Wow, the last thing she said really shook me to my core. It takes courage to stand up against falsehood and not everyone has the guts to do so. I thoroughly enjoyed listening to Ma'am Ayesha's insightful podcast, and kudos to the host for a great job! The questions you raised were spot on.
On 7th Nov, 2017 I refused to have sex with my teacher Aimen Nadeem FSP 43rd CTP at Brunei Hostels, Got software updated at h384,st17,Shahzad town and Dad murdered by ISI and CIA to cover up tracks in wheat smuggling
@@gulabisinghkhankhan7012 😂😂😂😂 she is stating facts army bot . Shameless army , harami Asim muneer ,Nadeem ,DG ispr and curropt crook generals greedy for money have destroyed justice system and also Pakistan
So she meant that Nawaz sharif , Zardari and other bluddy civilian dictators mills who hired black water and RAW agents should be given open hands to even sell nuclear assets to enemies ? 😊 just think on whose pay roll she works on and why she’s living in USA 😂 and Europe
At 33:30, Why would they listen to Manzoor Pashteen. The Punjabi Army is aware of Pakistan toot raha hai due to their mismanagement. Thats why, they are looting other 3 provinces as much as ;possible. All these so-called Shia Sunni faced is perpetuated by the army to loot oil, gas, minerals, and precious stones of Waziristan.
@@trynaru since imran khan government was toppled many social media v loggers sharing awareness among the public from different platform English and Urdu languages
As a private sector working woman that has been grinding herself for over 3 years for peanut shells, i woke up at 5 in the morning and i was so hooked that i watched this whole podcast without even skipping. Please bring this lady again in the podcast, please bring this lady to Pakistan.
what other books will you recommend because this was shitty book.. it's like only written because there is some sort of personal rivalry going on between her's and military org.
Wow, my mind is blown. This is what you call effective communication. No profanity, facts based discussion, to the point, simple to digest by a novice like me. I was going to sleep and ended up watching it past midnight and shared it with my mom as well. Hats off to the lady. Much respect!
بہت پیاری اور حقیقت پر مبنی باتیں کیں ۔ چبا چبا کر بھی سب کچھ کہ ڈالا پیاری عاءشہ نے ۔ سلامت رہیں اور محفوظ رہیں ۔ اللہ کرے کوءی ایسا آءے جو جن کو بوتل میں واپس بند کرے
یہ جن اب عینک والے کی طرح نہیں ہے سمجھ دار ہے یہ جن اب بوتل میں جا بند ہو کر نہیں دکھائے گا کہ میں جن ہوں یہ عوام کو مار دیں گئے اپنے کاروبار چلانے کے چکر میں
Thank you for speaking the truth. You said the golden words " To the Pakistan Military Pakistan is equivalent to Punjab only (sindh, balochistan and nwfp doesn't matter). This mentality has to change to bring stability in Pakistan. I am not sure whether this will happen during my lifetime
It's absolutely not easy to reveal the truth. It's the hardest thing to do. Future generations of Pakistan will undoubtedly appreciate your candor and patriotism. Thank you very much for your outstanding work. May God bless you abundantly. Ameen.
Daikhnay k Baad b boley gi k yeh dhushman ki agent hay , paison aur fame k liyie yeh kaam kiyia hay . . . Pakistan army zindabad . Iss khoti hajoom ko aqal qayamat tak nahi aanay wali . Iss badqismat mulk ka Allah he Hafiz hay .
Dr. Ayesha Siddiqa is the well courage and well educated women and she is the most honourable to us, because she gave us the good education for seaeching in the meddling of Military soldiers in the Businesses and Politics. Thank You So Much Honourable Dr.Ayesha Siddiqa.
Dr. Ayesha Siddiqa's frank, concise assessment of evolution of political military structure, covering the good, the bad and the ugly following her book Military Inc. Thank you Dr. Ayesha, for genuinely caring for Pakistan. First time i watched Shayan Mahmud podcast, i liked the way you did not unnecessarily interrupt the speaker to show you know the subject. You were a true professional, and your guest was relaxed. The indexing at the bottom of the screen is very helpful. Keep it up. I am a subscriber.
One of the problem is one man has so much power There’s no check and balance Now public is more aware of what they have been doing to civilians? No military can succeed without public support
When I first encountered your book i was just shocked at how you have written this masterpiece in a country like Pakistan. Appreciate your efforts. Thanks to Shayan for bringing this kind of knowledgeable full podcasts.
The think tank the intellectual the brain of Pakistan Aisha Siddiqa..May my god bless you specially the team of siad youtube chanlle with much hapiness.ameen.❤❤❤.
