🇦🇺 Australia: “West Papua needs to be free, just like how I made Timor-Leste 🇹🇱 oil and gas free for me to take!” "Timor-Leste loses $1 million a day due to Australia's unlawful exploitation of resources in the disputed area. Timor-Leste cannot be deprived of its rights or territory because of a crime." *-First Prime Minister of Timor-Leste, Mari Alkatiri*
Every time some third worlder gets mad at us for pointing out their human rights abuses they start whining "no u!!" because they can't actually defend themselves. lol
The West Papua situation is actually much more complicated. Firstly, west papua already have autonomy, in which only west papuan can became governor. The west papuan also split between pro Indonesia and pro independence, where pro indonesian is predominantly around coastal area, and pro independence is around mountainious area. I myself live in Merauke, which is quite isolated to the rest of papua and having much more economical ties with Surabaya than the rest of Papua. This makes Merauke very pro Indonesia compared to the other Papuan city. The papuan independence movement itself quite fractured. ULMWP is the most recognizable internationally, but they have no actual power in west Papua. West Papuan are much more supportive of OPM, which is a separatist militia that still operates to this day, but OPM have become very fractured as of late. There are other separatist movement, but they have become very irrelevant. In short, while ULMWP got the most support internationally, OPM got the most support locally. Furthermore, Indonesia just recently split Papua Province of Indonesia into four province. On one hand, this have become the cry of papuan people since a long time. Papua province is too big to govern with so little population, thus making it hard to developed. In addition many seen Jayapura as very corrupt and also want the Civil servant quota, in which they have to compete with other papuan ethnicity. On the other hand, this is a ploy by Indonesian goverment to weaken the Independence movement. This could be seen in the Papua Tengah Province, where the Central Government pick Nabire instead of Timika even thought Timika is the proposed capital since a long time. I belive this is because the situation in Timika got the worst during 2019 West Papua unrest.
😂😂😂 You want West Papua to be separated from Indonesia, after that you will exploit its natural wealth. then left it like Timor Leste, Iraq, Afghanistan
It's actually Indonesia gave them authority to became Autonomous region but the things are the government from themselves are always being corrupt so made it like that
How would you know that? there was no government for these people similar to how there's no effective representative of aboriginal Australian in their own land
I think ethnicity is not the main problem. In maluku or flobamora, theres so many people with simmiliar looks. And also some people in buton and celebes too. The javanese also have many dark skinned people that have the negrito/australoid anchestor gene
INDONESIA IS NOT A RACE BUT A NATIONALITY WITH MORE THAN 1.300 ETHNICITIES AND RACES LIKE CHINESE,JAVANESE, MELANESIANS AND DAYAKNESE FOR EXAMPLE WTFF,WE HAVE A SLOGAN CALLED "UNITY IN DIVERSITY"THAT MEANS NO MATTER WHAT'S UR RELIGION,SKIN COLORS OR RACES YOU'RE STILL INDONESIAN🇮🇩
Yes, "Indonesian" is indeed a nationality. The problem is that the country's current socio-political situation does not benefit the indigenous Papuans' integrity. They are disadvantaged compared to their brown neighbors and their cultures and languages, just like with the rest of the country, are threatened by the one national identity policy. If the Papuans want to create their own government that satisfies their own interests and self-determination as a people, then they rightfully deserve that. I mean Indonesia, Malaysia, and the Philippines’ national identities are all based on colonial territories, not cultural divisions. And so, insisting that Indonesia should remain as it is given its treatment of its minority cultures is shallow and inconsiderate. So before anyone insists that West Papua should stay under Indonesian governance, first address if their rights as the rightful peoples of their land and society are met.
@@rvat2003 Wdym so before anyone insist african american should stay under USA first address their right as the rightful people of their land and society are met? You do know Papuan actually have more right than other islanders because they got special autonomy privilege right?
Bro, West Papua join Indonesia was such a big deal for future, but because cold war, USSR want Indonesia to be Comunist, and US doesnt want it, instead US, Secretly make Indonesia strugle, and broke apart
West Papua: *[Finally Free]* Constant Corrupt Government, Economic Recession, Civil Wars between Pro-Indonesia and Pro-West Papua, Inflation, and any Governmental obstacles that I doubt they’ll handle it: Hello there 😁
Betcha 1lbs of gold from Freeport that there'll be foreign "peacekeeping" forces suddenly appearing there. If that happens I sure hope to hell that China will also be there, so I can enjoy the surprise Pikachu face of the US and Australia. Come to think of it, I hope Timor Leste would accept Chinese money for infrastructure deal, so China can open a naval base there. I mean why would Australia object to a military base of their biggest trading partner there.
Lol you all new Zealand and Australian just want lands, since long ago the Papuans already made a party to gain independent from the Dutch. And also many people in papua now suffering because of the rebels, oh yea don't forget yall Australian massacred the Native Australian population😂😂
Bhinneka tunggal ika, kita memang berbeda tetapi tetap satu. Negara lain bnyk yg menghasut tp jangan tertipu mereka sbenrnya punya kepentingan masing2.
I do not know which one i have to support, Indonesia support my homeland against malaysia, australia help us during the Japanese occupation, And West papua also has similar goal to has about being Freedom, These three are rival to each other (not australian against papua) but they supporting my homeland, Guess im just chilling being neutral then
This is kind a old trick that australia does. They want to take natural resourses from indonesia which located in papua. They support separatis people in papua to seperate from indonesia. And after that they can take natural resourse as much as possible. Just what they did to east timor... And fyi... There are so many people in papua that dont want a seperate from indonesia.. just come there..
they did it before. At first they supported Indonesia to anex Timor Leste due to communist Fretilin. Since they knew about oil in Timor Sea, they opposed Indonesia.
And these Indonesians dare to criticize Israel with the Palestine issue but look at them what they did in East Timor and still do today in West Papua. But since Muslim Brotherhood is "good" everything else bad.
They can still criticize Israel even if they're not perfect. If we stopped calling out issues just because we also have our own, then nothing can be resolved. They can definitely improve in regard to West Papua without tolerating Israel's crimes.
@@rvat2003 But it's hypocrite from them to support Hamas and Palestine Independence but they shut down the same to West Papuans seeking independence since 1960s also calling them terrorists but again since to them. Muslim = Good Non Muslim = Bad.
@@RevoIke Did you know that the island of New Guinea partly belongs to the sultanate of Tidore. 😊 And the sultanate of tidore could not be conquered by the Dutch
lol. Your slander is more cruel than the country of Papua New Guinea. Indonesia has always been afraid of Papuans because they are strong and firm. because of that, most of them became debt collectors in Jakarta, especially Javanese people 😂😂
@@dugalaksit5570 Yeah well the Bismarck Archipelagos isn't part of the Province of West Papua, or Indonesia, it's part of Papua New Guinea, and well you know it!! It's people like you, who come out of the wood work in the comment section and try to misinform "dumb Westerns," and believe me, most Westerners aren't just dumb, they're FUCKIN' DUMB, when it comes to anything related to this part of the World. Get Yank, to point out on a map, where he thinks Jayapura is on a map map. I'll bet you 9 1/2 out of 10 would have to talk to "uncle Google" first, even when it comes to the question "well, which hemisphere is it in?" Again, the answer will be crickets!!
@@liambmn Common Liam, we gotta do better than that, mate. We gotta help these people gain a reasonably coherent, confident and above all, UNIFIED Political Voice of their people, from their people instead of yet, another (however well meaning) churning out yet "another impassioned plea for justice" to a by and large, empty. If you're the guy that's gonna give the monologue, and do the soundbites, you've lost me already, understand. But what I really do hope, is that you realise why it is that I say all this. It's like that old proverb "give a Man a fish, you've fed him for a day, but teach a Man to fish, and you'll feed him for a lifetime." I hope I haven't come off too "preachy", and that you "get" my message, if you think I have one. Thanks.
