Given the implication the original Adam was replaced by an Alternate that everyone ignores, I love the idea The Flood was God destroying the Alternates.
I remember visiting greece and showing the mandela catalogue to my two friends. one of them immediately stopped watching after gabriel's face distorted but the other continued to watch with me. now those two best friends I have aren't friends with eachother anymore. I still talk to them both. I might ask the other one if he's still scared of gabriel. edit: I asked him, he said he's not scared anymore 👍
Gabriel replying "For what?" after being asked wether or not the sheperd was forgiven, implies he didn't get the shepherd's prayers, because the former isn't holy.
Theory Time: 1: Gabriel feeds off prayers, but doesn't actually hear them OR 2: the "For what?" is just a little "sarcasm" thing before showing the sheperd his little one was "brought back".
Gabriel haunts me, so much to the point when the normal archangel is mentioned his face (normal and distorted) flash before my eyes. It’s really horrifying
@@marvibun shit was disproven months ago. Do some follow-up instead of throwing pedo accusations around just because you heard them on twitter one time
Mandela Catalogue is the analog horror that made analog horror popular, the first analog horror ever is No Through Road, in 2009. Edit: Actually, I believe Local 58 is the first one to label itself as "Analog Horror"
@@untiff7169 I forgot about No Through Road. That one actually shook me up the first time I watched it and yeah I would call it analog horror definitely got the vibes
Slight mistake: we don't actually know what Alternates do with the originals. Mark and Jude unsubscribing from life is not their aim, since we saw that Alternates can assume the forms of still living people when it came to Thatcher. In fact, I think what happened to Thatcher is what Alternates normally fo with the originals.
I'm pretty sure it's implied throughout the series that killing the originals, or influencing them to do it, is their goal, why would cesars alternate torment mark until he killed himself if it didn't want him dead?
@@helloagain.andagain.andagain Mark killed himself because he realized his faith was to the monster tormenting him. Realizing that shattered him, and living in a world where God had been usurped by Satan from the beginning was too much to bear. That is why it said, bad decision, mark.' It is implied that the Alternates have some other plane of existence, the place of sand and chains that Gabriel/Jeses was taken. That is probably where the originals are, and since the Alternates appear to not be bound by time, that realm might make the originals watch for all eternity.
@@helloagain.andagain.andagain no, he realized his faith was to a LIE. He killed himself because the walls that held his life together was his faith in God. Had the fake Gabriel not usurped God, Mark would have shot the Alternate, not himself.
@@Michael_Breiterconsidering the alternates afflict M.A.D, and M.A.D is described as information that is not desired to be known, the alternate is probably who revealed to Mark that his religion is a lie, probably after Mark opened the door and tried shooting it
Since no one else ever does it, I always take it upon myself to sing the praises of Jonah's voice actor on his performance especially during the argument and aftermath, it is just so dramatic and raw in the best way. You can FEEL and hear the grating exasperation and fear as he's BEGGING Adam to make sane and mortal decision to just leave, how much he HATES Adam for keeping them here this long and just in general insisting on pursuing this suicidal investigative career that Jonah probably felt semi-obligated to tag along on because of his concern for his friends safety and how much the devotion that concern bred has worn thin. Also the guilt in his screams of "SHUT UP!" over leaving Adam tearing him to shreds as the GPS torments him saying how he left him and how he'll die without you which is probably what Jonah was already thinking because from his point of view Adam was his friend and someone he cared about. Absolutely phenomenal.
Crazzzzzy that you released this 2 hour long video, I’ve always enjoyed your content. Been wondering for so long when you would ever make long essay based videos like these! Happy 100th!
at 38:02 while waiting on the black screen for the thingy to go skjajkswhaishkaoosh, i got a shampoo ad. i hate to admit that, since i was in such a dark room, it startled me.
Its highly possible that Adam isn't a full alternate but a hybrid a test to see if alternates can be shaped into something more hence why so many kids were kidnapped. He was the successful one and there could be more
I love the intruder as an antagonist, because its kind of not, the intruder is an antagonist from the perspective of the people, but the intruder is against gabriel, ultimately protecting adam, the final true protagonist of the series, it would be awesome to see mandela catlogue end the same way as like fnaf 6, adam, with the help of the intruder, finds a way to kill alternates, and finally ends the torment...
