Varinder.p. Singh Denmark paji fikar na kro. Agar unjaisa log hy toh hum jaise log vi toh hy jinke lahu me aj vi incalab baheta hy. Blo incalab zindabad, bharat mata ki jy
I am so sorry Bhagat Singh ji you had to hear this . where ever you are we all love and respect you and we will never support this. and this people are not even aapke pairon ki dhul, Jo bik Gaye hain Desh ki barbadi karne me woh kya samjhenge aapko .
Well, who really benefited by Gandhi's Ahimsa propaganda and suppression of revolutionaries. He delayed Indian independence by 20 to 30 yrs so that colonialists did not feel any pressure during world wars. Gandhi supported recruitment of 2.5 million Indian soldiers (to be used as cannon fodder in world war I and II) In fact, Gandhi himself was a soldier in South Africa (fought in Anglo Boer War 1899) before becoming a barrister. Gandhi was brainwashed by leo-tolstoy's (a crypto jew) non-violence ramblings before being imported by East India company to India through Gokhale). We have proof of letter correspondence between leo-tolstoy and MK Gandhi.
+kashsoldier Arnab has come around on Indian Nationalism. Welcome Sir, I (we) welcome you. Now you could see how East India Company was taken over by JawaharLal Nehru Private Limited Corp. aka the CONgis. I am telling you my fellow Indians, *WE MUST DISMANTLE CONGRess PARTY ASAP. WE MUST PUT CONGRess PARTY TO REST IN NEXT GENERAL ELECTION* . Jai Hind! Jai Bhawani! Jai Maharashtra! Jai Punjab! Jai Bengal! Jai Bhim! Sabhi ki mata ki jai! Bharat Mata Ki Jai!
yeah right.. he died in 1931.. bhai independence movement mei bohot logo ke sacrifices hai.. ek do logo ko credit dena band karo.. moreover in his book bhagat singh wrote that methods of revolutionaries were not useful.. only way to get independence was to ignite people.. that's why he bombed the assembly..
+Rishank Devadiga Arre! Yaar! Why waste your time with dimwits? The BJP bhakths will believe soon Hedgewar got us independence 😃😃😃 Let them imagine and reimagine history. Come 2019 we can dump all this nonsense in the bin!
@@GabbarSeTakkar I laughed a lot when you said hedgewar gave us independence. Actually bhakts are the biggest hypocrites. They hate and abuse communists but tend to respect Bhagat Singh a lot. That is their hypocrisy. History also says that it were some RSS people who gave statement against Bhagat Singh in court. And moreover, Bhagat Singh was fully secular, too secular more than Gandhiji and Pandit Nehru. and bhakts hate seculars. That is their hypocrisy. Bhagat Singh has refered RSS to be Musolini group. Actually they don't have anyone contributed in India's independence, so they try to swing in Bhagat Singh's legacy. But their hypocrisy is that he was a communist as well a secular, people whom they hate nowadays.
Thank you Arnab for standing your ground in the face of adversity regarding the legend like Bhagat Singh, who is a true hero. If it wasn't for him, we would've gotten dominion status, however, it was Bhagat Singh who asked for "Poorun Swaraj" - total independence.
we should have Bhagat Singh's picture on currency notes along with M Gandhi's picture . i mean Bhagat singh sacrificed equally if not more than Gandhi .who agrees with me
कभी नोटों के लिये मर गये कभी वोटों के लिये मर गये, कभी भगवान के नाम पे मर गये कभी अल्लाह के नाम पे मर गये, कभी जात पात के नाम पर मर गये कभी आपस में दो गज जमीन के लिय मर गये, होंगे जहां भी वीर भगत सिंह तो कहते होंगे... यार सुखदेव - हम भी किन कमीनों के लिये मर गये!!!
Arnab has come around on Indian Nationalism. Welcome Sir, I (we) welcome you. Now you could see how East India Company was taken over by JawaharLal Nehru Private Limited Corp. aka the CONgis. I am telling you my fellow Indians, *WE MUST DISMANTLE CONGRess PARTY ASAP. WE MUST PUT CONGRess PARTY TO REST IN NEXT GENERAL ELECTION* . Jai Hind! Jai Bhawani! Jai Maharashtra! Jai Punjab! Jai Bengal! Jai Bhim! Sabhi ki mata ki jai! Bharat Mata Ki Jai!
If Bhagat Singh was called "terrorist" 16 times in a history book, what were all the professors, students, parents etc doing all these years ? Or didn't they know whom to complain to ? Isn't there no mechanism to point out such "errors" ? Who were the so called "historians" who wrote this ? Their names should have been given credit in the book. What were they thinking ? Shouldn't they be questioned ? How many such falsehoods are there in history books ? I have lost faith in history.
***** If you think public discussion is only about rebuttals then..... aw hell forget it, you seem like an ass. Dip shits like you don't know how to be thankful for what you have now. Even if you are from pakistan if it hadn't been for countless revolutionaries your ass would have been still raided by colonial brits.
***** When did I claim you are from pakistan I said "If". I don't make claims like troll bhakts do. Btw Bhagat singh fought when he was alive you have undermined his existence ever since you have appeared in this section.
***** Gandhi contributed In his own way. But you seem to be comparing people who fought for our independence just like low life fucking bhakts. I will say this once, you disgust me.
