Hope y'all enjoy this lil mystery investigation! If you want to see any more videos like this give me suggestions! :D Also, don't forget to go follow me over on Instagram! --> goo.gl/6m5uYk
Omg what if a flood spore was in the water and a poor unsuspecting marine conveniently take a crap at the time got infected... anally. RIP Jenkins #2018
I heard it was due to teleportation: 1) Pelicans flying in have to coordinate with air traffic controllers. Any infected humans would not be able to coordinate, and something would have been clearly wrong, and permission to land denied. 2) Flood spores would take time to reproduce, and a properly-designed spaceship would be like a submarine- it can seal off areas to prevent the entire vessel from being destroyed. The spores would have to either bide their time to reach critical mass, or get extremely lucky and infect the bridge controls team. 3) The humans on the ground had already made contact with the flood, and their radio chatter wasn't scrambled. So the humans on board would have been watching out for flood-infected vessels 4) Low orbit is several miles above he ground. At that altitude, the air is too thin for humans to breathe, so the vents would be closed to avoid de-pressurization. It would take some while for anything that wasn't in a flying machine to float/fly up, and we already discussed how the infected pelicans would stand out to the flight controllers 5) The Gravemind teleported both the Chief and Arbiter
You know at first I thought that idea would just be full of shit since the gravemind lol TPing all the flood everywhere seems like it'd be an unfair power to have but now it really does make sense. O_O I guess it could just be a feasible ability he had due to having access to forerunner tech from delta halo since 343 could do it and even cortana learned how to at some point.
I'm actually suprised you missed something in this. In the lore after the UNSC beat the Covenant on the Ark there was a new rule set in place to avoid this type of situation in the future. The rule was and i quote... *"DON'T GO FULL MIRANDA KEYES"*
No, it was a set of rules: 1) don't park your Frigate directly above the Library or any other flood infected facility 2) don't hesitate to remove reclaimers about to be forced to activate life ending Forerunner weapons 3) give your troopers an actual rally point
2:50 That flying scorpion is hostile to the player and can fire its 90mm at you. I remember getting one shotted a few too many times on legendary by it.
Anyone else wanna see the I C O N I C ODSTs return in Infinite? Honestly as long as Marines are commonplace I'm happy, but my helljumper bois need some love outside of Arcade Games.
Totally agree. But I will say that the addition of Spartan 4s kinda diluted everything. The 2s and 3s were trained from kids and were pretty much one of kind. The 4s are like "anyone can be a Spartan." I miss when Buck was an ODST
Spore theory valid, gravemind teleport theory valid, infested pelican theory valid. I'm partial to the pelican one myself. Keyes and crew were operating on Halo 1 intel, so could not know the effect a gravemind would have on the rest of the flood; keeping aircraft and In Amber Clad out of jumping distance was probably considered sufficient. Staying close minimizes travel time and maximizes firepower against the infestation, not to mention reduces the chance of being spotted and swatted by the covy fleet (before it got busy tearing itself appart in civil war). If a bird gets shot down, oh well write it off, not like they can fix it. Oh look, that one survived after all...
Hopefully not. Lmao i just imagined that Del Rio might have actually made the decision to run from the flood area. For once running away wasn't being a bitch.
@@fredrick1043 CE magnums are more effective at mid to long range, CE Shotguns instantly fuck them up at close range in 1 to 2 shots with a 12 round mag and 60 rounds instead of 6 and 30 of later games *(god I miss the Halo CE Shotgun)*
Exactly! It can't be spores. It has to be an aerial vehicle hijacked by the Flood for IAC boarding action. Unless... Oh dear God! What if someone got bitten?! The In Amber Clad and Miranda Keyes by extension were never mentioned to have history fighting against the Flood before. Plenty of ways to tell this. So none of them woulda guessed that getting bitten by space zombies could lead to infection and conversion! What if a pelican "rescued" injured marine *'TROJAN HORSES!!!!"* :0
@KingDeath720 he's actually partially infected. the Orion augmentations essentially made the flood reject him as a host, but his DNA is still partially infected with the flood supercell
Bored Ninja Which mean we’ll never get that. Because 343 can’t do awesome, only mediocre. And Bungie decided they’re better off making money off of starting failure games, and then fixing them over the course of two or three years.
@@crypto1223 We'll see what happens after Halo Infinite. They've had 3+ years to work on the game already. Hopefully they'll be able to rectify Halo for what it truly is, an amazing masterpiece. If not, then I'm finished with Halo.
I had always assumed that it was infected due to the Gravemind’s ability to teleport. If it had the ability to teleport the Master Chief onto High Charity, then the Gravemind had the ability to teleport infected soldiers onto In Amber Clad.
But gravemind specifically sent them to locations known by the profit of Regret and penitent tangent, his other captives in the cutscene. Perhaps he needs specific knowledge of some sort. Though neither of our theories address why gravemind needed the In Amber Clad to infect high charity then.
@@alphabet2238 this would make waaay more sense, maybe even too much sense. one of the known flood containment protocols is setting teleporters into a local loop configuration, so we can assume that the flood is teleportable by forerunner tech and that teleporting someone who is infected does not screen the flood out as a cure. it would make even more sense if they just didn't allow flood teleportation at all, or if they had the scanning resolution to be able to pick out what's infected and what's not.
@@shadowblood95 It may be that the teleportation capacity is limited, we only see the Gravemind teleport two individuals to two separate spots, so in order to infiltrate High Charity with as large of an initial force as possible, an entire ship might have been a better insertion method.
Third Theory: A pelican landed to drop off troops or supplies in the infected zone. Then a Infected Form or two crawled up too and attached to the bottom side of the pelican without anyone seeing it. The pelican then returned to the ship and the madness started. But that’s my opinion of what could have happened.
Or the one and only theory that actually makes sense... The Flood sent direct flood forms to the In Amber clad via the Halo rings teleportation grid. After all, when High Charity was compromised, at a certain part in the mission you begin to see HUGE tentacles form out of practically no where, giving the idea that the Gravemind teleported parts of his body to High Charity it-self when the infection started.
@@Nighterlev Except no flood forms are seen being teleported during gameplay. Only Arbiter and Chief are teleported. It wouldn't make sense for a forerunner teleportation network to be able to teleport the flood.
@@Nighterlev Unless the arbiter shutting down the sentinel wall shield allowed gravemind to utilize the teleportation network for the flood. Gravemind may also been helped by its precursor knowledge and the fact that High Charity is made from reverse-engineered Forerunner tech.
There could be a sort of third theory where a pilot or a few marines was infected by flood spores and because of their slow infection nature went to In Amber Cald for treatment, but transformed in the medical bay or hangar which would sooner or later spread throughout the whole ship.
Yeah really, @@ItsButterBean1020. Though you would think the human medics would of quickly identified "Oh fuck! You're Infected!!" then promptly run out of the medical room then immediately have their ship's AI put the medical room on lockdown to await for the ship's few remaining guardsmen to come in and incinerate the medical room. The teleportation idea holds the most water in this. How would a few Infected Marines easily bring down the entire ship with what I described most likely being the new medical procedures involving the Flood.
