What really impresses me about Mariah is that she's the most successful female vocalist in music history, is considered one of the best vocalists of all time all when battling the most feared and dangerous vocal illness (Nodules). Seriously nodules are no joke! and its a testament to her genius that she still delivers awesomely and writes all her songs! and figures out how to sing with nodules and aging and vocal deterioration. She really lives up to her title as Song Bird Supreme and a Legend:).....Not to mention she has the most octaves out of the trinity and writes the hardest songs......everrrr
Haven't these nodules been more of a blessing than a curse after all? I read that's it's thanks to them that she had that natural and effortless access to higher and whistle register as a child. Given that it's what made her mother decide she is cut out to be a singer and what actually made her special and unique, I don't understand why her fans always whine about her nodules and how they keep her back. If she had them removed, she wouldn't now have a career since a big part of her singing ability relies on them, period. Will she not be able to sing decently at all in some years? Probably yes, but that's the sacrifice for a huge and successful career that placed her name in the history of music and also granted her and her family 400 million dollars.
There’s something special with Whitney. The power of her voice, the volume, the intensity, the range, headvoice, richness, emotions overload and especially in performing LIVE on stage. #thevoice
oaisab twenyfour I still cannot believe she’s dead! She screwed up her voice with drugs and alcohol. They found all kinds of crap in her system according to her autopsy report.
I think Celine wins in long mid notes. Mariah in whistle and belts. And Whitney in low and head voice. They’re really good knowing that they’ve got different styles and different mixes.
i agree, however, i think CD is highly underrated, her C6 shouldve won. I think CD is nicely in the middle between WH and MC. WH's headvoice is unavoidably the best. MC's is non-existent. And i like CD's headvoice too. I love CD's voice but not so much her music and she also has the best personality of all 3.
Mariah was hitting the notes accurately and doing more extra, more difficult melismas. Creativity wise, Mariah ALWAYS wins. Case in point: anytime you need a friend
Whitney is the best for me. Something in the way she sings just gets me! The way she just let the voice comes out is so raw and beautiful! It’s not only technically good, but soulfully perfect!
Whitney’s voice was just AMAZING. She’s one of the greatest singers to ever walk the face of the Earth. Rest in Heaven, Whitney Houston. We will always love you. ❤️🎼🎶🎵 🎤
In my opinion she sucks in technique. Her vocal couch was really bad. But knowing that you’re a fan, why do u think she surpass Mariah and Celine in technique?
Sr. Cátalo Her Voice was very powerful yet she didn’t scream to the point as the singers now and her technique wasnt bad at all. There are more reasons. She picked the worst videos to look at tbh tho.
I love reading the comment section when people get salty because they’re fave didn’t come out on top. All three women are/were unmatched vocalists. Beautiful!
Every female artist with a good tone is called a songbird. Mariah is supreme to all of them according to Guinness. Songbird SUPREME will forever be a more iconic title and universally accepted by neutral sources than The Voice given to Whitney by a random talk show host. I went to atleast 40 countries. I asked King of Pop. People answered MJ. Queen of Pop. Madonna. Songbird SUPREME. Mariah. The Voice. People asked what's that?
Honoric Nicknames I'VE HEARD, READ, OR SEEN for The Vocal Trinity: Whitney: The Voice Mariah: Songbird Supreme Celine: Queen of Power Ballads Don't attack me
Going up the difference between Whitney and the two others get so clear to me. I don't need to be a vocal coach to see that Whitney had the best voice of all. Her voice is the voice every singer aspires to have.
Singers aspire to have Whitney’s consistency and control…. Mariah is the one most of todays artist look up too because she has a HUGE range and can switch octaves so fast and smooth. They are all amazing and they’re wouldn’t be The holy trinity without all 3 of them… But Mariah in her prime was untouchable.
@@butternutscotch I respect your opinion so much. I half agree though. I think Celine technique wise is just a little bit better than Mariah. She has more control, good range, runs on head voice are much clearer than Mariah. She also has a better tone and more power than Mariah. She's the full package, but while Whitney does lack the range of Mariah and Celine, she absolutely is the queen of head voice and runs. I think technique wise Whitney is superior to Mariah and Celine.
@@nathanieljohnson5908 Mariah, Celine and Whitney are the three queens, they are our divas forever nobody could ever reach to them. They all have a special advantage, they have opened the gate that every new artist are getting through but they won't get the key, our divas got it tho.
8:45 Growling is a typical vocal embellishment for vocalists with a background in gospel singing. If you listen to Yolanda Adams or Aretha Franklin's gospel album you'll notice that it's a typical feature that Whitney imported into mainstream music. This has nothing to do with her technique, it's a reference to her gospel heritage and its appreciation is totally subjective so I don't think you should take it into consideration to judge her technique.
Georgina mainly focuses on consistent pitch, healthy technique, and bright tone. Typical vocal coach. She really likes brightness. These three really set the standard for vocalist today.
@@paolovez9688 actually, during this concert (Boston) she was singing live you can hear it. After she hits the note (eb5) on "anymore" then the "awow" you can hear the differences with the pre recorded. I hope you understand me my English is very bad.
Mariah always had a bright and childish voice, like a trademark. Whitney had a powerful and strong voice especially in the 4th octave. Mariah is the queen of 5th 6th and 7th octaves... yes Celine is good tho 😂
Yes. But she seems to not like celine. And gave a lot of points for her. Altough she seems to not like oversinging. She likes mariah. It seems, at least
Whitney wins every round to me just out of personal preference. Some of the higher notes she can’t sustain like Mariah because their ranges are not built the same but middle chest voice, head voice, and mixed voice Whitney absolutely kills. Celine’s very good but no contender to the other two.
