Mercedes C-Class vs Audi A4 comparison REVIEW - what's the better premium sedan?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 2 лип 2024
  • This is our in-depth review of the Mercedes C-Class AMG-Line vs Audi A4 (S-Line interior). We're taking a look at Exterior, Interior and the driving experience.
    ►Follow us on Instagram @autogefuehl and @thomas.letsgo
    ►Subscribe here: ua-cam.com/users/autogefu...
    ►BMW M440i vs Audi S65: • BMW M440i vs Audi S5 R...
    ►Mercedes C43 review: • 2023 Mercedes C43 AMG ...
    00:00 Mercedes C-Class and Audi A4 battle it out!
    00:15 Sensual design for the CClass
    00:37 Bauhaus design for the A4
    01:10 Length and side profile comparison
    02:00 Rear CClass vs A4 and technology
    03:26 Turning indicators
    03:45 Key fobs
    04:00 Mercedes C-Class interior
    04:43 AMG-Line steering wheel
    05:00 Artico MB Tex seats with ventilation
    05:43 Seating position CClass
    06:06 Mercedes Cockpit and build quality
    07:40 MBUX infotainment system
    08:46 Voice control
    09:06 Digital instruments and HUD
    09:22 Rear seating C-Class
    10:37 Audi A4 s-line interior
    11:11 S-Line steering wheel
    11:25 Seats with fabric mix
    11:54 Seating position A4
    12:42 Audi Cockpit and build quality
    13:57 MMI infotainment system
    15:03 Digital instruments Virtual cockpit
    15:34 Rear seating A4
    16:54 Trunk / boot comparison C-Class vs A4
    18:21 Engine differences
    19:17 Driving Audi A4 on German Autobahn
    22:57 Fuel economy A4 50 TDI
    23:29 More high speed driving
    24:02 Steering feel and comparison BMW 3-Series
    25:27 User interface while driving
    26:06 Assistance systems
    27:32 quattro AWD differences
    29:16 Agile driving A4
    31:46 Driving Mercedes C-Class on German Autobahn
    33:56 Ambient lighting in the tunnel
    34:39 Build quality while driving
    36:29 Suspension comparison
    37:43 Assistance systems
    38:54 More high speed driving
    40:09 Which one is better to drive?
    43:40 Fuel economy C300
    44:14 Rear-axle steering
    45:05 Comparison previous generation C-Class
    46:00 Comfort C-Class vs A4 vs 3-Series
    47:22 Agile driving C-Class
    48:58 Digital vs analog?
    49:34 Which one would I take home?
    #Mercedes #Audi #MercedesCClass
    Transparency note: Autogefühl videos are independent and free from editorial influence on opinion and rating. But since manufacturers enable us to do the reviews in the first place, for legal reasons this video is marked as _advertisement_.
    WATCH OUT FOR SPAM/FAKE ACCOUNTS. Across UA-cam, you'll find fake accounts taking the identity of original channels, they use the same profile pic, similar names and include a telephone number in the name or their comments, trying to get you to message them on Whatsapp or Telegram. DO NOT MESSAGE THEM, they are trying to get your personal details, bank accounts etc. and in the end, they will ask for money. They promise you giveaways, prices etc. Do not fall for these cheap tricks and PLEASE HELP everyone and MARK THEIR MESSAGES and their whole accounts/channels as Spam. We from Autogefuehl will never ask for your bank details. Check out our original channel marked with the verified badge.
    We do have other official channels, so you can identify them and also subscribe if you like e.g. in your native language:
    2nd channel:
    / autogefuel
    Spanish: Auto Sensación - Prueba de coches a fondo
    / @autosensación
    Arabian: حس السيارات
    / @حسالسيارات
    Korea: 오토센스
    / @오토센스
    Japan: カー フィーリング
    / @car-feeling
    Russian: Анатомия Автомобиля
    / %d0%90%d0%bd%d0%b0%d1%...
    ►FULL REVIEWS 2022 Q3
    • FULL REVIEWS 2022 Q3
    ►FULL REVIEWS 2022 Q2
    • Mercedes EQE 500 AWD A...
    How to support Autogefühl?
    ►Subscribe, activate notifications (bell symbol) and bookmark our direct channel: www.autogefuehl.com
    ►Support us on Patreon: / autogefuehl
    ►Exclusive supporter: Ajlan Saeed
    What is Thomas wearing?
    ► Noah shoes www.noah-shop.com/
    Autogefühl viewers get a 20 % shoe discount with the following code: Autogefuehl-20
    Social Media & Blog
    ►Facebook: facebook.de/autogefuehl
    ►Twitter: / autogefuehl
    ►Instagram: / autogefuehl
    ►Instagram: / thomas.letsgo
    ►German Blog: autogefuehl.de
    Autogefühl is your no. 1 resource for in-depth car reviews and your no. 1 community to discuss cars. Each year we present you 150 cars from every segment and from a wide range of brands. If you have any suggestion, just write a comment or contact us on our other socials. Even if you have further remarks, just let us know.
  • Авто та транспорт