What is the fundamental problem with Pakistan is lack of common man's participation in political leadership. Politics is totally dominated by feudal elites in Pakistan. As a result military in Pakistan established itself as composite institution.
Siddiqa is not so Siddique What she is saying about Pak Arny is not the whole truth. She is looking at the things from one side only. Some of her findings or observation in her book Military Inc are valid but what she failed to understand that all those business concerns being established and being owned or run by Pak Army are not a burden on the Govt or tax payer. The Army is managing these institutions like Fauji Foundation on self help basis and any Profits accruing from these'set ups are being spent on different welfare projects like health, education,. These are self generating entities and saving lot of financial burden of Govt. What is wrong with them. Armies all over world are paid for their welfare projects. As far Housing Projects like DHA etc are concerned, these are again self financed and are meant to provide housing facilities to Officers and other ranks after retirement who keep paying for cost of land in instalments during service. The DHAs are not getting even single peni from tax payer but rather paying huges taxes and providing employments to million of people being hired in construction of houses or in the down stream industries linked with construction business. Pak Army is now the biggest employer in country. Ms Ayesha must realise that Army service is a very tough job over demanding profession with bare minimum emoluments. I dont think Siddiqa' has any of her sons serving in the Army who could withstand the vigor of life at heights over 22000 feet and face 50 percent deformity to body. Moreover our mothers and sisters and daughters sleep well in cosy rooms bcz the Army is there to protect them from both internal and external threats . Maintaining large Armies is a universal phenomena and not only in Pakistan. Dont you realise the multiple threats emanating from all sides of borders . It's the soldiers who are bearing the brunt of terrorism 7/24 at the cost of their blood. By the way, Does She know as to what happened with Bangladeshi women folk in 1971. A huge number if women and young girls were abducted by Indians directly under nose of Indian Army and sold out in brothels of Kolkata and Bombay. Does Siddiqa want same kind of scenario here. Mind you Pak Army is protecting the nation from a ten times bigger enemy for the last 75 years. A Again She should be knowing as to who invited Soviet to invade Afg and pose a big threat to Pakistan as well? was it Pak Army or Zia? And later who invited the US and NATO Forces there who occupied Afg for two decades. Do you think if Pak Army was not there, who could save the country from these Super Powers threat . More so, most of the major development projects in all provinces were undertaken by Military and completed which are now serving as back bone of economy. Lastly dont bluff. Army was not called in Islamabad in recent disturbances nor she fired any bullet. Aap Dushman ki Zaban Bolti ho. Army Chief openly stated that lawful agitations is the right of people and that we will not create hindrance except where there is grave threat to life and properties of public .
At the same time your civilian governments teach in school India / Hindus are our enemies! Also the syllabus says we won the 1965, 1972 & Kargil war! Today, because of the internet Pakistanis came to know the reality!
@@AhmedSultan-hi4gv بلَڈی کَوکونٹ فوجی، آپ ماں چُدا لیتے مگر ایسی بچگانہ و بدصورت وکالت فَرنگیوں کے میراث کافر و طاغوتی ادارے فوج کی نہ کرتے۔۔۔ آپ نے اِتنے کھوکھلے دلائل دیے ہیں کہ ایک پُھونک سے اُڑ جائیں، مگر میں وقت اِس چوتیاپے پر زیادہ ضائع کیے بغیر چند باتیں کروں گا کہ چند کہاوتوں پر غور و فکر کرنا، اگر عقل و فَہم ہے۔ 1- جس کی لاٹھی اُس کی بھینس۔ 2- Power corrupts, and absolute power corrupts absolutely. 3- داناؤں کی کہاوت ہے کہ طاقت وہی پچاتا ہے کہ جسے خوفِ خدا ہو۔ بھلا۔۔۔جو ادارہ کافر و طاغوت ہو اُسے خوفِ خدا کیسا۔ بس! بندر کے ہاتھ میں اُسترا آگیا ہے۔
اس بی بی کا بہت بڑا کردار ہے اینٹی فوج عوام بنانے میں ۔ میں اس کا بڑا فین تھا ۔ آج یہ بڑی خوش ہوگی کہ سارے فوج کے خلاف ہوگے ہیں ۔ مجھے یاد ہے اس پر سابق فوجی بھارتی لکھاری ہونے کا الزام لگاتے تھے ۔ اس کی کتاب ہر سکول اور یہ پاوڈ کاسٹ ہر بچہ کو سنانی چاہیے ۔ بڑا ہوگیا اب بیرک میں واپس جاو
چلو تمام باتیں مان بھی لی جائیں کے یہ بی بی ایسی پھر بھی اس بات کا کوئی جواز نہیں ہے کے پاکستانی فوج بزنس کر رہی اور پولیٹیکل اور سویلینز کو کنٹرول کر رہی ہے ۔ بھائی دوسروں کو الزام دینے کے بجائے اپنے گریبان میں جھانکنا چاہیے اگر اتنی فکر ہے پاکستانی فوج کو اپنے ایمیج کی تو پیچھے ہٹ جائے ان تمام غیر آئینی معاملات سے تو کسی کو بولنے کا موقع ہی نہیں ملے گا
Many people knows the fact but the don’t talk they are not honest to their knowledge…. Respect you for your honesty with your knowledge .. may Allah keep you safe
At 19:40, why not? Punjabi PM was supporting the Punjabi army. There are so many relatives and intermarriages. At 33:30, Why would they listen to Manzoor Pashteen? The Punjabi Army is aware that Pakistan toot raha hai due to their mismanagement. That is why they are looting the other 3 provinces as much as possible. All these so-called Shia Sunni faced is perpetuated by the army to loot oil, gas, minerals, and precious stones of Waziristan.
