In year 1978 we were transiting Japanese inland sea the pilot claimed Chandra Bose did not die in tyhoku plane crash, he said more that he himself was with Indian azad hind army before the us force occupied Japan. He also claimed there was no plane crash there on that very day. Also in year 1998 one college of mine whose father late Ajab Khan,migrated to Pakistan, as his family forced the migration and he too said same that Netaji not die in plane crash. Janab anam Khan till his death he faught for mother india not just for Pakistan. I mailed to Mukharji commission mentioning those two gentlems claim
My name is Subash and I was born on Dec.30,1943 in Lahore. My parents did not keep the name "Subash" just like that , it was their love for Netaji and the work he was doing for the country . My parents must be in their 20s and 30s and their emotions for the freedom of the country and faith in Netajis actions . Now when we see how Gandhi and Nehru specially Nehru did for Netaji and tried to keep him out of History pages by declaring him dead it is an act of TREACHRY for which the whole nation should stand up and do through investigation , bring out the truth .Any one who so ever he may be should not be pardoned. Even if we have to change the Government we should do so.
People of the country should not vote for those who have suppressed the facts inorder to survive in the polity of the country without any competitors., it is treachery committed on the trust reposed by the innocent citizens of this country to make them believe that Nethaji had died., it was pure treachery nothing more nothing less. the people of this country should teach a lesson to those TRAITORS In the coming elections.
Lisa Saxena when i reached 8th grade, i was really excited about studying the Indian history(history fanatic)now i feel cheated and i feel like a fool after this controversy. Though i'm pretty interested as to what happens in the coming days! JAI HIND!
Lisa Saxena history books in India serve a variety of political propaganda and appeasement policies.... look at this piece from a book by renowned middle age historian Dr. Santosh C Saha books.google.com/books?id=HeXPlopNwp0C&pg=PA273&lpg=PA273&dq=circular+number+syl%2F89%2F1&source=bl&ots=65xy7jDr04&sig=OtzuVxMVjjwZ-0CN1mzp-CwpRPU&hl=en&sa=X&ei=NH8rVdOOGYevggTfv4LgAg&ved=0CDQQ6AEwAw#v=onepage&q=circular%20number%20syl%2F89%2F1&f=false It clearly states how the Marxist govt. in West Bengal removed/subdued pieces of history for appeasement of a certain community and maintaining so called "Communal Harmony"
Lisa Saxena No one ever resigns from anywhere Lisa .. its time for head shots.. lol XD don't u remember how our childhood got destroyed by our wrong teachers teaching us all bul***t things.. & now we r left astray and alone.. most of the nation struggling unemployed from impractical untrue knowledge of our existence, life & fake history?? we have got ill treated all our lives from our own people & society only on basis of scoring marks & earning money..We people have to DO something to drastically change the mindset of this plagued society as left by those bloody west people back in history.. .. I have to say this.. its high-time.. we can no more let handful of people do whatever they feel to deceive the nation.. 120 crore people have equal rights to freedom and an exposure to truth.. we must spread videos of Amar Saheed Sri Rajiv Dixit ji.. to everyone around.. we must see through the vision of nation lovers most people even don't know names of!! :o.. Lets all work together.. for our Bharat Maa.. :)
It would be sin to vote for congress party. Look at the Sharmista Mukherjee how she is defending congress party over Netaji death. Shame on you sharmista Shame! Shame! Shame Mukherji. Sharmista please support Subhash Chandra bose as a true Bangali and India.
Mridula Mukherjee and Sharmistha Mukherjee. Complete disgrace of Bengali community. I don't understand how they have the audacity and moral allowance to support Congress against Netaji Subhash Bose ?! Their political interest is more important to these two women than life and image of Netaji !!
Being a Senior Citizen , It is feel to pain that Mrs Sharmistha Mukheerjee did not aware about dccent note in 1st Enquiry Commission as no plane crash took place on 18th August '1945 also India Govt. receipt in 1956 that no Plane Crash from Taiwan Govt, Sharmistha Mukherjee is nothing but a defender for high degree of conspiracy leaded by Pd. Neheru and Congress Party
Mridula Mukherjee history teacher at JNU (Pt. Jawaharlal Nehru University). Enough said. We cannot have a neutral and balanced point of view from her on this issue at least. Congress representative well, I don't think there is any need to comment on her. Great grandson of Netaji, Mr. Chandra Bose has flashes of his great grandfather in looks and in style of speaking. Wow, Fantastic. That is the DNA of Netaji.
We Indians who love and worship him as the liberator of our Motherland , we want to know the truth . No Individual or any party is greater than Netaji in my opinion , so we have every right to know what had happen to him . Let there be only answers . Felt really sorry to witness the opposition role in the issue of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose and the sarcastic smiles .