КОМЕНТАРІ • 536

  • @autogefuehl
    @autogefuehl  Рік тому +12

    ►Follow us on Instagram @autogefuehl and @thomas.letsgo
    ►Subscribe here: ua-cam.com/users/autogefuehl
    ►BMW M440i vs Audi S65: ua-cam.com/video/k2rzDPEcysk/v-deo.html
    ►Mercedes C43 review: ua-cam.com/video/fWcHHqUvO7g/v-deo.html
    00:00 Mercedes C-Class and Audi A4 battle it out!
    00:15 Sensual design for the CClass
    00:37 Bauhaus design for the A4
    01:10 Length and side profile comparison
    02:00 Rear CClass vs A4 and technology
    03:26 Turning indicators
    03:45 Key fobs
    04:00 Mercedes C-Class interior
    04:43 AMG-Line steering wheel
    05:00 Artico MB Tex seats with ventilation
    05:43 Seating position CClass
    06:06 Mercedes Cockpit and build quality
    07:40 MBUX infotainment system
    08:46 Voice control
    09:06 Digital instruments and HUD
    09:22 Rear seating C-Class
    10:37 Audi A4 interior
    11:11 S-Line steering wheel
    11:25 Seats with fabric mix
    11:54 Seating position A4
    12:42 Audi Cockpit and build quality
    13:57 MMI infotainment system
    15:03 Digital instruments Virtual cockpit
    15:34 Rear seating A4
    16:54 Trunk / boot comparison C-Class vs A4
    18:21 Engine differences
    19:17 Driving Audi A4 on German Autobahn
    22:57 Fuel economy A4 50 TDI
    23:29 More high speed driving
    24:02 Steering feel and comparison BMW 3-Series
    25:27 User interface while driving
    26:06 Assistance systems
    27:32 quattro AWD differences
    29:16 Agile driving A4
    31:46 Driving Mercedes C-Class on German Autobahn
    33:56 Ambient lighting in the tunnel
    34:39 Build quality while driving
    36:29 Suspension comparison
    37:43 Assistance systems
    38:54 More high speed driving
    40:09 Which one is better to drive?
    43:40 Fuel economy C300
    44:14 Rear-axle steering
    45:05 Comparison previous generation C-Class
    46:00 Comfort C-Class vs A4 vs 3-Series
    47:22 Agile driving C-Class
    48:58 Digital vs analog?
    49:34 Which one would I take home?
    #Mercedes #Audi #MercedesCClass
    Transparency note: Autogefühl videos are independent and free from editorial influence on opinion and rating. But since manufacturers enable us to do the reviews in the first place, for legal reasons this video is marked as _advertisement_.

    • @ekhoury1000
      @ekhoury1000 Рік тому

      Old A4 clear winner over all new C class.. Thomas needs more experience with both cars

    • @Ramzes945
      @Ramzes945 Рік тому

      Audi S65?

    • @jbabenchmark
      @jbabenchmark Рік тому

      You didn't talk about the voice system of the Mercedes

    • @alexk.9952
      @alexk.9952 Рік тому

      ua-cam.com/video/mYzFAhMdF14/v-deo.html
      There are some channels that appear to republish your content. I think that we as viewers cant report them doing as such. So here is the link, so you could do this. Lets hope UA-cam fixes this soon.

    • @kreigerbailey3550
      @kreigerbailey3550 Рік тому +1

      Portland, JAMAICA in the Building!!!

  • @coreyk288
    @coreyk288 Рік тому +144

    There is something about the displays in the Mercedes that is somehow impressive and detracting at the same time. Personally both cars are great, but just coming down to interaction points would make the difference for me. Interaction points and visual integration of the tech is better in the audi, while the Mercedes would probably be more stunning in a show room but more cumbersome in day to day use.

  • @kurtkomaromi3690
    @kurtkomaromi3690 Рік тому +78

    I recently purchased an A4 Sport line 45 and absolutely love it. Thomas nailed all of the best features in his review. Great combination of sport and comfort, direct driving feel, and tech that's easy to use.

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому +4

      highly appreciated !

    • @munch666nath
      @munch666nath Рік тому

      I bought a a4 black edition 40 tdi quattro, loving it

    • @blueboy189
      @blueboy189 9 місяців тому +1

      Just ordered an A4 Avant S-Line 40 as a replacement for my 330i M Sport. Wanted to upgrade to an M340i Estate but the monthly price was ridiculous.
      I'm a bit concerned about the drop in power from my outgoing car, but at least now I know that overall it's adecent car.

  • @NotCommanderShepard
    @NotCommanderShepard Рік тому +79

    I really like the MB, but the sheer amount of touch sensitive buttons for frequently used functions such as AC, seat controls etc. make no sense on the user-end, it sucks.

  • @chrispnw2547
    @chrispnw2547 Рік тому +77

    I believe Mercedes made a mistake going all screen and capacitive buttons. Honda seems to have learned this and current new vehicles have the right mix of screens and physical buttons. Quality at Mercedes has suffered at the expense of style and bling.

    • @IhabFahmy
      @IhabFahmy Рік тому +1

      Agree... except that there's more "bling" than "style" in both vehicles, and unfortunately doubly so in the new C-class. After the B6 generation of the A4 and the W203 generation of the Mercedes, all their style and elegance went downhill.

    • @coyote6154
      @coyote6154 Рік тому +2

      I drive a C class estate, and I don't see any downside for the bigass center screen.
      It's extremely handy for GPS navigation and for rear camera display, and if you don't feel like talking to your car, most of the control can be done through buttons on the steering wheel anyway.
      As for those saying that it won't age well, or will become junk, well it's been more than a year now, and it feels and looks as great as it did a year ago.
      So I understand that not everyone like this style, and that many prefer the designs of BMW, Audi or whatever, but as for the quality, it's there. Undeniably.

