6:08 Deleted scene confirmed that Joni's company is bankrupt, people keep complaining that her products cause stuff like rashes, she's been stealing extra money claiming it's all for her daughter's university fees when she's really pocketing half of it. The thing with Meg is that she doesn't seem in a rush to pay for anything on her own or to get a job once she's finished uni. Another deleted scene shows why Walt's prejudiced wife is so jumpy, Walt started doing insider trading and is now in debt to the wrong people, that's why he's walking with the cane, his leg was hurt as a warning. He's desperate for money.
@@rxbeccarose Guess they now have no alternative now but to swallow their pride and ask Marta for help. Could be good for them. Wonder if Walt's alt-right son knows about his dads money troubles - and if he knows his grandad bought the house from a Pakistani real-estate developer, not sure if he'd like that. Do you think Marta sue him for filming her without her permission - that live-stream video he took of her when they family were clustering around her car.
This sounds almost like Umineko with th parents being in debt and trying to win favor with their father (grandpa for the second gen) for the money. Only this time everyone is alive besides the father/grandpa.
Another commenter about this film mentioned that it starts out a mystery but turns into a heist - when the audience thinks Marta is responsible, you start rooting for her to avoid getting caught.
The notorious dog lover Chris Evans has said that acting mean to the dogs for the takes with them was extremely difficult for him, cause all he wanted to do is get down and play with them. To get the dogs jumping up on him, he hid their toys in his pockets for the scene, but immediately gave them back as soon as the scenes were shot and I'm sure having a grand old time playing with them when cameras weren't rolling.
That's something Agatha Christie points out. Nurses, Doctors and Dentists, they don't just suddenly make mistakes. Don't get me wrong, she wrote about a few stories about murderous doctors or nurses but then the point would be that they used their knowledge and their training to cover their tracks and make it look like someone else did it or that it was natural. But the point is that they don't just suddenly give the wrong dosage or the wrong medication, not after years of training and practice and experiences, they just give the right medication and the right dosage automatically. There was one case of someone considering (not really as a plan but as a half-idea for revenge) caring for someone so badly they'd die of their illness but, to paraphrase what they said so as not to spoil too much, 'when you're professionally trained you can't really do that." She also put a lot of focus on the questions of 'What did they see exactly?' and 'What exactly did they say?'
This was the movie that inspired me to finally make my top 15 movies list (couldn't narrow it down to 10 aha) and it honestly makes me happy that a movie made in the late 2010s that I have no nostalgia for, is not based on a franchise I'm interested in, and is a genre I've never had more than a passing interest in, could make it on that list. "Because you are a good nurse" gets me every time. Benoit Blanc is a tough, seasoned SOB but he's clearly so compassionate too, and he values goodness in the world. It's like the movie is saying goodness can still matter even if the world is a pretty objectively shitty place. While many aspects of the film are cheesy, that message is presented in probably the least cheesy way possible, and I really appreciate that.
Note that just about all of them at some point mention where Marta is from - each of them says a different South American country. That's how much they really care.
6:20 Not really. Walt's wife is likewise jumpy and she's an outsider, only in the family because she married Walt. Richard's an outsider, he's only in the family because he married Linda. And Joni's an outsider too, she's only in the family because she was married to another son who's now dead. And lets not forget Fran the housekeeper, they'd see her as an outsider as well. Plenty of murder mysteries are done by outsiders either because they wormed their way into something or because it turns out they have a closer connection to a family or a person than anyone knows, but just as many are done by family members. Sometimes it's even both.
20:44 wow i would hate all of them staring at me like that. it's like the equivalent of having to do a presentation in front of the class and they all stare at u
One of my favourite films of the decade, brilliant acting, fantastic writing and great characters. Rian Johnson might've done a lot of bad work with Star Wars but he definitely redeemed himself after making this modern masterpiece and cant wait to see the next 2 he is working on right now.
Making one decent movie makes up for killing an entire franchise? 🤔 interesting. A lot of people deemed Star Wars 4, 5, and 6 as Masterpieces...yet Rian dismantled everything they did by changing Luke to his wretched version...and why we got the follow up trying to reassemble what he destroyed.
