Nice ranking! Well here's mine(I'm not a native english speaker but nevermind): #11 Invisible Kid: This song never gets me, I dunno it's kinda boring for me #10 Dirty Window: The same as Invisible Kid, but I like the chorus #9 My world: Nothing to say, the same as the last two #8 Shoot me Again: The "shoot me again I ain't ded yet" part it's badass, the rest of the song It's ok I guess #7 All Within my Hands: I really like the calm intro. I also think the "kill kill kill" section It's funny to sing and scream lmao #6 St. Anger: I've never listened to this song too much, but the chorus hits me in the right way #5 Purify: YOU AND I, PURIFY, YOU AND I, PURIFYyyYyyYYyah The raw energy on this one gets me every single time. What a fun and energetic song #4 Some Kind of Monster: Yeah, I think the same, It's too long, but I enjoy the chorus and the Rythm. I also love the main riff #3 The Unnamed Feeling: The best lyrics on the album in my opinion, I connect with this one for that reason The calm and the raw parts fits so well and I never get bored listening this one #2 Frantic: That drum intro, gets me every time, like the first time I listened to this album. The chorus, specially the "Frantic-tic-tic" part makes me want to jump around #1 Sweet Amber: The intro the energetic verse and the pre-chorus, they are cathing, the chorus It's so f#cking badass and the bridge works for me I think this is the most "nu-metal" song on this album
11. Invisible Kid 10. All Within My Hands 9. Dirty Window 8. Shoot Me Again 7. The Unnamed Feeling 6. My World 5. SKOM 4. Frantic 3. Sweet Amber 2. Purify 1. St. Anger
Kind of similar I too put Purify last. Maybe without it there would be less bad moments that didtract from the passable ones. 10.- my world. More or less the same. 9. All within my hands. A shorter version would have been better. 8. Shoot me again. I also love the part that you showed!!. 7. Invisible kid. A little shorter would have been better but still passable. I love all the riffs here. 6. Some kind of monster. It seems very repetitive at this point but yes, the lenght is a problem. Still, i enjoy a lot the main riff and the chorus and the "ominous" part. Terrible ending, though; i mean that weird circus-esque thing. 5. Sweet amber. That main riff is great. I love it 4. Dirty window. Again, a great riff. Although the lyrics in this album have problems (this is not the best example of james' lyrics), I like the message of this one. It is great the song is being played in the tour. 3. St anger. This song is good, i agree with you, people compare it to their best work and it loses there, but on its own it is just good. I never get tired of this one. 2. Frantic. I am too in the "love it" team. This one is not that long and that helps a lot. 1. The unnamed feeling. I agree with you too here. This one I think is the best. I love that it really captures what it feels to go through those moments; I relate to the lyrics, unfortunately. I think of the whole album that it is not the garbage some people say it is. It has flaws but it also has good moments. Maybe it is not suitable for listening to it in one sitting as a whole album but a song every now and then is enjoyable.
Here's my list: 1. All Within My Hands 2. Sweet Amber 3. Invisible Kid 4. Some Kind Of Monster 5. Invisible Kid 6. Shoot Me Again 7. The Unnamed Feeling 8. St. Anger 9. Frantic 10. Purify 11. Dirty Window
Bro was dead lmao 💀 Anyways, here’s mine: 11 - Purify 10 - All Within My Hands 9 - Shoot Me Again 8 - My World 7 - Some Kind Of Monster 6 - St. Anger 5 - Frantic 4 - Dirty Window 3 - Invisible Kid (grew on me a fuck ton, only 8/10 tho) 2 - The Unnamed Feeling 1 - Sweet Amber (still not a 10/10)
didn't think this day would come. can't wait for when you do death magnetic anyways, here's my ranking: #11 my world - forgettable minus the "not only do i not know the answer" part, which is why it's dead last for me; #10 invisible kid - again, feel like the song is largely forgettable except the "what a good boy you are" part. funnily enough, unlike you, i actually enjoy it whenever i listen to invisible kid; #9 purify - call me crazy, but i actually like the chorus xD. which is enough for me to put it above invisible kid and my world; #8 shoot me again - the first song i've heard from this album and the first one i liked. the chorus is cool but i also like the "bite my tongue trying not to shoot back. no compromise, my heart won't pump the other way" part. there's also the "all the shots i take, what difference did i make?"; #7 some kind of monster - while i do admit the song's length is a bit problematic, i still enjoy it due to its riffs and james' vocal delivery of the chorus; #6 sweet amber - enjoyable from start to finish. the chorus is particularly great; #5 all within my hands - love james' vocal performance in this song. i find it funny that this song, of all of them from metallica's discography, was chosen for the name of their charity organization; #4 the unnamed feeling - while this album doesn't sound as good as the rest, one thing's certain, james' voice is as good as before. you can particularly feel it in this song; #3 frantic - frantic tic tic tic tic tic tock frantic tic tic tic tic tic tock frantic tic tic tic tic tic tock frantic tic tic tic tic tic tock #2 st anger - nothing to add. what you've said in the video applies here; #1 dirty window - headbanging from start to finish. particularly love james' laugh following the "i drink from the cup of denial" part