This type of comment against Bhagat Singh is clear indication that in near future country is going to be slave and no any Bhagat Singh will come forward to this thankless country.
My elders were school mates with Bhagat singh Os daa apnee dharti naal bahut piar cee We are very surprise that Ajj Sara Pakistan Bhagat Singh ko Jaad karkeh ro riha hai Ih Jo Indian historian han mano lagda ih English dee olad han Jeh aj Bhagat Singh hunda tan tuhanu pushda ki Country free Tuhadeh laee kraee cee ki tusi manoo terrorist sado Os neh fir vapis aa jaan a hai ma dee KASH vich luk jaio fir Bhonkdeh ho Gadhi teh Nehro neh kee keeta kush nahi Ohna divan neh Bhagat singh Rajguru Sukhdev noo fansi lvaee cee ta ki oh india deh pardhaan Mantri bann sakan
Shame on you Indian Historian Bevkoof You should be proud of your freedom fighter We read so many English books they saying that Bhagat Singh is the person who first started to fight for freedom
Bhagat Singh is a hero. A really great one at that. Bhagat Singh, Rajguru and Sukhdev are heroes of Indian freedom. I'm Nigerian but I love Bhagat Singh. I've read all of his letters several times. What a legend!
jaskaran gill Sir Bhagat singh is a great man.. He is not so cheap to print on note....... He is in our heart , photos are printed of those who died but Bhagat singh is alive in all of us....
I am constantly watching your debates. I really appreciate your way of Journalism. Some people are criticizing you but I think they have relation with the politician to whom you have exposed for their corruption or those young people who have lack of knowledge, they are not very well aware about the situation and conditions of the country or those who don't have time to think on these issues. But in my point of view you are doing a phenomenal, marvelous and fantastic job. Hats off to you. Amazing personality. Just doing your job with your own standpoint, simultaneously you should take care of your health too. Don't take that aggression on your mind, if someone trying to let you down. keep it up. My all best wishes are with you and times now. with Regards, Reena Singh
Bhagat Singh sacrificed his life for the country and people sit at home, enjoying their free lives talking about Bhagat Singh being a terrorist?? How sad..wish I was never born..
Veer ji tumheh aap books likhnni chahideh Bhagat Singh Raj guru sukh dev Os keh lieh reference books proof milde an han Or there are so many elderly still alive in Pakistan where Bhagat Singh was born They can tell you truth about Bhagat singh On ytube there are so many video from Pakistan and India you can watch More over Bhagat Singh dee sister abhi jinda hai os seh pusho Ic bahis meh ik English Historian jaroor honna chahieh Tab to kisee neh nahi bolnna tha Bevkoof lok kadar nahi paiee in honeh gadha hai
दिन आज तो बड़ा सुहाना मौसम भी बड़ा सुनहरा हम सर पे बाँध के आये बलिदानों का ये सेहरा बेताब हमारे दिल में इक मस्ती सी छायी है ऐ देश अलविदा तुझको कहने की घडी आई है महकेंगे तेरी फिज़ा में हम बन के हवा का झोंका किस्मत वालों को मिलता ऐसे मरने का मौका निकली है बरात सजा है इंक़लाब का डोला मेरा रंग दे... मेरा रंग दे बसंती चोला माये रंग दे मेरा रंग दे बसंती चोला माये रंग दे मेरा रंग दे बसंती चोला रंग दे, रंग दे.. रंग दे बसंती चोला माये रंग दे.. Bhagat Singh, Rajguru and Sukhdev were heard singing this just before they smilingly walked into the gallows to be hanged till death and lay their lives forever in the service and love of their "Mother" india...."Mai Re"...they said! I A thousand salutes and tearful bows to you our Beloved Heros of freedom for choosing to die for us rascals who cant even honor your life, leave alone your heroic death. You were only 23! Didnt you have dreams, love, a life you would have selfishly loved to live, like us, rather than die at such a tender age for your "Mother"? Beloved Bhagat Singh ji, We are truly ashamed. Mother India will remember a daring son like you for years and years to come. Vande Matram!
Bhagat Singh - You are in our hearts & minds and no power can fizz out from ourselves, Masterda Surya Sen - You taught us how to fight with limited resource against the most powerful strength of the world if your determination is strong as iron and mind is without fear; Mridula Mukherje and other congress laid historians - We don't need your education, we don't need thought control..GO TO HELL
Aranab let me tel you one thing , the people who is sitting in your office saying Bhagat singh was a revolutionary terrorist should immediately send to prison, They r anti-national...... And let comment to your TV , these type of debate should not be there on you channel . Dont do these type of debate to just increase your TRP
As an UPSC student we are told by teachers to read this book and i have read it multiple times....thanks for bringing up the issue....so there is a whole generation of bureaucrats with their minds modified intentionally
this writers need to be in jail and what ever money they made out of these books need to be donated and should be highly penalized. it is nota mistake, these writers are still working for British and want them to take over India again. First stupid guy in the show said that bhagat singh and his group would have gone to any extend to get freedom. . One patriotic will go to any extend to get freedom. according to these writers every solders is terrorist. because of these kind of people British were rule on us. These are born slave to white skin . Bhagat singh died in 22 years of age he did not get to live as Gandhi did 78 year old. These writers are terrorist by them self and have NO respect for country or freedom fighters. Freedom violence is not terrorism. without was can not be a freedom. these writters should not be not allowed on chenal. these should not called historians and should not be allowed to write any book about anything.
