Reasons for Taliban's Win
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 лип 2024
- How did Taliban take control over Afghanistan even though the US spent more than USD80 billion in upgrading Afghanistan's military capabilities?
******
Liked the background music? I use Epidemic Sound. You can get a 30-day free trial using this referral: www.epidemicsound.com/referra...
******
Editing: Ajeesh Babu ➡️ / ajeesh_babu
Art Director: ButWhy ➡️ / butwhy
Subtitles: Dhruv Bambhaniya ➡️ / dhruvkumar_2920
******
Markers
0:00 Introduction
3:09 How did the Taliban win
7:27 What does this mean for India
9:43 India’s options
10:49 Why even the Taliban faces a difficult choice
13:00 Conclusion
******
Support on Patreon:
/ sochyoutube
Contact:
Facebook: / sochyoutube
Instagram: / mohak.mangal
Twitter: / mohakmangal
******
Creative commons:
Pixabay
Unsplash
Flaticon
Freepik
Videvo
******
Sources:
0. Introduction
www.nytimes.com/2021/08/13/wo...
www.wsj.com/articles/afghans-...
www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-5...
/ 1426864171468034053
/ 1426461369889484801
www.nytimes.com/2021/08/12/us...
edition.cnn.com/2021/08/13/po...
/ 1426798340579250180
/ 1426976675431018499
/ 1426976895858446336
/ 1426467215830827008
/ 1426424111299928064
/ 1426723223572516872
/ 1426433896674168836
www.longwarjournal.org/mappin...
/ 1426832901602091009
www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-r...
/ 1426672345649983488
/ 1426578364123525121
1. How did the Taliban win
www.washingtonpost.com/world/...
www.vox.com/22618215/afghanis...
www.wsj.com/articles/afghanis...
www.nytimes.com/2021/04/28/wo...
/ 1426578364123525121
2. What does this mean for India
theprint.in/diplomacy/taliban...
/ 1425404552807858179
• Indian PM hands over m...
www.livemint.com/news/india/i...
thewire.in/south-asia/exclusi...
www.thehindu.com/news/nationa...
www.aljazeera.com/opinions/20...
3. India’s options
/ 1421451248012873733
www.hindustantimes.com/videos...
www.thehindu.com/news/nationa...
4. Why even the Taliban faces a difficult choice
www.nytimes.com/2021/07/31/wo...
www.aljazeera.com/opinions/20...
www.hindustantimes.com/india-...
www.hindustantimes.com/opinio...
5. Conclusion
/ 1426852794175270915
inkstickmedia.com/india-must-...
#Taliban #India #MohakMangal
"The only thing that we learn from history is that we learn nothing from history." -German philosopher Georg Hegel
Yes.....🤷🤷🤷
Lallantop
Absolutely true 💯😂
waah kya baat kahi h
@@lysia7743 beuty
Three thing that disappear when you need them the most:
1) Nail Cutter
2) Safety pins
3) America
@@pus3670 to make terrorist
3. Should be United Nations
@@pus3670 Hindu Republic of Pakistan
@@pus3670 No bro, future is Hindu Republic of Pakistan
@@pus3670 No matter where you are from. Expulsion of Abdul from India and Pakistan ,then declaring Hindu republic of Akhand Bharat is the future
I feel so bad for Afghans they have been under constant war, I just hope I get to see Afghans be free and flourish in lifetime. Kabul is such a beautiful and historical place, I hope it doesn't get destroyed
@@harshsb12 reallyy??? can see that in how ppl hung on to planes just to escape them
@@diya1113 did u saw Kashmiri pandits
Afghan sikhs,hindus,
Pakistan sikhs, Christians,hindus
Bangladeshi hindus
@@harshsb12 Can you provide the link to that research?
@@diya1113 those airplane people were American puppets who got betrayed😂😂😂
@@harshsb12 but when pew showed these for india
why everyone was angry then???
My thirst has been quenched as I come to my favorite SOCH. More detailed, Unbiased and research-based Analysis and Info. Keep it up MOHAK...
