Speechless - A Short Film

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 28

  • @CharlieX888
    @CharlieX888 6 років тому +63

    I'm not sure Selective Mutism really works like that....I've never heard of anyone being unable to speak at all ever. Selective mutes will usually have a few "select" people they can talk to. Also, It's very unlikely she'll just grow out of it. My selective Mutism was never sorted out as a child and I still have it at 27. A very nice film though. I've often worried If I would be able to call the emergency services in a situation like that...I hope she was able to :)

    • @Lincorn1
      @Lincorn1 5 років тому +5

      well some dont speak to anyone at all... not even their parents. Im not sure yet if i have selective mutism, but it seems familiar.. i didnt speak very much to anyone at all, atleast through my pre teenage&teenage years. I still feel quite awkward speaking and dont know what to talk about and my head turns into chaos. I was also left untreated regardless of what it is that i have... i didnt get the right kind of treatment for sure.

    • @Zampirezz
      @Zampirezz 5 років тому +2

      I’m don’t speak to anyone..

    • @pinkberry1098
      @pinkberry1098 5 років тому +6

      If they never speak they are never comfortable.. there must be at least one person you're comfortable with speaking freely... you might freeze up and not speak to others but maybe there's just that one person you talk to.. for me, it's my twin sister and no one else.

    • @lena644
      @lena644 5 років тому +9

      Selective Mutism is defined by speaking in some situations but not being able to in others. If she's not talking at all, it's total mutism.

    • @karyabugday
      @karyabugday 5 років тому +1

      Le Na Well maybe there was someone she talked to but the person might passed away?

  • @avalancha08
    @avalancha08 4 роки тому +5

    Progressive mutism is even more rare than SM. I’m a licensed therapist in California and I have successfully worked with both SM and PM. People always ask me how I’ve done it, and honestly, it has come down to my ability to connect with the kids and teens experiencing this condition, and using personalized clinical interventions along the way. Judgement, pathologizing, expectations and control on the side of the therapist does not work in my experience. Thanks for this, well made short film.

  • @TheKjoy85
    @TheKjoy85 2 роки тому +3

    The hardest part of my selective/situational mutism is not being able to speak when I need to the most. Fortunately, my family and I have found ways to work around it. They are my voice when mine doesn't work. I am not completely mute, but it is one of my biggest struggles with my autism.

  • @existing1538
    @existing1538 6 років тому +10

    I have selective mutism I'm about to cry I understand this so will

  • @thealicemoon
    @thealicemoon 6 років тому +20

    Who CAN she speak to? I used to have SM and I mostly could only speak to my dad and select friends.

    • @lazychip1876
      @lazychip1876 6 років тому +1

      Same here.

    • @TheKjoy85
      @TheKjoy85 2 роки тому

      If she doesn't speak to anyone, then she is a complete mute or non-verbal, not a selective mute.

  • @emmamathe4962
    @emmamathe4962 8 років тому +8

    That was amazing. I am literally crying.

  • @ohbrilliant9346
    @ohbrilliant9346 7 років тому +8

    this is so beautiful

  • @nadiadimattina6558
    @nadiadimattina6558 11 років тому +6

    Pretty amazing film i must say :D Well done girls :)

  • @mevp5287
    @mevp5287 5 років тому +4

    She’s lucky her sister is alive...😔

    • @Katia25
      @Katia25 4 роки тому +1

      I want to share with you truth and life.
      Jesus is the way, the truth and the life and no one comes to the Father but by Him (John 14:6). Jesus came in the world to become the sacrifice for our sins, save us and teach us the perfect faith.
      All have sinner and fallen short of the glory of God (Romans 3:23). Your sins will lead you to hell (1 Corinthians 6:9-10 and Revelation 21:8). If you want to go to heaven repent of your sins and turn to Jesus; love Him with all Your heart, mind, soul and follow Him (obey Him).
      I reccomend the UA-cam channel: ClevelandStreetPreachers
      God bless you.

    • @EminayDrackoness
      @EminayDrackoness 3 роки тому +1

      ​@@Katia25 So the flying man in the sky who in your idea, will reward you with heaven but if you "sin" Then you are going to hell fire and brim stone... so then why DID This flying blob in the sky who supposedly knows every thing even create evil? Isaiah 45:7 king james bible. If we are not to "Sin" then why did "GOD" CREATE it ANY WAY? Also, how are you so ready to have not faith (Which is gained by building trust and respect with some one on the mortal plain.) But BLIND faith which is not questioning a word and taking it as gospel. pun intended. How does any one actually know what happens to our consciousness when we die? And the whole you should not disrupt "Gods plan" or know one shall know gods plan, Means that they created us as they wanted us to be. But more importantly, why are you following blindly and unquestionably following what ever your particular church preaches. And it never seems to be the same even tho its the same religion. For some christian churches its "God hates the gay" and in other christian churches "God created us perfectly how we are." Also, did god save the christians from the roman lions? No, No "He" did not.

    • @Katia25
      @Katia25 3 роки тому +1

      @@EminayDrackoness God did not create sin; we chose to sin when we disobeyd God. Faith is not not questioning, it's believing and trusting in God, even when the times are hard. Because it does happened that I fall into sin and have doubts sometimes; that's why I ask God to help me understand and resist temptation.
      I still don't have a curch (building). I want to wait on God to fill me with the Holy Spirit and find one that has the Holy Spirit.
      I know God can guide me, and I say what He teaches me, through the Bible, life, prayer, other Christians, ecc.
      Some Christians today don't really follow the Word (Jesus), but are after money, fame,...and Jesus says that you cannot serve two masters. For example the prosperity or watered down gospel.
      I just know He is real, and the Bible says that the blind are actually those that don't believe Him, because they have been blinded by Satan and this world.
      God did save those people, by bringing them to Heaven, because they were ready to give their life to Christ. And that's a beautiful and bold thing, that many Christians today are afraid to do. I guess even me. That's why I pray to God to be more bbpld.

  • @Alex-zi3kl
    @Alex-zi3kl 3 роки тому +2

    I dont think she has sm usually they have a few people they can talk to and aren’t mute all the time

  • @skgoode75
    @skgoode75 3 роки тому +1

    Great movie like this one on your UA-cam channel you did a great job showing this amazing short film to us and I really like it like this one the name of this amazing short film is called speeches sending me more of your short films on my UA-cam channel ❤

  • @Zampirezz
    @Zampirezz 5 років тому +1

    Love it!

  • @sophstrafs96
    @sophstrafs96 11 років тому +3

    ending (y)

  • @2012XF3
    @2012XF3 6 років тому +7

    Music made it worse.

  • @avanisharma9781
    @avanisharma9781 9 років тому +3

    :)