"If You're In France, You're Not Desperate" | Julia Hartley-Brewer BLASTS 'Unworkable' Rwanda Plan
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 кві 2024
- Tom Slater and Julia Hartley-Brewer discussed the Rwanda migration policy, with both expressing doubts about its effectiveness. They also debated the UK's withdrawal from the European Court of Human Rights, with Julia Hartley-Brewer suggesting the government's decision is motivated by a desire to maintain a 'nice' reputation, while Tom Slater argued that the Tories are genuinely concerned about the potential consequences of leaving the court.
#rwandabill #rwanda #juliahartleybrewer
Click here for more from TalkTV talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
Personally, I cannot lose sight of the fact that they are coming from a safe country.
That's not how asylum works, asylum seekers can apply asylum in the country of their choice where they have family or cultural connections. And given the UK's colonial history a lot of people can claim a cultural connection. The whole safe country argument has no basis.
Their home countries they left behind were safe for them. This is a planned invasion of Europe and North America and the faster everyone realizes that the better.
The country most of them come from are safe countries. The plan is to saturate the Western world with the third world and destroy national identity and create a borderless world.
@@MrDeadhead1952 this is what most right wing nut jobs don't understand, you cant have a country conquer the globe, force Christianity and the English language on people and then be surprised they want to come here as they speak English
@@MrDeadhead1952 With rife promiscuity in Africa they are probobly all related. They could all come to UK!
STOP THE BOATS....ROYAL NAVY NOW!...
Stop the stupidity... schools and education now
If you left France a safe country you should have absolutely no right to claim asylum in the UK
yes you have a right to claim asylum
What if france says the same and then Spain etc , only country s that an asylum seeker could seek asylum would be there neighbours …. Usual rough old bird brewer lying about how easy things could be
Not if you don't have ID. Majority are destroying documents. So ,no , that type of person is not allowed here.😢🎉@@johnmcmahon5145
David Kurtin told us what france was doing
@@johnmcmahon5145 that's not the case there economic migrants who don't want to go through the proper process, others have to pay thousands to enter legally these people are scammers and this has been proven time and time again lying about where there really from lying about there age no documents etc etc
Julia, why don't we just treat migrants the SAME AS FRANCE, then they would stay there?? The EXTRA things we offer is the carrot. Just take it away. It can't upset the ECHR if we do the same as the rest of the EU????
Refugee applicants receive more money in France than they do in England.
Because the government wants this to continue. They want the mass influx of both "legal" and illegal migrants.
@@LerxstDirkandPratt why do they sleep in camps if they have money?
@@LerxstDirkandPratt And they get excellent accommodation in tents out on the streets in Paris and on the beaches. That`s much better than a hotel in England with free food and heating.
@@LerxstDirkandPratt I've not seen hotel France like I have hotel Britain.🙈
lets be frank the working class taxpayers see it as an insult that they are paying the 4 star hotel costs of the dinghy divers from France
id much rather my tax money go to help migrants then the pockets of the Tories
@@jacky5768I'd rather it went to the tories.
I'd rather have it in my own pocket instead of paying for illegal immigrants to stay in hotels.
We're you insulted about the weapons of mass destruction lie? The boat people were and they think you were not. They are not coming for 60 quid a week
Many of these people have had asylum claims rejected in France and elsewhere. Britain has the reputation of the soft touch who'll keep the rogues nobody else wants! Look at our deportations, compared to illegal entrants, they aren't even wrong! 🤦🏼♀️
A bloke was crying last time his kid died in the channel. Whilst seeking sympathy, he said he intends to do it again..with his other young children! My sympathy evaporated at that point.
How would you know who has had their claims turned down elsewhere? Facebook? X? Daily Fail?….
France is a safe country! If they choose to leave that is their choice!
Safe country rules no longer apply. We ain’t in the EU anymore..
@@stephenjon3502 even if we were in the EU safe countries doesn't matter to Asylum seekers!
@@polaris7122It does. Thats all part of the Dublin agreements. Havent someone told you before the referendum?
@@rollerrollerichson6258 hahahaha, another one who is totally confused. If you researched the subject, you would find that we received more migrants than we deported under the Dublin agreement in 2016/17/18/19. Germany has over 300,000 failed Asylum Seekers that they can't deport, last time I looked they were still in the Dublin agreement. All of Europe considers it not fit for purpose!!!!!