Yay! Finally, a new video. Happy late new year, also. 😂😂😂 Anyway, here's my ranking (I warn it won't exactly be very positive): 11) Purify 0/10 10) Shoot Me Again 1/10 9) All Within My Hands 1.5/10 8) Invisible Kid 2/10 7) My World 3/10 6) Some Kind Of Monster 3.5/10 5) Dirty Window 4/10 4) Sweet Amber 5/10 3) St Anger 6/10 2) Frantic 6.5/10 1) The Unnamed Feeling 7/10
You took 15 years to do this- jk. Here is my ranking anyway: 1. Shoot Me Again. You may ask... why this? Many people say this song is cringe... but to me... this is literally one of my favorite songs from Metallica. The length is perfect, the intro is amazing, the main riff is heavy yet groovy, the vocals and verses are amazing, the refrain is catchy and groovy, the pre-chorus is progressively angrier, the chorus is just amazing by all means... even the bridge is amazing, both of them. And my gosh... that outro... it is so angry, so raw, so powerful, just... perfect. Could this song be better? Yeah... but this is not worse than all the other songs. My favorite song of the album IMO 2. Frantic. Amazing intro, awesome riff, great vocals and a pretty good song structure, even if it sounds kinda... disjointed. A great opener for the album, even if St. Anger would work a little bit more. The lyrics are pretty great, yes, even the "My lifestyle determines my deathstyle", srry thrash fans. I really like the chorus and all, but the bridge is kinda underwhelming since it doesn't spin on the song, but it works. Really love this song. 3. Purify. I know people hate the guitar tone, drums, vocals and the chorus... but i love it! I love the main riff, i love the vocals and the verses, they are the most Nu Metal from the album... besides All Within My Hands. I also love the chorus, i know it sounds kinda ear-grating, but man... when you understand how raw the album is, you will tell why it is great. No, saying it is objectivally bad doesn't break my point. Also, i love the bridge riff and the lyrics, just such an underrated song. 4. The Unnamed Feeling. Is this the ballad of the album? Cause it feels so much like those Nu Metal ballads, being heavy and angry in a way. The lyrics are... not amazing, as well as the verses, but the pre-chorus and chorus are amazing. And the second chorus is longer and heavier... and so intense... and my gosh, the bridge is so fucking brutal and sad... what an amazing song. 5. Invisible Kid. Although the song is way too long... i really love the meaning of the song cause of how much i relate to it. The structure is kinda weird, but i love how the much the song progresses, James gets madder and louder until he yells "But It's All Too Much-yeaaah!" And i also love that soft chorus. I also really like the slow, heavy bridge, with how sad and ignorant it sounds with the lyrics. Such an amazing song. 6. Sweet Amber. That clean intro transitioning to the heavy and groovy riff, awesome. I love the vocals on everything, verses, chorus, pre-chorus, everything. And my gosh... that bridge riff... it is so amazing my gosh, and even better live. Such an amazing and intense song. 7. All Within My Hands. While this song is not perfect... my gosh is it the most Nu Metal song in the album, besides... most of the songs. The amazing riff, the catchy verses, the amazing chorus and the amazing "I will only let you breathe..." bridge. James' screams feel so raw and intense, while feeling weak and fragile... i love them. The song is not perfect 'cause of the lenght but it is still good, almost into my playlist. 8. Dirty Window. After many live presentations, i started to love this song. It is not in my playlist, but it is quite catchy and i really love the meaning of the lyrics. The riff is great, the lyrics as well, James' vocals are pretty good, the structure works so much... the only problem is the bridge with the weird "I" section, but that fits with the outro of the song, which is so rough and raw. Although in the studio album the snare sounds kinda annoying, i still like it. Good but not amazing. 9. Some Kind Of Monster. I used to say this song was meh... but after listening to the earlier songs, this song is pretty much better. I still dislike the long intro... but the main riff is still pretty good. The verses are kinda awkward but... they fit with the Nu Metal feeling of the album, and they are heavy af. The pre-chorus is awful, and the chorus is kinda underwhelming but it is oki. My favorite is the "Ominous. I'm in Us" section, it is so catchy and evil. But besides that, the song is way too long but it is decent. 10. My World. The riff is somewhat forgettable, since every time i think of this song is with the vocals... my gosh those vocals are so awful- at least for most of the song. My favorite part of this song is the... bridge? With "God it feels... like it only rains on me", and the Nu Metal screech of "I DON'T EVEN KNOW WHAT THE QUESTION IS", but besides that... this song is just decent hehe. 11. St. Anger. This song is just decent... like, the song itself doesn't start off bad... but then the second verse doesn't change a single word from the first one... then the second chorus as well... and it just gets repetitive. As well as the bridge just repeats the intro riff, and it doesn't exentuate it. I like the lyrics and vocals tho. Not bad at all, the chorus is great and the riff is rough... but it is kinda boring Also, they did play The Unnamed Feeling live, as well as Sweet Amber.
