I love the emphasis you put on time with these videos. It has taken me years to understand how precious time is, and I appreciate you mentioning future generations, it is very hopeful and optimistic. I would love to see the future Herons Bonsai team revisit this tree in many many years! Don't forget to stop and smell the pines!
The ancient Chinese used to go to the pine forests in the mountains just to smell the fragrance of the pines needles. It is supposed to be good for respiratory ailments.
Mr. Chan, one of these days you should do a proper tutorial with the superbly beautiful trees that you have, watched your video on bonsai empire and alot of them seem to underestimate your skills, and me having read bonsai masterclass there are no shortage of fine specimens you have made, though of obviously you absolutely don't need to prove yourself, it just irritates me how they blather about you and would be nice to see you show them the amazing stuff you have
I am not bothered in the least about brickbats or bouquets - I just focus on my thing and my style. As you say - I don't have to prove anything.The proof of the pudding is in the eating. The number of subcribers on my UA-cam channel speaks for itself !!! Not to mention our Nursery - it is UNIQUE !! Jealousy is not a nice thing but sadly there is a lot of it about.
@@peterchan3100 i completely agree with all that you've said right sir, kudos to your principles, come to think of it I suppose there is a sense of insecurity in the need to show something, and it is really nice to know that you are a very well established self, one day I will visit your nursery, the only one who/that seems to have a warm welcoming atmosphere as opposed to others I have seen, and a familial teacher student relationship you have with the team is very heartwarming thing to watch. Thanks very much for all the good you've done, I hope I can make something similar here in indonesia, though of course in the nature of a guru and a student, I'll try to better you sir...😆(apologies for the long and perhaps impertinent cacophony)
A very interesting video! I was fascinated to hear where the name "literati" came from. I can now see the characters inherent in the style, and have a new appreciation for it. Thank you, Peter.
I think I might've lost it this last year if it hadn't been for the continued zen of your bonsai videos. I hope everything is okay with you lovely people at Herons
Thank you for the inspiration. Have a similar tree that I wasn't quite sure how to style. I love your style, as I have always marched to the tune of a different drum myself. Why be different just like everyone else? Bless you for sharing your knowledge with us.
I was down at Herons on the weekend. The place was looking great! I was trying to spot this one, but I couldn't recognise / see it (from the last video) thanks for sharing!
I knew it! I am a true Peter Chan disciple. At 14:00 ... I have always felt the same about the dichotomy of loving maples and literati bonsai. As always, thank you for sharing your love and knowledge.
Guys, I really mean this: you need to make long form videos just following Peter around for 3-4 hours out of a workday and run an ad every 15 minutes. He doesn't even need to narrate the whole time, people *will* watch. Your compression and production time will skyrocket, but so will your viewership, Also, stream your bonsai workshops and evening wiring/pruning/shaping sessions, here or on Twitch. I bet you'll make a killing. Mail me one dope tree that will survive with love in AZ if it works out.
Did you hear about the British Bonsai Academy Awards Night? It was held at Pinewood Studios, had a minimalist theme and all the gLiterati was there, in their best style. The gin flowed freely throughout, word down the wire was that there was a lot of pot too.
Great video. Love these styles . They are very elegant and show the beauty in the trunk and tree with such a small amount of foilage.i am reading ur bonsai masterclass book now and wondering do u have another favorite of ur books that i should look into. Thanks
As the age of some trees was mentioned (the young instant bonsai, etc.) I am wondering at what point in the life of a tree (or raw material) might one determine what style will suite that material. I mean, could one start from seed thinking 'Oh, this one I'll make formal upright' or is it more typical to let a tree grow (in wild or on nursery) for a time and then discover it and consider what styles are possible? Sometimes I find a tree and it's already quite tall with few low branches and I think whether I can make it bud lower down to fit a certain style, or if maybe it's just not suited to bonsai but maybe could be a garden tree or topiary or just an interesting container tree in it's own way.
