live throughout the next GOW game. It's really painful to see them depicted as throw-away fodder in the series.
*Lizzie dies sadly*
video outro music
😭😭😭
I think Gary is most likely dead. Gary has a zombie skin in Gears of War 4 like Anthony and Benjamin. However, Clayton doesn't because obviously he's still alive. Because of that reason I think Gary's dead. R.I.P
Also if you reply to me, who's your favorite Carmine? Mine's Clayton
I liked Anthony personally and Clayton because he survived
Clayton. GRUB KILLER
A carmine
Benjamin was my favorite of the Carmines. He was a good kid. A shame Delta let him die. They literally could have grabbed him before he slowly slide out of the Raven and into the Worm's gaping maw.
Then enters Elizabeth. Played Gears of War 5 recently to see what the hub-bub was all about. Sees her come in, being a genuine badass like Clayton, with the two having a nice wholesome family reunion. I'm all like, hell ya, Liz is my new favorite.
Then she dies to friendly fire.
FFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU-
But Kait has a zombie skin and she’s not dead
Lizzie should have lived that was BS.
Gears of War 6 spoilers CARMINE FUCKING DIES my favorite was Benjamin as a character not him dying
How did Clayton Carmine survive a sniper shot but anything Carmine didn't
True
Andres Fousto he got shot in they eye (the very light blue eye part in the helmet)
@@GhostEntity-hf6ju 😓😨😰
I forgot to put Anthony Carmine who got shot in the eye, not "he"
They better kill a Carmine in Gears of War E-Day
Gonna be a random carmine in a suit because they ran a life insurance company lol
Benjamin was my first and favorite went back for remastered Anthony. And lived the glory days through Clayton. God Clayton is a fucking monster gigachad. Biggest one of them all too. Just an absolute monster
0:49 Get Ready for the new Gears of War: E-Day Game
Benjamins death genuinely makes me cry, the horror and desperation in his voice that dissipates to agonized fear as he dies haunts me. Even during death the last thing he wanted was for him brothers to know he loved him.
Ben Carmine will always be the Goat! RIP
1:30 marcus forgot to tell clayton and his mom that benjamin loves them
They did not have to do liz like that. She was the only good character they made.
Rip my dead cuzins rip cuzin Anthony cuzin Benjamin cuzin Gary and cuzin Lizzy oh and there's a uncle will carmine but he's in the comic book I hope you are doing well out there clay I will find you in gears 6 stay safe clay
honorable mention Will Carmine Killed by RAAM in comics
Dom: Oh my god they killed Carmine
Marcus: You bastards
Since microsoft owns gears and doom, i keep waiting for the day they release a cross promotion where you get a lancer and a clayton carmine outfit for the doomslayer, and the friggin doomslayer himself as a character in the gears multiplayer
The carmine family just has the worst of luck.
Well crazy things is she couldev went through the other door
My theory is the carmine family has many siblings, uncles and aunts, cousins born into it because life expectancy is short for them. Only a handful get to live long lives
Benjamin is still my boi
Clay looks the coolest but Benjamin is the best
I salute to them all
I'm getting real tired of Carmines dying, they're actually good characters.
Define “good”
(Rant) I feel like Liz was done absolutely wretched. To me, the Carmine deaths are a gag with the added effect of showcasing the brutality of war and how life can end in an instant. Liz didn't deserve what she got because they created an interesting character with her like they did with Clayton, but then killed her for plot development. That might not be so bad, if it weren't for the fact that the plot development was AWFUL. She didn't just die for plot development, she died for SHITTY plot development. JD is portrayed as this like villain character because his actions were reckless and caused people to die, but his dad did the SAME SHIT 25 years ago and was a hero for it. Specifically, when he and Delta used a, here it comes: Aging and unstable hammer of dawn satellite with poor targeting data to destroy a threat, the lambent berserker, while also risking the surrounding area and friendlies. The only thing that's different here is that JD doesn't have Marcus's plot armor. Then there is that JD did what he did because they had NO OTHER OPTION. Like there was no good call! They had an army of swarm at their doorstep including brumaks, they had a convoy of civilians that needed evacuated but was trapped, and neither the time nor firepower to sort out these problems, THE BRUMAKS WERE RIGHT THERE. Using the hammer was absolutely the right call, despite the risk. Liz and some civilians dying was horrible, but JD saved the rest of them and probably Delta squad too by calling in the hammer. The fact that Liz died for the purpose of painting JD as a villain is just horrible story writing because he made the right call. The only thing worse for a character than dying for plot development is dying for shitty plot development.