Brother, your research is very good, but I have a question: all the researchers you're referencing are non-Muslims. These people have always written against Islam. We can't blindly trust their research. Moreover, Allama Mohammad Iqbal has also spoken well of Mahmood; if there was something negative, Iqbal wouldn't have praised him. What's your take on this?
He has no take. He just find online articles suiting his ideology and thinking and makes his point based on that. Because he is promoting a propaganda, nothing else. He is a propagandu
I have been watching hundreds of Pakistani UA-cam channels for the last several years, some of them are cricket analysts, some are fake UA-camrs making videos on Indian content, some are geopolitical analysts, and some are good podcasters, but there is one person who is probably of my son's age, I have so much respect for him that I feel like saluting him. This man does not want to forget the past of his ancestors, likes to stay connected to his roots and fearlessly puts forward his views in a narrow-minded society.
@@Nat-ConPakistan literacy rate is 58% Lowest in the religion Can we call you unpad jahil kaum? Pakistan is biggest beggar of IMF bailout package in world Can we call you beggar?
@@theshahrukh_ali They're twisted stories. Written by those with any other motivations. For instance, Akbar had infact had his own Harem, which is never told in NCERT.
Hello syed I am from haryana(india) and there are literally folk songs about lootmaar done by ghaznavi in my local language. One of those songs is jaat lutere ragini in which the singer is praising khokar jats of sindh region for taking a stand against ghaznavi and in our culture we always own our heroes whether they were born in modern day india or pakistan. I think you should listen to this ragini ,it is available on youtube and you will find a haryanvi point of view about all this and much more in that song. Love your work from india
Jaats were Darbaris and their women were sent to harems of Mughals for sexual pleasure(Google:Darbari Jaats). They were conidered Chandaals but due to Punjab Land Alienation Act 1900, they were gifted lands by Britishers. And these same chandaals now consider themselves upper caste and tell how European they are, meanwhile Jaat women of Haryana look Dehaati af
Yes, local Jaats and Rajputs of Multan and Sindh defeated Ghaznavid forces and inflicted heavy losses on Mahmud's army. They kept harassing them after their sack of Somnath Mandir...
People hungry for power money own interest will not leave the subcontinent because the common people are also the same.. It's just they don't get chance.. Khuda hi akl de sabko
@@ranahammad6823 The relationships between Rajputs and Jaats are complex. As there are same clans in both Jaatis + He is referring to the Jaats of Multan and Sindh. This is true. They were brave men....
Somnath mandir was not looted just once but 4 times. 1026 by ghazni(looted 17 times) 1299 by ulugh khan 1395 by muzaffar shah 1 1706 by aurangzeb Now anyone can imagine Wealth and importance of temple. Still somnath is standing tall ❤ Kuchh baat hai is civilization ki koi mitaa nahi paaya ❤
Tum log khud hi Kafi ho issay mutant k Liye... Apnay hath say bna k Khuda mantay ho...jis nay saree dunya ko banaya usay ye Hindu bna rahay Hein...what joke... Watch movie.. PK😂😂😂😂😂
@umarkhan-tu3cq Allah ka shukr hai ke me maulana Abdul Kalam Azad ki pukar pe ruk gaya. JAMA Masjid, taj mahal , Lal qila ke liye ruk gaya.. tumhare tarha nahi ke suwar khane waale ke peeche Islami mulk banaya... 😀😀😀
Your actual heroes are Raja Daheer , Maharaja Ranjit Singh , Maharaj Chuch of Sindh , Raja Porus , Khan Abdul Gaffar Khan , Bhagat Singh , Dr. Abdul Salam , Raja Salya (Mahabharat era) , Chanakya etc whome you hate because most of them are Hindus & Sikhs .
Alhamdulillah , I left this hyper nationalism and religious fanaticism. Alhamdulillah I'm an Agnostic Now. Who feels connected towards Our Indian Roots.
Lmao. Read the history more. We were Hindus but we became Muslim and has been as such for thousands of years now. So your culture and tradition is Muslim Punjabi or Sindhi or whatever the race.
All thanks to British colonization, who created India after conquering dozens of nations one by one and then leaving their trained army, railways, factories, industries, English schools, Cinemas, Ports, Legal system, Parliament, bridges, printing press etc etc for " India". Historically, physically, racially ghatia qoums aaj tain tain ker rahi hain
@@sabrinakhan8217The British didn't create it out of thin air , those railways, buildings, bridges etc were done with Indian money, indian labour, and Indian soldiers, it's not for nothing that India was called the crown jewel of the Empire, the British also did the same things in Burma, Africa and half the globe where are those countries today except the anglo Saxon US & Australia. Go and read history madarsaachhap
@@sabrinakhan8217Indian is able to create thair own thing. If you think India grew up because of Britishers no doubt Britishers give lot of things. You need knowledge about history . If India doesn't have anything then why gazni , mehmud ghori, nadir shah , temur , Britishers comed India. India has already wealth and knowledge
The entire narrative was based on falsehoods, as the country was divided to serve the interests of a specific Muslim population in certain areas, while others were neglected. This led to the fabrication of more lies to sustain this division and the hegemony of a small elite. As a result, the poor are trapped in miserable conditions, lacking security, food, education, clean water, and any hope for a better future, while others continue to loot their resources
Pakistan itself have no history. You are all Indian by origin by DNA by blood you people just change your religion. Just by changing your religion it doesn't mean you change your Indian heritage.
As a Punjabi Pakistani Muslim i fully agree with Muzammil and khawaja asif. Looters who plundered beautiful Punjab must be exposed and no soft words for them. Enough is enough, tired of reading pk studies fiction.. I'm Pakistani for 75 years, but I'm Indian and Punjabi for thousands of years..
I am settled in USA for the last 37 years , being Indian native it is my curiosity to listen both pakistani and indian you tubers, i must say syed Muzammil is my most favourite , he works very hard to find truth , and is very dedicated in his profession to bring facts to the people. Mr Muzammil your hard work will never go wasted or unnoticed it is educating millions of youth in pakistan who have been brain washed with wrong history, never give up your hard work keep up your passion and hard work best wishes from USA dr Raj K dhar
I believe there are only a few things, even Pakistan itself can be proud of it and Muzamil is one❤ long live brother more power to you more power to the truth
Proud to be Sindhi ❤️🙌 who knows about history from the past Pakistan studies always though he is a hero but he was big looter my father used to tell he used to loot temples also whole Mughal empire was looter
This is British and Hindutva given history. Ghaznavi, Ghouri Abdalli and Mughals were supported by many nations in current Pakistani region. Northwest ( current Pakistan) have always had trade and cultural ties with Central Asia (Afghanistan, Iran, Uzbikistan Turkey) and attacks towards Ganga Jamuna ( current India minus Chinese burmese Tibet regions of so called Northeast Indioa that were captured by British). Otherwise, it's not possible to conquer region after region without local support. Afghan, persian and Uzbik history speaks of no such blood bath. In fact they speak of support and invitations from different South Asian nations. South Asia is a region like Europe and never a natural country. This region was/is full of dozens of culturally, religiously, historically, racially and linguistically separated nations for over 10,000 years. They were attacking and killing each other. Kingdoms from Northwest like Maurya, Kushan, dahir etc have always attacked ganga Jamuna. Mauryans alone killed 30 million ganga jamnis and destroyed their temples. Ask South Indians, they hate Indus Valley and Its kingdoms and refused to call themselves Indooz aka Hindus ( a name given by persians to ppl of Sindh) until Indra Gandhi bombed Tamil tigers twice. There was no Hindusthan before Ghouri and no India before British.
Learned Indian history from Pak Studies apparently. Hindus didn't have a practice of destroying places of worship of other religions. There are many places in India where Hindu. Buddhist and Jain temples have stood side by side for thousands of years. Hindus willingly and happily visit gurdwaras and worship there too. Because Hinduism accepts that there is one God but each of us can imagine him and worship him in any form that appeals to us. There is no hatred for the other.
Hindu heritage...?? It's regional identity.. or nationally... Not Hindu Muslim Sikh etc... Umeed hy ap baat ko smjho gay.. or GObar khorOn ko Trah react Nii kro gay...
(As a Punjabi cmnt kar raha hun ) ❤️🔥Pakistan 🇵🇰 ki buniyad hinduo se nafrat se shuru hui or aj b yeh missilo k name gori gaznavi yeh wo sab hinduo ki nafrat k silsaly main rakhy gay. But as a Punjabi Pakistani 🇵🇰 main samjhta hun k har wo Punjabi jisny punjab k culture punjab ki zameen k defaa k ley kisi se jang larhi wo hamara hero ha chahy wo hindu raja dahar hindu raja jey pal ya sikh maharaja Ranjeet Singh ho ya muslim hero Ray Ahmad khan kharal ho. Mery ley wo aham han. Or yeh sab gaznavi gori yeh wo sab k sab hamary ley dako or choor k ilawa kuch nai thy lehaza ham inko apna hero hargiz nai manty apni mitti mery ley sabse pehly ha. Or yeh sab to mery aj k watan Pakistan 🇵🇰 k b dairy se bahir hn. Lehaza mitti pehly ha.
to per to arbayo ka hero to muhammad SWA ka jaga na agozo ballah abo jahal , or dosra kafar mulk ka hero hona cahya , tora mind open kar ka bat ko smajo
I'm punjabi hindu rajput or hamare punjab me aj bhi abdulla bhatti k naam pe lohri festival manaya jaata hai or usko hero consider Kiya jaata hai kyunki usne muglo k julm k khilaf awaj uthayi or apni jaan de di par wo aj bhi hamare dil me Zinda hai
Mahmud is not our hero, he was a warrior and warriors are bloodthirsty plunderers. We belong to this land and our heroes were those who fought against the aggressors. Our hero is Raja Poorwa of Jehlum, Raja Rangeet Singh, Rai Ahmad Khan Kharal, Bahgat Singh, lala lajpat Rai and others.
