Great Job narrating with so much context and very well navigated through.. very professional and authentic!! Thanks for making this video with immense quality!!
Superb content and narration. I am surprised that there are only a 1000 subscribers! I hope you go to 10 lakh plus soon. Explore other options/coalitions/syndication/business models to get your content out. Doordarshan should be jumping at the opportunity to get this on their channels!
Good to see someone speaking on this basing on the facts founded by the archaeologists and not basing it on the false theories of so called 'dis'torians and indologists who sit in their ac cabin sipping whiskey somewhere in the west and write about an excavation that happened in the east without even taking part in the process But have a complain that many youtubers do and you have also not mentioned it which is about the whips that were discovered from the burials; only chariots pulled by horses must have whips where as carts that are pulled by ox/cow must have sticks because you hit the ox/cow in the back but you hit the horses on the shoulders and in the burials they found a whip with copper handle having place for leather whip to be tied in it unfortunately the leather has decomposed but they have found it which strongly indicates the fact that they were horse pulled chariots Keep it up...nice work...expecting more from you👍👍👍
MAGADH is the place that defended India from Greeks(selucid) Greeks(indo) Huns (toramana) Yeuzhi(kushan) Western satraps(scythians) Tibetans (in this case we were invaders) {licchivi dynasty in Nepal} Licchivi dynasty was the golden age of Nepal built by Maithils of Bihar after defeating kirats of tibetan origin. The people of kathmandu still look different from other Nepalis because of their Maithil dna. Medieval era wasnt good but still we had kings like SHIVA SIMHA SINGH who defeated Delhi sultanate and Bengal sultanate for 6 years. Narendra singh who defeated Alivardi khan of Bengal sultanate in Battle of kandarpi ghat(1752) MITHILA was independent between (1684-1804) Also Malla dynasty(1201-1779) of Nepal was built by maithils of Bihar. MAGADH 🔱 MITHILA 🔱 BIHAR 📉
Ohhh , we can't say it interesting instead unearthing a new hidden gem / glorious past of our ancient Bharat . My special thank to akkaara for bringing forward / revealing our lost heritage.
India is a country of variations and have people with different linguistic backgrounds. Lets celebrate the content, noting that accents will vary will region and person to person. The content is well researched and well presented.
I am sure you have an accent of area and region you belong to. If my accent doesn’t fit in your standards it doesn’t make it fake. Moreover we believe language is only a medium to pass information and as long as it’s understandable, it’s purpose is solved. I would love to work on what I speak rather than how I speak. Thank you for your feedback though. Be kind.
@@anamelessmonsterIt means it is clear you have no knowledge on Google maps. Still river saraswati was flowing near badrinath. You can see in Google maps also. Exact same location that was mentioned in Mahabharata and skanda puran. Even Google map also named it as a river saraswati a tributary to alakananda. But you barking without perfect knowledge by listening fake historians.😂😂😂😂😂
Sinauli excavations belonged to Mahabharat period between 3500 to 3000 BC. Dating is wrong. Horse, horse chariots, iron weapons were found which suggest presence of warrior people.
Very good scientific presentation with actual authenticated objects . These will be definitely make us respectable as seekers. Those videos with graphics, cut paste images from different regions and eras which make tall claims without any substantial evidence and with out understanding the cryptic nature of our scriptures /mythology are embarrassing and makes sensible Indians cringe. A big salute to all archeologists for their patience and hard work .👍👋👋
4500 years ago there was nothing " Buddhist". Buddhism is a religion not culture. Buddhists preach peaceful way of life and spiritual knowledge. why they will develop the technology for swords and chariot. 🙂
There is no controversy about Horses. Read Mahabharat (5250 BCE) and you will find the existence of Horses in Bharat. I am not sure who named 2000 BCE is Rigvedic period????
one small request... when you speak complete sentences either in English or Hindi, don't mix them. Throughout the video you are mixing hindi with english words, ofcourse difficult terms in hindi which are required to be translated to english are exception. This enhances viewers attention and it is also easier to understand.
मॅडम जी प्रणाम, आपने "सिनौली" पर वी. डी. ओ. मे भारतीय संस्कृती की बडी अच्छी जाणकारी दी हैं. आपसे अनुरोध हैं की ऐसे भारतीय सभ्यता की जाणकारी हिंदी में दे ताकी आम आदमी भी समझ सके.
Probably they were from the same culture but a different class with Sinali was a seat of governance where the ruler lived, and the Harappan cities were centers of commerce and manufacture where mainly artisans lived. In Egypt the Pharaohs and military barracks and chariot stables were separated from the population. It may have been the same in the Indian Valley Civilization.
11:17 about the shields - The design of Sinauli shields is somewhat similar to the Mycenean Greek shield designs (1600 to 1100 BC). The point to be noted is that these designs are much younger compared to the Sinauli shields, an argument can be made that the then Greeks might have copied/inspired by these shields while doing some trade back then or Indians might have migrated to Greece introducing the technology there. Do search for those Mycenean shields, it's interesting! Thanks
Yes we did find chariots there in burial . At it was the first time in Indian history that chariots were found. And as per the specialist of ASI these chariots are much advanced than most found in its contemporary era.