    • @bighands69
      @bighands69 Рік тому +1

      @@coyote6154
      When the car is moving it is easier to feel switches and buttons but that is not the same with capacitance and touch screen controls. They are fine when you are sitting still but not when you are driving.

  • @mikelobb8849
    @mikelobb8849 Рік тому +32

    Hey Thomas, I agree with you. I have a 2018 Audi A4 here in the US, and absolutely love the car. The style, precision in driving and ergonomics, and fit and finish are second to none. My friend has a Mercedes and my uncle has a BMW, and I've driven both, and I chose the Audi simply for the driving feel. Thank you for your insightful reviews and for proving my choice was correct! Keep up the great work!

  • @Danny.Nissan
    @Danny.Nissan Рік тому +3

    Just wanted to say that I was looking at buying used cars and your older videos of A6, E-class and S90 helped me find my first car - a 2020 A6 Saloon. So these comparison videos are really useful.

  • @jimf7654
    @jimf7654 Рік тому +57

    Thomas, really appreciate the level of detail and thorough test drives. I prefer the Audi for the driving dynamics and ergonomics, however I feel the exterior could use another refresh and hasn’t changed much over recent years.

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому +2

      Thanks m8!

    • @Doa744
      @Doa744 Рік тому +2

      Lol i never expected someone would ever say audi drives dynamic. Front wheel drive and dynamic care to explain?

    • @timeyinsholaye9169
      @timeyinsholaye9169 Рік тому +1

      @@Doa744 he said what he said

    • @darwenrover8910
      @darwenrover8910 Рік тому +2

      If you want driving dynamics, go for a BMW, Jaguar or Alfa Romeo.

  • @MarcosDemiato
    @MarcosDemiato Рік тому +10

    I own an Audi A4 like this one here in Brazil and I’m absolutely satisfied. 👌🏻

  • @johnj6518
    @johnj6518 Рік тому +16

    Always the best reviews on UA-cam! Thank you Sir. You are the reason I purchased a B9 Audi A4 and still enjoying the “analog” drive!

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому +2

      Cheers! And congratulations 😎

  • @drivetime6858
    @drivetime6858 Рік тому +37

    Audi models just never disapoint, with every generations they become more beautiful, they stick to their style. Not the best in a class but sure they never look bad.

    • @LCOF
      @LCOF Рік тому +3

      Audi's have always disappointed until very recently. The new RS3 is the new benchmark for Audi handling. This A4 clearly has decent steering feel and doesn't understeer as much as previous A4's. Traditionally Audi's have been front heavy with numb handling. They've always been screwed together brilliantly though.

    • @drivetime6858
      @drivetime6858 Рік тому

      @@LCOF and i never mention engine, steering.. As I said they are not best in the class, sure MB & BMW are better in most parts. I talked about design how they look, not their specifications.. You don’t need to shere informations like steering! It doesent match my comment. Seems like you dont like Audi.

    • @hiamaraldvaan7221
      @hiamaraldvaan7221 Рік тому

      Front lamps make this model look class lower in comparision with previous version.

    • @drivetime6858
      @drivetime6858 Рік тому

      @@hiamaraldvaan7221 idk, i like more restyle version..

    • @hiamaraldvaan7221
      @hiamaraldvaan7221 Рік тому

      @@drivetime6858 all look great, i dont like only those front lamps

  • @johndoe53831
    @johndoe53831 Рік тому +9

    I can agree that comfort of the seats in Audi is spectacular. I drove over 1500 km at once with short breaks and came out from my Q5 relaxed!

  • @luxpremium5714
    @luxpremium5714 5 місяців тому +3

    Finally someone that lays it true instead of getting lulled by the s class design elements. The audi still feels better overall driving and material wise in the interior. It comes down to whether the driver wants the more connected feel of driving with the audi or if they prefer a more of car driving you around feeling of the merc. The only thing I don't like about the A4 is that the tablet design sticking out of the dashboard is a big no. I have the new A3 and I love it so much more for the interior tech design upgrades.

  • @paulgrewal4339
    @paulgrewal4339 Рік тому +11

    Just bought the S-Line prestige and I attest, it drives phenomenal. You feel as if it’s gripping the road and you get crazy driving confidence. I’m fairly young (31) and the technology is just right. Anymore screen or larger screens, you lose my interest. I love the physical buttons and the interior is elegant yet, very luxurious. Now that being said, I think the Mercedes looks better on the outside. It’s more young, sporty and sexy. But when you buy an Audi, the decision comes with humility. The decision is to treat yourself and not others. Let’s just say the right people will be impressed.

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому +2

      Thanks for the feedback!

    • @japanluv
      @japanluv 5 місяців тому +1

      Still happy with it? What engine and is it quattro and if yes, what gearbox please if automatic? Thanks.

