The USA takes a purely capitalist, profit-centred view of education. China does not. China views education as a public good, not only for its own people but for the entire world.
More than that, _EVERYTHING_ in the West is considered a profit center and as such, thinks in the profitability in quarters, they _don't care_ about long term profitability, just what they can show their *shareholders* how they did this quarter, let the long term look after itself!
thanks to Deng XP who had the foresight to send students overseas to further their education. China was able to transitioned from low to mid, and then from mid-level to high tech is a result of that policy.
Wrong. Free market capitalism has been eliminated from the USA for almost 100 years now. The current decline in the United States is 100% due to the socialist/communist government interference in capitalism.
US universities have no choice. If they don't get overseas students, they will have financial problem. They are too many universities in US. Government has problem financing them all. So some are privately run without government sibsidies like Harvard, etc. I was told that 20% of overseas students fee is enough to cover the fees of local students.
Chinese universities should be as good if not better than overseas Universities, because china has all the infrastructure, facilities, and equipment to study, plus hiring professors from all over the world.
More importantly, the allocation of central government research support is more objective and less influenced by the corrupt system in the US which favors certain commercial areas, institutions,and ideologies. This is exemplified above all by the NIH and CDC whose senior administration flows interchangeably with Big Pharma. Never forget that the CDC has a major ownership stake in the patents underlying mRNA vaccines.
@@sciagurrato1831That's a bold lie that the CDC owns anything in the private corporate world. Prove your point and post references from reputable sources.
Not true. Despite this video'claim China's universities except for a handful don't produce many of the global best. Graduating from Peking University and a few others in Beijing is great but from others in China your diploma is fairly ordinary and not likely to get you a job by itself overseas. As for students from impoverished nations, I'm sure a Chinese university education is better than anything they could get at home.
@adolft_officialchinese has been adapting foreign ideologies since ancient times. Said Buddhism, china brought the thinking to china minus the india caste system Then the marxism adapted it to chinese culture then called it socialism with chinese characters 😅
@@MetaView7 The chinese election of their leaders is a superior system. All their leaders start from the bottom grassroot level (equivalent to community service), then you work your way up to county, to city, then to provincial level, and then national level through the process of the cream rising to the top. When you are at the national level, you should already have had the experience of governance, leadership and maturity to govern at the national level. Xi Jinping took 40 years to get to the top. There will never ever be a Donald trump in China who came out from the cold and went straight to the presidency without an iota of governance experience.
It is without a doubt that the tertiary education system is top class and doesn't need international rankings to confirm, as China is leading in most industries and also leading in innovations.... just look at the recent green/battery/EV sectors, 5/6G, chips, space, drones, phones, infrastructures, and the list goes on, the facts speak for itself! They don't need to talk about it, they just do it. Show me a country that comes close.
@@coliv2 There is now a “27” book series on what China invented that says we stole or copied from China But we have had a Eurocentric view of things these last few hundred years 👇 Why was China erased from Western memory The remarkable history of Chinese invention - Why was China erased from Western memory? Article by 龙信明 Introduction Joseph Needham was an English medical doctor and biologist, teaching in England in the 1930s. By an accident of fate he acquired some Chinese students, and was intrigued to hear their claims of so many medical and scientific discoveries having originated in China, rather than in the West. Needham became fully fluent in Chinese, and eventually moved to China in 1942 to investigate these claims and to research the entire history of Chinese invention. That work led to an astonishing voyage of historical discovery. Needham originally planned to write a book cataloguing Chinese inventions, but his first volume barely scratched the surface of his subject. He slowly gatherred many of his students into this enterprise, and they eventually wrote a collection of 26 books, to catalog the history of Chinese discovery. Myth and Misrepresentation It leaves one speechless to learn the vast extent of things invented by the Chinese many hundreds of years, and often several millennia, before they appeared in the West. MySingaporeBlogSpot
@@coliv2 China’s global lead extends to 37 out of 44 technologies that ASPI is now tracking, covering a range of crucial technology fields spanning defence, space, robotics, energy, the environment, biotechnology, artificial intelligence (AI), advanced materials and key quantum technology areas.1 The Critical Technology Tracker shows that, for some technologies, all of the world’s top 10 leading research institutions are based in China and are collectively generating nine times more high-impact research papers than the second-ranked country (most often the US). Notably, the Chinese Academy of Sciences ranks highly (and often first or second) across many of the 44 technologies included in the Critical Technology Tracker. We also see China’s efforts being bolstered through talent and knowledge import: one-fifth of its high-impact papers are being authored by researchers with postgraduate training in a Five-Eyes country.2 China’s lead is the product of deliberate design and long-term policy planning, as repeatedly outlined by Xi Jinping and his predecessors.3
This was an extremely interesting talk. From Chile alone, 20,000 students getting scholarships in Chinese universities. And it is happening all over Belt and Road countries. In the next 20 years, these countries will have very strong links to China in evey conceivable way, helping to integrate economies, industries, people. And in 5 years, China will have 5 universies in the top 10 in the world and 40 in the top 100.
Universities in China are not only very affordable, but also free from gun violence and drugs. No lGBTQ, No BLM, No sexual harassment etc. And those who study hard will not be considered as nerds, but respected.
Not so. Articles about students from Africa describe stings attached although they might be in the form of job opportunities no one else but the Chinese government might offer.
@@tonysu8860 so they offered 50,000 scholarships to african students and the strings attached to it is called a 'job offer'? that's a bad thing? really? is this an upside down world we live in or what or is it just in your head?
@@hz240 the old silk rd was 1000s of yrs old before Marco Polo "discovered" China using EXISTING maps. The west loves "made in China". China is "zhongguo" = center of the world😂
A lot of the high-ranked Western universities are actually in the main liberal arts institutions (Yale, Princeton, Oxford, Harvard... ) famous for producing lawyers and humanities graduates. When measured on a purely technical-engineering basis Chinese universities come out even higher in the rankings.