I don't think it was stupid put the in amber clad on low orbit, humans have only one ship, against a covenant cruiser is dead, against a fleet and high charity, there is nothing they can do, no camouflage, no mines, no back up, nothing. They do the only play at their disposal, go where they wouldn't, to orbit. And use that frigate to suport their men on the quarantine zone. And after recover the index evacuate faster to the ship and jump to hyperspace to human space
Or the one and only theory that actually makes sense... The Flood sent direct flood forms to the In Amber clad via the Halo rings teleportation grid. After all, when High Charity was compromised, at a certain part in the mission you begin to see HUGE tentacles form out of practically no where (suspecting this might be the Gravemind him-self judging from the talking alone), giving the idea that the Gravemind teleported parts of his body to High Charity it-self when the infection started. In Amber Clad was just a distraction, along with trying to quickly stop the prophet of Truth from leaving.
I agree with both of these, seeing as the only UNSC local presence was the In Amber Clad, they are forced to hide most of their presence, thus taking risks, subsequently causing the loss of the frigate, her crew, and the coordinates to Earth (most probable source unless otherwise detailed by canon sources). Either the pelicans or the Gravemind's access to the teleportation could easily spread the Flood to the frigate. And if it only took a day for High Charity to fall, how much easier for just one small frigate right above the quarantine zone?
@@fleetadmiralchompa Tbh the reason why High Charity seemed to fall so fast is what I speculate, the Halo teleportation grid. The Gravemind was teleporting large parts of his over-all presence over to High Charity, and in doing so he probably lost access to Halo's teleportation grid. So when the Elites started glassing the ring from Flood infection, he couldn't exactly teleport even more Flood forms to those ships in key area's. It could've also been because the Elites ships were out of range, because they mostly did it via plasma bombardment. High Charity on the other hand was practically right next to it..so when the sentinel wall/shields were shut down, the Gravemind went all out and tried to infect as many places as possible to get off the Halo ring.
@@Nighterlev Not to mention that the Gravemind already had in its possession a prophet (San shayuum (spl?)). All of these factors contributed to the very efficient spread of the Flood! Besides the fact that the b/c the Flood operates on an intelligible level, thus above purely epidemiological distributions, but also b/c they're coordinated, suggests an active and concerted effort to infect all living organisms on High Charity (this is the obvious conclusion 😅). I can't even begin to imagine what it must've been like trying to escape the increasingly desperate city; something akin to Deadspace, or worse!
I like this. If Keyes wants to not die to the Covenant fleet she has 2 options, hide on the outskirts of the system, behind a moon or something like that. That doesn't really leave any option to then do really anything on the ring. The other is go into low orbit so close to halo the Covenant would not risk bombardment for damaging the ring. They could try to stop her by boarding but it's harder. To minimise this risk you want to be there as short a time as possible, so being very close to her mission of the index gives her the maximum chance to get the index and run before the Covenant can stop her. Regarding the flood she may not have known the extent of the outbreak (she 100% could not anticipate infected pelicans) until she was already committed, after all the flood were way more contained on the first halo so why expect anything different. If she did know the risk then the library being an active combat and flood infected zone makes the Covenant putting a big fleet nearby way too risky for them. Over the Library is the only place she can get any real safety form the Covenant and she isn't going to expect the flood infection to be as bad as it was. It's a gamble but it's basically her only option if she wants to do anything.
Imagine how terrifying the situation must've been on the ground for those marines. The dark atmosphere, flood screeching in the distance. Only for even of your heaviest equipment to fall to the flood.
Arbiter: "In order to get to the Sacred Icon, I had to deactivate the Containment Shield." Master Chief: "That's a big fucking mistake right there. Next time we're at a Halo ring, that's not going to happen."
Now that I think about it, Miranda's capture by the covenant actually saved her life! If she hadn't had that confrontation she would have boarded the ship only to find the crew was completely infected, neither she or Johnson would have stood a chance, regardless of Johnson's slight immunity to the flood.
The mention of the section where Keyes and Johnson ride a gondola to the Index made me realize how much I'd love a game level or cutscene showing their point of view.
Would make an interesting series/mini game to see how the marines and crew members tried to fight off the flood and showing the events leading up to high charity
I love videos like this because I feel like this is the point of leaving things unknown to the player. The speculation of what might have happened helps make these games timeless! That’s something I really miss about halo
5:52 oh yeah, just throw a grenade at a sentinel. That definitely wont be a waste of a grenade Also, that isn't in orbit. It's just hovering there. The ISS is in orbit, falling around the planet at around 7 km/sec. If it was actually in orbit, it wouldn't be infected
*flood knocks on door* "can we come in?" *Canadian door guard "I don't know I'm not supposed to...." *Flood* "we promise we'll be nice" "well ok then if you promise!" *Opens door*
Actually, all pelicans in the level quarantine zone are piloted by humans and you can kill the scorpion marine being carried by one near the beginning of the mission.
The fact that so many marines were down on the ring, as evidence by the number of human combat forms, is a great clue as to how it was so easily captured. A frigate wouldn't have a huge complement of marines to begin with, and losing so many before the flood even breech the ship, however they do it, would be an instant death.
I always felt that the Flood's appearance in Halo 2 felt Shoehorned in, espcially coming from Halo CE. Though Miranda was an infuriatingly incompetent leader
Her one-liner at the beginning of Halo 3 drives me ballistic. For those who might not remember, a marine at a comm station requests a rally point for the troops, asking where he should send them. Keyes just says, "To war." I know it's just to look cool to the player, but I'd have much preferred if she gave some sort of contingency order or something. Like, c'mon, it's ridiculous
@Melissa Waterman Tbf, both her amd Johnson got that short end of the stick, with him getting captured and then killed by Guilty Spark. In the end, they served as "friendly NCO and Officer" for MC in Halo 2 and 3.
I always had the theory that the frigate entering low orbit happened after a Medi-Vac of one of the ground teams (we see plenty of infected marines and dead marines down there) who had flood spores, turned then parked it in low orbit to make infection easier | and that partially infected spore marines started calling down pelican supplies and support to rapidly drain the defensive capability right before they began sieging the ship
Gravemind was so shortsighted for taking the in amber clad to high charity. He should have just booked it to the nearest populated planet and went from there.
@@stylesrj I'll assume you're serious and give you a simplified answer. Unless a planetary body is without an atmosphere, low orbit refers to any roughly circular orbit outside the atmosphere. For something like the Earth, that would be anywhere from roughly 100km to 2000km above the surface.
Now that I think about it. Captain Miranda Keys single handedly took down the galaxy's largest non Forerunner structure: High Charity. By mistake, lol. I mean I know it was the Flood but they couldn't have down it without her. :)
Captain: Where we landin', Bois? Navigator: Lazy Library! Crewman: Aww man, but that's where all the flood like to land. Captain: Lazy Library it is! Marines: ... Crewman: Is it just me, or are the Marines a bit too quiet. Infected Marine: Raaaaagh! Captain: Nope, definitely Marines being Marines. *Loud thud* Navigator: Hey, would someone get that? Crewman: But what if the flood get me? Captain: We'll cover you. Tell those Marines to pipe it down. *Just before the gang can get the Unfrigginbelievable Victory Royale, the infected Marines swarm the room and infect them. On screen, the flood t-bags the dead players*
There should be a special intro for these Flood videos. While nothing's there, you just see Flood tentacles creeping out of the darkness with the Elite (now infected) slowly coming out until it jumps at the screen, making things go dark, then have the classic Gravemind laugh there, then BAM. Video starts.
my theory has always been a pelican, since the amber clad was so low, not really the spores, I believe the spores usually affect unsc or covenant will weak immune systems, basically through the fact many instances of flood vs covenant and human vs flood, there wee many instances were both groups were exposed to heavy amounts of spores yet they didn't turn but when the spores reach there ships non-combat personnel did, The evidence I place my theory with comes with the many survivors of all the outbreaks in game and some books, john, sgt Johnsen, many marines, arbiter, and surviving covenant that retreated away from high charity during its infection
Could you please upload your Halloween livestream to youtube if you still have it, I live in the UK and was only able to watch the first 10 minutes, when I went to watch it in the morning after it was unavailable.
