Sufi History of Punjab, Indo-Pak Relations, Nawaz Sharif and Imran Khan - Jugnu Mohsin -

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,9 тис.

  • @manisshthakur621
    @manisshthakur621 4 дні тому +355

    One common pattern I've noticed while listening to Pakistani UA-camrs and their guests is their confident belief that they know more about India than Indians themselves.

    • @chaitanyakada1341
      @chaitanyakada1341 4 дні тому +39

      This confidence comes from their “peaceful ideology”

    • @trojanwar760
      @trojanwar760 4 дні тому +6

      Toh woh toh Indians ka bhi hota hai as if they know Pakistan and its issues better than Pakistanis.

    • @amitsai
      @amitsai 4 дні тому

      @@manisshthakur621 bilkul, easiest thing to sell, from day one their media is been spreading lies about us and they believe whatever is tild to them. They see India with a lens, lens of lies and hate. Some try to be fair and closer to truth but at end wahi hate nikalti hai. Per bikta hai toh becho.

    • @amitsai
      @amitsai 4 дні тому +17

      @@trojanwar760 can you show me few examples. We dont even talk about your issues. We know whats the issue.

    • @jamilkhan715
      @jamilkhan715 4 дні тому

      بہت گریزفل خاتون۔

  • @adityathakur_
    @adityathakur_ 4 дні тому +83

    Listened her with all of respect. There are lots of disagreement with her but one thing I wanna ask her that she care about Indian minorities but not about Pakistani minorities. Don't know does she care about them or she feel Pakistani minorities are not humans.

    • @Carryminatiroastvx3dw
      @Carryminatiroastvx3dw 4 дні тому +4

      Convert hone ke bad mind esa hi ho jata hai

    • @haiderfraz5148
      @haiderfraz5148 3 дні тому

      Maybe because she was asked only about India?
      She kept on criticising Pak policies more fervently.

    • @praveenadyanthaya6821
      @praveenadyanthaya6821 2 дні тому +3

      They care about the whole world except Pakistan itself 😂

    • @Football-Pundit-n9m
      @Football-Pundit-n9m День тому +1

      @@haiderfraz5148 Pak policies are much worse hence she criticized them. Also when she talked about Indian Muslims, her job is to focus of Pakistani minorities of which barely any are even left.

    • @sumithas9193
      @sumithas9193 3 години тому

      It's really laughable when Pakistanis talk about living together with Hindus and how partition was a bad idea and how they go on about Hinduism and the Indian social structure. Their take on Hindutva is really presumptous. This country which has an identity crisis thinks they are competent to comment about a civilizational identity. People like this lady, Mrs Najam Sethi, are part of the "Aman ki Asha" gang which exists on both sides of the border. Her friends who are in India who claim to be having a "difficult time" in present day India are the likes of Aamir Khan the hypocrite. The lady says nothing about the pathetic condition of Hindus and other minorities in Pakistan and sheds tears for Muslims in India. So long the host and the guests in podcast stick to their own country and its situation, it has value and is interesting. The criticism if it had been well informed is not a problem but false information based criticism is hollow.

  • @NuvoUno-1
    @NuvoUno-1 4 дні тому +284

    20:10 So she believes that the people of India, who live in India, grew up in India, understand less about their leaders then someone who lives in Pakistan and only understands India from an outsider's lens.
    Nehru deserves all the credit for leading the country towards modern education and early industrialization. But the credit of the Modern Indian Economy goes not to Nehru but to Narsimha Rao, Manmohan Singh, Narendra Modi and the Indian Enterpreneurs.

    • @mylord3003
      @mylord3003 4 дні тому

      These guests speak with an agenda, when they talk about India. They will call out right wing Hinduism and not other religions. When in fact these people do most of the global violence

    • @shivampatil23
      @shivampatil23 4 дні тому +12

      @@NuvoUno-1 Pakistani Intellectual 💀💀

    • @mahen3378
      @mahen3378 4 дні тому

      Her heart is outpouring in nostalgia just because she is missing sponsored tour of India. Otherwise she is a hollow pig.

    • @Itz_FJ5
      @Itz_FJ5 4 дні тому

      India was much better under our leadership when we ruled for 1000 years, after it went under hindu leadership the results is infront of you

    • @atulmestry4472
      @atulmestry4472 4 дні тому

      ​@@shivampatil23 Lahori Churan wali Aunty 😂😂

  • @AbleLawrence
    @AbleLawrence 4 дні тому +81

    Don’t blame RSS or BJP for change in Indian attitudes to Pakistan. It is the a Pakistani policy of thousand cuts through terrorism that succeeded. And it’s time Pakistanis think what they want to do with themselves before focusing on India.

    • @mayankindian3750
      @mayankindian3750 2 дні тому +1

      Time waste hai bhai hame koi matlab nahi hai bhai inko jo karna hai karte rahe 😊

    • @sreenarayanram5194
      @sreenarayanram5194 2 дні тому

      Islam and 72 hooris are arab concept culture and religion not indian subcontinent culture or religion
      Hindhu caste rajput gujjar jatt butt etc.. adopted Arab culture and living for Arabs distroyed their own culture and country for Arabs
      And alla is an arab god not indian subcontinent God concept
      And indian subcontinent is the most beautiful and most geographicaly diverse region in the entire world with wide variety of wether and the best place for human inhabitation through out human history of earth where as Saudi Arabia is mostly a hot desert with no river
      So Muhammad created a religion for the benefit of arab people and his arab land copying Christianity and Jewish religion offering 72 hooris and sex slaves for mens a dumb concept and he knows where ever islam grow ultimately it will benefit arab people and arab culture and he also requested to distroy other cultures to spread his own arab culture and the way he wants to see how the women's lives
      Now USA is also using and supporting and funding islam to destabilize their rival countries and regions expecilaly in central Asia and Pakistan banglades afganistan saudi arabia etc..

  • @NuvoUno-1
    @NuvoUno-1 4 дні тому +197

    There's a Hindu Temple in Azerbaijan with inscriptions in Punjabi language, the Temple was built by Traders from Punjab.

    • @nehpalsingh6511
      @nehpalsingh6511 4 дні тому +2

      More details kile time period or pic .
      ¿

    • @Masab_Rana1
      @Masab_Rana1 4 дні тому +6

      افغانستان کے حکمران بھٹی راجپوت.. ہے،راجہ کلر بھٹی نے 843 میں ترک کو شکست دینے کے بعد کابل پر اپنی حکمرانی قائم کی، بھٹی قبیلے نے تقریبا 150 سال تک لاہور، کشمیر، پشاور اور کابل پر حکمرانی کی۔ بعد ازاں ترک محمود غزنوی نے 1001ء میں راجا جئے پال کو شکست دی، یہ راجپوت ترک جنگیں تھی۔

    • @logiclogiclogic
      @logiclogiclogic 4 дні тому +1

      17th Century, Ateshgah of Baku ​@@nehpalsingh6511

    • @kishwerchaudary-n4g
      @kishwerchaudary-n4g 4 дні тому +1

      YES IT WAS ONE OF THE INDIAN LANGUAGES .

    • @AI-uc1vs
      @AI-uc1vs 4 дні тому

      It’s a Zoroastrian temple

  • @gouravgarg3791
    @gouravgarg3791 4 дні тому +487

    But ma'am after 26/11 india again voted for congress .... I think you guys are obsessed with BJP and hindutva.... Don't know a bit how india and indians behave electorally 🤦🏻‍♂️

    • @shatnermohanty6678
      @shatnermohanty6678 4 дні тому +66

      Also people of Delhi vote for Aam Aadmi party in the Assembly elections and same people vote for BJP in Lok Sabha elections

    • @kishoreshanbhag4535
      @kishoreshanbhag4535 4 дні тому +42

      26/11 affected South Indian as well and that has United entire india stand against our western neighbor.