@@akkaara but this is drawn by other any animal not possible to horse and these use for transportation etc other work by not with war because vedic chariots is ligh weight spoked wheel and drawn by horse but chariots is debated but other items swords and shield not found in ivc civilization means this people associated in war
@@MohammadkaifBabu abdul Do u know the basic Difference b/w a Cart and a Chariot? A cart is Big in Size and is used for Carrying a Bunch of People and heavy Goods For transportation And Shape is Usually Rectangular. Carts are used by Common People specifically Peasants and Trader class. carts can be Pulled by Horse,Donkeys,Buffaloes as well as Ox depending upon what you have to draw a Cart. A Chariot is usually 🧲 -Shaped made for lowering the air resitance over it and Chariot is Small in Size for Carrying 1-3 person at max at a Time. Chariots are used by Elite and warrior class. Chariots were also drawn by Ox,Horses,Deer,Onagers like Fast Swift and PowerFull animals. The Sinuali Chariots are Typical 🧲 shaped small War Chariots Found along with Elite Burials. They are not Carts by any Definition. Even if they were pulled by ox it is Still Chariot and those chariots were pulled by Which Animal is matter of Research and But most Plausibly Horses were used because horse leather whip was found along with it which is not Used over Oxen Chariots rather Horse chariot. And There are already plenty Of Horse evidence in Indus valley Since 2600B.C through Previous studies of bone remains and Terracotta figurines of Horse found in various IVc sites. So Abdul keep Crying as ur Opinions and False narratives are not going to work here.
We will look into the Rakhi Gari excavations and other research papers, thank you for the tip. Also our research is purely based on Sunali and not Vedas thus we prefer to present widely accepted fact on that area that are not of our expertise.
@amaragrawal9987 As far as I know there is no research paper that directly provides any conclusive evidence of age of rig veda. There are some insinuations that rig veda mentioned river Saraswati that went extinct in 1800 BC and along which much of Indus valley settlements were found. Also some altars were discovered that have resemblance of vedic culture. But beyond that no other connection has been unearthed so far. I am eager to learn more if my knowledge is incomplete.
@@MyNewAgewell there is No evidence of Many fire altars,Horses,Chariots In India even after 1500B.C So why that 1500-1000B.C time is considered as Vedic Era?? You dont have any Material Evidence to support the 1500-1000B C time for vedic period but u r comfortable in. Accepting that shitt but When Some one say Rigveda Cannot be Post 3000B.C u have problem in relating it with Evidences? What evidence do u need. Rigvedic people had barley based diet of which u find evidence only before 7000B.C Rigvedic Saraswati was Huge River during vedic period which is also Pre 7000B.C Time and The River start Declining post 4000B.C due to a heavy Decline in monsoon and shrinkage of Small river channels that Contributed to the flow of rigvedic saraswati. The Rigvedic Horse was 34 Ribs unlike modern Horse with 36 Ribs and evidence of Such small horses in India with less rib bones can be found before end of Last Glacial maxima. Fire altars were not Just Found in few sites but many Sites in different period even in Mehrgarh Fire pits dating back to 4000-5000B.C found The Weapons used in Rigvedic period was Knife,Spear,Axes and Bows Which were even used by Mesolithic and neolithic Societies. Meanwhile in 1500-1000B.C u will se evidences of Swords,Harpoons,maces which are part of post Vedic Tradations.
@@akkaara people says various researches have given conclusive evidences of about 54000 years of history of Indian subcontinent. most of the population of the world is related genetically to population from India About 50000 years ago. I liked you presentation and most of the content. please keep an eye on words like never use word like Indian Mythology its Indian history or Indian Vedic philosophy
2:35 so mohenjodaro harappa and sindhu saraswati "sabhyata"- 'civilisation' has been imperative in understanding our past. whole sentence is in english except the word sabhyata.. this makes the entire sentence sound so weird.
the duo lingo (eg use of both "civilisation" & "sabhyata") actually helps younger kids understand the concept more and highlights how these are synonyms. I actually appreciate the language used. It makes it suitable for the wider population, who speak different languages or are at differing skill level linguistically.
9:43 what nonsense, copper horde & Occ were belongs (indo Aryans) means steppe mlba & Sinauli dna doesn't public yet, how you claiming that Sinauli doesn't have steppe mlba ancestry???
@@anamelessmonster by that logic, everyone is "African" then? I guess you don't know what native being means? When we talk about any culture, we call native to those PPL who created or evolved it. & Sonauli dna matches with modern indians, so it's natives are indians
That itself is a propaganda, No humans have lineage from sun or moon, For them to claim that particular family lineage belongs to sun is out right ridiculous and laughable
@@anamelessmonster Haraxvati river does not match with the geographical location of the Sarasvati river that has been given in the rig veda, in Rig Veda Sarasvati river is between Yamuna and Shutudri (Sutlej) river. and anyways. The Haraxvati Hypothesis is long been rejected idea. You guys just keep bringing it up to maintain the aryan invasion theory coz' you know verywell that no ones gonna verify that.
@@saagnickchakraborty7758 aryan invasion theory is a genetically proven you can't deny this fact...the skeletons of mahenjodaro is a biggest proof of invasion
If we look at actual rivers Saraswati is most probably the river known as Helmud, also called Harahvaiti or Haraxawati that flows in Afghanistan. Vedic gappodis clearly had no clue of geography.
It means it is clear you have no knowledge on Google maps. Still river saraswati was flowing near badrinath. You can see in Google maps also. Exact same location that was mentioned in Mahabharata and skanda puran. Even Google map also named it as a river saraswati a tributary to alakananda. But you barking without perfect knowledge by listening fake historians.😂😂😂😂😂
if this site has 4K years old and gold ornaments so mining, refining and designing of those ornaments and knowledge pushes the date further of this part of civilization 🙂 West will not accept this 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Apka face indigenous Indians wala nahi, central Asians jesa dikhta hy. Bolne ka style acha hy but Lahore k logon jesa hy. Sinauli ko sb se older bna kr apko kia mile ga. Any how acha v log hy. Is research k bare ma international scientists ko b bta do ta k wo b apni raey de saken.
Chariot has spoken wheel, sinauli doesnt has spoken wheel its clearly wagon, more over no horse bone found but bone of ox,dog,hensmongoose,etc found, sinauli raft similar to damiabad oxen driven wagon. Present day people has steppe admixer high among brahmin among hindus, steppe admixer not found rakhigarh sample. Its clearly indicate steppe people where aryan come from cordedware culture of europe. According to david reich harvard lab, admixer of steppe in india starts around 1500BC. Sinuali weapon wer also not found in ivc dating 3500BC-1900BC. Ivc people wer peaceful society. Sinauli whom they wer fighting with? Too many false information in thi video, ASI also clearly manipulating or lack of knowledge and wasting there time.