My message to our Bravest freedom fighter Bhagat singhji may this so called history Book ncert forgot you your struggle for freedom struggle for Bharat mata But we the youth of india 🇮🇳 will never ever forget you the Bravest youthfredome fighter of india 🇮🇳 🧡🤍💚
jis bande ki wajah se hum sab log aaj azaadi ki sans le rahe he uske bare me agar esa koi sochta he to sidha mujhse baat kare me bataunga ki terrorist kesa hota hai kaat ke rakhg dunga saalo Inqalab Zindabad...!!!
These all historians are idiots and the ias students should have wrote to publishers to correct this. I can't believe this is being taught and even published.
yes it is a problem, 90% of social studies text book( especially in 10th std) is about gandhian movement and just mention extemist movement as mere unsuccessful attempt. Seriously there needs to be balance. I am not saying non violent movement is wrong it was one of the biggest reason why we got freedom. but atleast we need one chapter for this martyrs
+Kashiv Ranik quite india movement was failed as soon as British start regaining its terrorist in WW2...in 1942 but we got independence due to the mutiny by INA and the rise of nationalism in British Indian army..mainly due to bose
If we can call MK Gandhi as Mahatma for his Independence movements and Jawaharlal Nehru as a freedom fighter.... then how dare you label the Revolutionaries as terrorists... had it not been for the terror struck by these men in the minds of British we would be slaves for a longer period... we must change the books.... this is not a slight of academia.... this is Blasphemy....
first sentence of general GD bakshi was so true. historians think that wo Jo likhenge log wahi manenge, jise psnd karenge use hero bna denge nd jise mn use terrorist. saale inke so called freedom hero nehru etc, Kbhi jail gye !? kbhi laat khai, sirf Gandhi ji k pichhe khade hoke luxury life ji or logo ko bhasan Diya.
I read this book three days back as I am preparing for UPSC and even I was taken aback by seeing the word "revolutionary terrorist" for Shaheed Bhagat Singh and other martyrs. I was thinking to write to the publisher and Ministry of Human resource Development to take some action and to correct the word and today by chance I came across this debate. Happy to see that many people also want some action to be taken. And the biggest irony you know, this is the most read book by UPSC aspirants and many IAS, IPS and other central service officers have read this book and reached the place where they are. Most of the successful aspirants suggest this book! This book on a whole is written by Congress funding to the authors I suppose. In the whole book, Congress has been shown as the face of Indian nationalism and leaders like Jawaharlal Nehru has been portrayed the best. His and Gandhi's achievements have been very much highlighted throughout the book and undermining those of others like Subhash Chandra Bose, Bhagat Singh, etc. And do you know the book just covers just 2 pages on Bhagat Singh. Just two pages! The every wrong decision of the Congress and especially Mahatma Gandhi has been justified for example the abrupt calling off the non-cooperation movement.
This is not just an internal conspiracy of India. If we refer to the findings of Mr Rajiv Malhotra, there is a concerted effort by foreign powers to inculcate a sense of worthlessness among Indians, for which they have also bought over some of our so called academicians.
By calling Bhagat singh a terrorist, they are legitimizing the British rule. What a ridiculous school of thought. Why are these people even here??. They should have left with the British. Why are they Indian citizens??
26 references in a chapter calling the legendary bhagat Singh a terrorist and no one objected till now ..seriously this can happen only in India. really sad
It is a deliberate attempt to show that Bhagat Singh was Atheist, I would like to ask a small question to prove that he was not a Atheist but Believed in Sikhism ? How many Atheist wear Sikh Pagadi??????
bro we live in a country which biased only strong political people are legend. just because shaheed bhagat Singh was a ordinary boy who did extraordinary work. but historians puppets of Britisher wrote terrorist words. I mean who could they.
Though I am also pro Bhagat Singh. But yes he was Marxist in his belief and denounced religion and God. In his early ages he was follower of religion but later when he denounced all religions when he studied and read about concepts of European liberty, fraternity, Secularism etc he was influenced by them and became atheist. Read his own book, Read his family background.... His revolutionary ideas are influenced from French revolution. Pagadi on the other hand most of people even after becoming atheist wear just because of family traditions there are many other cultural sects other than Sikhs who wear Pagadi in spite of different religious bias or no religious bias, in fact they are more into culture than religion. But his personal belief whether Hindu, Sikh, Atheist etc won't make any difference in respect for him
Certified Experts Vs Common Man Wearing pagdi was common in punjab ..not only sikhs, other castes or religion used to wear pagdi too.. im hindu living in punjab n my grandfather n father wear pagdi too and bhagat singh cut his hairs too n Sikhs don't allowed to cut their hairs. So Clothes don't define A Man just know that
Baghat singh is was and will always be shaheed , he doesn't need label from anybody . Gandhi is only on Indian currency and bhaghat singh is in our hearts.
Bhagat Singh was not terrorist. He was a revolutionist and same is the case with Burhan Wani. Both has laid their life for the freedom of their country..