Have you ever realized how large Indonesia is? Sabang to Merauke has length of 5.250 km. It's the same distance from Lisboa, Portugal to Tehran, Iran. that's huge distance. Imagine a European country that spans from Portugal to Iran. It's kind of amazing that Indonesia is still a single country.
@@kaptenhiu5623 Yes. The Indonesian was another of islands behaviour with utilizing of railway and road tunnelling of undersea area was realized of constructions
@@andravideostation6101just leave thoose westerner in here regions of papua they dont care about we rule papua as long as they live properly then they accept it
This is the part where I don't understand as to why some 🇦🇺media and the so-called activists are compelled to behave like the "pacific protector" by sticking their noses into their immediate friendly neighbour and creating a spark of separatism. Or is it bc they're all deceived by pro-seperatist/terorist "activist" Veronica Koman who studied in 🇦🇺 with 🇮🇩 taxprayer' money & now working for Amnesty intl in 🇦🇺 spreading one-sided false narratives & lies about condition in West Papua. On the other hand, 🇮🇩 never brings up the systematic massacres of aboriginal people in 🇦🇺 or even bother about 🇦🇺's internal matter. The legal status of West Papua is crystal clear and in accordance with the intl system/norm. Just like all other 🇮🇩 territories and every postcolonial countries (🇮🇳🇵🇰🇲🇾🇵🇬🇺🇲🇵🇭🇰🇷 🇳🇬 so on). You should know better about Uti Posidetis Juris, the Treaty of the Hague and the New York Agreement. It's a done deal. Uti Posidetis Juris alone supersede self-determination / referendum, even so, it has been done (once and for all) when declaring independence from the 🇳🇱 colonisation, plus additional self-determination for West Papua in 1969 and was adopted by the UN.. If you guys care so much about self-determination maybe let's begin with holding a referendum in 🇦🇺 for aboriginal people and see if the indigenous aborigines really want to be ruled by white people. 😀 Note: One may wonder, how about TL🇹🇱? Simple. It's a different case. I must admit 🇹🇱 was annexed illegally (even though 🇦🇺 & 🇺🇲 supported 🇮🇩) but because 🇹🇱 was never colonized by or part of the 🇳🇱 territory in NEI, thus Uti posidetis juris isn't applicable (legally flawed). That's why the UN never recognised it which leads to a referendum or self-determination. But not in any other 🇮🇩 territory.
@@dukedukeson2158 Sure let's talk about human rights issues and how to improve development in West Papua instead of supporting separatism. When I say human rights issues, I mean including the separatists who killed both TNI and civilians.
@@riezan agree,central government should increase infrastructure and education in West Papua,when it's done,there is no longer separatism movement,like GAM back then
@@gp2779 But the difference is that Papuans live in Papua. And Jews live in Israel, there are no Arabs there, only in the Palestinian authority and then they are forced out of there, you will not meet an Arab in Tel Aviv.
If Papua does gain independence, it would lead to a civil war, Indonesia is madeout of hundreds of different ethnic groups. Our country is Diverse and always has been. So giving them independence, would spark independence movements all over Indonesia and eventually our country would cease to exist
@@OnionIlan but if your country is too unstable, it should be your own concern to make your country stable, not the Papuans, if they don't even wanna be part of your state.
It would be stupid if some people from several European countries provoked Papua to separate from the Republic of Indonesia. It's very funny that the international consensus has been decided in various stages under the UN, now it wants to be debated again. If a country has been formed for less than 100 years, of course there are still a certain percentage of parties who disagree with forming it into a country, but that percentage can be seen from the total number of existing residents. If it is much smaller, it means they are classified as rebels in that country. And rebels in one country can't fund themselves unless there is financial assistance from other countries as sponsors, and this can be sued internationally. So what happens to every country in the world if there are a handful of people who shout "INDEPENDENT" to break free and separate themselves from a legitimate country, then they have to be served by a referendum by the UN again? If that's the case, more than 200 sovereign countries in the world will be able to become thousands of countries in the near future, then all countries will be shaken politically and the world economic crisis will keep on hitting, and so and so it keeps repeating itself.
Bro forget to mention that Indonesian native Malays are also closer to Malaysia and Brunei than to Javanese. Also West Timorese are also closer to East Timor than to Javanese. You want us to be divided just like old times, we're not into it. We're not the one who invented Apartheid, we're living with Melanesians hundreds thousands of times until you arrived and enslaved all of us.
Pre-colonial Indonesia was even worse. Just look at the treatment with how many Austroasiatic tribes on Java committed on a widespread scale as far as Austronesian tribes. I'd tell you you're living a life of hatred. Kingdoms rise and fall. The longer it takes you to accept the fact that Indonesia is a complex, divided nation full of Islamofascist tribalism, the longer it'll take for you to realise that Apartheid is something learnt that the archipelago wants because of how distraught each island is.
Nice video, but I have one correction, Jayapura was the original capital of West Papua before it became part of Indonesia in 1963. In 2001, the province of West Papua was split, the eastern half with the capital still Jayapura, and the western half having its capital as Manokwari. The distance between Jayapura and Jakarta is the same as that of Anchorage and Los Angeles
geez you guys really want to impose one country one ethnic ideology to a country like Indonesia huh. if that's the case then why don't you also say "riau people should reunite with their borthers and sisters in Malaysia" just because they're not javanese like why? you guys always say the same narrative that doesn't depicts what actually happens
as an indonesian myself, i support the indepence of papua, yet i dont support the west papua national liberation army, not only because they bring lots of crimes with their agenda, but because the most support come to them mostly from white countries, just saying but i know more about the situation.
@@gp2779 I also support the independence of the Uighurs from the brutal regime of China. Dude, if we free them, it doesn't mean you're going to colonize them tomorrow.
No… The Netherlands did not just give up Papua to them, they argued that because they were ethnically different it should remain a colony & it was a self governing colony until the 1960s when Indonesia made multiple attempts to try & invade leading to the Dutch making a deal where the Dutch leave & grant it to Indonesia so long as the have a vote on it, however they were tricked/forced into voting against independence. Now it’s illegal to raise the old colonial era flag as they see it as a symbol of defiance
I'm living in Central java atm, and yeah, Papuan people are different from the typical Javanese majority that dominates Indonesia's demographics. Even in the most progressive of cities, Papuans aren't exactly as accepted like Sumatrans or Balinese
@@liambmn honestly, yeah myself also not care if Papua wanted to separate from us or not. But again, the concern is, can they do things on their own? How sure that you think they could thrive alone without our help? I highly doubt they could even survive in most aspect after seperated from us. If you support an extreme povertishm, then sure.. Just whatever you wanted to say man. Ok
Yes, and it's due to horrible Asian and European colonizers! South Korea burns the West Papuan forests! The real Indonesians feel emotional bound with West Papuans!
New Dutch?You saw that during the Dutch colonialism in Indonesia, they pitted races against each other in Indonesia when all the provinces were still kingdoms, they drained natural resources and forced labor.Take a look at Papua now, President Jokowi is trying to level development but the OPM or the independent Papuan organization continues to carry out terror by attacking civilians, attacking small army posts And hospitals are among the construction workers sent to level development in Papua
@nono-ri9bt Who taught you? I have lived in Indonesia since I was a child and I have been to Papua and almost died because of the actions of Papuan rebels
@nono-ri9bt We Indonesians have been colonized by the Dutch for around 300 years, our heroes were exiled, the people were starving and oppressed, not to mention the addition of 5 countries.