So You are saying that Cart Wheels cannot have spokes?🤡 Do u know there are old pictures available of Carts during british time and they all had Spokes. So spoke was never a Necessity for Chariots. A Chariot by Fundamental Definition should have D shape and Small in Size which sinauli chariots were and Carts do not have Umbrella rod over Them and Carts are not use by elite class people. Carts are meant for Heavy good Transportation..Unlike sinauli Chariots which Can carry only two persons at max due to its small size design. Atleast use ur common sense rather copy pasting western outdated Logics
@Xhauej rig veda has reference for spoken wheel, in academic anything without spoken is not chariot but wagon. chariot wer introduced by indo-iranian from steppe. Oldest material evidence for spoken wheel (in non-steppe region) dates to 1400BC. Chariot with spoken wheel became common from 1500BC used in warfare. All cart and wagon found before 2000BC wer soild wheel not spoken wheel. Ivc official end 1900BC. IVC who has no spoken wheel. British time picture 🤦🏽♂️ colonial time was 1700s-1947, i am talking about bronze age civilization 2000BC-1000BC.
@@Manikandan_supernova First it's indo-aryan and not indo-iranians, indo-iranians came in india long before the steppe people. And how do you call it a wagon? Wagon is a four wheeled heavy vehicle as per academia, it doesn't even look like a cart let alone a wagon what @Xhauej said above is right, fundamentals of charriot is D shape chasis and body, small and barely can hold 2-3 people. I mean seriously bro, say anything just to maintain the agenda. Although the solid wheel is a puzzle but at the same time the yoke and yoke saddles were far too small to be for any big animals (i.e. Bull or Buffalo) but just the right size for horses so that's a mystery definately.
@@saagnickchakraborty7758 so, this is your original ID, anyhow never mind. indo-iranaian wer also steppe come from corded ware culture part of kurgan model. As PIE expanses kurgan burial found wagons indeed four wheels. As PIE move to west mixed with bell beaker population they retained the wagon forming nordic /germanic branch, while PIE move east we see evolution and hybridation in wagon/cart which transforms into chariot over time in all kurgan burials. Refer:The Horse, the Wheel, and Language -Author, David W. Anthony. As per acedamic any cart which doesnt have spoken wheel will be consider as wagon/cart. Simply to say its not fit for warfare (not before 1700BC). As per eminent indologist asko parpola sinauli cart is clearly wagon not chariot they have similarity with BMAC. But ASI has agenda just like you to show aryan wer indigenous to IVC. Some Chariot also has four wheel so dont confuse with number of wheel. Shaft or yoke feature does exist even with bull, artifact found in daimabad which is IVC site show bull cart with long shaft.
According to National Curriculum Framework for School Education 2023 and the National Education Policy 2020, all NCERT books refer to the Harappan civilization as the 'Indus-Sarasvati' or 'Sindhu-Sarasvati' civilisation, highlighting the prominence of the Sarasvati river. These changes are not done by me. But while passing information on our channel we do intend to adhere to updated versions . It’s neither my place nor my expertise to discard what’s available in our national text books. The video is purely based on finding of Sinauli and is on all the information provided is by the ASI which has the real expertise and Dr manjul, the person who led the team. Neither me nor most people commenting have the expertise on the matter to discard his findings.
@@akkaara Appeal to Authority aye? You are Engaging in Classical logical fallacy of appealing to authority, NEP and NCERT are not the authority in determining what is history and what is not. Those Authority lies with scholars who research the field and majority of them and also the current scholarly consensus is calling it Indus valley civilization and not Sindu Saraswathi Civilization (which is what Hindu Nationalists do), There is Zero Evidence that IVC was Vedic. This Changes are done due to RSS ideology, and you are just accepting it and propagating it without any critical thinking applied to it. As you said you do not have the expertise, but you can refer to what other experts are talking about it and what is the actual Consensus among them.
We are a channel dedicated to talking about art, craft , architecture and glory of India. We do not need to appeal to anyone. This video is purely about the finding of Sinauli and we have stuck to the facts word by word. Rest of the agenda is not our business. Having said that if Allahabad is called prayagraj today then we will address it as Prayagraj. Our videos are not for scholars but a lot of young population use it for educational purposes. We would use the updated and widely accepted terms. Please watch the video to learn the stated facts not to find fallacy.
You are pushing an agenda since you say that 'true' history has been suppressed, you talk of Sindhu 'Sarasvati' civilization etc. Where do you get this Sarasvati? Where in Rigveda do you find the two traditions of burial and cremation? You are wrong when you say that the chariot found in Sinauli is similar to the chariot described in the Vedas. Which Veda, where/ You cleverly do not give reference. Vedic chariots had spoked wheels and the Sinauli chariot has disk wheels.
@@vish2553 Instead of indulging in ad hominem, answer the questions raised if you can. And if you cannot better listen to Mark Twain: It is better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than open it and remove all doubt.
@@vish2553 You are not answering the questions raised. Is it irrelevant to ask "Where in Rigveda do you find the two traditions of burial and cremation?" Is it irrelevant to ask "the chariot found in Sinauli is similar to the chariot described in which Vedas?" Answer me IF YOU CAN.
@ you are not qualified to ask questions with the irrelevant comments you have made 😒 what’s app is not a recognised sambradhya school! Keep proving Mark Twain right 😂 Now join a traditional Vedic padasala and start learning vedas under a learned pandit. Goodbye. Of course you can the last waffle.