Dil Dil Pak i also live in J&K ... keep ur burhan to urself.... omar fayaz was also a kashmiri... pandits were also kashmiri and they didn't wanted any fucking freedom.. u piece of crap
My name is Bhagat Singh and I am not a terrorist. Shame on those people who think Bhagat Singh was a terrorist. Kya ho gaya desh ko Bhagat Singh ko bhi apna pehechan dena paad raha hai.
why indian govt allow so called historian to publish or imposing their own propoganda on youth , university authority before making curriculum atleast should correct the fact & people who written bhagat singh as a terrorist should make apology in public for same .
How mean people they r.shame on that kind of people.. Always proud on Bhagat Singh..every Indian must know about him. He deserves so much respect .a National holiday and one chapter of every textbook about him.. And Mr Arnav deserve so much appreciation.. 👍👍👍
Penalists can have any opinion about bhagat sing ji, but in the millions of mind he is a greatest hero of our country often mother India gives such great sons to our country as long as sun shines these freedom fighters will remain in the minds ,in the hearts and in the soul of billions of people
Yaar bhagat singh tum b kin logon k lye mrr gaye
he would've wondered the same if is alive
Varinder.p. Singh Denmark paji fikar na kro. Agar unjaisa log hy toh hum jaise log vi toh hy jinke lahu me aj vi incalab baheta hy. Blo incalab zindabad, bharat mata ki jy
Shuvam Pal ..nice dear thanx
sahe ha bhai bharat mata ki jay
Varinder.p. Singh Denmark sahi kaha Bhai wo bhagat Singh Jo humare liye 116 din tak bina pani ke hadtaal kiya salute bhagat Singh he is our role model
I am so sorry Bhagat Singh ji you had to hear this . where ever you are we all love and respect you and we will never support this. and this people are not even aapke pairon ki dhul, Jo bik Gaye hain Desh ki barbadi karne me woh kya samjhenge aapko .
Well, who really benefited by Gandhi's Ahimsa propaganda and suppression of revolutionaries. He delayed Indian independence by 20 to 30 yrs so that colonialists did not feel any pressure during world wars. Gandhi supported recruitment of 2.5 million Indian soldiers (to be used as cannon fodder in world war I and II) In fact, Gandhi himself was a soldier in South Africa (fought in Anglo Boer War 1899) before becoming a barrister. Gandhi was brainwashed by leo-tolstoy's (a crypto jew) non-violence ramblings before being imported by East India company to India through Gokhale). We have proof of letter correspondence between leo-tolstoy and MK Gandhi.
+kashsoldier Arnab has come around on Indian Nationalism. Welcome Sir, I (we) welcome you. Now you could see how East India Company was taken over by JawaharLal Nehru Private Limited Corp. aka the CONgis. I am telling you my fellow Indians, *WE MUST DISMANTLE CONGRess PARTY ASAP. WE MUST PUT CONGRess PARTY TO REST IN NEXT GENERAL ELECTION* . Jai Hind! Jai Bhawani! Jai Maharashtra! Jai Punjab! Jai Bengal! Jai Bhim! Sabhi ki mata ki jai! Bharat Mata Ki Jai!
ghandhi=gandhugiri
attitude zero Thank You, Sardaarji !!
Shahbaz Alam Gandhi is the father of pOkistan.
Indian father of the nation is Neta Ji.
Shahbaz Alam Muhammad is a pedophile
Shaheed Bhagat Singh and Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose gave India independence
yeah right.. he died in 1931.. bhai independence movement mei bohot logo ke sacrifices hai.. ek do logo ko credit dena band karo.. moreover in his book bhagat singh wrote that methods of revolutionaries were not useful.. only way to get independence was to ignite people.. that's why he bombed the assembly..
+Rishank Devadiga Arre! Yaar! Why waste your time with dimwits? The BJP bhakths will believe soon Hedgewar got us independence 😃😃😃 Let them imagine and reimagine history. Come 2019 we can dump all this nonsense in the bin!
@@GabbarSeTakkar I laughed a lot when you said hedgewar gave us independence. Actually bhakts are the biggest hypocrites. They hate and abuse communists but tend to respect Bhagat Singh a lot. That is their hypocrisy. History also says that it were some RSS people who gave statement against Bhagat Singh in court. And moreover, Bhagat Singh was fully secular, too secular more than Gandhiji and Pandit Nehru. and bhakts hate seculars. That is their hypocrisy. Bhagat Singh has refered RSS to be Musolini group. Actually they don't have anyone contributed in India's independence, so they try to swing in Bhagat Singh's legacy. But their hypocrisy is that he was a communist as well a secular, people whom they hate nowadays.
@@gunjanverma7785 bhagat singh said " Congress ko humari aazadi nahi sirf kursi se matlb hai " wanna mention that too ?😌
@@soulsuneo1333 right. Ye bat Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose ne vi kaha tha. "Congress ko Azadi se zada Sarkar banane me interest hai."
HONORABLE SIR GENERAL BAKSHI ROCKS.
+DaSnipy Always
+DaSnipy It's a shame really that Gen. after serving our country have to sit through such debates.
general bakshi is awesome ....he puts his dick in these midget's mouths ...fuck these bastards who call bhagat a terrorist
sumit mahajan Bro, that is the price that you got to pay as your fault is that you served in a great army of a great country for worst intellectuals.
