Ranking Manga Art
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 жов 2024
- #anime #manga #ranking
Manga gets crusty :(
Another 50 minute video who would've thought. This isn't a scripted vid and is a lot closer to a livestream or something like that. It's more chill so i'd recommend listening to this while cleaning the house or something lol
Socials:
Instagram: / fumbuswumbusart
Twitter: / fumbuswumbus
Tiktok: / fumbus_wumbus
Timestamps:
Demon Slayer: 2:30
Attack on Titan: 5:12
D. Gray Man: 6:42
Vagabond: 9:24
Berserk: 10:00
Vinland Saga: 11:10
Dragon Ball: 12:07
Baki: 12:46
Urasawa Works: 13:33
Boys Love: 15:43
Black Clover 16:43
Asano Works: 17:27
Hunter x Hunter: 18:44
One Piece: 21:33
Naruto: 25:04
Bleach: 27:16
My Hero Academia: 28:34
Blame: 29:06
Jujutsu Kaisen: 31:05
Chainsaw Man 32:26
Boruto 33:11
Dr. Stone: 34:07
Fairy Tail: 34:34
Fullmetal Alchemist: 34:56
Fruits Basket: 36:39
Sailor Moon 37:29
Gantz 38:30
Jojo's Bizarre Adventure: 39:25
Kingdom: 40:39
Land of the Lustruous: 41:11
Mob Psycho 100: 42:21
Nana: 43:18
Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind: 44:18
One Punch Man: 45:10
Bibliomania: 45:39
Soul Eater: 46:27
Tokyo Ghoul: 47:23
Uzumaki 47:49
Toilet bound Hanako-kun: 49:37
Alright guys imma have to update my ranking a tad bit and admit that yes….i did rate JJK’s art a bit too high
I still agree that what I said at the time held was true, over time I felt like his art was a bit too inconsistent for my liking and that while his art in shinjuku showdown was still good in terms of choreography it just didn’t hold a candle to culling games or shibuya in terms of the way characters were drawn
Also I honestly don’t feel like gege is the greatest when it comes to making volume covers or promo art upon closer inspection
I think now I’d still have it a worst like a B, but I’m still leaning towards A just cus of the things I mentioned in this video
Gachiakuta u should read it. It's fun
Who in their right mind thinks that jjk's artstyle is better than jojos
Fr💀
My friend dropped jojo because the art was “trash” hes weird
You do know there's a thing called opinion right?
@@Nuggirts that is true
@@Nuggirts yeah, jojo is overall better
jjk in s tier is a bit of a crime (imo)
We do not talk about shinjuku showdown arc art style
It's a matter of preference
It's an A for sure
jjk is a great series, but the art is pretty good at best. i'd give it a high B tier
How the hell do you put jjk on s tier and bleach in bottom a tier
I would not correlate art skill that strongly with consistency. I have seen many comics (particularly in unprofessional fields) that have immense consistency, but use it as a crutch for the artist to avoid doing anything challenging, or fudge their way around learning the basics. That generally is not the case here, most of these are professional artists who know what they are doing, but I would argue that the mark of a great artist in an industry like manga is the ability to either effectively use art to convey the tone and ideas of their story, or at least their ability to show the audience something new and interesting, rather than just trudging along on the eternal Shonen grind.
Jjk glazing is strong with this one 😭🗣️🙏
28:04 Kubo in fact draws backgrounds, like the Soul Society and other scenery, it's just that when he focuses more on the character's perspective, their emotion and also most fights, then he doesn't draw backgrounds, cause he wants to focus more on the characters themselves and their emotions.
At the end of the day at least I can rest easy knowing only JoJo’s was featured at the Louvre. What other manga has done that? Best manga art tbh
Its very hard to rate these stuff, because some of these manga are monthly releases or went monthly after awhile which means they can afford to spend more time on polish stuff, etc. While weekly manga focus more on getting down the most important stuff while manga's like Berzerk can release 1-2 chapters in a year where it can polish or add insane amount of details. If you are going to rate by artist skill its pretty hard too as everyone works on different styles, but sometimes you can see these cross-overs panels paying tribute to different manga's which is cool to see when they don't do anything related to their IP. One of the more unique one out of it probably has to be Tite kubo given that his old artstyle (from Zombie powder) reminds me a bit about Trigun which has its own charm, but later on he evolves his style in Bleach. Its not that Kubo can't draw backgrounds he did a fair amount in the early bleach on a pretty high level, but he chooses not to where the characters become the main focal points, However some of his new stuff today are pretty insane when he takes his time especially what he did for the TYBW cour 1 end credit in the anime. When kubo continues the manga again and goes bi-weekly or monthly its going to be insane.