Jan tertipu liat aja timor leste di jadikan sapi perah australia begitu mereka merdeka, hal yg sama akan terjadi jika papua lepas maka jangan harap bisa merdeka kalian akan dimakan propaganda negara2 barat yg mau SDA kalian😅 Mereka menganggungkan kata kebebasan tp sbenernya cmn pen Sumber daya kalian contohnya coba liat IRAK, Afganistan syriah dan daerah timur tengah lainnya. Kedoknya mau membebaskan rakyat/teroris tp sbenernya itu cmn alasan saja spaya bisa masuk dan ngincer minyak negara2 lain. Hal sperti ini terjadi di era modern.
Kalo di pertahankan, Bisa jadi Duri dalam Daging. Kalo Dilepas Terlalu Sayang..........😞🇨🇺 Kalo menurut Prediksi gw, Papua Pastinya Bisa Merdeka Cepet Lambat. Kita sebagai warga harus siap² Menanggung Resiko jika kelak hari itu terjadi!
@@byyrka8710 west Papua become a independent country is only dream. We don't need to be new country. We need to live with peace in Indonesia without bastard rebel opm.
This is what I hate about Australia. They tried to flip the narrative so bad. And not to mention some Philippines siding with them just because Indonesia is a Muslim majority. First off there's only 500k people living in papua of which only a few hundreds wanted Independence and even fewer separatists grups, they are on the mountains in middle parts of mountainous region in papua. These separatists groups don't even trust each others and sometimes fight. They took people as hostages, burn down schools and hospital and ambush Indonesian police. Australia is beginning to look more like the Russians and we're Ukraine. They act like we tried to demolish the ethnic people in papua, but it's actually the opposite. The history of how Indonesia got Papua is sketchy yes, but times have changed president changed and policy changed.
@@Nagin-zt6sc what are you talking about, PNG is literally less safe than West Papua. There's gangs and tribe wars and the Australian Government are doing jackshit about it.
@@Nagin-zt6sc ua-cam.com/video/JWZBc44qB1I/v-deo.htmlsi=LT7UEGLMJP6piUqh Have a look yourself. While tribal wars in PNG happens, tribal wars in West Papua are always broken up by Indonesian Police. Nobody in their right mind would give Independence to Papua because a few grups consisting of a few hundred men wanted so. They don't even trust each other, recently the leader Joni Botak was killed by other Free Papua movement grups. You think non Papuans are governing West Papua? You'd be wrong cause most of them that are governing Provinces in Papua are Indigenous Papuans (unlike Australia), and even The Police there almost all are Papuans.
@@Nagin-zt6sc also there's no genocide now. But In the past there is. Suharto's dictatorship cracked down on a lot of groups, The Muslims in Aceh, the Fretelin communist in Timor Leste, The Ethnic Chinese and the Free Papua movement in Papua before Suharto's was forcefully stepped down as President.
@@theselectivecentrist8146 and the Australians didn't do the same thing in timor leste? Sucking their oil like there's no tomorrow?, and who barks if not the western countries and IMF when Indonesia bans its raw rare minerals for export. Protest? You mean the ones in batam? That's because the relocation plan there is not thought out yet, and people in Batam doesn't want foreign investors on their land even though it'll boost the economy. Also unlike other places batam has the luxury to not needing to pay taxes.
Sejarah Republik Indonesia adalah koloni Hindia Belanda..., Papua adalah koloni Belanda dan papua new guinea adalah koloni Inggris.., selesai NKRI harga mati.
But.. Independ3nt West Papua could end like PNG.. with tribes violence and slow economic growth, and the ruling Gov.. could not handle the situation,and pleading for foreign aid..
@@cryostatis3018 Discriminated? Maybe by some close-minded individual, but I dare to say that Papuans have slightly more rights to enjoy than other ethnic groups. The Papuan provinces only allow indigenous Papuans to be elected into governmental and other critical positions. Is that oppression to you?
@@黒田たかし-n5f None of what you said is okay helloo? Shouldn't everyone have the same rights?? From what I've seen Papuans are treated like cattle and if that's better treatment than most ethnicities then I don't wanna know what Indonesia does to them.
@@cryostatis3018 Let me put it words simple enough for that slimy pink thing inside your skull to understand. Some provinces of Indonesia are granted special privileges by the central government to govern themselves in ways that are not always in accordance with the constitution. For instance, the province of Aceh is allowed to implement Sharia laws as part of the 2005 peace agreement, despite Indonesia being a secular nation. Similarly, the province of Yogyakarta maintains a hereditary ruling system instead of the typical elections held in other regions, in recognition of its significant contribution during the war for independence. As for the Papuan provinces, these privileges take form of the implementation of various affirmative action policies. They aim to address social and economical disparities and improve the welfare of the local Papuans. These policies may not be perfectly implemented, but they represent our government's commitment to acknowledge and address the historical challenges faced by the Papuans. Stop thinking that Suharto is alive and well and still ruling over us with his iron fist. The Papuans bled in the past, but so did other ethnic groups. If you still think that separatism and balkanization are the solutions to many problems faced by minorities around the world today, maybe you can start by supporting your own local separatists?
West Papua is the territory of the Netherlands New Guinea which was included in the territory of the Dutch kingdom and was not a colony of the Dutch East Indies but Indonesia forced us Papuans to enter Indonesia until the day we were still colonized please tell the world media that we want independence, we Papuans don't want to live with the Indonesian state
Both are 'Dutch' so i don't see why Papua should be independent from Indonesia as both 'Dutch' is literally the same thing. Both headed by the same King/Queen
ya karna papua adalah indonesia dan juga australia ingin merebut papua dari indonesia dengan segala cara jangan harap, bagaimana dengan timor leste setelah di ambil dari indonesia, australia tidak bisa membuat makmur rakyatnya hanya ingin sumber Alamnya saja, dan rakyatnya miskin, kami akan mempertahankan papua sampai kapan pun, sekali pun nyawa taruhanya, NKRI HARGA MATI, KOMUNIS STOP CAMPUR TANGAN DENGAN PAPUA, PAPUA IN INDONESIA
How many Indonesians are going to deny that West Papuans don't want to be a part of Indonesia. This has nothing to do with anything else. "What about Australia waa waa waa" The difference is we aren't actively bombing Aboriginals so they don't want independence.
Are you sure? There is a lot of Papua People doesn't like The Papua Merdeka Movement. The Government can easily let them free like Timor Leste but it will make the Western come more Frequently to Western Papua and Taking their Gold, Oil, etc. To prevent Western Destroying Papua, Indonesia will protect it because *IN THE PAST* Papua People wanted to Be Integrated with Indonesia.
Actualy we papuan hate indo governemt, because lack of jobs, hospitals, internet is so expensive . Rice is expensive We raise star banner is so we re getting the attention, independece? Its more like a slogan of (treat us better, like other province).. we have HUGE I MEAN IT HUGE Hatred toward armed rebels .. those bstrd rape and killed my relative (Rest in peace) just because she was a teacher
Why??? because of the racial differences? As fellow Malay Race,, I demand the Philippines should be one of Indonesian provinces... If you're saying the Philippines never been a Dutch colony,, then West Papua has the answer to be an integral part of Indonesia. But,, most importantly... West Papuans (together with other delegation from other regions) were sending their delegates to the Indonesian Youth Pledge back in 1928 to declare themselves as one nation... Thought? 😎😎
colonized by the Dutch Portuguese for more than 3 centuries. We unite to expel invaders from our land. No matter race/religion, we are united. now see what they want? divide our nation. history is never lost.