That "snow" you tend to see in flood areas is the flood spores. They appear in every halo game the flood do though they don't stand out much compared to the yellowish fog. In some cases such as outside in Halo 2 it is actual snow but you will still see the spores inside.
The Lone One 0303 I’m pretty sure its Neural physics that the precursors used. Seeing how the flood came from precursor dust I think the abilities carry over to some degree
@@glitzyx4x852 i found this post on halo waypoint: "It's quite obvious, actually. When In Amber Clad landed on Delta Halo/Installation 04 at the same time that the Arbiter was [also] sent to retrieve the Index, multiple UNSC (and Covenant) troops were killed in the process, giving Gravemind more access to biomass. The Flood took over the bodies - and hence, the memories of those bodies - and they then proceeded to invade and capture In Amber Clad (in case you're wondering, Sgt. Johnson and Miranda Keyes were captured by Tartarus).Gravemind then had himself disassembled piece by piece to In Amber Clad, which later crashed into High Charity along with the friendly Flood infection asking for a cup of sugar. The Flood infection spread throughout High Charity and Gravemind had himself reassembled there. High Charity eventually crashed into the surface of the Ark where Gravemind slowly increased his biomass from the countless bodies from the War.Thusly, the Gravemind we all know and love from Halo 2 is the same Gravemind that we all know and hate [because of the constant mind interruptions] from Halo 3. And no, the proto-Gravemind from Halo: CE is not the same. the Proto-Gravemind was destroyed along with the rest of Alpha Halo/Installation 03. Plus, the Gravemind I'm talking about was far too old to have been the Proto-Gravemind."
Jayden Abraham ok but keep in mind high charity was already under flood control during quarantine it’s just the flood used the ship to increase the spreading then set up a grave mind
I really doubt spores had anything to do with this. Keys had Cortana access all the intel Chief had gathered on 04 and I would hope that included intel on the flood (if not, no reason for Cortana or Chief to not warn them). If the UNSC Navy operates anything like a real life Navy, standard operating procedure while in combat would have the ship set to condition Zebra (basically making the ship airtight and isolating compartments from each other to stop the spread of fire and flooding (pun intended). This would make the ship airtight and force a switch over to air recycling thus prevent spores from entering. As for the pelican theory Im sure at least 1 Marine or a flying pelican had to have radioed in saying "Hey guys they can use our shit! look out!" As a result of that the ships CIC would have been monitoring for pelicans to be squawking IFF and keeping track of downed birds in flood controlled areas and even possibly have orders to shoot down or at the least deny landing clearance to non responsive pelicans. This is all crap that a basic combative ship would have done in this situation in real life. In order for a spore to have entered they would have had to ignore the most basic shipboard survival procedures which I highly doubt they would have being that they are a highly advanced space based Naval force that chronologically follows our basic real life time line and therefore lessons learned in naval combat. In order for a pelican to get on board the ship would have had to 1) granted landing clearance to a non responsive pelican or at the very least maybe one that still had a working IFF signature but no comms (most likely but very stupid of the crew) or 2) have missed a commandeered pelican with all their point defenses and then said pelican crashed into and breaching the hull of the ship (highly unlikely). My theory is that the In Amber Clad became infected from either a sheer lack of common sense and training resulting from budget cuts, or because the flood has plot armor
A pelican crashed into the In Amber Clad isn't that far fetched, it's "only" a frigate, also it was probably understaffed so either comms/tracking/weapon systems is bound to get understaffed as well. Misscommandeering in such a situation is also not unfeasible, I mean at Cairo station Harper wants to engage the Covenant Battleships head-on. xD But yeah I imagine they would be recirculating air at the very least.
Or the one and only theory that actually makes sense... The Flood sent direct flood forms to the In Amber clad via the Halo rings teleportation grid. After all, when High Charity was compromised, at a certain part in the mission you begin to see HUGE tentacles form out of practically no where (suspecting this might be the Gravemind him-self judging from the talking alone), giving the idea that the Gravemind teleported parts of his body to High Charity it-self when the infection started. In Amber Clad was just a distraction, along with trying to quickly stop the prophet of Truth from leaving.
The Real Jeff I concur with the plot armor theory. Had a UNSC commander really paid attention to the intel, she would have stayed far away from the quarantine zone. Also I think when she mentioned the index, chief should have chimed in like, “hey going into the library is a terrible idea. Believe me I’ve been there...” in Halo 1 Cortana was very concerned with the flood. Halo 2, she forgot to mention the gravity of the parasite to her commanding officer, and so did the chief.
As someone pointed out elsewhere. The Gravemind had access to the telepot system (It teleports the chief and Arbiter later). All it had to do was infect one person that knew the location and layout of the ship. Then teleport an overwhelming force aboard. Job done. And naff all that Keyes or anyone else did could have stopped it
You're a Bridge Officer on the Frigate. Your Captain and the best Marine contingent you have just disembarked, leaving you and the other crew to just sit there waiting for her return. While you're standing there on the Bridge, looking out the viewport at the Library hoping, anticipating to see the Captain's Pelican return, you hear a slithering behind you.
How long do you have to be exposed to a room full of Flood Spores to be compromised? Arbiter was walking around in the complex with no mask or helmet for an hour or so, and was not infected. Surely it wasn't his armor's energy shields which protected him?
I'd just like to bring up how incompetent miranda Keyes was, she was not a good commander in fact far from it I'm guessing it's because she wasn't able to get the leadership training she needed and since the unsc were dealing with a missing gap in their fleet (aka Jacob keyes) they needed to fill in that rank and why not do it with his very own daughter who happens to be in the military herself, she left the amber clad completely defenseless considering she needed to use every available combat unit to secure the index which could turn the tide in humanity's favor, but she was a poor leader because of this I'm glad she died off due to her negligence, good riddance
Buuuuuut, I will say in halo 3, the story at least tried to make up for her poor leadership but all those amber clad deaths will forever be in Vien due to her actions, the sad part was she tried to redeem herself in halo 3 mostly by trying to rescue Johnson in the mission covenant but died in the process by a psycho perverted goat alien, she deserved a little bit more of a hero's death
Bulbasaur: your not mistaken lol I just really thought Miranda's death was super wrong and undeserved like at least make her die from a brute chieftain
ok what else could she have done in that situation, you have several Fleets of Covenant ships above the halo ring, plus the closer the ship is to your troops the faster it is for them to get supplies. Another thing how do we know it was defenseless, we never went into the ship during the library level so how do we know if the ship was attacked i mean we are talking about a near endless tide of space zombies numbers can overwhelm even the best of defenses, and plus she was a Navy Captain, she is trained for a completely different kind of warfare compared to marines, you don't send a Navy Admiral to do an Army General's job
@@Rammkommando well maybe they shouldn't have gotten a navy captain, earth alone right now has 8 billion people alive, thinks about all those military generals that were there I mean for God's sake its 2552 and all of the countries on earth are under a single banner all thise militaries that merged to make onsuper militarized organization/society that's fucking incredible, not to mention all of time and resources that were combined to from a perfect well balanced military structure with high class officer training centers and programs,and yes it was heat of the moment she just so happened to be near the prophets ship when it was in slip space but that doesn't excuse how incompetent she was with her troops, tell them to fall back at the very least, she asked cortona for any and all info on the delta halo ring which even means mast chief and cortana's encounters with the flood, which means she damn well knew how dangerous it was, not to mention how they can infect pelican pilots and those pelicans can be mistaken as friendly troops retreating from the battlefield, yes some of it wasnt her fault but when you ask for a shit ton of info on a previous ring from an Aithat experienced first hand contact with this space parasite and you damn well know what your getting into maybe she shouldn't be so fucking incompetent and risk all those innocent lives, I'm training for the military myself I'm second in command of a squad,you ALWAYS put men's lives above yours and the mission no matter what, because even having one soldier is enough to turn the tide not to mention humanity was near extinction and needs all the soldiers it can to do there part not sacrificeing themselves when they have an actual chance of pulling out of a dangerous situation, and the supplies oh boy. When you play as arbiter and you walk around during the flood containment breach there's is so much human supplies everywhere like there were just random military containers literally in every corner, which means what evere drip ship flew them down there was able to not only drop off troops but enough supplies to continue their mission, clearly it didnt work out well, also you can her some surviving marines begging for help and to pull out of the mission over comms, meaning that they weren't even properly debriefed, like wtf?Doesent matter what ranks those standard marines were if you have info on a dangerous life form or possible tango then you better well those troops what their getting into, which is why they were so easily wiped out and infected.