I love them all three! You sometimes can't compare with logic. Singing is art and passion. Mariah is also a very talented songwriter. All of them are legends!
I don’t understand how she keeps choosing Mariah when literally Mariah has to keep taking breaths to sustain long notes, some were clearly lipped, and clearly she has a bias for Mariah And it’s easy to change the note key if you stop breath and go again why she said it is difficult is beyond me. And all the Whitney clips are cut short.
Kelly Pierce finally someone who said it! She clearly has a bias towards lighter voices. Some of these notes were clearly not won by Mariah, yet she still chose her. If we’re being honest, Whitney won every midbelt.
Kelly Pierce Mariah during her prime was untouchable. That’s why she’s more successful and legendary than the two. The fact that Mariah has nodules and outsinging the other 2 shows her amazing technique. Let’s see the other two try to sing Mariah songs livened with nodules.
I found your videos last weekend. My husband and I spent hours watching over the last few days and we are both addicts. Your voice is soooo soothing. You are so good at this! Keep going, can’t wait to see more! Also....ever heard of the band Hurts? I’m curious as to what you think of them. Thanks!
On one of the clips you named Mariah the winner before Celine's clip even started. Also, it's not really fair to compare the notes when some of the clips are from poor quality videos. Some of Celine's clips were just her vocal warm ups.
Besides, many of Mariah's clip were taken from lipped or dubbed performances, especially her concerts on sale, unplugged included, she goes back to the studio and fixes all the flat, waek and raspy notes mixing them with the original studio recordings or new studio recordings, so that people think it's live...
Andrés E the druggie fan can’t accept the fact that Marian is way way better than Whitney in every aspect and this video proves it. Try harder flop fan. Whitney at her peak, was no match to Mariah, at her peak, whether in the studio or live. And people in the real world not delusional fans like you buy and listen to studio music not live. Mariah is the only one among these 3 that had a global number 1 live hit songs and sold millions of her live album because Mariah is the best live and in the studio. Come back when Whitney gets another hit song from her flop music discography.
Andrés E there are dubbed and undoubted vocals. Either way it’s still Mariah voice. Whitney at her peak couldn’t even sing her the climax of her songs live and relied on annoying unnecessary adlibs. Whitney could never sing the same way like the album version since she couldn’t hit the high notes live and had to chop up her songs with adlibs. Hahahahaha
That's because the video she put on the screen after editing is advanced. This is the case for a lot of her reaction vids ... she reacts 2 secs earlier to what's being shown .
Kind of funny how you said Whitney had too much farce in her D5, and too much of the growling... then turned right around and gave the E5 to Mariah and it was just as growled 🙄
I’m also a music teacher, and I don’t understand why you said Mariah’s technique is better when her voice has lots of breath and her tone is not “clean”.
Ginette B she’s naturally a soprano and she lowers her larynx to reach the notes. She can support the upper 2nd octave/lower 3rd octave if she wanted too
@@burninandearnin8311 Just Powerful notes don't make you a better singer lol you also need to have good technique and musicality, which Mariah has over Whitney
For the ones who pict Mariah and Céline, y’all don’t know soul, and in the music industry, soul will always beat any other music genre! Whitney was known for the voice, and not only, she has a very unique voice, you always hear singers Mariah and Céline, but you will never hear a voice like Whitney!
For me Houston has more soul to the sound. Carey sounds more blond and Dion always more nasal. Technique can be discussed too as here and my feeling is several clips with Houston sound past her prime?
@@qxyzzz Lmao Mariah adds emotion and excitement? I've heard from alot of people that her concerts are boring and that Whitney was the exciting one because she never sang a song the same. You would never hear I will always love you the same cause she always changes it and it makes it exciting.
@@nathanieljohnson5908 What you said is subjective. I do not want to be mean to you. I'm sorry. I've been to several of Whitney's concerts and I see people leaving the hall during the performance itself. You can google. Much worse. Mariah NEVER had people leaving her concerts DURING the performance itself. What you feel about Whitney's voice is how I feel abot Mariah's voice. You cannot say green is better than blue. People say what they like.
I've always adored Celine Dion for the her incredible vocal range but also for the emotion, and excitement she injects into her singing, even if sometimes a note might be a little rough round the edges, but I truly believe Whitney Houston would have been an incredible classical soprano. Oh! If only she had lived and switched genres it would have been absolutely amazing to see and hear. May God bless Mariah and Celine's incredible voices. RIP Whitney, who is singing her soul out in heaven.
Hi Georgina! I'm a Scottish drag queen, I'm obviously a man deep down (lol) and I wish I could harness my voice! I've been told I'm good at stuff like Coldplay, Keane, etc. because I have good tone and emotion there. I'll message you for more advice. Down to the video, you're right, these 3 are meant to be "the divas" so they should be the best but ultimately everyone's different like you're saying. I've been catching up with your channel and videos! Love you babes! Xx
I love that you are very fair with your judgements and back that up even by saying "by this particular set up clips" because they are all equally talented in their own respect and better at certain aspects of singing versus some other singers.
