But you don't get to properly learn a topic more than once without tutions. If there won't be online tutions then how will knowledgable tutors who don't want to teach in schools spread their knowledge in the way they teach(which may be awesome)?
Why isnt the chinese government thinking about "Why these parents are reaching out for these online education companies ??" It is because of the Gov's GAOKO exam. It is a crazy exam like JEE+NEET+few more exams combined. Instead of reforming the exam and their education system, they are shutting down the online companies. This is not going to change the fact that parents will still seek out tutors. Now only the rich will be able to pay for private tutors.
@@infinityxtanishq8712 Look reservation is not the best way to tackle the problem but the simple fact still remains that most of the poor in our country are SC/ST's & OBC's I had also apposed the reservation system but when u look at the data they are most of the poor. I am not saying its a good solution, i would rather have the gov. try to improve their education, health & food infra of these communities than give just reservations. not to mention it is just used as a political tool.
"Jo smart bachhe vese semiconductor manufacturing me kaam kar rahe hote vo ab ad optimisation me kaam kar rahe hai"- i felt that!! Everyone is going into it sector, even those who did engineering in interesting fields like material science or nano technology. India really need to up its game in high end manufacturing and biochemistry related industries. Ee have the capability to do so.... If only our government understands its importance.
I love how so many people in this comment section are praising Xi Jingping's Model despite bashing the Indian Education system for not letting them follow their passion.
Xi pings Education model is stupid Children living in rich areas will have better school education and poor areas students won't This will bring Huge Opportunity gap. Xi ping is doing so because he wants more people in Non technical work force
Its easy to appreciate from 5 dollar a month internet, sitting on a sofa. Do you on personal level have followed all traffic rules, planted a single tree or stop using unnecessary vehicles? If the answer is no then no gouvernement can help you
It's a huge mistake for a country of India's size and economic situation to ignore the manufacturing sector and focus only on service sector. As explained her, most of the service sector products are only nice to have and the over-indulgence of these products is what's causing a huge brain-drain here. We need to be self sufficient in manufacturing, otherwise we'll always remain in this same condition. More people pushed into poverty and income-gap increasing and increasing....
Most manufacturing are automated. Its not job producing sector. There is no need to be self sufficient in manufacturing. This thought is dictatorial and has given us leaders like hitler, musuloni and xi jinping. I dont want india to follow in same way. Let private sector drive innovation as and when necessary. No need for government to micromanage and pick and choose winners and loosers.
@@cyclopes968 there is need for self sufficiency because we export raw material cheaply and export manufactured goods in more value India is not ahead in internet and most manufacturing
We did not focus on the service sector it just happened, mainly cos it was the only area which had no regulations and because Nehru had the foresight to build IITs and hence at least had some educated people in the country who started to work in the only area which they saw future growth cos no regulation. Yeah I put Nehru in this just to piss off the bhakts
Qualities of a true visionary leader. India needs to learn from its equally populated and large neighbouring country like China instead of slandering, trolling people who provide constructive criticism, shutting them by claiming to be better than the likes of Pakistan and Afghanistan.
Another reason is shareholder capitalism china liberalised its market around 15 years before than india and 15 years ago china gdp was 2.5 trillion dollars approx.but very less care is about climate change which might sink all the economic progress every country have made.
Tiktok is a perfect example how youth of a country can be distracted. But still there are similar apps existing in India which need to be banned immediately. Same is with the Coaching Institutes, the reason we need coaching institute in itself reflect the failure of our education system. Even passout engineers need coding coaching so that they can get a job. Xi is truly seeing the future.
I see they’ve got a valid point. With the advancement of manufacturing sector they can make other countries rely on them and it can help to build nations growth in many ways where as India is completely focusing on technology that is solely targeting Indian consumers and finding ways to make them more lazy and it’s not a positive growth. Can’t deny China is always ahead in building nation.
@@believer0001 true and now China introduced new gaming laws for minors saying they can only play for 3hours a week which is Friday, Saturday and Sunday
Innovation isn't just about thinking deeply into a picture, it's about thinking beyond picture With the ban on several other fields and shutting up the critics will actually have negative effects P.S. what Chinese are doing is equivalent to demonetization to recover black money 😂😂
As an electronics graduate watching all my friends go for either software development (computer science) or competitive exams for govt jobs instead of seeking to work for core electronics companies and the fall of local smartphone manufacturing companies like micromax etc since 2013, i can easily say that India sucks in the manufacturing sector, especially semiconductor chips
lol Micromax was never a smartphone manufacturing company, all they did was importing cheap Chinese mobiles and rebranding them. That's why they failed after 2014
@@dibyanshumishra3536 Yes bro but all of them are Service sector it's ok for now but we need to move to Manufacture sector our Indian talents are working under western companies and fleeing to other countries we need to create our own FB, UA-cam like Tech sector in India
China has a very good understanding of power. Some of these companies were getting very big. They know that periodic destruction is also required for more creation. We are seeing what monopolisation of power in tech companies can do in places like the USA.
@@RealCherry8085 these three companies are asset management companies and are not owned by a single person or a small group of people, literally hundreds of thousands of people own it through mutual funds the people in charge for managing the company(CEO,CFO,Executive chairman) can't just do anything as they want, it could lead them into trouble because it not their money it's the public money, like in India there is UTI, SBI, also to some extent LIC, LIC is a insurance company but even LIC has a lot of assets. I included LIC because even today people in India preffer insurance over mutual funds.
India is simply focusing on service sector because it's profitable in short term and EASY for Mass people in India! But we fail to understand that Easy is always harmful in long term‼️Dk when our leaders will realise importance of focusing on other sectors too Edit :For all of those who are saying I don't know anything and service sector should be priority and govt is doing great are so pathetic that they fail to understand we are F*ing 1.3 billion people going to be 1.5B not like developed nations with millions Focusing on service sector which needs less manpower day by day Due to AI!! It is anyday better than accepting reality that we are poor nation and work to improve it, rather than Glorifying politcal parties (BjP or congress both) for the nation where healthcare ,education (which are most imp thing) are only available for Only cream layer of society!Jai hind🇮🇳
r u kiding me bro do some research now gov focused on manufacturing sector. u can see so many schems India became 2nd largest phone manuacturing and many more. do some research everything doesnt come overnight India is doing great. something is better than nothing
Manufacturing infra nahi haa investment Ane se isiliye darte ha. Privatisation is just a flop management ko Sahi Karna chaiye apne itna slow haa. Our govt doesn't realise anything they are all about selling the country.
I've heard several discussions on this topic but never heard this perspective before. Amazing video and really happy that Mohak is bringing out quality content more frequently these days
India's jump from agriculture to tertiary sector can be clearly seen in the education sector also students are much more interested in cs/it branches than core branches.
India needs to maintain a balance between manufacturing & public sector ,if they not do so in future when there would be a huge need of manufacturing sector there would be a lack of skilled employees.
it's a cycle where manufacturing sector isn't picking up due to which core branches aren't paying well and vice versa. Also, Inidan IT professionals are relatively cheap labour for the global market. Indian as well as foreign companies are making the best use of this skewed cost of labour.
Student's interest point is baseless 😅 I myself took *Computer Science* because CS & IT department have best placement. To achhi job to chahiye na bhai🙂
The thing they did with educational institutions was actually right as most of them are fraud, such things are necessary in India too. If this is implemented in India, the problem of shortage of teachers can be solved too.
@ Mukta Singodia Use your brain, these are private companies. If there are no profits, they will not stay in the market for long term and move away. This idiotic socialist mindset has destroyed our country. We are not a authoritarian country like China. These private players will simply move to another sector.
@@shrinivasj610 authoritarian and socialistic values are not necessarily same or go together. I agree we need profitable private players but if you take edtech space rn in India for example, companies like BYJUs are solely living off marketing and sales targets for their employee, which is leading to toxic work culture as well as gullible parents getting these expensive tuitions for their kids thinking it's the best while they're mediocre at best. This is also harmful for the consumers, employees and industry as a whole.
@@Sachin.Sheelavant you can have strong labor laws like France to fix that issue but the Indian Union can't afford to do what the Chinese has done. We are not an industrialised nation. We have very few industries. Almost 50 percentage of our population works in agriculture.
I think schools don't get good teachers as they are very rigid, If I had a choice I would leave school and join a coaching as it is better than schools, school teachers are just people who couldn't get anything so became teachers
@@shrinivasj610 that's not my point here dear, the thing is many good teachers are in these institutions, many good schools teachers too leave (private) schools for joining such institutions. And there is really a shortage of teachers in India And actually my motive (which I actually didn't write) was to say that why isn't school enough, why is there even a need of these institutions, schools should be made good enough, and as there are few really good and experienced teachers in these institutions, they can improve the quality of teaching. Not to mention, these institutions cost more than schools.
That's what I am keep saying about Byjus's and such apps. These apps and mentality to support such technology could be a cancer for the coming generations.