😌😌😌😌😌
but who is really biased in this situation? every one is against taliban as they should be
@@neel3198 watch ndtv ...you will get to know who are trying to justify Taliban
@@syamamamanibehera3340 hmm no ? they are just asking questions to them
@@syamamamanibehera3340ndtv is a congressi channel don't believe them
Maturity comes when u think geo politics is more interesting than any web series.
Finally I have found someone like me
Lol
Are u inside my brain or u can hear my thoughts??
I am 100 ℅ agree with u😅
😂agre
"To be enemy of America can be dangerous but to be a friend is fatal" - Henry Kissinger.
Legit....
America is like the rat who is the first to leave/run away from a sinking ship..
People should remember.
@@simrannisha8793 isn't that what u have done?
Didn’t exactly get that quote. 🤔 Aren't US allies like South Korea/Israel/England well supported and protected by USA?
@@ashokkumarpanda329 well what?
Russia : leaves Afghanistan
British : leaves Afghanistan
France : leaves Afghanistan
USA : leaves Afghanistan
Afghanistan : leaves Afghanistan
lol
Talibans : Enters Afghanistan
At prior afganistan leaves India.
No shit
You forgot India leaves Afghanistan 😂
I have never found this man biased not even slightly towards any side. Apart from all the chaos his narrative is amazingly logical and relaxing. Without getting us into emotions he tells us the real problem.
He was baised towards the left wing but now he is neutral
He does have lot of left-wing bias though. Just not overt.
@The Last Person Who Said You Were A Weeaboo. Yes but it never comes into his videos
Seems Mohak is smart and knowledgeable than 90% of Journalists and Politicians combined 😒
or any Commentator who Comments or say blame Afg. to being coward r the part of that 90% too .
@Pagan Min was talking about Indian politicians and journalists
The point is what to do now pakistan , china and Taliban wuuuf.🙄
Mohak and open letter are best infotubers
@@vivekt.2038 Yet 10% good journalist are left
The moment you realise, sitting in a room and praying for Afghan citizens by tweeting is not the same as holding on to a plane that is about to take off, in the hope that you can flee this failing government. Life is unfair :(
That scene shook me. It was so scary. People could fall and die and still running behind a flight..... it's just so uncomfortable to watch.
@@baghyasrib6929 Some people literally fell from that flying plane.
@@baghyasrib6929 even if they don't fall; they were going to freeze as the plane flies at higher altitudes. Also, plane flies at very high speed which would make people outside dizzy and with lesser oxygen as well as dropped atmospheric pressure at higher altitudes they were not going to survive for long.
Flight cabins are pressurized compartments so that people can survive and fly safely at high altitudes.
Jesi karni vesi bharni
@@thanosbaba2078 what do you mean? Vistaat mein batao
After everything I am glad I was born in a country like India.
Where Hindu and Muslims fight
@@reshmee6285 still living peacefully. No-one has to leave their country.
@@xyzr9138 poor people can't leave their country
@@reshmee6285 bro jinko dar lag rha tha ya hai abhi chale jao Afghanistan .....mauj kro waha jake ... baki it's my good luck that I am Indian. Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳
@@xyzr9138 Britishers ruled for 200 yrs still can't speak english, talibans also learnt English 😂
this is the most underrated channel i have ever seen...carry on you will grow...
USA is like a Bad math's teacher... They give(create) great problems but don't know how to solve it.
Yes....and also today Trump said Joe Biden to Resign.....as Rahul says to PM Modi 🤷🤷🤷
Correct 😂😂. First of all Taliban was created with the support of America. Then America itself failed to control it😒😒
@@sokaparnabishoyi8834 Taliban was created by Pakistan. Educated yourself
@@williamcunninghammorrison3894 created by pakistan and supported by the us
@@williamcunninghammorrison3894 But only pakistan was not able enough to create a strong terror organ . But when Russia tried to establish a governance there America gave his support to Taliban in order to counter Russia.. that's why it is one of the greatest discovery of America 😏😏
Man the editing level and background music and all the background stuff really makes this video as pure documentry 👏
Altaquia kya hai???
He is always dope
Watch apostate prophet.
I really want to request you to make a video on "how is now the relationship between India and Russia"
Thank you Mohak, for your effort to make this type of informative video, keep it up man.
Greed for power is the second worst thing in the world.
Diplomacy of developed countries is first one.