Okay, so I know you're the honest coach so believe me when I say I'm honest too. I absolutely no doubt knew (before I watched) that you would choose Mariah. The video you reviewed was obv made by a lamb. The quality of Celine and Whitney videos was awful. A very biased video. I would love for you to make a video selecting your own fave performances of these three and giving us your expert opinion. Lambs will thank you, but remember, they can't bite. I also happen to know for a fact that some parts of those Mariah performances used pre recorded vocals. Its strange you don't notice that. I've observed you tend to only notice pre records for artists who dance. Maybe its more noticeable that way but I assure you, Mariah lipped large sections
Turned Around Well, Mariah will still win since even if Mariah pre-recorded those notes and not a lot of good examples were used on Mariah even though it was made by a lamb!
Turned Around thank you! I was getting so annoyed by watching this. These 3 ladies were/are powerhouses, which they made clear. However, this to me, was very much a preference to Mariah. Whitney and Céline can most definitely hold their own on any vocal battle.
You're right, and many of Mariah's clip here are lipped or dubbed performances, especially her concerts on sale, unplugged included, she goes back to the studio and fixes all the flat, waek and raspy notes mixing them with the original studio recordings or new studio recordings, so that people think it's live...
The clips chosen were so obviously tipped in favor of Mariah . The clips used for Whitney were a joke . I have seen Mariah , Celine and Whitney in concert . Hands down Whitney was the best live performer ...incredible actually ... I have never seen a live performer as great as her ever . Frankly , Mariah and Celine were disappointing . Boring performers ... Mariah lip synced a lot of her performance . This is why I went to 12 Whitney concerts and only one concert for Mariah and Celine . Whitney never sang the same song the same ... she put her all into her performances - she was amazing ... and never disappointed . To me , she is the premier voice .
You got to go to 12 Whitney concerts!!!! That is AMAZING!!! I never got to see her live :( Breaks my heart! But I agree, Mariah lips WAY too much! I honestly think the fact that Whitney never lipped and always performed live had as much to do with her vocal decline as cigarettes and drugs(I think more so cigarettes). Whitney just SANG. It wasn't about technique at all with her, and that just may have been a good and bad thing. While I respect Mariah and believe she has one of the greatest voices of all time... She's definitely not the best. She has range but something always seemed phoned if with her and her struggle with stage presence always bothered me. Whitney was just natural and always could command a stage and crowd.
Tell us your opinion when you manage to find a time machine and watch more than one Celine and Mariah concerts. Everybody have bad days. You can't expect singers to be at their best at every concert.
9:33 yes i always found that celine clip weird because she went very sharp. The note she was supposed to hit was an Eb5 but maybe she couldnt hear herself or idk what happened but went sharp
Beautiful women, each with an astounding gift from God himself. Mariah will always be my number one but Celine and Whitney are equally as talented. Long live the Vocal Trinity.
@@nivrealedasor265 what makes you think whitney cant make music do you know all of her talents she probably didnt want to to because she does something different than mariah she can SAANNGG
You're right. Many of them were lipped and others were dubbed, especially her concerts on sale unplugged included, she goes back to the studio and fixes all the flat, waek and raspy notes mixing them with the original studio recordings or new studio recordings, so that people think it's live...
I don't get... Whitney was perfectly technically, her tone is darker than the others, it's too much ask for her sound more bright and let understand that dark sound it's a way incorrect or worst.
I wouldn't say she was perfect technically(she had her faults) but her voice was definitely more developed than the other singers. This coach is not really trustworthy. She confuses brightness with resonance and clarity. Whitney sang with more depht through a slightly lowered larynx(which elongates the vocal tract and allows the voice to projects more) so of course she is not gonna sound girlish like Mariah. Her tone was still clearer and cleaner than both Mariah and Celine.
@@MatgoStyles The only reason her prime extended for ten years is because her technique was great. Otherwise, her voice would have crumpled much earlier with all the overtouring, lack of rest, cigarettes, drugs, parties etc. Well, look at what happened to Adelle and she didn't even had the same bad habits as Whitney.
I love them all, but Whitney's head voice makes me go weak at the knees.
And chills and goosebumps
Her loudness makes everyone weak
Philip Cohen Is that a compliment?
@@lordvoldemort5725 Ikr I'm so confused by that
Period
We all know their qualities
-Whitney : Head Voice/Tone/Power(Esp Mid Range)
-Celine : Sustained notes/Power/3th lung lol
-Mariah: Incredibly Buttery tone/Lows/Phrased upper belts/Whistles/Transitions
Mariah is falsetto and melisma too
Great tone for mariah and agility...
LMAO THIRD LUNG
@@colynians it literally says "Buttery tone" ;-;
And agility for Celine and piercing resonance. It’s like a crystal although I think they were all agile just different styles
I cant fathom that Mariah has a whole octave more to showcase 😭❤
Lol.. Mariah would be like: "That's it? C'mon guys let's keep going" 🤣🤭
@@marishkagranada7985 but she has the lowest belt of them 3
@@marishkagranada7985 we've seen Mariah live. That's not how she was lol
@ prime mariah 😭
@@marishkagranada7985 but she's non-existent HEADVOICE 😂 and a terribly pathetic belting range and power
What really impresses me about Mariah is that she's the most successful female vocalist in music history, is considered one of the best vocalists of all time all when battling the most feared and dangerous vocal illness (Nodules). Seriously nodules are no joke! and its a testament to her genius that she still delivers awesomely and writes all her songs! and figures out how to sing with nodules and aging and vocal deterioration. She really lives up to her title as Song Bird Supreme and a Legend:).....Not to mention she has the most octaves out of the trinity and writes the hardest songs......everrrr
She's not the most successful where did you get that impormation
@@wilmarallensilva6746 which other solo artist had a career as successful, influential, and impactful as Mariahs I’ll wait...
