The liveliest politics: Australia or UK? - BBC News
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 лис 2024
- The political system in Australia has several similarities with the UK model, featuring a PM with cabinet, plus red and green benches.
And in both countries proceedings can sometimes get a little heated, as these clips show some of the more famous feistier exchanges.
Please subscribe HERE bit.ly/1rbfUog
World In Pictures • World in pictures | BB...
Big Hitters • Playlist
Just Good News • Positive stories | BBC...
you left out all the best bits of australian politics. like that moment someone brought in a full size cardboard cutout of the prime minister
So tru tho
Someone did that in Canada too.
Stop being triggered
I would have liked to have seen that.
Lol cardboard kev
Malaysian Parliament:
"PHAK YOOO!!!!"
We malaysian do have the liveliest one no doubt
@@NashTheGreat I think that award goes to Jordan where they shoot AK-47s in their Parliament
@@benlonghurst7777 that is not lively, that is terrorism
Somebody said F you in the Irish parliament once. ua-cam.com/video/ugailEn8U5o/v-deo.html
He do speak English 😂
“May we say ‘God Save the Queen’ because nothing will save the Governor General.
That is one of my favorite political lines of all time
God Save the King
@@gytan2221 1975 mate.
The Governor General could be saved, but, whatever, it happened many moths ago.
Gough Whitlam, Australia's greatest PM who was removed by the Australian establishment in collusion with the CIA for asserting Australia's foreign policy independence and sovereignity.
"your a miserable pipsqueak of a man gove " priceless
trew news what is a man gove
No idea what that maens. Had me laughing for days. Feel sorry for these guys
Alexander Do Gove is the name of a major minister in the government. Michael Gove
Arcade it means penis
“Mad dog”
"dodgy David"😂😂😂😂 what an insult.
Done by the best MP around Dennis ‘beast of Bolsover’ Skinner.
@@georgemacpherson1992 Alexander Boris de Pfeffel Johnson is the best PM
I want to see a merging of UK and Australian parliaments, purely for entertainment purposes, as we all know nothing ever gets done anyways 😂
Oouuudaarr aawudaar
reality tv show potential
Same 😂
“stuff” just gets done, the interesting stuff usually just comes from prime ministers questions which happens literally once a week
CANZUK PARLIAMENT WHEN
There’s far better choices of instances that occurred in the Australian parliament than shown here, especially anything featuring former PM Paul Keating.
was just about to say that.
'Mate. Maaaate. I want to do you slowly. There's gotta be a bit of sport in it.'
Amen. PM Keating was a straight up parliament gangster.
The "I want to do you over slowly." Remark by Paul Keating came to mind.
This comment is just unrepresentative swill
The UK wins but only because the speaker in Australia has 94a and can tell anybody to leave at basically any time for saying something rude. Plus we must address the speaker and we can't say opinions, only facts and reasonable observations, which means, any insult is a 94a. Plus ours is just questions and answers.... which means British politics is more entertaining.
There is a reason that Speaker, Bronwyn Bishop, was sacked by her own party and permenantly expelled from parliament. She was an utter disgrace.
Nah. Australia wins because it has Australians. :)
@@JemClarke comparing UK and Aussie politics is like comparing Apple to Nokia 😂
@@ngdukic Ah yes the helicopter incident
Australia wins
Parliament House: "We have the craziest politicians!"
Westminster: "No! We do!"
Taiwanese Parliament: "Hold my legislation"
And flying chair
Indian parliament : That's amateur.
Malaysian Parliament: FAK U!
Malaysia : Fvck you
PH Congress: Pfft... peasants.
Should’ve had the famous Paul Keating line ‘I wanna do you slowly’ 😂😂😂😂 never gets old
"He's going troppo"
"Twelve years later he brings his miserable political carcass back to the front bench of the Australian Parliament, limping in like the Bishop of Autun - the Talleyrand of the Liberal party - scraping his way back into Australian history, seeking to put his miserable politics..."
Pual Keating calling John Howard "curly" never gets old! :)
yaa
Yeah, didn't work out when he lost an election that year in the biggest landslide of the decade.
Would love to see a UK vs Australia "roast" in parliament
I would pay to see this
I vote for PJ Keating on #TeamAustralia
We’ll never David Cameron to come back into politics
Noone got a chance against Keating
I don't know man...they're still classy even when angry, that's a hard skill to master right there..... :))
the brits maybe but definitely not us lmao
@@Catnippy Turnbull certainly had a twang of the Queen's English though.
Bruh the Aussie parliament is like having highschool kids at a debate
This isn't nearly as bad as South African parliament. There wasn't even a single punch thrown here
Is SA even a democracy?
@@presidentxijinpingspoxdoct9756 yeah why wouldn't it be?
@@kin-3877 ahhaa it’s not a democracy from an ex South African
@@spillintea683 people choosing to vote for the shitty party every time doesn't make it not a democracy.
Letting stupid people vote is one of the cornerstones of democracy
@@spillintea683 One of the ones who left the country after they allowed all adults to vote and never complained about it not being a democracy when it literally wasn't, by any yardstick, a democracy, by any chance?