No you make do with what you've got at the time. Starting from a seedling would take too long unless of course you have years and years of time on your hands !!
You love the Japanese Maple and also the Literati style of Bonsai... I have a solution. Don't try to put the two together, enjoy both for their strengths. I like fast cars and gardening. Trying to mash them together would be absurd. So, when will we see a Herons Bonsai branded potato peeler, sorry, bark removal tool, for sale? 😂
Dear mister Peter, today i find in thé garden from my brother, 9 Acer Pseudoplatanus, 2 quercus, 12 castanea sativa i hope thé are good to become bonsai , Wath do you think???
what about to cut the trunk in exactly the middle? (exactly where it goes from straight up to a left-side bend) at 16:04 (create new roots there and make the overall height way shorter) to me the straight very long trunk looks a bit empty.
@@pansepot1490 you are right. at the end of the video I did like it more. (but also many literati have no height at all they grow out of the pot and cascade downwards. I thought more of that style) personal preferemce.
All literati bonsai have long thin trunks, literati is a very much less is more approach hence the bare empty long trunks, maybe your confusing with cascade or semi cascade style !
@@beth7467 yes I see it... however with the “white bag” principle 😀 if that branch is reduced almost completely, the entire bonsai, in my opinion gain elegance
People do not understand the idea of building capital through years of purposeful service. Things worth anything, takes time to develop from raw materials. There is no inherent value in raw and uncultivated materials.
@@peterchan3100 not trolls just criticism i find your work very uninspiring rough and not very refined everything seems unfinished but no true bonsai is ever finished I find the likes of Corin Tomlinson and others more inspiring
@@shropshireladoutdoors743 not at all, he keeps things simple and that continues to this day to inspire many beginners into this hobby which is an amazing quality for a person to have. what level anybody then wishes to take their hobby is an entirely personal decision each to their own as they say. For anybody that freely gives up there time to share their knowledge and help inspire others on utube has balls, and I can only take my hat off to them as do many others. I bet you are subscribed and will continue to watch more of his videos in future 😋
I love the emphasis you put on time with these videos.
It has taken me years to understand how precious time is, and I appreciate you mentioning future generations, it is very hopeful and optimistic. I would love to see the future Herons Bonsai team revisit this tree in many many years!
Don't forget to stop and smell the pines!
The ancient Chinese used to go to the pine forests in the mountains just to smell the fragrance of the pines needles. It is supposed to be good for respiratory ailments.
thank you sir for keeping us happy with your videos.
As always, thank you.
Sharing your time and talents is greatly appreciated.
Beautiful
Love that dramatic look. This tree could live somewhere in the mountains.
I quite enjoy it on the side with the drift wood in the front. Just fits better to me. Love it either way though 😍
My, what a difference! Yes, the driftwood with the lighter wood gives the tree a more three dimensional look, showing depth. Lovely.
you always turn an ordinary looking bonsai into something incredible! thank you for the video :)
Very nice sir! The literati certainly has a style and finesse of its own.
The tree has actually gained a lot of expression.
I liked the comparison with the wine very much.
Thank you.....🙏 😔 🙏
Dr. Chan, another wonder filled video. I always learn something totally new with each video. So many gifts you give us.
🙏 🖖 🙏 😔 🙏
Mr. Chan, one of these days you should do a proper tutorial with the superbly beautiful trees that you have, watched your video on bonsai empire and alot of them seem to underestimate your skills, and me having read bonsai masterclass there are no shortage of fine specimens you have made, though of obviously you absolutely don't need to prove yourself, it just irritates me how they blather about you and would be nice to see you show them the amazing stuff you have
I am not bothered in the least about brickbats or bouquets - I just focus on my thing and my style. As you say - I don't have to prove anything.The proof of the pudding is in the eating. The number of subcribers on my UA-cam channel speaks for itself !!! Not to mention our Nursery - it is UNIQUE !! Jealousy is not a nice thing but sadly there is a lot of it about.
