Christopher Plummer accidentally said the word 'Captain' to Julie Andrews during the argument scene. Despite the error Robert Wise thought it was that amusing and liked it that much he kept it in the film. -IMDb so i guess the small smile in maria's face is because of that slipped. #OhYesYouAreCaptain!
@@mypuppywilltakeovertheworl8300 it was an error but the director thought it was good and changed the script to that noone woudl let that big of an error slip by during publishing
"Do you mean to tell me that my children have been roaming around Salzburg dressed up in nothing but some old DRAPES?" "Mhm and having a marvellous time" Maria 1 - Captain 0
Isn't he?! This has been my favourite film, or one of them, since I was old enough to remember films. I never noticed how gorgeous the dad was til I was much older. It came on one new years day when I was about 23 and I looked at Christopher Plummer through VERY different eyes! 😍 I thought woah, he was GORGEOUS. No wonder Maria fell for him and vice versa, Julie Andrews herself has always been beautiful and charming but as Maria Von Trapp she was just so enchanting. I remember crying my eyes out when she went back to the Abbey, then being so excited I nearly pee'd myself when she came back, I was 17 🤣 nah, I was about 3 or something. Now I cry at this film for different reasons, the subplot went over my head as a little kid but now it breaks my heart when he sings Eidelweiss at the concert and nearly starts crying and Maria has to step in and help 😭 then all the Austrian people singing along and knowing what was probably gonna happen to a lot of them just kills me. It's far from just a happy, sing song musical, it's really deep. Timeless film for sure. I hope people are still watching it 100s of years from now on whatever devices they have in the future
This exchange is brilliant. Captain Von Trapp is trying to control the conversation by how he moves around. He tries walking in on Maria to intimidate in and crowds her space. She doesn’t budge. Then he walks past her to brush her off but she keeps after him with words alone. He then repeatedly turns his back to her to dismiss her and end the conversation. Maria just keeps on going, refusing to be shut down. She stands in the same spot because she is holding the control.
To be fair, no parent is usually open to hearing that they are a bad parent, especially from a failed nun who has only been nannying for a few days. His reaction is 100% believable, especially as a decorated naval officer who is a widower.
1. Nobody is saying its not believable 2. I think its safe to say she's been there more than a few days. He was away for a month last time he went away.
@@DavidBennet I had forgotten how the storyline flows, haha. I just find it fascinating. We're supposed to view him as the antagonist sort of in this scene, but I was just commenting on how it's interesting, because I think most parents would have his reaction, for better or worse.
Very realistic. Of course she reacted defensively. She knew the children had needed that break and she really cared, so a normal emotional response. And he, same thing. Of course he is also going to be defensive. They were all credible in that scene. Also, she was not a "failed" nun; she was obedient to her superior, who wisely guided her steps.
Check out Eleanor Parker in The Naked Jungle, the most powerfully erotic performance ever on film. It's the one with Charlton Heston and the killer ants.
Maria was precisely what the Captain needed, honestly. Someone who wasn't intimidated by him and would tell him the truth, even if it wasn't what he wanted to hear. The most satisfying moment is when he realizes she was right and even thanks her for opening his eyes. He says he fell for her on the first night when she accidentally sat on the pinecone at dinner, but I've no doubt it was after this that he realized she was truly the one and that he wanted her to be part of his family.
Agreed. :) The pinecone was just the first sign she was someone unusual, she did cover for the kids after all, but this moment showed how deeply she loved his children, and even though not knowing them long was such a special woman she had reached them like no other had since their mother's passing. I love when he called of his engagement to Elsa, and he was afraid to reveal his truest feelings at first, and he said "Nothing was the same when you left, and it will all be wrong again when you leave." I love this movie SO much. 😊
You do know that the movie is nothing like the reality. Maria was not the sweet, lovey dovey lady that Julie Andrews portrayed. Read up on it - your opinion will be drastically changed once you see how their life actually was.
@@mandyadler4536 I'm aware that they were real people and that the film is not an accurate picture of their lives. I was referring to the film in my comment, and never said I thought that's what Maria and Captain Von Trapp were like in reality.
