i’ve only heard Forget, Fabulous Muscles, and Girl With Basket of Fruit, but if Forget isn’t even a top 10 Xiu Xiu album, i’m really pumped to listen to the rest
Xiu xiu is a great band, but their music exhausts me so much that I rarely dive deeper into their discog. Its so weird to watch you describe their stuff with so much enthusiasm. Great video, but forget deserved better
Angel Guts is super underrated imo. The synths and drums sound so chunky and great. And despite the minimal approach, there's a lot of texture and detail surrounding each track. Def one of my favorite albums from this decade.
knife play is my favorite album of all time. its indescribably earth shattering for me. top 5: knife play, chapel of chimes, fab muscles , a promise, always. In that order!
just wanted to let you know I appreciate this video a ton, top notch tribute to the greatest band of the past two decades. Could tell a lot of passion went into this so I hope your love for this band spreads around
aight this was my ranking the last time i thought about this but i haven't listened to Xiu Xiu in a while tbh... 12 women as lovers 11 dear god i hate myself 10 the air force 9 always 8 girl with basket of fruit 7 fabulous muscles 6 knife play 5 la foret 4 twin peaks 3 angel guts: red classroom 2 a promise 1 forget
I mostly enjoyed only half of Xiu Xiu's discography. I wasn't a fan of the more poppier albums but there are some exceptions. For me the tops are: 1. Girl With Basket Of Fruit. 2. A Promise. 3. Forget.
1. La Foret 2. Knife Play 3. A Promise 4. Dear God 5. Forget 6. Plays Twin Peaks 7. Fabulous Muscles 8. Ignore Grief 9. Girl with Basket of Fruit 10. Angel guts
Awesome Video My ranked Xiu Xiu 14: Women as Lovers 13: Dear God I Hate Myself 12: Angel Guts : Red Classroom 11: Unclouded Sky 10: Nina 9: Plays the Music of Twin Peaks 8: Always 7: Forget 6: Knife Play 5: Le Foret 4: Girl With Basket of Fruit 3: The Air Force 2: Fabulous Muscles 1: A Promise
I have only made it about halfway through their discography so I don’t have a full ranking but thank you very much for providing me with the schwee schwee content
My top 2 tend to be Knife Play and A Promise. After that it's hard to rank because I think Fabulous Muscles, La Foret, The Air Force, Dear God, and Always are all fantastic.
One of the best concerts ive ever been to. Saw them during Forget tour in Cambridge Ma My physical collection: Knife Play LP (white/clear) + 7" (clear) Fabulous Muscles LP (teal marble) Dear God I Hate Myself LP (black, 1st pressing) Forget LP (teal marble) Xiu Xiu and Devendra Banhart 7" Also i think ur women as lovers take was way off. I do what i want, when i want FTW No Friend Oh! Are 3 of their best songs ever!!!
Dear god I hate myself is not distinct? lol. He wrote the entire album for his take on pop bc he has a love for it and after Morrisey came out with one. ALSO apple for a brain is so amazingly written. “JS am come to me I’ll ruin you” lol.
This is great! Thank you for posting this! Jamie "Xiu Xiu" Xiutewart has long been one of the most truly creative & unique artists in music, and his body of work is filled with tasty diverse sounds that are emblematic of forward thinking musician who is not afraid to be bold and take risks. And you certainly xiummed up Xiu Xiu well, by saying, "fans can always expect to be surprised to see what doors and xiound dimensions, Xiu Xiu/Jamie Xiutewart will open for next." As much as I enjoyed this, I think I need to watch it again, after I've had my morning coffee enema, because even with the CC turned on, my wee brain couldn't keep up, so I am glad this is here on youtube for repeated listenings. Thank you again, David Rowe and most of all thank you to Jamie XIU XIU Stewart for his work.
I was really shocked to see twin peaks on number 9, since it's one of my favourite albums ever. Still, I could clearly see your passion and respect for xiu xiu. Great video.