That means that the you are not grateful to be a muslim if your heroes are the likes of raja dahir ranjeet singh over the likes of Muhammad bin qasim and muslims that make us all look like ungrateful
The day we understand that we share the same culture, sane icons, same ancestry and have always been culturally Bharat,united bharatvarsh... Peace will prevail
@@chaudhryALIG We will definitely do. If he was truthful. Syed is neutral, Rathe is not. He is against a particular political party does propaganda and does not even live in India. Never talks about historical empires but just Mughals. Do you think India was uncivilized before 7th century? Before invasions India was considered to be the richest and prosperous. This is not just an Indian claim, historians from all over the world say that. But someone who claims neutrality should be unbiased which Ratee is not. Who cares about Modi? Modi is not Bharat.
@@chaudhryALIGdhruv rathee is credible ?? Dhruv's whole channel is based on anti modi....and most of his subscribers doesn't have to do with truth they just blindly follow him🥲🥲🥲
@StayFocused-m4w Till 1000AD india had 30-40% world GDP and right till 17th century 24% of World GDP and was at proto- industrial stage BEFORE Europe. West looted and developed on the ashes of India. By 1947, GDP share crashed to 2%
Why you don't appreciate Rahul Who talks secularism in India why you Support Modi In India who talks extremism Hindutva and Hindurashtra why you support Muzammil Who talks secularism in Pakistan hypocricy and it peaks😂
Thank you Syed Muzammil Shah for exposing the truth about these cruel looters who were so obviously only motivated by power and financial gain. Please stay safe! You are a light to us Pakistanis.
Quran has a chapter 8 (Surah Al-Anfal ) which means Loot Mar ka Maal and in that Allah and beloved prophet justifies killing Kafirs (chapter 8 verse 12) and how to split the spoils of war how much will caliph take etc...
The Somnath Temple today is a fabulously rebuilt structure in all its glory. Gujarat is among the most developed provinces in India, and the district where the temple is- has infrastructure and wealth comparable with any developed country. Compare that with Baghdad and Ghazni of today. Time has a sweet way of taking revenge.
Well said, I feel bad for the people of Iraq and Afghanistan and I wish things will get better in both places. Our somnath is standing tall and in all its Glory ❤️.
bhai aap Mahmud Gaznavi ko to bhala bura bol rahe ho but ye aapka Akhilesh Yadav daily basis par sanatan ko abuse kar raha hai eska kya karoge. Ye log bhi Gaznavi se kam nahin hai.
What do you mean those who looted it are living in ruins? how many 1000 year olds do you know? I am from that region and certainly did not ruin Soomnath or any other temple. This channel, among others, is to bring enlightenment. Live that way bro, don't go the dark route. Peace
Hahaha. Muslims enslaved you for 1000 years. Muslims are spread everywhere whereas hindu clowns are limited to 2 countries. Muslims will always be your Abbu Ji. 💪💪💪
@@theadnanrazait’s not we have archeological evidences , astronomical evidences , textual evidences of Krishna , Rama existing on earth and walked on India’s land ! India is the only land due to geographical conditions survived younger dras, mass extinctions !
I am always confused, that why especially Pashtun believe that they could not be pegan, Hindu or Buddhist. What makes us Pashtun believe that we were not having any religion other islam before it. Seriously this question should be asked from us Pashtuns. We were a part of this local system of hind. Why do we believe we are not from this region or we don't have any relationship to this land of hind.
Bro first learn pashtoon history we are basically from Palestine migrated okay we are in the generation of talot and his son armeya alih salam and armeya alih salam had a son afghana okay learn history first
Iam from Sindh , Pakistan.Our people rejected all the invaders and looters since years but no one listened us ;when we called the Muhammed bin qasim as a looter.
Prophet Muhammad looted Quresh and there goods so what would you say? In the rule of Umar bin khattab Muslim forces attack and invade many empires as well so what would you say? Mughals and Brithers came and rule the whole Sindh and Hind what would you say?
Bro come back to your original culture which is hinduism ,I'm not against any religion but our culture and our ancestors were all sanatani hindus ,we are same ,our blood are same ,we are all sons of sanatani culture
A coward who thinks that killing another faith for his own sake is no hero, looters can never be legends, they are beggars with an army. And for the fact, there is no Ghazni today but only our great temple is standing.
Ruined? Afghanistan defeated the Soviet Union, USA and is still growing faster in terms of economy. Meanwhile india can't even resist little Pakistan 😂economy is shedding up
@@FlawLess_333 Afghanis were defeated by Raja Maan singh under Akbar's reign and later were countlessly defeated by Sikh and ruled over them for 100s of years
My identity is Muslim when Human created by Allah in the Name of Adam As. After that my identity renewed in 1400 years ago ,when Muhammad (peac be upon him) came.My identity as a muslim renewed again When Quide Azam made Pakistan in the name of Islam.
To be honest these things doesn't hurt us , somnath is standing with lots of wealth . The country which attacked it (Afghanistan) and the one who idolises it ( Pakistan) is in ruins , struggling to survive , begging from every courtry while my country India is about to become 3rd largest economy and 2nd largest economy in coming 20 years . Yes our leaders didnt control population of india and that's why we have population of poor also and we will change it .
Please clarify first in what ? Filhaal to dono marne maarne mein lage pade hain. Your advise and evidence based future predictions will help viewers. @@Dominatingman
Respect your sentiments. However, you are not going to be a global power. Your government is running on the same pattern that we followed for years. Wait for consequences😅
Being a pakistani hindu mujhe sharmindgi hoti thi class 10th mai urdu ka chapter parhte huay "somnath ki fateh" aur jabke sab muslims ghor sy sunte thay ...
I'm from 'SOMNATH'. SOMNATH ABHI BHI MAJBUTI KE SATH SINA TAN KE KHADA HAI. AUR JINHONE SOMNATH KO LUTA , USKA NAAM O NISHAN AUR USKE HALAT DEKH LO JAKAR😂
Brother Vikash if you think any raw kind of people become automatically civilised because of claiming islam as religion then (with due respect but)you are in dellusion. I have personally seen Muslims being arrogant while quran says it without leaving any chance for discussion that "A camel may pass through the eye of a needle (which is simply impossible) BUT an arrogant human being will never enter into God's grace (i.e heaven)." So those Muslims who put such lessons in school books you can imagine the weakness of their minds as well as humanity. By the i am myself a Muslim But why shall that lead me to praise ourselves where we don't deserve any.
Koi sharm ki baat nahi hai bhai inko nasal chali gai hum hindu hai aur rahenge sanatan satya hai aur rahega somenath wahi sina tan ke khada hai ghazni dhul ho gaya hai
Abhi somnath boht hi jyada sundar hain, I am from Gujarat, kafi baar Somnath darshan krne bhi gye hain. Itni baar “Fateh” krne k baad bhi aaj humara mandir wesa ka wesa hain but jisne loota uska aata pta nahi.
Aap log ne ye right kho diye or aaj dekho apke pas kud ka nam tak nhi hai or dna ki to bat xoro aap yisbak ye tentoin hai kon sa culture folk keu arab or apna jo kar rhe ko aapke sath dhokha huwa hai ye sabko pata hai par ye dhokha aap log kud hi kud ko diye or aab nhi nikl pa rhe
That person must've called himself as "genius", not by others. Because, without being emotional and serious, nothing can be learned or remembered. The person who does this without being emotional n serious, is just a news reader who keeps doing his same job everyday, learns nothing.
Quran has a chapter 8 (Surah Al-Anfal ) which means Loot Mar ka Maal and in that Allah and beloved prophet justifies killing Kafirs (chapter 8 verse 12) and how to split the spoils of war how much will caliph take etc...
Loved the presentation, articulation, bravado and above all, unadulterated facts. I would love to see longer, documentary-type content from you. Best wishes from 🇮🇳
Nabi saw ne kaha jo log apne kafir aba o ajdad par fakhar or unki himayat karte hain muslim hone ke bawajud unki misal aise he jese wo un kafiron ki sharam gah apne mu me rakh len.
One of the wonderful unbiased presentation. It is not the matter of hindu or muslim truth is always truth. Lots of love and appreciation from TN India.
A very brave & intelligent narration of authentic history by Muzzamil... it's not easy to learn but it's harder to "UNLEARN" & see the world with a realistic new perspective. As always a great podcast. Thanx a lot Muzzamil.
About a decade back a Pakistani posted on Twitter that Mahmud massacred as many Muslims as Hindus. I was not convinced at that time but today you proved him right with references. Thanks Muzammil.🙏
Books refered are not original source You have described your view point,not history,dont claim it. Afghans are not foreigners in Hind as Afghanistan has been its part since ancient. Your speach has contradictions. You cannot explain why enormous wealth was accumulated and stored in religous places with Brehman class.
@@Knockingvoice65 You nitiwit, Enormous wealth was stored in Religious places under rule of Kings. Brahman doesnt own anything. its the Royals who owned temples. First learn real history not whatsapp forwards.
I have no idea how long it will take to actually teach the correct history to Pakistanis. Just saying wont be enough because the brain washing is too deep. I think the previous generation and the current generation are too far gone. We just need to protect the new generation.