Those American universities are known for more than liberal arts. Most if not all have strong law schools which is nearly non-existent in all of China. Most have strong medical schools far advanced of anything that exists in China and the same is true for related sciences like biology. And MIT is regularly considered the leader or among others at the top in engineering and technology, far advanced ahead of anything seen in China. Those are just a few examples but it's why the US is so far ahead in knowledge and technology. China does a good job improving on ideas but is very backward in researching the basic and advanced sciences.
@@tonysu8860 You may say that but I know in the UK, that Imperial College is the top scientific-engineering-medical university but doesn't even appear in the global list. This means that the difference in ranking between Oxford-Cambridge and Imperial College is accounted for by their liberal arts curriculum and reputation. What this tells us is that these general global rankings do not inform us much about science-technology rankings. As to the US superiority in medical schools, that can be discounted by the number of Americans that actually have access to the best medical treatment. China's institutions are coming from not even appearing in the top 100 a decade ago. That they now feature in the top 10 is testimony to their improvement and closing the gap with Western institutions. In the main, these Chinese institutions are not advancing up the rankings based on a liberal arts curriculum, i.e. producing lawyers and humanities graduates. They are advancing up the rankings based on their excellence in scientific-technical education. These rankings are not a static unchanging table and the direction of travel for China's institutions points to matching and even superseding Western universities.
@@tonysu8860 you still believe that ! , if the US is far ahead Gina Raimondo , Blinken and Yelen wouldn't be issuing threats to China.....they are certainly not doing that to any other country in Asia, except may be North Korea...China is producing high class Engineers than any other countries in the world ,China leads the world in 37 out of 44 critical technologies....so again what are you talking about here ?
Actually many chinese universities should be many times in higher placings instead of now as the scaling and grading system is biased towards western and US universities.
They do but typical mainland Chinese especially from rural tend to think "land of freedom" have better and higher standard of education. They rather don't eat, wear worn clothes just to fund their kids abroad especially to America but they don't realize China University is better, stricter and syllabus is more to science + tech instead of "gender confusing/dorm s3x party/get laid" in America.
Kids from wealthy families, among whom many are academically doomed in China ‘s educational institutions would choose to skip college entrance exams and study in western countries. And things wouldn’t always turn out rosy for them when they swim back to the Chinese shore. Chances are they would once again be outsmarted by their locally educated peers. 😢
Very few foreigners can afford American Universities. The price just keeps going up and up and up. It's so far up now that they're practically in space. Even Americans are having a tough time trying to afford it unless you come from wealthy families. Or you can take out an mortgage for it.
the colleges have priced themselves out of students, even the homegrown ones. the tuition is so high, kids are already convincing themselves that college is not necessasry to be succesful. Thus nobody wants to be engineers, researchers, or study in the STEm fields, how can they when the tuition is out of their reach.
I don’t know it’s a good thing or bad thing for humanity. But US schools are not accepting Chinese STEM students. It has been largely the huge contribution from the brightest Chinese students to the US that maintains the high productivity and academic ranking. Look who is running Nvidia and AMD vs Intel. And look who was/is running the engineering team at Boeing then (during its golden ages) and Tesla now.
Another video I'll ask my son to watch! As he's been learning Mandarin since 6 years old, when we were living in Beijing.... Thanks a lot 🙏 for the many great videos I've watch since yesterday after discovering your channel. Be good 🤝
there are two types of Chinese students in the US. 1. Ivy league - Cream of the crop who wants to excel. 2. party- school, for those from well to do family who couldn't get into top or good university in China.
According to the *CWTS Leiden Ranking 2023,* most of the universities that produce the most scientifically impactful research are Chinese - that’s 16 out of the top 25 universities!
That's misleading. That evaluation would be true in application and implementation but ignores the fact that China typically isn't the original creator, discoverer or owner of that technology. For anything that's open source and publicly licensed, China can do whatever it can with that technology with few restrictions but for anything that's publicly licensed, China has problems.
@@tonysu8860 China is granted more patents than the USA and Japan combined! In 2021, China was granted 607,758 patents. USA, 286,205 patents. Japan, 256,890 patents. China is highly inventive and innovative.
Kevin, I've been binging a lot of your videos the past few days. Very impressed by the research and preparation you put into them, and the no nonsense presentation of facts along with easy to follow analysis. Bravo and keep it up. You should consider becoming a teacher.
And some 40% are STEM majors which are the necessary manpower ingredients to power the technology industrial revolution. You presented an excellent expose of China's rise in education and what that portends for the future of China and its relationship with other countries. Relationships matter in business and government so finding and building on these relationships from college years are important as much as education is. Today, China graduates twice as many university students as the US and that ratio is growing. The Chinese value education and families are willing sacrifice all their family wealth to see their kid(s) get the best education they can afford.
@@jggouvea i THOUGHT you were joking until i googled it. WOW unreal, the duimbest sh1t i ever seen! They might as well give Ph.D in watching and studying how birds take a sh1t while flying at the same time, a 4yr education is needed for this.
Lol one of the reasons why many Chinese working/living in the US are flying back home is because they fear the schools in America will cut off their children’s d*k…especially so for those IT workers in California😅
China is undergoing “fast and furious “ 30-40 years of nation building works by shifting her orientation to emphasie on science and maths curriculum in the universities. Most of China mayors are graduated with science and maths engineering but NOT business and management graduates. That’s making the difference, presumably
Wish I was 18 years old again. Instead of going to England where I suffered greatly living in substandard and very expensive accommodation and lousy food. I could go to China, have decent food and a nice apartment.
Because it’s far easier to get into a top university in USA. It’s like 10x harder to get into Tsinghua than Harvard. Too much competition to go university in China
The generational impact of Chinese university education is yet to be seen. Over the past couple hundred years, the majority of the world's leaders were educated in Western universities, especially Atlantic UK & US ones like Oxford, Harvard, Princeton, & Yale. They were conditioned and trained for Western democracy and capitalism. China is now educating the future leaders of the Global South where they can see the general prosperity of a market socialist economy under a meritocratic bureaucracy, and receive education in Communism with Chinese Characteristics so that they can implement it at home. In 20 years, the West will be in for a rude shock as the Global South takes back their economies.