@@levantineking98 Are you talking about solo artists in general? If you are then Michael Jackson, Madonna, and Elvis Presley comes to mind
Haven't these nodules been more of a blessing than a curse after all? I read that's it's thanks to them that she had that natural and effortless access to higher and whistle register as a child. Given that it's what made her mother decide she is cut out to be a singer and what actually made her special and unique, I don't understand why her fans always whine about her nodules and how they keep her back. If she had them removed, she wouldn't now have a career since a big part of her singing ability relies on them, period. Will she not be able to sing decently at all in some years? Probably yes, but that's the sacrifice for a huge and successful career that placed her name in the history of music and also granted her and her family 400 million dollars.
@@nathanieljohnson5908 she said female*
Mariah=Unique tone
Celine=Long notes
Whitney=Power
Whitney was known for her tone .
Cèline has a unique tone too
@@elodie_bel yeah a nasal tone
@@Youmightwannaknowthat THANK YOU
Mariah is known for range more than tone IMO. Houston definitely had the best tonal quality out of all three
Seeing Mariah without a microphone in her hand looks so ilegal! LOL
There’s something special with Whitney. The power of her voice, the volume, the intensity, the range, headvoice, richness, emotions overload and especially in performing LIVE on stage. #thevoice
It's the tone, its velvety and rich. I dont think she's as technical as the other too so she sounds more soulful.
oaisab twenyfour I still cannot believe she’s dead! She screwed up her voice with drugs and alcohol. They found all kinds of crap in her system according to her autopsy report.
With all of em
purkabe12 what the definition of technical?
@concepts stfu. It's his opinion. You don't have to butt in every time someone praises Whitney but not Mariah. Get a life
I think Celine wins in long mid notes.
Mariah in whistle and belts.
And Whitney in low and head voice.
They’re really good knowing that they’ve got different styles and different mixes.
Celine kinda surprised me. She's really good
Sr. Cátalo I'm pretty sure Mariah takes the lows dahling LOL
@@qxyzzz yuh . I think Whitney wins in mid belts ?
moonlight butterfly Tbh Mariah did excellent in all the parts of her chest range, but Whitney mainly sounded great in her mids
Sr. Cátalo Whitney definitely does not win low notes.
5:44 when Mariah's Bb4 perfectly blends with Celine's 🙈
Omg yesss
Indeed
I didn’t even notice that it switched, I was wondering where Celine’s clip was
Whoever made this video obviously picked the worst quality clips of Celine's performances. LOL. Mariah's clips have clearer audio than WH & CD.
I totally agree with you!
i agree, however, i think CD is highly underrated, her C6 shouldve won. I think CD is nicely in the middle between WH and MC. WH's headvoice is unavoidably the best. MC's is non-existent. And i like CD's headvoice too. I love CD's voice but not so much her music and she also has the best personality of all 3.
Lol the excuses. Mariah would win regardless.
Yeah they didn’t use a bunch of Celine’s better clips, same with Whitney
Khris 10 Celine is beneath Mariah and Whitney in ALL GREATEST ARTIST LISTS. Since her vocals always sound nasal, forced, and over the top.
I see Mariah, i click 💯
My motto 😂🎶🦋
I see Whitney and Celine, I click. I see Mariah get most of the personal choices, I dislike.
Relate! 😂
@@nathanieljohnson5908 he was just showing his love for Mariah. Calm down
@@nathanieljohnson5908 lol
mariah carey in her prime was unstoppable, she was the best and for me she’ll always be the best, i love a skinny legend
I don't think she was unstoppable but you can have your opinion. My fave is 1985-1998 Whitney
Mariah in 90s: Skinny Legend
Mariah in 2010s: Thicc Queen
Late comment, but...
Mariah in her prime is not beating either Whitney or Celine
yeah. Vocal Critics were astonished by her 5 octave range when she entered the scene :)
The trinity was unstoppable in their prime honey
The quality of the audio is inconsistent. Limits a fairer judgment. Just sayin'.
That's why I thought.
Yeah, I agree
I agree. It would be good judging each at their very best and with clear good quality sound.
Guys this is a re-upload video because the previous video is blocked by UA-cam due to the copyright
before this was reuploaded, every clip had the same quality. The video was intentionally made inconsistent to avoid being blocked again
Mariah’s tone is what sets her apart. But I love all of them❤️
Yassss the vocal trinity! The best ♥️
Mariah and Celine are my babies. My two favorites singers. ❤❤❤
Whitney is astounding.
Mimi and Whitney are mines 😌
Mariah was hitting the notes accurately and doing more extra, more difficult melismas. Creativity wise, Mariah ALWAYS wins. Case in point: anytime you need a friend
Whitney is the best for me. Something in the way she sings just gets me! The way she just let the voice comes out is so raw and beautiful! It’s not only technically good, but soulfully perfect!
Love Whitney head voice, people keep on talking on her powerful belts.
Whitney’s voice was just AMAZING. She’s one of the greatest singers to ever walk the face of the Earth. Rest in Heaven, Whitney Houston. We will always love you. ❤️🎼🎶🎵 🎤
No the greatest but she was soo perfect
I agree with 04 but to my ears Whitney sounds better
Mariah's voice is so good
Whitney will always be #1 for me! There is just something about her voice😍 then Mariah and Celine.