I did wonder that. When I first played Halo 2, I was kinda too young to really have a grasp on everything happening story-wise, so I never even grasped that the human ship crashing into High-Charity was the very same ship you rode in on. Even later, I was like... that's In Amber Clad? How the fuck!?
Halo: Whispers of Amber would be a cool title for a book or horror game. Detailing the last moments of In Amber Clad's crew fighting off the Flood aboard the ship over the Library. They manage to survive in the snowy mountains, being stalked by the parasite and a few Covenant stragglers left from the initial battle.
Hope y'all enjoy this lil mystery investigation! If you want to see any more videos like this give me suggestions! :D Also, don't forget to go follow me over on Instagram! --> goo.gl/6m5uYk
Are you still on amino
Nice video dude👍👍👍👍👍
Your the best! Please keep up the amazing work!
I've wanted this video for ages, THANK YOU
What was the crashed ship that appeared in the halo CE terminals?
And keep in mind this is the 2nd ship that someone in the keys family lost in the games
Never give a Keyes the key to a ship
HiddenXperia Give them the keys to a brand new Chevy truck instead.
@@HiddenXperia wonder what would happen if one was in charge of Infinity
Jedi Spartan oh Jesus Christ no
@@justsomeguywithprimusapoth5927 lol, they'd probably end up crashing bridge first into Requiem
They were infected because they didn’t wash their hands after going to the toilet.....Dun Dun Dun !
Omg what if a flood spore was in the water and a poor unsuspecting marine conveniently take a crap at the time got infected... anally.
RIP Jenkins #2018
lol
Every mom in a nutshell
What if an infected form snuck in through the bathroom
Well, no wonder the Gravemind was in the sewers of the Ring.
I heard it was due to teleportation:
1) Pelicans flying in have to coordinate with air traffic controllers. Any infected humans would not be able to coordinate, and something would have been clearly wrong, and permission to land denied.
2) Flood spores would take time to reproduce, and a properly-designed spaceship would be like a submarine- it can seal off areas to prevent the entire vessel from being destroyed. The spores would have to either bide their time to reach critical mass, or get extremely lucky and infect the bridge controls team.
3) The humans on the ground had already made contact with the flood, and their radio chatter wasn't scrambled. So the humans on board would have been watching out for flood-infected vessels
4) Low orbit is several miles above he ground. At that altitude, the air is too thin for humans to breathe, so the vents would be closed to avoid de-pressurization. It would take some while for anything that wasn't in a flying machine to float/fly up, and we already discussed how the infected pelicans would stand out to the flight controllers
5) The Gravemind teleported both the Chief and Arbiter
Makes sense
But do you think the Gravemind can teleport people high in the sky also ?
@@BobaFettCh1 He got the Master Chief into High Charity didn't he? High Charity was even higher up in orbit than In Amber Clad.
@@michaelmccabe3079 Right man, right.
You know at first I thought that idea would just be full of shit since the gravemind lol TPing all the flood everywhere seems like it'd be an unfair power to have but now it really does make sense. O_O
I guess it could just be a feasible ability he had due to having access to forerunner tech from delta halo since 343 could do it and even cortana learned how to at some point.
*_"I am a monument to all your sins."_* Halo 2/3 Gravemind, May 97,227 BC - December 2552 AD
Jedi Spartan BCE and CE are generally used in the Halo Universe now :)
@@ChocolateManOfficial look at the Halopedia page for different years, goes through every year where something happens
Halo 3 vs halo 5 my pick is halo 3 what is your pick
@@silverbloodborne9495 3 all day every day
@@silverbloodborne9495 obviously Halo 3, that question is basically (debatably) the best game vs the worst
"They've taken over the navy!"
"NOT THE NAVY!"
"The flood have taken over the world!!"
*Awkward silence*
"OUR WORLD!"
*Panic erupts*
"NOT THE NAAVY
YOU CAN'T SAIL THE SEVEN SEAS
NOT THE NAVY!"
Ever wonder why we're here?
It’s one of life’s greatest mysteries isn’t it?
I'm actually suprised you missed something in this. In the lore after the UNSC beat the Covenant on the Ark there was a new rule set in place to avoid this type of situation in the future. The rule was and i quote...
*"DON'T GO FULL MIRANDA KEYES"*
No, it was a set of rules:
1) don't park your Frigate directly above the Library or any other flood infected facility
2) don't hesitate to remove reclaimers about to be forced to activate life ending Forerunner weapons
3) give your troopers an actual rally point
These rules should be called the *Miranda Keyes rules*
@@fredrick1043 lol
Remember kids, never be a keyes! 1 way or the other, the flood trick them!
Let's just leave our frigate parked here with the Space Zombies, that seems like a smart idea.
It must have been a slaughter on the Amber clad
*slaughter in the in amber clad in orbit full of flood in marines in init
@@amused7928 goddamn tongue twister
Yuuuuuuup, a pretty one sided fight I'd imagine
If only they had Halo CE Shotguns...
TRUTH
2:50 That flying scorpion is hostile to the player and can fire its 90mm at you. I remember getting one shotted a few too many times on legendary by it.
there is actually a marine inside of it. Kill the driver and a marine pops out.
Now that is a heavy, mobile sniper!
I hope it's hostile your the Arby before the Alliance.
Makes sense
Anyone else wanna see the I C O N I C ODSTs return in Infinite? Honestly as long as Marines are commonplace I'm happy, but my helljumper bois need some love outside of Arcade Games.
Falcon Wargaming - Agreed
only if we get them popcorn boys back.
meep deep - Engineers boi
Totally agree. But I will say that the addition of Spartan 4s kinda diluted everything. The 2s and 3s were trained from kids and were pretty much one of kind. The 4s are like "anyone can be a Spartan."
I miss when Buck was an ODST
Angel Amaro - Same bro....The Spartan 4s made the Spartan title commonplace
I’ve always asked this question, and now I got it.
There is much talk, and I have listened...