If you start today to teach actual history, it may take 10-15 years to rectify the situation. Of course , reforms must be brought to the madraasa education which should be confined to only religious studies. Otherwise children will be confused and any effort to correct the situation will go waste. ..
بھائی تمہاری ہسٹری کیوال 1947 کے بعد کی ہے کبھی اسکے آگے اور پہلے کی پڑھنے کی کوشش کرنا اگر خود کی آنکھیں نہ بھر آئے تو بولنا ،جنکے ساتھ لوط مار ہوئی و کوئی اور نہیں ہمارے ہے پرواز تھی ،وہ الگ بات ہے کی آج کنورٹ ہو گئے ہو تو نہیں سمجھ آئیگا
Punjabi 🥻 everywhere the protector of their benefits they never can listen truth and neither speak truth. What's their achievement at all? Except of looting the benefits of every government 😢
@@yogeshdobhal5773dharam badalte rehte hain pr identity nhi badlati Punjabi chahy hindu ho sikh ho ya Muslim Punjabi to Punjabi hi hota hai amd hindu Muslim sikh Punjabi are brother genetically
Quran has a chapter 8 (Surah Al-Anfal ) which means Loot Mar ka Maal and in that Allah and beloved prophet justifies killing Kafirs (chapter 8 verse 12) and how to split the spoils of war how much will caliph take etc...
Tum Bangladeshi to kisi kaam ke hi nahin ho aur na baat karne layak. kya aatank machaya hua hai vahan rahne wale hinduo me. Sach me Bangladeshiyo se bada ehsaan faramosh nahin dekha, humne aap logon ko freedom dilwayi apne sainiko ke balidan kiya aur aaj daily basis par hamari hi insult karte ho. Ashamed on you people.
مشاہد حسین سید کیس قسم کا سید ہے جیس کا ڈی این اے سید ھونے کہ باوجود ایک ڈاکو لوٹیرے سے جاملا نانبی پاک نااہلبیت ع سے ملا ایک چور ڈاکو لوٹیرے سے جاملا کیسی نے سہی کہہ ضمیر زندہ ھونا چاہتے اگر بغض اہلبیت ع نا ھوتا تو ان مزاہیلوں کہ نام حیدر ذولفقار حسین حسن عباس مختار ھونے لیکن افسوس ہے😢😢😢
یار میں راجپوت ہوں، انڈین خطے کا اصلی باشندہ اور اسی وجہ سے بیرونی حملہ آوروں کو بہت برا سمجھتا ہوں، ہمارے وسائل چھینے گئے اور تم سید ہو جو کہ آیا عرب ملک سے ہے پھر بھی عربوں کے کئیے گئے لوٹ مار کو ایکسپوز کر رہے ہو، آپ ایک حقیقی سچ پر چلنے والے انسان ہو 🥰❤️
If he does his own DNA, the chances are he will be true Hindu. That applies to 99 % of the contrived Pakistani Sayeds who falsely claim the pedigree. They are fake.
Many sayyed are not Arabic but most of them convert from high cast Hindu brahmin who kept their high rank by calling themselves sayyed I know many rajput accepted khan title for warrior identity of kshatriya
As a Indian I watched you video on analysis of Mahmoud Gazani and latter war of 1965 .. Dear I have become your Fan ..with such authentic references you have presented the fact to brake the laies...I appreciate and selute you We always know that there is an intelligent and intalect Zamato, individuals in Pakistan...jo such bolte he ...isliye nahi ki India ki tareef ya favour me he...but such ko aaanc nahi pe chalte he Keep doing a good work young man , I proud of your fact finding zeal and very sober way of presenting it. Regards Abhijit - from Mumbai
While money was a primary reason of these plunders of Islamic rulers, you cannot deny the fact that Islam never respects any other faiths and consider Islam as only true faith and therefore conversion was always their second motive besides wealth plunder.
Please get this through your head. Every religion states that what they say is the truth. This perennial and liberal ideology that has seeped in to the modern day Hindu minds is only 100 years old. There is one God vs There are three Gods (Brahma, Vishnu, Shiva) cannot be correct at the same time. Either one is true or the other. Every practitioner of his or her religion would want others to adopt their faith because he or she believes it is true and something that will benefit the other. Your case would have made significance if christians and muslims were asking you to adopt a faith and teaching that they do not believe in just to harm you. What is to be criticised is forced conversion, done by any faith. Also some examples does not mean everyone was forcefully converted. Till this day people convert from one religion to another, which includes people abandoning Hinduism.
@ Your beginning statement itself is contradictory to pillars of Hinduism which is eternal, non dogmatic and doesn’t follow a prophet or a single book. Besides, you cannot deny the fact that majority of Hindus converted to Islam or Christianity due to fear, being lured in to economic benefits (more in Christianity) and simply to keep their women and children safe. Also, I just stated clearly that all I and millions of Hindus in India want is to simply accept the fact that Muslims in Pakistan have Hindu heritage and that’s all. Doing so will not make you Hindu. It may solve your identity crisis and possibly create better relations with India and may also instill sense of cultural and civilization pride. Abdul Kalam Sir who was a Muslim was one of the shining example of a Muslim who was proud of his Hindu civilizational heritage and he was a great contributor to Indian missile program and a nationalist.
@Yalla12347 You're dead wrong, Mr.'People of the Book'. The deities of Hindu pantheon are just manifestation of the one devine reality. Also, these are devtas and devis not Gods. This is a very wrong term to use. Read Rajiv Malhotra ji's book Sanskrit Non-Translatables. Only then you will understand the Hindu concepts and concept of God. Also, this claim that all religions are same and equal and all preach that their religion is superior, is pure BS. This is a Western secularist post-modernist BS which unfortunately got interiorised even by the secularist Indians who are mostly Anglicised Hindus who have no knowledge of their religion and literature. Most of the conversions to Islam and Christianity were under duress and force. On the other hand, Indian religions are not even having any such concept and notion of religion and conversion. Also, Hindus who are even anti-religion and atheist, remain within the Hindu fold and Hinduism. And in India, Hinduism's gains are still in positive in comparison with Islam whose net gains are in negative. As if a non-M ends up converting to Islam. By that time, 10 Muslims had already left Islam. They become ex-Muslim atheists or convert to other religions. Even that 1 guy embraces Islam ends up leaving it after 2-3 years. This is as per the PEW Research surveys on religion in India. In Western countries and ME, it is even more. 1/4th of the total M population is ex-Muslim and half of the Muslim girls and ladies are married to non-Muslims in USA. In India, there are 2 Crore ex-Muslims and 4-6 Crore potential ex-Muslims aka those Muslims who are skeptical of Islam. This is outta 20 Crore total M population in India. All religion teach same blah blah blah. Had this been the case with Indics then they too would have been waging their own holy wars against others.
I think you missed the whole point, he meant to say that Pakistanis celebrate ghazni because he attacked hindus and india, but Pakistanis themselves forgot at that time they were non muslim and were part of greater india.
@@sumitrabhardwaj4120They dont want to see the whole picture. They just want to see the part of movie after they converted to islam before that what was the fact was just to painful for them so they dont wanna see it.
@@Charwaak-Athiest much better than those who killed your forefathers, and now you yourself become their stauch supporter, and consider them as your ancestors instead of the true ancestors
Mahmud Ghaznavi used to LOOT " Somnath Mandir & Various Others Temple". Still Somnath Mandir is here and Ghaznavi is Lost. Hari Singh Nalva ripped Afghan looters apart at his time
@@umakantbhalerao8185 For real. Egypt tabah ho gaya. Iran tabah ho gaya. Afghanistan aur pakistan tabah ho gaya. Hindustan aaj bhi khara hai. Kabhi bhi arbi mazhab ko nahi qubool karenge.
Afghans have Turkic tribes Mr 🕉️ . The ruling families Durrani & Ghilzai both are Turks who assimilated in Pashtun culture. You still find unmistakable resemblance between them .
@farhansadozai9167 Yes brother 🙏 Ahmad Shah ji Abdali = hepthalite white hoon Turks . Alauddin Khilji was also a turk woh become Ghilji . Full support to Afghans Whole Pakistan and Indian occupied Punjab belongs to Afghanistan .🔥.
bhai joot bhol raha hy multan mai qaramati shia thy jinhon ny kabba sy black stone choree ke the history dekho ya sub hum in sy pehly padh chooke hy likin ya beghairat youtub payment k lya sub koch kar raha hy
To support this channel and our content, use our patreon: www.patreon.com/user?u=62775812&Link&
Brother, your research is very good, but I have a question: all the researchers you're referencing are non-Muslims. These people have always written against Islam. We can't blindly trust their research. Moreover, Allama Mohammad Iqbal has also spoken well of Mahmood; if there was something negative, Iqbal wouldn't have praised him. What's your take on this?
@@mohammadsheraz7901
Why are you idealizing Iqbal his half of poetic work is also nothing but translation of others work...
He has no take. He just find online articles suiting his ideology and thinking and makes his point based on that. Because he is promoting a propaganda, nothing else. He is a propagandu
آپ پلیز ڈسکرپشن میں ویڈیو میں بتائے گئے فیکٹس کا بکس سے حوالہ بھی دے دیا کریں تو آپکی مہربانی ہوگی ۔❤
200 percent correct sir...!
Ghazni in Afghanistan has fallen and become ruins but India and Somnath stands tall today
What about last 800 years uska kya hisab hai?
Fir a gaya ghaznavi to kya karoge?