管仲 Guan Zhong (720 - 645 BCE): “The best investment for one year is to grow grains; the best investment for ten years is to grow trees; the best investment for a lifetime is to educate people“ Chinese origine: 一年之計，莫如樹穀; 十年之計，莫如樹木； 終生之計，莫如樹人 . American universities treat their students as the milk cows. The longest term planing in the US is 2 years. Since in the 1st year of the president so preoccupied with blaming the previous regime. The 4th yr is the election campaigning year: mega talks but no meaningful action.
Chinese studies US universities now post a risk being accuse of SPY or being discriminated as well. Not to mention the living cost. Just isn't make sense for them to pursue higher education while their homeland provide same.
Affordability, quality and reliability. That’s what China offers to the world at large in every spectrum. In addition, China extends an open arm to the developing countries to share its success with them. Unlike the US empire, whose sole goal is to preserve its hegemonic power so as to continue to dominate the world, China’s vision of the world is vastly different and superior - a harmonious and peaceful world where everyone prospers and no single country dominates the rest. To understand and appreciate why China does things a certain way, one must first understand China’s vision and therefore its motivations. Kevin, I reject the notion that China is educating the brightest minds from other developing countries with an ulterior motive - the calculus that one day these China-educated intellectuals would favor China in some way. That’s exactly the mindset of colonialists and imperialists from the west - always calculating how to dominate others through manipulation. China genuinely believes in their higher vision of the world. It is lending a helping hand to countries that are hoping to travel the same path that China has. That’s the Confucius way - be humble and generous to others. That’s the only way to achieve harmony.
No surprise here: the concept of a moral, well-run society rooted in a professional class selected by meritocratic examination comes from China, which tied education, good governance and civil services 2,000 years ago. Prospective office-holders would spend years studying classic texts in math, poetry, history, etc., then take a written exam. The British adopted this system in the 1850s for their own civil service system, based on a proposal written by Trevelyan and Northcote, two officials who were familiar with this 'Mandarin' system.
The Chinese are playing Wei Qi, where each move lays the groundwork that is strategically important twenty moves later. The Americans are playing Tic Tac Toe where every move is either an immediate gain or loss.
Chinese universities have been underrated for so long. Cuz in the western ranking system, politics are always involved. For example, One of the scoring criteria would be: "democratic level" and takes 20 grades, and Chinese unis got 0 on this one, Ofc the rank has always been low. This is how most of the western ranking works.
China has overcapacity in their education which ruins American university business. We should put a tariff to American students who choose to study in China to make an even plain field for American universities to compete.
@@DragonYang01 No. That would be a terrible idea. People exchange/interaction is better for overcoming political vitriol. China should encourage Americans to visit and study in China and let Americans see for themselves that their rabid politicians have been gaslighting them.
@@BSnicksthat is true but first China is an emerging superpower and second Chinese respect all people, regardless of their origins, religions etc. the 5000 years Chinese civilization is very inclusive.
Another grim sign of the demise and accelerating downfall of the u$ imperial empire. Anyone on this post care to predict the future u$ socioeconomic outlook based on this trend? 📈 No crystal ball needed. The writing is definitely on the wall!
Imagine ... If the US would have invested the money for wars around the planet to offer high education and free university admission to foreigners over the last 40 years. I can't imagine where the US would be today but I can see the state of the affaire looking downtown SF, LA, ...
It's relatively easy to understand and agree with the domestic view of 'home grown' is better - for a variety of reasons - and why spend huge $$$ to fund such extravagance that does not help the home country? The same is true back here in the way we now run our universities - much of what is taught (for big $$) is basically worthless - from an educational point or as a 'network' value. Thanks for the message. With Yale accepting EDI, that says it all. Unlike most of the West, the Orient has always taken the 'long view' as it has been around for thousands of years with deep, unwavering ties to history, 'family' and cultural tradition. All in all, not a bad way to live and pass on life.
For Latin American students, all they need to do is to look at history and see what the Europeans has done to them for the past several centuries, they would turn to China in a heartbeat.
This reportage is absolute fact A massive number of international students from all over the world including from.the USA are converging to PRC universities in last 2 decades , fair cost , no student loans tied up on graduate s neck , quality improvement , etc.. Is the main driver for this influx .
most of the mathematics students who graduate and become professors in the american universities are all chinese and they are moving back to china and teaching there similar to india. most high tech jobs that cross through medical technology are all chinese engineers and are moving to china so to say chinese universities (back in the day) wasn't competitive is an understatement. most of the chinese students learn geometry and algebra in 5th grade and calculus in 7th grade, advanced calculus in 9th grade when they come to the universities in usa it's a breeze to them as they become teacher's assistant to teach other undergraduates, similar with india they do the same thing.
It simply just doesn't make sense to pay 10x more tuition fee to get similar quality of education. You can use that extra money as downpayment for house or as capital to start a business after graduate.
During the 60s in Africa, the Chinese donated schools, seaports, railways, roads, and hospitals to many African countries. Nonetheless, they found these African countries don't have qualified people to fill those jobs, such as teachers, heavy machine operators, train operators, electricians, doctors, and nurses. So, the Chinese need to educate them before the donation takes place in African countries. I think you get the idea of how the Chinese help the Africans, Latin Americans, and Asians to build their countries. They come to learn from the Chinese. When they graduate from Chinese universities, they can fill those jobs in their countries.
For a comparison, Undergraduate tution fee of George Mason University, in USA, in 2006: 900$ per course, per 5-month-semester $900 x4 courses x2 semester = 7200 US Dollars / year ! & that does not include the make up courses during summer vacation, if needed.
I didnt know about the scholarships to China but it makes perfect sense. When you have co-operation and collaboration underpinned by effective strategic planning thats got to deliver results. Whether the demands of the intense work ethic that runs in parallel to this is sustainable long term is another matter entirely.
As someone who, 30 years ago, went as an Asian student to Cambridge University on full scholarship inclusive of room & board, I can say that sheer appreciation for a top education given freely (albeit earned with a LOT of hard work) gives rise to an emotional bond between the student and the institution which lasts for decades and is hard to break.