@pulpficti i only like 4. I consider films like Train to Busan, Willow, Ghost in the Darkness, Conan the Barbarian(1982), A Silent Voice, Sword of the Stranger, Kill Bill Volume 1, 3 Idiots, Midnight FM, all better. So what are some movies you consider better than the 2 Star Wars u like? I assume ur a Rian Johnson fan so probably some other overrated Hollywood stuff? Twilight? 50 Shades? Hateful Eight or Inglorious Bstrds? With your name i assume you love Tarantino so think he can't do any bad cinema... he's about as close to the same % of good movies as Star Wars. Those in a glass house shouldn't throw stones. Comments like urs are the worst. Accuse, poke with little input, trying to invoke a fIippid response. 0 content. Shows character.
@@myTERAexperience I am so sorry to hurt your feelings. Tbh I don't like any Rian Johnson movies except for knives out. Obviously I like every Tarantino movie. Objectively speaking maybe 2 are mediocre but that's definitely better than whatever those prequels were. And funnily enough, the prequels are considered good now amongst Star Wars fans lol
Suspecting the "outsider" for so long just because she's the "outsider" is hella sus, ngl. (Especially when literally all the other characters are shown to be awful people and she's the only one who seems even a little human).
I know some people really hated Rian Johnson because of The Last Jedi, but I actually really liked it (less after Rise of Skywalker because it undid most of it, but still) and I love this movie. They’re even kind of similar if you think about it, in that both of them deconstruct some aspect of themselves: The Last Jedi deconstructs Star Wars by showing realistic outcomes of the franchise’s tropes or subverting expectations based on past movies. Knives Out meanwhile deconstructs the whodunnit by setting it up as a typical one, then showing the answer in the beginning and how the ”killer” tries to cover her tracks and having the eccentric detective seem like a total goofball. Then it turns that around by showing how competent the detective is despite his quirks and revealing that the whole cover-up plot has continued the whodunnit mystery and given the hints to who the real killer was
There's actually a very cheap way to figure out who did it: Apple doesn't allow movie villains to use their devices on screen. Whoever doesn't have one is who did it.
This film is interesting, because the flashbacks are 100% factual, but what the suspects/witnesses are saying is not. For everyone but Marta, they don't necessarily show the perspective of the characters. Rather, they show an objective look at the events - superimposed over their verbal accounts of what happened. Another interesting aspect of this film is that it's a mystery, but you're not trying to figure out whodunnit. You are still given a cast of characters with motives to wish harm on Harlan Thromby, but with the apparent killer revealed early on, the task for the viewer ends up being to make sense of the story. For most of the rest of the film, the story's purpose is unclear until the very end.
My only complaint is that assuming this was set in present time when it was filmed it would be 2019. No one that lives in that type of house with that kind of money and a private security system then would have a security system that records on VHS tapes. It would be a DVR or a cloud storage type of set up.
I got a perfect recommendation the hot animation call Arcane the show critics are calling it a masterpiece. I believe it is this generation's classical story that will be apart of pop culture for now and decades to century.
I wonder if you would have immediately figured out that it was Ransom if you had watched the trailer first. The only reason I wasn't impressed with this film was the trailer, to me, made it really obvious that Ransom was the killer. And every scene about Ransom and every scene he was in just made it more and more obvious that it was him. The Grandma at the window is what locked him in as my number 1 suspect without a doubt which made the will reading scene really interesting the first time watching but the whole film sadly disappointing as I was basically just waiting to be confirmed right. But as time goes on I do enjoy the film more and more. The best thing it has going for it is that at the very least it's entertaining from start to finish.
I don’t know why you would ever watch the trailer for a mystery film like this. I don’t even watch most trailers for any movie I’m interested in seeing.
@@rxbeccarose You need to. This movie owes a lot to it. Same type of vibe but more comedic and campy. Stars Tim Curry, Chrisotpher Lloyd, Madeline Kahn, and Michael McKean among others screenplay co-written by John Landis.
Please never ever buy or rent a Rian Johnson film again. 😅 i bare a grudge against this man for the horrible Star Wars movie "The Last Jedi" he did. 🤨 He must never work again! Ewoks!Assemble! 🦁
@Curtis Murphy "Grow up," he says through tears streaming down his face. "The movie was fine," as he caressed Rians face with one hand, the other, hidden from view. "Good, even to some," as he leaned in for a kiss.