I'm so glad I stumbled on your video. Whatever your choices & tastes are regarding Jamie, it's said with genuine passion. Got lucky, saw him perform with Caralee in Paris & Toulouse long long ago, got my pacman pink tee signed all over, chatted a bit, yook pictures, the fan things ... I wouldn't have ranked the albums in the same order of course but what matters is that we heard him, we liked him (and some) and nothing was ever the same after. Thanks for sharing.
I actually can't get into albums like angel guts and GWBOF.. because angel guts was just a bit too overly provocative, with black dick sounding almost like a parody of the more bluntly personal emotions I wanted like in a promise or the 2012 live show of fast car.. girl with basket of fruit also felt too.. obtuse compared to the blunt pain i wanted Maybe it's just my emo wants for something more immediately lovable and pained
Awesome rank ! I enjoyed your video a lot, it is nice to hear someone talk about xiu xiu´s music with passion, i am a huge fan since I can remember and I always wish I had someone to talk about their music with depth. Also, I believe the witch song at the end of La Foret, has something to do with the Tsunami that occurred in previous years, or so I read in some interview about how it talks about a witch that came from under the ocean. I think my favorite Xiu xiu album has to be Angel guts, just for how depraved it is in a beautiful way, I saw them live for the second time during that tour and damn! the drums sounded like huge earthquakes in songs like Archie´s fades or Lawrence Liquors. Anyway, i ran into your video today and im glad I did. Just subscribed too. =)
Always will forever be their worst album imo but I love every one of their other albums. My ranking as of 2021 14. Always 13. Women as lovers 12. Dear god I hate myself 11. Angel guts 10. OH NO 9. Nina 8. The Air Force 7. Forget 6. A promise 5. Knife play 4. La foret 3. Girl with basket of fruit 2. Xiu Xiu plays the music of twin peaks 1. Fabulous Muscles
Subscribed. Cool to hear you talk about such an underground (but great) band. Listened to 7 of their albums so far. How I'd rate them: 1. The Air Force 2. A Promise 3. Plays The Music Of Twin Peaks 4. La Foret 5. Girl With Basket Of Fruit 6. Knife Play 7. Fag Patrol
Holy cow are you nuts (respectfully said, lol). I love Nina and I love Xiu Xiu. I love anything unrestrained so naturally they are two of my idols, Nina and Jamie (who I had the pleasure to meet and take a photo with and keep up an email correspondence. Very insanely kind artist)..... and with that said. the Nina covers is by far the weakest, unless you count ambient projects that aren't listed. I agree with your placement of A Promise. but I don't see how you could put that album at 1 and put Knife Play (the best one) THAT far back. Forget and Dear God I Hate Myself are also top 5 worthy. I just couldn't disagree more with anything but putting A Promise and Fab Muscles up high enough. But I totally respect that you are shining a light on Xiu Xiu nonetheless. Great vid even though I don't agree.
I find it funny how you thought Knife Play was gonna be the most controversial one because of how low it is and not DGIHM lol. Anyways, solid video. This actually got me into Angel Guts when I'd originally just written it off for having such a simplified sound compared to most other Xiu projects. Hope to see rankings like this for other obscure indie bands
Alright alright. Despite your problematic opinions I enjoyed your video. Xiu Xiu is my favorite band and I have been a fan since the first record so I feel a little protective some times. My rankings: 1. The Air Force 2. Knife Play 3. Angel Guts 4. Fabulous Muscles 5. GWBoF 6. A Promise 7. Forget 8. Twin Peaks 9. La Foret 10. Dear God.. 11. Always 12. Unclouded Sky 13. Women as Lovers 14. Nina Special mention: Fag Patrol. Probably comes in between A Promise and Forget. Oh No would probably fall after Always (was a cool record with some killer tunes but far from my fave)
XIU XIU
XIU XIU
XIU XIU
XIU XIU
XIU
XIU XIU
XIU XIU
XIU XIU
XIU XIU
XIU XIU
XIU XIU
XIU XIU
XIU XIU
XIU
XIU XIU
XIU XIU
XIU XIU
XIU XIU
I met Jamie at a show a couple months ago at his merch table. It was a v cool experience and his performance was incredible
Thomas Stremfel whoa i bet that was crazy 😳
It's nice to see every comment I encounter about meeting him is wholesome
i’ve only heard Forget, Fabulous Muscles, and Girl With Basket of Fruit, but if Forget isn’t even a top 10 Xiu Xiu album, i’m really pumped to listen to the rest
Listen to Air Force or A Promise
Forget is hands down their best album
CyranoForever101 Forget And A Promise Are Easily My Favorites in their discrography. Love the synths on Forget
@@CyranoForever101 nope, and i saw them perform it live. Its super dope, but The Air Force is still their best body of work to me
A Promise NOW
Shwee Shwee
Nice reference
Where the Shwees at?!