The 2nd reason is because of 1st one.
Every terror group is greedy for power
@@amongussus4 cannot agree more... live and let live peacefully
Religions extremism is 1st one
@@aditideo907
Only if ppl all over the world agreed
The global humanitarian crisis is worsening day by day
is it? nice observation i must say....
@@SaraswatMajumder can't you see it yourself ? Myanmar genocide, Uyghur genocide, Ethiopian genocide and now this, all being carried out at the same time.
@@sakshamtyagi9652 shouldn't have done 9/11
And we haven't even started counting Climate migration :(
@@williamcunninghammorrison3894 shouldn’t have devastated afganistan
Namaste... thank you, you have helped me a lot in understanding the topics I would have never found in my school text books. As a sign of gratitude I can just subscribe and like, but the number of times when I get clarity of any topic, I wish a thousand smiles for you.
Very well researched and easy to understand. Thanks for this video, the geopolitical situation seems clearer now.
Never ever believe on US government.
This is starting to feel like the beginning of bad times- climate crisis, pandemic, geopolitical tensions, this is genuinely frightening.
true intent
One word - KAALYUG
It's been building for decades now....Listen to Master Eschatological Professor Chuck Missler Koinonia House and listen to his talks about Gog and Magog end time prophecy's being fulfilled. As sad and unsettling as all of this is it is true what he says...."Everything is running right on schedule".
Lets go to a diff dimensiom
I think India would be surrounded by enemies again.. Nepal,Sri Lanka (China city), Pakistan, Afghanistan,Mayanmar and specially the main threat China
We had many afghan students including girls in my medical college as india sponsored their education as a friendly gesture, the scenes of khalid hosseini's books are runing through my mind again and again.
Praying for the women and innoncent people of afghanistan
Bahi Inko nahi Lana chahiye
@@nishantrawat1635 who are u talking about?
@@nothing_035 Afganistan Muslims
No need to pray for them 99percent of their population wants sharia law now they are enjoying their sharia
@@manishmalviya1620 did you do a survey of 99% ?
Stop hating all the time, atleast think of the women there, they are the greatest losers in wars like these.
This is most well defined and studied video I have watched, The last few questions that you raised is concerning really, Coz China has recognised Taliban as country and joined hands. it's tough time for india. more tough time for citizen of afghan
Yes China Pakistan and Taliban...I'm scared now 😩
China has joined hands with Taliban so they can develop and carry forward their Belt and Road Initiative project. Taliban was acting as a deterrent to Chinese project workers by not letting them work and in extreme cases even killing them.
Also China thinks of Taliban to be supporting and radicalising Uighurs Muslims against China. Hence the friendship.
Yes def hard time for women and children in Afghanistan and for India india also had some projects in there 😥 😔
Thanks for bringing so many prospectives of this situation. It’s not easy to understand this disaster.
Its not disaster its evolution after disaster because Taliban are sick of vulgarity of american people
I am really saddened. An entire generation of Afghans had grown up relatively free of Taliban terror and they had begun to flourish. On a day India celebrated its Independence Day an entire country just fell apart.
As a woman I'm terrified to just imagine the horrors awaiting Afghan women. In any war the biggest war crimes are always against women and children. What a God forsaken world we live in.
The news is deeply unsettling.
All that is happening in the name of god duh 🤷♀
an Afghan girl was dhot dead for tight clothes
*Save some sympathy for Home.* We have our own Taliban called "Hindutva". Mob-lyching people while chanting "Jai Shri Ram" is the same as beheading and chanting "Alla-hu-Akbar"!
@@bobinpune We have our own Islamic Taliban in West Bengal, Kashmir and Kerala also
@@bobinpune Boko haram, al qaeda, islamic state, talibaan
inme se kitne christian ya hindu naam hai?
Aur kasmiri pandits ko bhool gye kya?
Moral -
Be a free minded person.
Never be a slave of any ideology .
Go where the logic follows
@charan thej very correct 💯
@charan thej they don't make fun of liberalism or secularism the make fun of pseudo liberalism and pseudo secularism.
"Almost"every one support liberalism
Islamic ideology is wrost then communist ideology .