![**THE EMPERORS NEW GROOVE** Is the FUNNIEST Disney Movie [Movie Reaction/Commentary]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JES8a95x6Qw/mqdefault.jpg)
6:08 Deleted scene confirmed that Joni's company is bankrupt, people keep complaining that her products cause stuff like rashes, she's been stealing extra money claiming it's all for her daughter's university fees when she's really pocketing half of it. The thing with Meg is that she doesn't seem in a rush to pay for anything on her own or to get a job once she's finished uni.
Another deleted scene shows why Walt's prejudiced wife is so jumpy, Walt started doing insider trading and is now in debt to the wrong people, that's why he's walking with the cane, his leg was hurt as a warning. He's desperate for money.
Oooh that’s interesting
@@rxbeccarose Guess they now have no alternative now but to swallow their pride and ask Marta for help. Could be good for them. Wonder if Walt's alt-right son knows about his dads money troubles - and if he knows his grandad bought the house from a Pakistani real-estate developer, not sure if he'd like that. Do you think Marta sue him for filming her without her permission - that live-stream video he took of her when they family were clustering around her car.
This sounds almost like Umineko with th parents being in debt and trying to win favor with their father (grandpa for the second gen) for the money.
Only this time everyone is alive besides the father/grandpa.
I was so sad every time you suspected Marta bc I was over here like she's the only good person here LOL loved the reaction!!
Ik, editing this made me mad at myself 😭😹
@@rxbeccarose A room full of rich, white jerks and you pick the immigrant girl to be suspicious of.
Yeah, why just suspect one person just because she was an "outsider"?!
Putting everything in my life on pause for the next 30 minutes, thanks bestie
As you should
Hi
Toni Collette looks like a 66 year old the same age of my grandma
Another commenter about this film mentioned that it starts out a mystery but turns into a heist - when the audience thinks Marta is responsible, you start rooting for her to avoid getting caught.
The notorious dog lover Chris Evans has said that acting mean to the dogs for the takes with them was extremely difficult for him, cause all he wanted to do is get down and play with them. To get the dogs jumping up on him, he hid their toys in his pockets for the scene, but immediately gave them back as soon as the scenes were shot and I'm sure having a grand old time playing with them when cameras weren't rolling.
Awww, precious!
That's adorable!
You MURDERED Richard
Musty Crusty dusty and pale male and stale????
You win this 😂😂
Hello billy
billy!
It’s what he deserves
lolol
That's something Agatha Christie points out. Nurses, Doctors and Dentists, they don't just suddenly make mistakes. Don't get me wrong, she wrote about a few stories about murderous doctors or nurses but then the point would be that they used their knowledge and their training to cover their tracks and make it look like someone else did it or that it was natural. But the point is that they don't just suddenly give the wrong dosage or the wrong medication, not after years of training and practice and experiences, they just give the right medication and the right dosage automatically. There was one case of someone considering (not really as a plan but as a half-idea for revenge) caring for someone so badly they'd die of their illness but, to paraphrase what they said so as not to spoil too much, 'when you're professionally trained you can't really do that."
She also put a lot of focus on the questions of 'What did they see exactly?' and 'What exactly did they say?'
Chris Evans and that cable knit sweater 🥵
Seems to have you in a chokehold
This was the movie that inspired me to finally make my top 15 movies list (couldn't narrow it down to 10 aha) and it honestly makes me happy that a movie made in the late 2010s that I have no nostalgia for, is not based on a franchise I'm interested in, and is a genre I've never had more than a passing interest in, could make it on that list.
"Because you are a good nurse" gets me every time. Benoit Blanc is a tough, seasoned SOB but he's clearly so compassionate too, and he values goodness in the world. It's like the movie is saying goodness can still matter even if the world is a pretty objectively shitty place. While many aspects of the film are cheesy, that message is presented in probably the least cheesy way possible, and I really appreciate that.
I appreciate it too
Note that just about all of them at some point mention where Marta is from - each of them says a different South American country. That's how much they really care.
This movie is literally so good, you think you know where it’s going and then it does a turn on you. Plus the cast is just exquisite
6:20 Not really. Walt's wife is likewise jumpy and she's an outsider, only in the family because she married Walt. Richard's an outsider, he's only in the family because he married Linda. And Joni's an outsider too, she's only in the family because she was married to another son who's now dead. And lets not forget Fran the housekeeper, they'd see her as an outsider as well.
Plenty of murder mysteries are done by outsiders either because they wormed their way into something or because it turns out they have a closer connection to a family or a person than anyone knows, but just as many are done by family members. Sometimes it's even both.