Same
Spore theory valid, gravemind teleport theory valid, infested pelican theory valid. I'm partial to the pelican one myself. Keyes and crew were operating on Halo 1 intel, so could not know the effect a gravemind would have on the rest of the flood; keeping aircraft and In Amber Clad out of jumping distance was probably considered sufficient. Staying close minimizes travel time and maximizes firepower against the infestation, not to mention reduces the chance of being spotted and swatted by the covy fleet (before it got busy tearing itself appart in civil war). If a bird gets shot down, oh well write it off, not like they can fix it. Oh look, that one survived after all...
So now in Halo Infinite Lasky will leave the Infinity unguarded above the library on Zeta Halo. Plot confirmed
Hopefully not. Lmao i just imagined that Del Rio might have actually made the decision to run from the flood area. For once running away wasn't being a bitch.
Well…
Simple they didnt have shotguns
They did, just not Halo CE Shotguns
No they didn't have ce magnums
@@fredrick1043 CE magnums are more effective at mid to long range, CE Shotguns instantly fuck them up at close range in 1 to 2 shots with a 12 round mag and 60 rounds instead of 6 and 30 of later games *(god I miss the Halo CE Shotgun)*
It was just chipps dubbo wasnt there to save them.
Didn't have flamethrowers as well
I can’t imagine it was spores cos then Johnson and Keyes would have been infected too but as the pelican thing that makes sense
And possibly Arbiter, Rtas and Tartarus
Exactly! It can't be spores. It has to be an aerial vehicle hijacked by the Flood for IAC boarding action. Unless...
Oh dear God! What if someone got bitten?! The In Amber Clad and Miranda Keyes by extension were never mentioned to have history fighting against the Flood before. Plenty of ways to tell this.
So none of them woulda guessed that getting bitten by space zombies could lead to infection and conversion! What if a pelican "rescued" injured marine *'TROJAN HORSES!!!!"* :0
@@TheStuffEnjoyer cool idea
I think johnson is immune to the flood if I remember correctly
@KingDeath720 he's actually partially infected. the Orion augmentations essentially made the flood reject him as a host, but his DNA is still partially infected with the flood supercell
If we get a flood horror game it needs to be set during the later years of the Forerunner Flood War.
Jedi Spartan that would be awesome!
Bored Ninja Which mean we’ll never get that. Because 343 can’t do awesome, only mediocre. And Bungie decided they’re better off making money off of starting failure games, and then fixing them over the course of two or three years.
Yeah!!
@@crypto1223 We'll see what happens after Halo Infinite. They've had 3+ years to work on the game already. Hopefully they'll be able to rectify Halo for what it truly is, an amazing masterpiece. If not, then I'm finished with Halo.
Playable prometheans hmm?
"A single flood spore can wipe out an entire species..."
I had always assumed that it was infected due to the Gravemind’s ability to teleport. If it had the ability to teleport the Master Chief onto High Charity, then the Gravemind had the ability to teleport infected soldiers onto In Amber Clad.
Wow such a good theory
But gravemind specifically sent them to locations known by the profit of Regret and penitent tangent, his other captives in the cutscene. Perhaps he needs specific knowledge of some sort.
Though neither of our theories address why gravemind needed the In Amber Clad to infect high charity then.
@@shadowblood95 Or it could be possible that the teleportation doesn't work with the flood if the technology is Forerunner based.
@@alphabet2238 this would make waaay more sense, maybe even too much sense. one of the known flood containment protocols is setting teleporters into a local loop configuration, so we can assume that the flood is teleportable by forerunner tech and that teleporting someone who is infected does not screen the flood out as a cure. it would make even more sense if they just didn't allow flood teleportation at all, or if they had the scanning resolution to be able to pick out what's infected and what's not.
@@shadowblood95 It may be that the teleportation capacity is limited, we only see the Gravemind teleport two individuals to two separate spots, so in order to infiltrate High Charity with as large of an initial force as possible, an entire ship might have been a better insertion method.
Keys: park the ship above the library, what's the worst that can happen.
The Flood: *whispers* it's free real estate.
Third Theory: A pelican landed to drop off troops or supplies in the infected zone. Then a Infected Form or two crawled up too and attached to the bottom side of the pelican without anyone seeing it. The pelican then returned to the ship and the madness started.
But that’s my opinion of what could have happened.
Or the one and only theory that actually makes sense...
The Flood sent direct flood forms to the In Amber clad via the Halo rings teleportation grid. After all, when High Charity was compromised, at a certain part in the mission you begin to see HUGE tentacles form out of practically no where, giving the idea that the Gravemind teleported parts of his body to High Charity it-self when the infection started.
@@Nighterlev Except no flood forms are seen being teleported during gameplay. Only Arbiter and Chief are teleported. It wouldn't make sense for a forerunner teleportation network to be able to teleport the flood.
@@Nighterlev Unless the arbiter shutting down the sentinel wall shield allowed gravemind to utilize the teleportation network for the flood. Gravemind may also been helped by its precursor knowledge and the fact that High Charity is made from reverse-engineered Forerunner tech.
The classic "Aliens" manoeuvre
I don’t think two infection forms would be enough to infect the ship
This is what happeness when you leave your "keys" in the car
Gravemind cames to steal it. Ha
Good joke
Get out
There could be a sort of third theory where a pilot or a few marines was infected by flood spores and because of their slow infection nature went to In Amber Cald for treatment, but transformed in the medical bay or hangar which would sooner or later spread throughout the whole ship.
I could buy that
Granted I feel it was teleportation but that’s it
Yeah really, @@ItsButterBean1020. Though you would think the human medics would of quickly identified "Oh fuck! You're Infected!!" then promptly run out of the medical room then immediately have their ship's AI put the medical room on lockdown to await for the ship's few remaining guardsmen to come in and incinerate the medical room. The teleportation idea holds the most water in this. How would a few Infected Marines easily bring down the entire ship with what I described most likely being the new medical procedures involving the Flood.
i'm surprised the Hiddenxperia username wasnt taken on insta
Same actually, it was taken on PSN lol
@@HiddenXperia rip that sucks
@@HiddenXperia Imposter... That was heresy
Matt Pine II the council was,... overzealous. We know you are no heretic.
Why? You make it sound like he is a big deal
Another reason why I consider the flood one of if not the scariest things to be created by sci-fi.
I never noticed Amber Clad in orbit or the pelicans flying in tanks, and I LOVE this mission
I don't think it was stupid put the in amber clad on low orbit, humans have only one ship, against a covenant cruiser is dead, against a fleet and high charity, there is nothing they can do, no camouflage, no mines, no back up, nothing. They do the only play at their disposal, go where they wouldn't, to orbit. And use that frigate to suport their men on the quarantine zone. And after recover the index evacuate faster to the ship and jump to hyperspace to human space
Or the one and only theory that actually makes sense...
The Flood sent direct flood forms to the In Amber clad via the Halo rings teleportation grid. After all, when High Charity was compromised, at a certain part in the mission you begin to see HUGE tentacles form out of practically no where (suspecting this might be the Gravemind him-self judging from the talking alone), giving the idea that the Gravemind teleported parts of his body to High Charity it-self when the infection started.
In Amber Clad was just a distraction, along with trying to quickly stop the prophet of Truth from leaving.