I love it when Maria says "you've got to"! His transition from an abrupt, seemingly uncaring father, to a father who suddenly realized he didn't know his children, happened too quickly. They should have had one more seen.
@@ARReithit was a line flub by Christopher Plummer that director Robert Wise left in because he thought it was funny and let the characters feel more real
@@Juustja she keeps finishing her statements with his title "captain" and he's trying to refute them quickly, as it's so heated he gets caught up and says captain back 😂
Saskia I thought it was because she’s so powerful in the argument. So he slips the word ‘captain’ out, because she was sounding more like a captain than he was.
He wasn't an abusive father at all. He was trapped in a rut and needed help as a widowed father. Maria saved him at the last minute. Notice how he doesn't yell at them and how he jumped when the children fell in the water. He still cares for them and used military discipline to cope with his depression and keep his children clean and in order.
Agreed. I think that the military-stiffness toward the children was not meant to be cruel but it was a way for him to keep them at a distance from him because being close to them just made him even more sad about the loss of his wife. I think he fell so hard for Maria because of how easily she helped the family to mend the gap between him and the children.
Fun fact: The youngest couldn't swim... so the actor for Maria was gonna fall forward and catch her. Buuuuuuut that didn't go as planned and the kid ended up throwing up water
I read the dialogue for the Broadway script once and it went: "Louisa wants to have a good time!" and that Marta was the one Maria didn't know about yet, but someone must find out about her." As for Louisa, it always seemed to me that she was a rather sneaky one, having sneaked a "jar full of spiders into the bed of former governesses," and even in the scene earlier where Maria has just arrived and the children are going for their walk, a frog or toad has been put in Maria's pocket(Frau Schmidt the housekeeper informs Maria that with Fraulein Helga, "it was a SNAKE!")and there is a slight diabolical look on Louisa's face then-a dead giveaway that SHE was the one who did it.
This scene in particular really epitomizes something I heard Julie say in an interview - there were many intentional choices made in the acting and adaptation of script to keep the film from becoming TOO saccharine and sickly sweet. Maria and Georg are both FURIOUS at each other here and it's such a sudden tone shift from what precedes it but it's also dramatically so important.
Liesl - Shes not a child anymore but one of these days you're going to wake up and find shes a woman. You won't even know her. Frederick - Hes a boy but he wants to be a man like you and theres no one to show him how. Brigitta - could tell you about him if you let her get close to you. She notices everything. Kurt - Pretends hes tough, not yo show how hurt he is when you brush him aside the way you do all of them. Lousia - I don't know about yet but someone has to find out about her. Marta & Gretl - Just want to be loved. Love them all!
That was the turning point for Captain von Trapp, he realised he needed to spend more time with his children and get to know them better rather than go away on long trips all of the time and treating his home like a military bootcamp. Maria was right to be outspoken towards her boss by telling him what she thought of him. Cpt Von Trapp's children wanted their father's attention and love but weren't getting it that was why they were always playing tricks on their governesses to get his attention. This was the turing point for Maria she brought back music and laughter which the house was lacking after Cpt Von Trapps wife had died. Maria is slowly gaining the trust and affection of the children by treating them with kindness and patience, and slowly winning Captain von Trapp over in the process.
this scene: the captain impotently yelling and protesting every word she says literally like two minutes later: omg please no stay i'm a complete asshole you have to stay 😍
@@manuelorozco7760 Julie actually entertained all of the kids during breaks where she sang the songs from *Mary Poppins* and they had absolutely NO idea that they weren't part of the movie they were working on.
ever since I was very young I admired Maria's courage finally standing up to that man. I don't think the former governess the children had would have had dared to do that. she was not afraid to tell him exactly how it was. although he initially took offense to it I think in his heart he knew she was right. this was exactly the push he needed
I think it is implied that the captain has actually been away for several weeks. Every day on their “outings” she teaches the children another lesson about singing. So I imagine she has gotten to know them fairly well.