Madam Ayesha, you have very nicely explained the most talked about & sensitive issue of our country which was in the past & it is today. But I would have been grateful to you if you could have also pointed out how to resolve this matter.
Good podocast. Military intervention in economy and politics has weekend Pakistan`s economy and political arena which has directly impact on every sector of Pakistan.
Brilliant analysis by Dr Ayesha Siddiqa. In Pakistan Manzur Pashteen has the makings of a genuine national leader willing to face down the Army. But because of that he has not been allowed to broaden his political following beyond the Pashtun. The military of Israel is hugely popular with Israeli civilians because of its military record against Arab armies. Sadly the Pakistan Army to put it politely cannot match this record. The only Muslim country's army that enjoyed a similar respect is the Turkish army - and even this respect was compromised by its efforts to constrain civilian supremacy until Erdogan emerged and survived military conspiracies to eliminate him. In addition, the Israeli army has not taken comprehensive control of the Israeli economy. Its influence over Israeli strategy flows from its record of success on the battlefield and not the abuse of its power against its own civilian leadership as has happened in Pakistan. Of course, the whole of Israel including its IDF is a raging cancer implanted in the body politic of the Arab world. Nevertheless, inefficient and greedy militaries may conquer their own civilians but they can never conquer the enemy. The only solution to this challenge lies in organizing and sustaining civilian resistance. Imran Khan today is the only leader attempting to do this.
غیرت مند پاکستانیوں کے عظیم لیڈر مرشد عمران خان صاحب اور انکی با وفا اہلیہ اور ساتھیوں کو سلام ہو عمران خان صاحب نے اپنا حق ادا کر دیا ہے ۔ الله رب العزت عمران خان صاحب کی حفاظت فرمائے آمین
Her comments on America and disadvantages of privatisation are of next level because most of our so called intellectuals keep playing in the hands of ultra elite industrialists to speak rubbish against public institutions. Listening this critical commentary from a lady who is a professor London and still loyal to Pakistan’s public interests as most of other people like Miftah and Ayesha Jalal keep pretending to be liberal by defending undefendable . Salute to anchor as well!
At 59:44 she's right. What she said I totally agree, because my father was a train driver and he said to me a decade ago that Railways earn from freight not from passenger trains. And NLC completely out through the railway from freight or cargo.
As a nation and to become a real nation and nation state, we must have to engage parliament, academia, military, judiciary and all civil society how to run this in long term under the Constitution of Pakistan. Efficient parliament Professional military (w/out politics, economy) Independent judiciary Clean bureaucracy All the Check& Balance
Hats off to mdm for her boldness. Pak army hazarpa janwar hai jis ka pait,power aur grip itni ziada hai k iss k jaal sey nikalna boht mushkil hai. Ek circle hai jis mn power aur pesa hn jo ek doosrey ko promote krtey hn
Amazing topic fantastic guest and well educated podcast. Keep up the good work bro, our new generation needs to know these things. Instead of running out of Pakistan stand tall and take control of Pakistan. I love the military but, long as it does what there job is, to protect the country not to own the country.
Wow, the last thing she said really shook me to my core. It takes courage to stand up against falsehood and not everyone has the guts to do so. I thoroughly enjoyed listening to Ma'am Ayesha's insightful podcast, and kudos to the host for a great job! The questions you raised were spot on.