I agree with both of these, seeing as the only UNSC local presence was the In Amber Clad, they are forced to hide most of their presence, thus taking risks, subsequently causing the loss of the frigate, her crew, and the coordinates to Earth (most probable source unless otherwise detailed by canon sources). Either the pelicans or the Gravemind's access to the teleportation could easily spread the Flood to the frigate. And if it only took a day for High Charity to fall, how much easier for just one small frigate right above the quarantine zone?
@@fleetadmiralchompa Tbh the reason why High Charity seemed to fall so fast is what I speculate, the Halo teleportation grid. The Gravemind was teleporting large parts of his over-all presence over to High Charity, and in doing so he probably lost access to Halo's teleportation grid.
So when the Elites started glassing the ring from Flood infection, he couldn't exactly teleport even more Flood forms to those ships in key area's. It could've also been because the Elites ships were out of range, because they mostly did it via plasma bombardment.
High Charity on the other hand was practically right next to it..so when the sentinel wall/shields were shut down, the Gravemind went all out and tried to infect as many places as possible to get off the Halo ring.
@@Nighterlev Not to mention that the Gravemind already had in its possession a prophet (San shayuum (spl?)). All of these factors contributed to the very efficient spread of the Flood!
Besides the fact that the b/c the Flood operates on an intelligible level, thus above purely epidemiological distributions, but also b/c they're coordinated, suggests an active and concerted effort to infect all living organisms on High Charity (this is the obvious conclusion 😅). I can't even begin to imagine what it must've been like trying to escape the increasingly desperate city; something akin to Deadspace, or worse!
I like this. If Keyes wants to not die to the Covenant fleet she has 2 options, hide on the outskirts of the system, behind a moon or something like that. That doesn't really leave any option to then do really anything on the ring.
The other is go into low orbit so close to halo the Covenant would not risk bombardment for damaging the ring. They could try to stop her by boarding but it's harder. To minimise this risk you want to be there as short a time as possible, so being very close to her mission of the index gives her the maximum chance to get the index and run before the Covenant can stop her.
Regarding the flood she may not have known the extent of the outbreak (she 100% could not anticipate infected pelicans) until she was already committed, after all the flood were way more contained on the first halo so why expect anything different. If she did know the risk then the library being an active combat and flood infected zone makes the Covenant putting a big fleet nearby way too risky for them.
Over the Library is the only place she can get any real safety form the Covenant and she isn't going to expect the flood infection to be as bad as it was. It's a gamble but it's basically her only option if she wants to do anything.
The Keyes's aren't very good at keeping their ships safe from Flood are they?
Humans dont seem to be good with ships in general
Still holds true with Infinite.
Imagine how terrifying the situation must've been on the ground for those marines. The dark atmosphere, flood screeching in the distance. Only for even of your heaviest equipment to fall to the flood.
Arbiter: "In order to get to the Sacred Icon, I had to deactivate the Containment Shield."
Master Chief: "That's a big fucking mistake right there. Next time we're at a Halo ring, that's not going to happen."
A mystery I’ve always wondered since Halo 2, a great way to finally find some closure.
Now that I think about it, Miranda's capture by the covenant actually saved her life! If she hadn't had that confrontation she would have boarded the ship only to find the crew was completely infected, neither she or Johnson would have stood a chance, regardless of Johnson's slight immunity to the flood.
When u click the video so fast it doesn't work yet. 😎
Wait what lol, is there an issue with YT?
@@HiddenXperia it's legit the same with Twitch
@@HiddenXperia not sure. It came up right after I reloaded tho so no worries.
I believe that because of the grave mind and the fact that they had infected UNSC that the pelican theory is the best
UNSC: *parks their ship over a flood area.* Flood: -its free real estate-
The mention of the section where Keyes and Johnson ride a gondola to the Index made me realize how much I'd love a game level or cutscene showing their point of view.
It was cut from the game
Would make an interesting series/mini game to see how the marines and crew members tried to fight off the flood and showing the events leading up to high charity
I love videos like this because I feel like this is the point of leaving things unknown to the player. The speculation of what might have happened helps make these games timeless! That’s something I really miss about halo
Wow, I actually thought about this very question just a few hours ago. Spooky.
Great content like always, I figure that the amber clad was most likely infected because it was left unguarded while floating above the library.
Heh, the In Amber Clad soundtrack at the beginning.
Nice touch
OMG FINALLY! THANK YOU FOR DOING THIS XD Its been driving me crazy.
5:52 oh yeah, just throw a grenade at a sentinel. That definitely wont be a waste of a grenade
Also, that isn't in orbit. It's just hovering there. The ISS is in orbit, falling around the planet at around 7 km/sec. If it was actually in orbit, it wouldn't be infected
Miranda did the Halo equivalent of parking your brand new car under a tree with lots of bird activity.
Maybe some flood spores got into a pelican, and then it docked
I have waited a long time for a video like this about the In Amber Clad!
Science class can wait, HiddenXperia has a new video!!
I will never get tired of your flood videos dude 😁😁
4:27
“However I concur”
Did you mean “I digress”?
Not gonna lie I thought he said that too.
this video felt like i sort of completed the story even further with halo 2. awesome work, halo 2 is my favorite forever!
3:19 the flood definitely had sufficient knowledge on how to fly a pelican...
Just not how to land one
I'm proud to support your channel.
14 years.... But at least we're all alive to find out why
man ive wondered for years on how the ship got infected THANK YOU
Im here papa
"Safe is better than close, Sergeant Major."
-Cortana, Halo 3
Keyes could have used that advice, it seems.
Good Video as usual
*flood knocks on door* "can we come in?" *Canadian door guard "I don't know I'm not supposed to...." *Flood* "we promise we'll be nice" "well ok then if you promise!" *Opens door*
My friend is Canadian and he agrees with this message
Most likely flood flew on board cus they were flying pelicans in the next mission
xXcashXx3 the pelicans would have been shot down
Actually, all pelicans in the level quarantine zone are piloted by humans and you can kill the scorpion marine being carried by one near the beginning of the mission.
The fact that so many marines were down on the ring, as evidence by the number of human combat forms, is a great clue as to how it was so easily captured. A frigate wouldn't have a huge complement of marines to begin with, and losing so many before the flood even breech the ship, however they do it, would be an instant death.
I always felt that the Flood's appearance in Halo 2 felt Shoehorned in, espcially coming from Halo CE.
Though Miranda was an infuriatingly incompetent leader
Her one-liner at the beginning of Halo 3 drives me ballistic. For those who might not remember, a marine at a comm station requests a rally point for the troops, asking where he should send them. Keyes just says, "To war."
I know it's just to look cool to the player, but I'd have much preferred if she gave some sort of contingency order or something. Like, c'mon, it's ridiculous
@Melissa Waterman Tbf, both her amd Johnson got that short end of the stick, with him getting captured and then killed by Guilty Spark. In the end, they served as "friendly NCO and Officer" for MC in Halo 2 and 3.
Thanks for making this video! I have until now, how the Inamberclad was infected. Keep up the great work!
LOVE IT
KEEP IT UP
I always had the theory that the frigate entering low orbit happened after a Medi-Vac of one of the ground teams (we see plenty of infected marines and dead marines down there) who had flood spores, turned then parked it in low orbit to make infection easier | and that partially infected spore marines started calling down pelican supplies and support to rapidly drain the defensive capability right before they began sieging the ship
Only one problem with the flood spore theory, if the atmosphere was so bad had did Keyes and Johnsan remain uninfected while retrieving the icon?
Well johnson was immune to the flood and keyes had plot armor
The flood can choose not to infect. Perhaps the Gravemind needed them alive.