    • @shatnermohanty6678
      @shatnermohanty6678 4 дні тому +34

      @@gouravgarg3791 what can we expect from a country that was created by rejecting democracy ?
      pakistani don't seem to understand that the Indian public is greater than any Party or Ideology
      Rahul Gandhi won in Rae Bareli because it was the will of the people and BJP lost in Ayodhya because it was the will of the people

    • @TruthPrevailz
      @TruthPrevailz 4 дні тому +30

      Shehzad keeps calling ppl from pakistan who talk on bjp and Indian politics. Sadly india is so diverse these guys no nothing other than hindu raat ke Andheri me aake ....😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @suyashsingh2247
      @suyashsingh2247 4 дні тому +3

      Sahi

  • @shivampatil23
    @shivampatil23 4 дні тому +173

    Pakistani Intellectual on India 💀💀
    Jawaharlal Nehru - GOOD MAN
    Indira Gandhi - Breaks Pakistan in 1971
    Manmohan singh - Opened Indian Economy
    Narendra MODI - Muslims Khatre me Hai 😱😱😱

    • @TruthPrevailz
      @TruthPrevailz 4 дні тому +4

      Lol

    • @DipJyotiDeka
      @DipJyotiDeka 4 дні тому +2

      Jai Shree Ram probably evokes the same emotions to a muslim as that of Allahu Akbar to a Hindu.

    • @kishwerchaudary-n4g
      @kishwerchaudary-n4g 4 дні тому +2

      STILL YOUR COUNTRY ON THE POVERTY LIST NUMBER 107 AND PAK ON 109 LIST , AND WATCH YOUR "SLUMS IN JIST VIDEOS IT IS REALLY FANTASTIC.

    • @shivampatil23
      @shivampatil23 4 дні тому

      @kishwerchaudary-n4g Pakistani Hindu Spotted crying 😱😱

    • @TruthPrevailz
      @TruthPrevailz 4 дні тому

      @@kishwerchaudary-n4g Good. Soon there won't be any pakistan.

  • @Raj-fu1lo
    @Raj-fu1lo 4 дні тому +46

    She very intelligently adds and high light points of Pakistan army ….Anti BJP , Kashmir issue, atrocities on Indian Muslims….we can understand her compulsion as she has to survive in the garrison state..

    • @praveenadyanthaya6821
      @praveenadyanthaya6821 33 хвилини тому

      She is a controversial figure. They have demanded a separate country based on religion. Now let them live and let others live peacefully. We don't care what Pakistan is. Better don't talk about India to cover your mistakes.

  • @AnujKumar-wj3ju
    @AnujKumar-wj3ju 4 дні тому +24

    Her history knowledge will be summed up in as "Adha Titar Adha Bater". 🙏 😊

  • @MrSaurav1983
    @MrSaurav1983 День тому +10

    The lady is driven more by ideology than reality. She presents the 'moderate' version of the extreme ideology which is damaging Pakistan.

  • @kapilslog
    @kapilslog 4 дні тому +56

    When Pakistani say they want normal relations with India, what they mean is that they want good relations with Indian Muslims which gives them more subject matter and strength to ridicule Hindus. Unfortunately for them, right now they have to live with BJP and Hindutva as the only terms to vent their frustrations.

    • @haiderfraz5148
      @haiderfraz5148 3 дні тому

      Nope, instead she’s criticising Pak too.

    • @vickboss6751
      @vickboss6751 3 дні тому

      Very true. Muslims of India are their Trojan horse. When India was very poor and our cricket team used to loose more often against Pakistan, these leftover muslims would celebrate. Many had the strength and courage to not be politically incorrect to point that out

    • @Vk-sk7nm
      @Vk-sk7nm 2 дні тому +1

      True. And free chai pakodas with Lelis too and free trip to Tajmahal. Ab vo nahi mil pa Raha becharo ko

    • @Football-Pundit-n9m
      @Football-Pundit-n9m День тому

      @@haiderfraz5148 Thats her job, why she needs to talk about Indian Govt and Indian Muslims, your Jinnah was perfectly ok to abandon them, heck he was willing to get them smashed and obliterated just to get a country for his rich landlord and british patrons

  • @chanchalbpsingh6708
    @chanchalbpsingh6708 4 дні тому +21

    At 38:37 she said Hindus and Sikhs were not converted using force by muslims invaders. She is such a lier ! The rise of Khalsa Sikhs in Punjab took place because of forceful conversions. Our Sikh Gurus, Baba Banda Singh Bahadur and other sikh martyers sacrificed their everything just to save the dharam from muslim invaders and she is saying their sacrifice is misplaced. O oldie, spare some time to read about how brutelly our Guru Shri Teg bahadur ji, Shri Guru Gobind Singh ji , his sons, Baba Banda Singh Bahadur ji, his 04 years old son and many others like Veer Sambha ji maharaj were griesly and brutelly murdered by muslims for not accepting and converting to Islam. If the rulers of India were inflected upon so much cruelity think about the ordinary people must have gone through for not converting to Islam.

    • @chaitanyakada1341
      @chaitanyakada1341 4 дні тому +5

      What more do you expect from Pathological liars !!!

    • @vineetdeorari8017
      @vineetdeorari8017 2 дні тому

      Are ye aaj Tak bhi mithu miya ko apna kaam karne de rhe hain Sindh mai… jhuti quom hai

  • @Knowledgewithdeepakbaghel
    @Knowledgewithdeepakbaghel 4 дні тому +262

    26/11 was propaganda used by modi and bjp. 😂😂😂😂.
    What do you think common people of india is blind. 😂😂😂

    • @iamRitiksharma
      @iamRitiksharma 4 дні тому +49

      It doesn't take much to be called intellectual in Pakistan.😂😂😂bar is way too low😂😂😂

    • @manisshthakur621
      @manisshthakur621 4 дні тому +26

      One common pattern I've noticed while listening to Pakistani UA-camrs and their guests is their confident belief that they know more about India than Indians themselves.

    • @mdalfaaz8333
      @mdalfaaz8333 4 дні тому +5

      ​@@manisshthakur621har jagah ek hi comment chep rha hai 😂😂😂

    • @Anonymous_Introvert_26
      @Anonymous_Introvert_26 4 дні тому +14

      ​ @mdalfaaz8333 Doesn't matter how many times he comments the same, the point he is making is true to the core.

    • @shashanksanwal6787
      @shashanksanwal6787 4 дні тому +3

      No she is saying that 26/11 ki wajh se modis BJP got a space in indian public, or along with lot of reasons this is also a reason. I voted Modi I. 2014 for economy but he failed me congress performed better3 than him in their 10 years

  • @realplusimaginary244
    @realplusimaginary244 4 дні тому +25

    2 million muslims are in detention camps in Uyghur province of China under Communist/CPC military watch. All religions freedoms have been curbed brutally. They are suffering like hell. But Islam ka tekedar chup hai. The foreign educated Paxstani elite knows well when to ‘sell’ Islam and whom to sell it to. Selective amnesia! Allah ko daro yaar.

  • @atulmestry4472
    @atulmestry4472 4 дні тому +84

    Jugnu aunty is typical Lahori Punjabi Muslim ranting Indian Muslim Indian Muslim stuff😂😂😂.

    • @amarjeetsinghkala
      @amarjeetsinghkala 3 дні тому +4

      Far far away from ground reality!!! People like her are the reason why millions of poor Muslims in Balochistan/ KPK / Sindh and Northern Areas are suffering in poverty

    • @haiderfraz5148
      @haiderfraz5148 3 дні тому

      The Indian Muslims are in no way in a favourable position, plus all sorts of topics come up when you’re discussing miscellaneous issues in a podcast.

    • @rohand04
      @rohand04 3 дні тому

      ​@@haiderfraz5148
      The real reason why Muslim are really unhappy is BJP govt is treating them as Muslims have been treating their minorities for decades and centuries...
      BJP isn't actively discriminating against Muslim..
      Indian Muslim have been the centre point of most of Indian policy ever since independence.. congress in it attempt to defend its vision of post independence India.. tried very hard to keep Muslim happy.. so all our foreign policy and internal policies were in consideration of keeping them happy.. India kept distance from isreal.. in a attempt not to offend it's Muslim.. while Hindu never had a problem..
      Muslim took this to be norm .
      Christian Jain Sikh or Parsi were never a good political vote bank.. due to our size.. im a Christian.. all the opportunity that are created are created equally and we all have equal rights to pursue the road to prosperity..
      importance of Indian constitution is, that never cared about your religion while creating opportunities..
      hence we all succeed in education and wealth..
      Muslim took undue advantage of the population boom.. and increased population size. Rather than economic development
      Now post 2014 Modi did nothing but made them irrelevant to central government policy position..
      So what policy applies to all will apply to them..
      This irrelevance is what Muslim call discrimination..
      Now tell me what will you call all the Muslim countries.. please show me a single policy made by Pakistan keeping it minorities in picture..

    • @atulmestry4472
      @atulmestry4472 3 дні тому

      @@haiderfraz5148 well agree or not they only made themselves like that.