"Gotta take my sisters and her friends to Shoo-Shoo, or something."
My sister's dumb emo friends love shwee shwee
Xiu xiu is a great band, but their music exhausts me so much that I rarely dive deeper into their discog. Its so weird to watch you describe their stuff with so much enthusiasm. Great video, but forget deserved better
SAME
Angel Guts is super underrated imo. The synths and drums sound so chunky and great. And despite the minimal approach, there's a lot of texture and detail surrounding each track. Def one of my favorite albums from this decade.
i know its been 4 years but knife play at 12 is willddddd. an album with over over, don diasco, suha, homunculus, and i broke up??? jeeez
Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu
Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu
Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu
Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu
Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu
Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu
Xiu Xiu Xiu Xiu
Xiu Xiu Xiu
Xiu Xiu
Xiu
Shwee shwee
knife play is my favorite album of all time. its indescribably earth shattering for me.
top 5: knife play, chapel of chimes, fab muscles , a promise, always.
In that order!
my hot take: Angel Guts is their best album and Botanica is their best song
Divingstation95 I used to absolutely love Botanica but idk why it sounds less appealing to me lately
AGREE, Botanica was the first song I ever heard by them during the credit scene from Creep 2 and I've been hooked since
4 years late but knife play at 12 just kills me
its tied with A Promise for their best album for me
YOU TALK VERY FAST
just wanted to let you know I appreciate this video a ton, top notch tribute to the greatest band of the past two decades. Could tell a lot of passion went into this so I hope your love for this band spreads around
watch twin peaks
aight this was my ranking the last time i thought about this but i haven't listened to Xiu Xiu in a while tbh...
12 women as lovers
11 dear god i hate myself
10 the air force
9 always
8 girl with basket of fruit
7 fabulous muscles
6 knife play
5 la foret
4 twin peaks
3 angel guts: red classroom
2 a promise
1 forget
forget man! it is amaizing !!!! i love it.
1. Xiu
2. Xiu
3. Xiu
4. Xiu
5. Xiu
6. Xiu
7. Xiu
8. Xiu
9. Xiu
I agree
10. Xiu
I mostly enjoyed only half of Xiu Xiu's discography. I wasn't a fan of the more poppier albums but there are some exceptions. For me the tops are:
1. Girl With Basket Of Fruit.
2. A Promise.
3. Forget.
1. La Foret
2. Knife Play
3. A Promise
4. Dear God
5. Forget
6. Plays Twin Peaks
7. Fabulous Muscles
8. Ignore Grief
9. Girl with Basket of Fruit
10. Angel guts
Buffalo Staple's setup is getting dealt with rn
Yes!!!! I’ve been waiting for someone to do this 😭
if you would have counted it where would MERZXIU stand in the ranking because it's one of my favourites from both merzbow and xiu xiu
probably last place
I seem to favor 'Dear God I Hate Myself' above most people.
I love shwee shwee
Apple brain is probably my favourite song by Jamie but it’s lovely to see xiu xiu getting some love xxx
You forgot Syro 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Seeing you around the place sometimes JQ
Glad you showed love to “Drill with a basket of fruit.”
When people tell you to watch videos on 1.25x to conserve time and David just does it for you 😂
Great video man! Shoutout Soundbinge
Lmao put it in 0.75x and it's like he's speaking at a normal speed
Rankings aside, I love your energy when talking about them. Good stuff
Awesome Video
My ranked Xiu Xiu
14: Women as Lovers
13: Dear God I Hate Myself
12: Angel Guts : Red Classroom
11: Unclouded Sky
10: Nina
9: Plays the Music of Twin Peaks
8: Always
7: Forget
6: Knife Play
5: Le Foret
4: Girl With Basket of Fruit
3: The Air Force
2: Fabulous Muscles
1: A Promise
L
I would have had another ranking, BUT that was a cool description of every single record of one of my top fave bands, thanks for taking the challenge!