Totally agree with you, all amazing artists but Whitney's voice is just magical, my #1 always ❤️
In my opinion she sucks in technique. Her vocal couch was really bad. But knowing that you’re a fan, why do u think she surpass Mariah and Celine in technique?
Sr. Cátalo Her Voice was very powerful yet she didn’t scream to the point as the singers now and her technique wasnt bad at all. There are more reasons. She picked the worst videos to look at tbh tho.
For all of them
Sr. Cátalo okay that’s your opinion if you think her technique sucked....like wtf....no one personally asked for your opinion.
Mariah Carey’s voice is really amazing. Thank you so much 😍❤️
Brianna Jones 'was' amazing
jeolous all over the world
Turned Around Still amazing, I have evidence get ready
@@turnedaround4954 Jelousy
Nivre Aled Asor baby dont waste your Time.💙😂
I love reading the comment section when people get salty because they’re fave didn’t come out on top.
All three women are/were unmatched vocalists. Beautiful!
Mariah 💕💕💕💕💕💕. The Songbird Supreeme
Whitney ❤❤❤💕💖 The Voice
Whitney THE VOICE 😂
Every female artist with a good tone is called a songbird. Mariah is supreme to all of them according to Guinness. Songbird SUPREME will forever be a more iconic title and universally accepted by neutral sources than The Voice given to Whitney by a random talk show host. I went to atleast 40 countries. I asked King of Pop. People answered MJ. Queen of Pop. Madonna. Songbird SUPREME. Mariah. The Voice. People asked what's that?
@Jackson Storm ??? No one was hating on Whitney? Why are you saying this?
Honoric Nicknames I'VE HEARD, READ, OR SEEN for The Vocal Trinity:
Whitney: The Voice
Mariah: Songbird Supreme
Celine: Queen of Power Ballads
Don't attack me
Going up the difference between Whitney and the two others get so clear to me. I don't need to be a vocal coach to see that Whitney had the best voice of all. Her voice is the voice every singer aspires to have.
Singers aspire to have Whitney’s consistency and control…. Mariah is the one most of todays artist look up too because she has a HUGE range and can switch octaves so fast and smooth. They are all amazing and they’re wouldn’t be The holy trinity without all 3 of them… But Mariah in her prime was untouchable.
Mariah is truely a vocal beast 🦋
Mariah She is flop
No one can change the love I have for Whitney Houston. The Goat
she was amazing for sure I grow up listening to her and I am from middle East😅
Yes Mariah has that very pleasant innocent, girlish and bright tone to her that puts her above the rest at times
We all know who’s the best out of them three go Whitney ❤️
Mariah is the best in singing and songwriting not Whitney
You're both wrong. Celine is queen.
@@butternutscotch I respect your opinion so much. I half agree though. I think Celine technique wise is just a little bit better than Mariah. She has more control, good range, runs on head voice are much clearer than Mariah. She also has a better tone and more power than Mariah. She's the full package, but while Whitney does lack the range of Mariah and Celine, she absolutely is the queen of head voice and runs. I think technique wise Whitney is superior to Mariah and Celine.
@@butternutscotch haha queen of nasal
@@nathanieljohnson5908 Mariah, Celine and Whitney are the three queens, they are our divas forever nobody could ever reach to them. They all have a special advantage, they have opened the gate that every new artist are getting through but they won't get the key, our divas got it tho.
8:45 Growling is a typical vocal embellishment for vocalists with a background in gospel singing. If you listen to Yolanda Adams or Aretha Franklin's gospel album you'll notice that it's a typical feature that Whitney imported into mainstream music. This has nothing to do with her technique, it's a reference to her gospel heritage and its appreciation is totally subjective so I don't think you should take it into consideration to judge her technique.
Miguel ANTILE Right
That's what I thought
My issue is that she didn't even acknowledge in the next video after Whitney growled Mariah did twice .. and she gave Mariah both those points
She had an unhealthy growl
Whitney doesn't growl with proper technique like Mariah
Mariah is just beautiful inside and out with her voice😍😍
Yes Mariah is.
Mariah is not beautiful inside. Her personality sucks
JR GR she actually seems like a nice person, there are just a lot of misconceptions of her due to the tabloids, rumors etc.
@@xrey83 how did u know.you know nothing about mariah
@@xrey83 They are inventions of the media
#1 Mariah
Georgina mainly focuses on consistent pitch, healthy technique, and bright tone. Typical vocal coach.
She really likes brightness. These three really set the standard for vocalist today.
I got really excited and clicked so fast when I saw this vid
Turns out it's just a re-upload :(
Whitney: depthness, low, mid range, head voice, riffs, and SOUL
Mariah: range, tone, whistle, belts, transitions, and melisma
Celine: sustained notes, sharp belts, accent, runs, dramatic style
Mariah❤️
I can’t believe they used clips of Celine in the recording studio just playing around for comparisons lol.
RIGHT??? Not to mention, a lot of the video clips had bad sound quality or weren't the best examples of the notes.
-Lori- Aphantasia Gematria
Ikr? How could they use clips like 9:11 that are completely lipped? Poor Celine
Legit! Overall, there are so many better better clips of Celine hitting these notes.
@@paolovez9688 actually, during this concert (Boston) she was singing live you can hear it. After she hits the note (eb5) on "anymore" then the "awow" you can hear the differences with the pre recorded. I hope you understand me my English is very bad.