Yeh ! our army is our enemy and it's very unfortunate
😊
On 7th Nov, 2017 I refused to have sex with my teacher Aimen Nadeem FSP 43rd CTP at Brunei Hostels, Got software updated at h384,st17,Shahzad town and Dad murdered by ISI and CIA to cover up tracks in wheat smuggling
Despite the fact that He was part of Benazir Bhutto murder team
She said an Israeli author wrote so BEAUTIFULLY. I could clearly sense hate in Shayan's eyes.
Brave lady , may allah protect her . ❤
She doesn't live in Pakistan and is therefore able to speak the truth.
She was css officer and have strong relations in military.
@@Umartech_official No matter how many contacts you have in the army, any word against the institution will put her right in the hitlist.
@@AbcDef-d7b yep she resigned and went abroad. I think in uk, USA, Belgium, and germany pakistani feel more protective than pakistan.
She has been writing about it for years. I have read her books.
But musalman manhooz log hain
Thank you Dr. Ayesha Siddiqa You have diagnosed the long-standing problems of Pakistan, until the army of Pakistan does not correct itself.
At 19:40, why not? Punjabi PM was supporting Punjabi army. There are so many relatives and intermarriages.
She is heavily funded by Raw
@@gulabisinghkhankhan7012 😂😂😂😂 she is stating facts army bot .
Shameless army , harami Asim muneer ,Nadeem ,DG ispr and curropt crook generals greedy for money have destroyed justice system and also Pakistan
So she meant that Nawaz sharif , Zardari and other bluddy civilian dictators mills who hired black water and RAW agents should be given open hands to even sell nuclear assets to enemies ? 😊 just think on whose pay roll she works on and why she’s living in USA 😂 and Europe
@@sabrinakhan8217enemies of Pakistan spreading these sort of conspiracies since Pakistan came into being. Were Ayub Khan, Yahya Khan etc Punjabis.
What a great podcast. Every Pakistani needs to listen to this podcast.
At 33:30, Why would they listen to Manzoor Pashteen. The Punjabi Army is aware of Pakistan toot raha hai due to their mismanagement. Thats why, they are looting other 3 provinces as much as ;possible. All these so-called Shia Sunni faced is perpetuated by the army to loot oil, gas, minerals, and precious stones of Waziristan.
Agree
99% won't even understand what she is saying. That's the level of education.. 😑
Exactly
@@trynaru since imran khan government was toppled many social media v loggers sharing awareness among the public from different platform English and Urdu languages
As a private sector working woman that has been grinding herself for over 3 years for peanut shells, i woke up at 5 in the morning and i was so hooked that i watched this whole podcast without even skipping. Please bring this lady again in the podcast, please bring this lady to Pakistan.
That makes two of us.
As a student of Military and CSP sex workers from Pakistan, I laughed when Her Eminence Ayesha Siddiqa said: "inko nahin ata"
Ayesha Siddiqa's this book is one of the best book i have ever read
کہاں سے ملتا ہے
@@PUPILOFWORLD is it available in Pakistan?
Good 👍
what other books will you recommend because this was shitty book.. it's like only written because there is some sort of personal rivalry going on between her's and military org.
@@saadomar1101 Ooh acha to aap research kr k ek book publish kr dy , Topic m dy deta hu ( Topic = Pakistan's Bureaucracy )
Wow, my mind is blown. This is what you call effective communication. No profanity, facts based discussion, to the point, simple to digest by a novice like me. I was going to sleep and ended up watching it past midnight and shared it with my mom as well. Hats off to the lady. Much respect!
Wonderful conversation and I learnt a lot - Proud of Aysha Siddiqa - honest and very brave!!
*I first heard about Ms. Aisha and her book from one of my teachers, and today I finally found her podcast, it is a wealth of knowledge for me*
Such a brave and well articulated lady, Hats off to this courageous daughter of Pakistan
بہت پیاری اور حقیقت پر مبنی باتیں کیں ۔ چبا چبا کر بھی سب کچھ کہ ڈالا پیاری عاءشہ نے ۔ سلامت رہیں اور محفوظ رہیں ۔ اللہ کرے کوءی ایسا آءے جو جن کو بوتل میں واپس بند کرے
یہ جن اب عینک والے کی طرح نہیں ہے سمجھ دار ہے یہ جن اب بوتل میں جا بند ہو کر نہیں دکھائے گا کہ میں جن ہوں یہ عوام کو مار دیں گئے اپنے کاروبار چلانے کے چکر میں
@@ExcavatorwithAsgharexactly now they turned into wolf, looting us
ڈئیر عائشہ ہر پاکستانی نوجوان سوچ رہا ہے کہ فوج کو سیاست سے آوٹ ہونا چاہیے۔ سیاستدان یہ بولیں یا نہ بولیں اہم بات یہ ہے کہ عوام سمجھ چکے ہیں
پاکستانی محنت کش لوگ ہیں سوشل میڈیا امرانڈوز نہیں
True. Public has made its mind .