I feel like watching Twin Peaks really enhances the Xiu Xiu version.
I have only made it about halfway through their discography so I don’t have a full ranking
but thank you very much for providing me with the schwee schwee content
I got GwBoF and La Forêt on vinyl!
My top 2 tend to be Knife Play and A Promise. After that it's hard to rank because I think Fabulous Muscles, La Foret, The Air Force, Dear God, and Always are all fantastic.
One of the best concerts ive ever been to. Saw them during Forget tour in Cambridge Ma
My physical collection:
Knife Play LP (white/clear) + 7" (clear)
Fabulous Muscles LP (teal marble)
Dear God I Hate Myself LP (black, 1st pressing)
Forget LP (teal marble)
Xiu Xiu and Devendra Banhart 7"
Also i think ur women as lovers take was way off.
I do what i want, when i want
FTW
No Friend Oh!
Are 3 of their best songs ever!!!
1. FORGET
2. Girl With Basket of Fruit
3. The Air Force
4. Fabulous Muscles
5. Plays The Music of Twin Peaks
Why are Xiu Xiu fans not down with Forget and DGIHM? They consistently rank low. Those are my favorite albums.
Good review. Dear God will always hold a place in my heart. A bigger one than you do do do do do do
Dear god I hate myself is not distinct? lol. He wrote the entire album for his take on pop bc he has a love for it and after Morrisey came out with one. ALSO apple for a brain is so amazingly written. “JS am come to me I’ll ruin you” lol.
Brown Cynthia Thomas Anthony Young Sarah
Funnily enough Jamie and Perfume Genius were roommates way back before PG got famous!
This is great! Thank you for posting this! Jamie "Xiu Xiu" Xiutewart has long been one of the most truly creative & unique artists in music, and his body of work is filled with tasty diverse sounds that are emblematic of forward thinking musician who is not afraid to be bold and take risks. And you certainly xiummed up Xiu Xiu well, by saying, "fans can always expect to be surprised to see what doors and xiound dimensions, Xiu Xiu/Jamie Xiutewart will open for next." As much as I enjoyed this, I think I need to watch it again, after I've had my morning coffee enema, because even with the CC turned on, my wee brain couldn't keep up, so I am glad this is here on youtube for repeated listenings. Thank you again, David Rowe and most of all thank you to Jamie XIU XIU Stewart for his work.
love your enxiusiasm!!
Xiu Xiu 'Plays the Music of Twin Peaks' not at top 5 huh? Bro, are you okay?
Feel like i'm the only person who loves apple for a brain 😭
жаль что в обзоре отсутствует музыка
Idk I really love knife play. Kinda top tier for me.
You almost lost me with placing Knife Play at 12, but your descriptions of each of the albums was very thorough and thoughtful
Shoe Shoe
Love this vid! Want to know your opinion on the new record of duets (xiuets?) x
I was really shocked to see twin peaks on number 9, since it's one of my favourite albums ever. Still, I could clearly see your passion and respect for xiu xiu. Great video.
Great vid glad you did this
ALL THAT YOU LEFT YOU LEFT FOR SOMEONE
mine is
1.a promise
that’s all i’ve heard
I'm so glad I stumbled on your video. Whatever your choices & tastes are regarding Jamie, it's said with genuine passion. Got lucky, saw him perform with Caralee in Paris & Toulouse long long ago, got my pacman pink tee signed all over, chatted a bit, yook pictures, the fan things ... I wouldn't have ranked the albums in the same order of course but what matters is that we heard him, we liked him (and some) and nothing was ever the same after. Thanks for sharing.