No one has ever found saraswati nor did it ever flow in the same region as Indus river, even according to the puranas then only a fool would call it sindhu-saraswati. This is like saying Ganga-Kaveri or Narmada-Brahmputra. Hai koi logic aapki baat mein?
According to National Curriculum Framework for School Education 2023 and the National Education Policy 2020, all NCERT books refer to the Harappan civilization as the 'Indus-Sarasvati' or 'Sindhu-Sarasvati' civilisation, highlighting the prominence of the Sarasvati river. These changes are not done by me. But while passing information on our channel we do intend to adhere to updated versions . It’s neither my place nor my expertise to discard what’s available in our national text books. The video is purely based on finding of Sinauli and is on all the information provided is by the ASI which has the real expertise and Dr manjul, the person who lead the team. Neither me nor most people commenting have the expertise on the matter to discard his findings.
It means it is clear you have no knowledge on Google maps. Still river saraswati was flowing near badrinath. You can see in Google maps also. Exact same location that was mentioned in Mahabharata and skanda puran. Even Google map also named it as a river saraswati a tributary to alakananda. But you barking without perfect knowledge by listening fake historians.😂😂😂😂😂
That's a daft argument... Why do you think there are large sites like Dholavira in the middle of a desert if there was no water source? This Thapar and Habib history had destroyed generations.
Ajj v Bo log hai inka population 80lak k aaspaas hai... Sanatan Dharm & Hindu oka Raksha karna SouthEast Asia ko civilized karna logo ko engineering science technology May Advance karna ya sub pramukh kam tha Bo log Devdutt Thai Kharab politics k Karan Bo log Ajj Hide hai
I dont understand why people fake theory of #Romilathapar #IrfanHabibi n other who jever educated from Hisoty, ancient and archeology but weote Aryan theory Reality in ancient people from India migrated to all over world.
Why you guys are pressing that same people of Sindh migrated and throwing artefacts everywhere...why can’t simply say the civilisation was growing simultaneously
Sinauli resembled aryan ,iranian migration chariot and matched with time line of aryan migration 2000 bc or 4000 years old.And pottery also matchd with vedic aryan migration time-line
@@akkaara yes that is what i am saying and according to some studies R1A1 dna is found in higher amount in south indians than north indians and some central asian tribes so aryan invason is a myth . these are english flowers with a parrot mind . keeps immitating doesnt improve.
@akkaara We got many unreleased ancient samples from India- Medieval Kashmir,Sanauli,Megalithic South India and others. There's one sample from Sanauli(post Harappan) which was majority Steppe_MLBA(60-80%). I can literally show u. Almost all of these samples are all under the supervision and affiliation of Dr. Niraj Rai.
Who are these aryans? Our texts which so carefully documented kings and lineages never mentioned any foreign invasion by these “aryans” nor any mention of they invading or migrating from a different land. “Arya” just meant someone who adhered to principles of dharma in Indian references.
Sinauli really very fascinating for me.
Great Job narrating with so much context and very well navigated through.. very professional and authentic!! Thanks for making this video with immense quality!!
We are glad you enjoyed it!
Very informative video❤. Kindly post more videos ,you should increase their frequency as well as do shorts
Thank you so much.
Superb content and narration. I am surprised that there are only a 1000 subscribers! I hope you go to 10 lakh plus soon. Explore other options/coalitions/syndication/business models to get your content out. Doordarshan should be jumping at the opportunity to get this on their channels!
Thank you so much for the encouragement!
Good to see someone speaking on this basing on the facts founded by the archaeologists and not basing it on the false theories of so called 'dis'torians and indologists who sit in their ac cabin sipping whiskey somewhere in the west and write about an excavation that happened in the east without even taking part in the process
But have a complain that many youtubers do and you have also not mentioned it which is about the whips that were discovered from the burials; only chariots pulled by horses must have whips where as carts that are pulled by ox/cow must have sticks because you hit the ox/cow in the back but you hit the horses on the shoulders and in the burials they found a whip with copper handle having place for leather whip to be tied in it unfortunately the leather has decomposed but they have found it which strongly indicates the fact that they were horse pulled chariots
Keep it up...nice work...expecting more from you👍👍👍
Thank you for this insight. We will surely learn more about it
MAGADH is the place that defended India from Greeks(selucid)
Greeks(indo)
Huns (toramana)
Yeuzhi(kushan)
Western satraps(scythians) Tibetans (in this case we were invaders) {licchivi dynasty in Nepal}
Licchivi dynasty was the golden age of Nepal built by Maithils of Bihar after defeating kirats of tibetan origin. The people of kathmandu still look different from other Nepalis because of their Maithil dna.
Medieval era wasnt good but still we had kings like
SHIVA SIMHA SINGH who defeated Delhi sultanate and Bengal sultanate for 6 years.
Narendra singh who defeated Alivardi khan of Bengal sultanate in Battle of kandarpi ghat(1752)
MITHILA was independent between (1684-1804)
Also Malla dynasty(1201-1779) of Nepal was built by maithils of Bihar.
MAGADH 🔱
MITHILA 🔱
BIHAR 📉
True !
But hey, we can restore our past glory 🇮🇳
Proud of tamil 🙏🙏🙏 thanks sister finally you reviewed
We’re happy to have shared this information with you 😊
thank you, for telling us our true history, please keep making more!!
You’re welcome, it’s a pleasure to share the stories of our heritage.
Thanks for your valuable analysis ❤
Thank you so much
Ohhh , we can't say it interesting instead unearthing a new hidden gem / glorious past of our ancient Bharat . My special thank to akkaara for bringing forward / revealing our lost heritage.
So nice of you
Great Content ! Can you please react to Mr.Yajnadevam's decipherment of indus valley script ?
Thank you so much. I will check it out
Wow. I am mesmerized with you and your narration style. I dont know what it is, but you are very captivng.
Thank you so much, I really appreciate it! 😊
thanks
You’re welcome!