@@peterchan3100 i completely agree with all that you've said right sir, kudos to your principles, come to think of it I suppose there is a sense of insecurity in the need to show something, and it is really nice to know that you are a very well established self, one day I will visit your nursery, the only one who/that seems to have a warm welcoming atmosphere as opposed to others I have seen, and a familial teacher student relationship you have with the team is very heartwarming thing to watch. Thanks very much for all the good you've done, I hope I can make something similar here in indonesia, though of course in the nature of a guru and a student, I'll try to better you sir...😆(apologies for the long and perhaps impertinent cacophony)
A very interesting video! I was fascinated to hear where the name "literati" came from. I can now see the characters inherent in the style, and have a new appreciation for it. Thank you, Peter.
It looks like the pines on the antique Japanese paintings. I like these "old style" bonsai!
Call me old fashioned but, literati style trees are my absolute favorite!! I love the "movement" and grace of them.
Magic work Peter Thank you.
Imagine how good it would be if we could live as long as our trees,
I
I think I might've lost it this last year if it hadn't been for the continued zen of your bonsai videos. I hope everything is okay with you lovely people at Herons
Stay safe and keep well.
I'd like you to show us how to create a literati tree from scratch.
Wow
Thank you for the inspiration. Have a similar tree that I wasn't quite sure how to style. I love your style, as I have always marched to the tune of a different drum myself. Why be different just like everyone else? Bless you for sharing your knowledge with us.
love ur cutting-edge decisions
Part 2 looking even better, love it. Thx for sharing Peter 👍. Can't wait for the next one 🙏.
I was down at Herons on the weekend. The place was looking great! I was trying to spot this one, but I couldn't recognise / see it (from the last video) thanks for sharing!
We have thousands of trees around the place, so its difficult to spot the ones done on UA-cam
I'm so jalous : you can visite and Buy from Herons Nursery. I can't, i'm from 🇨🇦 😫😫😫
@@echan3230 I do feel very lucky - I had no idea it was only 30 mins from me. I shall probably be down there once a month now!!
@@PKDoberman 👍👍👍 have fun you lucky Man. 🙏
I knew it! I am a true Peter Chan disciple. At 14:00 ... I have always felt the same about the dichotomy of loving maples and literati bonsai. As always, thank you for sharing your love and knowledge.
Guys, I really mean this: you need to make long form videos just following Peter around for 3-4 hours out of a workday and run an ad every 15 minutes. He doesn't even need to narrate the whole time, people *will* watch. Your compression and production time will skyrocket, but so will your viewership,
Also, stream your bonsai workshops and evening wiring/pruning/shaping sessions, here or on Twitch. I bet you'll make a killing.
Mail me one dope tree that will survive with love in AZ if it works out.
Well,indeed I think you did fine this way,It looks very elegant. And may you have a nice dinner!
Thanks Peter, Very inspiring as always.
Max
Very elegant.
I would shorten the dead branch and just made a short thick jin, and pulled the top a bit closer together in order to make the bend a tad sharper.
Did you hear about the British Bonsai Academy Awards Night? It was held at Pinewood Studios, had a minimalist theme and all the gLiterati was there, in their best style. The gin flowed freely throughout, word down the wire was that there was a lot of pot too.
Great video. Love these styles . They are very elegant and show the beauty in the trunk and tree with such a small amount of foilage.i am reading ur bonsai masterclass book now and wondering do u have another favorite of ur books that i should look into. Thanks
Bonsai Secrets is a good one.
it literati looks good from both sides
Amazing😊
Certainly giving me the confidence to have a go at my Scots pine, is now still a good time to wire?
Yes - you can wire anytime of the year.
Hey, cool! I picked the front from the very beginning of the video!!
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 so beautiful 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Yes yes 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽👌🏾👌🏾👌🏾beautiful ..