Indonesia Papua people enjoy a much more robust economy than PNG,higher gdp percapita,higher HDI,improved infrastructure iniciatives, AUSTRALIA CHOOSE TO LEAVE PNG ALONE,WHICH IS QUITE SAD
Dasar orng pengadudoba,sadar la masarakat papua,apakah benar kalian akanenikmati kekayaan kalaian,pasti kalau kalian lepas dri indonesia,orng luar yg akan mengeruk kekayaan alam kalaian,itu yg harus kalian yakini
I don't know where westerners know history from, since the 1920s the Dutch established concentration camps in Boven Digoel Papua, many Indonesian political figures were imprisoned there, it was then that brought the spirit of independence and the initiative of the indigenous Papuan youth to merge into a country called Indonesia, the propaganda of West Papua existed when the Dutch suddenly unilaterally came to Papua and promised independence, to local pro-Dutch officials, in exchange for which they would get a special place under Dutch administration, the Dutch did it because they lost at the Roem Royen negotiations. Indonesia exists not just because of race, but because of the commonality of being colonized by the Dutch, that's why if there was no Dutch, every tribe could claim their own country, because the basis is race.
Western scientists have researched Papua's natural resources before Indonesia's independence, they plan to take Papua's resources in full control, if Indonesia does not take Papua then the indigenous people of Papua will have the same fate as the Australian aborigines, maybe if Papua becomes independent before it is taken over by Indonesia maybe there will be the exact same country as Australia where the majority of the population is white and the natives were exiled or even massacred, indonesia do not have the power to fight the British and Americans to take over Freeport 100% If Indonesia struggles to get all of Freeport's shares, maybe we will have the same fate as Iraq and Libya
the government of indonesia wanted to have west new guinea (after all the indonesian government during the revolution had said that the dutch illegally owned west new guinea). others than that, papua new guinea was not independent yet until 1975.
🇦🇺 Australia: “West Papua needs to be free, just like how I made Timor-Leste 🇹🇱 oil and gas free for me to take!”
"Timor-Leste loses $1 million a day due to Australia's unlawful exploitation of resources in the disputed area. Timor-Leste cannot be deprived of its rights or territory because of a crime." *-First Prime Minister of Timor-Leste, Mari Alkatiri*
Is that True, is there anytruth about what you said???
Australia is the Japan of Oceania
@@hanggaraaryagunarencagutuh7072the UK of Oceania 😂
@@StickyKeys187 Hmm yeah
@@StickyKeys187makes sense since their British
Everytime there is land full of gold and oil West country suddenly spread props that " this country needs democracy "😂
AND YOU DON'T WANT TO GIVE THEM FREEDOM TO STEAL ALL THEIR RESOURCES. "SHAME ON YOU"
@@hekalkal8111and you want their freedom to have the chance to steal all their resources? "Shame on you"
except it was the west that historically supported indonesia surpressing locals and stealing their resources.
Every time some third worlder gets mad at us for pointing out their human rights abuses they start whining "no u!!" because they can't actually defend themselves. lol
@@yapsiauwsoengie6507 WE NEVER STEAL LIKE YOU DID.SHAME ON YOU.😂😂
The West Papua situation is actually much more complicated. Firstly, west papua already have autonomy, in which only west papuan can became governor. The west papuan also split between pro Indonesia and pro independence, where pro indonesian is predominantly around coastal area, and pro independence is around mountainious area. I myself live in Merauke, which is quite isolated to the rest of papua and having much more economical ties with Surabaya than the rest of Papua. This makes Merauke very pro Indonesia compared to the other Papuan city.
The papuan independence movement itself quite fractured. ULMWP is the most recognizable internationally, but they have no actual power in west Papua. West Papuan are much more supportive of OPM, which is a separatist militia that still operates to this day, but OPM have become very fractured as of late. There are other separatist movement, but they have become very irrelevant. In short, while ULMWP got the most support internationally, OPM got the most support locally.
Furthermore, Indonesia just recently split Papua Province of Indonesia into four province. On one hand, this have become the cry of papuan people since a long time. Papua province is too big to govern with so little population, thus making it hard to developed. In addition many seen Jayapura as very corrupt and also want the Civil servant quota, in which they have to compete with other papuan ethnicity. On the other hand, this is a ploy by Indonesian goverment to weaken the Independence movement. This could be seen in the Papua Tengah Province, where the Central Government pick Nabire instead of Timika even thought Timika is the proposed capital since a long time. I belive this is because the situation in Timika got the worst during 2019 West Papua unrest.
Fascinating comment
Kerenn
this guy need to do some research, complete crap full of oz propaganda cuz indonesia never invaded any country
@@kari916 **cough** timor timur
Despite the murders of 700,000 Papuans you are pro Indonesia
😂😂😂 You want West Papua to be separated from Indonesia, after that you will exploit its natural wealth. then left it like Timor Leste, Iraq, Afghanistan
Yes this is what they do best and it's sickening.
It's actually Indonesia gave them authority to became Autonomous region but the things are the government from themselves are always being corrupt so made it like that
How would you know that? there was no government for these people similar to how there's no effective representative of aboriginal Australian in their own land
I think ethnicity is not the main problem. In maluku or flobamora, theres so many people with simmiliar looks. And also some people in buton and celebes too. The javanese also have many dark skinned people that have the negrito/australoid anchestor gene
still different stupid..... Freedom for wets PAPUA....
INDONESIA IS NOT A RACE BUT A NATIONALITY WITH MORE THAN 1.300 ETHNICITIES AND RACES LIKE CHINESE,JAVANESE, MELANESIANS AND DAYAKNESE FOR EXAMPLE WTFF,WE HAVE A SLOGAN CALLED "UNITY IN DIVERSITY"THAT MEANS NO MATTER WHAT'S UR RELIGION,SKIN COLORS OR RACES YOU'RE STILL INDONESIAN🇮🇩
Based
Westoid only know a country only 1 ethnic
Yes, "Indonesian" is indeed a nationality. The problem is that the country's current socio-political situation does not benefit the indigenous Papuans' integrity. They are disadvantaged compared to their brown neighbors and their cultures and languages, just like with the rest of the country, are threatened by the one national identity policy. If the Papuans want to create their own government that satisfies their own interests and self-determination as a people, then they rightfully deserve that. I mean Indonesia, Malaysia, and the Philippines’ national identities are all based on colonial territories, not cultural divisions. And so, insisting that Indonesia should remain as it is given its treatment of its minority cultures is shallow and inconsiderate. So before anyone insists that West Papua should stay under Indonesian governance, first address if their rights as the rightful peoples of their land and society are met.
@@rvat2003 Wdym so before anyone insist african american should stay under USA first address their right as the rightful people of their land and society are met?
You do know Papuan actually have more right than other islanders because they got special autonomy privilege right?
@@muhammadajibakriaji3753 Yeah based on his sound typical anglo saxon westoid, other white ethnicity usually behave better though still colonizer.
Yea, it is a Nationality. But if you have to hold people at gunpoint to make them join, don't you realise that's a little messed up?
Bro, West Papua join Indonesia was such a big deal for future, but because cold war, USSR want Indonesia to be Comunist, and US doesnt want it, instead US, Secretly make Indonesia strugle, and broke apart
West Papua: *[Finally Free]*
Constant Corrupt Government, Economic Recession, Civil Wars between Pro-Indonesia and Pro-West Papua, Inflation, and any Governmental obstacles that I doubt they’ll handle it: Hello there 😁
Betcha 1lbs of gold from Freeport that there'll be foreign "peacekeeping" forces suddenly appearing there. If that happens I sure hope to hell that China will also be there, so I can enjoy the surprise Pikachu face of the US and Australia. Come to think of it, I hope Timor Leste would accept Chinese money for infrastructure deal, so China can open a naval base there. I mean why would Australia object to a military base of their biggest trading partner there.
"FREE ABORIGIN ✊🇦🇺
Free ABORIGIN
What do you mean
Do aboriginals want independence?
@@osheridan there’s no way to give it to them unless everyone leaves Australia
Lol you all new Zealand and Australian just want lands, since long ago the Papuans already made a party to gain independent from the Dutch. And also many people in papua now suffering because of the rebels, oh yea don't forget yall Australian massacred the Native Australian population😂😂
Bhinneka tunggal ika, kita memang berbeda tetapi tetap satu. Negara lain bnyk yg menghasut tp jangan tertipu mereka sbenrnya punya kepentingan masing2.