Wow, the world must know and history should be re written 🙏🇮🇳
Yes. They definitely should
Either you speak in English or Hindi please remove that artificial accent too
India is a country of variations and have people with different linguistic backgrounds. Lets celebrate the content, noting that accents will vary will region and person to person. The content is well researched and well presented.
I am sure you have an accent of area and region you belong to. If my accent doesn’t fit in your standards it doesn’t make it fake. Moreover we believe language is only a medium to pass information and as long as it’s understandable, it’s purpose is solved. I would love to work on what I speak rather than how I speak. Thank you for your feedback though. Be kind.
Forget accent there no such river like Haraxvati( sarasvati) ever existed in india...it has nothing to do with india
@@anamelessmonsterIt means it is clear you have no knowledge on Google maps.
Still river saraswati was flowing near badrinath. You can see in Google maps also.
Exact same location that was mentioned in Mahabharata and skanda puran.
Even Google map also named it as a river saraswati a tributary to alakananda.
But you barking without perfect knowledge by listening fake historians.😂😂😂😂😂
@@anamelessmonsterbecause you are an immortal from 3000 BC who have all the answers?
Good video. Hope to reach millions of views
Thank you
Good one 👍 Looking ahead for more such good content
Thank you for the encouragement!
You must Read about what's impact of Andronovo (proto Aryan) on copper horde or cemetery H
There is nothing as proto aryan
They are not horse drawn chariots but ox pulled carts, these people came from the Sintashta culture
Such a beautifully presented video. Its engaging. And so informative yet informal. I always wait for your videos.
Thank you so much, means a lot to us!
Beautiful presentation ma'am❤❤❤
Thank you so much, glad you liked it! 😊
Sinauli excavations belonged to Mahabharat period between 3500 to 3000 BC. Dating is wrong. Horse, horse chariots, iron weapons were found which suggest presence of warrior people.
The dating of Sinauli is based on scientific evidence and is a complex subject. We appreciate your perspective
Very good scientific presentation with actual authenticated objects . These will be definitely make us respectable as seekers.
Those videos with graphics, cut paste images from different regions and eras which make tall claims without any substantial evidence and with out understanding the cryptic nature of our scriptures /mythology are embarrassing and makes sensible Indians cringe.
A big salute to all archeologists for their patience and hard work .👍👋👋
We appreciate the support and hope we can continue to bring you well-researched content.,
Awesome presentation. 🙏🙏
Thank you so much
i have 5000 year old pashupati seal
Wow that’s fascinating.
Wishes from our family for this wonderful video . Thanks
You are so kind
very well explained loved it
Thanks a lot 😊
Please specify that you are not influenced by politics of today… loved the work and video
Thank you so much
This is not the first time, Ashoka Bharhut stupa and Sannati panels you can clearly see this same style Chariot. Clearly this is of Buddhist Origin.
4500 years ago there was nothing " Buddhist". Buddhism is a religion not culture. Buddhists preach peaceful way of life and spiritual knowledge. why they will develop the technology for swords and chariot. 🙂
There is no controversy about Horses. Read Mahabharat (5250 BCE) and you will find the existence of Horses in Bharat. I am not sure who named 2000 BCE is Rigvedic period????
one small request... when you speak complete sentences either in English or Hindi, don't mix them. Throughout the video you are mixing hindi with english words, ofcourse difficult terms in hindi which are required to be translated to english are exception. This enhances viewers attention and it is also easier to understand.
Well explained 🙌❤
Glad you think so!
मॅडम जी प्रणाम, आपने "सिनौली" पर वी. डी. ओ. मे भारतीय संस्कृती की बडी अच्छी जाणकारी दी हैं. आपसे अनुरोध हैं की ऐसे भारतीय सभ्यता की जाणकारी हिंदी में दे ताकी आम आदमी भी समझ सके.
Thank you . Main aage se zayada tar Hindi ka Prayog kerne ki koshish kerungi. Aapke feedback ke liye dhanyawad
❤
Probably they were from the same culture but a different class with Sinali was a seat of governance where the ruler lived, and the Harappan cities were centers of commerce and manufacture where mainly artisans lived. In Egypt the Pharaohs and military barracks and chariot stables were separated from the population. It may have been the same in the Indian Valley Civilization.
Good
Thanks
Swat valley in gandhara
11:17 about the shields - The design of Sinauli shields is somewhat similar to the Mycenean Greek shield designs (1600 to 1100 BC). The point to be noted is that these designs are much younger compared to the Sinauli shields, an argument can be made that the then Greeks might have copied/inspired by these shields while doing some trade back then or Indians might have migrated to Greece introducing the technology there. Do search for those Mycenean shields, it's interesting! Thanks
Thank you for the suggestion. We sure will
didnt we found charriot there?
No we found bull carts some interpret it chariots but this is bull carts
Yes we did find chariots there in burial . At it was the first time in Indian history that chariots were found. And as per the specialist of ASI these chariots are much advanced than most found in its contemporary era.
@@akkaara but this is drawn by other any animal not possible to horse and these use for transportation etc other work by not with war because vedic chariots is ligh weight spoked wheel and drawn by horse but chariots is debated but other items swords and shield not found in ivc civilization means this people associated in war
@@MohammadkaifBabu they are Chariots Bho pdu
@@MohammadkaifBabu abdul
Do u know the basic Difference b/w a Cart and a Chariot?
A cart is Big in Size and is used for Carrying a Bunch of People and heavy Goods For transportation
And Shape is Usually Rectangular.
Carts are used by Common People specifically Peasants and Trader class.
carts can be Pulled by Horse,Donkeys,Buffaloes as well as Ox depending upon what you have to draw a Cart.
A Chariot is usually 🧲 -Shaped made for lowering the air resitance over it and Chariot is Small in Size for Carrying 1-3 person at max at a Time.