Agree 200%
I think, this channel is so much informative and really analytical, non Biased in their views. Great work 💯💥. I just scrolling videos and found all videos very related which are need to be watched by everyone.
Another great video! cheers bud for the amazingly clear explanation!
Vox level knowledge
One of the main reasons Taliban won is that, most of the population of rural Afghanistan, wholeheartedly supported Taliban and their interpretation of Sharia Law. Nobody is talking about it. This discussion can't be swept under the rug. To beat a problem, one must recognise the problem.
I think one of the main reason is not providing basic needs to their soldiers.
And disconnection to their soldiers.
Exactly, certain communities support Taliban and that's why it is thriving.
@@shahwayne4302 Afghanistan elite commandos were there but USA didn't even bother to provide them aid
@@shahwayne4302 yeah
@@Subhrajyoti can we all say that USA and Britain will stab your back always.
it doesn’t matter who will be running the government.I hope that those innocent citizens don’t suffer.I hope they will not be deprived from their basic human rights.We should pray for afghani citizen
But indian muslims are celebrating this,
@@user-bc1nh5vx9p I also can't Understand why they are celebrating. There is nothing to be celebrated actually
@@user-bc1nh5vx9p they are clueless. It's too early to decide and take sides.
@@user-bc1nh5vx9p I haven't seen anyone with even one brain celebrating this bro there's nothing here to be celebrated about
@@abhishekranga2858 you can check twitter dear they seriously congrats taliban and all.not 1,2,3 but 1000 are there... Don't belive check it by yourself, it will affect them but they can't understand
as always brilliant video! but this time the end notes were to the point. Nailed it!
Beautiful Editing ❤️ smooth animations video after video so professional bro!
Mohak is here when we needed him most, to explain WTH is gonna happen to Afghanistan!
May Look Rascist
But
Afghanistan Is A Hell
@@_kartik_chauhan It has been from time immemorial.
@@_kartik_chauhan Now it'll be a heaven
Ever feel useless.
Just remember UN exist in the world.
🤣😂
🤣
My favourite bible story is when instead of telling women to dress modestly, Jesus tells his dudes to avoid lust by plucking his eyes out.
That's why it's a story, not an event.
@@shaheenakhter9975 what do u mean ?
@@humanbeing4076 It's not realistic. These kind of acts are only for moral stories. They're not effective in real world.
@@shaheenakhter9975 yes they are, see in western countries or any developed country it may not 100 % but it's better then wearing burqa. Think broadly, religious brainwashed people are so narrow minded.
@@humanbeing4076 see brother burqa and hijab these are safety for women whey woman wear revealing clothes it seduces men so I think men should also respect women but women should also cover their bodies
So the US literally said , " Don't worry we will not lose it and be as humiliated as we were in Vietnam . "
But it happened , what a joke man .
America didn't fight on its own and with its force and if they would have done that then the situation would have been like Gaddafi or Saddam Hossain.
@@vibhorejaiswal2997 Over 50,000 soldiers had been deployed in this 20 year struggle man .
@@AfaqueAhmed_ ur free to have your opinion that Usa having all the resources like air force drones etc.and still Taliban wins bcoz off some roohani power than there is no point off debate as internet is more or less a free space unlike Taliban controlled geographical entity.
@@vibhorejaiswal2997 Listen I don't believe in that sh*t , America has more firepower , technology and everything , we know that .
But did you forget what Krishna said in Mahabharat :- Everything is justified in a war . That's what people use :- Guerilla warfare , brutality to instil fear and the list goes on . So did the Vietnamese and Taliban .
@@AfaqueAhmed_
Everything is justified to protect dharma.. And taliban an Adharmi is not doing dharm...
Its enforcing something..Dont compare dharma with religion... Religion is only a single dimension of dharma..
The war in Mahabharata happened after detailed discussion of both sides, when agreed tht war was only solution. Wars in India never involved genocide of pple of any caste ,creed whatsoever, they used to happen on decided ranabhumi....
It wete the invaders , uncivilized looters, plunderer who saw women and people as a property of loot...
We can only PRAY that the innocent are spared 🙏
We Have No Options , we have Only One choice 😓😓😓
But the worrying part is, even the innocence of individuals is going to be decided by Taliban (or more specifically, Taliban's local leadership at each place).