    • @paulgrewal587
      @paulgrewal587 5 місяців тому +2

      Quattro, Automatic, Inline 4 and runs 0-100 in 5.2 seconds. Every moment I sit in it, makes me happy. I love my car

    • @paulgrewal587
      @paulgrewal587 5 місяців тому

      Quattro, Automatic, Inline 4 and runs 0-100 in 5.2 seconds. Every moment I sit in it, makes me happy. I love my car

    • @paulgrewal587
      @paulgrewal587 5 місяців тому

      Quattro, Automatic, Inline 4 and runs 0-100 in 5.2 seconds. Every moment I sit in it, makes me happy. I love my car

  • @mmaea
    @mmaea Рік тому +9

    You couldn’t have said it better: The A4 is the pinnacle of Bauhaus design. Everything is simple and oozes quality.

  • @christianwinter6242
    @christianwinter6242 2 місяці тому +1

    Wow, i'm thrilled with the way the vehicles are presented. Very good job Thomas, the details you present are very important for prospective buyers and are missing from other car tests.

  • @Andy-zi1wj
    @Andy-zi1wj Рік тому +4

    The suspension and wheel size makes a massive difference in refinement on the A4 I had a 2016 A4 3.0 tdi 272 s-line 19inch wheels you could always hear the tyres and the ride was firm. I'm now about to get 35 tsi technik with comfort dynamic suspension and 17 inch wheels it rides alot nicer and has next to no tyre noise.

  • @billsheehy1
    @billsheehy1 Рік тому +12

    Thomas you are brilliant. Love your honesty and great eyes for detail. Thanks

  • @izuaff04
    @izuaff04 Рік тому +46

    mercedes and their disco interior...

  • @dwade3202
    @dwade3202 Рік тому +15

    audi wins just by having physical buttons, I cannot stand that dumb TV in the new mercedes interior, I can't express how much I hate this trend.

    • @santanacorreia
      @santanacorreia Рік тому

      Cars without volume knob are a no go for me.

  • @samirmahdi8405
    @samirmahdi8405 Рік тому +2

    Thanks for your efforts, you always do great things...شكرا على مجهوداتك دائما تقدم اشياء رائعه

  • @long_fellow
    @long_fellow Рік тому +3

    Although I've never gone over 120km/h in my life, I still really enjoy watching these Autobahn rides!

  • @Simpson77Jack
    @Simpson77Jack 4 місяці тому

    Bought a 2022 A4 2.0T TFSI 4 days ago and literally everything you said is so spot on. Loved the video. Great review of both!

  • @golfbuddy1969
    @golfbuddy1969 Рік тому +14

    I bought a new S4 a couple months ago and very happy with my purchase. The small details are done better by Audi, than by MB and BMW. It sounds great, is the perfect balance of luxury and sport, and real exhaust pipes too.

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому +2

      Great car. Congrats!

    • @Chloiber
      @Chloiber Рік тому +1

      As a pre-facelift 3 series driver, I have to agree with the current generation. I believe BMW had nailed it nearly perfectly with the G20/G21 input-wise. The facelift seems such a massive step backwards - I'm really disappointed in this and it's also really hard to comprehend the decision making process behind it. Audi seems to have the lead again in this regard regarding the climate controls, but it's again sad that the controls in the center are gone.

    • @golfbuddy1969
      @golfbuddy1969 Рік тому +2

      @@Chloiber I had been looking seriously at BMW, it was in fact, the car I really wanted. It’s difficult to top their straight 6…in fact, It cannot be topped. But there’s other parts of driving that matter beyond the engine. This Audi feels special every time I get in it, and quite frankly, the bmw didn’t feel special at all. A bonus is that I don’t see an S4 on every corner neither.

    • @johnguidetti5839
      @johnguidetti5839 Рік тому

      @@golfbuddy1969 don’t kid yourself a M340i is Miles better than a S4. Drives better, quicker, better infotainment with a idrive controller and interior quality touch points are softer.

    • @golfbuddy1969
      @golfbuddy1969 Рік тому +1

      @@johnguidetti5839 I drove one…more than one. It’s a great car. The best engine. But I don’t like the looks to be honest. I tried but I just don’t. It’s steering isn’t as good. Brake feel isn’t as good neither. Seats are way better in the Audi, with massage function and leather that doesn’t feel like plastic. BMW leather is an offense to anyone spending that much for a car. Plus, 3 series are on every corner, at every stoplight, and in every subdivision. Sorry, but wasn’t for me. I drive both and initially was looking for bmw, but it doesn’t feel special. The Audi feels special every time I get in it.

  • @FilipFJ357
    @FilipFJ357 Рік тому +4

    Excellent comparasion with a lot of details good&bad 💯👌 such a rare approach and honestly review!

  • @johnlambert5674
    @johnlambert5674 Рік тому +13

    Excellent detailed revue Thomas, I like your analysis. In the past I've had many Audi A4 and now I have a C class ( albeit a previous model) and I think you are spot-on. Like other people I don't like the change to total touch screens instead of simple buttons, they've all gone just too far. However the biggest issue for me here in the UK is that both Audi and Mercedes offer predominantly dismal black interiors. I prefer lighter interiors and these are just not available particularly on AMG models where Mercedes seems to think everyone wants 'boy-racer' black. £50,000 and I can only get black !

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому

      Good point my friend!

    • @ApurtureSci
      @ApurtureSci Рік тому +1

      Totally agree, I'm sick of brands only offering black interiors here! Admitted they do sell the best, but luxury brands should be about choice. I'm ordering a company car soon and I'm thinking of going for a 'Sport Edition' A4 since it has the regular comfort suspension and you can spec a beige interior free of charge - go to S Line and you lose those!