@@polaris7122I said those rules no longer apply. I’d wager if we had the agreement now the tories would be using it big time. Too late thanks to people voting the wrong way.
They should NEVER have got rid of Saddam and Gadaffii !!!
👏👏👏👏👏👏👊👊
To late now.😂
I am from Libya and we missed Gaddafi and if you enter the country illegally or you have no passport you went straight to prison and sent back but now we are overrun there's 2 million of them waiting to cross over and let me tell you something they don't respect the countries that they migrate to and most of them are on the run from their government it's best you don't let them in
Another thing there's a load of Hindus who are posing as Christians or Muslims
Blame Blair!
No now we've got soddom and gomorrah 😂😂😂😂
Its unlawful the police should be detaining them on beaches wtf is going on???? If i go to travel out uk i need passport n would be refused if i didnt have one or a ticket ???? Anyone????
Only problem is they all claim Asylum, so they don't need passports and we can't detain them!
The difference between you and them is that they land and apply for asylum. You could do the same if you so wished to.
No one is Illegal until processed accordingly. You’ve been gaslit.
@stephenjon3502 the moment they land they are illegal.
@@cameronnicholson1980No they ain’t. In your mind maybe but not in the eyes international law. There’s no such thing as an illegal immigrant. Stop listening to people that spout shite on these channels.
@stephenjon3502 of course there is such a thing as illegal immigrants lol.
Ben way of dealing with the illegal migration was right. How long would it take for illegals to work out, that’s not the way to enter Britain ? It’s called tough love.
Stop giving and maybe their stop coming !
One big maritime law was broken in the fact that those in charge of the people onboard who lost their lives did not report the incident to the French authorities and just sailed away. Hit and run does not appear to be a thing at sea. The French government should extradite those responsible back to France for trial.
I was born in Manchester a long time ago would I ever go back .....HELL NO
great, manchester doesnt want you.
The Labour councils COLLUDED with the overbreeders for votes since the late 1970s...then Bliar fully opened the doors
Manchester is ok apart from the bits controled by the colonists.
@@jeremyboughtono2 You clearly skip past the arab slave trade, like you don't like to talk about the 2yr genocide of Christians in the middle-east either. But you'll sit talking about British history that was ended time ago by brave soldiers you could never be.
what hypocrites you ppl are.
@@jeremyboughtono2 Do you ever get bored of been a stuck record? You are probably sat with privilege, while criticising them who are affected by this issue, you see poor areas are cheaper to buy houses, so it massively affects already poverty ridden communities! I think it's you that as inner guilt, I certainly know my history want one of entitlement & privilege.
If I was French I would be offended that my country is not good enough with all these migrants wanting to leave 😂
Try going to France without the correct documentation.
@@gregnorth6413You could if you were applying for asylum there.
I was stood on the pavement waiting for a shop to open, out of approx 40-50people that walked past me most were foreign talking males in groups!!!!!!
WTF is this country coming too?
Where were you in a Spanish resort? , where many British immigrants can only speak English, and struggle to say the days of the week, or count to ten in any of the official languages of Spain, and expect locals to speak English, a, foreign language with them?
Exactly they've travelled all the way through Europe & aren't mitgrants got to claim asylum at 1st safe country ??????????
Nope….you’re wrong again, even after being repeatedly told what the law is !
@@trevaudioit doesn’t matter what the law says. If you’re fleeing tyranny, the first safe place is where they should claim asylum. Otherwise they are economic migrants looking for the best place.
@@ianrowley5762 Nailed it.
@@ianrowley5762 So you want to ignore the law until it fits your narrative?
@@trevaudio We know the law Trev, just when home office are buying up homes in the poorest of areas you sort of get fed up, it really should be put into areas of them who want it, not like they cant afford it! Just seems they always complain with lame excuses! Probably why you get conflict of opinions & ppl with frustrations.
If France was paying out free money there stay in France
😊😊
just reverse the law and insist all asylum claims must be made before arrival in the UK.
You can't force someone onto a plane. They can simply claim chest pains etc and can't fly.
it's at a military base Military law and and it will be hard when you're strapped to a stretcher no niceties with the Military Police !