    • @atulmestry4472
      @atulmestry4472 3 дні тому

      @@amarjeetsinghkala They won't talk about this.

  • @developer-bd9my
    @developer-bd9my 4 дні тому +162

    not even a single line on condition of minority in pakistan but i heard only modi hindutva muslim 😂

    • @kishwerchaudary-n4g
      @kishwerchaudary-n4g 4 дні тому

      WHAT ABOUT YOUR "UNTOUCHABLES AND DALITS"? WHY THEY ARE TREATED SO BAD? THESE INDIAN CHRISTIANS AND MUSLIMS ARE PRODUCTS OF YOUR OPPRESSION. WATCH JIST ONE OF THE TRIBES HOW AND WHY THEY ARE ACCEPTING CHRISTIANITY, IT IS MOST RECENT VIDEO.

    • @kishwerchaudary-n4g
      @kishwerchaudary-n4g 4 дні тому

    • @kiranpeter5630
      @kiranpeter5630 4 дні тому +2

      Both husband and wife have always talked for the rights of minorities

    • @manisshthakur621
      @manisshthakur621 4 дні тому +10

      One common pattern I've noticed while listening to Pakistani UA-camrs and their guests is their confident belief that they know more about India than Indians themselves.

    • @shidharbhagwat5866
      @shidharbhagwat5866 4 дні тому

      She is daughter of Nazam setting the best Dalal of establishment. He and his daughter both are soft speaking poisons. They are best Muslims following the tenants religiously. Lies, deceit, peddling fake narrative, selecting talking...they must be the first collaborative tribe with invaders. Their ability is justify every crime of the narrative n provide excuse for the Islamic crimes.

  • @PawanVishwakarma-ye5fj
    @PawanVishwakarma-ye5fj 4 дні тому +89

    What about Hindus situation in Pakistan

    • @vamppires
      @vamppires 4 дні тому +2

      @@PawanVishwakarma-ye5fj aja bhai daikh le godi media daikhna band kar

    • @iamRitiksharma
      @iamRitiksharma 4 дні тому

      ​@@vamppiresLOOK AT THE DELINE IN NUMBERS OF POPULATION OF MINORITY IN PAKISTAN AND RISE IN INDIA .... IT WILL TELL YOU EVERY THING

    • @shivansh3440
      @shivansh3440 4 дні тому +10

      ​@@vamppires NIKHIL CHANDWANI naam ka ek instgram account hai . He isn't godi media .
      Usme dekh liya Pakistani Sindhi hindus ka haal

    • @Football-Pundit-n9m
      @Football-Pundit-n9m 4 дні тому

      @@vamppires0.6% Hindus compared to 15% muslims in India. Ab kya hi dekhne ko reh gaya. It is payback time. But we dont even need to do much. Payback is happening from inside Pak itself. Snakes grown in backyard is biting the hand that fed them.

    • @chaitanyakada1341
      @chaitanyakada1341 4 дні тому +3

      You are asking a wrong question to these Peacefuls who feel that they can talk bullshit and get away.

  • @shivampatil23
    @shivampatil23 4 дні тому +202

    Pakistani Intellectual care for -
    Parachinar ❌️
    Baloch ❌️
    Pastuns ❌️
    Indian Muslims ✅️✅️✅️✅️✅️✅️✅️
    Hope 1971 doesn't REPEAT in 2071 💀💀

    • @atulmestry4472
      @atulmestry4472 4 дні тому +7

      😂😂😂

    • @pankajtiwari461
      @pankajtiwari461 4 дні тому +12

      @@shivampatil23 Trust me Pakistan won't last till 2071

    • @kishwerchaudary-n4g
      @kishwerchaudary-n4g 4 дні тому +2

      DO "SHIVA" CARES FOR THE SUFFERINGS OF INDIAN FARMERS FROM PUNJAB(WHENEVER THEY ASK FOR THEIR RIGHTS THEY ARE BLAMED AS TERRORISTS), WHAT ABOUT MUNIPUR CHRISTIANS? WHAT ABOUT BENGAL AND ASSAM?

    • @kishwerchaudary-n4g
      @kishwerchaudary-n4g 4 дні тому +2

      WATCH YOUR BOARDERS.

    • @kishwerchaudary-n4g
      @kishwerchaudary-n4g 4 дні тому +1

      CHINA LOVES YOU AS YOU GAVE BILLIONS ON MONTHLY BASIS AND BY BABA JEE MODI. WOW.

  • @Shva927
    @Shva927 2 дні тому +8

    Pandit nehru did not built any new college.
    He just NAMED the prestigious stem based colleges built by british and indian businessmen.
    There was no colleges built!
    He just gave stability and did land reforms.

  • @developer-bd9my
    @developer-bd9my 4 дні тому +71

    she seems much concerned about muslims in india but what about the sikhs and hindus you mascared (and still doing) in pakistan and a nation that has all rights to muslims only have problem with modi and hindutva the whole country is full with hypocrites they see everything from the lens of religion full support to rss and bjp from my side against these hypocrites

    • @Sam-kd2dc
      @Sam-kd2dc 4 дні тому +11

      She is left leaning staunch muslim. What else you expect?

    • @atulmestry4472
      @atulmestry4472 4 дні тому +4

      ​@@Sam-kd2dcagree congressi from across the border.

    • @jasha9sandhu
      @jasha9sandhu 2 дні тому

      Average Pakistani " sahafi " 😂

    • @sreenarayanram5194
      @sreenarayanram5194 2 дні тому

      Islam and 72 hooris are arab concept culture and religion not indian subcontinent culture or religion
      Hindhu caste rajput gujjar jatt butt etc.. adopted Arab culture and living for Arabs distroyed their own culture and country for Arabs
      And alla is an arab god not indian subcontinent God concept
      And indian subcontinent is the most beautiful and most geographicaly diverse region in the entire world with wide variety of wether and the best place for human inhabitation through out human history of earth where as Saudi Arabia is mostly a hot desert with no river
      So Muhammad created a religion for the benefit of arab people and his arab land copying Christianity and Jewish religion offering 72 hooris and sex slaves for mens a dumb concept and he knows where ever islam grow ultimately it will benefit arab people and arab culture and he also requested to distroy other cultures to spread his own arab culture and the way he wants to see how the women's lives
      Now USA is also using and supporting and funding islam to destabilize their rival countries and regions expecilaly in central Asia and Pakistan banglades afganistan saudi arabia etc.. because now they know that Islam will do more damage than a newclear bomb for their rival country's and their culture

  • @maheshbhandari4287
    @maheshbhandari4287 4 дні тому +39

    If partition nahi hota ,to Pura area barbaad Hota aaj .....partition sahi hua but complete nahi hua ....

  • @sougat18
    @sougat18 4 дні тому +16

    These guys are still obsessed with Kashmir. Article 370 is a done deal. We Indians care about Bharat and Bharat only. Pakistan is a mere joke for us.
    We have nothing to do with you and your country.
    Also stop behaving that you know more about Bharat more than the citizens of Bharat.

  • @YOUTUBE_AMERICA
    @YOUTUBE_AMERICA 4 дні тому +92

    31:52 oh ma'am koi kitna sahega
    80 sal se toh bass sheh hi rahe hai
    1945,1947,1964,1962,1965,1971,1990.1999,2001,2009
    Yarr kuch toh sharm karo

    • @Itz_FJ5
      @Itz_FJ5 4 дні тому +3

      Kashmiries bhi seh rae hai indian occupation from 80 years kiu unko azad nahi krty?

    • @atulmestry4472
      @atulmestry4472 4 дні тому +10

      ​@@Itz_FJ5Aur hamesa rahege

    • @prabhatsingh4530
      @prabhatsingh4530 4 дні тому +14

      @@Itz_FJ5 bro baloch , sindhi , pashtuns sab seh rahe punjabi musalmano ko . kutta bana ke rakh diya mulk ka unko kab azadi mil rhai h please bataiye ?!!

    • @Itz_FJ5
      @Itz_FJ5 4 дні тому

      @ ma baloch hi hu saly duffer, aur hum sab proud pakistani hai

    • @ProNoooob97
      @ProNoooob97 4 дні тому

      ​@@Itz_FJ5sorry for kashmiris to keep them away from prosperity, happiness and democracy that they would get only in the "ISLAMIC" republic of Pakistan just like the rest of their country. Btw POK is the most prosperous part of Pakistan right now... 🎉🎉

  • @varun794
    @varun794 4 дні тому +9

    26/11 did change India. I literally remember my mum calling all our relatives saying her farewell because there were rumors that there were bombs in 10 buildings in Lokhandwala, Mumbai. We all were shit scared seeing our city under seige.