Must give credit where credit is due. The Chinese university system has vastly improved and the Chinese outreach policies outlined here are very wise. The U.S. must rethink its outreach approach to South and Central America. The U.S must also increase focus on STEM and computer science at every level. I am teaching myself Spanish to add to my English and German. Thank you, Mr. Walmsley.
In Australia universities have become cash cows. They only run two twelve week semesters a year, permanent staff have been replaced by hourly paid students in many cases and courses are often just thrown together with low quality online content. Overseas students are charged like wounded bulls while the Vice-Chancellors all earn over a million dollars and never see their students. The annual student loan debt repayment is his higher than Australia collects each year from its natural resources taxes.
Its not just guanxi that is affecting their outcomes later in life.. Students go to the US, when the are unable to qualify for Chinese universities.This is the same in Singapore. The best are able to get into the local universities. With the exception of top rated US universities, the kids that go abroad are those who are unable to make it to local universities.
China's main objective is willing to invest in the long-term to build The Belt and Road Initiative (BRI or B&R). In order to improve their future, corporations must win with mutual respect. As humans, we all require a better life. The superior man makes the difficulty to be overcome his first interest; success only comes later.
The Anglo--Saxon universities in US, UK and Australia take overseas students to boost their income. Decisions (e.g. to admit) there are often taken on financial grounds. China is not taking on overseas students to make money. They don't have to. The top ones take overseas students if they are promising and can return to help their home countries. Often they can receive scholarships.
I remember in 2008 the ex CEO of the IMF telling US students at Harvard the money and middle class is moving east, looks like he was right, 97,000 chinese students were studying in the US at that time, brain drain, only 19,000 US students in China studing.
Most rich people stay rich by spending like the poor and investing without stopping then most poor people stay poor by spending like the rich yet not investing like the rich but impressing them
Even though digital currency has taken over the world, people still work for people. So, why not consider buying stocks and crypto and holding onto them?
That's a great point! With the rise of digital currency, investing in stocks and crypto can be a smart move. It's a way to potentially grow your wealth and secure your financial future.
I went to the top university in Australia, 28 yrs ago. I lol now, looking back. I now tell my son to aim for Chinese unis. Actually, even German ones. The anglophone ones r just profit centred, degree mills.
海歸 HaiGui isn't sea turtle, it's only the pronunciation which sounds the same. Hai is the short form of " 海外 Hai Wai" which means " oversea or abroad" . Gui is the short form of " 歸來Gui Lai“ which means "come back". So Hai Gui isn't Sea Turtle, it actually means 海外歸來 Hai Wai Gui Lai ， which means those who " Came back from abroad or foreign countries " or shoart form as " Hai Gui 海歸.“
The USA takes a purely capitalist, profit-centred view of education. China does not. China views education as a public good, not only for its own people but for the entire world.
But as well, China is smart enough to know that all of these economies will be intricately linked to theirs.
More than that, _EVERYTHING_ in the West is considered a profit center and as such, thinks in the profitability in quarters, they _don't care_ about long term profitability, just what they can show their *shareholders* how they did this quarter, let the long term look after itself!
thanks to Deng XP who had the foresight to send students overseas to further their education. China was able to transitioned from low to mid, and then from mid-level to high tech is a result of that policy.
Wrong. Free market capitalism has been eliminated from the USA for almost 100 years now. The current decline in the United States is 100% due to the socialist/communist government interference in capitalism.
US universities have no choice. If they don't get overseas students, they will have financial problem. They are too many universities in US. Government has problem financing them all. So some are privately run without government sibsidies like Harvard, etc. I was told that 20% of overseas students fee is enough to cover the fees of local students.
An internship with Kevin is worth more than a Harvard business degree.
Chinese universities should be as good if not better than overseas Universities, because china has all the infrastructure, facilities, and equipment to study, plus hiring professors from all over the world.
Attracting the best thinkers from the rest of the world
You forgot the biggest benefit: Chinese universities are not pushing a woke agenda.
More importantly, the allocation of central government research support is more objective and less influenced by the corrupt system in the US which favors certain commercial areas, institutions,and ideologies. This is exemplified above all by the NIH and CDC whose senior administration flows interchangeably with Big Pharma.
Never forget that the CDC has a major ownership stake in the patents underlying mRNA vaccines.
@@sciagurrato1831That's a bold lie that the CDC owns anything in the private corporate world. Prove your point and post references from reputable sources.
Not true. Despite this video'claim China's universities except for a handful don't produce many of the global best. Graduating from Peking University and a few others in Beijing is great but from others in China your diploma is fairly ordinary and not likely to get you a job by itself overseas.
As for students from impoverished nations, I'm sure a Chinese university education is better than anything they could get at home.
Absolutely Fascinating! Keep going China! TEAM CHINA NOW AND FOREVER ALL THE WAY!👍🙂
The strategic thinking of the Chinese never cease to amaze. They really think long term and are not afraid of taking a short term hit.
Many people are waking up to the shortcomings of a 4-year election cycle, but we are not wise enough, or upset enough to change it.
@adolft_officialthey never set up colonies and build 400 military bases around the globe. stfu and talk some sense
@adolft_officialchinese has been adapting foreign ideologies since ancient times.
Said Buddhism, china brought the thinking to china minus the india caste system
Then the marxism adapted it to chinese culture then called it socialism with chinese characters 😅
@@MetaView7hahahaha... Remind me of ARGENTINA 😂 the recent clown show from Argentina is more entertaining than comedy show.
@@MetaView7 The chinese election of their leaders is a superior system. All their leaders start from the bottom grassroot level (equivalent to community service), then you work your way up to county, to city, then to provincial level, and then national level through the process of the cream rising to the top. When you are at the national level, you should already have had the experience of governance, leadership and maturity to govern at the national level. Xi Jinping took 40 years to get to the top. There will never ever be a Donald trump in China who came out from the cold and went straight to the presidency without an iota of governance experience.
Bless China, a pillar and beacon of peace and harmony. May she grow in strength. 27 April 2024.