That's what we call, A real and hardcore talk which very few people have courage to do 💯
Regards: Umer Chishti
Shayan aap ne bohot acha podcast ki.I will be very pleased if you invite her again. Shukrya
Thank you for speaking the truth. You said the golden words " To the Pakistan Military Pakistan is equivalent to Punjab only (sindh, balochistan and nwfp doesn't matter). This mentality has to change to bring stability in Pakistan. I am not sure whether this will happen during my lifetime
Agreed
Unfortunately but the truth is they only belong to themselves. Being a punjabi military has never benefited me
Bravo for bringing her to your podcast and making these much needed conversations! How sad that such thinkers are kept away from Pakistan by military
One of the most comprehensive podcast on the subject with apt knowledge on the subject Dr. Ayesha. Kudos to the team!
Salute to A.siddiqui .. Truly a gem & brave woman ..
آپ کی حقیقی گفتگو سے بہت معلومات حاصل ہوئیں انشاللہ ہماری نوجوان نسل اپنے حقوق حاصل کرنے میں کامیاب ہو جاتے گی
It's absolutely not easy to reveal the truth. It's the hardest thing to do. Future generations of Pakistan will undoubtedly appreciate your candor and patriotism. Thank you very much for your outstanding work. May God bless you abundantly. Ameen.
Hope the whole of Pakistan can get to see this video
Hole of Pakistan to be seen by whole.....
Hole....
Daikhnay k Baad b boley gi k yeh dhushman ki agent hay , paison aur fame k liyie yeh kaam kiyia hay . . . Pakistan army zindabad .
Iss khoti hajoom ko aqal qayamat tak nahi aanay wali .
Iss badqismat mulk ka Allah he Hafiz hay .
Excellent analysis. Dr Ayesha Siddiqa is a great speaker and analyst on military operations
Very educated and outspoken lady....
I really admire her class 🎉
Dr. Ayesha Siddiqa is the well courage and well educated women and she is the most honourable to us, because she gave us the good education for seaeching in the meddling of Military soldiers in the Businesses and Politics.
Thank You So Much Honourable Dr.Ayesha Siddiqa.
Ayesha sahiba makes a lot of sense.
Dr. Ayesha Siddiqa's frank, concise assessment of evolution of political military structure, covering the good, the bad and the ugly following her book Military Inc. Thank you Dr. Ayesha, for genuinely caring for Pakistan. First time i watched Shayan Mahmud podcast, i liked the way you did not unnecessarily interrupt the speaker to show you know the subject. You were a true professional, and your guest was relaxed. The indexing at the bottom of the screen is very helpful. Keep it up. I am a subscriber.
Anchor is very mature and letting her speak
Aysha is the asset of our country.
We are proud of her intellectual capabilities
Long live mam for speaking the truth. Pakistan needs more people like you.
I listened to the whole podcast of madam ayesha a great intellectual and brave lady. She explained the system faults in a outstanding manner
What a personality aisha siddaqua masallah
Allah bless you
I just see specs mounted on two big holes, below which; row of blackish lower teeth prominent.
Black teeth, two holes, specs mounted.
Specs mounted on two holes
Thharrrrrkeee ...
Lol 😂😂😂
One of the problem is one man has so much power
There’s no check and balance
Now public is more aware of what they have been doing to civilians?
No military can succeed without public support
saddest part is this is how pakistan operates. same case like in north korea no dares to do anything about kim,
When I first encountered your book i was just shocked at how you have written this masterpiece in a country like Pakistan. Appreciate your efforts. Thanks to Shayan for bringing this kind of knowledgeable full podcasts.
Aimen Nadeem foreign service of Pakistan sex racket 43rd ctp
The think tank the intellectual the brain of Pakistan Aisha Siddiqa..May my god bless you specially the team of siad youtube chanlle with much hapiness.ameen.❤❤❤.
What is the fundamental problem with Pakistan is lack of common man's participation in political leadership. Politics is totally dominated by feudal elites in Pakistan. As a result military in Pakistan established itself as composite institution.
Siddiqa is not so Siddique What she is saying about Pak Arny is not the whole truth. She is looking at the things from one side only. Some of her findings or observation in her book Military Inc are valid but what she failed to understand that all those business concerns being established and being owned or run by Pak Army are not a burden on the Govt or tax payer. The Army is managing these institutions like Fauji Foundation on self help basis and any Profits accruing from these'set ups are being spent on different welfare projects like health, education,. These are self generating entities and saving lot of financial burden of Govt. What is wrong with them.