@@okaycool5145 Meme aside, saying "Nah, I'd win" in this analog horror might increase your survivability. Even more if you start rambling about something like "WE'RE DESTINED TO CONQUER THE STAAAAAAAARS" or something
@@okaycool5145 the alternates actively hunts those who are scared and lack of hope. You can see that the alternates always do anything they can to crush the hopes of the real humans. Having self confidence and a goal set to fight not for revenge, but a hope for mankind survival and harmony will give you more days to live before they'll just attack you directly It sounds comedic, but anything to overwrite your fear is useful when your opponent loves to snorts 1kg of fear If the government send the national guards to fight against the alternates, they will give them drugs to boost their adrenaline and to make them feel powerful
Amazing collaboration guys I've been a subscriber for a long time now but this essay got me really invested in your brand of analysis and production Thanks to both of you
I found this channel a week ago and Ive been watch non stop I love the horror and I saw the video count was 99 and I was like :o the next one will be 100 I wonder what it was going to be havent watched it yet but I'm ready for 2 hours of horror :3 your videos are good :)
I think the relocation program in volume 5 is just an easy way for the alternates to replace people, hence why the guy basically told judas to off himself cause now he has to deal with an alternate.
Man I remember when you were some random small channel I found when I needed something to listen to and crochet now your channel is so much bigger and I’m still listening and crocheting lol! You’re doing good man, keep up the work!
loved this video!! always looking forward to watching a new upload from you guys! honestly perfect vids to fold the laundry to because my hands can mindlessly work while i hone in on all the info
My personal theory is that the original messanger was a nun at the local church which was taken over by gabriel, the nun follows a young Mark home as a child marking him as a possible prey which explains why he talked about the alternate as a child and is also why a bunch people left the church much later in the series because it was only being used as a base for gabrial trying to manipulate people
The vine compilation made me think, the alternates using fear just wouldn’t work on the modern internet with apps like TikTok as 90% of people just wouldn’t be afraid, and the people that would be afraid would just scroll past
i feel like it's more of the factor of 1. its a long video,it could've taken a while to make or 2. the controversy with the creator finally being cleared up or 3. people are just busy in life.
1:56 ‘My lack of knowledge when it comes to the bible and its antics, are basically zero’ That would mean that you have 0 lack of knowledge regarding the bible, meaning you know everything. Small mistake, but still there. It should also be ‘is’ rather than ‘are’.
i just finesh that and honestly im really shoken to the core that shit might be the scariest analog ive ever seen and you guys really hit the nail on the head or whatever the saying is but im really suprised this shit was so well made and im glad to see this.
31:09 since you didn’t know what this meant, I’ll explain it a little. The “type 2: detectable” is from the old volume 1, not the renewed one. In the old one, it goes over 3 types of alternates. 1 being “doppelgänger”, 2 being “detectable”, and the 3rd one not getting a name.
Given the implication the original Adam was replaced by an Alternate that everyone ignores, I love the idea The Flood was God destroying the Alternates.
wait that's genius I love that idea
I mean, the whole goal was to punish people for their sins and technically "purify the earth" so the idea of flood holds grand value.
WE KEEPIN THE LIGHTS ON WITH THIS ONE 🗣️🔥💯‼️
Not me ☝🏼 I’m watching this at 12am alone in my bedroom in the darkness
We sitting out in the living room with our dog for emotional comfort with this one ✌️✨🧚💕🍄
nah I'm no pussy
sleeping with my mommy with this one 🗣️🔥🔥💯💯💯‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️
Bro its 2am rn for me its pitch black out and i heard a noise in the kitchen💀💀
Weird to think that the Mandela series is already 3 years old. Seems like just yesterday everyone and their cousin were making theory videos about it.
I honestly thought this started in 2023
I remember visiting greece and showing the mandela catalogue to my two friends. one of them immediately stopped watching after gabriel's face distorted but the other continued to watch with me. now those two best friends I have aren't friends with eachother anymore. I still talk to them both. I might ask the other one if he's still scared of gabriel.
edit: I asked him, he said he's not scared anymore 👍
the way a ad hit everytime a jump scare was about to happen
YOU ARE THE CHOSEN ONE
revanced
That's God trying to save you.
@@Don-gl6mf *an ad
FUCKING FR BRP
Gabriel replying "For what?" after being asked wether or not the sheperd was forgiven, implies he didn't get the shepherd's prayers, because the former isn't holy.
Theory Time:
1: Gabriel feeds off prayers, but doesn't actually hear them
OR
2: the "For what?" is just a little "sarcasm" thing before showing the sheperd his little one was "brought back".
@@AuuuuuuuuuuuA likely 2
Sorry for what?