I do not know which one i have to support,
Indonesia support my homeland against malaysia,
australia help us during the Japanese occupation,
And West papua also has similar goal to has about being Freedom,
These three are rival to each other (not australian against papua) but they supporting my homeland,
Guess im just chilling being neutral then
Free Aborigin....
This is kind a old trick that australia does. They want to take natural resourses from indonesia which located in papua. They support separatis people in papua to seperate from indonesia. And after that they can take natural resourse as much as possible. Just what they did to east timor... And fyi... There are so many people in papua that dont want a seperate from indonesia.. just come there..
they did it before. At first they supported Indonesia to anex Timor Leste due to communist Fretilin. Since they knew about oil in Timor Sea, they opposed Indonesia.
And these Indonesians dare to criticize Israel with the Palestine issue but look at them what they did in East Timor and still do today in West Papua.
But since Muslim Brotherhood is "good" everything else bad.
They can still criticize Israel even if they're not perfect. If we stopped calling out issues just because we also have our own, then nothing can be resolved. They can definitely improve in regard to West Papua without tolerating Israel's crimes.
@@rvat2003 But it's hypocrite from them to support Hamas and Palestine Independence but they shut down the same to West Papuans seeking independence since 1960s also calling them terrorists but again since to them.
Muslim = Good
Non Muslim = Bad.
@@RevoIke Did you know that the island of New Guinea partly belongs to the sultanate of Tidore. 😊 And the sultanate of tidore could not be conquered by the Dutch
Yeah, they're hypocrite AF.
As a Muslim. You're right. It hurts me,they should help the oppressed and not oppress. It's 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮
🇨🇦 😔 I heard how Indonesian governors attacked their people for their economy & called locals “dogs” once sparking a big controversy.
Source trust me😂
lol. Your slander is more cruel than the country of Papua New Guinea. Indonesia has always been afraid of Papuans because they are strong and firm. because of that, most of them became debt collectors in Jakarta, especially Javanese people 😂😂
Indonesia population: 300millions+
austrlia population :26millions🤣🤣🤣
free aborigins!
Free West Papuan indigenous people.
@@liambmn The same as you completely free the rest of Bismarck archipelago, not just Bougainville. :)
@@dugalaksit5570 Yeah well the Bismarck Archipelagos isn't part of the Province of West Papua, or Indonesia, it's part of Papua New Guinea, and well you know it!!
It's people like you, who come out of the wood work in the comment section and try to misinform "dumb Westerns," and believe me, most Westerners aren't just dumb, they're FUCKIN' DUMB, when it comes to anything related to this part of the World.
Get Yank, to point out on a map, where he thinks Jayapura is on a map map. I'll bet you 9 1/2 out of 10 would have to talk to "uncle Google" first, even when it comes to the question "well, which hemisphere is it in?" Again, the answer will be crickets!!
@@liambmn Common Liam, we gotta do better than that, mate. We gotta help these people gain a reasonably coherent, confident and above all, UNIFIED Political Voice of their people, from their people instead of yet, another (however well meaning) churning out yet "another impassioned plea for justice" to a by and large, empty. If you're the guy that's gonna give the monologue, and do the soundbites, you've lost me already, understand.
But what I really do hope, is that you realise why it is that I say all this. It's like that old proverb "give a Man a fish, you've fed him for a day, but teach a Man to fish, and you'll feed him for a lifetime."
I hope I haven't come off too "preachy", and that you "get" my message, if you think I have one. Thanks.
@@dugalaksit5570 the thing is bougainville is going to be free and the other islands around PNG don't want independence
The West papua is an Indonesian 🇮🇩 region province in East Indonesia. "From Sabang until Merauke"
Have you ever realized how large Indonesia is? Sabang to Merauke has length of 5.250 km. It's the same distance from Lisboa, Portugal to Tehran, Iran. that's huge distance. Imagine a European country that spans from Portugal to Iran. It's kind of amazing that Indonesia is still a single country.
@@kaptenhiu5623 Yes. The Indonesian was another of islands behaviour with utilizing of railway and road tunnelling of undersea area was realized of constructions
Colonizer.
@@VanessaSouza-rz8uoyou probably lived in the country of colonizers that colonized many nations😂😂
@@andravideostation6101just leave thoose westerner in here regions of papua they dont care about we rule papua as long as they live properly then they accept it
This is the part where I don't understand as to why some 🇦🇺media and the so-called activists are compelled to behave like the "pacific protector" by sticking their noses into their immediate friendly neighbour and creating a spark of separatism. Or is it bc they're all deceived by pro-seperatist/terorist "activist" Veronica Koman who studied in 🇦🇺 with 🇮🇩 taxprayer' money & now working for Amnesty intl in 🇦🇺 spreading one-sided false narratives & lies about condition in West Papua.
On the other hand, 🇮🇩 never brings up the systematic massacres of aboriginal people in 🇦🇺 or even bother about 🇦🇺's internal matter. The legal status of West Papua is crystal clear and in accordance with the intl system/norm. Just like all other 🇮🇩 territories and every postcolonial countries (🇮🇳🇵🇰🇲🇾🇵🇬🇺🇲🇵🇭🇰🇷 🇳🇬 so on). You should know better about Uti Posidetis Juris, the Treaty of the Hague and the New York Agreement. It's a done deal. Uti Posidetis Juris alone supersede self-determination / referendum, even so, it has been done (once and for all) when declaring independence from the 🇳🇱 colonisation, plus additional self-determination for West Papua in 1969 and was adopted by the UN.. If you guys care so much about self-determination maybe let's begin with holding a referendum in 🇦🇺 for aboriginal people and see if the indigenous aborigines really want to be ruled by white people. 😀
Note: One may wonder, how about TL🇹🇱? Simple. It's a different case. I must admit 🇹🇱 was annexed illegally (even though 🇦🇺 & 🇺🇲 supported 🇮🇩) but because 🇹🇱 was never colonized by or part of the 🇳🇱 territory in NEI, thus Uti posidetis juris isn't applicable (legally flawed). That's why the UN never recognised it which leads to a referendum or self-determination. But not in any other 🇮🇩 territory.
Because Australia is not killing Aborigines RIGHT NOW
OK but that doesn't mean we shouldn't look past things that are wrong
@@dukedukeson2158 Sure let's talk about human rights issues and how to improve development in West Papua instead of supporting separatism. When I say human rights issues, I mean including the separatists who killed both TNI and civilians.
@@riezan agree,central government should increase infrastructure and education in West Papua,when it's done,there is no longer separatism movement,like GAM back then
GAM stands for Gerakan Aceh Merdeka
West Papua: woo hoo we’re finally free from the Dutch!
Indonesia: allow me to introduce myself
Indonesia is basically successor of Dutch East Indies, Papua is already free from colonizer Netherlands 😂
@@Momo-nk6lddan dilanjutkan penjajah rakus berkulit sawo matang.
If you don't know the history, it's better to keep quiet
Terjemahkan
@@jackjimny7417you aint shit without us
@kenyoh475 he wasn't born in 1910-1920s genius....
I also went to west Papua and the locals want independence
And hopefully one day by God's grace they will be free
I can literally tell you never went there based on your bullshit 😭😭😭
FINALY SOMEONE TALKS ABOUT IT MALUKU DAN PAPUA MERDEKA
Papua Indonesia is better than Papua New Guinea
By the same argument, ‘Israel’s West Bank is better than Palestine’s West Bank’ 🤡
@@gp2779 I don't care
@@gp2779 But the difference is that Papuans live in Papua. And Jews live in Israel, there are no Arabs there, only in the Palestinian authority and then they are forced out of there, you will not meet an Arab in Tel Aviv.
@@hatewarwarWhy voice your opinion if you don't care about it?