11. Shoot Me Again (never enjoyed this one) 10. Dirty Window 9. Some Kind of Monster 8. St. Anger 7. All Within my Hands 6. Invisible Kid 5. Purify 4. My World 3. Frantic 2. The Unnamed Feeling 1. Sweet Amber
11. Purify 1/10 (worst) 10. All within my hands 2/10 9. My world 2/10 8. Frantic 4/10 7. Shoot me again 5/10 6. Some kind of monster 5/10 5. St. Anger 7/10 4. The unnamed feeling 10/10 3. Sweet amber 10/10 2. Dirty window 10/10 1. Invisible kid 10/10
I have just now realized I misspelled Mike's YT name with "Night" instead of "Knight". Ain't that embarrassing... :,)
Nice ranking! Well here's mine(I'm not a native english speaker but nevermind):
#11 Invisible Kid: This song never gets me, I dunno it's kinda boring for me
#10 Dirty Window: The same as Invisible Kid, but I like the chorus
#9 My world: Nothing to say, the same as the last two
#8 Shoot me Again: The "shoot me again I ain't ded yet" part it's badass, the rest of the song It's ok I guess
#7 All Within my Hands: I really like the calm intro. I also think the "kill kill kill" section It's funny to sing and scream lmao
#6 St. Anger: I've never listened to this song too much, but the chorus hits me in the right way
#5 Purify: YOU AND I, PURIFY, YOU AND I, PURIFYyyYyyYYyah
The raw energy on this one gets me every single time. What a fun and energetic song
#4 Some Kind of Monster: Yeah, I think the same, It's too long, but I enjoy the chorus and the Rythm. I also love the main riff
#3 The Unnamed Feeling: The best lyrics on the album in my opinion, I connect with this one for that reason
The calm and the raw parts fits so well and I never get bored listening this one
#2 Frantic: That drum intro, gets me every time, like the first time I listened to this album. The chorus, specially the "Frantic-tic-tic" part makes me want to jump around
#1 Sweet Amber: The intro the energetic verse and the pre-chorus, they are cathing, the chorus It's so f#cking badass and the bridge works for me
I think this is the most "nu-metal" song on this album
Appreciate the in-depth comment my dude! 🤘
11. Invisible Kid
10. All Within My Hands
9. Dirty Window
8. Shoot Me Again
7. The Unnamed Feeling
6. My World
5. SKOM
4. Frantic
3. Sweet Amber
2. Purify
1. St. Anger
Kind of similar
I too put Purify last. Maybe without it there would be less bad moments that didtract from the passable ones.
10.- my world. More or less the same.
9. All within my hands. A shorter version would have been better.
8. Shoot me again. I also love the part that you showed!!.
7. Invisible kid. A little shorter would have been better but still passable. I love all the riffs here.
6. Some kind of monster. It seems very repetitive at this point but yes, the lenght is a problem. Still, i enjoy a lot the main riff and the chorus and the "ominous" part. Terrible ending, though; i mean that weird circus-esque thing.
5. Sweet amber. That main riff is great. I love it
4. Dirty window. Again, a great riff. Although the lyrics in this album have problems (this is not the best example of james' lyrics), I like the message of this one. It is great the song is being played in the tour.
3. St anger. This song is good, i agree with you, people compare it to their best work and it loses there, but on its own it is just good. I never get tired of this one.
2. Frantic. I am too in the "love it" team. This one is not that long and that helps a lot.
1. The unnamed feeling. I agree with you too here. This one I think is the best. I love that it really captures what it feels to go through those moments; I relate to the lyrics, unfortunately.