"PUT ON YOUR TIE AND SING THE NATIONAL ANTHEM"!
well I remember that
I didnt get that. What was the context?
@@disneyplay4 not sure
It was about Comrade Corbyn.
Gotta look good for the country if you’re going to molest livestock…
@@archierch0463 critiquing Corbyns lack of patriotic pride and his ‘unparliamentary’ appearance
Paul Keating will forever be the undisputed king of Parliamentary debate and sledging. Just play his clips and you'll see a master at work
In a speech in the Australian federal parliament a politician representing a rural electorate referred to himself as a country member.
Someone on the opposition interjected "we remember".
It was the mighty, quick witted, Gough Whitlam!
In one sitting Winton Turnbull shouted: "I am a Country member". His opponent Gough Whitlam cut him off, saying "I remember".
Fantastic! Lol
@@Sydneysider1310 yes, that was Gough Whitlam.
I could just imagine if The Nationals still kept their former name - the Country Party today...
@@JoTheSnoop Whitlam's quip is even more relative for today's Nats LOL.
They're all c(o)unt-re-members imo ;)
Anybody from other countries just watch a bit of Australian Question Time. It's hilarious.
I'd love to get British parliament on one side, Australian on the other
'Westminster Ashes' you reckon? 🤣
I love parliaments : ) the fact that the people's representatives can confront the chief executive like that is awesome!
Presidential systems are pretty terrible.
Why wasn't Christopher Pyne dropping the c-bomb included in this montage?
Probably a bit _too_ extreme for the BBC
"I wanna do you slowly" was one of Keating's finest moments. Surprised it didn't make the cut
It's actually scary how similar Australia is to the UK😂
I wonder why.
Well Sir Australia Is independent nation from UK but system shares a monarchy with the United Kingdom and since we are members of Commonwealth and her majesty Queen Elizabeth II is head of our state so political system is 100% similar also that goes to the Canada New Zealand
But we are different than the US with accent haha
What you are seeing is called “question time”.
@@ZaiKerizm She might be your head of state, but most Australians could take or leave the queen without a second thought. We'll become a republic eventually
@@HingleMcCringleberryPSU
Perhaps you should try speaking for yourself in future instead of ‘most’ of you.
"We have Boris Johnson at home"
Boris Johnson at home: 0:20 to the left of Corbyn
Wow great observation
ORDER, ORDER, OOOOOOOO, ORDER.
Well to be very frank,nothing can beat the House of Commons show starring David Cameron and Jeremy Corbyn.
"mr speaker; give him a valium" LMFAO
and of course Bronwyn Bishop was labelled the "Worst Speaker Ever" as Comic Book Guy would say
yeah, she seemed terrible. We had her in Betty Boothroyd.
She was labelled the best
Throwback to when Anthony Albanese explained to the speaker that 10+10+5=25 and then called him an embarasment
The only fair and reasonable comparison is that between the Australian Parliament when Paul Keating was Prime Minister (or Treasurer) and the UK Parliament when Thatcher was PM.
What????
Paul Keating was Labor, thatcher was scum Tory which is our equivalent of the libs
This should have included Keating’s “I want to do you slowly”
Aussie! Aussie! Aussie!
Oi! Oi! Oi!
"Well it better be better than the first 2!"
*puts up 4 fingers*
"Mr speaker, give him a Valium!"
0:34 haha that dude always keeps it pg
For me,...in my opinion they belong to one family well and alive a parliamentary system od democracy UK, Australia Canada New Zealand and other Commonwealth Realms.
I missed Mr. Bercow... You know his way of silencing the house... Oodah... 😂
Who else missed Mr. Bercow?
UK Parliament & US Congress > Australian and Canadian Parliament, Israeli Knesset, French Assembly
You forgot the clip about the pm eating a onion or the clip where the pm was showing of the piece of coal he was hiding in his pocket
How can you miss "Mate, I want to do you slowly" reply by Mr Paul Keating !!
This missed all of Australia's classics... "I wanna do you slowly" is my all time fave
The last guy had me in tears LMAOOO.
This is one of the reasons why I love democracy. You're allowed to voice your opinion. In a communist or dictatorship system, everyone just bow their heads to their supreme leader.
Communism is when no opinion
Yes, the "freedom" to have your voice bounce off a brick wall is truly liberating.
Both shown are Parliamentary democracies, though. Have you seen the stupidity that is the Presidential "democracy" yet?
That's scary as I observe US politics. Pray for us, we live in fear for our democracy.
entertaining but also disappointing. I feel like us Aussies have lost a bit of our banter and self deprecating humour; we've become a bit too americanised for the worse. The Brits do parliamentary antics way better imo
As an aussie i always watch these for a laugh but love watching the motherland pollies as well. We all just love taking the piss. Miss paul keatings parliament antics.
It’s like they put 2 primary school classes together to do a debate but neither side knows what the heck they are arguing
A south Australian MP called Steele-Hall was known as Tin Shed and my favourite was the Queensland state minister of transport/infrastructure Russ Hinze a huge fat guy who was known as the Colossus of Roads…..