Games khel rahe -pubg, freefire ,call of duty, among us Grocery and goods online manga rahe hai -bigbasket, amazon, paytm mall, reliance mart Food ghar baithe manga rahe hai -zomato, swiggi Now I understand why we are lacking behind in technology I totally agree at this point our country people are becoming lazy and unproductive
Aisa nhi hai ki china me ye sab nhi hai par tum dekh lo ki inn companies ke wajah se kitne logo ko employment milti hai, kahi pe change ki jarurat hai to wo logo ka mindset change hona chahiye
Kejriwal always talks about the need of Manufacturing sector boost, but our beloved Modi thinks, lets build (manufacture) another issue around temples or mosques and create divide in the society Lets hope we get a PM like Kejriwal in 2024
@@rushikeshmorye80 PLI scheme, labour law reform, export policy changes, RODTEP, Logistic infrastructure focus, trade facilitation reform, FTA negotiations, digitisation of processes, cut in manufacturing corporate taxes. Modi govt has done more than Kejriwal could ever do and more than Congress has ever done... Even China took 15 years to build up Manufacturing infrastructure and policy set-up. I challenge you to prove me wrong...
@sigma male mindset 0001 Infrastructure=Economy. If the govt upgrades infrastructure, then the economy will automatically do well after a while. I genuinely believe that within 2-3 years, India's economy will undergo a huge structural shift into manufacturing and exports and witness unprecedented growth (as long as the govt doesn't screw it up)...
Manufacturing is not halwa to made in one day it is long time process required atleast 25 years. Did we have skills for manufacturing sectors ? No... It required a whole generation to get skilled... And kejru have delhi he can make delhi a manufacturing hub... But he had made it worse. Example he had increase electricity charges for manufacturing sector to fullfill a brainless scheme to make it free for people... You are antiindia not a sensible indian to made india better... You are political stooge
Xi pings rival Jeing Zamin and Other CCP rivals has many shares in Ali baba , tancent and many big companies who support Jeing Zamin. So he want to restrict their power this is actually main reason for this crack down.
Why isnt government thinking about "Why these parents are reaching out for these online education companies ??" It is because of the Gov's GAOKO exam. It is a crazy exam like JEE+NEET+few more exams combined. Instead of reforming the exam their are shutting down the online companies. This is not going to change the fact that parents will seek out tutors. Now only the rich will be able to pay for private tutors.
@@Tanmay_Bhattacharya this is what Delhi government is doing but everyone is scolding them even youth. They are running in profit but still people are scolding. Such brainwashed and educated ( for namesake but waste no thinking ability and in depth analysis.) youth we have in India. Sorry for harsh words. To watch my other comments in this comment section. You will understand aam aadmi party economics. They have studied all developed countries polices and implementing in India. See it not because they are developed they can implement those policies, it is because of those policies they developed. 😎
@@PK-tt5kk sir in ancient India education, health and food was free to everyone. That is why ancient India was 25% of world gdp. Temples were also used as banks where kings donated money and this was used to be given to needy. That is why always remember in ancient India people who donated were considered greatest than rich people or kings or everyone in the society for example dhanveer karna in Mahabharata. (dhanveer means donor of donors) Sir our ancient people had the wisdom which cannot be explained in words but we lost it. We should study those texts again in right sense and manner and increase our wisdom. Simply west did not want to search India for Centuries and India had immense influence in east whichever place there would be Buddha or some other person. who was from India. Land of Indus valley was changed to india. Simply we did not make arthashashtra by chanakya and it was kept in highest security possible and even anyone tried to take it other than the people who can access there were awesome traps which will kill other people. And when invaders came here they copied this idea and went and implemented it properly. See if we had world' s first university and many education related things obviously most of them were copied by those people. (It was considered greatest achievement in rest of world to get educated in India. We do not know our glory and it is kept secret so that corrupt people can run government and our work will be hidden ORELSE it will make our people wise and then their time will end) And now we are copying our own idea and we think they came up with this. 😂 This is ultimate truth. Hope we understand the importance of this. sir we need more good quality of colleges not entrance exams to Crack and get into colleges . Or just good content made just one time and given to every student which they can learn from. Here students role is high as he has to learn while in schools and colleges teachers has to make him sit and make him concentrate. That is the difference that's it. That is why people like Elon musk did not study aerospace engineering in formal way but just learn it from good source. Like eklavya not arjuna from mahabharat. And also good teachers to give the quality. But what happens is in India to become teacher you should study B. Ed and other degrees for job. Delhi government has thought people who have passed iit and iim and other institutes who are already most awesome just need some months or 1 year training in teaching institute and given a degree and they can directly go and teach students. They are opening skill university (tied up with companies for developing syllabus and training methods) and teacher university and sports university etc. All these iit and iim is OK but we need many many of them so automatically students who are coming from schools will get into good colleges without too much exam nonsense. And also This is a clever system built by corporates to just have enough supply needed for their jobs etc. If most of the people in India got quality college education then there will be so many people to apply for jobs with so much skill but jobs won't be there. Think 356 million people (youth or working population) in India right now with quality education etc. What will happen to jobs. So we need to increase small scale businesses and msmes as they employ the most and if most of the businesses will compete then product will be spectacular. So it is good trick to make people believe that they are not good enough and competitive to break into colleges. And if we see west countries they do not cutoffs for most of the colleges and just people go and study and then do businesses or startups etc. And lead a nice life.
yesterday BJP bhakt argue with me .. on my tweet that .. even Taliban taking press conference BHAKT. bro so what our modi ji is also great leader in india modi ji is from poor background why there is need of conference when we have man ke baat 😥 ME. i never mention MODI in my tweet it is just . even taliban taking press nothing els why you get triggered .😂😂 BHAKT . why to compare with TALIBAN ???? ME ,. lets compare with USA .NORWAY. SWEEDON . BRITAN 😂😂 he left the chat ...
Entertainment add value to it by entertaining people alluding them out of their pressure of family and other thing also educate them . And yeah liqquir shop do not add any value at all . 🤦🤦🤦🤦🤦🤦 to your low cognitive thinking .
Don't take it Negativity, I am a Software Developer and I know what is the Importance of Security in today's world. China's policies are far better than India's. India should learn from it and need to apply it in India too. Education, Hospital, and Hotel fields should be either controlled or Audit strictly by the government.
I think you meant regulated. Controlling will lead to Govt misusing it's power and strong arming the company when they deem so. We definitely need regulations where in consumers are getting decent value without company relying on unfair practices
@@Sachin.Sheelavant Yeah, You can say it. But my opinion is too much freedom makes our system vulnerable. For example- Traffic Rules. I don't think anyone explanation about it☺☺
i think the Indian model is like saying "i've started writing my notes but i'll jump straight to writing the current class notes even though i have incomplete in the middle so that i can be on par with what our teacher is saying"
Power of One party/ autocracy . No protests , no dissent ,no fear of continuous change of policies . A largely homogeneous population helps in the acceptance of the ideology as well .
@@Lee-kf5jq Who said there are no religion in China ? They follow folk religion in most places somewhat on the lines of shintoism in Japan and animal/nature/ancestor worship in many parts of the world . There are lot of Buddhists and Christians as well but they are not given undue freedom like in India under law ( article 25-30) . Thys how they keep the state and church (religion) seperate. Those who try to dissent or go against it are given Xinjiang like treatment .
@@Lee-kf5jq Not India but the 6 decade long CONg at centre was not interested in developing NE . I have lot of friends from NE . The neglect was mostly during their tenure .
@@madtitanoboa462 Education is a public good and should be publicly funded in a manner that its access is not correlated to you income levels. Private coaching is highly exclusionary and creates a vicious cycle where poor continue to not have access as public goods are privatized and in this form poor are not seen as a profitable market segment. In your world Education to poor is always in shortage
Private online coachings like unacademy are doing it all : 1)Cheap price pe kota/hyderabad level coaching 2)even teachers getting more than enough salary
Don't know why useless game streaming channels are hyped in India at the same time useful contents like this is blatantly ignored. *Can you do an analysis on this Mohak Bhai?*
@@zsar_official see people discriminate against weak and once they become strong then things become equal or better. Chinese government is nothing more than representative of Chinese people and they want to develop their economy and be strong and dominate others because they suffered a lot after invasions so they have learnt the lessons. But these lessons are still not the best lessons. They are even trying to dominate India which was its closest friends for thousands of years because that India and China and today's India and China is way different. Before India had 25 or 30% gdp of world while China had 24% something. So we were very close in gdp and thoughts and way of life like Buddhism etc. And many things before it. East was spiritual and wanted to spread their work and thoughts indirectly by having the best thoughts and wisdom and people using it. People were tolerant and non violent and practiced meditation and did practices to reach ultimate truth and source of creation etc and warriors were ultimate in their job as they were best and lived like.. Only thing is we had internal conflicts after sometime and this was the main reason. Nothing else and west were brutal civilization destroyers who went to other civilizations and destroyed them and considered the very act as great. Complete looting and doing animalistic ( when I say this that means compulsive) things with other people like trading people etc. Even now Chinese people consider west as barbarians who know to use some tools (which became more advanced and deadly) while here it was humans who were made awesome in every aspect. This was the fundamental difference. And if this thought of east would have spread to west then today the world would be different and because west came here destroyed our thoughts and civilization then their way of living spread elsewhere. Now after they got the loot and got comfortable life so automatically other things which used to happen reduced but still is very much there.
He didn't cover main reason Xi pings rival Jeing Zamin and Other CCP rivals has many shares in Ali baba , tancent and many big companies who support Jeing Zamin. So he want to restrict their power this is actually main reason for this crack down.
@@infinityxtanishq8712 India has one of the slowest 4g speeds in the world, that's why it's so cheap, while China has top 3 fastest and they also switching to 5g with more users than rest of the world combined.
@@kapildeshmukh7878 Uncle, social media is engineered to psychologically hack you and get you to return every few mins Being dimwit is not realising this fact and making the usual statement of "this generation is not disciplined".