I think of the whole album that it is not the garbage some people say it is. It has flaws but it also has good moments. Maybe it is not suitable for listening to it in one sitting as a whole album but a song every now and then is enjoyable.
If this wasn't labeled as a 'Metallica' album, it would be looked at in a different light.
Here's my list:
1. All Within My Hands
2. Sweet Amber
3. Invisible Kid
4. Some Kind Of Monster
5. Invisible Kid
6. Shoot Me Again
7. The Unnamed Feeling
8. St. Anger
9. Frantic
10. Purify
11. Dirty Window
@@Raylan_1223 Interesting.
Bro was dead lmao 💀
Anyways, here’s mine:
11 - Purify
10 - All Within My Hands
9 - Shoot Me Again
8 - My World
7 - Some Kind Of Monster
6 - St. Anger
5 - Frantic
4 - Dirty Window
3 - Invisible Kid (grew on me a fuck ton, only 8/10 tho)
2 - The Unnamed Feeling
1 - Sweet Amber (still not a 10/10)
didn't think this day would come. can't wait for when you do death magnetic
anyways, here's my ranking:
#11 my world - forgettable minus the "not only do i not know the answer" part, which is why it's dead last for me;
#10 invisible kid - again, feel like the song is largely forgettable except the "what a good boy you are" part. funnily enough, unlike you, i actually enjoy it whenever i listen to invisible kid;
#9 purify - call me crazy, but i actually like the chorus xD. which is enough for me to put it above invisible kid and my world;
#8 shoot me again - the first song i've heard from this album and the first one i liked. the chorus is cool but i also like the "bite my tongue trying not to shoot back. no compromise, my heart won't pump the other way" part. there's also the "all the shots i take, what difference did i make?";
#7 some kind of monster - while i do admit the song's length is a bit problematic, i still enjoy it due to its riffs and james' vocal delivery of the chorus;
#6 sweet amber - enjoyable from start to finish. the chorus is particularly great;
#5 all within my hands - love james' vocal performance in this song. i find it funny that this song, of all of them from metallica's discography, was chosen for the name of their charity organization;
#4 the unnamed feeling - while this album doesn't sound as good as the rest, one thing's certain, james' voice is as good as before. you can particularly feel it in this song;
#3 frantic - frantic tic tic tic tic tic tock frantic tic tic tic tic tic tock frantic tic tic tic tic tic tock frantic tic tic tic tic tic tock
#2 st anger - nothing to add. what you've said in the video applies here;
#1 dirty window - headbanging from start to finish. particularly love james' laugh following the "i drink from the cup of denial" part
That laugh is awesome in a stupid way.😂
Yay! Finally, a new video. Happy late new year, also. 😂😂😂
Anyway, here's my ranking (I warn it won't exactly be very positive):
11) Purify 0/10
10) Shoot Me Again 1/10
9) All Within My Hands 1.5/10
8) Invisible Kid 2/10
7) My World 3/10
6) Some Kind Of Monster 3.5/10
5) Dirty Window 4/10
4) Sweet Amber 5/10
3) St Anger 6/10
2) Frantic 6.5/10
1) The Unnamed Feeling 7/10
Unnamed Feeling is a hidden gem.
You took 15 years to do this- jk. Here is my ranking anyway:
1. Shoot Me Again.
You may ask... why this? Many people say this song is cringe... but to me... this is literally one of my favorite songs from Metallica. The length is perfect, the intro is amazing, the main riff is heavy yet groovy, the vocals and verses are amazing, the refrain is catchy and groovy, the pre-chorus is progressively angrier, the chorus is just amazing by all means... even the bridge is amazing, both of them. And my gosh... that outro... it is so angry, so raw, so powerful, just... perfect. Could this song be better? Yeah... but this is not worse than all the other songs. My favorite song of the album IMO
2. Frantic.
Amazing intro, awesome riff, great vocals and a pretty good song structure, even if it sounds kinda... disjointed. A great opener for the album, even if St. Anger would work a little bit more. The lyrics are pretty great, yes, even the "My lifestyle determines my deathstyle", srry thrash fans. I really like the chorus and all, but the bridge is kinda underwhelming since it doesn't spin on the song, but it works. Really love this song.
3. Purify.
I know people hate the guitar tone, drums, vocals and the chorus... but i love it! I love the main riff, i love the vocals and the verses, they are the most Nu Metal from the album... besides All Within My Hands. I also love the chorus, i know it sounds kinda ear-grating, but man... when you understand how raw the album is, you will tell why it is great. No, saying it is objectivally bad doesn't break my point. Also, i love the bridge riff and the lyrics, just such an underrated song.