Holy yap
AND THE JJK GLAZINGG bro this cant be real ur tweaking over the fact that theres flow in the combat scenes like all the other action manga come on mane
Timestamps:
Demon Slayer: 2:30
Attack on Titan: 5:12
D. Gray Man: 6:42
Vagabond: 9:24
Berserk: 10:00
Vinland Saga: 11:10
Dragon Ball: 12:07
Baki: 12:46
Urasawa Works: 13:33
Boys Love: 15:43
Black Clover 16:43
Asano Works: 17:27
Hunter x Hunter: 18:44
One Piece: 21:33
Naruto: 25:04
Bleach: 27:16
My Hero Academia: 28:34
Blame: 29:06
Jujutsu Kaisen: 31:05
Chainsaw Man 32:26
Boruto 33:11
Dr. Stone: 34:07
Fairy Tail: 34:34
Fullmetal Alchemist: 34:56
Fruits Basket: 36:39
Sailor Moon 37:29
Gantz 38:30
Jojo's Bizarre Adventure: 39:25
Kingdom: 40:39
Land of the Lustruous: 41:11
Mob Psycho 100: 42:21
Nana: 43:18
Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind: 44:18
One Punch Man: 45:10
Bibliomania: 45:39
Soul Eater: 46:27
Tokyo Ghoul: 47:23
Uzumaki 47:49
Nice to see some D.Gray-Man Love :) great video man.
9:50 Inoue also made slam dunk, and while not as intricate as vagabond, is also really REALLY well drawn. And that was weekly, in shonen jump.
We seem to have similar taste in art. Although I do feel that Naruto is the best out of the big 3, because it makes the characters feel more like human beings, and he’s such a good artist. I would also probably switch JJK and Chainsaw Man, but I like them for similar reasons.
I love the Hunter x Hunter art so much. It feels like the art was made for the manga format. If you colored it, it would look terrible, but it looks absolutely gorgeous in black and white. I love the simple character designs, they just have so much character to them. And the fact that it isn’t very consistent makes the detailed panels go hard and the poorly drawn panels hurt a little less. The anime just looks so generic, and it annoys me when people say the anime looks better because the manga looks terrible. As for Shojo manga, although I don’t think the art is very amazing, I do think that it has a benefit as a storytelling tool. I feel like it is really good at capturing a mood and tone of a scene really well that is somewhat lacking in a lot of Shonen and Seinen I’ve read. It’s hard to explain. Also would love to see where Devilman and Fist of the North Star rank, as I feel that Devilman is cool and very detailed and North Star is just a better looking version of early JoJo. Also a tier list for art in anime original series like Gundam and Kill la Kill.
I think bleach has the best art style because it is one of the only manga that makes a simple art style work I also just think Naruto’s art style is average
@@Bigeblaze1 Naruto does more in art style then Bleach though, when it comes to characters, background, emotion I'm not sure how Bleach takes it
@@mdrago2098 yeah I agree I just don’t enjoy the art of Naruto all that much tbh
@@mdrago2098 when I mean average I just mean bleach’s art style has the like simple art style with those semi weird and very masculine chins while I feel Naruto’s art is good I just don’t see anything that stands out
@@mdrago2098 they are just different and I.personally like bleach’s art style a tad better but it’s not something everyone has to agree with
Ngl, I feel like in the JJK section you made some points that kinda contradict/slightly invalidate the way that you're rankings these? Like you're talking about how the important thing with JJK is the "rhythm" of it, however when you're looking at some of these mangas that you haven't read before like BLAME, you're looking at individual pages and not as a whole? And another point on slightly biased ranking, is that all of these manga is just 1 piece of work at 1 time frame in each of these mangakas carrers, but for Urasawa and Asano, you're ranking their art as a whole when their body of works span over decades, which ofc in that amount of time, they would have most likely improved and refined their work, which could be the same for some of theses other artist, that if you were to take all their bodies of work as a whole, could drastically change thier position?