I am a mechanical engineering student and presently I see that most of my friends want to get a job in technology and software domain. The reason is less about interest and more about money. The point is we should not neglect much the manufacturing and agriculture industries in our country. The Government should revise their engineering courses and make it up to date so that children take interest in the core fields. Because if all move to the tech and software industry then no one will be left in manufacturing sectors and we have to be dependent on other countries.
People pay money for the value they get or what a company can extract them from. The amount of jobs available in mechanical sector is not enough. Tech has nothing to do with it. With automation the amount of manual jobs will reduce even further. Only r&d kind of jobs/tech jobs will exist. Market determines what job will exist. Tech worker can work from anywhere hence the global demand. Imagine if most of the tech sector vanished do engineer from other branch have any back up ? Then reduce the number of colleges so on. Till economy has shrunk so much that everyone is jobless.
@@dibyanshumishra3536 With due respect Sir, I am never trying to say that due to tech and software jobs core jobs are decreasing. I am saying about the decease of interest for these types of jobs in students. Those who are interested can go for the tech jobs no problem. But those who want core jobs are also not able to know about the resources they need to enter the manufacturing industry. And with due respect sir, jobs have decreased but are there. The food you are eating now was grown by an farmer in his/her agricultural field and he/she used fertilisers. The fertilisers are made using various components of chemical, electrical and mechanical engineering. Sir, the problem is that for those jobs that the students are applying they have very less skills to work on it. So, we need an updated curriculum so that students once again start taking interest in this field. As they say a nation's might is seen when all the three sectors software and tech, manufacturing and agriculture are developed.
@@shuvenduswain2612 i agree that other sectors need boost but if there is not enough money no good talent will follow that path. Imagine would you like to earn 12-20lpa after 7yr of experience or 1crore+. Having more university gives second chance to people who were not good at physics maths etc but can be great at their line of work. I am not saying manufacturing is not needed heck its even essential. Rather its important but some people are fit for one type of job while others are suited for other types. One sector having more money doesn't mean other sector is losing out money. Its not like government is funding those tech sector. Its the companies and employees who need to be innovative to get more money to attract better talent.
About what you said the resources needed to enter manufacturing are not available in india because most of the jobs in such sector is outside india like Germany. E.g. biotech engineer barely has any good opportunities in india but in US/developed nations they can do great research. What i am saying is india is very bad market to enter any domain apart from software in the current job scenario. (Not my word but based on the salaries ).
@@knowledgeBoosterkb123 He is trying to do good but with communism and without much freedom. Modi and Rahul you may consider anyone but they also want but with a heavy politics. Xi jinping's policies are good and india should learn from him. Whatever might happen but communism and and single party system should not come here anymore. Remember the word FREEDOM
Arvind Kejriwal always talks about the need of Manufacturing sector boost, but our beloved Modi thinks, lets build (manufacture) another issue around temples or mosques and create divide in the society Lets hope we get a PM like Kejriwal in 2024
Bruh!! Critical policies nad decisions doesn't make the leaders so called "Nationalist" and "visionary" and whatever nonsense. U gotta understand that. Critical Decisions can be terribly wrong too, and i m feeling so for china
This is incredible, definitely its not what it seems - you should always look the things in a different perspective as well to completely understand why certain things are happening. Kudos to you!!
he has been there just for few years we don't know if his economic policies will be successful or not you can say xiaoping was a visionary , at last kal kisne dekha hai....
I wish Modi turns a dictator like him with one party system under BJP. This is the only party dedicated to capitalism and beating the dead horse of socialism.
Most important part of this video was Countries who focus on 'nice to have' won't develop in long term where as Countries who focus on 'need to have' would always have an edge in the future.
Will u let anyone criticise your parents? Development is important protecting culture and standing for themselves is important too otherwise you will genocides and massacres like 1921,1947,1999 remember your past otherwise you will have no future.
@@aldenfarias4873 we villagers are better than you. You people's get more facilities than us but we never complaint and abuse our motherland first of all changes yourself because our leaders also came out from between us
India unfortunately failed to bring the manufacturing business from China to India. Most companies shifted to Vietnam, Taiwan and Japan. By shifted I mean from China to the three countries.
Its mostly vietnam not Japan, and there is a trick china used to bypass US tariffs they built a product 90% completion in china and exported to vietnam and then finished rest 10% in Vietnam, put made in veitnam tag and exported to US bypassing tariffs. And also integrating veitnam with China even further.
Absolutely great video, with some amazing insights!!! As a teenager makes me think more critically of what path I must tread on in the future!!! This is the kind of content we need, keep up the good work!
If you want think critically or want to understand things critically please read historical dialectical materialism written by Karl Marx then you will understand everything very wisely.. thank you
India has started focusing in manufacturing through Make in india program and now become the world's 2nd most attractive destination for manufacturing beating USA. Hope so it does well and we progress as a nation not only in primary and tertiary sector but also in secondary.
But it is actually more individual level. There is no proper ecosystem incorporating people, companies and government and other small businesses. I hope this unorganised nature changes in India.
Having read first two chapters of the book by Yuval Noah Harari, "21 problems of 21st century", and after watching this video on crackdown on internet companies I think it is safe to say what Xi did for China's economy in the coming future is visionary step. Because you don't want unemployment to rise so high that they become burden on their own economy.
Actually there should be some bar on the profit of private educational institutions and also pvt health care systems. Secondly, i agree that boosting service sector has become priority in India, its advantage is that it provides crores of jobs..but simultaneously India shd focus on manufacturing sector without hampering already boosted service sector.
They are actually doing the right thing. I always wondered about this that how long this can go on that people will constantly earn money through gaming, entertainment and advertisement, someday the bubble will burst and we will have a big chunk of incompetent population. The population is constantly rising and our planet has limited resources, if more and more people go away from innovation and join easy ways of making money it will prove to be disastrous. Directing more and more people to higer education and manufacturing is the need of the hour.
Yeah I agree with the point but in telecom and service sector there is also a future In service sector people can have employment and it is not like that ki people who are in service sector cannot do innovation or they're wasting their time but people can grow in both way if wants to have sector is useless or they're not helping with the development of society if that was in that way then america and many western country could have crash but the thing is each way you go their is always a bright future either it is on industry or technology
But the thing is the government of every country should focus on both sector the games are not completely waste of the time if people are smart then they could build the careers on both sector so just my honest opinion
this exposes one of the shortfalls of democracy. Here, we can't focus on long term goals like these coz politicans are judged on the basis of 5-year performance and these moves will likely create huge short term pain. But will take these shortfalls anyday over authoritarian regimes.
Authoritarianism is no good! USSR & North Korea are big examples. Dictators run authoritarian regimes however China is run by engineers, businessmen and traders who practically understand economy. Where as politicians run democracy and eventually turn a beautiful republic into oligarchy. India is run by academic economist who have no real-time knowledge of economy and politicians who have tremendous empathy with poor and helpless Indians.
Well leaders are judged by 5-yrs performance but what about the other elections that leader has to fight between those 5yr? even thought about that? Truth is leaders are judged based on the performance between state elections and not general elections. Democracy naturally promotes socialism bcoz the 1st priority in democracy is votes which free electricity, water can easily give.
So right. I notice all around Internet companies rising and it can be seen in households of every people. Yes, obviously it is good for the company and country's economy but...as we can see Internet for the most part is distracting the MOST IMPORTANT ASSET OF INDIA... THE YOUTH. If the Youth is distracted in 2021, then by 2030 India will only have a rising PHARMA sector with people visiting Psychologists, Doctors, Orhtopedics and Popping in Pills.
The problem is u consider internet to be a distraction, i consider it be to an innovation. Not all people in a country are interested in building aircraft carriers, some are interested in building techs that provide better facilities to citizens.
@Zack Smith Mao ruled with brute force and hence the people at that time didn't dare to say anything against him. Xiaoping brought some good changes which helped the people to actually earn money and own property and the people started liking him. even Xiaoping wasn't all clean. he killed 10 thousand students in Tianamen square in 1989.
@@D__Ujjwal Not neccessary we need to emulate or copy china. we could have our own form of governance. Like Single party rule with freedom of speech allowed. you might say it's not possible but we could invent our own form of governance that other countries might like. Democracy has proved to be a double edged sword for a lot of countries including us. Policy paralysis, state elections, idiotic schemes such as free water and electricity (which ultimately lead to everything being given for free free, which would turn us into venezuella)
In my opinion china's idea to improve need to have technology is mind blowing because we cant use nice to have technology without need to have technology
I am stunned by xi jinping vision and the division of need to have and nice to have companies , but india focus on internet companies . Our start-up still lack of innovation it's more like copy cat . We strongly need innovation and R &D .
@Yash Dakhare ya china bhi krta h but unka manufacturing industry bhi deko hmlog sirf internet company ka baat kr rhe h look at chinese manufacturing company , china having world class manufacturing unit aur india doesn't have any good manufacturing mobile company
Some peeps are praising Xi-Ping and his decision (even to some extent praising authoritarianism) If some gov and politician will do same thing here in India,these peeps will cry over here and still hue over here that the govt has turned authoritarian You can praise xi and his descion but if you are praising his authoritarianism and autocractic system - These are big double standards I belive
@10m30 I don't divide indians low educated people into ideological and political category as westerners use . Indians are not left , indian are not right , indians are not liberals . They are just ignorant and less educated socially .
we are not praising Xi-Ping's authoritarian policies but need to focus on manufacturing is need of the hour.The civil engineers from IITs are opting for software jobs.Over reliance on one sector will lead to disaster.