  • @rohand04
    @rohand04 3 дні тому +10

    41:17 Guru Tegh Bahadur
    The ninth Sikh Guru was beheaded by Mughal Emperor Aurangzeb in Delhi on November 24, 1675. Guru Tegh Bahadur was executed for refusing to convert to Islam. His execution and cremation took place at the Gurudwara Sis Ganj Sahib and Gurdwara Rakab Ganj Sahib in Delhi. India commemorates his martyrdom on November 24 every year.
    Guru Arjan
    Guru Arjan was executed by a Mughal emperor for political opposition. He compiled the first edition of the Sikh scripture, the Adi Granth, by 1604.

  • @KiranSahni-h1z
    @KiranSahni-h1z 4 дні тому +48

    Salman Rushdie said - Pakistan as a state was insufficiently imagined
    So sad

    • @vineetdeorari8017
      @vineetdeorari8017 2 дні тому

      He also says India is a rainbow whereas Pakistan is a sad monochromatic green

  • @rohitpatel4360
    @rohitpatel4360 4 дні тому +139

    Kashmir ko pakistan kaa hissa hona chahiye 🤡
    Rassi jal gayi lekin akad nhi gyi ......

    • @cute511teddy
      @cute511teddy 4 дні тому +31

      When I watch this channel I feel blessed to be in India. Agar padhe likho ka yeh haal hai..imagine!!

    • @moizahmed8355
      @moizahmed8355 4 дні тому +6

      Partition was done on the premise of Hindu majority areas being India and Muslim majority areas being Pakistan, based on that premise Muslim majority Kashmir logical annexation should be Pakistan...

    • @AbhishekVerma-jk2tt
      @AbhishekVerma-jk2tt 4 дні тому

      ​@moizahmed8355 then Sindh should have never gone to Pakistan. The initial idea of ppl can't live together was by Muslims. Hindus Sikhs did not bring this up. Khudh hi puthey kaam karke fir "haye haye" karna koi insey seekhey

    • @vamppires
      @vamppires 4 дні тому

      @@rohitpatel4360 tera yaha kiya kaam hai we don’t serve tatti in Pakistan india mein kha ja k 😂

    • @mohsinmumtaz2390
      @mohsinmumtaz2390 4 дні тому +1

      Kashmir ha hi hamar...rassi nai jalay ga...India jalay ga insha'Allah

  • @RahulYadav-ke5re
    @RahulYadav-ke5re 4 дні тому +30

    Kahi na kahi
    Pakistan 🇵🇰 ke intellectuals ka v point of view radical hi hai
    She is absolutely biased…

    • @urvashiverma9585
      @urvashiverma9585 4 дні тому +3

      Totally

    • @gonysharma
      @gonysharma 4 дні тому

      To tum bewkoof log inn se umeed hi kya rakhte ho..apna ghar dekho apne bharat ko dekho modi k piche raho ge to barbaad hi honge sab.

    • @Hnky_edits
      @Hnky_edits 4 дні тому +4

      They can't change. She has no shame over the way she talks on 26/11 as just a way for rss modi to gain their narrative!

  •  4 дні тому +29

    Muslims in india ka haal ? Mam ? So sure about a media narrative.
    You speak well mam , but you must make an informed statement .visas may be an issue , but please call educated Muslims and take a feedback .

  • @nishanttyagi29
    @nishanttyagi29 4 дні тому +40

    35:00 i challenged pakistan make a law CAA type and let's see how many muslim will migrate
    A single muslim will migrate they are cry baby here they are in denger from 75 years but their population is growing what tyoe of denger is this 😂😂

    • @zaffirbokhari3289
      @zaffirbokhari3289 4 дні тому

      pakistan is top countries to take in most refugees. muslims mostly

    • @srijandatta287
      @srijandatta287 4 дні тому

      @@zaffirbokhari3289 Prove it, how many went in the last 10 years??

    • @deshraj.insta.
      @deshraj.insta. 4 дні тому

      Please take as much you can from India ​@@zaffirbokhari3289

    • @s9ka972
      @s9ka972 4 дні тому

      ​@@zaffirbokhari3289 that's from Afghanistan. Indian Muslim don't want to go poor by migrating to Pakistan.

    • @mpqw
      @mpqw 4 дні тому

      ​@zaffirbokhari3289 we know why you took most refugees from Afghanistan. It was all aid money from US😂. Once the aid was stopped we all know how they were kicked out😂.

  • @NuvoUno-1
    @NuvoUno-1 4 дні тому +101

    Goa ko invade kar lete hai? ❌️
    Goa ko liberate kar lete hai. ✅️

    • @omanalinasir5955
      @omanalinasir5955 3 дні тому

      Depends on how you look at it.

    • @santoshkumarpati3998
      @santoshkumarpati3998 2 дні тому

      Kisse? Portuguese?

    • @jasha9sandhu
      @jasha9sandhu 2 дні тому

      Clever by half pakistani punjabi Islamists. Never mind 😂

    • @NuvoUno-1
      @NuvoUno-1 2 дні тому

      @@jasha9sandhu Kya kehna chah raha hai Gobar Buddhi?

    • @sreenarayanram5194
      @sreenarayanram5194 2 дні тому

      Islam and 72 hooris are arab concept culture and religion not indian subcontinent culture or religion
      Hindhu caste rajput gujjar jatt butt etc.. adopted Arab culture and living for Arabs distroyed their own culture and country for Arabs
      And alla is an arab god not indian subcontinent God concept
      And indian subcontinent is the most beautiful and most geographicaly diverse region in the entire world with wide variety of wether and the best place for human inhabitation through out human history of earth where as Saudi Arabia is mostly a hot desert with no river
      So Muhammad created a religion for the benefit of arab people and his arab land copying Christianity and Jewish religion offering 72 hooris and sex slaves for mens a dumb concept and he knows where ever islam grow ultimately it will benefit arab people and arab culture and he also requested to distroy other cultures to spread his own arab culture and the way he wants to see how the women's lives
      Now USA is also using and supporting and funding islam to destabilize their rival countries and regions expecilaly in central Asia and Pakistan banglades afganistan saudi arabia etc.. because now they know that Islam will do more damage than a newclear bomb for their rival country's and their culture

  • @Mazehimazelo
    @Mazehimazelo 4 дні тому +30

    32:20 #Correction- it's not Nehru it's #Sardar Patel who manage to get Raja Harisingh on the side of India...
    Same goes with Hydrabad and Other Princely states..

    • @santoshkumarpati3998
      @santoshkumarpati3998 2 дні тому

      Lol Sardar Patel kasmir ko India mein milane se problem hoga isliye Hari Singh ko chhod do ye baat Nehru ko kaha tha lekin Nehru ne Kashmir ko India mein mila diya tha. Itihas kitab se padho Terrorist organisation RSS ki shakha se nahin. 😂

  • @udayabose2357
    @udayabose2357 4 дні тому +24

    Pakistanis should look back at three events which helped build the wall.
    16th August 1946 - Direct Action ordered by Jinnah,
    1st September 1965 -Operation Grand Slam,
    26/11/08 - The attack on Bombay.
    The door is now permanently shut.
    Be happy.

  • @radhikaverma6603
    @radhikaverma6603 3 дні тому +10

    Maam , I’m a hardcore Punjabi. There was a time when I felt a connection with you guys but now I feel a total disconnect . I can say with certainty that the current generation is totally uninterested in building any bridges.
    When I hear any of your online / channel, discussions it’s all about Muslim , Muslim brotherhood, Islam etc,
    You made your choices n now seeing your obsession , I think partition was a blessing

  • @shivampatil23
    @shivampatil23 4 дні тому +68

    35:40 Romila Thapar 2.0 - Pakistani Version 😂
    It's 2025 & still Pakistani ELITE 🇵🇰 are selling this DECADES OLD JUMLA to Pakistani civilians - India me Muslims Khatre me Hai 😂😂

    • @SanjayChauhanMumbai
      @SanjayChauhanMumbai 4 дні тому +3

      Better than plagiarist Vikram Sampath 😀😀😀😀😀😀

    • @JohnSnow-l8j
      @JohnSnow-l8j 4 дні тому +8

      Yeah 😂 And the majority of these pakistanis actually read history from romila thapar😂

    • @shivampatil23
      @shivampatil23 4 дні тому +6

      @@SanjayChauhanMumbai Tipu sultan son got hurt 😂😂

    • @shivampatil23
      @shivampatil23 4 дні тому +4

      @@SanjayChauhanMumbai Please listen to the whole podcast & then decide your side, sir 😊😊😊

    • @Momin1-x3z
      @Momin1-x3z 4 дні тому +3

      ​@@SanjayChauhanMumbaikyu bro lagta hai chacha ka the wire tho hai hi

  • @vinod.19
    @vinod.19 4 дні тому +20

    Koi bhi beetaa hua maazi itni aasaani se dar-guzar karke aagey nahi badha jaata. All the love to you (anchor & guest both) but we Indians can never move past the hurt of 7/11 & 26/11 so easily. Warmth & Sincerity from India.