Thank you Arnab for standing your ground in the face of adversity regarding the legend like Bhagat Singh, who is a true hero. If it wasn't for him, we would've gotten dominion status, however, it was Bhagat Singh who asked for "Poorun Swaraj" - total independence.
us book ka naam hona chahiye "backchodo ki backchodi"
hahahaha. sahi bola yaar
Sree Sree lolz true
+jassi singh Tu toh har baat be india todta hai
+Jedi Master if they do like that
definitely india totayga
jassi singh So the opinion of some idiots is enough for you?
Also do you know what they are saying is by their own accord are they paid out
It ached my heart when a very close friend of mine , used the same term 'terrorist' to describe THE LEGEND , BHAGAT SINGH.
You need a new friend
BHAGAT SINGH is legend in the heart and minds of true patriots of India , let these worms Murmer which is meaning less.
we should have Bhagat Singh's picture on currency notes along with M Gandhi's picture . i mean Bhagat singh sacrificed equally if not more than Gandhi .who agrees with me
inquilab zindabad backchods who call Bhagat Singh a terrorist should be shot dead
कभी नोटों के लिये मर गये
कभी वोटों के लिये मर गये,
कभी भगवान के नाम पे मर गये
कभी अल्लाह के नाम पे मर गये,
कभी जात पात के नाम पर मर गये कभी आपस में दो गज जमीन के लिय मर गये,
होंगे जहां भी वीर भगत सिंह तो कहते होंगे... यार सुखदेव - हम भी किन कमीनों के लिये मर गये!!!
sahe hai bro jay ho
👏👏👏👌
Well written brother salute you
So trueee
Bahut Asha likhia aap neh
Bevkoof han ih log
Aaj in sabhi neh muslmaan bneh hona tha
Arnab has come around on Indian Nationalism. Welcome Sir, I (we) welcome you. Now you could see how East India Company was taken over by JawaharLal Nehru Private Limited Corp. aka the CONgis. I am telling you my fellow Indians, *WE MUST DISMANTLE CONGRess PARTY ASAP. WE MUST PUT CONGRess PARTY TO REST IN NEXT GENERAL ELECTION* . Jai Hind! Jai Bhawani! Jai Maharashtra! Jai Punjab! Jai Bengal! Jai Bhim! Sabhi ki mata ki jai! Bharat Mata Ki Jai!
+MRG ENT PLC totally agree with you brother
If Bhagat Singh was called "terrorist" 16 times in a history book, what were all the professors, students, parents etc doing all these years ? Or didn't they know whom to complain to ? Isn't there no mechanism to point out such "errors" ? Who were the so called "historians" who wrote this ? Their names should have been given credit in the book. What were they thinking ? Shouldn't they be questioned ? How many such falsehoods are there in history books ? I have lost faith in history.
+Mlob5 Pussyfier Showing your true face are you?
***** If you think public discussion is only about rebuttals then..... aw hell forget it, you seem like an ass. Dip shits like you don't know how to be thankful for what you have now. Even if you are from pakistan if it hadn't been for countless revolutionaries your ass would have been still raided by colonial brits.
***** When did I claim you are from pakistan I said "If". I don't make claims like troll bhakts do.
Btw Bhagat singh fought when he was alive you have undermined his existence ever since you have appeared in this section.
***** Gandhi contributed In his own way. But you seem to be comparing people who fought for our independence just like low life fucking bhakts. I will say this once, you disgust me.
No, disgust because, there's TOO much of a bhakt in it.
what is happening bhai desh ko andhar se thoda jaaraha hai.
this is fucking disspointed
dissapointing
dissapointing
***** true
Arnab has earned respect in my eyes with this debate
This type of comment against Bhagat Singh is clear indication that in near future country is going to be slave and no any Bhagat Singh will come forward to this thankless country.
shame on these historians,, shame ,shame On them
Ih sabh Bevkoof hai
My elders were school mates with Bhagat singh
Os daa apnee dharti naal bahut piar cee
We are very surprise that
Ajj Sara Pakistan Bhagat Singh ko Jaad karkeh ro riha hai
Ih Jo Indian historian han mano lagda ih English dee olad han
Jeh aj Bhagat Singh hunda tan tuhanu pushda ki Country free Tuhadeh laee kraee cee ki tusi manoo terrorist sado
Os neh fir vapis aa jaan a hai ma dee KASH vich luk jaio fir
Bhonkdeh ho
Gadhi teh Nehro neh kee keeta kush nahi
Ohna divan neh Bhagat singh
Rajguru
Sukhdev noo fansi lvaee cee ta ki oh india deh pardhaan Mantri bann sakan
English writer books paroh Jo England dee reference library vich hai
Ajj vee English bow their head to
Bhagat Singh Raj guru sukhdev
And oodam singh
Shame on you Indian Historian
Bevkoof
You should be proud of your freedom fighter
We read so many English books they saying that Bhagat Singh is the person who first started to fight for freedom
Bhagat Singh is a hero. A really great one at that. Bhagat Singh, Rajguru and Sukhdev are heroes of Indian freedom. I'm Nigerian but I love Bhagat Singh. I've read all of his letters several times. What a legend!