This video make me think about China's communist party from a different angle. There are very bad things about ccp but i think the good things are, they prioritize nation above religion,cast, power.
Whole new dimension to think ! Thank you. I feel tech companies are over valued in India, they are exploiting employees with long hours and there is no regulations.
I hope you had the experience in working in one of them to give that opinion. Because I am working in a technology company. And my experience has been pretty good.
@@rishabhupadhyay9575 I myself work in a Tech company and post pandemic all of my friends in Tech are logging long hours. Not sure which part of the Tech you are on !
Very informative video mohak!!!!!!!! Now i understand that India needs to make a balance between its manufacturing and service companies!!!!!because without the balance we can not stabilise our economy for a long period!!!!
@@don-ow7sw No... Democracy is good only when it is localized like Switzerland. Democracy in country like India should be different because we are not same, we are group of people united in a sub continent and everybody thinks differently here not like china which country of one race ethnic *Han*
Tech companies only create monopoly, and monopoly dose not help to boost the economy, china's policies are future prove and as every time India is the second mover. Indian government I think doing nothing to break the monopolies in our country.
I thinking if this system carried on one day will come when whole of the world will work for 10-15 companies and governments will be there secretaries. Every one will work for them to get the salary by them and spend it on them😥😓
Few months ago china celebrated the creation of ball pen nip Yes in 2021 they have developed a nip on their own. So imagine the complexity attached to jet engines, turbines, semi conductor etc. This big the high scale manufacturing is
to most of the people here, banning and censorship is never good for any given country, it all looks good on paper but reality is often different. Here the crackdown was rather to show the political influence CCP has. Service sector is important, this video was bit biased although he himself is from that sector. Edit:- also he forgot to mention china has 996 work culture, meaning you work from 9am to 9pm for 6days, (just check the video on vice) people are already frustrated from it and if they ban social media from their life god knows what will happen.
@@JR-vc4gm chinese firms are working around for it, they are hiring people on different contractual basis which is sad, also this is a prospective rule.
I too was thinking about this some time ago, how india's manufacturing sector lags behind the service sector, i think if this continues it's going to be a huge problem because our dependence on countries like korea and japan is growing exponentially
I support what they did with tutions. If a student opts for private tuition, it means the school is not doing its work properly.
you are fucking right
But you don't get to properly learn a topic more than once without tutions. If there won't be online tutions then how will knowledgable tutors who don't want to teach in schools spread their knowledge in the way they teach(which may be awesome)?
man nowadays you can easily learn anything on youtube
@@physicsbiology9756 A knowledgeable person can write books, blogs or even do UA-cam videos... Schools are collecting fees to teach.
@@sheeshh5275 I know but
many people view it as a "Nice to have" technology not "Need to Have" and you know the reason why.
Crackdown on tutoring companies is a good move. Privatisation/Corporatization of education promotes inequity.
Why isnt the chinese government thinking about "Why these parents are reaching out for these online education companies ??"
It is because of the Gov's GAOKO exam. It is a crazy exam like JEE+NEET+few more exams combined.
Instead of reforming the exam and their education system, they are shutting down the online companies.
This is not going to change the fact that parents will still seek out tutors. Now only the rich will be able to pay for private tutors.
Inequity already exists in the Indian education system , it’s called reservation
@@infinityxtanishq8712 Look reservation is not the best way to tackle the problem but the simple fact still remains that most of the poor in our country are SC/ST's & OBC's
I had also apposed the reservation system but when u look at the data they are most of the poor.
I am not saying its a good solution, i would rather have the gov. try to improve their education, health & food infra of these communities than give just reservations. not to mention it is just used as a political tool.
@@infinityxtanishq8712 reservation is not inequity, it exists in the first place to bridge inequity.
Promotes inequity while degrading the overall educational experience of millions of bright students.
"Jo smart bachhe vese semiconductor manufacturing me kaam kar rahe hote vo ab ad optimisation me kaam kar rahe hai"- i felt that!! Everyone is going into it sector, even those who did engineering in interesting fields like material science or nano technology. India really need to up its game in high end manufacturing and biochemistry related industries. Ee have the capability to do so.... If only our government understands its importance.
I love how so many people in this comment section are praising Xi Jingping's Model despite bashing the Indian Education system for not letting them follow their passion.
exactly 🤦
True @physics biology
Ur use of 'despite' in the statement turning the meaning i should get out of ur statement upside down 😬
Yah people love xi
Xi pings Education model is stupid
Children living in rich areas will have better school education and poor areas students won't
This will bring Huge Opportunity gap.
Xi ping is doing so because he wants more people in Non technical work force
Whoo... Got goosebumps after knowing how critically they think
Except India every country thinks the same way.
Noone is as lazy and as primate like us
2:30 that parallel news reporting transition is some *Johnny Harris* level editing bru....Sick!! 🔥
Vox
That similarity is impeccable
This video give me a completely different way to rethink Chinese economic policy... Thank you Mohak.
Its easy to appreciate from 5 dollar a month internet, sitting on a sofa.
Do you on personal level have followed all traffic rules, planted a single tree or stop using unnecessary vehicles?
If the answer is no then no gouvernement can help you
It's a huge mistake for a country of India's size and economic situation to ignore the manufacturing sector and focus only on service sector. As explained her, most of the service sector products are only nice to have and the over-indulgence of these products is what's causing a huge brain-drain here. We need to be self sufficient in manufacturing, otherwise we'll always remain in this same condition. More people pushed into poverty and income-gap increasing and increasing....
Also service sector mostly gives jod to educated which leaves poor as poor
Most manufacturing are automated. Its not job producing sector. There is no need to be self sufficient in manufacturing. This thought is dictatorial and has given us leaders like hitler, musuloni and xi jinping. I dont want india to follow in same way. Let private sector drive innovation as and when necessary. No need for government to micromanage and pick and choose winners and loosers.
@@cyclopes968 there is need for self sufficiency because we export raw material cheaply and export manufactured goods in more value India is not ahead in internet and most manufacturing
We did not focus on the service sector it just happened, mainly cos it was the only area which had no regulations and because Nehru had the foresight to build IITs and hence at least had some educated people in the country who started to work in the only area which they saw future growth cos no regulation.
Yeah I put Nehru in this just to piss off the bhakts
@@aryaaswale7316 didn't Rajiv Gandhi started IIT and I think he is one of the reason for it sector to grow in India
Qualities of a true visionary leader. India needs to learn from its equally populated and large neighbouring country like China instead of slandering, trolling people who provide constructive criticism, shutting them by claiming to be better than the likes of Pakistan and Afghanistan.
Yeah..... but china also blocks people even more severly who provides constructive critizism
India is better than Pakistan and Afghanistan is not more than a joke.
You can criticise CCP for being authoritarian, but the way they have uplifted China is commendable
make india autocratic you will get the same thing 😂
huh, do you know then ground reality of china, watch videos of laowhy86 and serpentza (ex expats in china) you will be shocked to know the truth
@@riav.T jruri nhi h
@@riav.T it's impossible to make India autocratic
Another reason is shareholder capitalism china liberalised its market around 15 years before than india and 15 years ago china gdp was 2.5 trillion dollars approx.but very less care is about climate change which might sink all the economic progress every country have made.
Tiktok is a perfect example how youth of a country can be distracted. But still there are similar apps existing in India which need to be banned immediately. Same is with the Coaching Institutes, the reason we need coaching institute in itself reflect the failure of our education system. Even passout engineers need coding coaching so that they can get a job. Xi is truly seeing the future.
Reels is there instead of tiktok
@@619ry7 there are many similar apps too which r following the same thing which tiktok did.
so what ban coaching institutes?
@@madtitanoboa462 make them non profitable. They shouldn't work like companies whose sole aim is to create profits.
@@ramji_ki_katha moj & mxtakatak are 🤮
I see they’ve got a valid point. With the advancement of manufacturing sector they can make other countries rely on them and it can help to build nations growth in many ways where as India is completely focusing on technology that is solely targeting Indian consumers and finding ways to make them more lazy and it’s not a positive growth. Can’t deny China is always ahead in building nation.
These guys thinking of 2050s
Mahnnn these guys gave our Indian youth pubg and now they are cracking down thier own online gaming industry
@@believer0001 true and now China introduced new gaming laws for minors saying they can only play for 3hours a week which is Friday, Saturday and Sunday
Chinae me jake rah lo.
Innovation isn't just about thinking deeply into a picture, it's about thinking beyond picture
With the ban on several other fields and shutting up the critics will actually have negative effects
P.S. what Chinese are doing is equivalent to demonetization to recover black money 😂😂
Stop admiring dictatorship!
As an electronics graduate watching all my friends go for either software development (computer science) or competitive exams for govt jobs instead of seeking to work for core electronics companies and the fall of local smartphone manufacturing companies like micromax etc since 2013, i can easily say that India sucks in the manufacturing sector, especially semiconductor chips
lol Micromax was never a smartphone manufacturing company, all they did was importing cheap Chinese mobiles and rebranding them. That's why they failed after 2014
hopefully after the new vedanta foxconn semiconductor plant, others will follow suit
they are absolutely correct , just look in Indian all engineers join software companies even if they were from electronics or some other branch
If there were no software sector those engineers would have been jobless. Better to have a job right or am i missing something?