Also I think not talking about paneling is kinda odd considering it's a video about MANGA art, since some of these mangakas are KNOWN for their amazing paneling work like Tatsuki Fujimoto, and CSM does even have some creative use of paneling . Also on the point of CSM, it's funny how the panel you chose when you started to talk about how CSM has stiff looking characters, it's an insanely tense moment in the manga where Denji is meant to be tense
I would obviously disagree with the placement of a lot of these mangas, but at the end of the day, you can't tell another person that they should like something as much as you like something, as it is a ranking on something as subjective like art
Like I said, there's gonna be some issues cus some manga I have more first hand experience with and others I either don't or not as much. I read a little bit of blame at barnes and noble and jjk I read week to week so yeh there's gonna be some unfairness unfortunately.
Just to clear things up I do generally just like jjk's art more in terms of style, panel flow, and in some cases even individual panels (although blame had some bangers especially in its' architecture). It was tough especially when some of these manga it feels like i'm giving them a taste test rather than a fully formed opinion cus i'm seeing them for the first time.
There is some stuff i kinda missed of course so i chose to just talk about what sticks out to me. For one piece composition and visual clarity is a major talking point, for jjk is fights and panel flow, for vagabond it's those individual breathing taking pages. There were also some i just didn't have much to say so i'd rather not try to pad things out (the vid was already long enough lol). So if i couldn't say much about a manga u like then sry bout that
either way i still had fun recording this and I hope u still enjoyed the vid
your gfs right tbhk should've had a 40 minute segment that breaks down the complexities and evolution of its art as a monthly manga
So glad you put mha in s tier immideately. Horikoshis artistry has gone underrated for way too long, one of the best artists in shonen jump.
You gotta respect Oda tho. Most manga art becomes more messy toward the end of the series because the artists are too overworked. But Oda has been making weekly chapters for 25 years and it’s still pretty good.
Honestly that’s a great point, oda is the goat 🐐
his art has improved so much and continues to get better imo
I mean his art is more loose now compared to his early one piece, in his early works he would apply screentone to give a sense of depth but this you don't see him do anymore or to a much smaller degree.
@@WieldMyWord I think his paneling had become worse and his art is more cluttered but I think he has greatly improved on his art style
@@skilledbros
I really love how magical & colorful the world of One Piece is. I also love how unashamedly cartoonish the art style is.
Always nice to see some D.Gray-Man recognition. :) It’s one of my all time favourite series. However, It’s sadly quite overlooked.
It’s still pretty niche but turning around a bit thanks to creators like the masked man, arveuss and alexenterprises
That’s true. They’ve all made great content about D.Gray-Man which have introduced the series to more people that hadn’t really heard of it before. :)
I'm new to the channel and I really like how you explain stuff, pretty good. Just one thing about this specific tier list, I feel that jjk and csm art are on the same boat, where they're a.bit rough but the battles give it all, and I actually prefer csm art both because those stand out panels are just so incredible and the panelling is on the level of dragon ball that makes it super easy to read
I think chainsaw man has more standout panels but I like the flow of panels, the artstyle itself, and posing more in jjk. They’re definitely very comparable cus they’re both rough like u said but I notice csm stumbles a bit more in posing and such. I think the author even admitted this himself cus he was primarily self taught. But yeh both r still really good and I feel like it came down to personal preference. But we’re all entitled to our own opinions ofc
Jojo literaly has no artstyle because it change's between parts which make's it unigue and bizzare. putting it in A is wild.
??? he's just ranking how it looks as a whole
NEVER rank again 😭
this video was a crime bruh 😭🙏
it's his opinion?