  • @mackjsm7105
    @mackjsm7105 Рік тому +2

    Getting new 2023 Audi A4 in two days.. my 2017 A4 was great! TY for finally making reliable cars.

  • @fabiobernardes974
    @fabiobernardes974 Рік тому +1

    Great review as always! Keep going

  • @mbojilov1
    @mbojilov1 Рік тому +20

    Your point about the importance of steering feel at the 25:13 mark is exactly how I feel when comparing autos. And as a lifelong 3 series fan and owner, I am very disappointed that the 3 series is no longer the steering benchmark in the segment (but it used to be… across nearly all segments). I still like my F30 Sport Line, but I doubt my next car will be a BMW.
    An excellent comprehensive review as always!

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому +6

      Cheers and agree!!

    • @RakeshSharma-iy1fj
      @RakeshSharma-iy1fj Рік тому

      Is the audi a4 the new benchmark in this segment ?

    • @bapr3887
      @bapr3887 Рік тому

      3 Series never was been benchmark in the segment. Audi B8 has a lot better steering than E90 too. B6/B7 with servotronic again had better steering than E46. Nimble B5 with 260 cm short wheelbase has AGAIN better steering fell than E36. "benchmark of segment" is just internet myths and bs.

    • @mbojilov1
      @mbojilov1 Рік тому +1

      Wrong. Prior to the electrified steering F30, the 3-series was the definitive benchmark, not just with respect to steering but also overall agility, cornering, etc. Even since the F30 I’d still rather have that than an A4 but the difference is no longer that big.

    • @bapr3887
      @bapr3887 Рік тому

      @@mbojilov1 F30 is a lot newer car than old 2007 B8. B8 is E90 era.

  • @siddharthr1853
    @siddharthr1853 Рік тому +20

    Damn, I wanted this alongside bmw 330i as well

  • @fuhrerhosty
    @fuhrerhosty Рік тому +9

    I definitely prefer the Bauhaus design of the Audi.

  • @elroz1675
    @elroz1675 Рік тому +2

    very relevant comparison! excellent details and observations.

  • @wim955
    @wim955 Рік тому +2

    Thx for your quality review again. It happens to be the case I am awaiting my A4 avant s-line to be delivered in a couple of days😀

  • @gkrieger6824
    @gkrieger6824 Рік тому +14

    Exterior, Audi all day long. Especially in Tango Red. Interior, looks wise, the MB takes it. BUT, the touchscreen to control everything and the capacitive buttons for windows, seats, ect would be maddening. Have to go Audi again. Build quality, hands down Audi. The question is, which will prove to be more reliable in the long run. Great review as usual Thomas!!

  • @yegutierrez87
    @yegutierrez87 Рік тому +5

    Hi Thomas, please do a comparison review like this one for Audi A4 vs BMW 3 series, it will be much apprieciated.

  • @bevinseejackson7625
    @bevinseejackson7625 Рік тому +1

    Nice and detail review I have ever viewed... great job sir

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому +1

      thanks! Feel free to recommend our channel :-)

  • @broadbent2001
    @broadbent2001 9 місяців тому +2

    Agree with your choice completely! I am an Audi guy and they never disappoint! Great channel and reviews.

  • @carverparkes2276
    @carverparkes2276 Рік тому +2

    Excellent presentation skills!!

  • @BinhTran-io4ck
    @BinhTran-io4ck Рік тому +1

    Awesome review! Thanks!

  • @DanielL.
    @DanielL. Рік тому +2

    Nice! Keep up the good work 👌

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому +1

      thanks feel free to recommend !=)

  • @ikgeignirengiu
    @ikgeignirengiu Рік тому +3

    Give me the c-class front and back with the side profile of the a4!
    Great review

  • @Crackers2549
    @Crackers2549 Рік тому +6

    Personally I prefer the Audi A4... I agree with you.... Very nice comparison... I currently own an A4 and in a couple days am trading it for a A5 Sportback... Really enjoyed my 2019 A4, terrific car... Thank you for this excellent video.... GG...IN... USA

  • @Cls17953
    @Cls17953 Рік тому +5

    I'm a few months late but my 2 cents: I have had the 2022 Mercedes C300 since August 2022 (I ordered it in August 2021!) and would return it tomorrow if I could (mine is the mid-level trim package, 3-year lease). All of the touch controls and software are super glitchy and the braking is an abomination. The squishy pedal feel when applying brake pressure is the worst experience I have ever had and totally disconcerting. If this is attributable to the regenerative braking caused as a result of the mild hybrid engine, hard to believe that Mercedes engineers could not figure out how to make the brakes better. For the brake problem alone, I would not recommend this car. The glitchy software and touch controls along with the extended MBUX system learning curve seal the deal: do not buy (or lease). I am unfamiliar with the Audi A4 but I enjoyed this comparison review very much. I do love watching videos of the excessive speeds achieved on the Autobahn (I especially love the reviewers driving one handed). For me: I live on Long Island in New York and for anyone whose driven on the Long Island Expressway (along with many other Long Island roads built in the 1930s) watching these videos is a fantasy.