Can you guys show how to propegate Juniper Nanas from cuttings or what would be the best way to do it in detail please :)
'Will it be as nice as something that's really old - no; not in a million years'.
lol
Yeah he was referring to mallsai or cheap bonsai
the point is that a million years is a period of time and by then it would be nice...ie bonsai needs time but not quite a million years lol
Looks #Awesome #Dude
Awesome Peter
Some might call it Charley Brown's Christmas tree. I call it the work of an artist.
As the age of some trees was mentioned (the young instant bonsai, etc.) I am wondering at what point in the life of a tree (or raw material) might one determine what style will suite that material. I mean, could one start from seed thinking 'Oh, this one I'll make formal upright' or is it more typical to let a tree grow (in wild or on nursery) for a time and then discover it and consider what styles are possible? Sometimes I find a tree and it's already quite tall with few low branches and I think whether I can make it bud lower down to fit a certain style, or if maybe it's just not suited to bonsai but maybe could be a garden tree or topiary or just an interesting container tree in it's own way.
No you make do with what you've got at the time. Starting from a seedling would take too long unless of course you have years and years of time on your hands !!
Good luck sir
This tree looks like it was taken from an ancient chinese painting.
That is what Literati is all about.
You love the Japanese Maple and also the Literati style of Bonsai... I have a solution. Don't try to put the two together, enjoy both for their strengths. I like fast cars and gardening. Trying to mash them together would be absurd.
So, when will we see a Herons Bonsai branded potato peeler, sorry, bark removal tool, for sale? 😂
You can buy it from any hardware store - its nothing special.
Thanks Peter. Am I the only one who thinks that from a distance that stub at the bottom of the S looks like a bird on the branch?
😍👍
🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹super !!!!!
Dear mister Peter, today i find in thé garden from my brother, 9 Acer Pseudoplatanus, 2 quercus, 12 castanea sativa i hope thé are good to become bonsai , Wath do you think???
🌲
what about to cut the trunk in exactly the middle? (exactly where it goes from straight up to a left-side bend)
at 16:04
(create new roots there and make the overall height way shorter)
to me the straight very long trunk looks a bit empty.
Pines are bad at air layering
Long naked trunk are typical of the literaty aesthetic. If you don’t like the style fine, but the pine looks good as it is.
@@pansepot1490 you are right. at the end of the video I did like it more. (but also many literati have no height at all they grow out of the pot and cascade downwards. I thought more of that style) personal preferemce.
@@PolinaS-gq1te true. I didn't think of that.
All literati bonsai have long thin trunks, literati is a very much less is more approach hence the bare empty long trunks, maybe your confusing with cascade or semi cascade style !
The dead branch can be removed almost completely
I kind of like it. It adds more movement to the tree. (Mind you, I know nothing about bonsai.)
@@beth7467 yes I see it... however with the “white bag” principle 😀 if that branch is reduced almost completely, the entire bonsai, in my opinion gain elegance
👍👌👌🙂🙂
People do not understand the idea of building capital through years of purposeful service. Things worth anything, takes time to develop from raw materials. There is no inherent value in raw and uncultivated materials.
Well said.
@@peterchan3100 Thanks 😎👍
Why would you have six down-votes. Mind boggling. .
This is a price one has to pay for social media - Trolls etc abound in this world !!
@@peterchan3100 not trolls just criticism i find your work very uninspiring rough and not very refined everything seems unfinished but no true bonsai is ever finished I find the likes of Corin Tomlinson and others more inspiring
@@shropshireladoutdoors743 so stop complaining and go watch them instead !
@@petergrisdale6797 I will this guy is a has been
@@shropshireladoutdoors743 not at all, he keeps things simple and that continues to this day to inspire many beginners into this hobby which is an amazing quality for a person to have.
what level anybody then wishes to take their hobby is an entirely personal decision each to their own as they say.
For anybody that freely gives up there time to share their knowledge and help inspire others on utube has balls, and I can only take my hat off to them as do many others.
I bet you are subscribed and will continue to watch more of his videos in future 😋