Alright now drop to middle cove lol
I actually can't get into albums like angel guts and GWBOF.. because angel guts was just a bit too overly provocative, with black dick sounding almost like a parody of the more bluntly personal emotions I wanted like in a promise or the 2012 live show of fast car.. girl with basket of fruit also felt too.. obtuse compared to the blunt pain i wanted
Maybe it's just my emo wants for something more immediately lovable and pained
Awesome rank ! I enjoyed your video a lot, it is nice to hear someone talk about xiu xiu´s music with passion, i am a huge fan since I can remember and I always wish I had someone to talk about their music with depth. Also, I believe the witch song at the end of La Foret, has something to do with the Tsunami that occurred in previous years, or so I read in some interview about how it talks about a witch that came from under the ocean. I think my favorite Xiu xiu album has to be Angel guts, just for how depraved it is in a beautiful way, I saw them live for the second time during that tour and damn! the drums sounded like huge earthquakes in songs like Archie´s fades or Lawrence Liquors. Anyway, i ran into your video today and im glad I did. Just subscribed too. =)
I feel alot of Simon Krug vibes. Listing to the album Random Spirit Lover by Sunset Rubdown.
iirc unclouded sky was a special release done for record store day. which is why its the most under the radar albums
Nice!! I love always
Always will forever be their worst album imo but I love every one of their other albums.
My ranking as of 2021
14. Always
13. Women as lovers
12. Dear god I hate myself
11. Angel guts
10. OH NO
9. Nina
8. The Air Force
7. Forget
6. A promise
5. Knife play
4. La foret
3. Girl with basket of fruit
2. Xiu Xiu plays the music of twin peaks
1. Fabulous Muscles
Subscribed. Cool to hear you talk about such an underground (but great) band. Listened to 7 of their albums so far.
How I'd rate them:
1. The Air Force
2. A Promise
3. Plays The Music Of Twin Peaks
4. La Foret
5. Girl With Basket Of Fruit
6. Knife Play
7. Fag Patrol
The Air Force is my favorite :D
Holy cow are you nuts (respectfully said, lol). I love Nina and I love Xiu Xiu. I love anything unrestrained so naturally they are two of my idols, Nina and Jamie (who I had the pleasure to meet and take a photo with and keep up an email correspondence. Very insanely kind artist)..... and with that said. the Nina covers is by far the weakest, unless you count ambient projects that aren't listed. I agree with your placement of A Promise. but I don't see how you could put that album at 1 and put Knife Play (the best one) THAT far back. Forget and Dear God I Hate Myself are also top 5 worthy. I just couldn't disagree more with anything but putting A Promise and Fab Muscles up high enough. But I totally respect that you are shining a light on Xiu Xiu nonetheless. Great vid even though I don't agree.
My favourite album is A FORET
7:54 He really likes to live in other people's xiu
React to young thugs new album
What did you think of Oh No? I thought it was super good
I find it funny how you thought Knife Play was gonna be the most controversial one because of how low it is and not DGIHM lol.
Anyways, solid video. This actually got me into Angel Guts when I'd originally just written it off for having such a simplified sound compared to most other Xiu projects. Hope to see rankings like this for other obscure indie bands
Omg hi we have the same taste u have good taste hi
Great video but no way knife play should be that low
I agree
I think Knife Plays a bit overrated
your video description is so real
Spazzy Lil kid.
I love you
Nice video
knife play is the best album
Kling Klang the real goat
WONDERING.... maybe
Schwee schwee
1:12 lmao
You did Apple For a Brain wrong 🧐
Ok, you dissed Tonight and Today. Not cool dude 🤨
Nina at #5!? Get real.
Alright alright. Despite your problematic opinions I enjoyed your video. Xiu Xiu is my favorite band and I have been a fan since the first record so I feel a little protective some times.
My rankings:
1. The Air Force
2. Knife Play
3. Angel Guts
4. Fabulous Muscles
5. GWBoF
6. A Promise
7. Forget
8. Twin Peaks
9. La Foret
10. Dear God..
11. Always
12. Unclouded Sky
13. Women as Lovers
14. Nina
Special mention: Fag Patrol. Probably comes in between A Promise and Forget. Oh No would probably fall after Always (was a cool record with some killer tunes but far from my fave)
1- always
2- knife play
3- a promise
4- fabulous muscles