Before taking political sides , i was a student who was interested in reading ncert history but it seemed dull to me learning from class 6th onwards only about Mughals and the British . Even the freedom struggle section is full of congress leaders or is very boring , whereas it should be such which gives us patriotic goosebumps on how British did atrocities and how Indian freedom fighters fought it years passed . Now learning history myself since the end of Covid and getting some astonishing revelation about realities of big personalities , culture through the timeline , religious practices , geopolitical history , ideological clashes , ideas , identities and scale and scope of influence , about esteemed and determined strategists , warriors , thinkers , explorers , emperors of the Greater India and their associations , reflection of inspiration and influence on each other every day , every week that many things are told disproportionately and hidden deliberately and even told falsely that i become furious at the writers of history and their followers and preachers today or at those innocent public who shuts their mind against listening to our arguments as some false premises have been rockified in their minds now that they can`t listen something contrary to it or accept that they may have been deliberatly taught wrong or incomplete things in their whole school life .
General Shide who was sitting next to Netaji in that plane never died either, but he went to Manchuria to take charge of the Japanese Army in Manchuria.
Mrs. Sharmistha Mukherjee, Being a Senior Citizen I would like to say Please take it note that " Legally" does not arise in connection the missing / Destroy the Files as it is a big Crime against the Nation as well as Countrymen.. Baseless defend, support & safe guard for the conspiracy leaded by Pd. Neheru & Congress Part.There is no doubt about it that Netaji Subhash Chandra did unattainable job with a life risk against the adverse situation during World war-II for the freedom of his Motherland which was beyond the imagination by all forefront Leaders & they were very much afraid about their Political life if Subash came in picture. I want to know about the Inquiry in 1946 as you mentioned.
Let them destroy files of Netaji, does not matter anymore. By now, it is known to countrymen who gave freedom to India. People like Gen Bakshi, Dr Anuj Dhar, Pushpendra ji and many others have already educated us on history of 70 years of post independent India.
Looks like Mridula has an agenda. She does not want the latest commission to be taken seriously. Lord Mountbatten ! lol. Everybody knows who his wife was & what was her relationship with Nehru. She wants his words to be taken seriously. That said, Why or how did the Netaji land in the British soil against whom he formed the INA (Indian National Army) & fought ? Who was behind it ? We clearly know that Sardar Patel & Subhash Chandra Bose were the 2 other contenders for the post of the PM. While Patel died in 1950 conveniently, Netaji landed up in the enemy territory never to be seen again. National hero. National tragedy ! "your war criminal" is what Nehru wrote to GB ! The INA treasures where women & men had poured their precious jewels, cash etc were looted by the Nehru Govt, the first scam according to the family of Netaji.
It is really shame how the participants keep on interfering into this discussions.Look at the polished family members of Subhash Chandra Bose have been participating in this . Discipline is very important.
Please finish this fast .. Come out with Truth ... Youth of this Great Nation will Not Allow Memory of Netaji to be dragged through political mud...this must not pass...this shall not pass... HE LIVES IN OUR HEART .. cant erase that now .. can you.. family ?
Gandhi and Nehru were stooges of British, used to craft a safest form of exit through a non-violent independence. The threat of INA was looming large, especially after losses during WW2, and had that threat prevailed, they would have marched all the way to London. One important fact most people tend to ignore that Bose had somewhat of a nationalistic ideology, may not be as extreme but similar to that of Hitler (who used it as an excuse to commit genocides and annexations). So on the other hand, with WW2 fresh in the memory, one could say that another crisis was averted.
Mind boggling question is why the government is still hesitating to unearth the whole truth, Especially when there is no one of Gandhi/Nehru family is in power.
If you like this video and support the justice towards Netaji, follow : Anuj Dhar : twitter.com/anujdhar Chandrachur G : twitter.com/chandrachurg Chandra Kumar Bose : twitter.com/Chandrakbose Gen. G D Bakshi : twitter.com/GeneralBakshi and PMO : twitter.com/PMOIndia for more updates.
Intaletuals must put some time on what happened to INA, soldiers who fought with Netaji, figures say 28000 soldiers died and what independent India, did rewarded them and what happened to the soldiers, we never heard about them.
This is laughable. Why is it difficult for us to read or accept anything against Gandhi or the Nehru family. God has given us all the cognitive capacity to reason and question. What are u doing? wake up comrade! (:
MadarGoat Does the quote "Tum mujhe khoon do..." not excite you, then question these bigots and end this shit the day before yesterday. We are nation who are prodigies of Bose, we have our way with blood and hardwork. Nehru and family has robbed us of our identities and made us a soft, corrupt power with satyagraha and other nonsense. Jai Hind!
The three biggest blunders of nehruji 1-kashmir issue 2-china border dispute both today greatest security challenges for India 3-dynastic politics-made Indira president of INC in 1959-at that time she had no experience
+narahari javaji He also didn't want the princely states to merge with India. Heck, Pakistan was still flying to Hyderabad, even when Pakistan was well established to be an enemy state. It was Patel who actually got us the map of India, as we know it today. If for the populist Nehru, then god knows where India would have been,
Ms Sharmistha Muhkerjee should be ashamed of herself , being a Bengali,to support the denial of rightful respect to the greatest patriot of India , whom Pandit Nehru couldn't reach hundred miles near , in any respect.
to mIt is surprising matter that Netaji research Bureau and their key man did not raised any objection about the File missing , enquiry about Netaji Family and it is sorry to see how stand defense as supported for Congrees party 's activities in connection of " NETAJI! Mrs Sharmistha Mukherjee & Mrs Midula Mukherjee : Did you know " about the descent report was submitted by Suresh Chandra Bose. PM Neheru compelled to set up Shanowaz Commission in 1956 while there was a proposal for set up an inquiry leaded by Dr. Radha Gobidra Paul , famous person during World War -II in Asian Region. . .