@@UnknownGamer40464 TURN DOWN FOR WHAT
the way he said it is terrifying.. 😭
Gabriel haunts me, so much to the point when the normal archangel is mentioned his face (normal and distorted) flash before my eyes. It’s really horrifying
archangel gabriel
Same.
loving the ads before all the jumpscares LOL
LOL
Fr
you are the chosen one
Imagine adam being really scared and he hears ''Im batman''
*door opens* Hi! Welcome to Chili's!
I'd imagine he'd respond with "It's Da freakin bat!"
nah he hears "I dont hide in the shadows, I am the shadows"
“Justice for Gotham!”
Or "Henshin" considering Agito having a similar plot with this Analogue Horror
in the mandela county. straight up "jorking it". and by "it", haha, well. let's just say. My alternatets
FOUL. I STILL CACKLED AT THIS.
If there was a poster child for analog horror, it's the Mandela Catalogue.
Let's not bring Alex Kister and children too close in proximity, yeah?
@@marvibun fake
@@marvibun aligations proven false a long time ago
@@marvibun that was disproveb months ago
@@marvibun shit was disproven months ago. Do some follow-up instead of throwing pedo accusations around just because you heard them on twitter one time
I was like “let’s go a 4 plus vid today!” only got a brief look and I was like a “HR LONG?!?!?” Looked again “2HRS LONG?!?!? 😃”
Gives real
"A platypus?"
"PERRY THE PLATYPUS?!?!"
I’m so glad you’re finally covering this. This is by far one of my favorite horror series.
It’s nice to know that Mandela Catalog is one of the original analog horror to start it all
Mandela Catalogue is the analog horror that made analog horror popular, the first analog horror ever is No Through Road, in 2009.
Edit: Actually, I believe Local 58 is the first one to label itself as "Analog Horror"
@@untiff7169local 58 was the first to be A analog horror
@@untiff7169 I forgot about No Through Road. That one actually shook me up the first time I watched it and yeah I would call it analog horror definitely got the vibes
no through road is my favorite one off analog horror
0:11 is bro slurping spaghetti or something😭🙏
Maybe the real Mandela catalog was the friends we made along the way
and those friends aren’t real
What friends were not real bob u need to wake up
it truly was a "Mandela Catalog".
@@Nekochan456 What are we? Some kinda... "Mandela Catalogue?"
This quote made my shaboingboing get all jubilated
“And we have one of the most soul crushing scares in the whole series”
*Tide ad plays*
AHHHHHHHH
Who up mandelaing their catalog
In the mandela straight up “cataloguing it” . And by it. Haha well. let’s justr say… my alternate
@@brakk7117what
@@brakk7117 my alternate puts drake to shame
she mandela on my catalogue till I heathcliff
She Mandela on my alternate until i catalog
6:55 This text is from “The Divine comedy” when Dante saw Lucifer.
Slight mistake: we don't actually know what Alternates do with the originals. Mark and Jude unsubscribing from life is not their aim, since we saw that Alternates can assume the forms of still living people when it came to Thatcher.
In fact, I think what happened to Thatcher is what Alternates normally fo with the originals.
I'm pretty sure it's implied throughout the series that killing the originals, or influencing them to do it, is their goal, why would cesars alternate torment mark until he killed himself if it didn't want him dead?
@@helloagain.andagain.andagain Mark killed himself because he realized his faith was to the monster tormenting him. Realizing that shattered him, and living in a world where God had been usurped by Satan from the beginning was too much to bear. That is why it said, bad decision, mark.'
It is implied that the Alternates have some other plane of existence, the place of sand and chains that Gabriel/Jeses was taken. That is probably where the originals are, and since the Alternates appear to not be bound by time, that realm might make the originals watch for all eternity.
@@Michael_Breiter ..because the alternate tormented him to the point he didn't trust his own faith and killed himself
@@helloagain.andagain.andagain no, he realized his faith was to a LIE. He killed himself because the walls that held his life together was his faith in God. Had the fake Gabriel not usurped God, Mark would have shot the Alternate, not himself.
@@Michael_Breiterconsidering the alternates afflict M.A.D, and M.A.D is described as information that is not desired to be known, the alternate is probably who revealed to Mark that his religion is a lie, probably after Mark opened the door and tried shooting it
Sick another several hour long youtube video essay, i think im addicted 💀
Since no one else ever does it, I always take it upon myself to sing the praises of Jonah's voice actor on his performance especially during the argument and aftermath, it is just so dramatic and raw in the best way. You can FEEL and hear the grating exasperation and fear as he's BEGGING Adam to make sane and mortal decision to just leave, how much he HATES Adam for keeping them here this long and just in general insisting on pursuing this suicidal investigative career that Jonah probably felt semi-obligated to tag along on because of his concern for his friends safety and how much the devotion that concern bred has worn thin.