Both of them have the queen
The Queen is in no way involved in Australian politics. The most powerful person in Australian politics is our Governor General.
@@ngdukic True, but they are under the CON, so they are related quite closely
The same Queen!
@@ngdukic The governor general is the queens representative. So the most powerful person in Australian politics is... The Queen!
This did not include Paul Keating's best quip, "I wanna do you slowly." It made even his opposite number laugh.
You missed Keatings comment, " Mr speaker GIVE HIM A BALIUM, GIVE HIM A VALIUM!"
Britain 🇬🇧
I don’t know why but, I feel like every parliament always have the funniest argument even tho you didn’t understand a thing
0:19 my guy used the holy word in an argument! It's a double edged sword!
Australia and UK should merge so the parliaments can roast each other
That just might happen with #CANZUK!
I wish there were videos of sessions from the 1760s and 1770s around the Stamp Act and others leading up to the American Revolution.
Same
You missed the "im gonna do you slowly" from Keating
I am the Senate!
Malaysia
More...more....more.....(and Michael Heseltine swinging the mace!)
Loved how Keating tore into his opponents
Do you love how got belted by John Howard in 96 and never recovered? 😂
@@kaniel_outis1 Keating lost the election in 96 sure, but that was after 13 years of continuous Labor governments. It was inevitable there would be a change of government (ie Labor to the Coalition) at some point...
@@gloveyourway2000 Menzies stuck around for over 18 years and Hawke 8 years. Keating was not even able to last more than 3. Hawke carried him his whole career.
@@kaniel_outis1 Keating was in for 4 (according to Wiki). Though I’m not what your point is? Most PM’s who are voted out of office leave politics soon after. Furthermore Keating was the treasure for several years prior to becoming PM. Someone who isn’t performing wouldn’t have lasted that long…let alone retain the support of the party which allowed Keating to become the PM after his time as the Treasurer…
@@kaniel_outis1 Howard never beat Keating in question time. True he successfully suckered people into voting for him in 96, but he never had Keating’s measure in parliament. Or even came remotely close, come to think of it.
I guess "lively" is one way of saying "where democracy goes to die"
Australian...British... they are the same group of people so I SAY BOTH
Australia hasn't been a British colony for 117 years. Catch up.
I want to see a merging of UK and Australian parliament, purely for entertainment purposes, as we all know nothing ever gets done anyways 😂
Dennis Skinner is a legend of British Politics
i can’t believe John Bercow wasn’t included in this
Member of Australia’s country party ( a conservatives mob) “ I’m a country member!” … labor response “ we remember!”
Britain for this video
Where's Albo saying "Sit down, Boofhead" to the Treasurer.
the primary difference is that the australian house is angrier than the british house, which just sounds more jovial
“Ordaaaaaaaaa ordaaaaaaaaa mate”
"The Honourable member for [...] has the brains of a [donkey]!"
- speaker: you have to withdraw that
"The Honourable member for [...] does _not_ have the brains of a [donkey]."
Can't remember which country that was, I think it might have been Australia, or older in the UK.
South Africa puts both of these houses to shame
aussie politicians saying ‘hey madam speaker’ is the equivalent of a student saying ‘oi miss’
You didn't allow the last guy to finish.
0:43
Canada gets into it aswell
UK
Still can't hold a candle to the Brooks - Sumner Incident
UK parliament needs more light and bright colours to wake all the polles up.
This makes the 2020 debates look like the Gettysburg Address
you need a bit of Paul Keating in there
Ordah! Ordah!
English ruling party
Aussie in opposition in the same house would be a cracking sketch for a show!
Dodgy dave best one🤣
The Aussies just yell at each other all the time and so does their Speaker who constantly talks over the MP who is speaking.
BBC loves to apply a translucent film to any footage of Australia
This is why I liked parliamentary system.
South africa
These parliamentarians look extremely tame when compared to the Taiwanese lawmakers! 😂
Because CCP is much better!
Ah yes, the Commonwealth
Australian and proud
Also a monarchist
Long live the Queen (idk why we say this she's probably immortal)
Dennis Skinner🔥🔥🔥🔥
The Australian one should all be Paul Keating, that man was brutal
I preferred House of Lords, savage but still respectful at a time.
actually - Bulgaria
UK without a doubt. Oz copied the UK parliamentary system anyway so no contest.
taiwan
malaysia
australia
uk
us(presidential debate)
“YOU’RE A MISERABLE PIPSQUEAK OF A MAN!” Lmaoooooo
Indian parliament looks exactly like this even infrastructure and colour of houses.
I dunno about UK and Australia politics, but that's some dope rap battle
Thanks UA-cam algorithm, see you guys in another 3 years time👍
Malaysia: *Allow us to introduce ourselves*
I think the best moment was when president Bush address the Australian parliament and everybody laughed when he called John Howard a man of steel.
Reminds me of when Obama addressed the Australian parliament, and then opposition leader Abbott called him the 'Quiet American' when it came to US foreign policy; completely oblivious that the phrase was coined by Graham Greene to ironically call out covert US terrorism by the CIA in SE Asia.