Mr. Chandra Bose's deposition on the matter of disappearance of INA's funds is a revelation. This must be investigated thoroughly and explained to the citizens of the country. Anything short of it will be a breach of trust.
Unfortunately we have to remember that our history was written by the "winners"(Neheru, Gandhi) and and Bose is in the opposite side. and this is the result.
Nice to know the truth is coming out slowly. Love to know the truth. Let the world know the truth. Truth triumphs. Subhas chandraji was not an ordinary person. This in not a joke.
yes; today the whole nation want to declassify the hidden files and put in-front of public to know the truth about what happened really to beloved son of mother india. any govt should not play games with this sensitive issue for their political benefits. it is the responsibility of every indian to show his/her honor towards great freedom fighter. i cant understand why a govt not support to break the mystery by opening the secret files.how many years you want to prolong this issue. this is the time supreme court should involve in this issue. "No one can conceal the truth ". jai hind...
Dear Ms. Sarmistha Mukherjee - your beloved Congress party was in power for so many years. Why did you not table the reports/ file so far? Now you are shouting and asking the present Govt. to publish the files?
Out of two investigations , one which doesn't visited the scene of incident and one which did , i would trust the second one . Given that the two investigations contradicts each other .
I will allow Mridula Mukherjee to hide when the files are released and the truth comes out. When it is clearly evident that there was no crash... She continues to harp the same malicious n monotonous tune.
It is a matter of shame that Files of Netaji have been destroyed / missing etc happened if died in " Plane Crash" on 18th August '1945. There was a Descent Note made by Suresh Chandra Bose in Shan Awaz Committee in 1956 , Mrs Midula Mukherjee & Sharmisttha Mukherjee Did you know it No Plane Crash took place as per report of Taipey Government which was receipt by Government through British Government in 1956 , Did you know ? Yes 100% correct the letter submitted by Mr. jAIN In 1946 As there was a enmity relation between Neheru & Netaji : I shall fight Subash witth Sword..... . & not consider the contribution of Azad hind Government in Freedom fighting.
Pandit nehru at the time of independence is so wanting for being the PM so he was ready to do anything..thats what i understand from different articles and discussion..
after listning, the debates from many sources, i viewed that, the then Cong govt especially the Gandhi parivar & Nehru pariwar has falsified the mistery of the death of super hero of india to occupy the throne of India. they all tried to proclaim against the real hero of India, Subhash Ch. Bose as the war criminal before other other countries, but in fact, he has done too much more /100% more than any other members of then Cong party. they should be rooted out at all from India.
1. The whole world still today believe that Nethaji Subash Chandra Bose died in aircraft fire accident. 2. But that's not true at all. It's all just picturised. 3. A Swamiji whose name is Aadhi Sokkar from South Tamilnadu (India) strongly says that his body is burried at Kodukku Mountain in Theni District (Tamilnadu). 4. He has also got the proof for his saying. His funeral took place on 3rd September 1945. 5. Actual death day of Subash Chandra Bose is 3.9.1945. But it is recorded as 18 August 1945. That's not the correct one. 6. World war-I (28 July 1914 to 11 November 1918. 7. World war-II (1 September 1939 to 2 September 1945 - 6 years and 1 day) Here the one day seems to be the primary one because on that day only he died i.e 3.9.1945. 8. All this incidents have been recorded in a file and now it is under the custody of British Government. Now Swamiji is asking the britishers Can you deny my saying?
Sarso me hi vut rahte hay netaji subhash chandra bose was not the property of their family he is our hero who give our freedom nd we born in free india
We as a nation are so unlucky. Look at our history, we have always been invaded and looted. But after 1947,we were being looted by our own. The congress has probably looted us of wealth more than 10times of our present GDP. If we were ruled by Bose instead of Nehru, the present would have been a lot better.
Congress spokes person is laughing. Oh my god not sure they don't even show the respect for a national freedom fighter. It is really painful to see congress spokesperson smile on the sensitive matters. It is very irritating whether god is still in the world? Shamesless act and don't know how many years we are going to see the people laugh at us
The need of the hour, the urgent need is to urge the Govt of India to put aside all reservations and declare an Investigation at the most high powered executive level headed by a sitting Supreme Court Judge to study all these said files, say 165 ones, after the same are immediately de-classified, and submit a report to Parliament within 6 months, the earlier enquiry reports including Shah Nawaz Committee majority report, Suresh Bose's dissentient report, Khosla Commission report and Justice Mukherji commission report and all related exhibits to be opened up for enquiry and debate, re-writing of Indian political History will naturally follow
Nehru and Indira Gandhi were against Netaji, so they destroyed some important files so that people would not know the real history of the freedom movement. Sugata Bose wrote some books on Indian history in collaboration with Ayesha Jalal, the Pakistani historian, which are the Muslim view of Indian history. His sister Sharmila Bose wrote a book to prove that the Bangladesh Government lied that Pakistan army killed 3 million people. Their parents Sisir Bose and Krishna Bose are members of the Congress Party. They both agreed to the conclusion of the Khosla Commission and Shah Nawaz commission that Netaji died in the Aircrash.