Its because no jobs in hardware!
@@dibyanshumishra3536 correct
@Leftist's Antidote are o pagal, CCP nahi banna hai
@@dibyanshumishra3536 Yes bro but all of them are Service sector it's ok for now but we need to move to Manufacture sector our Indian talents are working under western companies and fleeing to other countries we need to create our own FB, UA-cam like Tech sector in India
it's not called "destroying" but rather "regulating" to make the industry more stable.
7:33 That's 100% correct. Even my sister who was good at maths started learning SEO a few years ago thinking it's a promising sector.
There is no future in SEO
@@unrealsamurai2023 as if there's anything in engineering. Most people can't find employment despite being engineers
Can you tell me what that is
@@unrealsamurai2023 why bro, can u explain a little bit
@@manthan6434 abe search engine optimization 🤣🤣
It actually makes more sense. Damn. This is some next level thinking.
This was very informative!
Chinese thinking indeed sounds very logical.
China has a very good understanding of power. Some of these companies were getting very big. They know that periodic destruction is also required for more creation. We are seeing what monopolisation of power in tech companies can do in places like the USA.
Not only tech but also finanace coporate like vanguard, blackrock, blackstone
@@RealCherry8085 you're a very smart bot
Chinese government is big monopoly in itself.
You are wrong Top companies in china are state monopolies. This is indeed monopoly by CCP itself regulating Price as they wish
@@RealCherry8085 these three companies are asset management companies and are not owned by a single person or a small group of people, literally hundreds of thousands of people own it through mutual funds the people in charge for managing the company(CEO,CFO,Executive chairman) can't just do anything as they want, it could lead them into trouble because it not their money it's the public money, like in India there is UTI, SBI, also to some extent LIC, LIC is a insurance company but even LIC has a lot of assets. I included LIC because even today people in India preffer insurance over mutual funds.
India is simply focusing on service sector because it's profitable in short term and EASY for Mass people in India! But we fail to understand that Easy is always harmful in long term‼️Dk when our leaders will realise importance of focusing on other sectors too
Edit :For all of those who are saying I don't know anything and service sector should be priority and govt is doing great are so pathetic that they fail to understand we are F*ing 1.3 billion people going to be 1.5B not like developed nations with millions Focusing on service sector which needs less manpower day by day Due to AI!! It is anyday better than accepting reality that we are poor nation and work to improve it, rather than Glorifying politcal parties (BjP or congress both) for the nation where healthcare ,education (which are most imp thing) are only available for Only cream layer of society!Jai hind🇮🇳
Japan survived in this service trap but for highly populated countries like India ,its not possible :(
The IT sector might take a massive rock bottom hit... But it will boom the other sectors massively which is good actually
Thanks to protectionist policies
r u kiding me bro do some research now gov focused on manufacturing sector. u can see so many schems India became 2nd largest phone manuacturing and many more. do some research everything doesnt come overnight India is doing great. something is better than nothing
Manufacturing infra nahi haa investment Ane se isiliye darte ha. Privatisation is just a flop management ko Sahi Karna chaiye apne itna slow haa. Our govt doesn't realise anything they are all about selling the country.
I've heard several discussions on this topic but never heard this perspective before. Amazing video and really happy that Mohak is bringing out quality content more frequently these days
India's jump from agriculture to tertiary sector can be clearly seen in the education sector also students are much more interested in cs/it branches than core branches.
India needs to maintain a balance between manufacturing & public sector ,if they not do so in future when there would be a huge need of manufacturing sector there would be a lack of skilled employees.
it's a cycle where manufacturing sector isn't picking up due to which core branches aren't paying well and vice versa.
Also, Inidan IT professionals are relatively cheap labour for the global market. Indian as well as foreign companies are making the best use of this skewed cost of labour.
Student's interest point is baseless 😅
I myself took *Computer Science* because CS & IT department have best placement. To achhi job to chahiye na bhai🙂
@@just_a_curious_thinker true
@Gourab yes we need more car companies or machine manufacturing companies and robotics
The thing they did with educational institutions was actually right as most of them are fraud, such things are necessary in India too. If this is implemented in India, the problem of shortage of teachers can be solved too.
@ Mukta Singodia Use your brain, these are private companies. If there are no profits, they will not stay in the market for long term and move away. This idiotic socialist mindset has destroyed our country. We are not a authoritarian country like China. These private players will simply move to another sector.
@@shrinivasj610 authoritarian and socialistic values are not necessarily same or go together. I agree we need profitable private players but if you take edtech space rn in India for example, companies like BYJUs are solely living off marketing and sales targets for their employee, which is leading to toxic work culture as well as gullible parents getting these expensive tuitions for their kids thinking it's the best while they're mediocre at best. This is also harmful for the consumers, employees and industry as a whole.
@@Sachin.Sheelavant you can have strong labor laws like France to fix that issue but the Indian Union can't afford to do what the Chinese has done. We are not an industrialised nation. We have very few industries. Almost 50 percentage of our population works in agriculture.
I think schools don't get good teachers as they are very rigid, If I had a choice I would leave school and join a coaching as it is better than schools, school teachers are just people who couldn't get anything so became teachers
@@shrinivasj610 that's not my point here dear, the thing is many good teachers are in these institutions, many good schools teachers too leave (private) schools for joining such institutions.
And there is really a shortage of teachers in India
And actually my motive (which I actually didn't write) was to say that why isn't school enough, why is there even a need of these institutions, schools should be made good enough, and as there are few really good and experienced teachers in these institutions, they can improve the quality of teaching.
Not to mention, these institutions cost more than schools.
That's what I am keep saying about Byjus's and such apps. These apps and mentality to support such technology could be a cancer for the coming generations.
What's wrong with Byju's?
@@strawmanfallacy8666 everything
@@shauryasharma3757 umm what exactly
This videos going to change the mindset of millions of people of India. Thanks buddy for splendid information.
Never, Anshuman..
Games khel rahe -pubg, freefire ,call of duty, among us
Grocery and goods online manga rahe hai -bigbasket, amazon, paytm mall, reliance mart
Food ghar baithe manga rahe hai -zomato, swiggi
Now I understand why we are lacking behind in technology I totally agree at this point our country people are becoming lazy and unproductive
Aisa nhi hai ki china me ye sab nhi hai par tum dekh lo ki inn companies ke wajah se kitne logo ko employment milti hai, kahi pe change ki jarurat hai to wo logo ka mindset change hona chahiye
@@thenoobdashow7428 lekin ye comapany kahi logo ka dhandha bhi band karti hai
Lol to ye sab companies technology se hi banai, aag me tel dalne se nahi bani
@@263yashkhandagale5 upgrade nahi karoge to fail hi hoge
Simple hai
@@263yashkhandagale5 in compny time ke sath imrove karti hai naki dukan kholke pan masala thukhti hai
Kejriwal always talks about the need of Manufacturing sector boost,
but our beloved Modi thinks, lets build (manufacture) another issue around temples or mosques and create divide in the society
Lets hope we get a PM like Kejriwal in 2024
LoL he told about make in India
@@pankajanagaraj673 Make in India are failure
@@rushikeshmorye80 PLI scheme, labour law reform, export policy changes, RODTEP, Logistic infrastructure focus, trade facilitation reform, FTA negotiations, digitisation of processes, cut in manufacturing corporate taxes. Modi govt has done more than Kejriwal could ever do and more than Congress has ever done... Even China took 15 years to build up Manufacturing infrastructure and policy set-up. I challenge you to prove me wrong...
@sigma male mindset 0001 Infrastructure=Economy. If the govt upgrades infrastructure, then the economy will automatically do well after a while. I genuinely believe that within 2-3 years, India's economy will undergo a huge structural shift into manufacturing and exports and witness unprecedented growth (as long as the govt doesn't screw it up)...
Manufacturing is not halwa to made in one day it is long time process required atleast 25 years. Did we have skills for manufacturing sectors ? No... It required a whole generation to get skilled... And kejru have delhi he can make delhi a manufacturing hub... But he had made it worse.
Example he had increase electricity charges for manufacturing sector to fullfill a brainless scheme to make it free for people... You are antiindia not a sensible indian to made india better... You are political stooge
Your videos are so informative and thus open new doors in my mind.
Xi pings rival Jeing Zamin and Other CCP rivals has many shares in Ali baba , tancent and many big companies who support Jeing Zamin. So he want to restrict their power this is actually main reason for this crack down.
Watch china uncensored channel to know real reasons for this crack down.
India is proud to have UA-cam content creator like you
Man that education thing also needs to happen in India.
Why isnt government thinking about "Why these parents are reaching out for these online education companies ??"
It is because of the Gov's GAOKO exam. It is a crazy exam like JEE+NEET+few more exams combined.
Instead of reforming the exam their are shutting down the online companies.
This is not going to change the fact that parents will seek out tutors. Now only the rich will be able to pay for private tutors.
Yup. Instead of giving edu loans and trapping families as a whole, govt should make education affordable everywhere.
@@Tanmay_Bhattacharya this is what Delhi government is doing but everyone is scolding them even youth. They are running in profit but still people are scolding. Such brainwashed and educated ( for namesake but waste no thinking ability and in depth analysis.) youth we have in India. Sorry for harsh words.
To watch my other comments in this comment section. You will understand aam aadmi party economics. They have studied all developed countries polices and implementing in India. See it not because they are developed they can implement those policies, it is because of those policies they developed. 😎
@@PK-tt5kk sir in ancient India education, health and food was free to everyone. That is why ancient India was 25% of world gdp.