@@jianxey.his opinion can still be scrutinized by another opinion. It’s like saying only artist can critique art 💀
15:44 this is going to be an "erm! well, actually! 🤓" moment, but just so you know, all of the images you pulled up were VERY old 😭
most if not all newer and more recent bl manga has good art. sasaki and miyano, lovesickness of the wolf, link click, slow damage, etc.
i dont read much bl but most newer ones that i've read have good art. 👍
My personal favorites are hunter x hunter the oldfashion type drawing is so good and jojos, i mean its jojos
No way in hell jjk art is ranked higher than mha
I like Vagabond artstyle more, But I appreciate Berserk art in the same level
Same same
I don’t know how I feel about One Piece being better in color. I feel like sometimes it can look vibrant, and other times it looks pretty bad. I feel the black and white is more consistent. I’m sure if Oda colored it, it would be amazing. Although I think that with the One Piece remake, I think it could be the best version of the story with more color and better action.
Another hot take: Hunter x Hunter manga looks better than the anime. The anime looks so generic. But I see that many people prefer the anime, and this is why people say “Togashi should just write the story, and let’s someone else draw.” This is because they only care about the anime and want it to continue
Edit: which anime do you think is better than the manga? If you want you can make a video about it.
I genuinely feel like one piece in color is my fav Fs. I never encountered a panel that was bad or anything but I can see the value in black and white. They still did a good job in replicating odas colors style for the most part imo
Idk if I’d say Hunter x Hunter is straight up better, but the best panels are truly peak
Also to answer ur question I think demon slayer anime is better from what I experienced (not a hot take I think most ppl will agree)
But I also think jjk is better as an anime as well.
One piece anime has many parts that I think elevated the source material. In fact I think some of the best moments of one piece were just done better in the anime because there were extra scenes to build up the emotions. There were certain scenes from the one piece anime that I really loved but I was disappointed they weren’t in the manga 😢
What I do now is read one piece and go back watch the moment I just read but in the anime
@@fumbuswumbus I dropped the anime pretty early on at Alabasta, and I did not really notice any of the emotional moments in the manga to be bad. In fact the way he draws just brings a lot to the story imo and it’s hard to imagine the anime doing them better. Although I have seen I wanna live which is amazing in both versions, I can’t decide which is better, and the punch of the celestial dragon is just straight up better.
I’ve heard that JJK anime is better, but I’m more of a casual reader and don’t really have any strong desire to watch it. It probably is great as I have heard amazing things about Shibuya anime. But as a “casual manga reader” which is a weird thing to say, I have only read it. Might check out the anime when the manga finishes in 8 months or so.
i dont care if naruto chainsaw man or blame is at b but what the f is db doing at s tier?
peak panelling and fights
Real shit looks flat
Honestly this is one of the things I mostly agree with. Dragon ball has pretty solid panels and good use of space with its art. Dragon ball deserves a high tier placement imo
imo PunPun deserves a S. Asano might be my favorite artist rn, not only his writting is good his art always hit so damn hard
also jjk S but Vinland or Bleach not really hurts to see, but at the end of the day its just opinion based
Is this ranking on the artists overall work or just on one manga. With boichi (arist of dr stone) there art is up there with vagabond and berserk imo. The art gets to the point where it genuinely looks realistic ever panel
Bro OPM has the greatest manga art of all time no contest and it’s such a great series with a proper mix of spectacle and comedy
the composition in one punch man is god tier shyeet
Honestly one of the only manga I'd say contests with one punch man in terms of art is like.. some parts of dr stone.
Opm the only manga where the Art make the serie straight 10
naruto really does have great perspective. the fight scenes are also great and swift
ONG
I've watch only the reboot of Fruits basket and it was great imo, so I can recommend this at least lol.
Waiting for part 2
Some names I wish to see : dorohedoro , blue lock , ashita no Joe, after god , hell's paradise, innocent, Usogui
You place fullmetal and one-piece in the wrong places bro they are peak
Kaoru Mori desreved a mention, her character drawings and interior design should not be overlooked.
You. Go give Witch Hat Atelier a look. You'll love it.