when i was in school i read a story of nehru writing a letter to her daughter from jail as in jail he was given political treatment without any 3rd degree or any latiis on him but never came to now about a man who was in fasting for nearly 114 days nd was brutally beaten in jail nd were not even given water instead were feeded with milk to break the fasting never heard of it in text books ITS TIME TO CHANGE OUR HISTORY TEXT BOOKS
If the truth comes out there will be a tsunami within the government and may be the so called nationalist Gandhi and Nehru will forever loose respect. There were secret clauses when the British transferred the power to the Indian government and if Bose truth comes out those clauses will be also dragged out. In short a lot of things will be disbalanced.
The Congress Spokesperson and the said Historian have to prove though desperately that Nehru is a great statesman as is being taught to students for decades and that he is too great a man to think low and spy on Netaji's kin and be insecure of Subhas Bose who he loved a lot
If a man died by so called myth of " Plane Crash" , why Files missing , destroyed & not to be declassified raised? Was there any conspiracy to cover up the real truth? Mere wastage of time for debating and taking defense against this issue in term of Netaji disappearance.. Please don't take political issue. If it was noted in all files that Netaji died in "Plane Crash"and problem does not arise. Definitely there was some difference that's is the problem of contemporary leaders.
Politicians do not have right to speak on this. Subhas Chandra Bose was not killed in plane crash, its Indian politics which actually killed him. Mukherjees shut your mouth and now go back to your party houses and make dirty politics.
More than 3 years after this, what is Times Now doing regarding declassification of Netaji files and destruction of classified files? Secondly, what did Modi Government do regarding this issue? The issue is there but, was it was raised to divert the attention of the people from some scam that we do not know of now, since the present Government failed/ did not resolve the issue or brought it to a closure?
Professor Mridula Mukkherjee stop calling your self a Professor of History .. And Mr Anuj Dhar ,, Hats off to you sir ,, You are a one man army .. !!!
Moment Anuj dhar opened his mouth the commie aunty and Congress bhompu started blaring.....they simply can't tolerate the truth
Yes bro these r historians.. Who don't go on facts.. They go on nehru and gandhi lolipop
In year 1978 we were transiting Japanese inland sea the pilot claimed Chandra Bose did not die in tyhoku plane crash, he said more that he himself was with Indian azad hind army before the us force occupied Japan. He also claimed there was no plane crash there on that very day. Also in year 1998 one college of mine whose father late Ajab Khan,migrated to Pakistan, as his family forced the migration and he too said same that Netaji not die in plane crash. Janab anam Khan till his death he faught for mother india not just for Pakistan. I mailed to Mukharji commission mentioning those two gentlems claim
Im felling very bad, how can nehru call Subash Chandra Bose "your war criminal". Its a shame. Bose is our Hero. He lives in our heart. We respect him.
Yaa bro..it's disheartening
This is their nature of blood, I am not surprised
Yes when netaji fight against British Raj that time nahuru is on vacation in Europe
Yeah bro my blood is boiling
Bose is the real father of the nation
avinash ramadass umm not really.
Why not...?? Even if you have any disagreement on the term 'father' the ethos remains the same.
it's about person not about ethos and by the way how can a crab take the place of lion , huh !!
+chirag singh
Who's the crab and who's the lion?
congress
IsLofersParty&includingNeharu
My name is Subash and I was born on Dec.30,1943 in Lahore. My parents did not keep the name "Subash" just like that , it was their love for Netaji and the work he was doing for the country . My parents must be in their 20s and 30s and their emotions for the freedom of the country and faith in Netajis actions .
Now when we see how Gandhi and Nehru specially Nehru did for Netaji and tried to keep him out of History pages by declaring him dead it is an act of TREACHRY for which the whole nation should stand up and do through investigation , bring out the truth .Any one who so ever he may be should not be pardoned. Even if we have to change the Government we should do so.
subash sareen
Nice to read your story Uncle.
Lahore was the city of patriots, the city we lost.
His name is Subhash, not Subash.
People of the country should not vote for those who have suppressed the facts inorder to survive in the polity of the country without any competitors., it is treachery committed on the trust reposed by the innocent citizens of this country to make them believe that Nethaji had died., it was pure treachery nothing more nothing less. the people of this country should teach a lesson to those TRAITORS In the coming elections.
Absolutely right . We want all NETAJI files should be made Public .
Missing Subramaniam Swamy on this debate. He would have rocked it!
Mridula mukherjee u shud resign for teaching wrong history to young generation
I completely agree on that. I feel cheated as a student when they teach such nonsense.
victor256in I completely agree on that. I feel cheated as a student when they teach such nonsense
Lisa Saxena when i reached 8th grade, i was really excited about studying the Indian history(history fanatic)now i feel cheated and i feel like a fool after this controversy. Though i'm pretty interested as to what happens in the coming days!
JAI HIND!