It is without a doubt that the tertiary education system is top class and doesn't need international rankings to confirm, as China is leading in most industries and also leading in innovations.... just look at the recent green/battery/EV sectors, 5/6G, chips, space, drones, phones, infrastructures, and the list goes on, the facts speak for itself! They don't need to talk about it, they just do it. Show me a country that comes close.
According to recent German reporting it was all stolen from Germany by Chinese spies 😂😂😂
@@coliv2
There is now a “27” book series on what China invented that says we stole or copied from China
But we have had a Eurocentric view of things these last few hundred years
👇
Why was China erased from Western memory
The remarkable history of Chinese invention - Why was China erased from Western memory?
Article by 龙信明
Introduction
Joseph Needham was an English medical doctor and biologist, teaching in England in the 1930s. By an accident of fate he acquired some Chinese students, and was intrigued to hear their claims of so many medical and scientific discoveries having originated in China, rather than in the West.
Needham became fully fluent in Chinese, and eventually moved to China in 1942 to investigate these claims and to research the entire history of Chinese invention. That work led to an astonishing voyage of historical discovery.
Needham originally planned to write a book cataloguing Chinese inventions, but his first volume barely scratched the surface of his subject. He slowly gatherred many of his students into this enterprise, and they eventually wrote a collection of 26 books, to catalog the history of Chinese discovery.
Myth and Misrepresentation
It leaves one speechless to learn the vast extent of things invented by the Chinese many hundreds of years, and often several millennia, before they appeared in the West.
MySingaporeBlogSpot
Great comment.
The results speak for themselves.
@@coliv2 China’s global lead extends to 37 out of 44 technologies that ASPI is now tracking, covering a range of crucial technology fields spanning defence, space, robotics, energy, the environment, biotechnology, artificial intelligence (AI), advanced materials and key quantum technology areas.1 The Critical Technology Tracker shows that, for some technologies, all of the world’s top 10 leading research institutions are based in China and are collectively generating nine times more high-impact research papers than the second-ranked country (most often the US). Notably, the Chinese Academy of Sciences ranks highly (and often first or second) across many of the 44 technologies included in the Critical Technology Tracker. We also see China’s efforts being bolstered through talent and knowledge import: one-fifth of its high-impact papers are being authored by researchers with postgraduate training in a Five-Eyes country.2 China’s lead is the product of deliberate design and long-term policy planning, as repeatedly outlined by Xi Jinping and his predecessors.3
Just look into the classrooms of chinese students from primary to high school and one can see that the Chinese education standard has risen sooo much.
This was an extremely interesting talk. From Chile alone, 20,000 students getting scholarships in Chinese universities. And it is happening all over Belt and Road countries.
In the next 20 years, these countries will have very strong links to China in evey conceivable way, helping to integrate economies, industries, people.
And in 5 years, China will have 5 universies in the top 10 in the world and 40 in the top 100.
Exactly! When the leaders of the Global South learn how to do anti-imperialism by emulating China, the West is going to have a very tough time.
Universities in China are not only very affordable, but also free from gun violence and drugs. No lGBTQ, No BLM, No sexual harassment etc.
And those who study hard will not be considered as nerds, but respected.
Good topic ! Chinese they believe in ‘good will’ without being ‘transactional’, ‘no strings attached’.
Not so. Articles about students from Africa describe stings attached although they might be in the form of job opportunities no one else but the Chinese government might offer.
@@tonysu8860your point?
@@tonysu8860 so they offered 50,000 scholarships to african students and the strings attached to it is called a 'job offer'? that's a bad thing? really? is this an upside down world we live in or what or is it just in your head?
False. China always attached. If you can not Pay loans at higher rate, China takes you down and takes over at your country.
@@tonysu8860 what’s wrong in that. At least they are offering something instead of promises and wars.
All roads and rail and plane and ship leadings to China.
Damn right!
The old silk road and now the new silk rd aka BRI
all the politicians heading to China Macron, Scholz, Maloni, Yellen . . .
All roads lead to ch1na period (includes the cosmos too)!! Well put.
@@hz240 the old silk rd was 1000s of yrs old before Marco Polo "discovered" China using EXISTING maps. The west loves "made in China". China is "zhongguo" = center of the world😂
A lot of the high-ranked Western universities are actually in the main liberal arts institutions (Yale, Princeton, Oxford, Harvard... ) famous for producing lawyers and humanities graduates. When measured on a purely technical-engineering basis Chinese universities come out even higher in the rankings.
Agree,the Engineering in China is superb and very demanding courses.
Those American universities are known for more than liberal arts.
Most if not all have strong law schools which is nearly non-existent in all of China.
Most have strong medical schools far advanced of anything that exists in China and the same is true for related sciences like biology.
And MIT is regularly considered the leader or among others at the top in engineering and technology, far advanced ahead of anything seen in China.
Those are just a few examples but it's why the US is so far ahead in knowledge and technology. China does a good job improving on ideas but is very backward in researching the basic and advanced sciences.
@@tonysu8860 You may say that but I know in the UK, that Imperial College is the top scientific-engineering-medical university but doesn't even appear in the global list.
This means that the difference in ranking between Oxford-Cambridge and Imperial College is accounted for by their liberal arts curriculum and reputation.
What this tells us is that these general global rankings do not inform us much about science-technology rankings.
As to the US superiority in medical schools, that can be discounted by the number of Americans that actually have access to the best medical treatment.
China's institutions are coming from not even appearing in the top 100 a decade ago. That they now feature in the top 10 is testimony to their improvement and closing the gap with Western institutions. In the main, these Chinese institutions are not advancing up the rankings based on a liberal arts curriculum, i.e. producing lawyers and humanities graduates. They are advancing up the rankings based on their excellence in scientific-technical education.
These rankings are not a static unchanging table and the direction of travel for China's institutions points to matching and even superseding Western universities.
Not true, they also produces top notch scientists. Check their novel winners.
@@tonysu8860 you still believe that ! , if the US is far ahead Gina Raimondo , Blinken and Yelen wouldn't be issuing threats to China.....they are certainly not doing that to any other country in Asia, except may be North Korea...China is producing high class Engineers than any other countries in the world ,China leads the world in 37 out of 44 critical technologies....so again what are you talking about here ?