Chariots are used by Elite and warrior class.
Chariots were also drawn by Ox,Horses,Deer,Onagers like Fast Swift and PowerFull animals.
The Sinuali Chariots are Typical 🧲 shaped small War Chariots Found along with Elite Burials.
They are not Carts by any Definition.
Even if they were pulled by ox it is Still Chariot and those chariots were pulled by Which Animal is matter of Research and But most Plausibly Horses were used because horse leather whip was found along with it which is not Used over Oxen Chariots rather Horse chariot.
And There are already plenty Of Horse evidence in Indus valley Since 2600B.C through Previous studies of bone remains and Terracotta figurines of Horse found in various IVc sites.
So Abdul keep Crying as ur Opinions and False narratives are not going to work here.
Where did they get all this copper and tin from? Where were the the copper mines?
Please check Rakhi Gari excavations research details and make video of it please
We will look into the Rakhi Gari excavations and other research papers, thank you for the tip. Also our research is purely based on Sunali and not Vedas thus we prefer to present widely accepted fact on that area that are not of our expertise.
@amaragrawal9987 As far as I know there is no research paper that directly provides any conclusive evidence of age of rig veda. There are some insinuations that rig veda mentioned river Saraswati that went extinct in 1800 BC and along which much of Indus valley settlements were found. Also some altars were discovered that have resemblance of vedic culture. But beyond that no other connection has been unearthed so far. I am eager to learn more if my knowledge is incomplete.
@@MyNewAgewell there is No evidence of Many fire altars,Horses,Chariots In India even after 1500B.C
So why that 1500-1000B.C time is considered as Vedic Era??
You dont have any Material Evidence to support the 1500-1000B C time for vedic period but u r comfortable in. Accepting that shitt but When Some one say Rigveda Cannot be Post 3000B.C u have problem in relating it with Evidences?
What evidence do u need.
Rigvedic people had barley based diet of which u find evidence only before 7000B.C
Rigvedic Saraswati was Huge River during vedic period which is also Pre 7000B.C Time and The River start Declining post 4000B.C due to a heavy Decline in monsoon and shrinkage of Small river channels that Contributed to the flow of rigvedic saraswati.
The Rigvedic Horse was 34 Ribs unlike modern Horse with 36 Ribs and evidence of Such small horses in India with less rib bones can be found before end of Last Glacial maxima.
Fire altars were not Just Found in few sites but many Sites in different period even in Mehrgarh Fire pits dating back to 4000-5000B.C found
The Weapons used in Rigvedic period was Knife,Spear,Axes and Bows
Which were even used by Mesolithic and neolithic Societies. Meanwhile in 1500-1000B.C u will se evidences of Swords,Harpoons,maces which are part of post Vedic Tradations.
@@MyNewAge I have removed my comments. looks like you are going in the right direction. Please keep it up
@@MyNewAge There are many researches about it, I will send you references about them
Naam badalne se genetics ni badalne wala 😂
kiski baat kar rahe ho
@@MAN-ei5ws lingtao ki jabardasti khud ko indian proof krte hain naam badal badal ke jabki unki dna ivc mai match hi ni krta 🤣
@@anamelessmonstermatch krta hain
@@anamelessmonster kiski baat ho rahi h thoda spast kare
Bhimetka caves has horse paintings in it , also mewar horses are indegenous
lol those painting painted around 1000 years ago😂😂😂
@@anamelessmonsterread history again... they're some of the oldest rock paintings...some appx 30000 yrs old....clearly not 1000 yrs ....
Please make a video about Rakhi Gari too
Thank you for the suggestion. We will surely research about it.
@@akkaara people says various researches have given conclusive evidences of about 54000 years of history of Indian subcontinent. most of the population of the world is related genetically to population from India About 50000 years ago. I liked you presentation and most of the content. please keep an eye on words like never use word like Indian Mythology its Indian history or Indian Vedic philosophy
2:35
so mohenjodaro harappa and sindhu saraswati "sabhyata"- 'civilisation' has been imperative in understanding our past.
whole sentence is in english except the word sabhyata.. this makes the entire sentence sound so weird.
the duo lingo (eg use of both "civilisation" & "sabhyata") actually helps younger kids understand the concept more and highlights how these are synonyms. I actually appreciate the language used. It makes it suitable for the wider population, who speak different languages or are at differing skill level linguistically.
9:43 what nonsense, copper horde & Occ were belongs (indo Aryans) means steppe mlba & Sinauli dna doesn't public yet, how you claiming that Sinauli doesn't have steppe mlba ancestry???
There aryan doesn't have steppe amcestry
Is sinauli older than Harappa?
No it’s not older: it’s almost contemporary
The more you dig the more you will become foreigner so don't dig anymore...😂
@@anamelessmonster are you Native then???
@@AsterRays7979 i might be also a foreigner so claiming anything is baseless...
@@anamelessmonster by that logic, everyone is "African" then?
I guess you don't know what native being means?
When we talk about any culture, we call native to those PPL who created or evolved it. & Sonauli dna matches with modern indians, so it's natives are indians
The radiating Sun on chariots means ....these were SURYAVANSHIS ..people who claim lineage from sun
That itself is a propaganda, No humans have lineage from sun or moon, For them to claim that particular family lineage belongs to sun is out right ridiculous and laughable
Very interesting
No kne ever paid attention why vedas told "Vasudev Kutumbakma"
Education doent not guranteed intellect
Please use correct version vasudhaiva ( vasudha + iva) Kutumbakam meaning earth is one family
Saraswati is mythical river. Indus is real.
No remins of the river's basin has been found by GSI and the present remnants of the river is the Ghaghar-Hakra river system.