Armies all over world are paid for their welfare projects.
As far Housing Projects like DHA etc are concerned, these are again self financed and are meant to provide housing facilities to Officers and other ranks after retirement who keep paying for cost of land in instalments during service. The DHAs are not getting even single peni from tax payer but rather paying huges taxes and providing employments to million of people being hired in construction of houses or in the down stream industries linked with construction business. Pak Army is now the biggest employer in country.
Ms Ayesha must realise that Army service is a very tough job over demanding profession with bare minimum emoluments. I dont think Siddiqa' has any of her sons serving in the Army who could withstand the vigor of life at heights over 22000 feet and face 50 percent deformity to body.
Moreover our mothers and sisters and daughters sleep well in cosy rooms bcz the Army is there to protect them from both internal and external threats .
Maintaining large Armies is a universal phenomena and not only in Pakistan. Dont you realise the multiple threats emanating from all sides of borders . It's the soldiers who are bearing the brunt of terrorism 7/24 at the cost of their blood. By the way, Does She know as to what happened with Bangladeshi women folk in 1971. A huge number if women and young girls were abducted by Indians directly under nose of Indian Army and sold out in brothels of Kolkata and Bombay. Does Siddiqa want same kind of scenario here. Mind you Pak Army is protecting the nation from a ten times bigger enemy for the last 75 years. A Again She should be knowing as to who invited Soviet to invade Afg and pose a big threat to Pakistan as well? was it Pak Army or Zia? And later who invited the US and NATO Forces there who occupied Afg for two decades. Do you think if Pak Army was not there, who could save the country from these Super Powers threat . More so, most of the major development projects in all provinces were undertaken by Military and completed which are now serving as back bone of economy.
Lastly dont bluff. Army was not called in Islamabad in recent disturbances nor she fired any bullet. Aap Dushman ki Zaban Bolti ho. Army Chief openly stated that lawful agitations is the right of people and that we will not create hindrance except where there is grave threat to life and properties of public .
Well said 👍.
Truth. @@AhmedSultan-hi4gv
At the same time your civilian governments teach in school India / Hindus are our enemies! Also the syllabus says we won the 1965, 1972 & Kargil war! Today, because of the internet Pakistanis came to know the reality!
@@AhmedSultan-hi4gv
بلَڈی کَوکونٹ فوجی، آپ ماں چُدا لیتے مگر ایسی بچگانہ و بدصورت وکالت فَرنگیوں کے میراث کافر و طاغوتی ادارے فوج کی نہ کرتے۔۔۔
آپ نے اِتنے کھوکھلے دلائل دیے ہیں کہ ایک پُھونک سے اُڑ جائیں، مگر میں وقت اِس چوتیاپے پر زیادہ ضائع کیے بغیر چند باتیں کروں گا کہ چند کہاوتوں پر غور و فکر کرنا، اگر عقل و فَہم ہے۔
1- جس کی لاٹھی اُس کی بھینس۔
2- Power corrupts, and absolute power corrupts absolutely.
3- داناؤں کی کہاوت ہے کہ طاقت وہی پچاتا ہے کہ جسے خوفِ خدا ہو۔
بھلا۔۔۔جو ادارہ کافر و طاغوت ہو اُسے خوفِ خدا کیسا۔
بس! بندر کے ہاتھ میں اُسترا آگیا ہے۔
Sir politics is only a game for the rich and corrupt the rest are just sheep.
محترمہ عائشہ صدیقہ نے بہت زبردست انداز میں فوجی جرنیلوں کے پاکستان کی سیاست اور معیشت میں کھلی مداخلت کو بیان کیا ہے ۔
اس بی بی کا بہت بڑا کردار ہے اینٹی فوج عوام بنانے میں ۔ میں اس کا بڑا فین تھا ۔ آج یہ بڑی خوش ہوگی کہ سارے فوج کے خلاف ہوگے ہیں ۔ مجھے یاد ہے اس پر سابق فوجی بھارتی لکھاری ہونے کا الزام لگاتے تھے ۔ اس کی کتاب ہر سکول اور یہ پاوڈ کاسٹ ہر بچہ کو سنانی چاہیے ۔ بڑا ہوگیا اب بیرک میں واپس جاو
ہمارے بزرگ کہتے تھے کہ فوجی کی عقل اسس کی تھوڑی میں ہوتی ہے آج یہ بات سمجھ آی محترمہ کے پوڈکاسٹ میں
چلو تمام باتیں مان بھی لی جائیں کے یہ بی بی ایسی پھر بھی اس بات کا کوئی جواز نہیں ہے کے پاکستانی فوج بزنس کر رہی اور پولیٹیکل اور سویلینز کو کنٹرول کر رہی ہے ۔ بھائی دوسروں کو الزام دینے کے بجائے اپنے گریبان میں جھانکنا چاہیے اگر اتنی فکر ہے پاکستانی فوج کو اپنے ایمیج کی تو پیچھے ہٹ جائے ان تمام غیر آئینی معاملات سے تو کسی کو بولنے کا موقع ہی نہیں ملے گا
Thank you Ayesha for your bravery and courage
A very good educated and well researcher guest today. Do invite her more on your podcast for her take on several issues.