I think he ment he doesnt care about Palestinian@@Adriaticus
Wait! Sabah and Sarawak along with our european Brothers basque and catalonia need some recognition too!
Free abogirin, free real Australian people.... 🎉 save Aborigin, save indian ,free indian & native America, save maori people & new Zealand🎉🎉🎉🎉
If Papua does gain independence, it would lead to a civil war, Indonesia is madeout of hundreds of different ethnic groups. Our country is Diverse and always has been. So giving them independence, would spark independence movements all over Indonesia and eventually our country would cease to exist
That's not the Papuans problem.
@@liambmn Of coarse it is, they triggered the civil war
@@OnionIlan but if your country is too unstable, it should be your own concern to make your country stable, not the Papuans, if they don't even wanna be part of your state.
@@liambmn almost everyone here is different not just the papuans
@@liambmn without papua our country would break up
It would be stupid if some people from several European countries provoked Papua to separate from the Republic of Indonesia. It's very funny that the international consensus has been decided in various stages under the UN, now it wants to be debated again. If a country has been formed for less than 100 years, of course there are still a certain percentage of parties who disagree with forming it into a country, but that percentage can be seen from the total number of existing residents. If it is much smaller, it means they are classified as rebels in that country. And rebels in one country can't fund themselves unless there is financial assistance from other countries as sponsors, and this can be sued internationally. So what happens to every country in the world if there are a handful of people who shout "INDEPENDENT" to break free and separate themselves from a legitimate country, then they have to be served by a referendum by the UN again? If that's the case, more than 200 sovereign countries in the world will be able to become thousands of countries in the near future, then all countries will be shaken politically and the world economic crisis will keep on hitting, and so and so it keeps repeating itself.
Aborigin will be free and not west papua
-wise man
Ok pls tell the Palestinians that they are free but not West Bank
Bro forget to mention that Indonesian native Malays are also closer to Malaysia and Brunei than to Javanese. Also West Timorese are also closer to East Timor than to Javanese. You want us to be divided just like old times, we're not into it. We're not the one who invented Apartheid, we're living with Melanesians hundreds thousands of times until you arrived and enslaved all of us.
Pre-colonial Indonesia was even worse. Just look at the treatment with how many Austroasiatic tribes on Java committed on a widespread scale as far as Austronesian tribes. I'd tell you you're living a life of hatred. Kingdoms rise and fall. The longer it takes you to accept the fact that Indonesia is a complex, divided nation full of Islamofascist tribalism, the longer it'll take for you to realise that Apartheid is something learnt that the archipelago wants because of how distraught each island is.
@@ali_tafa006yes,Im Sumatera Malay etnic
@@ali_tafa006Do you teach US about our history? Really dude? 🤣🤣
@nono-ri9btat least tell to your palestinian that west bank will not free
Nice video, but I have one correction, Jayapura was the original capital of West Papua before it became part of Indonesia in 1963. In 2001, the province of West Papua was split, the eastern half with the capital still Jayapura, and the western half having its capital as Manokwari. The distance between Jayapura and Jakarta is the same as that of Anchorage and Los Angeles
Yeah, I'm afraid you need to look on more updates towards these statements hehe.. :D most things have changed though 😁
ok boomers
Need to be reunited with their brothers and sisters in PNG
That garbage crime ridden country? Yuck
geez you guys really want to impose one country one ethnic ideology to a country like Indonesia huh.
if that's the case then why don't you also say "riau people should reunite with their borthers and sisters in Malaysia" just because they're not javanese like why? you guys always say the same narrative that doesn't depicts what actually happens
that's racist by the way, just because they look same it doesn't mean they're the same there is lot of different tribe and language in Papua
Lol 😂 Try lah dogo and lets see who going to become part of us
What accent is this? I kind of found it hard to understand his accent especially the second half of the video
as an indonesian myself, i support the indepence of papua, yet i dont support the west papua national liberation army, not only because they bring lots of crimes with their agenda, but because the most support come to them mostly from white countries, just saying but i know more about the situation.
Finally a rational Indonesian and not a extreme nationalist
@@gp2779 I also support the independence of the Uighurs from the brutal regime of China. Dude, if we free them, it doesn't mean you're going to colonize them tomorrow.
White countries biggest "batu api", war-mongers. Strictly for their own selfish benefits.😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡
Our first history! when Gajah Mada united the entire NUSANTARA including West Papua
FREE ABORIGIN AUSTRALIA🇦🇺
No… The Netherlands did not just give up Papua to them, they argued that because they were ethnically different it should remain a colony & it was a self governing colony until the 1960s when Indonesia made multiple attempts to try & invade leading to the Dutch making a deal where the Dutch leave & grant it to Indonesia so long as the have a vote on it, however they were tricked/forced into voting against independence. Now it’s illegal to raise the old colonial era flag as they see it as a symbol of defiance
Gusdur who made it legal to raise the morning star flag as long as its not higher than the red and white flag: 👁👄👁
West papua je Indonesia ❤ dont stand down to the rebels and auszies 🐖🐖🐖
Meanwhile in Australia ... so stfu redlinepod
Iam from papua and we love indonesia....🇮🇩
Free west papua
No free west papua, but free aborigin.
I'm living in Central java atm, and yeah, Papuan people are different from the typical Javanese majority that dominates Indonesia's demographics. Even in the most progressive of cities, Papuans aren't exactly as accepted like Sumatrans or Balinese
So more like Java Supremacist heh?
@@dugalaksit5570 not really but their pyshique are really diffrent among another tribe sunda, jawa, bali, etc
Dominate in where except java and lampung?
I am a Jakartan and born until I grew up I don't like to be called Javanese also jakarta event are in Java
All Indonesian presidents are Javanese
Kolonial lagunya ngajarin kebebasan
As indonesian I don't give a sh*t whatever Papua peoples wants to independent or not
Why? Then why you even in here? 😂
I don't give a shit what you want, or Indonesians want. If Papuans want to be independent, they should be.
@@liambmn governing government isn't easy if Papua become independent I guarantee they are going to become like Timor Leste
@@liambmn honestly, yeah myself also not care if Papua wanted to separate from us or not. But again, the concern is, can they do things on their own? How sure that you think they could thrive alone without our help? I highly doubt they could even survive in most aspect after seperated from us.
If you support an extreme povertishm, then sure.. Just whatever you wanted to say man. Ok
@@dugalaksit5570 Does that mean you do not care if Indonesia loses Papua? Or do you just not care about the will of the people who live there?
Indonesia become the new Dutch for the West Papua.
Yes, and it's due to horrible Asian and European colonizers!
South Korea burns the West Papuan forests!
The real Indonesians feel emotional bound with West Papuans!
New Dutch?You saw that during the Dutch colonialism in Indonesia, they pitted races against each other in Indonesia when all the provinces were still kingdoms, they drained natural resources and forced labor.Take a look at Papua now, President Jokowi is trying to level development but the OPM or the independent Papuan organization continues to carry out terror by attacking civilians, attacking small army posts And hospitals are among the construction workers sent to level development in Papua
@nono-ri9bt why you call me liar?
@nono-ri9bt Who taught you? I have lived in Indonesia since I was a child and I have been to Papua and almost died because of the actions of Papuan rebels
@nono-ri9bt We Indonesians have been colonized by the Dutch for around 300 years, our heroes were exiled, the people were starving and oppressed, not to mention the addition of 5 countries.
Papua is Indonesia forever 🇮🇩
Jan tertipu liat aja timor leste di jadikan sapi perah australia begitu mereka merdeka, hal yg sama akan terjadi jika papua lepas maka jangan harap bisa merdeka kalian akan dimakan propaganda negara2 barat yg mau SDA kalian😅
Mereka menganggungkan kata kebebasan tp sbenernya cmn pen Sumber daya kalian contohnya coba liat IRAK, Afganistan syriah dan daerah timur tengah lainnya. Kedoknya mau membebaskan rakyat/teroris tp sbenernya itu cmn alasan saja spaya bisa masuk dan ngincer minyak negara2 lain. Hal sperti ini terjadi di era modern.