@@rahularya5312 sahi bola bhai. Lekin ish bar wo pele jayenge .
@@rahularya5312ane do, is bar...Pura Afghanistan cheen lein ge......
Ab wo jawana@@rahularya5312
I have been watching hundreds of Pakistani UA-cam channels for the last several years, some of them are cricket analysts, some are fake UA-camrs making videos on Indian content, some are geopolitical analysts, and some are good podcasters, but there is one person who is probably of my son's age, I have so much respect for him that I feel like saluting him. This man does not want to forget the past of his ancestors, likes to stay connected to his roots and fearlessly puts forward his views in a narrow-minded society.
I love this guy,a fearless few voices he is on the top when it comes to Pakistani content creators
u have never been to pakistan, u have no right to call us narrow minded
100% agree 👍 immense respect for Muzammil bhai❤
@@Nat-ConPakistan literacy rate is 58%
Lowest in the religion
Can we call you unpad jahil kaum?
Pakistan is biggest beggar of IMF bailout package in world
Can we call you beggar?
@@Nat-Connot you brother however your leaders have been narrow minded, frauds and cheaters.
I am Pakistani since1947.
But I am Sindhi For 5 thousand Years
SINDH DHARYA KE BETE HAI HUM JIYE SINDH JIYE SINDH DHARYA JIYE SINDHI
We r sindhis for 5000 years and no country founded in 1947 can change that fact period.
@sona-zw8us Sada Jiye. 💖
That is very rightly said.
Phire se apni identity kho raha 😂😂
Here Indian Muslims also consider Mughals as their heroes
AKBAR AND SHAHJAHAN ARE CONSIDERED AS PER NCERT.
@@theshahrukh_ali They're twisted stories. Written by those with any other motivations. For instance, Akbar had infact had his own Harem, which is never told in NCERT.
AESY HEROES NAHI CHAHIYE HUME BHAI
Yes, the Somnath Temple in Gujarat, India is still standing tall despite being destroyed multiple times by invaders over the centuries
hey dont blame us blame ure afghan allies for it,
@@Nat-Coneven islamic state kattar muslims afghans are not your ally
Then who is really ally of Pakistan?
Pakistan is a failed country
@@Nat-Con they are turks not afgan
But your education system establishment army glorify them ?@@Nat-Con
@@uncleji6763 was abdali, ghauri, balban, lodhi, suri, khilji,durrani and tughlaq also turk?????😆
Hello syed
I am from haryana(india) and there are literally folk songs about lootmaar done by ghaznavi in my local language.
One of those songs is jaat lutere ragini in which the singer is praising khokar jats of sindh region for taking a stand against ghaznavi and in our culture we always own our heroes whether they were born in modern day india or pakistan.
I think you should listen to this ragini ,it is available on youtube and you will find a haryanvi point of view about all this and much more in that song.
Love your work from india
Jaats were Darbaris and their women were sent to harems of Mughals for sexual pleasure(Google:Darbari Jaats). They were conidered Chandaals but due to Punjab Land Alienation Act 1900, they were gifted lands by Britishers. And these same chandaals now consider themselves upper caste and tell how European they are, meanwhile Jaat women of Haryana look Dehaati af
Yes, local Jaats and Rajputs of Multan and Sindh defeated Ghaznavid forces and inflicted heavy losses on Mahmud's army. They kept harassing them after their sack of Somnath Mandir...
Wese wo khokar pothohar punjab kay thy aur pothar punjab me khokar rajput kahlwaty hy jaat nai
People hungry for power money own interest will not leave the subcontinent because the common people are also the same.. It's just they don't get chance.. Khuda hi akl de sabko
@@ranahammad6823 The relationships between Rajputs and Jaats are complex. As there are same clans in both Jaatis + He is referring to the Jaats of Multan and Sindh. This is true. They were brave men....
Somnath mandir was not looted just once but 4 times.
1026 by ghazni(looted 17 times)
1299 by ulugh khan
1395 by muzaffar shah 1
1706 by aurangzeb
Now anyone can imagine Wealth and importance of temple.
Still somnath is standing tall ❤
Kuchh baat hai is civilization ki koi mitaa nahi paaya ❤
واہ
Similar briths looted all small kings of India 400 king's of India( 95% hindu kings)
Tum log khud hi Kafi ho issay mutant k Liye... Apnay hath say bna k Khuda mantay ho...jis nay saree dunya ko banaya usay ye Hindu bna rahay Hein...what joke... Watch movie.. PK😂😂😂😂😂
Khilji also plundered Somnath in 1312 appx.
List bohot badi hain....
Superb video... You are a true Muslim. India Pakistan should reunite as it was centuries back.
We both have radicals in our respective countries.
Allah tujay qayamat k din modi k saat utaye 😂
@umarkhan-tu3cq Allah ka shukr hai ke me maulana Abdul Kalam Azad ki pukar pe ruk gaya. JAMA Masjid, taj mahal , Lal qila ke liye ruk gaya.. tumhare tarha nahi ke suwar khane waale ke peeche Islami mulk banaya... 😀😀😀
@@umarkhan-tu3cq dil jeet liye dada
I'm Pakistani since 1947 and I'm Baloch for more than thousands of years ❣️
Baloch me hindu rehte hai
@Ayush.m8080
Yaar Baloch hindu dekha ni aaj tak. Liken balochistan mn hindu kaafi hain jo pashto bolty hain
@@unknown29587 partation se phale rhatae the jada the oo migrate kar gye india me
@@unknown29587bhaiya konse se City main rehte hai hindus Balochistan main??
@@unknown29587Hindu Baloch bhi hote the lekin sab India aa gaye 1947 mai... Bollywood ka famous actor... Raj Kumar Balochistan se hi tha
Time to Relocate our Heroes and Our Enemies. . ❤
go and live in india
and who they r??
Your actual heroes are Raja Daheer , Maharaja Ranjit Singh , Maharaj Chuch of Sindh , Raja Porus , Khan Abdul Gaffar Khan , Bhagat Singh , Dr. Abdul Salam , Raja Salya (Mahabharat era) , Chanakya etc whome you hate because most of them are Hindus & Sikhs .
Lol their hero is Ranjit Singh who used to burn Muslims for eating beef, even though cow is not holly in Sikhism like it is in Hinduism.
who will do it?
You can change your religion but you can't change your ancestory
A muslim hardly change his or her religion.if some one does its is his or her hard luck.
Hazrat Adam a.s was the father of all humanity and he was Muslim, yeah i didn't forget my ancestry
Wake up and accept reality 😂😂😂@RomasaAzhar
@RomasaAzhar Adam was Christian ✝️
@RomasaAzhar Read genetics, science and history. Learn to accept facts…Don’t engage religion everywhere….
Muslim Indian here... Totally with you.
Stay safe Muzammil 🙌
He is safe and we will not allow anyone to harm him.
He is speaking facts.
Then get back to your roots "Sanatan" ... Else all this hyper emotional comment is of no use.
@infinityuniverse4858 and what would that do?
@ save you the embarrassments that you face today... And if it's not an embarrassment then your hypocritical comment/response is exposed
@infinityuniverse4858 what embarrassment? convert to peaceful sanatani who behave like goons?
Alhamdulillah , I left this hyper nationalism and religious fanaticism.
Alhamdulillah I'm an Agnostic Now. Who feels connected towards Our Indian Roots.
❤
Lmao. Read the history more. We were Hindus but we became Muslim and has been as such for thousands of years now. So your culture and tradition is Muslim Punjabi or Sindhi or whatever the race.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@burhan1527 we didn't become Muslims , We are the descendents of the Oppressed Hindus.
@@ehtisham49 😘
Rare truth from Pakistan. You deserve appreciation. ❤
Huge truths from Ram Puniyani ❤
Today gazni empire gazni predecessors are all dust but india and Somnath temple is shining with huge wealth
All thanks to British colonization, who created India after conquering dozens of nations one by one and then leaving their trained army, railways, factories, industries, English schools, Cinemas, Ports, Legal system, Parliament, bridges, printing press etc etc for " India". Historically, physically, racially ghatia qoums aaj tain tain ker rahi hain
@@sabrinakhan8217The British didn't create it out of thin air , those railways, buildings, bridges etc were done with Indian money, indian labour, and Indian soldiers, it's not for nothing that India was called the crown jewel of the Empire, the British also did the same things in Burma, Africa and half the globe where are those countries today except the anglo Saxon US & Australia.
Go and read history madarsaachhap
@@sabrinakhan8217Indian is able to create thair own thing. If you think India grew up because of Britishers no doubt Britishers give lot of things. You need knowledge about history . If India doesn't have anything then why gazni , mehmud ghori, nadir shah , temur , Britishers comed India. India has already wealth and knowledge
Love from Pakistan🎉❤
@@bhattiig2 Love too brother ❤️
Unbiased होकर बहुत कम लोग ही तारीखों को बताया करते हैं ।Salute to ur Job
I am proud to be a descendant of Rajput Clan of India.
Pakistani can do anything now to be part of India. Why would not they? As, their people betrayed their own country.
We respect and love our pakistani rajput brothers, ....im indian rajput
😂😂
Many Rajputs were converted forcibly
@unniammaman4429 vo naam dekh ke pata lag rha hai
A much needed talk where an entire generation post 1947 was fed upon false narratives.