And we already know which stone age ideology Taliban follows on most of the matter.
innocents are the first target of any war.
@@lysia7743 true
You should pray for us Kashmiris first
August 15th for different countries.
India : Independence day.
Afghanistan : Back to 8th century day.
USA : Deja Vu of 30th April 1975 ,Fall of Saigon.
japan- surrender of kuomitang army in ww2 .
Mohak you are doing great job bro. Your research is up to the mark. you deserve more 👍 keep it up bhai
Joined and subscribed after Dhruv's recommendations.
When Donald Trump first talked about leaving Afghanistan then was the time India could have done something but now.... Kashmir is going to be affected by this very badly in coming years.
खौफ का माहौल है🗿
let them come. We aren't pushovers.
Why the fear? Let them come over here. Know that Islamists only understand one language and that is total violence. If you try to make peace with them like the Afghan government did, you'll end up like them.
I hope they don't land in Kashmir we already got enough problems.
We defend kashmir our all costs . It happens when Taliban roll in Afghanistan 1998 and now we defend ourselves .
To be an enemy of america can be dangerous, but to ba a friend is fatal.
~ Hanry A. Kissinger ~
Wow there citizen knows very well
It's suits on one religion too
Watch apostate prophet
was waiting for this video :')
You are an analyst in deed.Great Mangal !
What a wonderful neighbours we have 🙏
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Neighbours!!! Dude, even All India Muslim personal law board members supported it. So, we have snakes in our bucket too.
Lol meanwhile Israel be like mai kuch bolu kya?
@Akshat Singh israel k neighbouring countries bhut e weak hain israel k compare me
but India k neighbouring countries me China ab 2nd super power hai aur dosri tarf 1947 se enemy country hain
economically weak hai but militry vo b kuj na kuj tu hai...
Is liya india ko tough competition hai as compared to israel
@@mrwani610 Ha but bhai israel ka area aur army kitne hai dekha hai? India technology mai lack kar raha sirf israel ke comparison mai India ko sirf China se zyada dikkat hai mainly
I feel sad about Afghan citizens , especially women 😔
Womens feel more safe than ever in Afghanistan than any other country. No one ever think about rape or force any women on force marriage better stop listening zee news
@@sellersolutionhub I am not zee news listener and yeah if you look history Taliban always try to force women on what they wear , they do job or not and many more restriction they just snatch about, all rights of women, history proved this true, and this is just about but they also try to force other citizens, I think you should read about Taliban and its history.
@@mohammadsahilkhan3155 bro Abu Bakar is idiot he don't know the actual situation of afganistan
@@toonplus5400 true,
@@sellersolutionhub Which world r u living in? I'm curious. Or u need to justify Taliban?
Taliban rule was inevitable. USA would not have stayed there for ever, at some point, Afghans had to take control of their country. The only issue with US withdrawal is that it wasn't systematic.
As far as India is concerned, India won't be able to form any good relationship with Afghanistan as long as Taliban is in power, due to Pakistan and China. Modi is smart enough to understand it. Instead he would rather use this situation in Afghanistan as an election narrative against Muslims in India to get more votes from Hindus.
Right
Well it certainly helps when certain sections of Indian muslims show support to Taliban on social media.
Because both the Afghan government and the US had messed it up. US asked help from the very same country that was supporting the Taliban despite thousands of warnings from Afghan officials. On the other hand, the Afghan government was weak. They were incredibly corrupt too and so was the Afghan National Army. Out of the 350K registered soldiers in the ANA, only around 290K soldiers were on ground. Rest were ghost soldiers. There's an uncorroborated estimate that there were only 50K-60K soldiers in the Afghan National Army. And the US was rigid on withdrawing each of its personnel at once. No units to train the Afghan forces were left either. And the most important of them - their American contractors. There's a very brilliant opinion piece by a former officer of the Afghan National Army on NY Times explaining their situation. They felt abandoned by their own government. And above all of that - the consistent Pakistani support to the Afghan Taliban. This was the most important factor.
These all things culminated in the Fall of Afghanistan. It wasn't a very predicted thing.