Also the guilt in his screams of "SHUT UP!" over leaving Adam tearing him to shreds as the GPS torments him saying how he left him and how he'll die without you which is probably what Jonah was already thinking because from his point of view Adam was his friend and someone he cared about. Absolutely phenomenal.
Bro is terrified of literally everything (and so am I) glad you got to this one, it’s one of the best I’ve seen
Crazzzzzy that you released this 2 hour long video, I’ve always enjoyed your content. Been wondering for so long when you would ever make long essay based videos like these! Happy 100th!
at 38:02 while waiting on the black screen for the thingy to go skjajkswhaishkaoosh, i got a shampoo ad. i hate to admit that, since i was in such a dark room, it startled me.
2 HOURS OF FOUR PLUS?!?! MY PRAYERS HAVE BEEN ANSWERED (congrats for the 100th video and I love your content
Bro... You and I'm pretty sure it was Minues are the best. You two deserve a lot of credit for edeting and making voiceover's here. Take care, man.
this was a real treat! I always put on 4 Plus while I'm drawing and having a whole 2 hr video was awesome. Thanks so much for all of your hard work!
That "for what" response to the shepherd was absolutely chilling
I look forward to seeing a longer version when we get the full thing out
Finally he did it, the mandela catalogue
what a shitty pointless comment
learned more about my own religion in this video than i ever have in church 😭😭
also mr plus sounds just like nick crowley!
Happy 100th vid🎊🎉🎉🎉
Its highly possible that Adam isn't a full alternate but a hybrid a test to see if alternates can be shaped into something more hence why so many kids were kidnapped. He was the successful one and there could be more
Holy cow this deserves way more views, this is amazing
I love the intruder as an antagonist, because its kind of not, the intruder is an antagonist from the perspective of the people, but the intruder is against gabriel, ultimately protecting adam, the final true protagonist of the series, it would be awesome to see mandela catlogue end the same way as like fnaf 6, adam, with the help of the intruder, finds a way to kill alternates, and finally ends the torment...
This series always scared me and as a grown up I’m still terrified to rewatch this
i love watching these kinds of videos while I play dress up games on roblox
this is probably the only analog horror where my attitude is "nah, i'd win"
You're not winning
@@okaycool5145 nah, i'd win
@@okaycool5145 Meme aside, saying "Nah, I'd win" in this analog horror might increase your survivability.
Even more if you start rambling about something like "WE'RE DESTINED TO CONQUER THE STAAAAAAAARS" or something
@@ded4700 explain how
@@okaycool5145 the alternates actively hunts those who are scared and lack of hope. You can see that the alternates always do anything they can to crush the hopes of the real humans.
Having self confidence and a goal set to fight not for revenge, but a hope for mankind survival and harmony will give you more days to live before they'll just attack you directly
It sounds comedic, but anything to overwrite your fear is useful when your opponent loves to snorts 1kg of fear
If the government send the national guards to fight against the alternates, they will give them drugs to boost their adrenaline and to make them feel powerful
this guy is perfect to watch when ur too scared to watch analog horror by yourself tbh
shoutout my boy Gabriel 🔥💯‼️🗣️
Thanks for the upload, always nice to watch you break it down 🔥
I love these vids and Mandela catolog so when I saw these I was SO EXITED, love this channel ❤
little fun fact but Thatcher Davis is played by Thorne baker! He is most known for his music under the name "Teenage Disaster"
Amazing collaboration guys
I've been a subscriber for a long time now but this essay got me really invested in your brand of analysis and production
Thanks to both of you
I found this channel a week ago and Ive been watch non stop I love the horror and I saw the video count was 99 and I was like :o the next one will be 100 I wonder what it was going to be havent watched it yet but I'm ready for 2 hours of horror :3 your videos are good :)
37:58 I GOT A TIDE AD RIGHT AFTER YOU SAID THAT
this was insane. thanks a lot Mr.Plus and Mr.Minus
im already hyped for next video
I watched this in one sitting a couple days ago. And now I’m gonna do it again. Great video
I got an ad and then the whispering scare seen hit me
I think the relocation program in volume 5 is just an easy way for the alternates to replace people, hence why the guy basically told judas to off himself cause now he has to deal with an alternate.
yippeee happy 100 video!!!! you’re my favorite analog horror youtuber, i’m so happy you exist!!