The entire narrative was based on falsehoods, as the country was divided to serve the interests of a specific Muslim population in certain areas, while others were neglected. This led to the fabrication of more lies to sustain this division and the hegemony of a small elite. As a result, the poor are trapped in miserable conditions, lacking security, food, education, clean water, and any hope for a better future, while others continue to loot their resources
100% agreed with you my brother, Allah bless you - Aameen
Pakistan itself have no history. You are all Indian by origin by DNA by blood you people just change your religion. Just by changing your religion it doesn't mean you change your Indian heritage.
Soooooooo
What if the story was same since 1000 years and these youtubers are wrong??? Would you believe then?
As a Punjabi Pakistani Muslim i fully agree with Muzammil and khawaja asif. Looters who plundered beautiful Punjab must be exposed and no soft words for them. Enough is enough, tired of reading pk studies fiction..
I'm Pakistani for 75 years, but I'm Indian and Punjabi for thousands of years..
Lol go to India then
Be safe
Very well said ❤
Beautifully said truth 💜
Dont mind but you are pakistani i dont think your age is more than 76. Years if so then you will be indian
जिसे लूटा गया, और जिसने लूटा। दोनों के हालत में आज जो अंतर है, वहीं उपर वाले इंसाफ है ❤
I am settled in USA for the last 37 years , being Indian native it is my curiosity to listen both pakistani and indian you tubers, i must say syed Muzammil is my most favourite , he works very hard to find truth , and is very dedicated in his profession to bring facts to the people. Mr Muzammil your hard work will never go wasted or unnoticed it is educating millions of youth in pakistan who have been brain washed with wrong history, never give up your hard work keep up your passion and hard work best wishes from USA dr Raj K dhar
I believe there are only a few things, even Pakistan itself can be proud of it and Muzamil is one❤ long live brother more power to you more power to the truth
Rishi sunak c😢😢😢
Pakistan is not safe place for him now.
Pakistan is not safe place.....
Whatever may happen mr syed Muzammil you will meet almighty someday because of being fearless truth speaker.
Proud to be Sindhi ❤️🙌 who knows about history from the past Pakistan studies always though he is a hero but he was big looter my father used to tell he used to loot temples also whole Mughal empire was looter
This is British and Hindutva given history. Ghaznavi, Ghouri Abdalli and Mughals were supported by many nations in current Pakistani region. Northwest ( current Pakistan) have always had trade and cultural ties with Central Asia (Afghanistan, Iran, Uzbikistan Turkey) and attacks towards Ganga Jamuna ( current India minus Chinese burmese Tibet regions of so called Northeast Indioa that were captured by British). Otherwise, it's not possible to conquer region after region without local support. Afghan, persian and Uzbik history speaks of no such blood bath. In fact they speak of support and invitations from different South Asian nations. South Asia is a region like Europe and never a natural country. This region was/is full of dozens of culturally, religiously, historically, racially and linguistically separated nations for over 10,000 years. They were attacking and killing each other.
Kingdoms from Northwest like Maurya, Kushan, dahir etc have always attacked ganga Jamuna. Mauryans alone killed 30 million ganga jamnis and destroyed their temples. Ask South Indians, they hate Indus Valley and Its kingdoms and refused to call themselves Indooz aka Hindus ( a name given by persians to ppl of Sindh) until Indra Gandhi bombed Tamil tigers twice. There was no Hindusthan before Ghouri and no India before British.
Free sindh❤❤
@Md.ubaid6537 ohh please stop doing this l m also from.sindh but never want to free from pak
Learned Indian history from Pak Studies apparently. Hindus didn't have a practice of destroying places of worship of other religions. There are many places in India where Hindu. Buddhist and Jain temples have stood side by side for thousands of years. Hindus willingly and happily visit gurdwaras and worship there too. Because Hinduism accepts that there is one God but each of us can imagine him and worship him in any form that appeals to us. There is no hatred for the other.
@@sabrinakhan8217Apne hisab se Kuchh vi..Wrong and Baseless Comments karne se pehle..Thoda research to kar lete..
The day when Pakistanis start accepting and acknowledging their Hindu ancestry and heritage, Pakistan will start prospering.
you mean like India is prospering since last 800 years ?
I assume you are brahmin, right?
Hindu heritage...?? It's regional identity.. or nationally...
Not Hindu Muslim Sikh etc...
Umeed hy ap baat ko smjho gay.. or GObar khorOn ko Trah react Nii kro gay...
😂😂😂😂
Have you prospered??
@ Are you Indian or Pakistani?
My respect increases for you.... U always stand wid true facts... Thank u from India 🇮🇳❤
(As a Punjabi cmnt kar raha hun ) ❤️🔥Pakistan 🇵🇰 ki buniyad hinduo se nafrat se shuru hui or aj b yeh missilo k name gori gaznavi yeh wo sab hinduo ki nafrat k silsaly main rakhy gay. But as a Punjabi Pakistani 🇵🇰 main samjhta hun k har wo Punjabi jisny punjab k culture punjab ki zameen k defaa k ley kisi se jang larhi wo hamara hero ha chahy wo hindu raja dahar hindu raja jey pal ya sikh maharaja Ranjeet Singh ho ya muslim hero Ray Ahmad khan kharal ho. Mery ley wo aham han. Or yeh sab gaznavi gori yeh wo sab k sab hamary ley dako or choor k ilawa kuch nai thy lehaza ham inko apna hero hargiz nai manty apni mitti mery ley sabse pehly ha. Or yeh sab to mery aj k watan Pakistan 🇵🇰 k b dairy se bahir hn. Lehaza mitti pehly ha.
Khush kitta e mundeya khush reh aabad reh ❤
Hasda reh
to per to arbayo ka hero to muhammad SWA ka jaga na agozo ballah abo jahal , or dosra kafar mulk ka hero hona cahya , tora mind open kar ka bat ko smajo
kaya islam lootro ka waja sa pahla ta hm muhammad swa ka bad ? oder be gold or dosra mal ganemat malat ta
But prasti
Shaseyat prasti aur apkay comment mn koi ferq nahi
AP Islam ko defend kerain baki sab Fana hai
Buhat se misalaien hain
But kaya kahuo apko
I'm punjabi hindu rajput or hamare punjab me aj bhi abdulla bhatti k naam pe lohri festival manaya jaata hai or usko hero consider Kiya jaata hai kyunki usne muglo k julm k khilaf awaj uthayi or apni jaan de di par wo aj bhi hamare dil me Zinda hai
Dadwal are khatris
@HistoricalMyths-j6m in district hoshiyar ,pathankot dadhwal are rajputs
I'm Punjabi Muslim Rajput Dhulla Bhatti Muslim Rajput Zindabad Tiger 🐅 Of Punjab Babbar Sher Cheetah
@ranamunawarhussain6281
Rajput is mughalput 🤣🤣🤣🤣😜
Jai mughalputana
Jai Jodha Akbar
Sultan Mahmud Ghazni Zindabad
Mohammad Ghori zindabad.
@@HistoricalMyths-j6mRajputs are also Kshatriyas.
You are one amongst the very few Muslims I feel respectful towards...
Mahmud is not our hero, he was a warrior and warriors are bloodthirsty plunderers. We belong to this land and our heroes were those who fought against the aggressors. Our hero is Raja Poorwa of Jehlum, Raja Rangeet Singh, Rai Ahmad Khan Kharal, Bahgat Singh, lala lajpat Rai and others.
Raja Dahir of Sindh.
That means that the you are not grateful to be a muslim if your heroes are the likes of raja dahir ranjeet singh over the likes of Muhammad bin qasim and muslims that make us all look like ungrateful
Raja hasan khan mewati
The day we understand that we share the same culture, sane icons, same ancestry and have always been culturally Bharat,united bharatvarsh...
Peace will prevail
Just imagine a united Aryavrat. The entire subcontinent under a single native independent government.
Imagine the heights we will touch again.
A gem from Pakistan, appreciated more by Indians than his own people. Sad but true
Do you appreciate dhruv rathee and condemn Modi? If you do then great but if not , you don't have credibility and don't damage muzamil's image.
@@chaudhryALIG We will definitely do. If he was truthful. Syed is neutral, Rathe is not. He is against a particular political party does propaganda and does not even live in India. Never talks about historical empires but just Mughals. Do you think India was uncivilized before 7th century? Before invasions India was considered to be the richest and prosperous. This is not just an Indian claim, historians from all over the world say that. But someone who claims neutrality should be unbiased which Ratee is not. Who cares about Modi? Modi is not Bharat.
@@chaudhryALIGdhruv rathee is credible ?? Dhruv's whole channel is based on anti modi....and most of his subscribers doesn't have to do with truth they just blindly follow him🥲🥲🥲
@StayFocused-m4w Till 1000AD india had 30-40% world GDP and right till 17th century 24% of World GDP and was at proto- industrial stage BEFORE Europe. West looted and developed on the ashes of India. By 1947, GDP share crashed to 2%
Why you don't appreciate Rahul Who talks secularism in India why you Support Modi In India who talks extremism Hindutva and Hindurashtra why you support Muzammil Who talks secularism in Pakistan hypocricy and it peaks😂
Thank you Syed Muzammil Shah for exposing the truth about these cruel looters who were so obviously only motivated by power and financial gain. Please stay safe! You are a light to us Pakistanis.
Hi 🙏 ma'am, good to see you againg.
Quran has a chapter 8 (Surah Al-Anfal ) which means Loot Mar ka Maal and in that Allah and beloved prophet justifies killing Kafirs (chapter 8 verse 12) and how to split the spoils of war how much will caliph take etc...
Yeh Dougla Hai Kan ri ka bach
By Islamic doctrines.
Pakistan is not safe place for him now.