Bhagat sing,Chandrasekhar Azad, Subash Chandra Bose 🇮🇳 are real hero of BHARAT
@Prauteeto Ray bhai kya likha tha
india ki currency pe bhagat singh ki photo lagni chahiye na ki gandhi ki
jaskaran gill# bilkul sahi bola yaar
jaskaran gill
Sir Bhagat singh is a great man..
He is not so cheap to print on note.......
He is in our heart , photos are printed of those who died but Bhagat singh is alive in all of us....
Sahi kaha
@@shahbazalam1324 tujhe kyu prblm ho rhi h bhai
Have some respect to the patriot like Bhagat Singh..Before calling him a terrorrist, one should be ashamed of oneself...Outrageous!
Bhagat Singh did not murder any innocent Brtish people.How dare these people call Bhagat Singh a Terrorist
I am constantly watching your debates. I really appreciate your way of Journalism. Some people are criticizing you but I think they have relation with the politician to whom you have exposed for their corruption or those young people who have lack of knowledge, they are not very well aware about the situation and conditions of the country or those who don't have time to think on these issues. But in my point of view you are doing a phenomenal, marvelous and fantastic job. Hats off to you. Amazing personality. Just doing your job with your own standpoint, simultaneously you should take care of your health too. Don't take that aggression on your mind, if someone trying to let you down. keep it up.
My all best wishes are with you and times now.
with Regards,
Reena Singh
Bhagat Singh sacrificed his life for the country and people sit at home, enjoying their free lives talking about Bhagat Singh being a terrorist?? How sad..wish I was never born..
kushal agarwal# same here Bhai 😿😿😿 PTA nhi aise kuttiya k bachhe paida kyun lete hn.
Veer ji tumheh aap books likhnni chahideh Bhagat Singh Raj guru sukh dev
Os keh lieh reference books proof milde an han
Or there are so many elderly still alive in Pakistan where Bhagat Singh was born
They can tell you truth about Bhagat singh
On ytube there are so many video from Pakistan and India you can watch
More over Bhagat Singh dee sister abhi jinda hai os seh pusho
Ic bahis meh ik English Historian jaroor honna chahieh
Tab to kisee neh nahi bolnna tha
Bevkoof lok kadar nahi paiee in honeh gadha hai
Yes shame
"Conspiracy by the court historians..." ----- well put comment by Gen. Bakshi
दिन आज तो बड़ा सुहाना
मौसम भी बड़ा सुनहरा
हम सर पे बाँध के आये
बलिदानों का ये सेहरा
बेताब हमारे दिल में इक मस्ती सी छायी है
ऐ देश अलविदा तुझको कहने की घडी आई है
महकेंगे तेरी फिज़ा में हम बन के हवा का झोंका
किस्मत वालों को मिलता ऐसे मरने का मौका
निकली है बरात सजा है इंक़लाब का डोला
मेरा रंग दे...
मेरा रंग दे बसंती चोला माये रंग दे
मेरा रंग दे बसंती चोला माये रंग दे
मेरा रंग दे बसंती चोला रंग दे, रंग दे..
रंग दे बसंती चोला माये रंग दे..
Bhagat Singh, Rajguru and Sukhdev were heard singing this just before they smilingly walked into the gallows to be hanged till death and lay their lives forever in the service and love of their "Mother" india...."Mai Re"...they said! I A thousand salutes and tearful bows to you our Beloved Heros of freedom for choosing to die for us rascals who cant even honor your life, leave alone your heroic death. You were only 23! Didnt you have dreams, love, a life you would have selfishly loved to live, like us, rather than die at such a tender age for your "Mother"? Beloved Bhagat Singh ji, We are truly ashamed. Mother India will remember a daring son like you for years and years to come. Vande Matram!
+CR7 TV NOW THIS IS A ``COMMENT`` .. SALUTE :)
Salute
He was a separist against british rule close debate thank you.
I am ashamed to say that we were taught more about akbar and his wifes than Bhagat Singh and Azad and Ashfaq ....
Books should be removed from the Uni and put the Authors in Jail.
Bhagat Singh - You are in our hearts & minds and no power can fizz out from ourselves, Masterda Surya Sen - You taught us how to fight with limited resource against the most powerful strength of the world if your determination is strong as iron and mind is without fear; Mridula Mukherje and other congress laid historians - We don't need your education, we don't need thought control..GO TO HELL
1st time arnab is right
What in the world? How is this even a legitimate topic of discussion?
Thank you Bhagat Singh and all other freedom fighters for your service.
well said Smriti ji
'innocent error' wow how impertinently these bunch of rowdies calling our shaeed e azam a terrorist shame shame shame
great job Arnab
This host is a beast. 2 thumbs up
This really hurts me
Aranab let me tel you one thing , the people who is sitting in your office saying Bhagat singh was a revolutionary terrorist should immediately send to prison, They r anti-national......
And let comment to your TV , these type of debate should not be there on you channel .