Many thanks for sharing your views on hard facts
What a brave woman, may Allah protect her , ameen
Many people knows the fact but the don’t talk they are not honest to their knowledge….
Respect you for your honesty with your knowledge .. may Allah keep you safe
Very thought provoking and insightful discussion by a sober intellectual like Dr. Ayesha
masha ALLAH she is such a sensible and brave lady
so much clarity of expression and argument. Thank you.
The world has changed and levels of awareness among masses is what is driving this change in attitude.
An Eye Opening podcast for those, who still support Pakistan Army ,Thank you very much Dr. Ayesha Siddiqa ,
It's amazing how Ma'am has effectively answered the host's silly questions with such knowledge, information, and wisdom.
Enjoyed this interesting enlightening talk. Thanks Ayesha Saheba. Stay safe!
At 19:40, why not? Punjabi PM was supporting the Punjabi army. There are so many relatives and intermarriages.
At 33:30, Why would they listen to Manzoor Pashteen? The Punjabi Army is aware that Pakistan toot raha hai due to their mismanagement. That is why they are looting the other 3 provinces as much as possible. All these so-called Shia Sunni faced is perpetuated by the army to loot oil, gas, minerals, and precious stones of Waziristan.
she is assets for country but unfortunately due to duffers she is not contribute in Pakistan as she can do.
Stay safe and stay strong.
Great job Madam had Dane
All mighty Allah gives u more strength to be aware our innocent people
Thank you for such an informative podast. Our nation needs more such podcasts💗
Thank you so much 💓 Aysehah Maam
many may criticize me.. But I feel strongly for our army compared to everyone else..
In what
@@Longlivepetergriffin In real estate business
@EnigmaticEgo I think our politicians, judges, military elites, civil servants all are corrupt bastards
Hahah@@EnigmaticEgo
Madam Ayesha, you have very nicely explained the most talked about & sensitive issue of our country which was in the past & it is today. But I would have been grateful to you if you could have also pointed out how to resolve this matter.
Iron lady of our nation, history will always remember you name ❤. Thank you so much ma'am for playing your role in spreading awareness.
MashaAllah Alhamdulillah InshaAllah✅
Ayesha siddiqa is well learned scholar on the subject, in pti govt she should be consulted for engagements with military affairs
آج احساس ہوا علم اور نیت کی سچائی سے اگر کوئی کام کیا جائے تو کچھ مشکلات ہونے کے باوجود عوام عزت اور احترام کے ساتھ پذیرائی کرتے ہیں۔
Superb Awesome Fantastic Mind-blowing 👌🏻👏🏻
Amazing podcast. Hats off to Ayesha Saddiqa.
Words of Wisdom from Ms. Ayesha, Such a tremendous person of knowledge, kudos to the host for such informative podcast 👏 👍
Good podocast. Military intervention in economy and politics has weekend Pakistan`s economy and political arena which has directly impact on every sector of Pakistan.
Absuluty right speech. I salute u.
Excellent topic and excellent podcast 👍❤
Best analysis 😊😊😊 so happy to hear. 😊
What a Brave lady I m big fan of her and admirer of her. God save her .
Save with whom by Allah From Army ISI Gernails?
Very informative. Want to listen more from her❤
Great podcast.
Kindly bring her back for another podcast.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Amazing n truthful statement, bravo
Brilliant analysis by Dr Ayesha Siddiqa. In Pakistan Manzur Pashteen has the makings of a genuine national leader willing to face down the Army. But because of that he has not been allowed to broaden his political following beyond the Pashtun. The military of Israel is hugely popular with Israeli civilians because of its military record against Arab armies. Sadly the Pakistan Army to put it politely cannot match this record. The only Muslim country's army that enjoyed a similar respect is the Turkish army - and even this respect was compromised by its efforts to constrain civilian supremacy until Erdogan emerged and survived military conspiracies to eliminate him. In addition, the Israeli army has not taken comprehensive control of the Israeli economy. Its influence over Israeli strategy flows from its record of success on the battlefield and not the abuse of its power against its own civilian leadership as has happened in Pakistan. Of course, the whole of Israel including its IDF is a raging cancer implanted in the body politic of the Arab world. Nevertheless, inefficient and greedy militaries may conquer their own civilians but they can never conquer the enemy. The only solution to this challenge lies in organizing and sustaining civilian resistance. Imran Khan today is the only leader attempting to do this.
