Intake pipe dyno testing - K24 honda Pt5

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 129

  • @Garage4age
    @Garage4age  Рік тому +34

    Hey everyone. This will be the last video with this car, as the owner wants to move it on. If you are in NZ, Up for grabs are all the parts i made. Headers, exhaust & inlet manifold (currently on hold for someone) check out my instagram (garage4age) for pictures and details. Also some notes on the video; In this case, ideally you would tune the vct for each length. so results could vary, maybe a touch more power to be had at some lengths. Was already over 30 runs (i don't show them all) making this video. would easily 3x that tuning vct for each length. Its a pretty cool example of how the intake tuning moves along the graph and progressively gets weaker as the tube gets shorter.

    • @cbdrift
      @cbdrift Рік тому +2

      gawds - i love the pic :)

    • @CheekyNinja
      @CheekyNinja Рік тому +3

      Real shame for this to be last K video, hopefully there's been enough interest to get another example in :)

    • @findtherightbeat
      @findtherightbeat Рік тому

      Would've been interesting to see the 375mm with a Blair bellmouth

    • @Garage4age
      @Garage4age  Рік тому +11

      @@CheekyNinja Unfortunately the revenue from these video's are lucky to pay for the fuel used, let alone anything else. it basically costs me money to make most of them. So yeah kind of hard to justify anything that isn't my own project, or lent to me like this one.

    • @Garage4age
      @Garage4age  Рік тому +1

      @@findtherightbeat whats a Blair bellmouth?

  • @mitch_sorenstein
    @mitch_sorenstein Рік тому +26

    Heres what I think. The Squirrel Monkey is the most frequently seen primate in the Amazon jungle. They are very small, weighing 3 pounds, and live in huge groups (sometimes up to 500 monkeys). Squirrel Monkeys are omnivores and primarily feed on fruit and small insects. And that's all I have to say about that.

    • @Giuliana-w1f
      @Giuliana-w1f Рік тому

      I'm not sure if you're a person or nor, but you look like a bot trying to say a generic comment that would fit in any video

    • @Garage4age
      @Garage4age  Рік тому +8

      @@Giuliana-w1f mildly interesting facts from said bot, so i'll let it slide

  • @wma6019
    @wma6019 Рік тому +6

    Arguably one of the most overlooked details when making max power NA with a single throttle body

  • @essb00
    @essb00 Рік тому +7

    I'm not sure what I like better... The drawings on this video or the 'magic' in your previous vids where you shove cams through the oil filler.
    Though choice!
    Nice K24 series! Sad to hear this is the last of it.

  • @AndyGT86
    @AndyGT86 Рік тому +4

    Love this one because intake pipe and filter is usually the first mod every body does.
    I would love to see more testing on this including different diameters and lengths.
    Btw all your vids are great!

  • @hicostlocost
    @hicostlocost 5 місяців тому +1

    So much actually useful information here. Thanks for doing all this. Now I can choose an intake length and move on to messing up other stuff.

  • @findtherightbeat
    @findtherightbeat Рік тому +3

    The picture you drew is were it's at! 😄🍻

  • @Rippthrough
    @Rippthrough Рік тому +4

    Those drawings and sounds made me legitimately laugh out loud :D

  • @matos_x_
    @matos_x_ Рік тому +5

    Now this is an experiment ive been wondering about. Good to see you testing it out, doing the Lords work. Cheers 🍻

  • @jdoggsgarage4494
    @jdoggsgarage4494 Рік тому +8

    I've been telling people for years to use the longest intake they can fit in the car, for most Hondas thats going to be the best, also fitting a nice velocity stack on a short pipe helps it act like a long pipe. Diameter makes a big difference too.

    • @redstonegarage
      @redstonegarage Рік тому

      What is an ideal diameter?

    • @jdoggsgarage4494
      @jdoggsgarage4494 Рік тому +2

      @@redstonegarage that will depend. Most Hondas want 3 to 4 inch. Length also changes what the best diameter is. Generally I'd build a 3.5" intake as long as will fit with velocity stack. That almost always works really well