Dont do these type of debate to just increase your TRP
As an UPSC student we are told by teachers to read this book and i have read it multiple times....thanks for bringing up the issue....so there is a whole generation of bureaucrats with their minds modified intentionally
this writers need to be in jail and what ever money they made out of these books need to be donated and should be highly penalized. it is nota mistake, these writers are still working for British and want them to take over India again. First stupid guy in the show said that bhagat singh and his group would have gone to any extend to get freedom. . One patriotic will go to any extend to get freedom. according to these writers every solders is terrorist. because of these kind of people British were rule on us. These are born slave to white skin . Bhagat singh died in 22 years of age he did not get to live as Gandhi did 78 year old. These writers are terrorist by them self and have NO respect for country or freedom fighters. Freedom violence is not terrorism. without was can not be a freedom. these writters should not be not allowed on chenal. these should not called historians and should not be allowed to write any book about anything.
+Kala Rai bipan chandra is no more!!!
Hahaha
Other writers can be who are writing nonsense. I am sure that was not only one. It is group of people not just one.
JAI BHAGAT SINGH
JAI RAJGURU
JAI SUKHDEV
JAI BHARAT
JAI TIRANGA
JAI SHAHEEDI
JAI KESARI
What has happened to our country , debate topics are becoming worse day by day , omg .. these professors are going to ruin our country
My message to our Bravest freedom fighter Bhagat singhji may this so called history Book ncert forgot you your struggle for freedom struggle for Bharat mata But we the youth of india 🇮🇳 will never ever forget you the Bravest youthfredome fighter of india 🇮🇳 🧡🤍💚
jis bande ki wajah se hum sab log aaj azaadi ki sans le rahe he uske bare me agar esa koi sochta he to sidha mujhse baat kare
me bataunga ki terrorist kesa hota hai
kaat ke rakhg dunga saalo
Inqalab Zindabad...!!!
They fucking teach this in UPSC ...people become IAS after learning this
These all historians are idiots and the ias students should have wrote to publishers to correct this. I can't believe this is being taught and even published.
General Bakshi Sir.... Well Said............
" 115 din ki hunger strike bhagat Singh aur unke sathiyo ne ki thii."
yes it is a problem, 90% of social studies text book( especially in 10th std) is about gandhian movement and just mention extemist movement as mere unsuccessful attempt. Seriously there needs to be balance. I am not saying non violent movement is wrong it was one of the biggest reason why we got freedom. but atleast we need one chapter for this martyrs
+Kashiv Ranik that is reasons there is less respect for our soldiers
+Kashiv Ranik quite india movement was failed as soon as British start regaining its terrorist in WW2...in 1942 but we got independence due to the mutiny by INA and the rise of nationalism in British Indian army..mainly due to bose
Sharam to un logo ko aani chahiye jo ase insult ko support kar rahe hain
shame shame shame ..
If we can call MK Gandhi as Mahatma for his Independence movements and Jawaharlal Nehru as a freedom fighter.... then how dare you label the Revolutionaries as terrorists... had it not been for the terror struck by these men in the minds of British we would be slaves for a longer period... we must change the books.... this is not a slight of academia.... this is Blasphemy....
Bhagat Singh was a National Socialist, not exactly a Communist, for him Nation was first!!
Vande Bharat Matram Jai Vande Bharat Bhartam
Heads off to The Legend of Bhagat Singh.......
our education system was destroyed by congi & CPM.
bhagat Singh is a indian revolutionary, leader.
no more discussion
These aren't Historians. Better if called Propagandists.
bhagat Singh ji is aur national hero
CHANGE THE NAME OF CHANDIGARGH TO BHAGAT SANHDU CITY
first sentence of general GD bakshi was so true. historians think that wo Jo likhenge log wahi manenge, jise psnd karenge use hero bna denge nd jise mn use terrorist. saale inke so called freedom hero nehru etc, Kbhi jail gye !? kbhi laat khai, sirf Gandhi ji k pichhe khade hoke luxury life ji or logo ko bhasan Diya.
Bhagat Singh should be idol of every Indian
bhagatsingh ki jay ho
I read this book three days back as I am preparing for UPSC and even I was taken aback by seeing the word "revolutionary terrorist" for Shaheed Bhagat Singh and other martyrs. I was thinking to write to the publisher and Ministry of Human resource Development to take some action and to correct the word and today by chance I came across this debate. Happy to see that many people also want some action to be taken. And the biggest irony you know, this is the most read book by UPSC aspirants and many IAS, IPS and other central service officers have read this book and reached the place where they are. Most of the successful aspirants suggest this book!
This book on a whole is written by Congress funding to the authors I suppose. In the whole book, Congress has been shown as the face of Indian nationalism and leaders like Jawaharlal Nehru has been portrayed the best. His and Gandhi's achievements have been very much highlighted throughout the book and undermining those of others like Subhash Chandra Bose, Bhagat Singh, etc.
And do you know the book just covers just 2 pages on Bhagat Singh. Just two pages!
The every wrong decision of the Congress and especially Mahatma Gandhi has been justified for example the abrupt calling off the non-cooperation movement.
This is not just an internal conspiracy of India. If we refer to the findings of Mr Rajiv Malhotra, there is a concerted effort by foreign powers to inculcate a sense of worthlessness among Indians, for which they have also bought over some of our so called academicians.
NGOS are hiring these jobless historians to distort and twist facts about Patriots.