Gravemind was so shortsighted for taking the in amber clad to high charity. He should have just booked it to the nearest populated planet and went from there.
They were not ICONIC Enough
And/or they didn't watch HiddenXperia's hundreds of Flood videos
Oh lord the puns I got give this ICONIC pun a like let me just go off my self
Yes another video been waiting. Love your vids
In amber clad: Hovers a couple hundred meters above the ground, well within the atmosphere.
HiddenXperia: *LOW ORBIT*
Isn't low orbit just a couple hundred metres above ground?
@@stylesrj I'll assume you're serious and give you a simplified answer.
Unless a planetary body is without an atmosphere, low orbit refers to any roughly circular orbit outside the atmosphere. For something like the Earth, that would be anywhere from roughly 100km to 2000km above the surface.
@@salameez
But what is Low Orbit technically on Halo?
An orbit is impossible in a giant ring. Outside, sure. Not inside.
@@salameez
Also, it could be low orbit over the Library. Not low-orbit over the ring. You can orbit stuff in-atmosphere
This video just popped up in my notifications. Its so good that YT safed it for me.
How did arby not get infectied
Plot armor friend plot armor :)
Shields
No. Then how did the non shielded Covenant forces and UNSC forces in that mission not get infected?
He ate too much Arby’s
*you're not supposed to ask these questions*
Now that I think about it. Captain Miranda Keys single handedly took down the galaxy's largest non Forerunner structure: High Charity. By mistake, lol. I mean I know it was the Flood but they couldn't have down it without her. :)
The flood were able to infect in amber clad because everyone on the ship was playing fortnite
Apart from one guy formally assigned to the Hellicarier, he was playing galaga
Jedi Spartan you mean pelican....
@@NotARangerBoy it's an MCU reference, in the first Avengers film Tony Stark/Iron Man spots someone playing galaga
Captain: Where we landin', Bois?
Navigator: Lazy Library!
Crewman: Aww man, but that's where all the flood like to land.
Captain: Lazy Library it is!
Marines: ...
Crewman: Is it just me, or are the Marines a bit too quiet.
Infected Marine: Raaaaagh!
Captain: Nope, definitely Marines being Marines.
*Loud thud*
Navigator: Hey, would someone get that?
Crewman: But what if the flood get me?
Captain: We'll cover you. Tell those Marines to pipe it down.
*Just before the gang can get the Unfrigginbelievable Victory Royale, the infected Marines swarm the room and infect them. On screen, the flood t-bags the dead players*
@@kyon8565 lol
There should be a special intro for these Flood videos.
While nothing's there, you just see Flood tentacles creeping out of the darkness with the Elite (now infected) slowly coming out until it jumps at the screen, making things go dark, then have the classic Gravemind laugh there, then BAM. Video starts.
my theory has always been a pelican, since the amber clad was so low, not really the spores, I believe the spores usually affect unsc or covenant will weak immune systems, basically through the fact many instances of flood vs covenant and human vs flood, there wee many instances were both groups were exposed to heavy amounts of spores yet they didn't turn but when the spores reach there ships non-combat personnel did, The evidence I place my theory with comes with the many survivors of all the outbreaks in game and some books, john, sgt Johnsen, many marines, arbiter, and surviving covenant that retreated away from high charity during its infection
I call the old design of the elites the squids, and the new ones the boulders
Could you please upload your Halloween livestream to youtube if you still have it, I live in the UK and was only able to watch the first 10 minutes, when I went to watch it in the morning after it was unavailable.
sadly, he said he won't because it messes with something about the youtube algorithm/views on future videos
or something along those lines
@@Vuadanee ok, thanks for letting me know why
Hearing flood lore or theories from you always give me the willies
Do a video on the frigate from Halo 3 sandstorm forge map
I honestly always wondered how the IAC became infected. Guess you answered my question then!
Great video dude! Keep it up!
How did high charity get to the Ark? Would love to see a video about this, it’s always been a plot hole in halo 3 that I wonder about.
The gravemind made a slipspace Portal near the planet of Mars
That "snow" you tend to see in flood areas is the flood spores. They appear in every halo game the flood do though they don't stand out much compared to the yellowish fog. In some cases such as outside in Halo 2 it is actual snow but you will still see the spores inside.
Hey hidden experia I have a legit question... how do the flood make proto gravemind, and gravemind. Do they mix the body's together?
The Lone One 0303 I’m pretty sure its Neural physics that the precursors used. Seeing how the flood came from precursor dust I think the abilities carry over to some degree
He made a video about it look for it i forgot the name
Im pretty sure the infected flood biomass all collects into one being, along with the consciousness of each individual infected
Yes man
Jai 006 Watch the Mona Lisa to see how they absorb biomass. And don’t count on eating squid ever again.
Man this concept would make such a good Halo horror novel.
I'm surprised we've not had it covered in a short story yet tbh
How did the gravemind get on in amber clad?
It didn't?
@@michaelcross7665 so what your saying is: the gravemind is still on instalation 05???
Jayden Abraham gravemind is on high charity and in a lot of places
@@glitzyx4x852 i found this post on halo waypoint: "It's quite obvious, actually. When In Amber Clad landed on Delta Halo/Installation 04 at the same time that the Arbiter was [also] sent to retrieve the Index, multiple UNSC (and Covenant) troops were killed in the process, giving Gravemind more access to biomass. The Flood took over the bodies - and hence, the memories of those bodies - and they then proceeded to invade and capture In Amber Clad (in case you're wondering, Sgt. Johnson and Miranda Keyes were captured by Tartarus).Gravemind then had himself disassembled piece by piece to In Amber Clad, which later crashed into High Charity along with the friendly Flood infection asking for a cup of sugar. The Flood infection spread throughout High Charity and Gravemind had himself reassembled there. High Charity eventually crashed into the surface of the Ark where Gravemind slowly increased his biomass from the countless bodies from the War.Thusly, the Gravemind we all know and love from Halo 2 is the same Gravemind that we all know and hate [because of the constant mind interruptions] from Halo 3. And no, the proto-Gravemind from Halo: CE is not the same. the Proto-Gravemind was destroyed along with the rest of Alpha Halo/Installation 03. Plus, the Gravemind I'm talking about was far too old to have been the Proto-Gravemind."
Jayden Abraham ok but keep in mind high charity was already under flood control during quarantine it’s just the flood used the ship to increase the spreading then set up a grave mind
you are the best halo lore channel. period.
I really doubt spores had anything to do with this. Keys had Cortana access all the intel Chief had gathered on 04 and I would hope that included intel on the flood (if not, no reason for Cortana or Chief to not warn them). If the UNSC Navy operates anything like a real life Navy, standard operating procedure while in combat would have the ship set to condition Zebra (basically making the ship airtight and isolating compartments from each other to stop the spread of fire and flooding (pun intended). This would make the ship airtight and force a switch over to air recycling thus prevent spores from entering. As for the pelican theory Im sure at least 1 Marine or a flying pelican had to have radioed in saying "Hey guys they can use our shit! look out!" As a result of that the ships CIC would have been monitoring for pelicans to be squawking IFF and keeping track of downed birds in flood controlled areas and even possibly have orders to shoot down or at the least deny landing clearance to non responsive pelicans. This is all crap that a basic combative ship would have done in this situation in real life.
In order for a spore to have entered they would have had to ignore the most basic shipboard survival procedures which I highly doubt they would have being that they are a highly advanced space based Naval force that chronologically follows our basic real life time line and therefore lessons learned in naval combat.