Paolo Vez This one is actually live
Mariah always had a bright and childish voice, like a trademark. Whitney had a powerful and strong voice especially in the 4th octave. Mariah is the queen of 5th 6th and 7th octaves... yes Celine is good tho 😂
Ste.B. Mariah didn't have a childish voice lmao, she had an angelic one 🙃
Whitney has power in her voice
Mariah has soul in her voice
@@qxyzzz I would day childlike quality which also means pure.
@@curleddoughnuts6857 I'd say Whitney had more soul. Mariah had more brightness
If you watch all of her videos you're gonna know she's such a die heart fan of Mariah Carey.
Gandhi Wijaya which is an automatic bias. I can’t take it seriously.
Anyways. It ain’t no surprise to anybody Mariah is the best vocalist out of the trinity
Yes. But she seems to not like celine. And gave a lot of points for her.
Altough she seems to not like oversinging. She likes mariah. It seems, at least
I'm a Mariah fan but Whitney deserved more justice in the belts naturally
That's so true. I knew it from the start that's why Im not surprised by her ranking. 😏
Celine dion❤❤❤❤Queen Power Ballad
Whitney was THE VOICE
Chris Wainwright But shes not the best Vocalist
And Mariah is the Songbird SUPREME
@Philip Cohen. yaaaaasss PREACH!!
Even Frank Sinatra, and Mariah they got this name it doesn't mean anything
Celine is the "Queen Of Vocals"
Plsss react to mariah carey all in your mind
yesss I love the whistle at the end
Mariah’s voice takes me to that place 😍
Whitney is on a different level than Mariah and Celine. There is so much more quality in her voice and her live performances.
Whitney is the best voice live
Céline: 2nd Place here I come
End of video Whitney: hold my wig
9:37 Georgina’s cringing face cracks me up right there. “Oh, dear, she lost it then.” 😂🤣
Mariah
The Whitney videos are shorter then Mariah’s and Celine’s ? Maybe it’s just me but I’m not sure all them Mariah videos are 100% live
Spot on a lot of them are ore pre recorded vocals
All Mariahs were live
All the Mariah parts were live
A lot of them were dubbed and prerecorded
I love them all, but Whitney is and always will be one of the best vocalist of all time
MARIAH CAREY 💖
Mariah is Iconic
I swear she’s posted this video before, I remember her comment about Mariah wearing the headset
Whitney wins every round to me just out of personal preference. Some of the higher notes she can’t sustain like Mariah because their ranges are not built the same but middle chest voice, head voice, and mixed voice Whitney absolutely kills. Celine’s very good but no contender to the other two.
whitney houston is the best for me
Mariah's tone, musicianship, melismas, range, resonance, technique, control, precision and artistry set her higher Céline and Whitney
Too bad live all that goes down the drain compared to Whitney
Not at all.
This is my most favourite video on this channel. I watch this video almost everyday.
I love them all three!
You sometimes can't compare with logic. Singing is art and passion.
Mariah is also a very talented songwriter.
All of them are legends!
I'm team Mariah... and I'm from Quebec 😂
And?
@@Ily.kenyan literally...🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Whitney has my full heart, and then definitely Mariah and then Celine. But this trinity is just out of this world.
I don’t understand how she keeps choosing Mariah when literally Mariah has to keep taking breaths to sustain long notes, some were clearly lipped, and clearly she has a bias for Mariah
And it’s easy to change the note key if you stop breath and go again why she said it is difficult is beyond me.
And all the Whitney clips are cut short.
Kelly Pierce finally someone who said it! She clearly has a bias towards lighter voices. Some of these notes were clearly not won by Mariah, yet she still chose her. If we’re being honest, Whitney won every midbelt.
Kelly Pierce exactly!
You’re right
lol 90’s Mariah is not lipping
Kelly Pierce Mariah during her prime was untouchable. That’s why she’s more successful and legendary than the two. The fact that Mariah has nodules and outsinging the other 2 shows her amazing technique. Let’s see the other two try to sing Mariah songs livened with nodules.
Queen of tone, Mariah.
I thought Whitney was the best in a lot of those clips. Whitney is divine💜
I found your videos last weekend. My husband and I spent hours watching over the last few days and we are both addicts. Your voice is soooo soothing. You are so good at this! Keep going, can’t wait to see more! Also....ever heard of the band Hurts? I’m curious as to what you think of them. Thanks!
I would change this;
E3, F3, A4, G#4 E5 and F#5 to Whitney
And A4, D5 to Celine, so the results are:
Mariah: 4
Whitney: 14
Celine: 9
Yeah you would because you are an idiot when it comes down to Technique
On one of the clips you named Mariah the winner before Celine's clip even started. Also, it's not really fair to compare the notes when some of the clips are from poor quality videos. Some of Celine's clips were just her vocal warm ups.
Besides, many of Mariah's clip were taken from lipped or dubbed performances, especially her concerts on sale, unplugged included, she goes back to the studio and fixes all the flat, waek and raspy notes mixing them with the original studio recordings or new studio recordings, so that people think it's live...
@@andrese9805 Not true 99% of them is live.
Andrés E the druggie fan can’t accept the fact that Marian is way way better than Whitney in every aspect and this video proves it. Try harder flop fan. Whitney at her peak, was no match to Mariah, at her peak, whether in the studio or live. And people in the real world not delusional fans like you buy and listen to studio music not live. Mariah is the only one among these 3 that had a global number 1 live hit songs and sold millions of her live album because Mariah is the best live and in the studio. Come back when Whitney gets another hit song from her flop music discography.