Temples were also used as banks where kings donated money and this was used to be given to needy.
That is why always remember in ancient India people who donated were considered greatest than rich people or kings or everyone in the society
for example dhanveer karna in Mahabharata.
(dhanveer means donor of donors)
Sir our ancient people had the wisdom which cannot be explained in words but we lost it. We should study those texts again in right sense and manner and increase our wisdom.
Simply west did not want to search India for Centuries and India had immense influence in east whichever place there would be Buddha or some other person. who was from India.
Land of Indus valley was changed to india.
Simply we did not make arthashashtra by chanakya and it was kept in highest security possible and even anyone tried to take it other than the people who can access there were awesome traps which will kill other people.
And when invaders came here they copied this idea and went and implemented it properly.
See if we had world' s first university and many education related things obviously most of them were copied by those people.
(It was considered greatest achievement in rest of world to get educated in India.
We do not know our glory and it is kept secret so that corrupt people can run government and our work will be hidden ORELSE it will make our people wise and then their time will end)
And now we are copying our own idea and we think they came up with this. 😂
This is ultimate truth.
Hope we understand the importance of this.
sir we need more good quality of colleges not entrance exams to Crack and get into colleges . Or just good content made just one time and given to every student which they can learn from. Here students role is high as he has to learn while in schools and colleges teachers has to make him sit and make him concentrate. That is the difference that's it.
That is why people like Elon musk did not study aerospace engineering in formal way but just learn it from good source.
Like eklavya not arjuna from mahabharat.
And also good teachers to give the quality.
But what happens is in India to become teacher you should study B. Ed and other degrees for job.
Delhi government has thought people who have passed iit and iim and other institutes who are already most awesome just need some months or 1 year training in teaching institute and given a degree and they can directly go and teach students.
They are opening skill university (tied up with companies for developing syllabus and training methods)
and teacher university and sports university etc.
All these iit and iim is OK but we need many many of them so automatically students who are coming from schools will get into good colleges without too much exam nonsense.
And also
This is a clever system built by corporates to just have enough supply needed for their jobs etc.
If most of the people in India got quality college education then there will be so many people to apply for jobs with so much skill but jobs won't be there. Think 356 million people (youth or working population) in India right now with quality education etc. What will happen to jobs. So we need to increase small scale businesses and msmes as they employ the most and if most of the businesses will compete then product will be spectacular.
So it is good trick to make people believe that they are not good enough and competitive to break into colleges.
And if we see west countries they do not cutoffs for most of the colleges and just people go and study and then do businesses or startups etc. And lead a nice life.
The research you do is amazing
That's what's his profession is you idiot
He's a Economist
@@deepakk1347 He just appreciated his video and you are just being an dummer
The same topic is already made by study iq
yesterday BJP bhakt argue with me .. on my tweet that .. even Taliban taking press conference
BHAKT. bro so what our modi ji is also great leader in india modi ji is from poor background
why there is need of conference when we have man ke baat 😥
ME. i never mention MODI in my tweet it is just . even taliban taking press nothing els
why you get triggered .😂😂
BHAKT . why to compare with TALIBAN ????
ME ,. lets compare with USA .NORWAY. SWEEDON . BRITAN 😂😂
he left the chat ...
@@deepakk1347 to kisi ke kam ki tarif nahi kar sakta kya....
Dimag ki bara mat bajaya karo sunday ke din
When Xi Jinping realises his daughter is using too much phone and not listening to him.
Arre bhai bhai bhai
😂😂😂🤣
Xi has only one children and who is his son not daughter .
@@criticalcommunist5 please someone confirm this. Mere ko jo wikipedia pe woh maine maan liya.
@@criticalcommunist5 joke hai yar vese bhi
Amazing video! Everyone did a great job - From the research to the editing to the art design to presenting. Congratulations to the team!
Kudos to your team for the level of research.
I totally agree with Xi we should also focus on technology which needed to have
No matter how bad China is overall but their vision of future is praise worthy
According to this logic, all liquor shops and entertainment industries should be closed because they do not add value to the society🤦
Entertainment add value to it by entertaining people alluding them out of their pressure of family and other thing also educate them . And yeah liqquir shop do not add any value at all .
🤦🤦🤦🤦🤦🤦 to your low cognitive thinking .
@Leftist's Antidote Idiot !! It's sarcasm
According to this logic, above mentioned industries and shops should not be closed but rather should not be given too much importance. that's all.
Infact it should
Don't take it Negativity, I am a Software Developer and I know what is the Importance of Security in today's world. China's policies are far better than India's. India should learn from it and need to apply it in India too. Education, Hospital, and Hotel fields should be either controlled or Audit strictly by the government.
Agree, China is controlling very well like Media, Politics, IT sector, Hospital, R&D, Caste disputes and all are perfectly managed by the china.
I think you meant regulated. Controlling will lead to Govt misusing it's power and strong arming the company when they deem so. We definitely need regulations where in consumers are getting decent value without company relying on unfair practices
@@Sachin.Sheelavant Yeah, You can say it. But my opinion is too much freedom makes our system vulnerable. For example- Traffic Rules. I don't think anyone explanation about it☺☺
@ That's why India is still a developing country and China is developed. Everyone wants change but no one want to change him/herself.
@ all because of the cpi and CPM 😡
i think the Indian model is like saying "i've started writing my notes but i'll jump straight to writing the current class notes even though i have incomplete in the middle so that i can be on par with what our teacher is saying"
This is what my professor taught me just a week ago.....Didn't understand properly at that time but now I can connect all the dots.
That's why there is a need of taking some strict decisions in our education system...
It is hard to believe that one man can control lives of billions.😳
Power of One party/ autocracy .
No protests , no dissent ,no fear of continuous change of policies .
A largely homogeneous population helps in the acceptance of the ideology as well .
@@rah8985 Most Importantly No Religion ... One Nation vision
@@Lee-kf5jq Who said there are no religion in China ?
They follow folk religion in most places somewhat on the lines of shintoism in Japan and animal/nature/ancestor worship in many parts of the world .
There are lot of Buddhists and Christians as well but they are not given undue freedom like in India under law ( article 25-30) .
Thys how they keep the state and church (religion) seperate.
Those who try to dissent or go against it are given Xinjiang like treatment .
@@rah8985 China mostly follow Atheism ...China has world most athiest people
@@Lee-kf5jq Not India but the 6 decade long CONg at centre was not interested in developing NE .
I have lot of friends from NE . The neglect was mostly during their tenure .
with this to be continues, India shall become that consumer tech market for China. China is literally leading towards an impeccable future.
Hats off to the work
I see each slide you shown need atleast 1 hour research in this video👍
Private tutoring or companies like aakash etc should be regulated, it is one of the few things china has done right
if there is not money in education why would people come to teaching , there will be not good teachers....
@@madtitanoboa462 Do you think quality of education has increased because of these institutes/businesses? Lmao
@@madtitanoboa462 Education is a public good and should be publicly funded in a manner that its access is not correlated to you income levels. Private coaching is highly exclusionary and creates a vicious cycle where poor continue to not have access as public goods are privatized and in this form poor are not seen as a profitable market segment. In your world Education to poor is always in shortage
@@madtitanoboa462 Finland government schools are much better than many well known private institutions .
anything else to say??
Private online coachings like unacademy are doing it all : 1)Cheap price pe kota/hyderabad level coaching 2)even teachers getting more than enough salary
Wow... Literally dhakar knowledge diya apne bhai...dil se selute..
It didn't turn out as I expected, seriously now I get why China's economy is strong.
This has been the most engaging video of yours and truly eye opening.
this video laterally shows why we are ur subscriber..
"Need to have" topic and well explained
Don't know why useless game streaming channels are hyped in India at the same time useful contents like this is blatantly ignored. *Can you do an analysis on this Mohak Bhai?*
True 😁😁😁
Ya...gaming channel behave like they are doing a big thing and millions of subscribers and views... But no significant value to the society...
Actually yesterday I was researching about these things after I heard about some actress getting blacklisted. Hope this clears everything 👍
Mind 💥
Kya?
Interior👀
@@4m0d She meant was Mind blowing
InteriorMaata your channel is 'Nice to have' but not 'Need to have' 😅😆
@@RoKuSa007 couldn't agree more
No matter how much others discriminate against the Chinese but deep down we all know they are extraordinary. 🤔
This video is show's only positives of ban
@@akashbharadwaj02 I would also like to know the negative effects, please share with me.
@@zsar_official search yourself bro
@@zsar_official see people discriminate against weak and once they become strong then things become equal or better.
Chinese government is nothing more than representative of Chinese people and they want to develop their economy and be strong and dominate others because they suffered a lot after invasions so they have learnt the lessons. But these lessons are still not the best lessons.
They are even trying to dominate India which was its closest friends for thousands of years because that India and China and today's India and China is way different. Before India had 25 or 30% gdp of world while China had 24% something. So we were very close in gdp and thoughts and way of life like Buddhism etc. And many things before it.
East was spiritual and wanted to spread their work and thoughts indirectly by having the best thoughts and wisdom and people using it. People were tolerant and non violent and practiced meditation and did practices to reach ultimate truth and source of creation etc and warriors were ultimate in their job as they were best and lived like..