Lisa Saxena history books in India serve a variety of political propaganda and appeasement policies.... look at this piece from a book by renowned middle age historian Dr. Santosh C Saha
books.google.com/books?id=HeXPlopNwp0C&pg=PA273&lpg=PA273&dq=circular+number+syl%2F89%2F1&source=bl&ots=65xy7jDr04&sig=OtzuVxMVjjwZ-0CN1mzp-CwpRPU&hl=en&sa=X&ei=NH8rVdOOGYevggTfv4LgAg&ved=0CDQQ6AEwAw#v=onepage&q=circular%20number%20syl%2F89%2F1&f=false
It clearly states how the Marxist govt. in West Bengal removed/subdued pieces of history for appeasement of a certain community and maintaining so called "Communal Harmony"
Lisa Saxena No one ever resigns from anywhere Lisa .. its time for head shots.. lol XD don't u remember how our childhood got destroyed by our wrong teachers teaching us all bul***t things.. & now we r left astray and alone.. most of the nation struggling unemployed from impractical untrue knowledge of our existence, life & fake history?? we have got ill treated all our lives from our own people & society only on basis of scoring marks & earning money..We people have to DO something to drastically change the mindset of this plagued society as left by those bloody west people back in history.. .. I have to say this.. its high-time.. we can no more let handful of people do whatever they feel to deceive the nation.. 120 crore people have equal rights to freedom and an exposure to truth.. we must spread videos of Amar Saheed Sri Rajiv Dixit ji.. to everyone around.. we must see through the vision of nation lovers most people even don't know names of!! :o.. Lets all work together.. for our Bharat Maa.. :)
congress person says "trust me". What a Joke..
Biggest joke of the century or even of whole mankind
Biggest Joke !
congress party is a joker party since independence.... lifetime joker
It would be sin to vote for congress party. Look at the Sharmista Mukherjee how she is defending congress party over Netaji death. Shame on you sharmista Shame! Shame! Shame Mukherji. Sharmista please support Subhash Chandra bose as a true Bangali and India.
Mridula Mukherjee and Sharmistha Mukherjee. Complete disgrace of Bengali community. I don't understand how they have the audacity and moral allowance to support Congress against Netaji Subhash Bose ?! Their political interest is more important to these two women than life and image of Netaji !!
Gokul ji , may be they have been paid by Congress .
Being a Senior Citizen , It is feel to pain that Mrs Sharmistha Mukheerjee did not aware about dccent note in 1st Enquiry Commission as no plane crash took place on 18th August '1945 also India Govt. receipt in 1956 that no Plane Crash from Taiwan Govt, Sharmistha Mukherjee is nothing but a defender for high degree of conspiracy leaded by Pd. Neheru and Congress Party
brilliant commanding arnab.india's best journalist.
Netaji is the real father of our nation in India...
UA-cam have given freedom of speech a great platform where people of all ideologies come out banging in the debates
Mridula Mukherjee history teacher at JNU (Pt. Jawaharlal Nehru University). Enough said. We cannot have a neutral and balanced point of view from her on this issue at least. Congress representative well, I don't think there is any need to comment on her. Great grandson of Netaji, Mr. Chandra Bose has flashes of his great grandfather in looks and in style of speaking. Wow, Fantastic. That is the DNA of Netaji.
congress spokes person and congress paid historian are helpless :)
Best response from Sri Anuj Dhar at 25:05
😂😂😂😂 I must have watched it 10 times...
Shame on u Sharmistha Mukherjee..Shameless politician
We Indians who love and worship him as the liberator of our Motherland , we want to know the truth . No Individual or any party is greater than Netaji in my opinion , so we have every right to know what had happen to him . Let there be only answers . Felt really sorry to witness the opposition role in the issue of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose and the sarcastic smiles .
Before taking political sides , i was a student who was interested in reading ncert history but it seemed dull to me learning from class 6th onwards only about Mughals and the British . Even the freedom struggle section is full of congress leaders or is very boring , whereas it should be such which gives us patriotic goosebumps on how British did atrocities and how Indian freedom fighters fought it years passed . Now learning history myself since the end of Covid and getting some astonishing revelation about realities of big personalities , culture through the timeline , religious practices , geopolitical history , ideological clashes , ideas , identities and scale and scope of influence , about esteemed and determined strategists , warriors , thinkers , explorers , emperors of the Greater India and their associations , reflection of inspiration and influence on each other every day , every week that many things are told disproportionately and hidden deliberately and even told falsely that i become furious at the writers of history and their followers and preachers today or at those innocent public who shuts their mind against listening to our arguments as some false premises have been rockified in their minds now that they can`t listen something contrary to it or accept that they may have been deliberatly taught wrong or incomplete things in their whole school life .
Destroying Files is like Corruption with Government Documents
We need Nehru & Gandhi less books for our children .!! Best episode ever..Pls continue !!
General Shide who was sitting next to Netaji in that plane never died either, but he went to Manchuria to take charge of the Japanese Army in Manchuria.
30:30 Bhagat Singh was called terrorist in our text books
Thanks for your comments I salute you mr chandra bose
neheru was the most bustd sample in the history
Mrs. Sharmistha Mukherjee, Being a Senior Citizen I would like to say Please take it note that " Legally" does not arise in connection the missing / Destroy the Files as it is a big Crime against the Nation as well as Countrymen.. Baseless defend, support & safe guard for the conspiracy leaded by Pd. Neheru & Congress Part.There is no doubt about it that Netaji Subhash Chandra did unattainable job with a life risk against the adverse situation during World war-II for the freedom of his Motherland which was beyond the imagination by all forefront Leaders & they were very much afraid about their Political life if Subash came in picture. I want to know about the Inquiry in 1946 as you mentioned.