4. The Unnamed Feeling.
Is this the ballad of the album? Cause it feels so much like those Nu Metal ballads, being heavy and angry in a way. The lyrics are... not amazing, as well as the verses, but the pre-chorus and chorus are amazing. And the second chorus is longer and heavier... and so intense... and my gosh, the bridge is so fucking brutal and sad... what an amazing song.
5. Invisible Kid.
Although the song is way too long... i really love the meaning of the song cause of how much i relate to it. The structure is kinda weird, but i love how the much the song progresses, James gets madder and louder until he yells "But It's All Too Much-yeaaah!" And i also love that soft chorus. I also really like the slow, heavy bridge, with how sad and ignorant it sounds with the lyrics. Such an amazing song.
6. Sweet Amber.
That clean intro transitioning to the heavy and groovy riff, awesome. I love the vocals on everything, verses, chorus, pre-chorus, everything. And my gosh... that bridge riff... it is so amazing my gosh, and even better live. Such an amazing and intense song.
7. All Within My Hands.
While this song is not perfect... my gosh is it the most Nu Metal song in the album, besides... most of the songs. The amazing riff, the catchy verses, the amazing chorus and the amazing "I will only let you breathe..." bridge. James' screams feel so raw and intense, while feeling weak and fragile... i love them. The song is not perfect 'cause of the lenght but it is still good, almost into my playlist.
8. Dirty Window.
After many live presentations, i started to love this song. It is not in my playlist, but it is quite catchy and i really love the meaning of the lyrics. The riff is great, the lyrics as well, James' vocals are pretty good, the structure works so much... the only problem is the bridge with the weird "I" section, but that fits with the outro of the song, which is so rough and raw. Although in the studio album the snare sounds kinda annoying, i still like it. Good but not amazing.
9. Some Kind Of Monster.
I used to say this song was meh... but after listening to the earlier songs, this song is pretty much better. I still dislike the long intro... but the main riff is still pretty good. The verses are kinda awkward but... they fit with the Nu Metal feeling of the album, and they are heavy af. The pre-chorus is awful, and the chorus is kinda underwhelming but it is oki. My favorite is the "Ominous. I'm in Us" section, it is so catchy and evil. But besides that, the song is way too long but it is decent.
10. My World.
The riff is somewhat forgettable, since every time i think of this song is with the vocals... my gosh those vocals are so awful- at least for most of the song. My favorite part of this song is the... bridge? With "God it feels... like it only rains on me", and the Nu Metal screech of "I DON'T EVEN KNOW WHAT THE QUESTION IS", but besides that... this song is just decent hehe.
11. St. Anger.
This song is just decent... like, the song itself doesn't start off bad... but then the second verse doesn't change a single word from the first one... then the second chorus as well... and it just gets repetitive. As well as the bridge just repeats the intro riff, and it doesn't exentuate it. I like the lyrics and vocals tho. Not bad at all, the chorus is great and the riff is rough... but it is kinda boring
Also, they did play The Unnamed Feeling live, as well as Sweet Amber.
Respect the Shoot Me Again Placement. 🤘
@@victorthemusicman7243 Yep, i also kinda expected you to shit on Purify-.
Man after 69 years…❤
🤘
11. Shoot Me Again (never enjoyed this one)
10. Dirty Window
9. Some Kind of Monster
8. St. Anger
7. All Within my Hands
6. Invisible Kid
5. Purify
4. My World
3. Frantic
2. The Unnamed Feeling
1. Sweet Amber
🤘
11. Purify 1/10 (worst)
10. All within my hands 2/10
9. My world 2/10
8. Frantic 4/10
7. Shoot me again 5/10
6. Some kind of monster 5/10
5. St. Anger 7/10
4. The unnamed feeling 10/10
3. Sweet amber 10/10
2. Dirty window 10/10
1. Invisible kid 10/10
Huh... Pretty unique ranking, I gotta say. What is it about Sweet Amber for you?
@@victorthemusicman7243 I've re-listened to sweet amber, and I've changed my mind about this song a lot.
purify is a banger. fight me.
@@ferretinaginnel Square up, fool.
i'm not even kidding or anything, it's heavy, i love the verses and i dare say it's underrated
although it kind of sucks towards the end
Agree 100%.
🤘
More like great to amazing
Unpopular opinion, but I respect it.
From Decent? to Guilty Pleasure