Considering how hard the Chinese students work no wonder the Universities are leaping ahead. Guanxi is vital no matter where.
Actually many chinese universities should be many times in higher placings instead of now as the scaling and grading system is biased towards western and US universities.
ya
They do but typical mainland Chinese especially from rural tend to think "land of freedom" have better and higher standard of education. They rather don't eat, wear worn clothes just to fund their kids abroad especially to America but they don't realize China University is better, stricter and syllabus is more to science + tech instead of "gender confusing/dorm s3x party/get laid" in America.
Kids from wealthy families, among whom many are academically doomed in China ‘s educational institutions would choose to skip college entrance exams and study in western countries. And things wouldn’t always turn out rosy for them when they swim back to the Chinese shore. Chances are they would once again be outsmarted by their locally educated peers. 😢
100% agree with you on this comment!
Not necessarily, they have couch jobs waiting for them or a family fortunate to inherit.
So true
This helps in selecting talents, as children from affluent families may not necessarily be smart
Fantastic analysis glad I Discovered this channel keep up the great work😊😊
Very few foreigners can afford American Universities. The price just keeps going up and up and up. It's so far up now that they're practically in space. Even Americans are having a tough time trying to afford it unless you come from wealthy families. Or you can take out an mortgage for it.
the colleges have priced themselves out of students, even the homegrown ones. the tuition is so high, kids are already convincing themselves that college is not necessasry to be succesful. Thus nobody wants to be engineers, researchers, or study in the STEm fields, how can they when the tuition is out of their reach.
I don’t know it’s a good thing or bad thing for humanity. But US schools are not accepting Chinese STEM students.
It has been largely the huge contribution from the brightest Chinese students to the US that maintains the high productivity and academic ranking.
Look who is running Nvidia and AMD vs Intel. And look who was/is running the engineering team at Boeing then (during its golden ages) and Tesla now.
Another video I'll ask my son to watch! As he's been learning Mandarin since 6 years old, when we were living in Beijing....
Thanks a lot 🙏 for the many great videos I've watch since yesterday after discovering your channel.
Be good 🤝
Isn't it similar in Africa?
China educating Students for whatever is needed in any particular Country.
China is a blessing and benefactor to the world 👍♥️🇨🇳
there are two types of Chinese students in the US. 1. Ivy league - Cream of the crop who wants to excel. 2. party- school, for those from well to do family who couldn't get into top or good university in China.
According to the *CWTS Leiden Ranking 2023,* most of the universities that produce the most scientifically impactful research are Chinese - that’s 16 out of the top 25 universities!
That's misleading. That evaluation would be true in application and implementation but ignores the fact that China typically isn't the original creator, discoverer or owner of that technology. For anything that's open source and publicly licensed, China can do whatever it can with that technology with few restrictions but for anything that's publicly licensed, China has problems.
@@tonysu8860 China is granted more patents than the USA and Japan combined! In 2021, China was granted 607,758 patents. USA, 286,205 patents. Japan, 256,890 patents.
China is highly inventive and innovative.
Awesome, Good day, be good.
China is investing in people for a prosperous future for China and around the world.
Kevin, I've been binging a lot of your videos the past few days. Very impressed by the research and preparation you put into them, and the no nonsense presentation of facts along with easy to follow analysis. Bravo and keep it up. You should consider becoming a teacher.
Thank you for a most insightful video.
All top twenty five mathematics and computer science universities are in China according to the CWTS Leiden University Ranking 2023.
Informative, thank you for sharing, this a way to our world a better place
And some 40% are STEM majors which are the necessary manpower ingredients to power the technology industrial revolution. You presented an excellent expose of China's rise in education and what that portends for the future of China and its relationship with other countries. Relationships matter in business and government so finding and building on these relationships from college years are important as much as education is. Today, China graduates twice as many university students as the US and that ratio is growing. The Chinese value education and families are willing sacrifice all their family wealth to see their kid(s) get the best education they can afford.
I noticed this just yesterday when I was looking through the world university rankings, there are a lot of Chinese universities on there now.
So Chinese students are missing out on US WOKE culture & LGBTQ++ if they choose US universities 🤣🤣🤣
I pity them. Where else could then get gender studies PhD? Or is it PTSD?
@@jggouvea i THOUGHT you were joking until i googled it. WOW unreal, the duimbest sh1t i ever seen! They might as well give Ph.D in watching and studying how birds take a sh1t while flying at the same time, a 4yr education is needed for this.
Gender study is another useless degree.
@@kaleeysmith8801 Wait, I WAS JOKING. Don't tell me that "Gender studies PhD" exists! Please, I want to remain ignorant.
Lol one of the reasons why many Chinese working/living in the US are flying back home is because they fear the schools in America will cut off their children’s d*k…especially so for those IT workers in California😅
Students from the US also have a hard time justifying the cost of college in the US.
Priority for education is part of Chinese culture since 1000s of years ago.
If you go to a US university you will have 6 figures in student debt (unless you have rich parents). Or go to China and have no debt.
Nice plan, just be careful you might get accused by the US government as a spy for the chinese.
Fundamental factor which We always tend to overlook. American High school / Elementary school is in shambles.
So the notion that higher tuition fee does not automatically translate to quality education is true.
China and Russia both play the long game. Both offer scholarships to Asian, African and South American countries.
Thank you for the information Kevin 😃👍
China is undergoing “fast and furious “ 30-40 years of nation building works by shifting her orientation to emphasie on science and maths curriculum in the universities. Most of China mayors are graduated with science and maths engineering but NOT business and management graduates. That’s making the difference, presumably
Wish I was 18 years old again. Instead of going to England where I suffered greatly living in substandard and very expensive accommodation and lousy food. I could go to China, have decent food and a nice apartment.
the table is turning...
Mr. Kevin is someone who understands China in depth
US politicians say, don't worry, we produce the best and most lawyers anyway 😂
About half of US government politicians in Senate & Congress are lawyers.
Why any Chinese parents would send their kids to the US for an education is difficult to understand given the fall of Western universities.
Benar sekali. Berangkat hanya tau 2 gender, pulangnya bawa ratusan gender Yang membingungkan...