    • @TassieLorenzo
      @TassieLorenzo Рік тому +3

      From my back of the envelope calculations, it seems like 1000mm is ideal for this engine with peak power @ ~8000rpm, but 700mm would be ideal for a 4-cylinder engine with peak power at 11,000rpm (so an extreme K20 or K24 destroker NA build) while 1300mm would be ideal for a 4-cylinder engine with peak power at 6000rpm (like say the 4-cylinder GM Atlas engine or the Porsche 924 engine or some other big capacity, low revving 4-cylinder engine).
      Assuming I've used the right equation, closed-open end resonance third harmonic, f = v/λ = 3v/(4L), which seems to match up with f = rpm * (4/2) / 60. [About 266 Hz for 8000rpm, 4-cylinder, 4-stroke -- I know nuffin' lol.]
      As intake length was shortened less than 1000mm, it increasingly pushed the (third) resonant peak past the maximum rpm of this particular K24 engine. So a 900mm long intake would be ideal for a mild K20 with peak power nearer 8600rpm, compared to 1000mm for a K24 with peak power near 8000rpm?
      Maybe the explanation is the pipe resonance driving "acoustic streaming" which provides for a slight increase in steady air flow into the engine at those resonance frequencies? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
      However there is another resonance at 1/3rd the length, which could also be useful for shorter intakes. None of this explains the hump at 4700rpm which seems to move both left and right without a consistent relationship to intake length, which might be due to something else (the relationship to the custom intake manifold or custom header or something)?
      I see the initial testing skipped over 300mm however I think 300mm (or 333mm) as a 1/3rd of the ideal 1000mm (i.e., fitting in the first resonance, half a wavelength in the intake tube instead of one and half) might actually be better than the 400mm that was settled upon. As 400mm seems to have a peak at 7500rpm while 200mm seems to have a peak that's past the maximum rpm once again. Edit -- My bad, 325mm was tested later and it *was* better than 425mm, at least for peak power, and 325mm was still a little bit better than 350mm, 375mm for peak power (if it a little less elsewhere). Very interesting.
      It seems like going from 325mm back up to 375-400mm shifted peak power down from (near) 8000rpm to about ~7700rpm. 325mm would perhaps have been more Honda-ish, 375mm as chosen gave a good compromise with more mid-range everywhere.
      I wonder if f = rpm * (4/2) / 60 = 3c/(4L), so *L = 3/8 * 60 * c / rpm* = 3/8 * 60 * 343 / 7800 = *989mm* gives a pretty good estimate of what is needed, or if that doesn't fit take 1/3*L (so L = *329mm* ) or 1/8 * 60 * c / rpm, at least in terms of getting peak power at f (7800rpm, 260Hz in this instance)? (Where c = speed of sound, ~343m/s for ambient temps. You'd replace the 4 in 4/2 with the number of cylinders for other types of 4-stroke engines.)
      This seems right to me and fits with the excellent data, but it might be total BS, please correct me if I'm wrong!
      I went and measured my Hybrid Racing K-swap cold air intake (the kind that goes down and draws from off to the side of the front bumper) and it seems like it's about 830mm long, so hopefully that's about right -- if having the resonant peak a little bit beyond the maximum rpm of the (K20) engine (~9200rpm?). Unfortunately it's the old 3" diameter model not the newer 3.5" version, though I did put a bellmouth on it, more like what it comes with nowadays! [*Ponders increasing intake length by about 70mm to make it more "optimal"...*]

    • @mattk9438
      @mattk9438 Рік тому

      what if i wanted to keep the stock airbox? its not a civic or integra.
      ive done the best i can so far; hondata modded, k&n airfilter, 2.5” smooth flex pipe (just changed from corrugated pipe yesterday) and attached a 45 degree pvc bend at the end and shaped it as best i could to be a velocity stack.
      positioned it so its above the radiator like a dc5 but in a way that air deflects into it from the edge of the grill.
      silicone 3 to 2.5” elbow for the throttlebody.
      the next mod is taking that velocity stack off and making a ram air feed.
      would making the inlet 3” be any benefit?
      no other mods aside from that.
      engine is k20 with a ppa head.

    • @ferio98jdm
      @ferio98jdm 4 місяці тому

      @@TassieLorenzo Hello, can You help me choose the best intake for my modded K24A3?

  • @CrAzZyTheCodingBoss
    @CrAzZyTheCodingBoss Рік тому +4

    this vid was awesome! love the drawings !

  • @yehnahthx
    @yehnahthx Рік тому +2

    This is great to watch to get a bit of context for what happened when Marty and Moog from MCM replaced the complex and extremely long intake on his Peugeot last week, and Moogs Swift lost 7kw from his shorty KN intake

    • @winha1435
      @winha1435 Рік тому

      Didnt they also chance wheels and other stuff at the same time too.

  • @fajsdkfskaf
    @fajsdkfskaf Рік тому +1

    extremely impressive picture you drew. seriously

  • @Ben_here_b4
    @Ben_here_b4 Рік тому +2

    Wow the picture and animations are top notch! Love the content, thanks for all the work to get it out for us to enjoy!