Kalo di pertahankan, Bisa jadi Duri dalam Daging.
Kalo Dilepas Terlalu Sayang..........😞🇨🇺
Kalo menurut Prediksi gw,
Papua Pastinya Bisa Merdeka Cepet Lambat.
Kita sebagai warga harus siap² Menanggung Resiko jika kelak hari itu terjadi!
Bendera Kuba? Papua tidak komunis bro
@@garangan2797 *hampir ,
Papua is always forever Indonesia
It's been illegally occupied by the Evil Colonialist Indonesian government but will NEVER truly belong to them
only dreams 😆
@@byyrka8710 Same as Papuan Independence i reckon 😂
@@byyrka8710 west Papua become a independent country is only dream. We don't need to be new country. We need to live with peace in Indonesia without bastard rebel opm.
@@byyrka8710lol the commentator is basically Papuan and you hear it by yourself Papua is always forever Indonesia who are you british children 😂
Indonesia is like a southeast Asia UK or US.
What
Ah yeah...OZ accent....not suprising at all😂
Free West Papua!!
This is what I hate about Australia. They tried to flip the narrative so bad. And not to mention some Philippines siding with them just because Indonesia is a Muslim majority.
First off there's only 500k people living in papua of which only a few hundreds wanted Independence and even fewer separatists grups, they are on the mountains in middle parts of mountainous region in papua.
These separatists groups don't even trust each others and sometimes fight. They took people as hostages, burn down schools and hospital and ambush Indonesian police.
Australia is beginning to look more like the Russians and we're Ukraine.
They act like we tried to demolish the ethnic people in papua, but it's actually the opposite.
The history of how Indonesia got Papua is sketchy yes, but times have changed president changed and policy changed.
@@Nagin-zt6sc what are you talking about, PNG is literally less safe than West Papua. There's gangs and tribe wars and the Australian Government are doing jackshit about it.
@@Nagin-zt6sc ua-cam.com/video/JWZBc44qB1I/v-deo.htmlsi=LT7UEGLMJP6piUqh Have a look yourself. While tribal wars in PNG happens, tribal wars in West Papua are always broken up by Indonesian Police.
Nobody in their right mind would give Independence to Papua because a few grups consisting of a few hundred men wanted so.
They don't even trust each other, recently the leader Joni Botak was killed by other Free Papua movement grups.
You think non Papuans are governing West Papua? You'd be wrong cause most of them that are governing Provinces in Papua are Indigenous Papuans (unlike Australia), and even The Police there almost all are Papuans.
@@Nagin-zt6sc also there's no genocide now. But In the past there is.
Suharto's dictatorship cracked down on a lot of groups, The Muslims in Aceh, the Fretelin communist in Timor Leste, The Ethnic Chinese and the Free Papua movement in Papua
before Suharto's was forcefully stepped down as President.
@@Nagin-zt6scdon't comment on Indonesian people, they lack education, they are like crazy, Papua wants independence from greedy Indonesian invaders
@@theselectivecentrist8146 and the Australians didn't do the same thing in timor leste? Sucking their oil like there's no tomorrow?, and who barks if not the western countries and IMF when Indonesia bans its raw rare minerals for export.
Protest? You mean the ones in batam? That's because the relocation plan there is not thought out yet, and people in Batam doesn't want foreign investors on their land even though it'll boost the economy. Also unlike other places batam has the luxury to not needing to pay taxes.
Free Papua!
Sejarah Republik Indonesia adalah koloni Hindia Belanda..., Papua adalah koloni Belanda dan papua new guinea adalah koloni Inggris.., selesai NKRI harga mati.
Lucu sih kau kalau teriak 'NKRI harga mati' tapi pilih imigran Aseng sebagai Presiden 2024 nanti 😂
Kita bukan NKRI
I searched this after I saw the Indonesian Sole Survivor rescue😂
Indonesia should give West Papua Independence and keep up good relationship.. give economic aid, so that Papuan will appreciate their former nation..
But.. Independ3nt West Papua could end like PNG.. with tribes violence and slow economic growth, and the ruling Gov.. could not handle the situation,and pleading for foreign aid..
Free Aborigin from 🇦🇺
Yes, also give Maori and Aboriginal people their lands back. Also Hawaii to local Hawaiian people instead of loud, snobbish fat Americans
@Nagin-zt6scno genocide happened anymore it was during Suharto regime before we became democratic 😂😂
@@bestbeast74Dutch East Indies is Indonesia, Papua always part of Indonesia 😏
Free West Papua✊🏽
At least Tell To Palestinian That Israel Will Conquer West Bank And Aslo Tell To ukrainian That All Of Crimea Is Belong To Russian
Free West Papua
Free West Papua 🙏🙏💪💪💪
West Papua has right to be independence
Right to another choice
No
@@ehwanzunaidi5244 Right to self determination
Hawaii and New Zealand also. Free from the loud, fat Whites back to the Pacific Islanders and Maoris
In your dream
It hurts so much to see the comment, there’s a reason why the Israel Palestine conflict kept happening it’s because people are hypocrites truly.
Iam from Papua and always forever indonesia
The West be like "This region is rich of resources therefore they should be independent" **wink wink**
No thanks
Indonesia is no better than the west
@kenyoh475 oh please
Free west papua
Or Indonesians should shut up about Palestine
If you consider Papuans' distinct ethnic identity as the main reason they should get independence, then your opinion is invalid.
No but the fact us is, that their ethnicity is one of the reasons why they are discriminated and oppressed by Indonesians.
@@cryostatis3018 Discriminated? Maybe by some close-minded individual, but I dare to say that Papuans have slightly more rights to enjoy than other ethnic groups. The Papuan provinces only allow indigenous Papuans to be elected into governmental and other critical positions. Is that oppression to you?
@@黒田たかし-n5f When armed people from 2000 kilometers away come and assault you and take your rightful land and goods, pretty much yeah.
@@黒田たかし-n5f None of what you said is okay helloo? Shouldn't everyone have the same rights?? From what I've seen Papuans are treated like cattle and if that's better treatment than most ethnicities then I don't wanna know what Indonesia does to them.
@@cryostatis3018 Let me put it words simple enough for that slimy pink thing inside your skull to understand.
Some provinces of Indonesia are granted special privileges by the central government to govern themselves in ways that are not always in accordance with the constitution. For instance, the province of Aceh is allowed to implement Sharia laws as part of the 2005 peace agreement, despite Indonesia being a secular nation. Similarly, the province of Yogyakarta maintains a hereditary ruling system instead of the typical elections held in other regions, in recognition of its significant contribution during the war for independence.
As for the Papuan provinces, these privileges take form of the implementation of various affirmative action policies. They aim to address social and economical disparities and improve the welfare of the local Papuans. These policies may not be perfectly implemented, but they represent our government's commitment to acknowledge and address the historical challenges faced by the Papuans.
Stop thinking that Suharto is alive and well and still ruling over us with his iron fist. The Papuans bled in the past, but so did other ethnic groups. If you still think that separatism and balkanization are the solutions to many problems faced by minorities around the world today, maybe you can start by supporting your own local separatists?
FREE WEST PAPUA!!!!
Free Aborigin Of Australia!
West Papua is the territory of the Netherlands New Guinea which was included in the territory of the Dutch kingdom and was not a colony of the Dutch East Indies but Indonesia forced us Papuans to enter Indonesia until the day we were still colonized
please tell the world media that we want independence, we Papuans don't want to live with the Indonesian state
👊🏻👊🏻🔥
Netherlands and dutch is literally a same thing
Both are 'Dutch' so i don't see why Papua should be independent from Indonesia as both 'Dutch' is literally the same thing. Both headed by the same King/Queen
Look the map of Dutch East Indies, Papua is part of it 😂😂
FREE WEST PAPUA ✊🏽
"Did someone said OIL?!!"🇺🇸 🦅
Free aborigin too!