Only thing is we had internal conflicts after sometime and this was the main reason. Nothing else
and west were brutal civilization destroyers who went to other civilizations and destroyed them and considered the very act as great. Complete looting and doing animalistic ( when I say this that means compulsive) things with other people like trading people etc.
Even now Chinese people consider west as barbarians who know to use some tools (which became more advanced and deadly) while here it was humans who were made awesome in every aspect.
This was the fundamental difference.
And if this thought of east would have spread to west then today the world would be different and because west came here destroyed our thoughts and civilization then their way of living spread elsewhere.
Now after they got the loot and got comfortable life so automatically other things which used to happen reduced but still is very much there.
Very informative. Got new perspective on economy and politics.
This video actually educated me on many things i never thought of before…. Kudos to Mohak
Everything is not that what it seems first but the things need to be analysed before judging.
Mohak taught me this lesson.
Thanks Man🙏🙏🙏🙏
Half of the decision needed to be implemented before analysis. I mean proper analysis.
He didn't cover main reason
Xi pings rival Jeing Zamin and Other CCP rivals has many shares in Ali baba , tancent and many big companies who support Jeing Zamin. So he want to restrict their power this is actually main reason for this crack down.
All this crack down is done only to limit CCP rivals ties with giant companies
Watch china uncensored to know reality
@@sumeersamarat706 china unsensored is definitely not the place you go to know about china.. its place to confirm your bias against china.
@@sumeersamarat706 china unsensored is definitely not the place you go to know about china.. its place to confirm your bias against china.
This is something our govt. should keep in mind as well. Softech is powerful but not as much as tangible tech.There should be a balance of both.
China does seem to be developing a more meaningful society in this case.
There should be a 'distraction tax' on internet companies
As if it’s gonna stop them from providing internet
India would still have the cheapest internet prices in the world , not gonna make a difference
@@infinityxtanishq8712 India has one of the slowest 4g speeds in the world, that's why it's so cheap, while China has top 3 fastest and they also switching to 5g with more users than rest of the world combined.
Or just like get off UA-cam for like 2 minutes, you dimwit
@@kapildeshmukh7878 Uncle, social media is engineered to psychologically hack you and get you to return every few mins
Being dimwit is not realising this fact and making the usual statement of "this generation is not disciplined".
I am a mechanical engineering student and presently I see that most of my friends want to get a job in technology and software domain. The reason is less about interest and more about money.
The point is we should not neglect much the manufacturing and agriculture industries in our country. The Government should revise their engineering courses and make it up to date so that children take interest in the core fields. Because if all move to the tech and software industry then no one will be left in manufacturing sectors and we have to be dependent on other countries.
People pay money for the value they get or what a company can extract them from. The amount of jobs available in mechanical sector is not enough. Tech has nothing to do with it. With automation the amount of manual jobs will reduce even further. Only r&d kind of jobs/tech jobs will exist. Market determines what job will exist. Tech worker can work from anywhere hence the global demand. Imagine if most of the tech sector vanished do engineer from other branch have any back up ? Then reduce the number of colleges so on. Till economy has shrunk so much that everyone is jobless.
@@dibyanshumishra3536 With due respect Sir, I am never trying to say that due to tech and software jobs core jobs are decreasing. I am saying about the decease of interest for these types of jobs in students. Those who are interested can go for the tech jobs no problem. But those who want core jobs are also not able to know about the resources they need to enter the manufacturing industry.
And with due respect sir, jobs have decreased but are there. The food you are eating now was grown by an farmer in his/her agricultural field and he/she used fertilisers. The fertilisers are made using various components of chemical, electrical and mechanical engineering. Sir, the problem is that for those jobs that the students are applying they have very less skills to work on it. So, we need an updated curriculum so that students once again start taking interest in this field. As they say a nation's might is seen when all the three sectors software and tech, manufacturing and agriculture are developed.
@@dibyanshumishra3536 Yes and I agree with you Sir about decreasing of universities.
@@shuvenduswain2612 i agree that other sectors need boost but if there is not enough money no good talent will follow that path. Imagine would you like to earn 12-20lpa after 7yr of experience or 1crore+. Having more university gives second chance to people who were not good at physics maths etc but can be great at their line of work. I am not saying manufacturing is not needed heck its even essential. Rather its important but some people are fit for one type of job while others are suited for other types. One sector having more money doesn't mean other sector is losing out money. Its not like government is funding those tech sector. Its the companies and employees who need to be innovative to get more money to attract better talent.
About what you said the resources needed to enter manufacturing are not available in india because most of the jobs in such sector is outside india like Germany. E.g. biotech engineer barely has any good opportunities in india but in US/developed nations they can do great research. What i am saying is india is very bad market to enter any domain apart from software in the current job scenario. (Not my word but based on the salaries ).
Such a mind opening analysis. And definitely zimping is a visionary leader.
xi jinping*
@@knowledgeBoosterkb123 He is trying to do good but with communism and without much freedom. Modi and Rahul you may consider anyone but they also want but with a heavy politics. Xi jinping's policies are good and india should learn from him. Whatever might happen but communism and and single party system should not come here anymore. Remember the word FREEDOM
@@mrsarcasm6885 Eleven Jinping
Anything to remain in power even if it cost lives.
@@asim3351 wt policies are good making humans as robots nope.
Very Good Analysis. I Wish Our Indian Government Think Something Like That.
Whether u hate them, or love them,
In current scenario, China policies are most effective, and their leaders are true nationalist, and visionary
Yes in India we r too linear, plus us is very suspicious,its like the west is slowly having a political and cultural control over many countries
@@thenoobinvestor6930 lol no party in India has intellectual capabilities which can be comparable to china or any developed countries
Guided by the party
Arvind Kejriwal always talks about the need of Manufacturing sector boost,
but our beloved Modi thinks, lets build (manufacture) another issue around temples or mosques and create divide in the society
Lets hope we get a PM like Kejriwal in 2024
Bruh!! Critical policies nad decisions doesn't make the leaders so called "Nationalist" and "visionary" and whatever nonsense. U gotta understand that. Critical Decisions can be terribly wrong too, and i m feeling so for china
1:26 , that would be great i.g . So-called 'coachings' fed on people's insecurities.
This is incredible, definitely its not what it seems - you should always look the things in a different perspective as well to completely understand why certain things are happening. Kudos to you!!
Man Don't get me wrong but I love the Work/business mindset of XI Jinping
Nothing wrong with that
he has been there just for few years we don't know if his economic policies will be successful or not you can say xiaoping was a visionary , at last kal kisne dekha hai....
Winnie the pooh
I wish Modi turns a dictator like him with one party system under BJP. This is the only party dedicated to capitalism and beating the dead horse of socialism.
@@secretscipio that's stupid
Most important part of this video was
Countries who focus on 'nice to have' won't develop in long term where as Countries who focus on 'need to have' would always have an edge in the future.
India with similar population
More youth than China
Is more focussed on religion, history modification, nationalism
India is a useless nation that can’t even stop China building a village in Arunachal Pradesh,.
@@Aven-Sharma1991 how can you say that please explain
Will u let anyone criticise your parents? Development is important protecting culture and standing for themselves is important too otherwise you will genocides and massacres like 1921,1947,1999 remember your past otherwise you will have no future.
Haha, our country can only change names of their cities, stadiums, awards, riots in the name of religion, that's it. :')
@@aldenfarias4873 we villagers are better than you. You people's get more facilities than us but we never complaint and abuse our motherland first of all changes yourself because our leaders also came out from between us
Surprisingly they started criticising 996, but after this explanation it look like a great move
India unfortunately failed to bring the manufacturing business from China to India. Most companies shifted to Vietnam, Taiwan and Japan.
By shifted I mean from China to the three countries.
Japan?
Its mostly vietnam not Japan, and there is a trick china used to bypass US tariffs they built a product 90% completion in china and exported to vietnam and then finished rest 10% in Vietnam, put made in veitnam tag and exported to US bypassing tariffs. And also integrating veitnam with China even further.
This statement is not correct
Japan, taiwan??
They are trying to shift there business from China but can't, so still doing business with China..
Taiwan? Japan?
Absolutely great video, with some amazing insights!!! As a teenager makes me think more critically of what path I must tread on in the future!!! This is the kind of content we need, keep up the good work!
If you want think critically or want to understand things critically please read historical dialectical materialism written by Karl Marx then you will understand everything very wisely.. thank you
An important topic. Discussed with great detail!
India has started focusing in manufacturing through Make in india program and now become the world's 2nd most attractive destination for manufacturing beating USA. Hope so it does well and we progress as a nation not only in primary and tertiary sector but also in secondary.
But it is actually more individual level. There is no proper ecosystem incorporating people, companies and government and other small businesses. I hope this unorganised nature changes in India.
What attractive destination. Countries like Vietnam and Indonesia are doing much better
@@bcp6086 go and see the latest report ...India is 2nd In terms of Manufacturing
@@Lee-kf5jq bro burden of proof falls on you. I'l be glad if you support your fact with some proof.
@@sheilakijawani2526
Go and read article by the Economist
Having read first two chapters of the book by Yuval Noah Harari, "21 problems of 21st century", and after watching this video on crackdown on internet companies I think it is safe to say what Xi did for China's economy in the coming future is visionary step. Because you don't want unemployment to rise so high that they become burden on their own economy.
Actually there should be some bar on the profit of private educational institutions and also pvt health care systems.
Secondly, i agree that boosting service sector has become priority in India, its advantage is that it provides crores of jobs..but simultaneously India shd focus on manufacturing sector without hampering already boosted service sector.