Haraxvati ko yeh log saraswati bolte hain yeh log 😂 jaise sindhu ko hindu😂
@@anamelessmonster Haraxvati river does not match with the geographical location of the Sarasvati river that has been given in the rig veda, in Rig Veda Sarasvati river is between Yamuna and Shutudri (Sutlej) river. and anyways. The Haraxvati Hypothesis is long been rejected idea. You guys just keep bringing it up to maintain the aryan invasion theory coz' you know verywell that no ones gonna verify that.
@@saagnickchakraborty7758 aryan invasion theory is a genetically proven you can't deny this fact...the skeletons of mahenjodaro is a biggest proof of invasion
@@saagnickchakraborty7758 there is no traces found of your so called river...
If we look at actual rivers Saraswati is most probably the river known as Helmud, also called Harahvaiti or Haraxawati that flows in Afghanistan. Vedic gappodis clearly had no clue of geography.
It means it is clear you have no knowledge on Google maps.
Still river saraswati was flowing near badrinath. You can see in Google maps also.
Exact same location that was mentioned in Mahabharata and skanda puran.
Even Google map also named it as a river saraswati a tributary to alakananda.
But you barking without perfect knowledge by listening fake historians.😂😂😂😂😂
Please update yourself. Paleo river track of Saraswathi is a published fact. Including abuse with a comment indicates intolerance to others' opinions
if this site has 4K years old and gold ornaments so mining, refining and designing of those ornaments and knowledge pushes the date further of this part of civilization 🙂 West will not accept this 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Yes, we are talking about an advanced civilization here.
Apka face indigenous Indians wala nahi, central Asians jesa dikhta hy. Bolne ka style acha hy but Lahore k logon jesa hy.
Sinauli ko sb se older bna kr apko kia mile ga.
Any how acha v log hy. Is research k bare ma international scientists ko b bta do ta k wo b apni raey de saken.
Maine kahin mention nahi kiya ki Sinauli oldest civilisation hai. Ye harappa ke baad ka civilisation hai.
Chariot has spoken wheel, sinauli doesnt has spoken wheel its clearly wagon, more over no horse bone found but bone of ox,dog,hensmongoose,etc found, sinauli raft similar to damiabad oxen driven wagon.
Present day people has steppe admixer high among brahmin among hindus, steppe admixer not found rakhigarh sample. Its clearly indicate steppe people where aryan come from cordedware culture of europe. According to david reich harvard lab, admixer of steppe in india starts around 1500BC.
Sinuali weapon wer also not found in ivc dating 3500BC-1900BC. Ivc people wer peaceful society. Sinauli whom they wer fighting with?
Too many false information in thi video, ASI also clearly manipulating or lack of knowledge and wasting there time.
So You are saying that Cart Wheels cannot have spokes?🤡
Do u know there are old pictures available of Carts during british time and they all had Spokes.
So spoke was never a Necessity for Chariots.
A Chariot by Fundamental Definition should have D shape and Small in Size which sinauli chariots were and Carts do not have Umbrella rod over Them and Carts are not use by elite class people.
Carts are meant for Heavy good Transportation..Unlike sinauli Chariots which Can carry only two persons at max due to its small size design.
Atleast use ur common sense rather copy pasting western outdated Logics
@Xhauej rig veda has reference for spoken wheel, in academic anything without spoken is not chariot but wagon. chariot wer introduced by indo-iranian from steppe. Oldest material evidence for spoken wheel (in non-steppe region) dates to 1400BC. Chariot with spoken wheel became common from 1500BC used in warfare. All cart and wagon found before 2000BC wer soild wheel not spoken wheel. Ivc official end 1900BC. IVC who has no spoken wheel.
British time picture 🤦🏽♂️ colonial time was 1700s-1947, i am talking about bronze age civilization 2000BC-1000BC.
@@Manikandan_supernova First it's indo-aryan and not indo-iranians, indo-iranians came in india long before the steppe people. And how do you call it a wagon? Wagon is a four wheeled heavy vehicle as per academia, it doesn't even look like a cart let alone a wagon what @Xhauej said above is right, fundamentals of charriot is D shape chasis and body, small and barely can hold 2-3 people. I mean seriously bro, say anything just to maintain the agenda. Although the solid wheel is a puzzle but at the same time the yoke and yoke saddles were far too small to be for any big animals (i.e. Bull or Buffalo) but just the right size for horses so that's a mystery definately.
@@saagnickchakraborty7758 so, this is your original ID, anyhow never mind. indo-iranaian wer also steppe come from corded ware culture part of kurgan model. As PIE expanses kurgan burial found wagons indeed four wheels. As PIE move to west mixed with bell beaker population they retained the wagon forming nordic /germanic branch, while PIE move east we see evolution and hybridation in wagon/cart which transforms into chariot over time in all kurgan burials. Refer:The Horse, the Wheel, and Language -Author, David W. Anthony. As per acedamic any cart which doesnt have spoken wheel will be consider as wagon/cart. Simply to say its not fit for warfare (not before 1700BC). As per eminent indologist asko parpola sinauli cart is clearly wagon not chariot they have similarity with BMAC. But ASI has agenda just like you to show aryan wer indigenous to IVC. Some Chariot also has four wheel so dont confuse with number of wheel. Shaft or yoke feature does exist even with bull, artifact found in daimabad which is IVC site show bull cart with long shaft.
जय नास्तिकता... अंध अस्तिकता बंद हो..!
So much crap.For your kind information it is indus valley civilization not so called sindu Saswati civilization. Veda's was imported from BMAC.
According to National Curriculum Framework for School Education 2023 and the National Education Policy 2020, all NCERT books refer to the Harappan civilization as the 'Indus-Sarasvati' or 'Sindhu-Sarasvati' civilisation, highlighting the prominence of the Sarasvati river.
These changes are not done by me. But while passing information on our channel we do intend to adhere to updated versions . It’s neither my place nor my expertise to discard what’s available in our national text books.
The video is purely based on finding of Sinauli and is on all the information provided is by the ASI which has the real expertise and Dr manjul, the person who led the team.