@@urooz9992 yes
Amazing video, Vox level editing 🙌
Yes Mohak is indian VOX ❤️
This is alarming situation for India . It's time for Indian govt to make necessary strategy . Well done Mohak . You explained thing very well
How it is alarming? You want to mean externally...?
@@satyomdebroy1210 they can team up with pakistan or even capture it just like afghanistan and get nuclear weapons easily
,🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@hydismail14 abey ek baat dhyan rakhna . Aaj k baad India ko koi intolerant Nahin keh saktha . Khud Taliban kk wajah se expose ho gaye
@@satyomdebroy1210 either way . Some are trying to make Sharia law here since ages . This will be opportunity for them
Selfish as it may sound, our (India's) first priority should be it's own security. The Himalayan region is more dangerous now than ever before. We're surrounded by foes on all sides. Hopefully, the abrogation of Art.370 will prove it's worth.
Indeed ☺️
That should be our first priority.
Maybe it's an essential decision with a change in a situation now it's like a three-way fight in Kashmir. But I don't think anyone will want a war between major powers in the world. Because it will be just foolish. Because we now have more deadly bombs than we had ever (I am not talking about nuclear heads). It will just come as total destruction having now four aggressive sides on the front. It's a disaster for any country. The only option I think we have is for you to make Kashmir an integral part of India and have a solid defense installed there. But I still don't like the way it was done.
1st j and k should be given statehood indian govt abrogating article 370 is not correct timing still pain remain in Kashmiris so Taliban or pak can use to radicalsiation ...
@@karanmungra5630 Defensive offence is the motto. Nuclear Umbrella should necessarily nuetralise any major conflicts. India needs to take care of Terrorism and Insurgency in Valley. And India wont take it lying down for cross border terrorism. I'm sure those threats always existed and conditions have only been improving these years. No need to imagine of these hypothetical situations. China and Pak have always been allies for 70 years and this new taliban doesn't change military equations. Chill.
@@javedakthar4230 Shutup.
Three things that disappears when you need them the most:
1) Nail Cutter
2) Safety pins
3) America
Uh r the most learned person on UA-cam for me ❤️ thank uh for ur everything!!
People were clinging to wheels of Aeroplane. The desperation is real.
better die like that than by those terrorists right?
@@jaygondaliya6245 those people was laughing they are mostly stupid can't say they was running for fear or what but they was stupid
@@KingshukMonsur woah
that is fuxked up then
I just feel horrible for the Afghani people who have to live under a terrorist dictatorship.
@Truth Seeker lol anyone with common sense will understand that hindu extremism is still way better than Islamic extremism.
@Truth Seeker hindu extremism is the reaction to Islamic extremism
@@abhisheksv8131 as an Indian Christian I can agree on this
@@abhisheksv8131 true
... The person who said that was my a supporter of extreme left wing... You know what i mean
@Truth Seeker But modi never killed any supporter..like the reporter who was killed by taliban despite of being a MUSLIM. He was a strong supporter of many ideologies of Talibani islam.
Name me any guy whom Modi killed who supported him?
Thanks this video is really informative on the topic.
Informative video.
American army is the most powerfull army in the world was my biggest misunderstanding.
And American NGOs and News Channel are Neutral Is Also a Great Misunderstanding
Now where are their Human Rights Activist who Bark about Human Rights when US Troops were Scaring the Afghan People through Apaches to Clear the Runway??
American army is Strong but politics sucks 👺
america looks like a global idiot nowadays instead of a superpower. we are seeing the fall of america right before our eyes.
They can be superpower but becuz of their idiot presidents these things happen alot
They are. They just don't give a shit about others and think America is at the centre of the world
I really like this channel. Straight facts.
Very well researched video! 👍
Good analysis , nicely explained ❤️
The sad thing is...not a single footage of any women have been seen.
@Truth Seeker well women especially Muslim are free to leave india for Afghanistan 😂😂😂
I have seen A hazara woman crying and showing her pain and agony . She even told that by the time this video reaches you i would i have killed by taliban. Cant even imagine the plight of non supporters of taliban
@Truth Seeker and who said you that lol?
@Truth Seeker from today I will say India is most developed country does it become one?
@Truth Seeker yeah those are based of reports created by 'experts' we don't even know who those experts are and those not even based of surveys so can we even say those reports are legitimate.