  • @johnb2572
    @johnb2572 Рік тому +2

    Love your reviews

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому +1

      🙏🙏🙏 please recommend ☺️

  • @TundeEszlari
    @TundeEszlari Рік тому +3

    You are a very good videographer.🤗❤

  • @nvkulk
    @nvkulk Рік тому +1

    Great as usual

  • @HH-hk3gr
    @HH-hk3gr Рік тому +1

    C300 Rwd with amg line package is the best choice of new C class,because AMG Line package - which brings a number of visual tweaks in addition to a 15mm drop in ride height, upgraded brakes, and retuned steering😊

  • @hieuphungminh6690
    @hieuphungminh6690 Рік тому +3

    You get the Audi A4 if you want a great car. You get the C-class if you want a Mercedes. If I can only pick 1, it's going to be the A4.

  • @mikee6220
    @mikee6220 Рік тому +12

    I love Thomas and the integrity he has to give a true critique. Yes Mercedes’ did decline. Yes the Audi clicks is symphonic! German is always quality over gimmicks. I believe the Audi demonstrates that more. Keep in mind I’ve owned only Mercedes’ for years. However I feel the A4 is more spiritually akin to the w201 and w202 than the new c class.

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому

      🙏🙏

    • @ikarugaxx3749
      @ikarugaxx3749 Рік тому

      Mercedes and BMW are giving heavier preference to the Eastern markets than Audi are. I don't know how the 3 brands do fare commercially in the East (China firstly). Audi are keeping more faithful to the history of European, and German, car-making. I don't think this bet on genuine identity will be a mistake, I think it's the best bet to make.

  • @andrewwheeler8591
    @andrewwheeler8591 Рік тому +28

    Real exhausts, real buttons, sharper styling, Audi all day long Thomas 👌. Tip Top yet again 👍. Regards

  • @justindaniel5959
    @justindaniel5959 Рік тому +1

    thanks for the truth! Great in depth review

  • @therealicon4781
    @therealicon4781 Рік тому +4

    Audi A4 has always been the least desirable of the German trios. 3 series, c class, audi A4. Audi has one last chance with the next audi a4 generation but very difficult with how good the c class and 3 series look currently.

  • @Chasing-Red
    @Chasing-Red Рік тому +3

    Good review. Suggestion: same color makes it better for viewers to see the lines clearer and the decision of which car fits them. Regardless thorough review. Good job.

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому +2

      Thanks 🙏 but it’s harder to differentiate the cars then 😅

  • @Darkheart80
    @Darkheart80 Рік тому +1

    Nice and complete review video, Clark Kent! A little bit to long for me, but it's fine!

  • @MoroccoGamer
    @MoroccoGamer Рік тому +2

    nice review

  • @molokochris
    @molokochris Рік тому +3

    seems like mercedes lost the fight as soon as you noticed that the vents arent straight..😂loved this review... you have gained a subscriber in me.

  • @JonnyBeoulve
    @JonnyBeoulve Рік тому +2

    You're one of the best car UA-camrs.

  • @SomeUnremarkableGuy
    @SomeUnremarkableGuy Рік тому +1

    I really love how MB stick to the skeumorphic design. I am tired of everything going with flat generic design.

  • @edysinsimon8646
    @edysinsimon8646 Рік тому +2

    Unless the new A-4 is updated for the exterior treatment the C class lust appeals to my eye more. It's a more classically refined design.

  • @YourSoulDriver
    @YourSoulDriver 9 місяців тому

    Nice comparison. I don't understand why the 6 cylinder engine is not available on the A4 in the US (is only available with the S4; A4's only get 40/45 TFSI I4's with on-demand Quattro)

  • @Dkliptus
    @Dkliptus Рік тому

    Design-wise I really like the C front. But I am not sure I’d pick one of the two.

  • @Biscuits645
    @Biscuits645 Рік тому +2

    What seems crazy to me is how interactive those screens are. How is that any different from being on your phone? I think physical dials are so much safer and I personally prefer them. It looks very nice though.

  • @FaberFest
    @FaberFest Рік тому

    video stupendo, bravo !

  • @DavidV4444
    @DavidV4444 Рік тому +4

    MB for me, love my C43!

  • @deepspacenine4313
    @deepspacenine4313 9 місяців тому +1

    Nice review Thomas. I just ordered an A4 40 TDI Quattro Ultra. Why? Best sport seats (leather) comfort wise, best suspension (sport adaptive dampers) and last but not least best steering feel, exactly as you described. Though there is no more dynamic steering, but the standard one is fine as well. Beyond that, it has far less weight than the competitors, even with AWD. I had also an G20 for 6 months, but the steering is really annoying, even after professional alignment you need corrections constantly while drivng straight ahead - this is a mess and not only with my G20. I tested several ones in order to buy one, but I simply can't get used to it. The same is with the Z4 G29 - strange center steering at all. The new C-Class is out of scope: to expensive, too heavy and the look and feel is somewhat strange by itself and feels cheap (like VW and Audi do with their new series).

  • @kevinhearts616
    @kevinhearts616 Рік тому +11

    Convinced Audi all the way. Thank you Thomas, for always giving us unbuyased n detailed information on your reviews. 🙏 💯

  • @kingares9768
    @kingares9768 Рік тому +4

    32:36 The truck driver is filming a truck review 😅

  • @timjones8837
    @timjones8837 Рік тому +4

    Fantastic detail in ypur review as always!! I would prefer the Audi too, even though the shape if the C Class is very appealing...