Andrés E there are dubbed and undoubted vocals. Either way it’s still Mariah voice. Whitney at her peak couldn’t even sing her the climax of her songs live and relied on annoying unnecessary adlibs. Whitney could never sing the same way like the album version since she couldn’t hit the high notes live and had to chop up her songs with adlibs. Hahahahaha
That's because the video she put on the screen after editing is advanced.
This is the case for a lot of her reaction vids ... she reacts 2 secs earlier to what's being shown .
Kind of funny how you said Whitney had too much farce in her D5, and too much of the growling... then turned right around and gave the E5 to Mariah and it was just as growled 🙄
Mariah did a healthy growl at least
@@theelusivelamb5276 hahahahaha shut up.
Whitney's E5 is an Eb5
The Elusive Lamb no such thing
something's definitely wrong with ur ear...
I’m also a music teacher, and I don’t understand why you said Mariah’s technique is better when her voice has lots of breath and her tone is not “clean”.
You're not a very good teacher then
Mário de Carvalho
Wrong!
Agreed. Her low notes have always been breathy and unclear
Ginette B she’s naturally a soprano and she lowers her larynx to reach the notes. She can support the upper 2nd octave/lower 3rd octave if she wanted too
Then you can't be a good teacher then......just sayin
Whitney wins for me.
Mariah wins for me. And I guess the vocal coach with the degree too 😌
That's why this woman is a vocal couch and you're not.
thiago boris mercado she is obviously bias smh. Whitney has a powerful voice in all her notes. She was a better live singer.
@@burninandearnin8311 Just Powerful notes don't make you a better singer lol you also need to have good technique and musicality, which Mariah has over Whitney
For the ones who pict Mariah and Céline, y’all don’t know soul, and in the music industry, soul will always beat any other music genre! Whitney was known for the voice, and not only, she has a very unique voice, you always hear singers Mariah and Céline, but you will never hear a voice like Whitney!
Mariah’s debut and Emotions albums are full of soul, R&B, pop and gospel. You don’t know about that
For me Houston has more soul to the sound. Carey sounds more blond and Dion always more nasal.
Technique can be discussed too as here and my feeling is several clips with Houston sound past her prime?
Dragan Vidic Mariah adds more emotion and excitement, I don't hear her sounding blond LmAo
@@qxyzzz Lmao Mariah adds emotion and excitement? I've heard from alot of people that her concerts are boring and that Whitney was the exciting one because she never sang a song the same. You would never hear I will always love you the same cause she always changes it and it makes it exciting.
Prefer Mariah! Or Celine Whitney her tone is dark and sharp not that pretty! And Whitney over the D5 sound pushy and not good.
@@nathanieljohnson5908 What you said is subjective. I do not want to be mean to you. I'm sorry. I've been to several of Whitney's concerts and I see people leaving the hall during the performance itself. You can google. Much worse. Mariah NEVER had people leaving her concerts DURING the performance itself.
What you feel about Whitney's voice is how I feel abot Mariah's voice. You cannot say green is better than blue. People say what they like.
@@shiftyclouds9591 how many people told you that mariah is boring singer?
I've always adored Celine Dion for the her incredible vocal range but also for the emotion, and excitement she injects into her singing, even if sometimes a note might be a little rough round the edges, but I truly believe Whitney Houston would have been an incredible classical soprano. Oh! If only she had lived and switched genres it would have been absolutely amazing to see and hear.
May God bless Mariah and Celine's incredible voices. RIP Whitney, who is singing her soul out in heaven.
Mariah Dahlingg💙 Love All of Them tho😍
There is something about Whitney's voice that makes her my favorite!
I love all three but there is no doubt that MC is the best singer of all time.
Hi Georgina! I'm a Scottish drag queen, I'm obviously a man deep down (lol) and I wish I could harness my voice! I've been told I'm good at stuff like Coldplay, Keane, etc. because I have good tone and emotion there. I'll message you for more advice.
Down to the video, you're right, these 3 are meant to be "the divas" so they should be the best but ultimately everyone's different like you're saying. I've been catching up with your channel and videos! Love you babes! Xx
I love that you are very fair with your judgements and back that up even by saying "by this particular set up clips" because they are all equally talented in their own respect and better at certain aspects of singing versus some other singers.
Okay, so I know you're the honest coach so believe me when I say I'm honest too. I absolutely no doubt knew (before I watched) that you would choose Mariah. The video you reviewed was obv made by a lamb. The quality of Celine and Whitney videos was awful. A very biased video. I would love for you to make a video selecting your own fave performances of these three and giving us your expert opinion. Lambs will thank you, but remember, they can't bite. I also happen to know for a fact that some parts of those Mariah performances used pre recorded vocals. Its strange you don't notice that. I've observed you tend to only notice pre records for artists who dance. Maybe its more noticeable that way but I assure you, Mariah lipped large sections
Turned Around Well, Mariah will still win since even if Mariah pre-recorded those notes and not a lot of good examples were used on Mariah even though it was made by a lamb!
Turned Around Mariah is better technically than Celine and Whitney so...
Turned Around thank you! I was getting so annoyed by watching this.
These 3 ladies were/are powerhouses, which they made clear. However, this to me, was very much a preference to Mariah. Whitney and Céline can most definitely hold their own on any vocal battle.
You're right, and many of Mariah's clip here are lipped or dubbed performances, especially her concerts on sale, unplugged included, she goes back to the studio and fixes all the flat, waek and raspy notes mixing them with the original studio recordings or new studio recordings, so that people think it's live...