Those who failed to enter Chinese top universities have no choice but to go abroad.
Because it’s far easier to get into a top university in USA. It’s like 10x harder to get into Tsinghua than Harvard. Too much competition to go university in China
Cause they are not competitive in China period.
@@hanmi1216 Chinese best two uni accept 8k students every year, and there are more than 10 million students every year attend college entrance exam.
The generational impact of Chinese university education is yet to be seen. Over the past couple hundred years, the majority of the world's leaders were educated in Western universities, especially Atlantic UK & US ones like Oxford, Harvard, Princeton, & Yale. They were conditioned and trained for Western democracy and capitalism. China is now educating the future leaders of the Global South where they can see the general prosperity of a market socialist economy under a meritocratic bureaucracy, and receive education in Communism with Chinese Characteristics so that they can implement it at home. In 20 years, the West will be in for a rude shock as the Global South takes back their economies.
Man I love your outlook into China's future 💪🙏🙏
管仲 Guan Zhong (720 - 645 BCE):
“The best investment for one year is to grow grains;
the best investment for ten years is to grow trees;
the best investment for a lifetime is to educate people“
Chinese origine:
一年之計，莫如樹穀;
十年之計，莫如樹木；
終生之計，莫如樹人 .
American universities treat their students as the milk cows.
The longest term planing in the US is 2 years. Since in the 1st year of the president so preoccupied with blaming the previous regime. The 4th yr is the election campaigning year: mega talks but no meaningful action.
奇貨可居也😂
Chinese studies US universities now post a risk being accuse of SPY or being discriminated as well. Not to mention the living cost. Just isn't make sense for them to pursue higher education while their homeland provide same.
Affordability, quality and reliability. That’s what China offers to the world at large in every spectrum. In addition, China extends an open arm to the developing countries to share its success with them.
Unlike the US empire, whose sole goal is to preserve its hegemonic power so as to continue to dominate the world, China’s vision of the world is vastly different and superior - a harmonious and peaceful world where everyone prospers and no single country dominates the rest.
To understand and appreciate why China does things a certain way, one must first understand China’s vision and therefore its motivations.
Kevin, I reject the notion that China is educating the brightest minds from other developing countries with an ulterior motive - the calculus that one day these China-educated intellectuals would favor China in some way. That’s exactly the mindset of colonialists and imperialists from the west - always calculating how to dominate others through manipulation.
China genuinely believes in their higher vision of the world. It is lending a helping hand to countries that are hoping to travel the same path that China has. That’s the Confucius way - be humble and generous to others. That’s the only way to achieve harmony.
No surprise here: the concept of a moral, well-run society rooted in a professional class selected by meritocratic examination comes from China, which tied education, good governance and civil services 2,000 years ago. Prospective office-holders would spend years studying classic texts in math, poetry, history, etc., then take a written exam. The British adopted this system in the 1850s for their own civil service system, based on a proposal written by Trevelyan and Northcote, two officials who were familiar with this 'Mandarin' system.
you are so right! the us' education prestige and diploma losses value: incompatible with local labor market
The Chinese are playing Wei Qi, where each move lays the groundwork that is strategically important twenty moves later. The Americans are playing Tic Tac Toe where every move is either an immediate gain or loss.
WeiQi = Go
❤❤Kevin, sounds like the cracks in our system is beginning to show😳⁉️
This is your best video yet. You summed it up.
Uni rankings are also bias towards western universities as well. Chinese universities actually rank a lot higher.
Chinese universities have been underrated for so long. Cuz in the western ranking system, politics are always involved. For example, One of the scoring criteria would be: "democratic level" and takes 20 grades, and Chinese unis got 0 on this one, Ofc the rank has always been low. This is how most of the western ranking works.
You just can’t accept that they are better. Pathetic tribalism
Wow, I was just wondering why you were so wise, Kevin. I didn’t realize that you’re in academia, in Singhua of all places. Happy for you.
BACK ON TOP!!
The US/EU should launch a unfair pricing investigation onto Chinese higher education. /s
Shhhhh... don't tell them please, please, please!
China has overcapacity in their education which ruins American university business. We should put a tariff to American students who choose to study in China to make an even plain field for American universities to compete.
@@DragonYang01 No. That would be a terrible idea. People exchange/interaction is better for overcoming political vitriol. China should encourage Americans to visit and study in China and let Americans see for themselves that their rabid politicians have been gaslighting them.
Many EU countries have free education.
@@BSnicksthat is true but first China is an emerging superpower and second Chinese respect all people, regardless of their origins, religions etc. the 5000 years Chinese civilization is very inclusive.
Not everything has to revolve around profit, especially education.
Another grim sign of the demise and accelerating downfall of the u$ imperial empire.
Anyone on this post care to predict the future u$ socioeconomic outlook based on this trend? 📈 No crystal ball needed.
The writing is definitely on the wall!
There is a chinese saying....if small money don't go out big money won't come in.
Breaking news! Jenet Yellen is coming to China to complain about the over supply of quality education at an affordable cost.
Thanks for sharing
Most informative. Thanks a lot.
Imagine ... If the US would have invested the money for wars around the planet to offer high education and free university admission to foreigners over the last 40 years. I can't imagine where the US would be today but I can see the state of the affaire looking downtown SF, LA, ...
China Universities are SIMPLY THE BEST! ❤❤❤ 👏👏👏
It's relatively easy to understand and agree with the domestic view of 'home grown' is better - for a variety of reasons - and why spend huge $$$ to fund such extravagance that does not help the home country? The same is true back here in the way we now run our universities - much of what is taught (for big $$) is basically worthless - from an educational point or as a 'network' value. Thanks for the message. With Yale accepting EDI, that says it all. Unlike most of the West, the Orient has always taken the 'long view' as it has been around for thousands of years with deep, unwavering ties to history, 'family' and cultural tradition. All in all, not a bad way to live and pass on life.
For Latin American students, all they need to do is to look at history and see what the Europeans has done to them for the past several centuries, they would turn to China in a heartbeat.
Such honest passion and eloquence in your videos. This channel deserves a lot more audience.