  • @zhaoyangxie
    @zhaoyangxie Рік тому

    13:56 subtle flexing of the iPhone 14 Pro 😂

  • @joeykitty2892
    @joeykitty2892 Рік тому +3

    As much as I like the C-Class, I'd choose the A4, primarily due to the ease of operation; analog.

  • @zimcoder
    @zimcoder Рік тому +1

    On the exterior design, the merc just looks like more car than the A4. from the side profile, the A4 looks so ordinary, like a car from 1998.

  • @Harrythehun
    @Harrythehun Рік тому +1

    What are the typical; Prices? Running costs? Servicing? Insurance? Estimated reselling price? How is going to buy this car? Is there any alternatives?

  • @6ixtynine
    @6ixtynine Рік тому +3

    Nice comparison but I disagree on the ride comfort settings. I like it how there is a big difference between comfort and sport in the C class. If you want constant balance there is no point in having the different dynamic options to select.

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому +2

      Thanks for the feedback!

    • @ikarugaxx3749
      @ikarugaxx3749 Рік тому +1

      I agree with you on that. Sporty is sportier (rougher), comfort is more on-the-clouds like (comfortier, let's say).

  • @caiolinnertel8777
    @caiolinnertel8777 11 місяців тому +1

    Oh, the analogue nature is what I like as well. I looked at a Tesla once, and just don’t like having to go through menus for some things.

  • @jling0427
    @jling0427 Рік тому +3

    this reviewer is very unbiased..... Probably the only reviewer i have seen that would go with this old audi A4 instead of flashy C-class.

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому

      🙏👍 please recommend our channel 🤗

  • @sunghokim4011
    @sunghokim4011 Рік тому +4

    The most recent generation of MB's interiors are gimmicky. In particular, from "less is more" stand point of view, I would assign a grade of F to them. MB should work on learning what to reduce, what to remove, and what to focus on. In this regard, Audi is clear the winner. Thank you, Thomas, for a great review.

    • @thorns66
      @thorns66 Рік тому +2

      They seem to be catering to more middle-eastern/eastern audiences, where "more is more"

    • @jrex3575
      @jrex3575 Рік тому

      for years I couldn't stand the glare bouncing off all the MB glossy piano black and chrome trim interiors!

  • @user-ie2ic1ty8r
    @user-ie2ic1ty8r Рік тому

    Great review Thomas, as always!, why Audi does not have a exterior S-line? At least it does not looks like it have even if you said it is S-line. My recent personal choice was Audi A4 Avant 45 tfsi Quattro (we can’t buy 50tdi here in Sweden it only available on Allroad model), due to exact, interior, ergonomics and natural driving experience.

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому

      Yeah in the US they dont offer sline exterior afaik but they do in germany eg

  • @richardm2661
    @richardm2661 Рік тому +3

    I really enjoy the interior on the A4

  • @CAS482
    @CAS482 Рік тому

    When you borrow these cars from the dealerships you should take the time to go thru the technology with the personal there. To have the panoramic roof or screen to open you just use the MBUX system and say (Hey Merecedes) open/close the roof or screen. The system will cut on the heat for the car and heated seats, control temp of the car and seats, control the radio stations/volume and more all you have to do is ask.

  • @EVANHAWKSLEY
    @EVANHAWKSLEY 8 місяців тому

    I had a c300. It was my first German car and I LOVED it. I’ve thought about getting another, but now I’m interested in Audi. Am I going to miss the interior of the C class?

  • @baron_xd4633
    @baron_xd4633 Рік тому +2

    im surprised about the air vent knobs being misplaced aswell. hopefully mercedes fixes this issue in production. but mercedes really nailed the visuals - audi looks 10 years older in comparison, especially inside.

    • @themercedestraveler9566
      @themercedestraveler9566 Рік тому +1

      This. I love the quality and such of the A4. But man it looks so dated to me. The inside is horrible. A premium...audi, as this youtuber reminds us, should not have such a dated looking interior. Audi can definitely do better

  • @Beyond_matter_111
    @Beyond_matter_111 Рік тому +1

    Very informative comparison Thomas, thank you!
    You mentioned that the suspension in the A4 is the perfect balance between comfort and handling. I was wondering if it's even better than the air suspension in the A6. I mean, sure the air suspension gives you that "flying carpet" ride and is very soft over bumps, but the overall comfort, i suppose is defined by various factors. Such as, the absence of body roll in the corners, how fast the car settles down after hitting a road imperfection, the impact of G-forces on the passengers and so on. Taking all of these into consideration, do you think that an adaptive suspension in the A4 is a more comfortable set up than the air suspension in a A6?

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому +1

      Thanks 🙏

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому +1

      The A6 air suspension is defo more comfortable. Also the normal adaptive suspension in the A6

    • @Beyond_matter_111
      @Beyond_matter_111 Рік тому

      @@autogefuehl Thanks for the feedback! All the best!

  • @seymourward7091
    @seymourward7091 2 місяці тому

    One word "outstanding!"

  • @zaitsev8128
    @zaitsev8128 Рік тому

    Hello Thomas, can you make a comparison video of all quattro systems which cars wear what? From your experience which quattro is better, A4 3.0 petrol-A4 2.0 petrol or rs3? Keep up the good work!