And labour will through spanners in
It's time all illegal migrants met criminal proceedings. Time to break off diplomatic relations with France. Like the EU, a one way relationship. Stop French fishing in our waters too.
one issue, they're not illegal......
@@jacky5768 of course they are illegal Jackie. They entered the country by an illegal method and without documents. Both of those things are plainly illegal. Further more, they were not leaving an unsafe country.
@@jacky5768 How are they not illegal? This is a real question not a rant. They came from a safe country and asylum seekers have to stop at the first safe country they get to. They came here without permission which is illegal therefore they are criminals. What did I get wrong? Also as criminals they should be in prison awaiting expulsion not in hotels.
@@davidankers9734 they are allowed to claim refuge in any country, they don't have to claim refuge in France who incidentally accept more refugees than the UK.They are not classed as illegal until they been processed and they have been deemed illegal
@@jacky5768 Say that to the women I see in my local paper that was just enjoying a night out with friends! I'm sure you can figure the rest out Jack & it's not the do-gooders that want it that get it on their doorsteps, it's the poorest of cities that they buy up cheap housing, so maybe you don't understand if its not affecting you Jack. 😉
IF the Prime Minister says it's a national emergency and the suspension of APS corpus for the migrants then send them to Rwanda for processing that ok in my book .
We all know why the head for Britain ?
Of course we do, no need for the question mark. It's freebies.
Because now we are not in the EU we can’t send them back to any country in the EU being a third country so essentially it was the Brexit voters that are at fault.👏🏻
@@stephenjon3502 So the Tories giving them free lifts and the red carpet treatment are as pure as the driven snow are they? it's months since the horse left the stable whose door you're trying to bolt.
Any European country is ok but the benefits one can obtain in the UK are amazing. You do not need to work before you get all the benefits and free health services. The UK has never addressed these issues. 🏴🇬🇧🏴🏴
3 million empty homes in France by the way...this situation is RIDICULOUS. Yes EVERYONE knows Rwanda won't solve ANYTHING. Personally I NEVER buy frog stuff...NONE of it
Yes, you do. You are simply too dumb to realise its coming from France 🙄
Can’t wait to move there permanently. Property cheaper, weather better, food better and they know how to protest properly. Over here people just moooooaaaannnn.
Never mind the weak 3 word slogan 'stop the boats'...... STOP THE TORIES!
Why?
Vote Labour...get MORE illegal immigrants
@@jeremyboughtono2 You'd never understand leftie.
So you don’t want to stop the boats then ?
@@uniquevideosUk So you want Labour to take over then.
They are in France, and they ARE desperate, desperate to get to England and a free and easy life!
@neilfoster814
You have nailed it in one Neil.
at what point did the Navy stop protecting our shores.. ?
it seems like any modern invasion force would simply be met half way by the coastguard, politely asking them if they're asylum seekers.
What has France not got that the UK has got???
Third country status.
How can someone claim asylum if they enter the UK from a safe country called France?????
I don't understand the logic.
Because Asylum seekers can travel through safe countries if they want, our Supreme Court judges have made it quite clear!
Safe country rules no longer apply to us. Wakey wakey
Blame Labour, the House of Lords and the legal profession.
There's posters in Paris telling immigrants to go to England for a free house and benefits
Billions on defense but conquered by a dingy invasion.
FRANCE IS NOT AT WAR!
What has that got to do with it?
@@polaris7122 Ummm they are fleeing...allegedly. But left a perfectly safe country.
@@enigma7791 they claim Asylum so according to our Supreme Court judges they are entitled to travel through safe countries. Do you know something that they don't??
@@polaris7122 I know they are chancers that come here because looneys like you are easy touches!
@@enigma7791Most are coming from Syria, Afghanistan, Iran.
They can cross as many safe countries they want too apply for asylum.
Now the UK is no longer in the EU we are a third country and thus it’s not allowed for the UK to send them back to any countries in the EU hence the Rwanda nonsense.
Have you got it yet?
Maybe we need to take a good long look at who is working as labourers on our building sites, cleaning dishes in our restaurants, painting our nails and delivering our pizzas. Not only will these migrants claim every single benefit going they will also be working on the black market. Remember that next time you get your car washed for a tenner.
play stupid games win stupid prizes!