@@jenniferlapidus2229 Hi Jennifer, I think Maria shows them to show their love for one another too. Nice to read your comments about this Momentous film. Kind regards Glynn n greetings from Stourbridge West Midlands UK 🕊🕊🕊
"Oh yes you are Captain" was an original shot that was initially a mistake on Christopher Plummer's part but kept it in. The classic films are always the best! :)
I think I see what you mean. A destined couple who had a one time arguement with the man having bad temper and the woman knowing how to roast him! 😆😆😆😆😆🤣
However, both arguements end with something more positive. Belle thanks beast for saving her life while maria & the captain hear their children singing for the baroness. This was Maria's idea.
A better sign of that is after they finished the "Lonely Goatherd" and everyone walked out of the room the Captain stood back to allow Maria to go before him.
@@joewhitehead3he’s been flustered and not thinking straight from being stood up to for once since he’s usually supposed to be the authority. Also Plummer messed up the line but they kept it in because it felt more authentic.
@@joewhitehead3No, the point was supposed to be that Maria is now the one in charge in this scene, the 'captain.' It's one of my favourite moments in the film, and has been since I first watched it when I was about ten.
Imagine Maria saying "No, u shut up & listen. U've been neglecting ur children for some time & it's not fair to them. It wouldn't b fair to yourself" either"
I love that the Captain tries to take control of the situation, and Maria simply won't let him steamroll over her. They both know she's right, even if he doesn't want to admit it.
@@DeepScreenAnalysis Indeed it was, but the musical starred Mary Martin, who interpreted the role of Maria in a completely different way. Having made Mary Poppins only a year earlier, Andrews was said to have taken a lot of Mary Poppins' tendencies into her interpretation of Maria. Having seen (and loved) clips of Mary Poppins before it was released, the directors of The Sound of Music totally supported the influence. I hadn't noticed it until I came back to this clip, which really reminds me of Mary Poppins discussing/arguing with Mr. Banks. What are your thoughts?
Yes, it's similar but I think this storyline wasn't unique to Mary Poppins and can be traced back to 19th century stories such as Jane Eyre (an outsider comes into a restricted world and influences it for good) @@MA-iu5hu
@@DeepScreenAnalysis Indeed! The storyline is tried and true :) I'm speaking solely of the acting interpretation--the way Julie Andrews says her lines here, and the mannerisms she chooses.
Near the end of filming (September 1964) for "The Sound Of Music", the "Mary Poppins" movie opened in theatres (late August 1964). From one classic movie to another.
Captain: *obviously angry* "You mean to tell me my children have been traipsing about Saltzburg (idk how to spell) dressed in nothing but old drapes?!" Maria- *completely unbothered* "Mmh!" 😂😂😂😂😂
It takes the children two minutes and eleven seconds (1:30 - 3:41) to run into the house, dry themselves up, put on fresh clean uniforms and otherwise groom themselves and serenade the baronessss.
Also they almost had a disaster because Gretl didn't know how to swim. Julie Andrews fell forward instead of backward and had to work like crazy to save the child.
RIP Sound of Music cast members in this video: Charmian Carr (Liesl) Heather Menzies-Urich (Louisa) Eleanor Parker (Baroness Elsa von Schraeder) Christopher Plummer (Captain Von Trapp)
Since the captain had to raise his children without his wife,the captain now had inhibitions and needed the talented insights of Maria to expose the negative tendencies he had towards his children.
It was rude of him to make her leave for reasons that should not have been considered. I’m glad though that he changed his mind, and at least Maria was telling the truth
"Frederich wants to be a man but there's no one to show him how" so sad how this is a great deal of young boys today growing up without a father figure.
I call this scene "The Captain's Transformation" When the children sang that "Sound Of Music" song, He transforms from a very bitter man into a nice relaxed gentalman.