Neither me nor most people commenting have the expertise on the matter to discard his findings.
@@akkaara Appeal to Authority aye? You are Engaging in Classical logical fallacy of appealing to authority, NEP and NCERT are not the authority in determining what is history and what is not. Those Authority lies with scholars who research the field and majority of them and also the current scholarly consensus is calling it Indus valley civilization and not Sindu Saraswathi Civilization (which is what Hindu Nationalists do), There is Zero Evidence that IVC was Vedic.
This Changes are done due to RSS ideology, and you are just accepting it and propagating it without any critical thinking applied to it. As you said you do not have the expertise, but you can refer to what other experts are talking about it and what is the actual Consensus among them.
We are a channel dedicated to talking about art, craft , architecture and glory of India. We do not need to appeal to anyone. This video is purely about the finding of Sinauli and we have stuck to the facts word by word. Rest of the agenda is not our business. Having said that if Allahabad is called prayagraj today then we will address it as Prayagraj. Our videos are not for scholars but a lot of young population use it for educational purposes. We would use the updated and widely accepted terms. Please watch the video to learn the stated facts not to find fallacy.
why abusive
Teri jal kyu rahi hai , unnecessary moral policing
You are pushing an agenda since you say that 'true' history has been suppressed, you talk of Sindhu 'Sarasvati' civilization etc. Where do you get this Sarasvati? Where in Rigveda do you find the two traditions of burial and cremation? You are wrong when you say that the chariot found in Sinauli is similar to the chariot described in the Vedas. Which Veda, where/ You cleverly do not give reference. Vedic chariots had spoked wheels and the Sinauli chariot has disk wheels.
You are from WhatsApp uni, a phd in Vedas😅
@@vish2553 Instead of indulging in ad hominem, answer the questions raised if you can. And if you cannot better listen to Mark Twain: It is better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than open it and remove all doubt.
@@bapuheddur284 obviously your irrelevant comments about Vedas shows that Mark Twain was right after all 😩
@@vish2553 You are not answering the questions raised. Is it irrelevant to ask "Where in Rigveda do you find the two traditions of burial and cremation?" Is it irrelevant to ask "the chariot found in Sinauli is similar to the chariot described in which Vedas?" Answer me IF YOU CAN.
@ you are not qualified to ask questions with the irrelevant comments you have made 😒 what’s app is not a recognised sambradhya school! Keep proving Mark Twain right 😂 Now join a traditional Vedic padasala and start learning vedas under a learned pandit.
Goodbye. Of course you can the last waffle.
Bail gadi
bail gadi ke saath Talwar kya kar raha hai?
No one has ever found saraswati nor did it ever flow in the same region as Indus river, even according to the puranas then only a fool would call it sindhu-saraswati. This is like saying Ganga-Kaveri or Narmada-Brahmputra. Hai koi logic aapki baat mein?
According to National Curriculum Framework for School Education 2023 and the National Education Policy 2020, all NCERT books refer to the Harappan civilization as the 'Indus-Sarasvati' or 'Sindhu-Sarasvati' civilisation, highlighting the prominence of the Sarasvati river.
These changes are not done by me. But while passing information on our channel we do intend to adhere to updated versions . It’s neither my place nor my expertise to discard what’s available in our national text books.
The video is purely based on finding of Sinauli and is on all the information provided is by the ASI which has the real expertise and Dr manjul, the person who lead the team.
Neither me nor most people commenting have the expertise on the matter to discard his findings.
It means it is clear you have no knowledge on Google maps.
Still river saraswati was flowing near badrinath. You can see in Google maps also.
Exact same location that was mentioned in Mahabharata and skanda puran.
Even Google map also named it as a river saraswati a tributary to alakananda.
But you barking without perfect knowledge by listening fake historians.😂😂😂😂😂
That's a daft argument... Why do you think there are large sites like Dholavira in the middle of a desert if there was no water source? This Thapar and Habib history had destroyed generations.
Ajj v Bo log hai inka population 80lak k aaspaas hai...
Sanatan Dharm & Hindu oka Raksha karna SouthEast Asia ko civilized karna logo ko engineering science technology May Advance karna ya sub pramukh kam tha Bo log Devdutt Thai
Kharab politics k Karan Bo log Ajj Hide hai
I dont understand why people fake theory of #Romilathapar #IrfanHabibi n other who jever educated from Hisoty, ancient and archeology but weote Aryan theory
Reality in ancient people from India migrated to all over world.
Why you guys are pressing that same people of Sindh migrated and throwing artefacts everywhere...why can’t simply say the civilisation was growing simultaneously
Sinauli resembled aryan ,iranian migration chariot and matched with time line of aryan migration 2000 bc or 4000 years old.And pottery also matchd with vedic aryan migration time-line
Aryan tribes buried their dead with their jewelry and chariots. This can be seen in south east European excavations too like in present Armenia etc.
this predates aryan invasion era . mixing of aryan dna isnt older than 1000-1500 bc
Sir these burial pits are from the Era before the so called aryan invasion. Thus cannot be credited to their rituals.
@@akkaara yes that is what i am saying and according to some studies R1A1 dna is found in higher amount in south indians than north indians and some central asian tribes so aryan invason is a myth . these are english flowers with a parrot mind . keeps immitating doesnt improve.
@akkaara We got many unreleased ancient samples from India- Medieval Kashmir,Sanauli,Megalithic South India and others.
There's one sample from Sanauli(post Harappan) which was majority Steppe_MLBA(60-80%).
I can literally show u.
Almost all of these samples are all under the supervision and affiliation of Dr. Niraj Rai.
Who are these aryans? Our texts which so carefully documented kings and lineages never mentioned any foreign invasion by these “aryans” nor any mention of they invading or migrating from a different land. “Arya” just meant someone who adhered to principles of dharma in Indian references.