  • @ramdharisinghdinkar1069
    @ramdharisinghdinkar1069 4 дні тому +80

    If she is pakistan's standard of intellectual; a person who you think understand India; then you can only hope for mending relations with India. Apne bubble me rahoge to ab hamare yaha koi Pakistan ka khokhla aur one sided narrative sunana nahi chahta.

    • @il313li
      @il313li 4 дні тому +3

      Its the other way around actually. You live in a bubble and want others to see things through your "bubble view".

    • @ankush-89
      @ankush-89 4 дні тому

      @@il313lithanks for telling illiterate citizen

    • @ramdharisinghdinkar1069
      @ramdharisinghdinkar1069 4 дні тому +11

      @il313li if we are living in a bubble then why Pakistan's economy is sinking and India's is rising. Ye madam typical Aman ki Asha wali bakwas kar rahi hai. Aur is aman ke tamashe ne india ko bahut nuksan pahuchaya hai. Jab se India ne Aman ke Tamashe ki bakwas chhodi hai tab se hamare Halaat better hai. Actions and Results speaks louder than Words, Hopes and Narratives.

    • @atulmestry4472
      @atulmestry4472 4 дні тому

      ​@@il313liThats why it's good for India and Pakistan to be not in relation.

    • @user-rh5jp2sh4s
      @user-rh5jp2sh4s 4 дні тому

      BJP IT cell doing overtime 🤦🏻‍♂️. If they dislike all that so much, why in the first place watch the video, let alone comment on it, that also a channel called the Pakistan experience. .. but then duty is duty...

  • @kamaljeetsingh1467
    @kamaljeetsingh1467 3 дні тому +13

    There should be no relationship between india and Pakistan!! You stay happy in your country and we’ll be happy here!! Both countries have the rest of world to do business, India shouldn’t be focusing on Pakistan now instead engage the world and grow your economy why to engage with these people 😂🤷‍♂️ they got a country for Muslims now let them enjoy their and live in peace

  • @rohitkakran5792
    @rohitkakran5792 4 дні тому +39

    Why did pak attack Kashmir in ‘47?
    If not for it , it might have been a very different scenario

    • @Itz_FJ5
      @Itz_FJ5 4 дні тому

      Kashmir is suppose to be with pakistan as its a muslim majority state, the kashmiris who lives in azad kashmir are very happy to be with pakistan and the Kashmiris who are living under indian occupation are willing one day to be with their home country which is pakistan, you do the voting today in kashmir for being with pak or india and ull find out lol

    • @TheAnuragsingh
      @TheAnuragsingh 4 дні тому

      @@Itz_FJ5If that is the rule then population transfer is the way.

    • @Popularfuzzyking-t1z
      @Popularfuzzyking-t1z 4 дні тому +11

      @@Itz_FJ5lol😂you guys are so away from the reality . You attacked Kashmir and then maharaja went to India . All Pakistanis will come to India if given choice you guys have made them so poor

    • @asangha182
      @asangha182 4 дні тому +5

      The principle of Partition was that Muslim majority areas of 'British India' would become Pakistan, depending on factors like contiguity of borders etc. Jammu and Kashmir was NOT a part of British India, but a princely state. In fact the Maharaja, Hari Singh was the Chairman of the Chamber of Princes once. The rulers of these states had the right to choose between the two. This right too was insisted upon by Jinnah, because he had his eye on Bhopal, Junagadh, Hyderabad, all states with Muslim rulers but Hindu majority. He ended up with none of these. So, it was not as simple as 'Muslim majority hai toh Pakistan mein hona chahiye'. The principle of Partition did not apply to J&K, and their Maharaja chose India when Pakistan attacked it on 22nd Oct 1947. India duly came to it's rescue and pushed back the invaders to the current LoC. Sheikh Abdullah did not hold much sway in the areas beyond it, and he probably convinced Nehru to let it be. The decision of acceding to India was ratified by the J&K State Constituent Assembly on 6th Feb 1954.

    • @rohitkakran5792
      @rohitkakran5792 4 дні тому +7

      @ not saying it was muslim or hindu majority
      It was Kashmir’s decision to stay away from both countries, and it was Pakistan who attacked in night like cowards to capture Kashmir against will.
      What do you expect then , same reason you lost Bangladesh.
      And if you are asking for voting?
      It is Pakistan who is avoiding plebiscite, by not vacating pak occupied Kashmir.
      Because it fears “FAIR” voting might happen and they might loose kashmir.
      Plus don’t lecture India on voting, no PM of your have completed full term.
      Atleast first behave like a country and then ask states to join.

  • @jagchahal1393
    @jagchahal1393 4 дні тому +10

    Indian, why worry about pakistani comments on india. Its their views, driven by their doctrine of islam.

  • @osamakhangermany
    @osamakhangermany 4 дні тому +30

    5:55 madam earth ki population ghalat bata gayeen we're not 12 billion, rather just above 8 billion now

    • @vickboss6751
      @vickboss6751 3 дні тому

      Muslim problem since Muhammad 😂😂😂

  • @AdityaSharma-qi3iz
    @AdityaSharma-qi3iz 4 дні тому +77

    CONVERT HONE KE BAAD YAHI HAAL HOTA HAI SABKA , OBSESSED 😊

    • @kishwerchaudary-n4g
      @kishwerchaudary-n4g 4 дні тому

      WHAT IS "SHARMA" PROBLEM YOUR LAST NAMES SHOWS YOU ARE "BRAHMAN" SMUGGLED FROM CENTRAL ASIA TO CONTROL POOR INDIANS.

    • @anuchugh31
      @anuchugh31 4 дні тому

      She’s Punjabi Hindu/sikh Sethi. First they should be ashamed but next shouldn’t have relations with pak army, genocidal army. But they’re shameless because properties had to be bought in London

    • @manisshthakur621
      @manisshthakur621 4 дні тому +5

      One common pattern I've noticed while listening to Pakistani UA-camrs and their guests is their confident belief that they know more about India than Indians themselves.

    • @agyanibaba1144
      @agyanibaba1144 4 дні тому +2

      Right

    • @AdityaSharma-qi3iz
      @AdityaSharma-qi3iz 4 дні тому +1

      @manisshthakur621 JAZBATI AUR FAILURE KAUM HAI🙂🙂

  • @NatarajJaganmohan
    @NatarajJaganmohan 2 дні тому +5

    We indians do not want any relationship with Pakistan in trade nor Business

    • @abdulmanan3488
      @abdulmanan3488 6 годин тому

      Phir comment Kyo kerte ho bagho yahan se

  • @dodiraj1
    @dodiraj1 2 дні тому +3

    31:37 Modi is a natural progression from ABV - both ABV and Modi gave enough chances for a normal relationship between countries.

  • @vadlamudisaikrishna
    @vadlamudisaikrishna 4 дні тому +47

    I know mr sethi gets a lot of flak in Pakistan but as an Indian, I have always looked to Mrs Mohsin and her husband for a rational, thinking view from Pakistan. Disagree with her on Kashmir. Pakistan's premature invasion compelled the Maharaja to accede to India, even then it was Pakistan's commission which is to blame. Even now if you are to hold a plebiscite as Pakistanis demand, the Pakistani army will have to vacate Pok. Nevertheless my best wishes to them both, hope to see Mr Sethi on the podcast too.