Mirdula Mukherjee should write the new history again and read it
Let them destroy files of Netaji, does not matter anymore. By now, it is known to countrymen who gave freedom to India. People like Gen Bakshi, Dr Anuj Dhar, Pushpendra ji and many others have already educated us on history of 70 years of post independent India.
Mridula Mukherjee should be kicked out of her post. Immediately.
Looks like Mridula has an agenda. She does not want the latest commission to be taken seriously.
Lord Mountbatten ! lol. Everybody knows who his wife was & what was her relationship with Nehru. She wants his words to be taken seriously.
That said, Why or how did the Netaji land in the British soil against whom he formed the INA (Indian National Army) & fought ? Who was behind it ? We clearly know that Sardar Patel & Subhash Chandra Bose were the 2 other contenders for the post of the PM. While Patel died in 1950 conveniently, Netaji landed up in the enemy territory never to be seen again. National hero. National tragedy ! "your war criminal" is what Nehru wrote to GB !
The INA treasures where women & men had poured their precious jewels, cash etc were looted by the Nehru Govt, the first scam according to the family of Netaji.
It is really shame how the participants keep on interfering into this discussions.Look at the polished family members of Subhash Chandra Bose have been participating in this . Discipline is very important.
I feel so sad to see that in this debate two women who are defending people who're against Netaji are Bengalees!!
I m a bengali and you are right there is a large section of bengalis are shameless liars covering truth and they can sell anything for money they get.
Please finish this fast .. Come out with Truth ... Youth of this Great Nation will Not Allow Memory of Netaji to be dragged through political mud...this must not pass...this shall not pass... HE LIVES IN OUR HEART .. cant erase that now .. can you.. family ?
Gandhi and Nehru were stooges of British, used to craft a safest form of exit through a non-violent independence. The threat of INA was looming large, especially after losses during WW2, and had that threat prevailed, they would have marched all the way to London. One important fact most people tend to ignore that Bose had somewhat of a nationalistic ideology, may not be as extreme but similar to that of Hitler (who used it as an excuse to commit genocides and annexations). So on the other hand, with WW2 fresh in the memory, one could say that another crisis was averted.
Netaji is Great . Non-violence movement was a big sleeping pill for Indian people .
Congress a waist , Nehre kutta tha , He stands no where in front of Mr bose..... Real hero.....
abc India I fully agree with you!
#JusticeForNetaji
Oh God I am so happy that I have Modi Ji as my leader now & because of this I HOPE.
I HOPE THAT TRUTH WILL PREVAIL.
Mind boggling question is why the government is still hesitating to unearth the whole truth, Especially when there is no one of Gandhi/Nehru family is in power.
Right ! We want true history of India .
You know how bad it feels to know about the real face of"CHACHA NEHRU"? My Books portrayed him like god and now I feel "I was worshiping false god".
Mr. Rahul Gandhi Please answer why was the mukherjee commission report was rejected
If you like this video and support the justice towards Netaji, follow :
Anuj Dhar : twitter.com/anujdhar
Chandrachur G : twitter.com/chandrachurg
Chandra Kumar Bose : twitter.com/Chandrakbose
Gen. G D Bakshi : twitter.com/GeneralBakshi
and PMO : twitter.com/PMOIndia
for more updates.
Indira Gandhi knew it was her father Nehru request Britain to take action on Subhashchandra Bose who was in Russia.
I equate Netaji with Shivaji . Therefore think what would have happened if there would be a mystery about death of Shivaji Maharaj
Intaletuals must put some time on what happened to INA, soldiers who fought with Netaji, figures say 28000 soldiers died and what independent India, did rewarded them and what happened to the soldiers, we never heard about them.
All Indians want to know "What happened our REAL HERO"?
Bose brothers and Anuj Dhar are the right ones.
First time I felt good hearing Arnab talk...
This is laughable. Why is it difficult for us to read or accept anything against Gandhi or the Nehru family. God has given us all the cognitive capacity to reason and question. What are u doing? wake up comrade! (:
MadarGoat Does the quote "Tum mujhe khoon do..." not excite you, then question these bigots and end this shit the day before yesterday. We are nation who are prodigies of Bose, we have our way with blood and hardwork. Nehru and family has robbed us of our identities and made us a soft, corrupt power with satyagraha and other nonsense. Jai Hind!
MadarGoat If you really had cognitive capacity you wouldn't believe in a 'God'
soulreaperichig0 I'm a goat, what do u expect?
soulreaperichig0 Which is again given by 'God' to test your faith in him/her.