How shameful our politicians which don't know Islamic history
The Somnath Temple today is a fabulously rebuilt structure in all its glory. Gujarat is among the most developed provinces in India, and the district where the temple is- has infrastructure and wealth comparable with any developed country. Compare that with Baghdad and Ghazni of today. Time has a sweet way of taking revenge.
LOL Please visit a developed country before making a stupid statement.
Well said, I feel bad for the people of Iraq and Afghanistan and I wish things will get better in both places. Our somnath is standing tall and in all its Glory ❤️.
@@nayan7721why iraq??
@@netaji-thebritishslayer khorasan was iraq
Fun fact: The Great Somnath Mandir is standing strong but those who looted it, living in ruins.
bhai aap Mahmud Gaznavi ko to bhala bura bol rahe ho but ye aapka Akhilesh Yadav daily basis par sanatan ko abuse kar raha hai eska kya karoge. Ye log bhi Gaznavi se kam nahin hai.
What do you mean those who looted it are living in ruins? how many 1000 year olds do you know? I am from that region and certainly did not ruin Soomnath or any other temple. This channel, among others, is to bring enlightenment. Live that way bro, don't go the dark route. Peace
@@iam.mahesh.jangrajo jaisa karega waisa bharega...
Akhilesh ke papa mulayam ka ant bura tha .. uska bhi time ayega
Gujarat and Somanath are still prosperous region’s but not Ghazni
Hahaha. Muslims enslaved you for 1000 years. Muslims are spread everywhere whereas hindu clowns are limited to 2 countries. Muslims will always be your Abbu Ji. 💪💪💪
Thank you Syed Bhai for using the term "Hindu Theology" and not "Mythology"... Thank you for this video overall !!
I was about to say this ❤
😂
Still it's mythology if not him many have said it
@@theadnanrazait’s not we have archeological evidences , astronomical evidences , textual evidences of Krishna , Rama existing on earth and walked on India’s land ! India is the only land due to geographical conditions survived younger dras, mass extinctions !
@@user-jf2oz4ye7u I don't wanna sound rude but do you really think that these evidence are proven
Very well explained, Muzammil bhai. Keep up the good work. ❤
We are the children of indus valley civilization
You're ancestors were also hindu
You were hindus
Come back ❤
@@mylakshmiveganheaven4562 lol no thanks and indus valley people were not hindus tum log aryan product ho
Yes bro
Nah fuck that, we are childeen of indus but the caste system and sati isnt for us. You are our brothers though.@@mylakshmiveganheaven4562
After all the loot and plunder India still stands tall and the people who looted are poor now
Made beggars by the uncivilised rulers.
It's Karma Haunting them
Actually they are not. Iran is where most of the wealth landed and they are rich.
wee say bru
Bruh iran is more cleaner than india 😂
I am always confused, that why especially Pashtun believe that they could not be pegan, Hindu or Buddhist. What makes us Pashtun believe that we were not having any religion other islam before it. Seriously this question should be asked from us Pashtuns. We were a part of this local system of hind. Why do we believe we are not from this region or we don't have any relationship to this land of hind.
Seriously why us Pakhtun can't accept that were having a mixture of established religions before islam.
@@rahdar2008 Mahabharat mentions about Pashtuns, they fought in Mahabharat as well. You were Hindus.
@@rahdar2008how will😂 you prove Islam great if not through this way lol
Where can one find a good resource for the history of Pashtuns?
Bro first learn pashtoon history we are basically from Palestine migrated okay we are in the generation of talot and his son armeya alih salam and armeya alih salam had a son afghana okay learn history first
Right Comments I am agree with you.
Iam from Sindh , Pakistan.Our people rejected all the invaders and looters since years but no one listened us ;when we called the Muhammed bin qasim as a looter.
Prophet Muhammad looted Quresh and there goods so what would you say? In the rule of Umar bin khattab Muslim forces attack and invade many empires as well so what would you say? Mughals and Brithers came and rule the whole Sindh and Hind what would you say?
You are a Hindu Sindhi
agar wo nahe ata to to aj be kafar hota
Yes Qasim was looter
Bro come back to your original culture which is hinduism ,I'm not against any religion but our culture and our ancestors were all sanatani hindus ,we are same ,our blood are same ,we are all sons of sanatani culture
“History is written by those who have hanged hero’s.” Quote from Braveheart
A coward who thinks that killing another faith for his own sake is no hero, looters can never be legends, they are beggars with an army. And for the fact, there is no Ghazni today but only our great temple is standing.
@@flame0111 are you a good human being because
"that counts, and nothing else does especially without it."
Javaid Ghamidi
Even Muhammed was a iconoclast.
Afghanistan is in ruined. India became $4 trillion economy in just 75 years. And Somnath ji...my God is still there, blessing us everyday.🙏🕉️🙏
কিছু বছরের মধ্যে সব শেষ হয়ে যাবে।
Ruined? Afghanistan defeated the Soviet Union, USA and is still growing faster in terms of economy. Meanwhile india can't even resist little Pakistan 😂economy is shedding up
You might b right.but why india us supportin afghanistan against pakistan?
@@naveedkamal9293because indians love afghan original Muslims, then converted Pakistan Muslims, 400 yrs back these Muslims converted .
@@FlawLess_333 Afghanis were defeated by Raja Maan singh under Akbar's reign and later were countlessly defeated by Sikh and ruled over them for 100s of years
Love and respect for Syed Muzammil from an Indian Muslim 🇮🇳
hi this guy is askari puppet
Indian likhte to kya hota
Indian Muslim me Kya dikkat hai....he is proud Indian and a proud muslim@@Ayush.m8080
Ek sawal hai bhai seriously. Why do you consider a warlord who made women into s*x slaves as prophet ?
My identity is 5500 years old, Punjabi and Pakistan is my country in recent history. I am proud Punjabi and then Proud Pakistani
My identity is Muslim when Human created by Allah in the Name of Adam As. After that my identity renewed in 1400 years ago ,when Muhammad (peac be upon him) came.My identity as a muslim renewed again When Quide Azam made Pakistan in the name of Islam.
@@KhanofKarachiso see only facts not tradition that you learned
There is no such thing Pakistan
Lol
Sab se pehle hum Hindustani os k baad Punjabi aour phir Pakistani
@@saqibrazzaq8801❤️
Mujhe ye bhai sach mai sensible lagta hai ye sach mai apne mulak ka bhala chahta hai 🙏love from Indian behan
Pichle 7 8 saal se kafi Pakistan ke logo ki aankhe khulne lagi hai isliye kehte hai ki jhuth ke pair nahi hote
I am Pakistani Since 1947
But I am Punjabi for 5500 Years
Muslim from past few hundred years
Correct 👍
Ex Muslim Sahil Khan Zindabad
Punjabi identity is only 1100 years old. There was no punjab before that and the region was known by different names.
Muslim for 25 years --- Because my Grand parents were Hindus
To be honest these things doesn't hurt us , somnath is standing with lots of wealth . The country which attacked it (Afghanistan) and the one who idolises it ( Pakistan) is in ruins , struggling to survive , begging from every courtry while my country India is about to become 3rd largest economy and 2nd largest economy in coming 20 years . Yes our leaders didnt control population of india and that's why we have population of poor also and we will change it .
If Pakistan and Bangladesh merge it will be 1st
Please clarify first in what ? Filhaal to dono marne maarne mein lage pade hain. Your advise and evidence based future predictions will help viewers. @@Dominatingman
@@Dominatingmanif you are paki? Really bruh? 😂 If you are Bangladeshi😂😂
This isn't about you, it's about history
Respect your sentiments. However, you are not going to be a global power. Your government is running on the same pattern that we followed for years. Wait for consequences😅
Being a pakistani hindu mujhe sharmindgi hoti thi class 10th mai urdu ka chapter parhte huay "somnath ki fateh" aur jabke sab muslims ghor sy sunte thay ...
I'm from 'SOMNATH'. SOMNATH ABHI BHI MAJBUTI KE SATH SINA TAN KE KHADA HAI. AUR JINHONE SOMNATH KO LUTA , USKA NAAM O NISHAN AUR USKE HALAT DEKH LO JAKAR😂
Brother Vikash if you think any raw kind of people become automatically civilised because of claiming islam as religion then (with due respect but)you are in dellusion.
I have personally seen Muslims being arrogant while quran says it without leaving any chance for discussion that
"A camel may pass through the eye of a needle (which is simply impossible) BUT an arrogant human being will never enter into God's grace (i.e heaven)."
So those Muslims who put such lessons in school books you can imagine the weakness of their minds as well as humanity.
By the i am myself a Muslim
But why shall that lead me to praise ourselves where we don't deserve any.
Somnath ke mandir me shudra aorato ke rape hote the jinko brahman kiya karte the
Gajnavi ne unko hi bachaya tha
Koi sharm ki baat nahi hai bhai inko nasal chali gai hum hindu hai aur rahenge sanatan satya hai aur rahega somenath wahi sina tan ke khada hai ghazni dhul ho gaya hai
Abhi somnath boht hi jyada sundar hain, I am from Gujarat, kafi baar Somnath darshan krne bhi gye hain. Itni baar “Fateh” krne k baad bhi aaj humara mandir wesa ka wesa hain but jisne loota uska aata pta nahi.