By calling Bhagat singh a terrorist, they are legitimizing the British rule. What a ridiculous school of thought. Why are these people even here??. They should have left with the British. Why are they Indian citizens??
yr is debate me shifuji ko b hona chahiye tha.......
love Radi exactlyyyyy
Those are the traitors who said bhagat is terrorist
Indeed a shame that these great men have been taken for so granted in today's India
The author of the book should have to be punished by Indian law
Shaheed e azam Bhagat Singh is one of the greatest revolutionaries ever.
arnab ji ,first ask what is defination of terrorist to that historians.shame on u historian
It breaks my heart what the hell is modi government doing
26 references in a chapter calling the legendary bhagat Singh a terrorist and no one objected till now ..seriously this can happen only in India. really sad
All madarsachaps have lost their minds.
shame on all those who had said this
It is a deliberate attempt to show that Bhagat Singh was Atheist, I would like to ask a small question to prove that he was not a Atheist but Believed in Sikhism ? How many Atheist wear Sikh Pagadi??????
well said and backed up your claim. ..
bro we live in a country which biased only strong political people are legend. just because shaheed bhagat Singh was a ordinary boy who did extraordinary work. but historians puppets of Britisher wrote terrorist words. I mean who could they.
Though I am also pro Bhagat Singh. But yes he was Marxist in his belief and denounced religion and God. In his early ages he was follower of religion but later when he denounced all religions when he studied and read about concepts of European liberty, fraternity, Secularism etc he was influenced by them and became atheist. Read his own book, Read his family background.... His revolutionary ideas are influenced from French revolution. Pagadi on the other hand most of people even after becoming atheist wear just because of family traditions there are many other cultural sects other than Sikhs who wear Pagadi in spite of different religious bias or no religious bias, in fact they are more into culture than religion. But his personal belief whether Hindu, Sikh, Atheist etc won't make any difference in respect for him
Certified Experts Vs Common Man Wearing pagdi was common in punjab ..not only sikhs, other castes or religion used to wear pagdi too.. im hindu living in punjab n my grandfather n father wear pagdi too
and bhagat singh cut his hairs too n Sikhs don't allowed to cut their hairs.
So Clothes don't define A Man just know that
Baghat singh is was and will always be shaheed , he doesn't need label from anybody . Gandhi is only on Indian currency and bhaghat singh is in our hearts.
Bhagat Singh was not terrorist. He was a revolutionist and same is the case with Burhan Wani. Both has laid their life for the freedom of their country..
very well said bro
Dil Dil Pak i also live in J&K ... keep ur burhan to urself.... omar fayaz was also a kashmiri... pandits were also kashmiri and they didn't wanted any fucking freedom.. u piece of crap
I would kindly reqst u dont u compare bhagat singh to burhan wani ....
Dude thats not even a comparision
Keep ur burhan wani away from bhagat singh
@@mehulchib it may be that you dont know who you f is
It's not difficult how British ruled India by dividing Indian on different issues and doing infinite number of propaganda
bhagat singh jinda bad
jai hind bharat mata ki jai
Bhagat singh jinda baad
My name is Bhagat Singh and I am not a terrorist. Shame on those people who think Bhagat Singh was a terrorist. Kya ho gaya desh ko Bhagat Singh ko bhi apna pehechan dena paad raha hai.
If Bhagat Singh was a terrorist than Nehru and Gandhi was Mujra wala
Defending their homeland is not a terrorist... But why the Palestinians are labelling as terrorist...???
respect to arnab 👍👍
Bhagat singh is a patriotic....
Debate depicts why Congress and affiliates should never win if, our country should remain free.
Vande Mataram.
Aise itihas kar ka bas chale to ye Army ko bhi terrorist keh de kyu ki vo bhi apne desh k liye dusman ko khatm karte hai
Very nice ARANABJI
why indian govt allow so called historian to publish or imposing their own propoganda on youth , university authority before making curriculum atleast should correct the fact & people who written bhagat singh as a terrorist should make apology in public for same .
Bhagath sing was one of the great great great great great great great great great great great great great great great freedom fighters in india
How mean people they r.shame on that kind of people.. Always proud on Bhagat Singh..every Indian must know about him. He deserves so much respect .a National holiday and one chapter of every textbook about him.. And Mr Arnav deserve so much appreciation.. 👍👍👍
we have a huge respect in our heart for bhagat singh ...any word in any books against him is not going to change our respectful feeling towards him...
Fuck bhagat Singh iska Ghar Pak main Hain abhi bhi usko hum jalayga
It is a great insult to one of our great Warriors! Shameless authors.
unjustice for G D Bakshi today..sadly
Penalists can have any opinion about bhagat sing ji, but in the millions of mind he is a greatest hero of our country often mother India gives such great sons to our country as long as sun shines these freedom fighters will remain in the minds ,in the hearts and in the soul of billions of people
I remember this term in my class 10 syllabus .. I hated that term and never felt good about it
Gandhi was always better than Bhagat
shame on those people who call legends like bhagat singh a terrorist they must have taken a handsome amount from britishers
BHAGAT SINGH ZINDABAD HE WAS A REAL FREEDOM FIGHTER OF INDIA WHO GAVE SACRIFICE IN SMALL AGE GREAT SALUTE TO OUR REAL INDIAN FREEDOM FIGHTER
long live bhagat singh.
If he was not a terrost then how can you label hamas terrost...
Bkl you're comparing pislim te£££ os£££ist with Bhagat Singh?
it is not only th insult of bhaghat singh it is the insult of 121 crore people of india