  • @Dane33781
    @Dane33781 Рік тому +3

    Great video! I had similar results in the past testing intake length on a k20. We opted to keep a long intake by plumbing it in like charge pipe. It retained most of the gains that way.

  • @3800S1
    @3800S1 Рік тому +2

    I found the same sort of thing with my mate's ecomang VL speedway car. We thought having a straight TB would increase power from the intake pipe it already had (which was about 5-600mm iirc) and it took a substantial dive in hp. So we put the pipe back and it regained.
    So we added more pipe length and it continued to gain throughout the curve until we called it quits at nearly 2m as it was impractical.
    On the car when the new engine was built, he added a long snaking intake of about 1500mm.

    • @garage4k989
      @garage4k989 Рік тому +1

      Nah bro that never happened aye

  • @jareknowak8712
    @jareknowak8712 Рік тому +1

    👍
    Thank You!!

  • @intrigue175175
    @intrigue175175 Рік тому +3

    Great stuff as usual.

  • @jakelong4271
    @jakelong4271 Рік тому +3

    Hey that video of the honda noise guy is my buddy X!

    • @Garage4age
      @Garage4age  Рік тому +2

      Nice! Ask him not to copyright me haha

  • @BEYTEK
    @BEYTEK Рік тому

    awsome seeing you play with k series club. Welcome.

  • @MasterofNoneTV
    @MasterofNoneTV Рік тому +1

    Mighty Car Mods needs to see this video. This is what they should have done with their intake mod video

    • @Garage4age
      @Garage4age  Рік тому +1

      Yeah, at least back to back, just changing the intake would have been good. but dyno time isn't cheap. assuming that's why they done it how they did

  • @ziorxkomtuper
    @ziorxkomtuper Рік тому

    This channel is gold

  • @theAngelofhevn
    @theAngelofhevn Рік тому +5

    If you ever get a chance to buy a old Redblock Volvo for a cheap price it would be really really interesting to see testing on it! They are stock really understressed (dont buy 1985-1988 blocks). They can handle all the abuse you can throw at it. And internet is full of theories how to tune them. But no near the test information you are doing are getting to the public on them. But i really like the Honda dyno series! Good Job! 😁

    • @ahcasablanca
      @ahcasablanca Рік тому +1

      If you haven't already, see @Stavtech for what he did to Volvo redblock engines. Extensive headwork to make a hemispherical combustion chamber with 30+ PSI boost!

    • @garagecedric
      @garagecedric Рік тому +2

      Over here its one of the most tuned engines in car history, both turbo and na, still plenty of them in motorsport use every weekend. Theres massive amounts of knowledge on these.

  • @MaggieCat83
    @MaggieCat83 Рік тому

    Yay, back to Toyotas!

  • @n1eg695
    @n1eg695 10 місяців тому

    Thank you for your service!!!

  • @РодионМухметов
    @РодионМухметов Рік тому +1

    Спасибо за видео!
    Попробуйте использовать сопло Лаваля с внутренним диаметром 1.5-2 дюйма в узкой части.

  • @n1eg695
    @n1eg695 Місяць тому

    Watching the second time, great info info!

  • @cbdrift
    @cbdrift Рік тому +4

    best intake i had on an old crx was made from marley downpipe :) looked almost identical to this one lol

    • @Garage4age
      @Garage4age  Рік тому +5

      the marley intake was always the best haha

  • @Christdeliverme
    @Christdeliverme Рік тому +2

    I see a Garage 4AGE I click like.

  • @WholesaleTurbos
    @WholesaleTurbos Рік тому +1

    interesting, we tested an employees car before it was turbo charged with the intake pipped up to the intercooler (before turbo and manifold fitted) and it gained a few kw up top. It was repeatable but we couldnt really figure out why and none of us cared too much anyway. Maybe its the volume similar to what you can see up top on your 1000mm pipe. Owner reported that he couldnt feel the difference in power lol

  • @gp8666
    @gp8666 Рік тому +6

    i guess the new trend is to have a hood intake pipe sticking out

    • @Garage4age
      @Garage4age  Рік тому +4

      it is now

    • @tortron
      @tortron Рік тому +1

      You get a snorkel, you get a snorkel, everyone gets a snorkel!

  • @GTRliffe
    @GTRliffe Рік тому +2

    i wonder if a smaller diameter short pipe would give the same gains as the 1000cm one. Assuming that 1m one is a restriction

  • @bomj12
    @bomj12 Рік тому +2

    The next test is choosing the best ventilation umbrella :)

  • @madjimms
    @madjimms Рік тому +4

    Holy crap, I'm first.... I'd like to thank jesus or something.