We need to read about our real heros people who actually were from this land and they were brilliant one of the example is chanakya
Bhagat singh also
@@RamsarangangwarSaran-ou1fj😂😂
If pakistan adopt Chanakya Neeti it would be on top in terms of nation building, trade relationship, geopolitics, etc
Aap log ne ye right kho diye or aaj dekho apke pas kud ka nam tak nhi hai or dna ki to bat xoro aap yisbak ye tentoin hai kon sa culture folk keu arab or apna jo kar rhe ko aapke sath dhokha huwa hai ye sabko pata hai par ye dhokha aap log kud hi kud ko diye or aab nhi nikl pa rhe
Chanakya was from bihar he was only a professor at takshila university which is now in pakistan but he wasn't born in punjab.
I agree with you that we should be realistic and truthful. We should revisit our history honestly and adjust in books in schools and colleges.
You are filled with compassion for every nation of Pakistan. And you have always raised your voice for the minority.
God bless you, my son.
From uk
Jaat ho.
well said rajpoot folks.
Once a genius said that there is no need to be emotional or serious about history , history is just for learning from past events .
That person must've called himself as "genius", not by others. Because, without being emotional and serious, nothing can be learned or remembered. The person who does this without being emotional n serious, is just a news reader who keeps doing his same job everyday, learns nothing.
Quran has a chapter 8 (Surah Al-Anfal ) which means Loot Mar ka Maal and in that Allah and beloved prophet justifies killing Kafirs (chapter 8 verse 12) and how to split the spoils of war how much will caliph take etc...
@@hindimovieadmirer6025 😂😂😂 Bhai ! Aapka sarcasm ko manna padega .
Then don't be serious about your 1400 year old cult.
@@flame0111since when did you start having pain with islam?
Loved the presentation, articulation, bravado and above all, unadulterated facts. I would love to see longer, documentary-type content from you. Best wishes from 🇮🇳
Khwaja Asif is absolutely right 👍
We are debating on Khwaja Asif remarkssss.... What a lol
Nabi saw ne kaha jo log apne kafir aba o ajdad par fakhar or unki himayat karte hain muslim hone ke bawajud unki misal aise he jese wo un kafiron ki sharam gah apne mu me rakh len.
Yesss 👍
Absolutely
😂😢😢😅fir taliban aaj sahi.... Pakistan army galat
One of the wonderful unbiased presentation. It is not the matter of hindu or muslim truth is always truth. Lots of love and appreciation from TN India.
Mahmood Ghanvi was a villain.
Hmary leyi hero h
@Clown5556 Murderer of innocent people is your hero? Read history. You will find truth.
He was villain
@@MuhammadAli1-xq4ss may be for not for us
@qaiserahmedraja
ایک ہی صف میں کھڑے ہو گئے محمود او ایاز ۔نہ کو بندہ رہا نہ کوئی بندہ نواز ۔۔علامہ محمد اقبال رحمۃ اللہ 😢
A very brave & intelligent narration of authentic history by Muzzamil... it's not easy to learn but it's harder to "UNLEARN" & see the world with a realistic new perspective.
As always a great podcast. Thanx a lot Muzzamil.
About a decade back a Pakistani posted on Twitter that Mahmud massacred as many Muslims as Hindus. I was not convinced at that time but today you proved him right with references. Thanks Muzammil.🙏
Books refered are not original source
You have described your view point,not history,dont claim it.
Afghans are not foreigners in Hind as Afghanistan has been its part since ancient.
Your speach has contradictions.
You cannot explain why enormous wealth was accumulated and stored in religous places with Brehman class.
So massacring Hindus is okay ? Only it turns evil when the victims are fellow Muslims right???
@@Knockingvoice65 You nitiwit, Enormous wealth was stored in Religious places under rule of Kings. Brahman doesnt own anything. its the Royals who owned temples.
First learn real history not whatsapp forwards.
@@Knockingvoice65 Ghazni was a turk not afghan.
Yeah ,his last name was khokhar
ये बंदा पाकिस्तान में बदलाव लाएगा 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Proud to be Hindu we never change our religion.. We love our religion and it's tge best religion in this planet
I have no idea how long it will take to actually teach the correct history to Pakistanis. Just saying wont be enough because the brain washing is too deep. I think the previous generation and the current generation are too far gone. We just need to protect the new generation.
If you start today to teach actual history, it may take 10-15 years to rectify the situation. Of course , reforms must be brought to the madraasa education which should be confined to only religious studies. Otherwise children will be confused and any effort to correct the situation will go waste. ..
How can you teach real history in Pakistan if doing so would shake the very foundation of the idea of Pakistan?
بھائی تمہاری ہسٹری کیوال 1947 کے بعد کی ہے کبھی اسکے آگے اور پہلے کی پڑھنے کی کوشش کرنا اگر خود کی آنکھیں نہ بھر آئے تو بولنا ،جنکے ساتھ لوط مار ہوئی و کوئی اور نہیں ہمارے ہے پرواز تھی ،وہ الگ بات ہے کی آج کنورٹ ہو گئے ہو تو نہیں سمجھ آئیگا
Then how will they justify 2 nation theory
Watch Adam seeker Urdu
time to expose ghazanvi’s lootmaar
😂😂😂😂 pihly jaipaal ne ungli ki thi 😂😂😂
To whom?
@ to masses of pakistan
@@yasDaily368 Raja dahir married ur innocent sister.....
Mr. Khwaja Asif is right on spot.
Kuch sharm hoti ha kuch haya hoti ha...khwaja asif jaisy insan choor dako dahshtgrd lutayry ki bat ko ap maan rahy ho
no he is not
@TechMALIK-pr7cw keep being dictated then.
@@TechMALIK-pr7cwhe is lol
Extetrmis joker 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤣@@TechMALIK-pr7cw
Absolutely true, dear Muzammil
Im Muslim from punjab Pakistan 🇵🇰 i agreed syed muzzamil ❤
Punjab zindabaad
Punjabi 🥻 everywhere the protector of their benefits they never can listen truth and neither speak truth.
What's their achievement at all? Except of looting the benefits of every government 😢
Teach your people learn history
You’re before Hindu
@@yogeshdobhal5773 yes we know. We r Muslims now Alhamdulilah
@@yogeshdobhal5773dharam badalte rehte hain pr identity nhi badlati Punjabi chahy hindu ho sikh ho ya Muslim Punjabi to Punjabi hi hota hai amd hindu Muslim sikh Punjabi are brother genetically
Respect from Bangladesh, muzammil sir❤
Quran has a chapter 8 (Surah Al-Anfal ) which means Loot Mar ka Maal and in that Allah and beloved prophet justifies killing Kafirs (chapter 8 verse 12) and how to split the spoils of war how much will caliph take etc...
Tum Bangladeshi to kisi kaam ke hi nahin ho aur na baat karne layak. kya aatank machaya hua hai vahan rahne wale hinduo me. Sach me Bangladeshiyo se bada ehsaan faramosh nahin dekha, humne aap logon ko freedom dilwayi apne sainiko ke balidan kiya aur aaj daily basis par hamari hi insult karte ho. Ashamed on you people.
شکر ہے کسی پنجابی نے تو تسلیم کیا کہ محمود غزنوی ایک لٹیرا تھا
ابدالی ہو غزنوی یا غوری سب لٹیرے تھے
Mughals too
mughal rulers loot ker wapis nahi gaye... india me poori life guzari@@spidylov3382
बिल्कुल सही कहा आपने
Tumhari aizat looti the kia inho ne?
پنجابی تو ہے ہی ہیرامنڈی کی پیداوار
مشاہد حسین سید کیس قسم کا سید ہے جیس کا ڈی این اے سید ھونے کہ باوجود ایک ڈاکو لوٹیرے سے جاملا نانبی پاک نااہلبیت ع سے ملا ایک چور ڈاکو لوٹیرے سے جاملا کیسی نے سہی کہہ ضمیر زندہ ھونا چاہتے اگر بغض اہلبیت ع نا ھوتا تو ان مزاہیلوں کہ نام حیدر ذولفقار حسین حسن عباس مختار ھونے لیکن افسوس ہے😢😢😢
یار میں راجپوت ہوں، انڈین خطے کا اصلی باشندہ اور اسی وجہ سے بیرونی حملہ آوروں کو بہت برا سمجھتا ہوں، ہمارے وسائل چھینے گئے
اور تم سید ہو جو کہ آیا عرب ملک سے ہے پھر بھی عربوں کے کئیے گئے لوٹ مار کو ایکسپوز کر رہے ہو، آپ ایک حقیقی سچ پر چلنے والے انسان ہو 🥰❤️
1-999 brat msg me brother
If he does his own DNA, the chances are he will be true Hindu. That applies to 99 % of the contrived Pakistani Sayeds who falsely claim the pedigree. They are fake.
Many sayyed are not Arabic but most of them convert from high cast Hindu brahmin who kept their high rank by calling themselves sayyed I know many rajput accepted khan title for warrior identity of kshatriya
Are you sure he’s a real Syed from Arab or just fake a Syed like many other Syeds living in Indian subcontinent?
Does he look like arab😂🤣. Al brrr ..kurr
We are proud to have Syed Muzammil .
Ghaznavi ne 17 time loota somnath ko but karma dekho somnath aaj bhi shaan se khada hai lekin ghaznavi kha hai ushka qila bhi nhi bacha
As a Indian I watched you video on analysis of Mahmoud Gazani and latter war of 1965 ..
Dear I have become your Fan ..with such authentic references you have presented the fact to brake the laies...I appreciate and selute you
We always know that there is an intelligent and intalect Zamato, individuals in Pakistan...jo such bolte he ...isliye nahi ki India ki tareef ya favour me he...but such ko aaanc nahi pe chalte he
Keep doing a good work young man , I proud of your fact finding zeal and very sober way of presenting it.