The three biggest blunders of nehruji
1-kashmir issue
2-china border dispute both today greatest security challenges for India
3-dynastic politics-made Indira president of INC in 1959-at that time she had no experience
+narahari javaji
He also didn't want the princely states to merge with India. Heck, Pakistan was still flying to Hyderabad, even when Pakistan was well established to be an enemy state. It was Patel who actually got us the map of India, as we know it today. If for the populist Nehru, then god knows where India would have been,
Biggest blunder by modiji Bjp Pdp alliance
Ms Sharmistha Muhkerjee should be ashamed of herself , being a Bengali,to support the denial of rightful respect to the greatest patriot of India , whom Pandit Nehru couldn't reach hundred miles near , in any respect.
I do not believe still how could Nehru write to UK that Let dear Netaji die....I feel shamed being born as Indian where looters reined for 60 yeras !!
Why Arnab Goswami don't allow the panelists to speak.
to mIt is surprising matter that Netaji research Bureau and their key man did not raised any objection about the File missing , enquiry about Netaji Family and it is sorry to see how stand defense as supported for Congrees party 's activities in connection of " NETAJI! Mrs Sharmistha Mukherjee & Mrs Midula Mukherjee : Did you know " about the descent report was submitted by Suresh Chandra Bose. PM Neheru compelled to set up Shanowaz Commission in 1956 while there was a proposal for set up an inquiry leaded by Dr. Radha Gobidra Paul , famous person during World War -II in Asian Region. . .
first destroy file and then put ask the govt to put in sequence
Mr. Chandra Bose's deposition on the matter of disappearance of INA's funds is a revelation.
This must be investigated thoroughly and explained to the citizens of the country. Anything short of it will be a breach of trust.
Files may have been destroyed to protect image of Netaji.
Unfortunately we have to remember that our history was written by the "winners"(Neheru, Gandhi) and and Bose is in the opposite side. and this is the result.
Yes true, in this case only survivors influence history while winners were made to die in a losers world of India 🇮🇳
Nice to know the truth is coming out slowly. Love to know the truth. Let the world know the truth. Truth triumphs. Subhas chandraji was not an ordinary person. This in not a joke.
The way of deliberation of the Congress Representative( Sharmistha) in this debate is very aggressive and irritating.
Anuj is awesome
Mridula mukherjee does not know how to debate also , shame !!!
yes; today the whole nation want to declassify the hidden files and put in-front of public to know the truth about what happened really to beloved son of mother india.
any govt should not play games with this sensitive issue for their political benefits.
it is the responsibility of every indian to show his/her honor towards great freedom fighter.
i cant understand why a govt not support to break the mystery by opening the secret files.how many years you want to prolong this issue.
this is the time supreme court should involve in this issue.
"No one can conceal the truth ".
jai hind...
If Congress does not throw the family out, Nobody should vote for them. Now we know why we are still poor all the treasures were looted by family
Avinash Rulz CONgress without the family is like a MAN without the PENIS!
Even if they throw out the family,which is certainly NOT going to happen,I swear not to vote them in my life
Dear Ms. Sarmistha Mukherjee - your beloved Congress party was in power for so many years. Why did you not table the reports/ file so far? Now you are shouting and asking the present Govt. to publish the files?
Out of two investigations , one which doesn't visited the scene of incident and one which did , i would trust the second one . Given that the two investigations contradicts each other .
THE MAN WHO HAD SAID '"I AM NOT THE CUSTODIAN OF FILE " MUST hv.distroyef THE SAME. JN
I will allow Mridula Mukherjee to hide when the files are released and the truth comes out. When it is clearly evident that there was no crash... She continues to harp the same malicious n monotonous tune.
Japan sold netaji to british and british killed him in secret.
It is a matter of shame that Files of Netaji have been destroyed / missing etc happened if died in " Plane Crash" on 18th August '1945. There was a Descent Note made by Suresh Chandra Bose in Shan Awaz Committee in 1956 , Mrs Midula Mukherjee & Sharmisttha Mukherjee Did you know it No Plane Crash took place as per report of Taipey Government which was receipt by Government through British Government in 1956 , Did you know ? Yes 100% correct the letter submitted by Mr. jAIN In 1946 As there was a enmity relation between Neheru & Netaji : I shall fight Subash witth Sword..... . & not consider the contribution of Azad hind Government in Freedom fighting.
Arnab please put out both the teacher of the studio.
Sharmistha &suny leone have no difference.
Modi should make aproper inquiry of Subhas Chandra Bose,s death mystery as he has personal interests of Netaji unlike neheru and Indira Gandhi
Congress arrest & murder my grandfather brother when he talk about Netaji in Assam at Dhamaji District in 1956.
All the Congress leaders beyond 80 age should be attested and still there's is achance of reveal the truth
Congress party made some history what they want to believe by Indians forcefully....Shame on it...
I am worried about the students of Mridula Mukherjee . Poor kids...
Pandit nehru at the time of independence is so wanting for being the PM so he was ready to do anything..thats what i understand from different articles and discussion..
after listning, the debates from many sources, i viewed that, the then Cong govt especially the Gandhi parivar & Nehru pariwar has falsified the mistery of the death of super hero of india to occupy the throne of India. they all tried to proclaim against the real hero of India, Subhash Ch. Bose as the war criminal before other other countries, but in fact, he has done too much more /100% more than any other members of then Cong party. they should be rooted out at all from India.
What has Nehru done to the country that we have to celebrate his b'day as a national holiday? Sharmistha Mukherjee pls make it clear first!