20:44 wow i would hate all of them staring at me like that. it's like the equivalent of having to do a presentation in front of the class and they all stare at u
Literally!!
You can't accuse Marta! She's a precious angel!
One of my favourite films of the decade, brilliant acting, fantastic writing and great characters. Rian Johnson might've done a lot of bad work with Star Wars but he definitely redeemed himself after making this modern masterpiece and cant wait to see the next 2 he is working on right now.
I’m interested to see what’s gonna happen in the next one!
Making one decent movie makes up for killing an entire franchise? 🤔 interesting. A lot of people deemed Star Wars 4, 5, and 6 as Masterpieces...yet Rian dismantled everything they did by changing Luke to his wretched version...and why we got the follow up trying to reassemble what he destroyed.
@@myTERAexperience Man Star Wars Fans are the worst. There's 2 good movies in the franchise. The rest is at best mediocre
@pulpficti i only like 4. I consider films like Train to Busan, Willow, Ghost in the Darkness, Conan the Barbarian(1982), A Silent Voice, Sword of the Stranger, Kill Bill Volume 1, 3 Idiots, Midnight FM, all better.
So what are some movies you consider better than the 2 Star Wars u like? I assume ur a Rian Johnson fan so probably some other overrated Hollywood stuff? Twilight? 50 Shades? Hateful Eight or Inglorious Bstrds? With your name i assume you love Tarantino so think he can't do any bad cinema... he's about as close to the same % of good movies as Star Wars. Those in a glass house shouldn't throw stones.
Comments like urs are the worst. Accuse, poke with little input, trying to invoke a fIippid response. 0 content. Shows character.
@@myTERAexperience I am so sorry to hurt your feelings. Tbh I don't like any Rian Johnson movies except for knives out. Obviously I like every Tarantino movie. Objectively speaking maybe 2 are mediocre but that's definitely better than whatever those prequels were. And funnily enough, the prequels are considered good now amongst Star Wars fans lol
15:05 won my heart with that quick wit Ms.Rose.
Ana de armis did a great job in knives out along with daniel Craig and Christopher Plummer 😊😉
They really did!
Everyone should see this movie at least once🖋
I'm dead on how everything she's sure of is wrong and all of the way ifs are right
Suspecting the "outsider" for so long just because she's the "outsider" is hella sus, ngl.
(Especially when literally all the other characters are shown to be awful people and she's the only one who seems even a little human).
I know some people really hated Rian Johnson because of The Last Jedi, but I actually really liked it (less after Rise of Skywalker because it undid most of it, but still) and I love this movie. They’re even kind of similar if you think about it, in that both of them deconstruct some aspect of themselves:
The Last Jedi deconstructs Star Wars by showing realistic outcomes of the franchise’s tropes or subverting expectations based on past movies.
Knives Out meanwhile deconstructs the whodunnit by setting it up as a typical one, then showing the answer in the beginning and how the ”killer” tries to cover her tracks and having the eccentric detective seem like a total goofball. Then it turns that around by showing how competent the detective is despite his quirks and revealing that the whole cover-up plot has continued the whodunnit mystery and given the hints to who the real killer was
I love how expansive the UA-cam reactor multiverse is
Me too :))
Netflix will be distributing the sequels to this. The first one has been made filmed and featured a whole new cast except for Daniel Craig
There's actually a very cheap way to figure out who did it:
Apple doesn't allow movie villains to use their devices on screen. Whoever doesn't have one is who did it.
Oh really?!?
I never knew that. Well, time to integrate something similar to my mystery manuscripts. 😂
@@RabbitsFunWorld they also did this in Dear Evan Hansen.
I had my iPad at school cause my teacher wanted to do something on it and I saw this notification I was so mad I wanted to watch it so bad
😭😭😭 that’s tragic
I LOVE this movie and I love that you watched it even more
Yay!
I love you and your videos sooooo much I’m so glad I found you!!!
Ah thank u!!
The character Donna is played by Riki Lindhome. I have seen her Big Bang Theory and 2 1/2 Men
Hi Rebecca hope you are having an great and awesome day ❤
You too John!!