Desperate - yes for our benefits and working in the black market, great help to our country that will be
Do we “ Flee “ home after a week’s Holliday in France ?
Exactly two years ago I had a bet with a mate for £1,000 that no one would be sent to Rwanda within two years. I offered him even money and he couldn’t take the bet quick enough. Today I offered him double or quits by the end of the year and he bit my hand off 🤣💰🤣💰🤣💰
Desparate only to suckle on the UK teat - for life. Stop the boats by stopping the giveaways.
Just watch the rush begin as from this morning
How often over the last decade & beyond have we heard this & still uncontrolled illegal immigration goes on ... Do we have a Govt that understands the scale of consequences that are to come ?
That's what France said about Italy, or Greece, Turkey its a safe country too, Tunisia its a safe country too, plenty of country's that are safe
What is attracting the invaders to enter the UK despite the risks.
So if flights start, new arrivals only have a 99% chance of remaining, rather than the 100% chance they have now! 🤔 Result.
France is a safe country.
Why do they choose the UK?.
They can choose where they want. They come here now thanks to the fact we are no longer in the EU and can’t send them anywhere.
@@stephenjon3502 They can't choose where they want by entering UK illegally..
We can't travel without a passport or document to any country in the world.
So why should they?
@@user-bo7fc9tj4zNo legal routes to apply for asylum exist. They are still entitled to apply for asylum ANYWHERE they want but to do that have to be standing on the soil of the country they wish to apply for asylum. The only reason any asylum seekers need to stay in a particular safe country is if they have family members already in that country or you didn’t pass thru a safe third country. As the UK is a safe third country now we’ve left the EU that’s one of the main reasons we cannot send them back to anywhere as we would be breaking international law by doing so.
Instead of listening to shite like these channels have a read of the refugee act or how to apply for asylum on the UNhcr website. Everything is there in black & white. This will stop you regurgitating the same old nonsense.
And YOU could do exactly what they are doing ( applying for asylum ) if you wanted to, that’s the difference between travelling with a passport/documents as you would more than likely be going on holiday.
Hope this helps.
But the Government is desperate to get them here?
Tommy Robinson one his trial……. What a great day for a win!!!🇬🇧👍
Why did France take all that money from the UK, knowing they would do nothing.
'Attempted illegal entry into the UK will be met with lethal response' broadcasts, and signage would soon get the message across.
In reality it will be 20 bald 50 year old plus men all in the same 400 quid sweatshirt with a badge on the arm shouting for 20 minutes before the pub opens.
This royal throne of kings, this scepter’d isle,
This earth of majesty, this seat of Mars,
This other Eden, demi-paradise,
This fortress built by Nature for herself
Against infection and the hand of war,
This happy breed of men, this little world,
This precious stone set in the silver sea,
Which serves it in the office of a wall
Or as a moat defensive to a house,
Against the envy of less happier lands,
This blessed plot, this earth, this realm, this England, .....
GONE ....
Africans,Latino americano will can come to school in Eastern Europe, schools are free, health care is free, in Eastern Europe we have the lowest unemployment rate, shops are open on Sundays, you can earn extra money on weekends. Eastern Europe, Intermarium countries need workers for factories in industry, processing, for highway construction, road traffic, paving stone sidewalks, infrastructure
It might sound radical but without Brexit we would have had some say about them staying in France.
its probaly better in france why moved to uk it always rains
Why did a four year old girl die if she was in the middle of the boat she wouldn't. What kind of people would let her die?
I see " The Tiber foaming red" on the horizon.
"Build a wall" - some smart man somewhere
I can't go to France for a holiday it's so dangerous
Enough is enough
Correct - if they're in France, they're not desperate, but they are desperate to reach the UK, where they've been told they'll get everything for 'free'. They're also desperate enough to risk their lives to reach the UK crossing the channel - this is something they obviously accept.
The French are allowing unsafe overcrowded boats 🚤 to leave their shores.
This is why i am so angry about this situation . and have absolutely no sympathy for these young men 1 they left a perfectly safe country 2nd France should just like the rest of Europe stronger borders to prevent this from happening !