Netaji Jindabad. INA Jindabad .
I can make out fr5om the geography of Sharmistha Mukherjee is a first-class thoroughbred crook
Matter must be sorted out.
1. The whole world still today believe that Nethaji Subash Chandra Bose died in aircraft fire accident.
2. But that's not true at all. It's all just picturised.
3. A Swamiji whose name is Aadhi Sokkar from South Tamilnadu (India) strongly says that his body is burried at Kodukku Mountain in Theni District (Tamilnadu).
4. He has also got the proof for his saying. His funeral took place on 3rd September 1945.
5. Actual death day of Subash Chandra Bose is 3.9.1945. But it is recorded as 18 August 1945. That's not the correct one.
6. World war-I (28 July 1914 to 11 November 1918.
7. World war-II (1 September 1939 to 2 September 1945 - 6 years and 1 day) Here the one day seems to be the primary one because on that day only he died i.e 3.9.1945.
8. All this incidents have been recorded in a file and now it is under the custody of British Government. Now Swamiji is asking the britishers Can you deny my saying?
Sarso me hi vut rahte hay netaji subhash chandra bose was not the property of their family he is our hero who give our freedom nd we born in free india
As of December, 2019, all netaji files have been declassified. Hopefully, they will soon discover the truth.
We as a nation are so unlucky. Look at our history, we have always been invaded and looted. But after 1947,we were being looted by our own. The congress has probably looted us of wealth more than 10times of our present GDP.
If we were ruled by Bose instead of Nehru, the present would have been a lot better.
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose shd hv been The Father of Our Nation and not the TRAITOR GANDHI
Congress spokes person is laughing. Oh my god not sure they don't even show the respect for a national freedom fighter. It is really painful to see congress spokesperson smile on the sensitive matters. It is very irritating whether god is still in the world? Shamesless act and don't know how many years we are going to see the people laugh at us
The need of the hour, the urgent need is to urge the Govt of India to put aside all reservations and declare an Investigation at the most high powered executive level headed by a sitting Supreme Court Judge to study all these said files, say 165 ones, after the same are immediately de-classified, and submit a report to Parliament within 6 months, the earlier enquiry reports including Shah Nawaz Committee majority report, Suresh Bose's dissentient report, Khosla Commission report and Justice Mukherji commission report and all related exhibits to be opened up for enquiry and debate, re-writing of Indian political History will naturally follow
Indira Gandhi also involved in the death of Lal Bahadur Shashtriji.
Nehru and Indira Gandhi were against Netaji, so they destroyed some important files so that people would not know the real history of the freedom movement.
Sugata Bose wrote some books on Indian history in collaboration with Ayesha Jalal, the Pakistani historian, which are the Muslim view of Indian history. His sister Sharmila Bose wrote a book to prove that the Bangladesh Government lied that Pakistan army killed 3 million people. Their parents Sisir Bose and Krishna Bose are members of the Congress Party. They both agreed to the conclusion of the Khosla Commission and Shah Nawaz commission that Netaji died in the Aircrash.
when i was in school i read a story of nehru writing a letter to her daughter from jail as in jail he was given political treatment without any 3rd degree or any latiis on him
but never came to now about a man who was in fasting for nearly 114 days nd was brutally beaten in jail nd were not even given water instead were feeded with milk to break the fasting never heard of it in text books
ITS TIME TO CHANGE OUR HISTORY TEXT BOOKS
Are these ladies Sharmistha Mukherjee, Spokesperson, Congress; Prof. Mridula Mukherjee, Professor Modern History in the good book of Congress .......
Why is he yelling so much?
Bosse's case... what a mystery and what a great man he was.
Greetings from Greece.
If the truth comes out there will be a tsunami within the government and may be the so called nationalist Gandhi and Nehru will forever loose respect.
There were secret clauses when the British transferred the power to the Indian government and if Bose truth comes out those clauses will be also dragged out.
In short a lot of things will be disbalanced.
anuj dhar the one man of our army
question is still there why was documents distroyed no one answered
The Congress Spokesperson and the said Historian have to prove though desperately that Nehru is a great statesman as is being taught to students for decades and that he is too great a man to think low and spy on Netaji's kin and be insecure of Subhas Bose who he loved a lot
If a man died by so called myth of " Plane Crash" , why Files missing , destroyed & not to be declassified raised? Was there any conspiracy to cover up the real truth? Mere wastage of time for debating and taking defense against this issue in term of Netaji disappearance.. Please don't take political issue. If it was noted in all files that Netaji died in "Plane Crash"and problem does not arise. Definitely there was some difference that's is the problem of contemporary leaders.
Politicians do not have right to speak on this. Subhas Chandra Bose was not killed in plane crash, its Indian politics which actually killed him. Mukherjees shut your mouth and now go back to your party houses and make dirty politics.
More than 3 years after this, what is Times Now doing regarding declassification of Netaji files and destruction of classified files?
Secondly, what did Modi Government do regarding this issue?
The issue is there but, was it was raised to divert the attention of the people from some scam that we do not know of now, since the present Government failed/ did not resolve the issue or brought it to a closure?
This daughter of Pranab Mukherjee is really strange