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому +1

      Thanks! 3.0 always because that is rear wheel biased / permanent awd !

  • @p.k.7111
    @p.k.7111 Рік тому +3

    Somehow a4 looks next to the new c class so much smaller. In my view a4 desperately needs a successor, those body lines no matter how many face lifts Audi will do, look outdated.

  • @luciancormos1648
    @luciancormos1648 Рік тому +2

    I received for a several days business trip a similar A4 (from the rental company) and I was a bit dissapointed, doesn't feel so expensive as the price tag shows. After a cople of weeks I received also an almost similar Mercedes (C300 4matic, only AMG line) and I realised that actually A4 was not so bad.

  • @ikgeignirengiu
    @ikgeignirengiu Рік тому +1

    Fingers crossed for a genesis gv70ev driving review!

  • @caiolinnertel8777
    @caiolinnertel8777 11 місяців тому +2

    I’ve had Audis since 1984. I’ve looked at MB but upstairs prefer Audis. They just seem to always suit me, or I’m just too invested in Audis and can’t drive anything else.

    • @animeman197
      @animeman197 Місяць тому

      I can see why you have been driving Audis for so long! I'm 38, own a 2017 Audi A4. I love the ride, my friend loves it. He's seen my father's Q5 and he would buy either one if my father or me were selling. My buddy actually was going to get an S4 in 2015 but decided not to because of a blown head gasket. Audis just look so nice and are fun to drive.

  • @b286guy
    @b286guy Рік тому +1

    Big hopes for the next A4 on the new B10 platform, but I’m concerned Audi cost cutting lately will diminish it. If so, BMW will reign supreme in the class for some time to come.

  • @dixierebelchic6423
    @dixierebelchic6423 Рік тому +2

    I work for a dealer's auction in Mobile, AL USA. I've had the privilege of driving them both. I do not like the seat controls on the door nor the vents & the large screen in the Benz. The seat of the Audi first me like a glove, the steering wheel is just fabulous & the smooth ride of the A4 is impeccable. After driving Alfas, BMWs, VWs, Benz & Audi of all types I am awaiting financing for a 2015 A4 premium plus. Mint condition with the walnut interior. I fell in absolute love with this car, & tracked down the dealer who purchased it. So impressive. ❤️

  • @gundalfx
    @gundalfx Рік тому +2

    I love the new Mercedes instrument/dashboard design but it looks the best on the c class, the e and s class have on the passenger side that weird empty chunk of plastic surface, am I the only one who sees it that way? On the EQS and SQS you can at least „fix“ that by getting the hyperscreen, but that comes with its own set of issues.

    • @siddharthgoyal4008
      @siddharthgoyal4008 Рік тому +2

      Hyperscreen is pure ugly, it's like trying to be Tesla but shittier.

    • @Carfan678
      @Carfan678 Рік тому +1

      The passenger side of this is also just trim so 🤷🏼‍♂️ but I do agree the tablet fits best in c class personally I think it looks the worst in the new SL just doesn’t fit the shape of the dash imo 😢

  • @steveluth3139
    @steveluth3139 Рік тому +3

    90s kid so I love the more angular lined car :p A4 for me

  • @georgeyung3546
    @georgeyung3546 Рік тому +1

    Any quality insights to cars.

  • @Florislaurens
    @Florislaurens Рік тому +1

    Unbelievable how well the A4 ages. It's still a very pretty car, even in comparison to the ultra modern W206. That said, why for Pete's sake do literally ALL modern cars have to be "sporty"? I hate sporty. Sporty nowadays almost always ends up in somewhat tacky, trashy or posh design details. Yuck! I want a car to be elegant, well proportioned and modest in a distinguished way. So no fake exhausts for me, or pops and bangs, phony diffusers, blinded intakes, comfort ruining oversized wheels and tyres and so on.... Anyone feeling the same? 😊

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому

      Yeah i also can’t imagine that more customers ask for sportiness than comfort

  • @jamiep61
    @jamiep61 Рік тому +1

    I enjoyed watching the Video Comparison. The Mercedes Is my favourite as I like the latest Mercedes Design 😊

  • @redrum3835
    @redrum3835 Рік тому +1

    🤣 🤣 🤣 right when I herd the alarm I knew there was going to be fake exhaust ports.

  • @andyz9455
    @andyz9455 Рік тому +1

    Thomas, the Audi A4 is not optioned with S-line. Look at the bumper and the grill, there is no 3-hole design above the grill.

    • @autogefuehl
      @autogefuehl  Рік тому +1

      Argh yes, the sporty black pack look irritated me

  • @MateuszMarek
    @MateuszMarek Рік тому +1

    Shame the next A4 will have touch-sensitive everything instead of a proper "clicky" AC controls and steering wheel buttons.

  • @ryans7097
    @ryans7097 Рік тому +1

    I like these comparisons. The real question is when will Mercedes start listening to us? I have literally not seen one review say they like the capacitive buttons more than a regular button. So bizarre to me that Mercedes seems to be pushing this on consumers for no reason.

  • @Mandela_House
    @Mandela_House Рік тому +1

    Great review. I prefer the MB digital screens. This is the future and MB are aiming at the younger generation who are used to this type of tech - ie mobile phones etc. The Audi tech looks dated but is nice. It’s the MB for me.