When your image is really bad, so even if you do the things which are slightly good, it gets really appreciated!
They are actually doing the right thing. I always wondered about this that how long this can go on that people will constantly earn money through gaming, entertainment and advertisement, someday the bubble will burst and we will have a big chunk of incompetent population. The population is constantly rising and our planet has limited resources, if more and more people go away from innovation and join easy ways of making money it will prove to be disastrous. Directing more and more people to higer education and manufacturing is the need of the hour.
Yeah I agree with the point but in telecom and service sector there is also a future In service sector people can have employment and it is not like that ki people who are in service sector cannot do innovation or they're wasting their time but people can grow in both way if wants to have sector is useless or they're not helping with the development of society if that was in that way then america and many western country could have crash but the thing is each way you go their is always a bright future either it is on industry or technology
But the thing is the government of every country should focus on both sector the games are not completely waste of the time if people are smart then they could build the careers on both sector so just my honest opinion
this exposes one of the shortfalls of democracy. Here, we can't focus on long term goals like these coz politicans are judged on the basis of 5-year performance and these moves will likely create huge short term pain. But will take these shortfalls anyday over authoritarian regimes.
I think PM and CM should Hold the office for just 4 years and Only 2 terms .
Authoritarianism is no good! USSR & North Korea are big examples.
Dictators run authoritarian regimes however China is run by engineers, businessmen and traders who practically understand economy.
Where as politicians run democracy and eventually turn a beautiful republic into oligarchy.
India is run by academic economist who have no real-time knowledge of economy and politicians who have tremendous empathy with poor and helpless Indians.
@@aksaiqin wow
Well leaders are judged by 5-yrs performance but what about the other elections that leader has to fight between those 5yr? even thought about that? Truth is leaders are judged based on the performance between state elections and not general elections. Democracy naturally promotes socialism bcoz the 1st priority in democracy is votes which free electricity, water can easily give.
@@aksaiqinLEE KUAN YEW
PARK CHUNG HEE
LDP AND KMT
MUSTAFA KEMAL ATATURK
these were all autocracies
Not every dictatorship is Kim Jong Un
So right. I notice all around Internet companies rising and it can be seen in households of every people. Yes, obviously it is good for the company and country's economy but...as we can see Internet for the most part is distracting the MOST IMPORTANT ASSET OF INDIA...
THE YOUTH. If the Youth is distracted in 2021, then by 2030 India will only have a rising PHARMA sector with people visiting Psychologists, Doctors, Orhtopedics and Popping in Pills.
So i should buy pharma shares.
@@ashishjaiswal453 yes and also buy a health insurance
@@ashishjaiswal453 Hahaha!
@@asifahmed6568 oh that means insurance sector will also grow.
The problem is u consider internet to be a distraction, i consider it be to an innovation. Not all people in a country are interested in building aircraft carriers, some are interested in building techs that provide better facilities to citizens.
Lot of valid points. This video explains truth of the changing world
When leaders are free from tension of elections then the innovative ideas definitely come faster
@Zack Smith Mao ruled with brute force and hence the people at that time didn't dare to say anything against him. Xiaoping brought some good changes which helped the people to actually earn money and own property and the people started liking him. even Xiaoping wasn't all clean. he killed 10 thousand students in Tianamen square in 1989.
@Leftist's Antidote Deng's policies were far more better than mao. It's bcoz of his policies that china could industrialise and globalise
like kim jong un ?
@@D__Ujjwal Not neccessary we need to emulate or copy china. we could have our own form of governance. Like Single party rule with freedom of speech allowed. you might say it's not possible but we could invent our own form of governance that other countries might like. Democracy has proved to be a double edged sword for a lot of countries including us. Policy paralysis, state elections, idiotic schemes such as free water and electricity (which ultimately lead to everything being given for free free, which would turn us into venezuella)
@Leftist's Antidote And we need an Indian Deng Xiaoping to set such policies and equally able successors to continue and refine those policies
In my opinion china's idea to improve need to have technology is mind blowing because we cant use nice to have technology without need to have technology
Instagram ban,Facebook ban,UA-cam ban will be cool🃏
Man this channel is so educational, keep up the good work!
I am stunned by xi jinping vision and the division of need to have and nice to have companies , but india focus on internet companies . Our start-up still lack of innovation it's more like copy cat . We strongly need innovation and R &D .
@Yash Dakhare ya china bhi krta h but unka manufacturing industry bhi deko hmlog sirf internet company ka baat kr rhe h look at chinese manufacturing company , china having world class manufacturing unit aur india doesn't have any good manufacturing mobile company
you deserve atleast 5m subscribers.
सर आपने मेरी सोच ही बदलदी इस विषय पर.
Thanks alot...
Some peeps are praising Xi-Ping and his decision (even to some extent praising authoritarianism)
If some gov and politician will do same thing here in India,these peeps will cry over here and still hue over here that the govt has turned authoritarian
You can praise xi and his descion but if you are praising his authoritarianism and autocractic system - These are big double standards I belive
@10m30 I don't divide indians low educated people into ideological and political category as westerners use .
Indians are not left , indian are not right , indians are not liberals .
They are just ignorant and less educated socially .
Exactly
we are not praising Xi-Ping's authoritarian policies but need to focus on manufacturing is need of the hour.The civil engineers from IITs are opting for software jobs.Over reliance on one sector will lead to disaster.
@10m30 who will build building for you ,when you have enough cash to buy an apartment?
Would you like to live in a poorly designed house ?
I think People are Praising Xi-Ping Government Authoritarianism over Tech Companies and other Sectors Not over People.
Lol no matter how mf China is.. He's really wise nation though
U think a country is mf? What does that mean?
No matter wt happens China won't progress with having absolute control.
@Zack Smith also Chinese wanting to get US degrees have been increased 7 times is just ew years because, they know their country education is shit.
@@bsobro
I think it means mother fu
@@bhaveshchoudhary2 have you even been to China or met actual Chinese people or blabbering like most Indians ?
This video make me think about China's communist party from a different angle. There are very bad things about ccp but i think the good things are, they prioritize
nation above religion,cast, power.
Whole new dimension to think ! Thank you. I feel tech companies are over valued in India, they are exploiting employees with long hours and there is no regulations.
I hope you had the experience in working in one of them to give that opinion. Because I am working in a technology company. And my experience has been pretty good.
Zomentooo indiamartttt is modern slavery for workers
@@newer8643 modern slavery not even close they get paid well.
@@bhaveshchoudhary2 lol no i have seen those workers so frustrated. I even gave tips to them. Looks like you are not fully aware of this issue
@@rishabhupadhyay9575 I myself work in a Tech company and post pandemic all of my friends in Tech are logging long hours. Not sure which part of the Tech you are on !
Very informative video mohak!!!!!!!!
Now i understand that India needs to make a balance between its manufacturing and service companies!!!!!because without the balance we can not stabilise our economy for a long period!!!!
Really impressed with what their Government did for them especially with the private coaching centre.
Whenever I hear Ali Baba , I remember Ali Baba 40 chor 😂
A growing youtuber 🙂
China is good country, but.........Indians are jealous of it, that how can they control internal issues better then india
Chinese system of copycat is not bad if its employing local people and is not harmful
@@RealCherry8085 why you spamming. You are not even Indian.
That's where the name is derived from I suppose, so isn't it obvious?
China here is playing 8D chess, while india is stuck
You dont know what india is doing china bias
Yep, as expected you know nothing about the things happening in our own country..
The worst part is that this fees of education don't go in teachers pocket but just few company owners
Imposing such visionary ideas in india for one leader is almost impossible because managing constantly evolving politics is tough
That's why democracy is worst
@@don-ow7sw No... Democracy is good only when it is localized like Switzerland. Democracy in country like India should be different because we are not same, we are group of people united in a sub continent and everybody thinks differently here not like china which country of one race ethnic *Han*
@@ayanverma5746 absolutely correct, brother even the ideology of whole China is same. And also CCP is doing great
Tech companies only create monopoly, and monopoly dose not help to boost the economy, china's policies are future prove and as every time India is the second mover. Indian government I think doing nothing to break the monopolies in our country.
I thinking if this system carried on one day will come when whole of the world will work for 10-15 companies and governments will be there secretaries. Every one will work for them to get the salary by them and spend it on them😥😓
Few months ago china celebrated the creation of ball pen nip
Yes in 2021 they have developed a nip on their own.
So imagine the complexity attached to jet engines, turbines, semi conductor etc.
This big the high scale manufacturing is
isnt its amazing that an unelected leader have better vision than elected one
he was elected by his communist party member
@@619ry7 yup bt not by peoples like us who got elected leader thts what i mean
You never miss out to be insightful. Thanks for your efforts.
to most of the people here, banning and censorship is never good for any given country, it all looks good on paper but reality is often different. Here the crackdown was rather to show the political influence CCP has. Service sector is important, this video was bit biased although he himself is from that sector.
Edit:- also he forgot to mention china has 996 work culture, meaning you work from 9am to 9pm for 6days, (just check the video on vice) people are already frustrated from it and if they ban social media from their life god knows what will happen.
China just banned 996.
@@JR-vc4gm chinese firms are working around for it, they are hiring people on different contractual basis which is sad, also this is a prospective rule.
I too was thinking about this some time ago, how india's manufacturing sector lags behind the service sector, i think if this continues it's going to be a huge problem because our dependence on countries like korea and japan is growing exponentially