This reportage is absolute fact
A massive number of international students from all over the world including from.the USA are converging to PRC universities in last 2 decades , fair cost , no student loans tied up on graduate s neck , quality improvement , etc..
Is the main driver for this influx .
most of the mathematics students who graduate and become professors in the american universities are all chinese and they are moving back to china and teaching there similar to india. most high tech jobs that cross through medical technology are all chinese engineers and are moving to china so to say chinese universities (back in the day) wasn't competitive is an understatement. most of the chinese students learn geometry and algebra in 5th grade and calculus in 7th grade, advanced calculus in 9th grade when they come to the universities in usa it's a breeze to them as they become teacher's assistant to teach other undergraduates, similar with india they do the same thing.
It simply just doesn't make sense to pay 10x more tuition fee to get similar quality of education. You can use that extra money as downpayment for house or as capital to start a business after graduate.
The more educated people you have, the world would be a better place.
During the 60s in Africa, the Chinese donated schools, seaports, railways, roads, and hospitals to many African countries. Nonetheless, they found these African countries don't have qualified people to fill those jobs, such as teachers, heavy machine operators, train operators, electricians, doctors, and nurses. So, the Chinese need to educate them before the donation takes place in African countries. I think you get the idea of how the Chinese help the Africans, Latin Americans, and Asians to build their countries. They come to learn from the Chinese. When they graduate from Chinese universities, they can fill those jobs in their countries.
For a comparison, Undergraduate tution fee of George Mason University, in USA, in 2006:
900$ per course, per 5-month-semester
$900 x4 courses x2 semester = 7200 US Dollars / year !
& that does not include the make up courses during summer vacation, if needed.
I didnt know about the scholarships to China but it makes perfect sense. When you have co-operation and collaboration underpinned by effective strategic planning thats got to deliver results. Whether the demands of the intense work ethic that runs in parallel to this is sustainable long term is another matter entirely.
Really enjoy your reports.Keep them up
As someone who, 30 years ago, went as an Asian student to Cambridge University on full scholarship inclusive of room & board, I can say that sheer appreciation for a top education given freely (albeit earned with a LOT of hard work) gives rise to an emotional bond between the student and the institution which lasts for decades and is hard to break.
Very soon American universities will have overpriced themselves. American students will go to EU and UK for universities where fees are halve.
Must give credit where credit is due. The Chinese university system has vastly improved and the Chinese outreach policies outlined here are very wise. The U.S. must rethink its outreach approach to South and Central America. The U.S must also increase focus on STEM and computer science at every level. I am teaching myself Spanish to add to my English and German. Thank you, Mr. Walmsley.
In Australia universities have become cash cows. They only run two twelve week semesters a year, permanent staff have been replaced by hourly paid students in many cases and courses are often just thrown together with low quality online content. Overseas students are charged like wounded bulls while the Vice-Chancellors all earn over a million dollars and never see their students. The annual student loan debt repayment is his higher than Australia collects each year from its natural resources taxes.
Its not just guanxi that is affecting their outcomes later in life.. Students go to the US, when the are unable to qualify for Chinese universities.This is the same in Singapore. The best are able to get into the local universities. With the exception of top rated US universities, the kids that go abroad are those who are unable to make it to local universities.
China's main objective is willing to invest in the long-term to build The Belt and Road Initiative (BRI or B&R). In order to improve their future, corporations must win with mutual respect. As humans, we all require a better life.
The superior man makes the difficulty to be overcome his first interest; success only comes later.
The Anglo--Saxon universities in US, UK and Australia take overseas students to boost their income. Decisions (e.g. to admit) there are often taken on financial grounds. China is not taking on overseas students to make money. They don't have to. The top ones take overseas students if they are promising and can return to help their home countries. Often they can receive scholarships.
The colleague in China is so affordable despite Chinese don’t much taxes compared to the U.S. US college used to be very affordable, what gives?
US education system from k-12 through grad school is broken. We can't afford to send our daughter to the same schools we went to. WTF.
I remember in 2008 the ex CEO of the IMF telling US students at Harvard the money and middle class is moving east, looks like he was right, 97,000 chinese students were studying in the US at that time, brain drain, only 19,000 US students in China studing.
It is a page out of Singapore's education system.
China has a far vision., Well.done to Chinese government ❤ its a win win strategy on long term investment 🎉
Most rich people stay rich by spending like the poor and investing without stopping then most poor people stay poor by spending like the rich yet not investing like the rich but impressing them
People prefer to spend money on liabilities, Rather than investing in assets and be very profitable
You are so correct! Save, invest and spend for necessities and a few small luxuries relatives to one's total assets ratio.
Making a living is becoming more challenging, and it's difficult for me to save enough to enjoy quality time with my loved ones.
Even though digital currency has taken over the world, people still work for people. So, why not consider buying stocks and crypto and holding onto them?
That's a great point! With the rise of digital currency, investing in stocks and crypto can be a smart move. It's a way to potentially grow your wealth and secure your financial future.
yutuber ben norton is getting his phd in chinese university now
I went to the top university in Australia, 28 yrs ago. I lol now, looking back.
I now tell my son to aim for Chinese unis. Actually, even German ones. The anglophone ones r just profit centred, degree mills.
Kevin, you should be running for US Presidency.
Student loans in the United States actually carry high interest rates. I was surprised when I heard this news.
海歸 HaiGui isn't sea turtle, it's only the pronunciation which sounds the same. Hai is the short form of " 海外 Hai Wai" which means " oversea or abroad" . Gui is the short form of " 歸來Gui Lai“ which means "come back". So Hai Gui isn't Sea Turtle, it actually means 海外歸來 Hai Wai Gui Lai ， which means those who " Came back from abroad or foreign countries " or shoart form as " Hai Gui 海歸.“
I still prefer "sea turtle"😂
I thought sea turtle was brilliant.
That's the problem, using abbrev., double down with phonetics, then you have lengthy explanation to make.
Don’t just think about 4 years later, think about 24 years later; and that’ll make it differently😊
Most of the professors in US universities are of Chinese descent.
Impressive.