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  4 дні тому +5

      I hope to also

    • @shatnermohanty6678
      @shatnermohanty6678 4 дні тому +4

      Very good points 👌

    • @mylord3003
      @mylord3003 4 дні тому +10

      She never spoke about secretive qabaili invasion on Kashmir by jinnah. So raja came running to India for help. India said, why would india have to loose life for a piece of land which is not its territory. Then raja agreed for accession agreement

    • @Popularfuzzyking-t1z
      @Popularfuzzyking-t1z 4 дні тому +3

      @@mylord3003yes she did not mention about mistakes of Pak attacking Kashmir

    • @fakebatli
      @fakebatli 4 дні тому +2

      The question of plebiscite is dead. It was legally dead after Pakistan partitioned PoK, and now it is buried 6 feet under after India partitioned it’s side.

  • @Randomdotexee
    @Randomdotexee 4 дні тому +53

    Sach toh ye hai ki kashmiri are India not Pakistani 😂

    • @moizahmed8355
      @moizahmed8355 4 дні тому

      Kashmir is Muslim majority and should logically have been part of Pakistan based on the premise on which partition was done,,

    • @amish2394
      @amish2394 4 дні тому +6

      @@moizahmed8355 India is a secular nation not hindu rashtra, this Hindu Muslim doesn't work in Kashmir, Kashmir and Kashmiris are Indian

    • @SunilKumawat57
      @SunilKumawat57 4 дні тому

      ​@@moizahmed8355 Lol Maharaja hari singh opted to remain a independent nation and wanted to develop kashmir on the basis of tourism just like Switzerland. Later on 24 october 1947 he sighed treaty with india. That document is still online you can watch on Google.

    • @Knowledgewithdeepakbaghel
      @Knowledgewithdeepakbaghel 4 дні тому

      ​@@moizahmed8355 then why all muslims not go to pakistan. Than you said ohh constitution

    • @Knowledgewithdeepakbaghel
      @Knowledgewithdeepakbaghel 4 дні тому

      ​@@moizahmed8355 25cr muslim living in india kya wo pakistan jane or taiyar then we think about kashmir.😂😂😂😂

  • @TruthPrevailz
    @TruthPrevailz 4 дні тому +7

    11:38 what is wrong with aunty ??? Muslims since 47 have progressed in india. Talk of your minorities aunty.

  • @ShivendraMishra-km9su
    @ShivendraMishra-km9su 4 дні тому +40

    साउथ एशिया का इतिहास इनके लिए मुगलों से शुरू होता है
    हमारा वैदिक युग से, बुद्ध से, अशोक से
    हम अलग हैं, थे, रहेंगे

    • @kishwerchaudary-n4g
      @kishwerchaudary-n4g 4 дні тому +1

      OUR HISTORY STARTS BEFORE GREAT KING ASOKA, TAXILA BELONG TO BUDDHA FOLLOWERS WHICH WERE DESTROYED BY HINDUS, WHY? IF THESE HINDUS WERE MUGHALS?

    • @ShivendraMishra-km9su
      @ShivendraMishra-km9su 4 дні тому

      @kishwerchaudary-n4g kis book se pdhi history?????

    • @amitsai
      @amitsai 4 дні тому +1

      @@ShivendraMishra-km9su true. And thats what Pakistan cant understand. This is the gap

    • @Carryminatiroastvx3dw
      @Carryminatiroastvx3dw 4 дні тому

      ​@@kishwerchaudary-n4gking Ashoka mother Subhagrani is Bhramin..pori History..Bhimte

  • @CGT127
    @CGT127 4 дні тому +10

    50 years of Aman ki Asha is shoved where the sun doesn't shines the difference with modi is that he refuses to be a fool like every other leader before him. That's the truth rest is poetry. 😊

  • @Football-Pundit-n9m
    @Football-Pundit-n9m 4 дні тому +13

    This humara tumhara attitude is the reason Pakistan is where it is. Keep it up..🤡

  • @kapilmhow
    @kapilmhow 4 дні тому +73

    This lady has no idea of today’s India. 😂😂😂😂😂

    • @visualdroplets
      @visualdroplets 4 дні тому +2

      Facts 😅

    • @h0w0w
      @h0w0w 4 дні тому +2

      Just like indians in podcasts are wrong about Pakistan

    • @indiranagar2007
      @indiranagar2007 4 дні тому +4

      Because she reads books and hasn't been educated by the whatsapp Univ like your esteemed self!

    • @vg82
      @vg82 4 дні тому +4

      @@indiranagar2007
      Acha aisi baat hai … so she is considered as intellectual of Pakistan???

    • @abdurrafay497
      @abdurrafay497 4 дні тому

      @@vg82still better than ur pm n that weird anchor.

  • @shivansh3440
    @shivansh3440 4 дні тому +16

    I m surprised to see , so many Pakistanis condemning 26/11.
    It would have been better if BOTH the countries would have come together to solve it , but sad .
    Yeh toh coincidence hai , that she , and Najam Sethi were in India that time when unfortunate incident of 26/11 happened. Atleast she might have felt , what COMMON INDIANS felt .

    • @RamsarangangwarSaran-ou1fj
      @RamsarangangwarSaran-ou1fj 4 дні тому +3

      She also connected with common Pakistani by telling Kashmir to Pakistan ka hona chahiye

    • @shivampatil23
      @shivampatil23 4 дні тому +1

      @@shivansh3440 why both countries should come together to solve Terrorism of Pakistan ???

    • @amirza1985
      @amirza1985 3 дні тому

      Bro wtf... We are not all terrorist sympathizers. It was a sad day.

    • @shivampatil23
      @shivampatil23 3 дні тому

      @amirza1985 every Muslim says same, before picking up gun 💀💀

  • @monistalha
    @monistalha 4 дні тому +25

    Seems like she read SAPIENS by Yuval Noah Harari just before coming for the podcast

  • @indian9428
    @indian9428 4 дні тому +6

    Their is a book ' Nehru's 97 Major Blunders' book by Rajnikant Puranik if Kashmir issue was also handle by Sardar vallabhbhai patel Sahebh then just like all other princely states POK would also be part of INDIA and BTW Kashmir is part of INDIA 19:37 Nehru was Socialist because of his policy INDIA paid the prize in 90's .. IMF said INDIA to open the markets what credit gose to Nehru ji is he stand non aligned he dint bow down in front of USA and USSR and we still follow it
    31:15 Seriously ISI is not to blame .. Islam Teachings is not to Blame 34:41 check the IMF report of poverty line of INDIA
    many pakistani see's India through lens by Indian left media outlets

  • @personalpr3723
    @personalpr3723 4 дні тому +21

    13:30 INDIAN changed DNA ? Or Paksitani??

    • @amitsai
      @amitsai 4 дні тому +2

      @@personalpr3723 what a beautiful reply. Identy crisis hee hai pakistan ka bada issue

    • @vineetdeorari8017
      @vineetdeorari8017 2 дні тому

      Converted DNA 😂😂😂😂 ek wo chacha bhi to hai Central Asia ke DNA wala jo bhonkta hai 😂😂

  • @sanjuktabrahma627
    @sanjuktabrahma627 4 дні тому +6

    Pakistan is 50 years behind India. India will be the 3rd largest economy of the world by 2027.Indian Muslims are lucky to stay in India,instead of Pakistan or Bangladesh

    • @maxtryme1508
      @maxtryme1508 3 дні тому

      No

    • @hemantpatel5691
      @hemantpatel5691 23 години тому

      Indian muslims are luck but Indian hindu are not so lucky ans have to live with 25 crore ticking time bombs.

    • @Guessswhosback
      @Guessswhosback 3 години тому

      Facts!!

  • @sunnybhat2997
    @sunnybhat2997 18 годин тому +2

    Maam I think you are wrong at Kashmir narrative....Nehru didn't manage Maharaja of Kashmir to visit Delhi before partition. It all happened after the partition, As Maharaja has decided not to accede to anyone.
    It was invasion of Pakistan on Kashmir which compelled Maharaja to go to Delhi and to sign the Accession so that India can help .
    Seriously I started to watch this podcast with interest but after this wrong information, I felt what kind of information would be there..
    For your kind information I m myself a Kashmiri...I know my history

  • @arslanahmed7530
    @arslanahmed7530 4 дні тому +5

    Nothing in the podcast is offensive, i don't know why people getting offended.
    Shehzad Ki jacket k ilawa it is perfect

  • @criticalthinker5764
    @criticalthinker5764 4 дні тому +8

    A failed state lecturing ,a developing and prosperous trending India . Ha ha

  • @avtarwasson4875
    @avtarwasson4875 4 дні тому +24

    Shahzad, i have been studying partition since the last 20 years. The movement for Pakistan was strong where the Muslims were in Minority e.g United and Central provinces. At best 10 to 15pc of those provinces wanted a separate state. Mr Jinnah wad opposed to plebiscite. How come the British gave nearly 40pc of land to Pakistan? Yet most of the Muslims didn't migrate to Pakistan.