The Rwanda bill will not make one bit of difference we send 300 to Rwanda and get 300 Rwandan’s and the boat keep coming Sunak and his cabinet should resign now it would take 29 years to move 27,000 illegals stop the boats Sunak couldn’t stop a bus at a bus stop
Notice how the Lords strung it out till after midnight so they could claim another £300
They're trying to get away from the French.
David kutin told you what was happening
Come on Julia you have to start asking anyone on your show, what is the altenative. I am fed up with everyone criticising this outcome[everone has a right to complain about this] however so ask your guests what is the legal alternative!!!!!!!!!!!
Only if you in England
Rwanda policy only applies single males....all they have to say is they are married and their spouse is still in another country
France dumping its migrant problem on us and we pay them millions to do it. Something doesn't add up.
France had over 320.000 immigrants during 2023 they need to take more and the overseas budget needs cutting as well LOL
No desperation and the land mass of France is 212.90 sq. miles. While Britain is 121.36 sq. miles. Population of France 68m, Britain 67m.
So why is the desperation so intent on getting to Britain. Could it be that only 9% of immigrants get free health care in France when they have a system that should cover all.
But apparently I must vote for the same old same old. Or be called a racist. You don't get called that in France or outside of France if you're in the EU.
The reason they are now coming here in record numbers is that thanks to the numpties that took us out of the EU and making the UK a third country it would be illegal to send them back to a country in the EU.
Of course Bojo the liar and the rest didn’t bother to tell you that when they were spouting the controlling borders and making everything super sovereign did they?
They are in a safe country they come here for the freebies shocking😮
Iam in France, and iam desperate.
I suggest you learn French or Kinyarwanda Swahili. ?
If they knew life was much harder in this terrible racist country of ours they might be less inclined to come. Just a thought.
Rwanda a gimmick
France is safe don't let the RNLI bring them here just return them they should be fined for trafficking.
Rough old bird Brewer making things sound easy by lying about international law What if france says the same and then Spain etc , only country s that an asylum seeker could seek asylum would be there neighbours ….
If I could just correct Julia. Actually, if you're a grifter in France, you are desperate. Desperate for the following: A nice, free hotel room with free food and eventually a council house with no waiting on the list. No bills to pay either. A free bike, free money each week, free WIFI, free gym and bus pass, free legal aid to fight your endless appeals and a free life in the land of milk and honey to grift and grift some more.
100% bang on 👍
What did you talk about before Rwanda. CAKE 😅
You guys definitely need more Muslims. Such a peaceful religion 😊😅😂
France a lovely country with one problem. Its full if french people.
And also France has said we are welcome to send out boats to tow there boats back to France get them British boats out there and tow them back. We have been given permission by France to do so today and save our money NOW
Duh huh imagine that yes if they managed to get to france then there no desperate are they 😊
Ukraine is desperate for military age men......
It could make a difference Rory Sutherland a modern marketing! If the few that get to sent to Rwanda are well publicised will have an effect! You do need all sent just a few and sufficient for cause worry for smugglers selling crossings!!!!
Funny the left believe in social engineering when it is woke stuff, but for something like this our imagination are blocked!
Need a message to be sent to affect the economic equation of buying and selling crossings!
No sympathy
If you are sitting on the edge of an overcrowded rubber boat trying to cross the channel you ARE desperate.
Julia would turn St George away if he applied for refugee status.
🤡 🤡 🤡 🤡
They don't qualify as refugees. They cost us billions a year.
If he had been bothered to set foot in England
Dont be so stupid
Ignorance abounds😮
As intellectually-challenged as her viewers
Including you ,thanks for watching😅
@@Royboy50Thank you for neatly proving my point.
A statement of opinion does not imply the person making the assertion has watched any of the emissions.
Secondly, your comment suggests you are one of the viewers and content to be classed as intellectually-challenged.
Well done.
@@edgyonetwo1 you’re another sucker easily hooked and landed ,ker ching ,now get back into your box until I rattle it again
uhhh... France is full of french people... I'd be desperate to get out too...
I think you’ll find there’s a hell of a lot of Brit’s to .
If Liebour get in they will stop the flights and let them stay Vote Reform folks 🇬🇧🇬🇧
Don’t forget to pay your £25
Not a singe mention of St George's day