Regards
Abhijit - from Mumbai
While money was a primary reason of these plunders of Islamic rulers, you cannot deny the fact that Islam never respects any other faiths and consider Islam as only true faith and therefore conversion was always their second motive besides wealth plunder.
Religion aka Isl..m sas also the primary reason for these acts of these M rulers..
Please get this through your head. Every religion states that what they say is the truth. This perennial and liberal ideology that has seeped in to the modern day Hindu minds is only 100 years old.
There is one God vs There are three Gods (Brahma, Vishnu, Shiva) cannot be correct at the same time. Either one is true or the other.
Every practitioner of his or her religion would want others to adopt their faith because he or she believes it is true and something that will benefit the other.
Your case would have made significance if christians and muslims were asking you to adopt a faith and teaching that they do not believe in just to harm you.
What is to be criticised is forced conversion, done by any faith. Also some examples does not mean everyone was forcefully converted.
Till this day people convert from one religion to another, which includes people abandoning Hinduism.
@ Your beginning statement itself is contradictory to pillars of Hinduism which is eternal, non dogmatic and doesn’t follow a prophet or a single book. Besides, you cannot deny the fact that majority of Hindus converted to Islam or Christianity due to fear, being lured in to economic benefits (more in Christianity) and simply to keep their women and children safe.
Also, I just stated clearly that all I and millions of Hindus in India want is to simply accept the fact that Muslims in Pakistan have Hindu heritage and that’s all. Doing so will not make you Hindu. It may solve your identity crisis and possibly create better relations with India and may also instill sense of cultural and civilization pride.
Abdul Kalam Sir who was a Muslim was one of the shining example of a Muslim who was proud of his Hindu civilizational heritage and he was a great contributor to Indian missile program and a nationalist.
@Yalla12347 You're dead wrong, Mr.'People of the Book'. The deities of Hindu pantheon are just manifestation of the one devine reality. Also, these are devtas and devis not Gods. This is a very wrong term to use. Read Rajiv Malhotra ji's book Sanskrit Non-Translatables. Only then you will understand the Hindu concepts and concept of God. Also, this claim that all religions are same and equal and all preach that their religion is superior, is pure BS. This is a Western secularist post-modernist BS which unfortunately got interiorised even by the secularist Indians who are mostly Anglicised Hindus who have no knowledge of their religion and literature. Most of the conversions to Islam and Christianity were under duress and force. On the other hand, Indian religions are not even having any such concept and notion of religion and conversion.
Also, Hindus who are even anti-religion and atheist, remain within the Hindu fold and Hinduism. And in India, Hinduism's gains are still in positive in comparison with Islam whose net gains are in negative. As if a non-M ends up converting to Islam. By that time, 10 Muslims had already left Islam. They become ex-Muslim atheists or convert to other religions. Even that 1 guy embraces Islam ends up leaving it after 2-3 years. This is as per the PEW Research surveys on religion in India. In Western countries and ME, it is even more. 1/4th of the total M population is ex-Muslim and half of the Muslim girls and ladies are married to non-Muslims in USA. In India, there are 2 Crore ex-Muslims and 4-6 Crore potential ex-Muslims aka those Muslims who are skeptical of Islam. This is outta 20 Crore total M population in India.
All religion teach same blah blah blah.
Had this been the case with Indics then they too would have been waging their own holy wars against others.
@@Yalla12347
Nope.
There's only one god ISHWAR.
Brahma Vishnu Mahesh r the names of that ISHWAR.
Dear Syed, really like your unbiased modern approach work. Keep up the good work. All countries need podcasters like you. Best wishes from India !
Excellent analysis of Mehmud Ghaznavi.
Khuda ka khof karu jhot kam bola karu aur pury haqaiq bayan karu..
Everyone has their own thoughts and views. But I do not consider Muhammad bin Qasim and Mahmud Ghazni to be heroes.
We do know you guys consider these idiots or lootera as Hero just because they were Muslim 😂
I think you missed the whole point, he meant to say that Pakistanis celebrate ghazni because he attacked hindus and india, but Pakistanis themselves forgot at that time they were non muslim and were part of greater india.
@@sumitrabhardwaj4120They dont want to see the whole picture. They just want to see the part of movie after they converted to islam before that what was the fact was just to painful for them so they dont wanna see it.
NETENHAYU CAN BE OUR HERO BY THIS LOGIC
@@Charwaak-Athiest much better than those who killed your forefathers, and now you yourself become their stauch supporter, and consider them as your ancestors instead of the true ancestors
Me somnath se hu.. ❤
Jy sri ram🚩
@VP-qg4uy jay shree ram❤️ har har mahadev
Somnath me chandradev ko naya jivan mila bholenath se toh somnath ko kitna bhi loot lete but Aaj bhi somnath shaan se khada hai❤❤
Gujrati am ne
@@Triptibhalavi24somanat kis city m hy
Kudos Muzzamil. Jiyo yaar for staying firm on the TRUTH. Satyamev Jayate - an Indian Sikh with ancestry from Rawalpindi.
Appreciate..
Sach bol ne ke liye jigar chahiye...that too staying in Pakistan.
I am a Khokhar from Sialkot and I am a voter of Khawaja Asif.
Khokar rajput hote hai ya jat??
Khokar are Rajputs not turk arabs or afghans
@@Rocket-raccoon-qRajput
@TheROI-republicOFindia Rajput
@@Rocket-raccoon-q Absolutely right.
Thanks Shah ji for this nice information about history of India,I am Pakistani long time in 🇪🇸🇪🇸 God bless you and protect you 🙏🙏
Syed muzammil shah is one of most wise minds in Pakistan
May god bless him with good health and wealth 🙏🏼
Agreed !! Just like great mind from India like Ram Puniyani..may God bless him and enlighten Hindus of India ❤
Ram Puniyanni is a manipulator. Not an honest man. @@technicalguy5668
He is a foreigner because he is "syed" he belongs to Prophet Muhammad's Family. He has no right to live in Bharat or Pakistan.
Issa India la jao apna sath hum pa aik ihsaan kur do.
Mahmud Ghaznavi used to LOOT " Somnath Mandir & Various Others Temple". Still Somnath Mandir is here and Ghaznavi is Lost. Hari Singh Nalva ripped Afghan looters apart at his time
یہ جتنے ہیرو بنائے ہوئے ہیں اصل میں یہ اتنے بڑے ڈاکو تھے
صحی بولے بھائی
Lol hai ye British tato es ki ketab 180 saal purani hai g janb ye pichly ketab sy nahi batauzmil lol g janb Hamid Mir ka program dhek g
Tere Koofi Ajdad per lanat
اس وقت کے ہندو راجہ اپنی ریاستوں میں مسلمانوں کو اپنے لئے خطر سمجھ جب ان کے خلاف کارروائیاں کرتے تھے تو غزنوی حملے کرتا تھا
تیرے ابوجداد محمود غزنوی کے لشکر کے ساتھ ہی ہندوستان اکر اباد ہوئے
Unless Pakistan embraces truth it will never progress. Salute you for your brave commitment to truth. 👍
India or Bharat is the only ancient living civilization . Hindustan duniya keh liye ek roshni hai !
😂😂😂
😅😅😅
@@umakantbhalerao8185 For real. Egypt tabah ho gaya. Iran tabah ho gaya. Afghanistan aur pakistan tabah ho gaya. Hindustan aaj bhi khara hai. Kabhi bhi arbi mazhab ko nahi qubool karenge.
@@AnamulHaqueSakibdont laugh u are also converted
@@shieldhealthandsafety7940its sad u are laughing think how they converted your forfathers
I completely support your thoughts Muzammil ji - love from India ❤
Good morning roli
I was waiting for video on this topic by you ❤❤❤
Informative
Keep it up brother 🖤
Love to watch him ..... His capability to show truth is just mind-blowing specially from Pakistan that kind of humour is rare salute bro
Lol tell Taliban that he was not Afghan but he was a Turk.
Afghans have Turkic tribes Mr 🕉️ . The ruling families Durrani & Ghilzai both are Turks who assimilated in Pashtun culture. You still find unmistakable resemblance between them .
They are Turkomongols and not Turkic
@farhansadozai9167
Yes brother 🙏
Ahmad Shah ji Abdali = hepthalite white hoon Turks .
Alauddin Khilji was also a turk woh become Ghilji .
Full support to Afghans
Whole Pakistan and Indian occupied Punjab belongs to Afghanistan .🔥.
@@farhansadozai9167
Aap bhi Aryans ki aulad ho
Aap log hi original Aryans ho
India waale Aryans kaale pad gaye hai.
@@farhansadozai9167
Ahmad Shah Ji Abdali was great king 👑
Sher Shah Suri
This is called journalism❤️❤️❤️ love from Nepal 🇳🇵 sir🙏
Love from INDIA 🇮🇳
Salute hai aapko paji, sun k bada achcha laga ki pakistani b sach bol sakte hai. Waheguru always bless you 🙏
Amazed at the level of knowledge of Mushahid Hussain Syed.
bhai joot bhol raha hy multan mai qaramati shia thy jinhon ny kabba sy black stone choree ke the history dekho ya sub hum in sy pehly padh chooke hy likin ya beghairat youtub payment k lya sub koch kar raha hy
Syed Muzammil has tried to factually disconnect Mahumd Ghaznavi from Islam, but the fact remains that this plunderer remains a hero to Islamic world.
Much needed topic thank Muzammil bhai