    • @kishwerchaudary-n4g
      @kishwerchaudary-n4g 4 дні тому

      SORRY PUNJABIS NEVER VOTED FOR "EVIL TRAITOR JINNAH" WHO WAS FUNDED BY BRITISH AND THIS EVIL WAS "GUJRATI" WHO ACCOMMODATED HIS SUPPORTERS AND RELATIVES IN PAKISTAN AND TOOK OVER ALL THE PROPERTIES LEFT BY SIKHS AND HINDUS.

  • @Mjjjyyy
    @Mjjjyyy 4 дні тому +36

    I don't like the distasteful comments made by my fellow Indians, but one thing genuinely bothers: the Kashmir comment she made is awful.

    • @atulmestry4472
      @atulmestry4472 4 дні тому +21

      This Lahori aunty is blabbering that old lahori churan again.😂

    • @TheAnuragsingh
      @TheAnuragsingh 4 дні тому +6

      Don’t be Dhimmi bro .

    • @AI-uc1vs
      @AI-uc1vs 4 дні тому +2

      Lol…perhaps u should ask the Kashmiris if they want to be part of India or Pak. Though I suspect they would want neither

    • @prajwalbharambe343
      @prajwalbharambe343 4 дні тому

      ​@@AI-uc1vstheir opinion doesnt matter to us. they killed or converted all hindus.

    • @atulmalhotra2303
      @atulmalhotra2303 4 дні тому

      ​@@AI-uc1vsAn independent Kashmir will turn into a Yemen

  • @aakashsrivastava2418
    @aakashsrivastava2418 4 дні тому +9

    My only difference is that with what she said about kashmir Pakistan's creation took Sindh away from us we Indians cannot call the place as ours where we derive the name of our country, kashmir is also a big part of indian identity and places like vashno devi and amarnath which are in J&K have huge religious significance for a majority of population of India, she just said that british divided the subcontinent into the mindset of us vs them and then in the following line she advocated for Kashmir to be a part of Pakistan because it is muslim majority. There is a problem in Pakistani intellectual that they fail to recognise that this land of Undivided India has many places which are of utmost religious importance to a sizable chunk of population of India specially the followers of non abrahmic religion and last point the way in which being Indian is not = being Hindu in the same way being Kashmiri is not = being muslim, Jawaharlal Nehru whome she writly praised was a Kashmiri himself

  • @Dilli_da_Djinn
    @Dilli_da_Djinn 18 годин тому

    As an Indian from the South, this Podcast which I purposely avoided for sometime 😊, I am Humbled 🇮🇳🚩🇮🇳 What a Woman 🙏🏻 Been listening to NS' Chidiya for years but now I know, how he has been able to be Stable and Sound 😊 Thank You Bhai and Respect for Ma'am 🙏🏻🇮🇳🚩🙏🏻🇮🇳🚩 Realised what Real Hindutva means after listening to Her 🙏🏻🚩🙏🏻🚩 Roots Matter!! ❤️🇮🇳🚩❤️🇮🇳🚩🇵🇰🇮🇳🇵🇰🇮🇳 (First Time) Blessings to you Kiddo from a 55 yr young 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🚩🚩🚩

  • @bdjha1297
    @bdjha1297 4 дні тому +4

    India is such a fine democratic country that bjp still struggling for majority

  • @ksvinayraj
    @ksvinayraj 4 дні тому +13

    Allaha ne 6 din mei earth banayatha, aur 716 se noor ke din shuru huva🥰🥰🤣🤣

    • @haiderfraz5148
      @haiderfraz5148 3 дні тому

      Mate, please avoid talking about stuff, you only know through hearsay. You do not know about the Islamic concept of Ayyam/time and space/metaphysical realities understanding among Islamic Falasifah.

  • @_viralhog
    @_viralhog 4 дні тому +3

    Jugnu ma'am, you're so beautiful and your voice is so soulful that if I was in your era I wouldn't have allowed Najam Sethi saab to get even close to you. No wonder, ma'am, that Ali has become such a wonderful singer. All thanks to you, I guess. Your knowledge about Indo-Pak realions is exceptional, ma'am. I wish you a long and healthy life, ma'am. God bless you.

  • @RaiFaizanK
    @RaiFaizanK 4 дні тому +4

    From Lahore to Multan, there was only one person who held the rebellion against the British, Rai Ahmad kharal in 1857

    • @Carryminatiroastvx3dw
      @Carryminatiroastvx3dw 4 дні тому

      Bitish erased Memory of Indian of 1857 rebellion. But Veer Savarkar one who Steel document of this 1857 rebellion and take him to india

  • @AnupZutshi-v4f
    @AnupZutshi-v4f 4 дні тому +17

    Kashmir ko Pakistan ka Hissa honaa chaihiye tha..... KYON? What dictates that this is obvious? Do you have a historical context, territorial context etc?? This is the absolutely ASININE problem with Pakistan. This is how the intellectuals think...no wonder the common man on the street is easily misled. Pakistan's only solution now might be its Balkanization. It cannot survive in the new world order which is fast leaving it behind. Even if it tries to radically alter its psyche, it will take at least 2 decades to re-engineer its course. Balkanization might be the only solution.

    • @nick-l4o2z
      @nick-l4o2z 4 дні тому

      kashmir was rajas terrority 😊

  • @mianshahbazahmed2485
    @mianshahbazahmed2485 17 годин тому +1

    جگنو بی بی کاش آپ ساری بات اردو اور پنجابی میں کرتیں ۔۔ تاکہ عام بندے کی بھی سمجھ میں آ جاتا ۔۔۔ آپ کی باتیں ھر بندے تک پہنچنی چاھئے ۔۔۔ بہرحال بہت خوب انٹرویو ❤️🌹

  • @aanakrukavi
    @aanakrukavi 4 дні тому +30

    She is the actual Chidiya Najam Sethi keeps mentioning about 😂

  • @achharsinghgill472
    @achharsinghgill472 4 дні тому +5

    Very compelling discussion love and regards from England

  • @muhammadowais9067
    @muhammadowais9067 3 дні тому +5

    Me Sandhu Jutt hu aur isi dharti ka beta hu...aur mjhe fakhar he is bat ka ke I'm a son of soil...aur sher e Punjab maharaja Ranjit Singh, Hari Singh nalwa, Shaheed Bhagat Singh Sandhu aur Rai Ahmed Khan kharal mere heroes hain naa ke koi daku bin Qasim, ghaznawi, abdali mere heroes nahi Hain...and on the other hand I'm a proud Muslim too

    • @anujchaurasia8460
      @anujchaurasia8460 9 годин тому

      A proud Muslims....you're preparing for gajwa e hind na??

    • @Guessswhosback
      @Guessswhosback 3 години тому

      Jeonda reh veer! Rabb kush rakkhe tainu!

  • @mirajesh
    @mirajesh 4 дні тому +8

    I feel Pakistan should understand. Hindus has one country where they looking for there space as earlier politicians squeezed them for there vote. Hindus do respect all religious.
    If that was not the case India would have dividend with communal divide longtime.

  • @ryanabhishekkumar6616
    @ryanabhishekkumar6616 4 дні тому +3

    Shahjad’s English is better than any UA-camr in Pakistan . Anyone can assume Shahjad to be an Indian if he doesn’t speak any Urdu words

  • @ala7515
    @ala7515 4 дні тому +3

    Regarding Pakistan politics: A balanced point of view by Jugnu and this comes out of wisdom.
    Regarding Indian politics/Modi govt: Out of touch and away from the ground reality. I'm not a BJP/Modi supporter, but the overall development the BJP govt has brought is positive for ALL Indians.

  • @sydzainraza
    @sydzainraza 11 годин тому

    I was always a fan of her writing, but it was amazing to see her speak about all these different topics from the history of our region to the current politics. Also, it is rare to see someone say "I made a mistake" in Pakistan, which is something she bravely mentioned when asked about her support for Musharraf. Even admitted that it may be coming from a place of bias. Thank you Shehzad for conducting these podcasts wonderfully where the guest is not just asked questions but is engaged in proper engaging conversations. Your knowledge of a wide range of topics also surprises me quite often! Initially, I started showing the TPE episodes to my parents, but now I often see them watch a new episode before me 😄 Keep up the great work.