I legit was watching this going "it would be cool if one of these lists had D Gray Man" and then DGM popped up
"don't like" dude aot's issue with art is that it is absurdly inconsistent EVEN in the late chapters.
the fact your example of anatomy being bad is a titan, where its supposed to be bad is insane
CHAINSAW MAN IN B TIER IS WILD
blame in b is wild bro
No Kamome Shirahama? No Witch hat Atelier?😢
Jjk art is not good bro. You literally cannot tell what’s going on during combat which is 99% of jjk
Music used for jjk
Fairy Tail at C is insane. It's A tier at least
😂
what about dorohedoro art style
You should try reading/ranking Video Girl AI for romance. Fruits Basket is mid at best, both in art and story.
bro did not put chainsaw man at b tier🙏
"it's great but it doesn't have any standout qualities...it doesn't do anything too too amazing" anyone who holds this opinion about FMA needs to be put in the psych ward
Welp, we gotta take this to court Ig
Except that it is true. It’s a pretty accurate take
@@thomasffrench3639 @marcofoster5095
"It doesn't do anything too amazing", "that's a pretty accurate take",
I don't entirely disagree, I think Hunter x Hunter, One Piece and JoJo are all better as far as battle shonens go so I don't think FMA is the greatest. But I do think at the very least the structure and set up of it is pretty astonishing in its field. The structure because everything is so clear and important, nothing is really wasted, and the setup because of how instinctually moving and evocative it is. Shonens are usually designed to go on forever and aren't very evocative in what their protagonists want. They don't dig deep into the human experience in that regard. FMA's premise really has that timeless, spiritual richness, in its particular blend of fear and hope, physicality and fantasy, pathos and horror. Because the premise is so perfect I think Arakawa is able to build everything else on top of it a lot more seamlessly, its telling that its one of the only shonens of its length that is never split into "arcs" by fans. The work is too unified for that. Even the manga that are better than it can't boast that.
Really I'd say FMA is better at most things than most shonens. But premise and overall structure are the two things that I think Arakawa nailed so perfectly that I can more easily argue for them off the top of my head. I think my big question is, if not FMA, what's a manga that does do something super super amazing?
JJK above JOJO's and Dr. Stone is unacceptable
JJK art that high is glaze ngl, it’s inconsistent asf
My Personal Tier List is:
Demon slayer: Low-Mid D
Attack on Titan: Low-Mid C
D. Gray-Man: High A
Vagabond: Mid A
Berserk: Low-Mid S
Vinland Saga: High B-Low A
Dragon Ball Z: High B
Baki: Mid-High B
Naoki Uresawa: Mid-High A
Boys Love Manga: Didn't Read (Low F, The Proportions of The Panels You Showed are Fucked.)
Black Clover: Low B
GN PunPun (Didn't Read Solanin): High A
Hunter x Hunter: Low B
One Piece: Low S
Naruto: High C-Low B
Bleach: Low A
My Hero Academy: Low C
Blame!: High A
Jujutsu Kaisen: Mid B
Chainsaw Man: Low S
Boruto: High F
Dr. Stone: High A
Fairy Tail: High C
Fullmetal Alchemist: High B
Furit Basket: High C
Sailor Moon: Low S
Gantz: Low S
Jojo's All Parts: Mid-High S
Kingdom: Low A
Land of the Lustrous/Houseki no Kuni: High S
Mob Psycho 100: High A
Nana: Didn't Read (Maybe Mid B)
Nausica: Low S
One Punch Man: Mid S
Bibliomania: High A
Soul Eater: Mid S
Tokyo Ghoul: High S
Uzumaki: High B
Jjk s tier what???
Honestly rn I'd probably have it lower. As it went on it kept becoming a bit too inconsistent for my liking
It's a matter of opinion, and i agree. Gege's posing and fights are incredible.
No one ever mentions Katsuhiro Otomo or Goseki Kojima
Gachiakuta?
What's the song at 47:35?
More respekt til fujimoto and his scinematic feel to it and man S tier panel lay out💩. The way darkness devil looks
28:19 anyone know the background music used?
"Hero A" from My hero Academia
Soundtracks used in the vid
Never rate again 🔥🔥
Demasiado subjetivo ranking
FMA is flawless, how dare you. lol
ok
this isthe worst taste in medium i have seen in a LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOONG time
Bad video. No, I will not elaborate, cause other people have already said enough.
Best manga art in C tier. Wtf?? What a crime. And putting stuff like JJK and OP above it is crazy.
Edit: Nevermind, checked your channel, you're one of those terminally online twitter folk who says objectively illogical points and doesn't have the most basic of basic reading comprehension skills, not engaging with reality, so no wonder these takes are bad lmao. At least these are only takes, can't say that about your other vids.