Yes
Very good and productive podcast really enjoyed it🎉
There are more than 300 billion projects in Balochistan which was awarded to FWO without any competition on the pretext of law n order
Amazing insight into history of military's political role.
There is an huge need of corrective measures to fix this problem.
میڈم ۔ اللہ پاک آپ کو سلامت رکھے ۔ سچ سکہانے بتانے کے لیے ۔ ❤
غیرت مند پاکستانیوں کے عظیم لیڈر مرشد عمران خان صاحب اور انکی با وفا اہلیہ اور ساتھیوں کو سلام ہو
عمران خان صاحب نے اپنا حق ادا کر دیا ہے ۔ الله رب العزت عمران خان صاحب کی حفاظت فرمائے آمین
شفافیت پاکستان کے ہر محکمے اور شعبے میں ہونی چاہیے ۔۔۔
A very fine conversation.. Worth watching❤
Need your books Mam Ayesha Siddiqa
Listening the whole conversation
Many lessons for #ik
I have read her book now planning to read it again ❤
Excellent Talks Thanks
Wah kia interview h just wow❤❤
Asim Munir: The Next Dictator to Fall After Bashar al-Assad, insha’Allah.
Bajwa ko Abu bolty thy tum
Wonderful podcast could not skip for a second.... definitely much needed information,
Thank you Jinnah for taking out the weed from India in 1947 😂
Thank you Jinnah for taking us out of weed in-fact , this current situation is awakening not declining .
still he forgot UP but what can we do
If this the case then retuthe Juna Gurah, Punjab, Kashmir, etc. Then the weed will be fully out@DesiJugaarDIY
Different types of pajeets
This one is negativjeet
yar tumharay apnay maslay hain, but yeah i agree ye chuutya fauj bhi tumhara hi masla hoti hmaray hissay na aati tou acha tha
Wonderful lady she is asset of Pakistan ❤
Her comments on America and disadvantages of privatisation are of next level because most of our so called intellectuals keep playing in the hands of ultra elite industrialists to speak rubbish against public institutions. Listening this critical commentary from a lady who is a professor London and still loyal to Pakistan’s public interests as most of other people like Miftah and Ayesha Jalal keep pretending to be liberal by defending undefendable . Salute to anchor as well!
At 59:44 she's right. What she said I totally agree, because my father was a train driver and he said to me a decade ago that Railways earn from freight not from passenger trains. And NLC completely out through the railway from freight or cargo.
It's an exciting to watch my hero.
Keep sharing honesty and words of truth!
As a nation and to become a real nation and nation state, we must have to engage parliament, academia, military, judiciary and all civil society how to run this in long term under the Constitution of Pakistan.
Efficient parliament
Professional military (w/out politics, economy)
Independent judiciary
Clean bureaucracy
All the Check& Balance
Hats off to mdm for her boldness. Pak army hazarpa janwar hai jis ka pait,power aur grip itni ziada hai k iss k jaal sey nikalna boht mushkil hai. Ek circle hai jis mn power aur pesa hn jo ek doosrey ko promote krtey hn
“Government” is not a widely taught subject in our education as in many other countries.
Dr Ayesha Siddiqa is gem of a person, brave and real feminist
MISS AYESHA SIDDIQUA FROM KHANQAH SHRIEF SHE IS OUR NEIGHBOUR AND KHANQAH WALON KA SALAM
Heyy, you're from which khanqah? Karachi wali?
@@Umar-s6e no bro Bahawalpur 🥰🥰🥰
Amazing topic fantastic guest and well educated podcast. Keep up the good work bro, our new generation needs to know these things. Instead of running out of Pakistan stand tall and take control of Pakistan. I love the military but, long as it does what there job is, to protect the country not to own the country.
Excellent video much needed truth
Excellent madam, Our history shows that nobody gets lesson even it is defeated badly.
Mam be safe ❤ from india
Bhai pahle jan liya karo ye uk me rahati hai 😂
@@jitendrtiwari2530you really think they can't get her in UK if it comes to that?
Dr. Ayesha was great as usual...