@@HallOfMimi She is not.
Whitney is perfection personified! She’s just not human. It’s interesting how Whitney’s clips are so much shorter than Mimi’s and Celine’s.
❤️Celine Dion ❤️
Mariah is the best voice of all time! The way her voice makes me feel wow it fills my soul
The clips chosen were so obviously tipped in favor of Mariah . The clips used for Whitney were a joke . I have seen Mariah , Celine and Whitney in concert . Hands down Whitney was the best live performer ...incredible actually ... I have never seen a live performer as great as her ever . Frankly , Mariah and Celine were disappointing . Boring performers ... Mariah lip synced a lot of her performance . This is why I went to 12 Whitney concerts and only one concert for Mariah and Celine . Whitney never sang the same song the same ... she put her all into her performances - she was amazing ... and never disappointed . To me , she is the premier voice .
You got to go to 12 Whitney concerts!!!! That is AMAZING!!! I never got to see her live :( Breaks my heart! But I agree, Mariah lips WAY too much! I honestly think the fact that Whitney never lipped and always performed live had as much to do with her vocal decline as cigarettes and drugs(I think more so cigarettes). Whitney just SANG. It wasn't about technique at all with her, and that just may have been a good and bad thing. While I respect Mariah and believe she has one of the greatest voices of all time... She's definitely not the best. She has range but something always seemed phoned if with her and her struggle with stage presence always bothered me. Whitney was just natural and always could command a stage and crowd.
pmmk24 did you watch Whitney’s last tour??? She has the most horrible voice and sounded like a dying cat whenever she opened her mouth. Hahahahaha
^^ keyword...Last tour. Her voice deteriorated with time just like Mariah's. Sigh.
Tell us your opinion when you manage to find a time machine and watch more than one Celine and Mariah concerts. Everybody have bad days. You can't expect singers to be at their best at every concert.
@@ginetteb7751 Mariah's voice has never got this bad .Mariah at 51 still sing better than Whitney at 35
9:33 yes i always found that celine clip weird because she went very sharp. The note she was supposed to hit was an Eb5 but maybe she couldnt hear herself or idk what happened but went sharp
Beautiful women, each with an astounding gift from God himself.
Mariah will always be my number one but Celine and Whitney are equally as talented.
Long live the Vocal Trinity.
Whitney Houston-Queen of r&b
Mariah Carey -Queen of pop
Celine Dion-Queen of balled
Madonna-Queen of entertainment
Janet Jackson-Queen of dance pop
Mariah's voice is just so gorgeous she is the best👌👌
and to think that mariah still has two full more octaves to show🤯
I think the quality of the original audio is really bad 😵
What the heck?! Whitney was the best of all of them. Pure emotion, vocal cord worth millions.
Jajaajja good Joke... Mariah is above of anysinger in music history
@@alejandrolopezcorrea6214 you better think .
whitney cant write a song.the good things is her great voice
@@nivrealedasor265 what makes you think whitney cant make music do you know all of her talents she probably didnt want to to because she does something different than mariah she can SAANNGG
No dahling she did not!
Don’t get me wrong I love mimi but 90% of what was shown of Mariah clips where prerecorded where as celine an Whitney’s where live!! So it’s biased
You're right. Many of them were lipped and others were dubbed, especially her concerts on sale unplugged included, she goes back to the studio and fixes all the flat, waek and raspy notes mixing them with the original studio recordings or new studio recordings, so that people think it's live...
Oh wow
90% is definitely an exaggeration. Less than 10% of the videos were actually lipped. I can only point one 2/3 performances
One can say the same for the others, when proofs will not be produced
Whitney was slighted in this video...especially before the head voice section
I understand its preference but I’m just saying
No she wasn’t, she is just hella biased toward Mariah. Whitney won a majority of these clips that she gave to the others.
the part they excel the most 👑
Whitney: head voice, power, clarity
Mariah: agility, range, tone
Celine: high belt, stability, precision
Tone is subjective.
Add ability, precision, and BELT to Whitney too
it’s not fair for Mariah as she can really hit those whistles and the lower register and she still won, she’s so underrated as a vocalist
wtf when was she underrated? where have you been living?? she's even called the song bird Supreme and everyone literally knows her and her songs0
That’s why I love Mariah the best. But all of them are truly the vocal trinity. There is just nobody nowadays that can compare to them
Queen Mariah👑❤️
Celine.😍😍
The clips were too short. Hard to understand what was going on
I don't get... Whitney was perfectly technically, her tone is darker than the others, it's too much ask for her sound more bright and let understand that dark sound it's a way incorrect or worst.
Not perfect, but good
I wouldn't say she was perfect technically(she had her faults) but her voice was definitely more developed than the other singers. This coach is not really trustworthy. She confuses brightness with resonance and clarity. Whitney sang with more depht through a slightly lowered larynx(which elongates the vocal tract and allows the voice to projects more) so of course she is not gonna sound girlish like Mariah. Her tone was still clearer and cleaner than both Mariah and Celine.
@@JCole-fg3rr ??? of couse she was perfect..this is a fact, lamb
Although Whitney had a great tool, she was never the best technically and some say this was a factor in the decline of her voice.
@@MatgoStyles The only reason her prime extended for ten years is because her technique was great. Otherwise, her voice would have crumpled much earlier with all the overtouring, lack of rest, cigarettes, drugs, parties etc. Well, look at what happened to Adelle and she didn't even had the same bad habits as Whitney.