In order for a pelican to get on board the ship would have had to 1) granted landing clearance to a non responsive pelican or at the very least maybe one that still had a working IFF signature but no comms (most likely but very stupid of the crew) or 2) have missed a commandeered pelican with all their point defenses and then said pelican crashed into and breaching the hull of the ship (highly unlikely).
My theory is that the In Amber Clad became infected from either a sheer lack of common sense and training resulting from budget cuts, or because the flood has plot armor
A pelican crashed into the In Amber Clad isn't that far fetched, it's "only" a frigate, also it was probably understaffed so either comms/tracking/weapon systems is bound to get understaffed as well. Misscommandeering in such a situation is also not unfeasible, I mean at Cairo station Harper wants to engage the Covenant Battleships head-on. xD But yeah I imagine they would be recirculating air at the very least.
Or the one and only theory that actually makes sense...
The Flood sent direct flood forms to the In Amber clad via the Halo rings teleportation grid. After all, when High Charity was compromised, at a certain part in the mission you begin to see HUGE tentacles form out of practically no where (suspecting this might be the Gravemind him-self judging from the talking alone), giving the idea that the Gravemind teleported parts of his body to High Charity it-self when the infection started.
In Amber Clad was just a distraction, along with trying to quickly stop the prophet of Truth from leaving.
@@Nighterlev That is a VERY good point.
The Real Jeff I concur with the plot armor theory. Had a UNSC commander really paid attention to the intel, she would have stayed far away from the quarantine zone. Also I think when she mentioned the index, chief should have chimed in like, “hey going into the library is a terrible idea. Believe me I’ve been there...” in Halo 1 Cortana was very concerned with the flood. Halo 2, she forgot to mention the gravity of the parasite to her commanding officer, and so did the chief.
As someone pointed out elsewhere. The Gravemind had access to the telepot system (It teleports the chief and Arbiter later). All it had to do was infect one person that knew the location and layout of the ship.
Then teleport an overwhelming force aboard. Job done. And naff all that Keyes or anyone else did could have stopped it
You're a Bridge Officer on the Frigate. Your Captain and the best Marine contingent you have just disembarked, leaving you and the other crew to just sit there waiting for her return. While you're standing there on the Bridge, looking out the viewport at the Library hoping, anticipating to see the Captain's Pelican return, you hear a slithering behind you.
How long do you have to be exposed to a room full of Flood Spores to be compromised? Arbiter was walking around in the complex with no mask or helmet for an hour or so, and was not infected. Surely it wasn't his armor's energy shields which protected him?
Arbiters energy shield may actually be what protected him from the spores.
Arbiter had a much older shield than the rest of the covenant it could be that.
I do not believe energy shields would be sufficient, you would need your own atmosphere. Must be proof those areas weren't filled with spores
There is something about a frigate in a night sky with snow falling, Just so beautiful.
4:26 i think u mean "I digress" not concur.
HiddenX says"floody hell" instead of "bloody hell". Guaranteed
I'd just like to bring up how incompetent miranda Keyes was, she was not a good commander in fact far from it I'm guessing it's because she wasn't able to get the leadership training she needed and since the unsc were dealing with a missing gap in their fleet (aka Jacob keyes) they needed to fill in that rank and why not do it with his very own daughter who happens to be in the military herself, she left the amber clad completely defenseless considering she needed to use every available combat unit to secure the index which could turn the tide in humanity's favor, but she was a poor leader because of this I'm glad she died off due to her negligence, good riddance
Buuuuuut, I will say in halo 3, the story at least tried to make up for her poor leadership but all those amber clad deaths will forever be in Vien due to her actions, the sad part was she tried to redeem herself in halo 3 mostly by trying to rescue Johnson in the mission covenant but died in the process by a psycho perverted goat alien, she deserved a little bit more of a hero's death
@@Tsar_Appologist gotta watch out for dem religious goat aliens...
They might kill you out of SPIKE (i'm sorry too soon ?) lol.
Bulbasaur: your not mistaken lol I just really thought Miranda's death was super wrong and undeserved like at least make her die from a brute chieftain
ok what else could she have done in that situation, you have several Fleets of Covenant ships above the halo ring, plus the closer the ship is to your troops the faster it is for them to get supplies. Another thing how do we know it was defenseless, we never went into the ship during the library level so how do we know if the ship was attacked i mean we are talking about a near endless tide of space zombies numbers can overwhelm even the best of defenses, and plus she was a Navy Captain, she is trained for a completely different kind of warfare compared to marines, you don't send a Navy Admiral to do an Army General's job
@@Rammkommando well maybe they shouldn't have gotten a navy captain, earth alone right now has 8 billion people alive, thinks about all those military generals that were there I mean for God's sake its 2552 and all of the countries on earth are under a single banner all thise militaries that merged to make onsuper militarized organization/society that's fucking incredible, not to mention all of time and resources that were combined to from a perfect well balanced military structure with high class officer training centers and programs,and yes it was heat of the moment she just so happened to be near the prophets ship when it was in slip space but that doesn't excuse how incompetent she was with her troops, tell them to fall back at the very least, she asked cortona for any and all info on the delta halo ring which even means mast chief and cortana's encounters with the flood, which means she damn well knew how dangerous it was, not to mention how they can infect pelican pilots and those pelicans can be mistaken as friendly troops retreating from the battlefield, yes some of it wasnt her fault but when you ask for a shit ton of info on a previous ring from an Aithat experienced first hand contact with this space parasite and you damn well know what your getting into maybe she shouldn't be so fucking incompetent and risk all those innocent lives, I'm training for the military myself I'm second in command of a squad,you ALWAYS put men's lives above yours and the mission no matter what, because even having one soldier is enough to turn the tide not to mention humanity was near extinction and needs all the soldiers it can to do there part not sacrificeing themselves when they have an actual chance of pulling out of a dangerous situation, and the supplies oh boy. When you play as arbiter and you walk around during the flood containment breach there's is so much human supplies everywhere like there were just random military containers literally in every corner, which means what evere drip ship flew them down there was able to not only drop off troops but enough supplies to continue their mission, clearly it didnt work out well, also you can her some surviving marines begging for help and to pull out of the mission over comms, meaning that they weren't even properly debriefed, like wtf?Doesent matter what ranks those standard marines were if you have info on a dangerous life form or possible tango then you better well those troops what their getting into, which is why they were so easily wiped out and infected.
I did wonder that. When I first played Halo 2, I was kinda too young to really have a grasp on everything happening story-wise, so I never even grasped that the human ship crashing into High-Charity was the very same ship you rode in on. Even later, I was like... that's In Amber Clad? How the fuck!?
I was just thinking of this yesterday!! Weird that this would pop up in my suggestions lmao
You have helped me understand a lot about the halo games thanks hidden Xperia😎😎😎😎
Love your vids I think you are in my top 5 best halo lore channels in youtube.
My god it's the iconic parasite, after 1000s of years it has finally returned.
Brand new subscriber. loving the work and effort you've been putting into these videos keep up the good work man!
Yes thank you! I was wondering about it for a while now!
Halo: Whispers of Amber would be a cool title for a book or horror game. Detailing the last moments of In Amber Clad's crew fighting off the Flood aboard the ship over the Library. They manage to survive in the snowy mountains, being stalked by the parasite and a few Covenant stragglers left from the initial battle.
If ever someone was able to make the Halo games into live-action films, this would be a very important scene to add.