Look at the elephant in front of your eyes, you Indonesian greedy invaders
Gold in Papua owned by Freeport. Freeport ain't indonesian company.
WRONG STATEMENT, YOU MUST SEARCH AND RESEARCH WHAT BACKGROUND OF INDONESIA HISTORY NOT ONLY FOR CONTENT AND PLAY FIRE
American bases surround Indonesia
Free west papua ❤
Profokator
Never
Free Aborigin ❤
Hello? Where is this West Papua you're selling for free?
For what?
Papua never exist without Indonesia
Colonizer mindset.
Free west papua
Free Australia and Hawaii
keep barking bro , papua is indonesia. no matter what u said it remain the same.. papua is indonesia
free market
Get out of west Papua free free west Papua
ya karna papua adalah indonesia dan juga australia ingin merebut papua dari indonesia dengan segala cara jangan harap, bagaimana dengan timor leste setelah di ambil dari indonesia, australia tidak bisa membuat makmur rakyatnya hanya ingin sumber Alamnya saja, dan rakyatnya miskin, kami akan mempertahankan papua sampai kapan pun, sekali pun nyawa taruhanya, NKRI HARGA MATI, KOMUNIS STOP CAMPUR TANGAN DENGAN PAPUA, PAPUA IN INDONESIA
Kami tidak butuh bantuan Australia kau makan tuh NKRI harga mati
Free aboriginals (AUSTRALIA continent native) from colonialism of australians which Australians are British (immigrants from UK)
No
Free West papua, free Northeast India, Free Tibet and Free Kurdistan
Free aborigin, go back to england
Bro what 💀💀
Yes! Free West Papua from European and Asian colonizers! Indonesia is not an Asian country!
Average Westoid
Free your finger
How many Indonesians are going to deny that West Papuans don't want to be a part of Indonesia.
This has nothing to do with anything else.
"What about Australia waa waa waa"
The difference is we aren't actively bombing Aboriginals so they don't want independence.
Are you sure? There is a lot of Papua People doesn't like The Papua Merdeka Movement. The Government can easily let them free like Timor Leste but it will make the Western come more Frequently to Western Papua and Taking their Gold, Oil, etc.
To prevent Western Destroying Papua, Indonesia will protect it because *IN THE PAST* Papua People wanted to Be Integrated with Indonesia.
Actualy we papuan hate indo governemt, because lack of jobs, hospitals, internet is so expensive . Rice is expensive
We raise star banner is so we re getting the attention, independece? Its more like a slogan of (treat us better, like other province).. we have HUGE I MEAN IT HUGE Hatred toward armed rebels .. those bstrd rape and killed my relative (Rest in peace) just because she was a teacher
As a Christian from 🇵🇭, I stand with West Papua!
How about mindanao, sulu and palawan???
If you support them come to them and see what will happen 😁
As a muslim i stand with Moro people
Why???
because of the racial differences? As fellow Malay Race,, I demand the Philippines should be one of Indonesian provinces...
If you're saying the Philippines never been a Dutch colony,, then West Papua has the answer to be an integral part of Indonesia.
But,, most importantly... West Papuans (together with other delegation from other regions) were sending their delegates to the Indonesian Youth Pledge back in 1928 to declare themselves as one nation...
Thought? 😎😎
Thank you! I'll set West Papua free from European and Asian colonizers!
colonized by the Dutch Portuguese for more than 3 centuries. We unite to expel invaders from our land. No matter race/religion, we are united. now see what they want? divide our nation. history is never lost.
Indonesia are the invaders now
Indonesia Papua people enjoy a much more robust economy than PNG,higher gdp percapita,higher HDI,improved infrastructure iniciatives, AUSTRALIA CHOOSE TO LEAVE PNG ALONE,WHICH IS QUITE SAD
❤❤❤Free west papua❤❤❤
Wrong statement Lol
I saw by myself, the violations of personal rights of West Papuan. Hopefully for the best of West Papuans. MERDEKA!
Free West Papua & Aceh..
Yes! Free West Papuans and Acehnese from racist Malaysians and Singaporeans!
what if instead of indonesia come to papua but australian.maybe no one will talk freely about indeoeendece because theyre already genocided hehhee
Papua merdeka 🇨🇺
Itu bendera Cuba bro
I think that's the Cuban flag. West Papua has a straight red line, Cuba's is triangular
@@FRISHR epenka Cupen toh
@@osheridan Obviously, because there isn't a West Papuan flag emoji, so Cuba it's the most similar flah
@@joaquinfernandez3347 yeah true
Just give them independence. How is Indonesia ruling West Papua different from Holland colonizing Java?
Indonesia want the west papua. And to get support for this action, they give america biggest gold mining grasberg.. 😊
i want west papua independence not because i’m in papua but because i want to be kind of sharing🤝
Sharing with western
Your a shame to the Indonesia country
Free aborigin
Same
Hello Unites Snakes, Are you there?
Yes
Dasar orng pengadudoba,sadar la masarakat papua,apakah benar kalian akanenikmati kekayaan kalaian,pasti kalau kalian lepas dri indonesia,orng luar yg akan mengeruk kekayaan alam kalaian,itu yg harus kalian yakini
Bahasa penjajah rakussss...... Biarkan papua Merdeka ditanah mereka sendri.... Bukankah kalian selama ini mengeruk sumberdaya mereka...
Go home return to your own motherland kaum pembuat kekacauan@@jackjimny7417
@@jackjimny7417bahasa penjajah itu sedang kamu gunakan 😂
@@カタキ cie bangga jadi penjajahan.....
Free aboriginals (native people of AUSTRALIA continent) from australians occupation which australians are british (immigrants from UK)
I don't know where westerners know history from, since the 1920s the Dutch established concentration camps in Boven Digoel Papua, many Indonesian political figures were imprisoned there, it was then that brought the spirit of independence and the initiative of the indigenous Papuan youth to merge into a country called Indonesia, the propaganda of West Papua existed when the Dutch suddenly unilaterally came to Papua and promised independence, to local pro-Dutch officials, in exchange for which they would get a special place under Dutch administration, the Dutch did it because they lost at the Roem Royen negotiations.
Indonesia exists not just because of race, but because of the commonality of being colonized by the Dutch, that's why if there was no Dutch, every tribe could claim their own country, because the basis is race.
Papua is Part Indonesia
Yes bro, netherland is dog.
Free Papua
channel provokator nih
Spam gini bang
Freedom of aborigin Australia ✊✊
West Papuan 🇨🇺 not Indonesian
We move capital to Borneo
I'm from Philippines why they not join in Papua New Guinea because they are same ethnic group unlike Indonesia?
different colonizer
Masalah etnis selalu yang membuat sebuah negara hancur bro, pikir kan lagi
Western scientists have researched Papua's natural resources before Indonesia's independence, they plan to take Papua's resources in full control, if Indonesia does not take Papua then the indigenous people of Papua will have the same fate as the Australian aborigines, maybe if Papua becomes independent before it is taken over by Indonesia maybe there will be the exact same country as Australia where the majority of the population is white and the natives were exiled or even massacred, indonesia do not have the power to fight the British and Americans to take over Freeport 100% If Indonesia struggles to get all of Freeport's shares, maybe we will have the same fate as Iraq and Libya
Indonesians are not even racially the same as Filipinos
the government of indonesia wanted to have west new guinea (after all the indonesian government during the revolution had said that the dutch illegally owned west new guinea). others than that, papua new guinea was not independent yet until 1975.