  • @slidenyo
    @slidenyo Рік тому +1

    Im interested about intake swirl ie from twisted butterflies or angled velecity stacks to promote higher air density at traditionally lower portions of the intake valve. Creating that vortex certainly works in a burn barrell (cutting L's and beating them inward to create a monodirectional inlet flow) as far as efficiency wonder whether it'd cross over to air mass delivery ?

  • @BDSMotorsport
    @BDSMotorsport Рік тому +1

    this reminds me of myself a few years ago.. XD

  • @jackweta
    @jackweta 7 місяців тому

    I swapped out my Injen short ram intake for a Hybrid cold air intake. Looking forward to trackday & see if i dropped some lap time. Honda EP3 stock K24 174kw at hub dyno with Injen. Havent dynoed new Hybrid intake.

    • @jackweta
      @jackweta 6 місяців тому

      My car was about 1 sec quicker & 2-3km/h top end increase on the main straight of Hampton Downs National track 189-190km/h to 192km/h. Last year I managed multiple 1:20 laps, this year I managed 1:19 x3 in final session. The long cold air intake was better. Thanks for your videos it inspired me to make the change!

  • @TOCHIKN
    @TOCHIKN Рік тому

    The KPOWER 86 SWAP uses a long intake.

  • @dfuent1988
    @dfuent1988 Рік тому +1

    Hi Can you also test whats the best megaphone size after the header? That would make a great content. Thank you!

  • @alojzijejozinovic9524
    @alojzijejozinovic9524 5 місяців тому

    My question is, is this now univeral messure for every engine, or i will have to messure my own and test? (Mx5 NC 1.8)

  • @Christdeliverme
    @Christdeliverme Рік тому

    LOLOL @ the hand drawn and audio overlays

  • @AllmotorTurbo
    @AllmotorTurbo 6 днів тому

    You has tested turbo free flow vs pipe X diameters?

  • @mrln247
    @mrln247 Рік тому +2

    Slightly disappointed it's not getting a snorkel just imagine the RAM effect.
    As a side question since I have been looking at graphs again, is there any relevance to measuring the area under the line of the graph for a certain rev range to smooth out the numbers? Rather than following the wiggles.

    • @otm646
      @otm646 Рік тому +1

      The effects of ram are are greatly exaggerated in most people's minds. At 100 MPH it's 0.17 PSI assuming STP. At 150 mph it's 0.4 PSI. We are talking a 2.5% power increase absolute maximum outside land speed record applications.

    • @mrln247
      @mrln247 Рік тому

      @@otm646 Yep joking the 4x4 boys go on about it while they have giant wheels and tyres plus all kinds of accessories stuck all over producing even more power sapping drag.
      The drag from the snorkel would use more power than ram would create.

    • @Garage4age
      @Garage4age  Рік тому +3

      @@mrln247 The amount of rain around here lately the snorkel would be helpful.. unsure what you mean by the other part?

    • @mrln247
      @mrln247 Рік тому

      @@Garage4age No worries, just the ramblings of someone who often comes at things left field re-learning data analysis.
      Snorkels are overconfidence device's, more useful as a clean air feed with a pre-cleaner. But I've seen a few morons who hydrolocked their engines trying to go through water at ramming speed.

    • @mrln247
      @mrln247 Рік тому +1

      @@Garage4age Rufford ford has got itself pretty famous for Muppets behaviour.

  • @crd-nz_001
    @crd-nz_001 Рік тому +1

    I wonder what the next project is...

    • @garage4k989
      @garage4k989 Рік тому +2

      Big 3/4 race cam 4k street engine
      Just waiting on kelford cams for teh hookup

  • @kalui96
    @kalui96 Рік тому +1

    inertial ram?
    edit: or ig there's a helmholtz resonance on the big pipe lol

  • @sachadohc2912
    @sachadohc2912 Рік тому +1

    Again very good contain as usual :) maybe i can ask what pipe diameter was it ?

  • @AlienLivesMatter
    @AlienLivesMatter Рік тому

    Test oversize catalytic converter, compared to oem

  • @ricepony33
    @ricepony33 Рік тому +1

    Technically you could put the intake in the interior #becauseracecar

  • @tiitsaul9036
    @tiitsaul9036 Рік тому +2

    Hey mate, I did some exhaust back pressure measurements and discovered it develops slight vacuum during deceleration. Is it normal?

    • @Garage4age
      @Garage4age  Рік тому +3

      Unsure, not something Ive bothered taking notice of tbh

    • @pecata01
      @pecata01 Рік тому

      Depending on the valve timing and overlap, it can probably transfer some of the intake vacuum in the exhaust.