Some videos of people falling off from planes is just heart wrenching
Subbed. Your videos are really well put together. :)
Waiting anxiously.... This vdo.... Very good analysis 👍👍
Omg this is really happening in 21st century..... can't imagine what Afghanis are going through....
USA is like the one friend who is the instigator but is the class rep too.
I knew it! All class reps are corrupt as shit
@@deadinside9745 felt like a personal attack
Watch apostate prophet
Analyzed the subject wonderfully!
wow amazing video thanks mohak for such wonderful videos
Eagerly waiting for your video brother on this Topic
@@Animatedeep ha chl aage bdh kitna geet gaega😂
Wow! This is amazing analysis. More informative than any news tv show. Keep them coming!
you making amazing vids man....impressed
Nice analysis bro
AFGANISTAN is known as graveyard of many empires...1st British then USSR and now USA
Even Alexander the great , Arab kings and Mongol ruler Genghis Khan tried to invade but all failed
I wish it becomes a graveyard for TALIBAN too
@@aryandhariwal5987 Unfortunately the war is over.(Period)
@@abduladil7332 sad but truth
I just wish for women and girls over there
More like Graveyard for Afghans themselves.
*These facts clarify that Taliban didn't invade Afghanistan. They simply walked on to it. Really sad for the poor innocent Afghans, specially their female and children. The world should understand that Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.*
They aren't innocent , Taliban is Afghani students of quran ,they gonna rule by Islam , no invasion . Just evacuate minorities , can't change muslims
@@abhishekyadav-hy3gq chup hoja saatvi fail 🤣
@@abhishekyadav-hy3gq Don't you have Muslim friends or colleagues around you...?
I hope you research more about Islam and check if your comment is right.
Please research...
And btw Islam is perfect.
average & ordinary afgans are Taliban.Those who oppose them r only less than 1%.When did guys understand it. Did u really think Taliban gain control of afganisthan without ppl consent. If they live into that system life then ppl should leave them. 1st world information age economy west shouldn't impose democracy, Woman rights into them
.
Oh nobody is safe even the young men will be forcefully indoctrinated and inducted by Taliban
One of the best information and reporting positive reporting please continue these types of efforts
Watch apostate prophet.
Great analysis sir!
Basically, Khel gaya Taliban.
🙄
I'm so scared for our country.😐
I feel this week is gonna decide a lot about where things are heading...
Don't be scared. We have strong military. Only We might loose on geopolitical front
@@user-dm9yk5wd9s I trust our army. Not the politician's tho.🙄
Geopolitical and the economic front...
@@MinMin-oe5od I believe we will be able to handle both fronts. Jaishankar baitha hai top pe. Economy will also be back on track.
Thank you so much for this video, I really needed this to understand the situation and you explained so well ❤️
Best explanation...
This conditions of Afghanistan... I feel the real meaning of Independence...
The best informative video till now 👍
The editing and production value of this video is mine blowing👍🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
It was so ironical that one country was celebrating it's independence and the other country was loosing it.. We can't even imagine the terrible and miserable life of the common people in Afghanistan under the Taliban.. 😥😥😣😢😟
@Arbaaz Khan O really... What else can we expect from the people like you who consider Taliban a people's chosen government 🤪
@@karinasen4330 he right people wanted that government because that's what evil Quran says and exactly taliban follows
@@karinasen4330 man not everyone is interested in democracy like us.
@Arbaaz Khan problem is sharia law cannot make development for a country
@@nabeel3 who in their right mind not like democracy?? Democracy literally gives power in the hands of people to choose who will govern them, otherwise they are just sheeps and pigs waiting to be slaughtered under tyrants in other forms of govt. Sure democracy has its flaws, but it is much much better than other forms of govt. by a mile.
Well researched video 👍
Can anyone tell me how does Taliban gets its weapons and support when even Afghan forces not getting weapons ?🤔
First they were funded by US and now they r funded by Pakistan and China.....China is doing this for its belt and road initiative and Pakistan u know it very well🤡
There might be more than one player invovled. China Russia wont want a US military base in its neighbouring country. International politics is very complicated. Also Pak but pak can only give training as they are not financially that good compared to china and russia.
