Institutional Crisis in Pakistan Ft. Prof Ilhan Niaz | 03 | TG Podcast
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 лип 2024
- Join us for an insightful conversation with Dr. Ilhan Niaz as we explore some hard-hitting questions about Pakistan's institutional meltdown and the state's struggles.
Why are our neighbors stronger than our own state?
How did the establishment become so powerful?
What went wrong along the way?
Chapters
00:00 Intro
01:48 Why our Neighbors are performing better
4:16 Is the Indian threat an actual threat or a Paranoia
5:34 Why did we go to the Afgan war
7:46 How Pakistan deviated from Secular to a Religious state
15:46 Is civilian government a colonial legacy?
22:55 Liaqat Ali's policy of nationalizing armed forces
25:58 Is real estate the real reason for the economic downfall
28:38 Corporate farming
29:00 Are we heading towards constitutional crisis
38:55 Why does the popular rhetoric appeal the masses
44:13 Is our intelligence getting weak
46:43 Khalistan Sentiments
Summary for FASTIANS assignment:
1- why our neighbors are performing better? They have had political stability unlike us.
2-Is the Indian threat real? Yes to some extent but the way we dealt with it led to negative consequences (speration of Bangladesh )
3-why did we go to afghan war? Strategic move by alligning with US although at the cost of negative impacts on society and culture.
4-Pakistan religious or secular? Initially India and Pakistan were both secular. Later on Pakistani leaders focused on making religious state. Implementation of religion however led to many problems due to Pakistan's vast diversity. In 1973 Pakistan was made a communal state.
5-Is civilian government a colonial legacy? Problems with civillian government now is no politician has ever had the wisdom to understand the purpose behind elections . Whoever loses doesn't accept defeat and says dhaandli hui hai, whoever wins says it is fair . People abuse power to stay in power. Chaos
6-Liaqat Ali's nationalization of the military ->Origin of political interference in army- promoted very low level officers to high ranks based on the politicians' likes and dislikes in 1951. Disturbed norms that destabilized entire system forever.
7- is real estate a reason for Pakistan's economic downfall? Real estate buisness is very common but not regulated and properly taxed. If done so, a great amount of revenue can be generated since much money is in this sector.
8- are we heading towards constitutional crisis? yes civilian leaders are dheet and do harkatein to protect their own power and interests. They are leading to constitutional crisis due to lack of political wisdom. According to them judiciary is good when it rules in their favour and is evil when rules against them. Bankrupt political class.
9-Why does the popular rhetoric appeal to the masses?idk random cheezein boli hain idher unrelated khud dekh lena
10- is our intelligence getting weak? Taliban are resurging and targeting hard targets(police, military) this is something the state needs to take seriously because it sends a strong message(unrelated to the question I know Lekin itna hee bola hai)
11- Khalistsn sentiment - indians will give a ferocious response if an attempt to make the Khalistsn state is made(pata nai Kya hai yaar ye)
So proud of your team. Doing Great. Ma Sha Allah
Thanks, means alot.
I read Mr. ILhan Niaz alot. Loved to listen him as well. Thank you for this❤️
Very interesting discussion by Doctor Ilhan Niaz Sir. Thanks admin for sharing it.
FASTIANS... assignment ki tayari kr rahay ho😂
If only someone could write the entire summary in the comments😔✊
Very good reply on Khalistan … appreciated 😂. Anchor is very much interested in Khalistan movement… better Khalistan will make on Canada , UK or In Pakistan only