24:01 “you’re broke” 😭😭😭 that was too funny
i never watched it but i saw movies in depth's reaction to it
He’s a LEGEND
You were so good at noticing the little details, but poor Marta! XD
This film is interesting, because the flashbacks are 100% factual, but what the suspects/witnesses are saying is not. For everyone but Marta, they don't necessarily show the perspective of the characters. Rather, they show an objective look at the events - superimposed over their verbal accounts of what happened. Another interesting aspect of this film is that it's a mystery, but you're not trying to figure out whodunnit. You are still given a cast of characters with motives to wish harm on Harlan Thromby, but with the apparent killer revealed early on, the task for the viewer ends up being to make sense of the story. For most of the rest of the film, the story's purpose is unclear until the very end.
*what actually happens get revealed*
Her: Uhm nah, this ain't it
I know I am going to love this
Aye that’s grand
Such a great movie!
1000% yes
Omg u should watch the sequel: Glass Onion. Thought it's better than the first one
I love your videos and it makes me want to make a commentary channel in the future so thankyou for inspiring me🥰💖
Ah DO IT
@@rxbeccarose oh my god thankyou❤
I love your content and your channel and the facts that you're British is icing on the fucking cake you are awesome.
My only complaint is that assuming this was set in present time when it was filmed it would be 2019. No one that lives in that type of house with that kind of money and a private security system then would have a security system that records on VHS tapes. It would be a DVR or a cloud storage type of set up.
Good reaction! I liked it
Thanks legend!!
First time I injoy a detective movie!
I got a perfect recommendation the hot animation call Arcane the show critics are calling it a masterpiece. I believe it is this generation's classical story that will be apart of pop culture for now and decades to century.
Thought this was a Trin Lovell video from the thumbnail lmao. Same haircut, similar glasses, similar thumbnail
You have to watch the wiz from 1978 it's so good
The latest in the Good For Her Cinematic Universe.
Richard probably ended getting divorced by Linda after she saw the letter from her father. I can't wait for Knives out 2 to come out on Netflix.
I had to click as soon as possible
LEGEND
I love Rival Reacts, he's my crush
Rian did a great job with this movie 👍🙂
They did!!
They took the movie off Prime?
Musty crusty dusty
Pale male and stale 😂
I wasn’t wrong
When are you going to finish high school Musical the musical The series
PLEASE REACT TO CRUEL INTENTIONS ITS HONESTLY ONE OF THE BEST MOVIES EVER
How about Arnold from 1973?
If you wanna see Katherine Langford in something good, PLEASE go try Spontaneous! I think you will be genuinely surprised!
Rebecca If u like this movie you should watch murder mystery it has Adam sander and Jennifer Anniston starring it’s also on Netflix
You should definitely watch to wong foo thanks for everything julie newmar starring Patrick Swayze and wesley snipes and john leguizamo 👍
Second favorite movie
What’s your first?
@@rxbeccarose Coraline lol
I wonder if you would have immediately figured out that it was Ransom if you had watched the trailer first.
The only reason I wasn't impressed with this film was the trailer, to me, made it really obvious that Ransom was the killer.
And every scene about Ransom and every scene he was in just made it more and more obvious that it was him.
The Grandma at the window is what locked him in as my number 1 suspect without a doubt which made the will reading scene really interesting the first time watching but the whole film sadly disappointing as I was basically just waiting to be confirmed right.
But as time goes on I do enjoy the film more and more. The best thing it has going for it is that at the very least it's entertaining from start to finish.
I don’t know why you would ever watch the trailer for a mystery film like this. I don’t even watch most trailers for any movie I’m interested in seeing.
Has she watched the movie clue yet?
I have not
@@rxbeccarose You need to. This movie owes a lot to it. Same type of vibe but more comedic and campy. Stars Tim Curry, Chrisotpher Lloyd, Madeline Kahn, and Michael McKean among others screenplay co-written by John Landis.
When are you going to react to the Creepy Game Show Host???
watch scream 2022 on soaop2day!
ewww when she threw up at his face 🤢🤢
Still haunts me
I think she missed the line
You kinda sus
Very good movie ...very average reaction! 👎👎👎
You talk too much.
Please never ever buy or rent a Rian Johnson film again. 😅 i bare a grudge against this man for the horrible Star Wars movie "The Last Jedi" he did. 🤨
He must never work again! Ewoks!Assemble! 🦁
Grow up. The movie was fine, good even to some
@Curtis Murphy "Grow up," he says through tears streaming down his face. "The movie was fine," as he caressed Rians face with one hand, the other, hidden from view. "Good, even to some," as he leaned in for a kiss.