Really a bad time is going on in Afghanistan 🇦🇫... It's very sad to hear this on the occasion of Independence Day 🇮🇳
Full Respect to Afghan Commandos. They fought to the last man standing.
प्रधानमंत्री भाग गया लेकिन तब भी घुटने नहीं टेके, फुल रिस्पेक्ट🤲
yeah elite commandos
real patriots
@@proudlyindian9113 why?
Such a coward
Then go to afgan
Very well explained
Very well Explained bro. Thank You.
I hope the people of Afghanistan are safe.
Let's pray for them 🙏
All this happened cause of America
🙏
@A Sprocket you're saying America stayed there for 20 years as if they were invited in as guests. 😂 They attacked the country, spent huge amounts of money on an idiotic war they couldn't even win, fucked up the country's society, polity, and economy, and then fucked off, having wasted everyone's time and money, including their own. Not only are they evil warmongers, they're incompetent evil warmongers. 🙄
@@zetaforever4953 agreed.
You can hope as much as you want or pray as much as it suits your damn beliefs it doesn't change one bit of anything for the afghan children and women whose fate is already sealed ??face the facts that we human are only entities playing God and entirely answerable to the miseries we bring upon one another..why do people do whatever shit they want and walk free then ask God to clean up their mess?
I realized that india relationship with its neighbouring countries is getting worse every day. China, Pakistan, and now taliban ruled afghanistan. This is really cause of concern. Another disturbing point is that terrorist activities might increase with taliban coming to power. 😫😫😫
U forgot sri Lanka
@@sanafizasana4351 yeah true, sri Lanka is also slowly turning against india.
Thinking about hijacks,terrorist activities just scare the shit out of me
@@swarupdey7553 true man, also not to forget that Pakistan and china will help taliban in to do the same.
@@sanafizasana4351 @satyabatra rout sri Lanka is a little complex cause both country need each other, sri Lanka doesn't want China on their land and India doesn't want them near their so no matter how many disagreement there might be the two will have to stick together but it is true our relationships with other countries are getting bad.
Watched Lallantop report before this video and there was very little takeway from that video, but how you Analysised and shared the information is commendable.
Great job sir ji... Ending music was superb
Corruption is one of many factors why afganistan fall , India must need to check on corruption for safety. I just don't want to imagine that for my country.
@Ashima Batra well we will never know that who will run who won't. Words don't stand for nationalism act does.
But my point is Do you really want to see country to stand on same door where afganistan is today. Corruption is increasing in India and it'll broke down India Internally if govt. Won't put check and balances on it , currently indian govt. Is failed to do so.
@Ashima Batra our institutions are filled with corruption. Without a doubt we won't fall down like afganistan today but in future we might if won't take care of corruption. Yes , external challenges will come with changing situation of afganistan but we also need to take lesson from what happened there.
I consider myself lucky to be born in india, the freedom that we get should be not be taken for granted.
Right
Kya baat kar rahe ho? I thought India is not safe at all.
BJP/RSS be like hold my beer
all border country is our enemy , dat why u lucky !
@@mediavirus5731 +RSS
Make video on China One Belt One Road Initiative
A very deep and good report..thanks..
we shouldn't expect anything from the west. this is the time for countries like India to step up on the global stage and help Afghanistan
Even the developed countries are staying back..........Ik India might be doing something in the background to secure the borders and indians people in Afghanistan and ofcourse India won't hand the Afghanistan nationals studying or working in India to Taliban controlled Afghanistan........we must think where UN or the human rights international organisations are.......as of what i heard the worst hit are the village women...........they might release videos of girls going to school or work in Kabul but not those villages
Every time women have to suffer
War_famin or anything.
I feel sorry for them
This world is cruel for women, we men made it worse 🙏
Because of islam
It's Islam
@@user-ej1fm7pi7y and krishna married 16k its islam 😂😂
Most rapes in india islam
@@user-ej1fm7pi7y how many rapes are registered in gujrat riots mumbai riots and riots in india.
Wow kya kamal ke vdo banate ho ap,acha hua dhruv bhai k channel se pata chal gaya apka thikana😊
Very well researched Vlog . Well done