    • @tiitsaul9036
      @tiitsaul9036 Рік тому +1

      @@pecata01 that was my suspicion as well.

  • @tiitsaul9036
    @tiitsaul9036 Рік тому +1

    Does the intake pipe length matter on turbocharged cars? Do intake pulses travel through turbo?

    • @Garage4age
      @Garage4age  Рік тому +2

      Unlikely to have much / any effect. but can't say ive tried it. Intake manifold itself still has a big effect. but its easier to make/sell short shiny stuff and run all the boost, hence why market flooded with them.

  • @dilsher12
    @dilsher12 Рік тому

    Was that 2 stroke sound track from a Yamaha banshee or RZ350?

  • @johnmann7o2
    @johnmann7o2 6 місяців тому

    Hopefully you’re not done with this car, maybe an e85 and 91 octane equaling e30 mix. I’ve heard a 5 whp can be gained without changing to flex setup.

    • @Garage4age
      @Garage4age  6 місяців тому

      Car is long gone sorry. but will have a video out soon testing ethanol on a NA engine

  • @AaronJessen-xu7ts
    @AaronJessen-xu7ts Рік тому

    Only in whangarei don't let the popo see you loll😂😂😂🎉

  • @haypurtiryading
    @haypurtiryading Рік тому

    Mercedes have a variable intake manifold. I think it work like that. What about ram intake?

    • @haypurtiryading
      @haypurtiryading Рік тому

      @@carstennobody7047 i will read, thanks.

    • @haypurtiryading
      @haypurtiryading Рік тому

      @@carstennobody7047 any link for book? E-book or hardcopy?

  • @TheSol115
    @TheSol115 5 місяців тому

    70 mm interior tube ?

    • @Garage4age
      @Garage4age  5 місяців тому +1

      would have been around 85mm inside diameter. the aluminum tube was 3.5" and the plastic extension was roughly same size

  • @DimZin
    @DimZin Рік тому

    K20 head swap would make big gains also

    • @AaroKo
      @AaroKo Рік тому +1

      bruh it's k20a so it already has it :D

    • @DimZin
      @DimZin Рік тому

      @@AaroKoThen why does it say k24 on the tittle and description?

    • @AaroKo
      @AaroKo Рік тому

      @@DimZin oh nvm my bad lol
      those come stock with k20 so it's weird but yeah you're right it's been swapped

    • @Garage4age
      @Garage4age  Рік тому +1

      @@AaroKo yeah its a stock k24 with aftermarket cams. unsure why they didn't use the k20 head. or just modified the k20

    • @AaroKo
      @AaroKo Рік тому

      @@Garage4age weird🤔
      but good news are that the k24 head is also as capable as k20 head as what I've heard

  • @tiitsaul9036
    @tiitsaul9036 Рік тому +3

    Cool.
    Have you considered making divided plenum intake? Pairing cylinders 1-4 and 2-3. BMW calls it DISA, other brands probably have some different name for it. It's an easy way to achieve multi length intake runners.

    • @flinchy-5224
      @flinchy-5224 Рік тому +1

      DISA isnt worth the hassle, it's only divided at low rpm, at high rpm the resonance chamber has an impact but it's out-performed by non-DISA manifolds for peak power.
      And it really doesn't do anything, kinda. N52 non-DISA sees power gains from DISA manifold and tune .. and further gains from DISA delete and N54 manifold.
      And I wouldn't call it THAT easy. Also moderately failure prone.

    • @AaroKo
      @AaroKo Рік тому +1

      honda had its own versions already in the 90s,atleast in some H22 and B18 engines not sure which all but the most performance oriented models never came with it so that tells alot :)

    • @tiitsaul9036
      @tiitsaul9036 Рік тому +2

      @@flinchy-5224 disa isn't for max power. It's for broader power band.
      N54 non disa manifold makes more power due to its runner dimensions, not because of lack of disa valve. With appropriate design, disa doesn't hurt peak power.
      The only failure point is the valve itself.
      I'd say it's the simplest way to achieve multi length intake manifold. Especially on a straight 6 engine and not too hard with 4 banger.

    • @flinchy-5224
      @flinchy-5224 Рік тому

      @@tiitsaul9036 DISA is a restriction as much as it's a benefit. The n54 manifold doesn't lose anything even down low or midrange

    • @tiitsaul9036
      @tiitsaul9036 Рік тому

      @@flinchy-5224 one of us don't understand physics.

  • @cub64
    @cub64 2 місяці тому

    Stock airbox factory are much2 better..