  • @nalinikoutha2091
    @nalinikoutha2091 3 дні тому +3

    first of all Pakistan should gain moral high ground by allowing Non-muslims to be eligible for holding high office in their country . till then this debate is moot. Ramesh kumar in pakistan said even their MNA members were asking him to read Kalma along with them. so what can we expect from pakistan . Even their present army chief has said that india has not recognized pakistan.

  • @AvinashPandey-h1h
    @AvinashPandey-h1h 2 дні тому +2

    List of modern days Sufis in 21st century Osama Bin Laden, Zakir Naik, Bitta karate, Imran Khan, Aljawahiri, Late.Mr. Jabbar, Afzal Guru, Ajmal Amir Kasab, Mulla Umar, Sayeed Sahabuddin, Jaki ur rehman lakhwi, Daud Hadley, Tahauur Husain Rana, Masood Azhar, Khalod Sheikh Muhammad, Muhammad Atta, Hafiz Saeed, zafar Iqbal, Hibatullah Akhuzada, Al Baghdadi, Burhan Wani,Zakir Musa, Yasin Malik,Ashfaq Wani, Javed Ahmed Mir,Ahmed Omar Saeed Sheikh, Salman Saqib, Fahad Naseem, and Shaikh Adil these are just few most famous across the world names of sufis and torch bearers of human kind who are or have spread the love,humanism, RIP the actual essence and meaning of religion of peace that is Islam, although the list is too much lengthy that we need to run this list in While loop in python.😂😂😂

  • @makadiyaronak2054
    @makadiyaronak2054 4 дні тому +9

    Madarasa me padhe huwe dono bacche 😂😂😂

    • @yusraashraf1489
      @yusraashraf1489 3 дні тому

      better than RSS ke chakkay anyday

    • @ajaygarwa9662
      @ajaygarwa9662 3 дні тому

      ​@@yusraashraf14891000 time's better than madarsachap

  • @haroonashraf3860
    @haroonashraf3860 2 дні тому

    With reading so much over the years, i've lost stamina for big screen. But I watched this episode uninterrupted and didn't check my phone even once. Also, I lost interest in Pakistani politics long ago, now I feel provoked again and eager to know more and remain updated. Lastly, what a pleasure listening to Jugnu sahiba for two hours straight. What a brilliant conversationalist. I consider myself a well read and informed person but listening to such people makes you realize how little you know. The canvas of her world view is immense. Also, it feels like she's definitely a great company for her friends and loved ones. God bless.

  • @deepakkulkarni4270
    @deepakkulkarni4270 4 дні тому +4

    @38:45 she is saying islam maar dhad se nahih faila.........aurngeb, tipu sultan to shanti doot the......there were many more like them.........and this is the level of pakistani intellects......hahahaha......and after that i stopped watching.......

    • @Hnky_edits
      @Hnky_edits 4 дні тому +1

      They won't agree but also spread lies. That is how they want islam to be seen as to they being accepted by others. But reality is what even they know but won't speak up on their wrongs!

  • @riazahmed340
    @riazahmed340 19 годин тому +1

    Real intellectual ❤

  • @mirajesh
    @mirajesh 4 дні тому +3

    I give full credit to Honourable Lady for her guts to speak frankly regarding the establishment role in Pakistan politics

  • @syedkazmi5474
    @syedkazmi5474 3 дні тому +1

    I can hear her voice for years. It's just like therapy to hear her💯🍀

  • @gytsixp
    @gytsixp 4 дні тому +5

    Nehru more than Patel understood the genius of its people.His call for Total Independence in 1930 was given from Lahore. And mind you, when Nehru conceptualised a liberated India,it encompassed UNITED INDIA. In Nehru's social and political ideas were discussed and adopted in Congress Karachi convention and was applicable to entire united India.

    • @anikeshmidya4882
      @anikeshmidya4882 4 дні тому +1

      yes that's why Karachi and Lahore are still the highest polling regions for Congress even today

  • @sanjayvhawal2404
    @sanjayvhawal2404 2 дні тому +1

    very thoughtful and balanced discussions

  • @redheadin
    @redheadin 4 дні тому +8

    Modi make them so frustrated 😂😂
    Imagine when yogi came in power😂😂
    Yeh log matam manayenge 😅

  • @raghunandan9290
    @raghunandan9290 4 дні тому +4

    What a Load of BS.
    The British didn't Teach Hindus that they Liberated Hs from brutal Islamic Rule ....
    Neither did RSS Hindutva think so.
    Marathas have completely nullified Islamic rule all over india.
    Its Hindu Rule ,Swaraj which was Removed by British .
    Mughal Rule just remained within Delhi because Marathas wanted to keep it that way

    • @chaitanyakada1341
      @chaitanyakada1341 4 дні тому +1

      What more can one expect from
      “Pathological liars” ??

  • @fatimamashood3825
    @fatimamashood3825 3 дні тому

    This was a brilliant conversation, very well led by the host as always. My absolute favorite part of the conversation was in fact: "1:34:00 Imran Khan and what is the solution?"
    It's important to unite, when the leaders are finally on the same page about who we need to fight for and from whom- what the solution really is.

  • @agyanibaba1144
    @agyanibaba1144 4 дні тому +6

    Radical Jugnu....😂😂😂😂😂

  • @ZeeClicks
    @ZeeClicks День тому

    Just loved it. Ghias, you're doing a wonderful job. I hardly subscribe to any channel, but yours is one of my favourite, more power to you, brother
    Zia Khattak ❤

  • @Devpal-un7kh
    @Devpal-un7kh 4 дні тому +21

    Inke intellectual se pata chalta why pakistan is like that

    • @abdurrafay497
      @abdurrafay497 4 дні тому

      Name ur intellectuals? Modi and kangna ranaut? N what u mean is pak like that, u are 3 t economy for billions of ppl dnt consider urself a superpower

  • @idbhandari9952
    @idbhandari9952 День тому

    Nostalgic in parts,Historical in parts, interesting conversation.Sub- continental contradiction are unique in the history🎉🎉

  • @anuchugh31
    @anuchugh31 4 дні тому +3

    I read comments of fellow Indians and decided to give this podcast a pass. But wanted to say her husband is Punjabi Hindu/sikh Sethi. First they should be ashamed but next shouldn’t have relations with pak army, the genocidal army. LeT was responsible for 26/11 and multiple other terrorist attacks against India are army’s assets. But they’re shameless because properties had to be bought in London and children had to be settled abroad. Just like all high officials of Pakistan. The country is a gateway to earn money and settle abroad.

  • @anupkalarickal9237
    @anupkalarickal9237 День тому

    Am not a punjabi, but loved the way madam spoke in punjabi. Great work

  • @SomnathDe-h7d
    @SomnathDe-h7d 4 дні тому +8

    Watching from India.
    Enlightening. Appreciated.

    • @atulmestry4472
      @atulmestry4472 4 дні тому +2

      Really 😂😂

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience  4 дні тому

      🙌

    • @chaitanyakada1341
      @chaitanyakada1341 4 дні тому +4

      You have bought into the AlTaqqia lies of these pathological liars !!
      And you felt that you were enlightened !!!!

    • @srijandatta287
      @srijandatta287 4 дні тому

      lying is an art of making gawars, take their side.

    • @fakebatli
      @fakebatli 4 дні тому

      Could you state a few things you were enlightened by?

  • @aone_ideas786
    @aone_ideas786 3 дні тому +1

    Madam,
    NS never been nutral. He always speak the mind of Army Generals
    Love Imran Khan❤❤

  • @usmanmir
    @usmanmir 4 дні тому +3

    BEAUTIFUL PODCAST PLEASE ALSO INVITE HER BETTER HALF :]

  • @malomattv5489
    @malomattv5489 4 дні тому +1

    پورے دو گھنٹے کی بورڈ کاسٹ میں نے دیکھی ہے اور بہت ہی انفارمیٹو ڈسکشن تھی اور تسلیم کرنا پڑے گا کہ جگنو محسن صاحبہ بہت ہی شاندار خاتون ہیں

  • @something1162
    @something1162 4 дні тому +3

    Heard the whole thing in one go. Wonderful listen. And you have the grace not to say it like that but I feel both your hopelessness about what the future holds. Would definitely like to hear a podcast with Jugnu again, and with NS too if possible, they're uniquely sensible and have a wealth of perspective to share from what all they've seen.