Really love the Mandela Catalog; it and Greylock could be scripted into a horror movie or show and I’d watch it over and over.
Man I remember when you were some random small channel I found when I needed something to listen to and crochet now your channel is so much bigger and I’m still listening and crocheting lol! You’re doing good man, keep up the work!
that's so funny how you have the same headphones that I do I recognize that beep from anywhere
loved this video!! always looking forward to watching a new upload from you guys! honestly perfect vids to fold the laundry to because my hands can mindlessly work while i hone in on all the info
Holy 2 hours video Batman
This is just biblical among us
I hate how much sense that makes
2 hour video. We eatin good tonight
1:44:00 remember, claymation can be done in 3D as well
Good God, this series has moved much faster than i expected it
Recommend watching the “non-restored” version of volume 1
37:55
When he said there was "the more sole crushing scares in the whole series" was about to play, a political ad started playing and I screamed
i'm sick and fell asleep watching this, had some WEIRD but cool dreams
Goodness I couldn't imagine
Congrats on your 100th videoo
I've been waiting for you to cover this!! So excited for this!
38:08 omggg he's beat boxing
Forget the catalogue. I need to know more about this chicken dinner.
The alternate in volume five is the one who was mentioned as only being observant at the beginning of the volume.
My personal theory is that the original messanger was a nun at the local church which was taken over by gabriel, the nun follows a young Mark home as a child marking him as a possible prey which explains why he talked about the alternate as a child and is also why a bunch people left the church much later in the series because it was only being used as a base for gabrial trying to manipulate people
I’m convinced this is the best analog horror deep-dive in all of history
11:29 Man I really hoped it would be the original ver. of think. Still gives me goosebumps
when the baby cry played i swear this is real, my little sister started crying (I nearly shat myself)
12:01 JOJO REFERENCE
I've been waiting for this one!!!
Gabriel says "For what?"
when The Shepard asks "Am I forgiven?"
Definitely love the long form
HAPPPY 100TH UPLOAD 4 PLUS 🎉🎉
BABE WAKE UP 4PLUS POSTED 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
The vine compilation made me think, the alternates using fear just wouldn’t work on the modern internet with apps like TikTok as 90% of people just wouldn’t be afraid, and the people that would be afraid would just scroll past
happy 100th video anyversary :D
THERE'S NO WAY, YOU DIDN'T SEE IT BEFORE OMG 😭😭😭
yeah thats the scariest part
I was thinking the samething.
i feel like it's more of the factor of 1. its a long video,it could've taken a while to make or 2. the controversy with the creator finally being cleared up or 3. people are just busy in life.
See what
@@trapstar..wait, what controversy?
My favorite analogue I gotta watch the wendigoon videos again to remind myself of the story it’s so damn good
Nah the soul crushing alternate by dissing anybody any day
OMG I WAS WAITING FOR THIS VIDEOO YESSSS
Not the fucking Dr Disrespect @ 53:00 LMFAO
AT 38:05 I GOT A COMMERCIAL FOR TIDE AND I WAS SCARED SHITLESS AND THEN I ALMOST DIED LAUGHING
YES HE FINALLY COVERED IT!!!!!!!
This entire channel is how dreams feel on psych meds. Im glad i found this, i can feed my weird.
THE UNDERATEDNESS I GET FROM THIS CHANNEL IS CRAZY WTHH
1:56
‘My lack of knowledge when it comes to the bible and its antics, are basically zero’
That would mean that you have 0 lack of knowledge regarding the bible, meaning you know everything. Small mistake, but still there. It should also be ‘is’ rather than ‘are’.
i just finesh that and honestly im really shoken to the core that shit might be the scariest analog ive ever seen and you guys really hit the nail on the head or whatever the saying is but im really suprised this shit was so well made and im glad to see this.
W vid, you should cover walten files too
Hi- just found you & subbed almost immediately - LOVE your content!! Watching this to crochet to 😊 Keep this content going, can't wait for more!
happy 100th 🔥🔥
Just wanna mention that the lights went out while I was listening to this video, scared the fuck out of me.
31:09 since you didn’t know what this meant, I’ll explain it a little. The “type 2: detectable” is from the old volume 1, not the renewed one. In the old one, it goes over 3 types of alternates. 1 being “doppelgänger”, 2 being “detectable”, and the 3rd one not getting a name.
Gabriel was right I dread THIS
Holy shit this series is awesome
ignore my comment, im saving my timestamp to come back later 44:48