She stood up to him and pushed him to be a better man and father. That’s why they fell in love. The baroness was just some whatever, but Maria was wifey material
The thing I like about this argument is how the characters don’t just say “you’re a bad person for this” and angrily finish the argument leaving no conclusion. They get straight to the point and the crux of the issue is that the children want to be loved. Maria even starts the argument not with “I think you’re terrible for not spending time with them,” but rather “they can’t speak up, they love you too much” to appeal immediately. She doesn’t act like some jerk delinquent who wants to force her opinion, she speaks as the mouthpiece for the children and shares their thoughts for them. It’s what gives her the ground to say “you’ve got to hear them”
I find that I always come back to this scene whenever I feel like being myself becomes a burden to others around me; whenever I’m placed in a position in life where doing what I think is right morally faces pushback. When fighting for what I believe in is seen as being rebellious. I watch this scene, I see the fire in Maria, and I remember to keep doing what I’m doing. This is a reminder to myself to continue to stand up to higher figures if what you’re doing matters to you. If what you’re doing means something to you. Be a Maria.
Trivia: Christopher Plummer admitted that other than working with Julie Andrews who he became close friends with, he hated working in the film. He even claimed that he regretted ever being in the film and he would often get drunk as he hated his role so much.
I love how she stands right up to him and doesn't cower in fear. She tells it EXACTLY like it is.
Lol how can you solve a problem like Maria
Me too! He really needed to hear the truth though or it would have been too late for him to get to know his children before they were all grown up.
If someone was talking 9ver me like that I wouldn't be able to talk😂
And i love her for it in that scene! Alot of men hate it thru them and when they get stood up too but too damned bad! :)
Some men hate that but i love it!;)
Christopher Plummer accidentally said the word 'Captain' to Julie Andrews during the argument scene. Despite the error Robert Wise thought it was that amusing and liked it that much he kept it in the film. -IMDb
so i guess the small smile in maria's face is because of that slipped.
#OhYesYouAreCaptain!
Jaine Red it wasn’t an error
@@mypuppywilltakeovertheworl8300 it was an error but the director thought it was good and changed the script to that
noone woudl let that big of an error slip by during publishing
🤔 I bet that's what the clever and charming Christopher Plummer wanted them to think! 😉
نبنلهبخيس٩يحه
It's perfect because it shows that Maria has gotten him flustered.
She wasn't telling him what he wanted to hear...she was telling him what he NEEDED to hear.
that's exactly my point!
Well said👍😍💚🧡🧡💕
If someone truly loves you, they will speak honestly to you, even if it's not always pleasant.
THANK GOODNESS 👍🏻 😊 she did.
and although he initially took offense to it he knew in his heart that she was right.
The children were really quick in changing out of their wet clothes and drying off.
John Ayres he did say immediately 😅
And just in time ! Whew !
Well their hairs were still wet.
They were brought up by the Captain “like he were still running one of his ships”.
You obviously haven’t met my school PE department 🤣
"Do you mean to tell me that my children have been roaming around Salzburg dressed up in nothing but some old DRAPES?"
"Mhm and having a marvellous time"
Maria 1 - Captain 0
"They have uniforms!"
She slayed that tho
@@davidcolantuono3622 "Straightjackets, if you'll forgive me."
@@jabbahut72 "I will not forgive you of that!"
That beaming smile as she said “Mmmhmmm!”was epic.
Dang, Christopher Plummer was even handsome while angry!!
Lol, right?! 😍
Ikr
Ikr?!
Yes!
Isn't he?! This has been my favourite film, or one of them, since I was old enough to remember films. I never noticed how gorgeous the dad was til I was much older. It came on one new years day when I was about 23 and I looked at Christopher Plummer through VERY different eyes! 😍 I thought woah, he was GORGEOUS. No wonder Maria fell for him and vice versa, Julie Andrews herself has always been beautiful and charming but as Maria Von Trapp she was just so enchanting. I remember crying my eyes out when she went back to the Abbey, then being so excited I nearly pee'd myself when she came back, I was 17 🤣 nah, I was about 3 or something. Now I cry at this film for different reasons, the subplot went over my head as a little kid but now it breaks my heart when he sings Eidelweiss at the concert and nearly starts crying and Maria has to step in and help 😭 then all the Austrian people singing along and knowing what was probably gonna happen to a lot of them just kills me. It's far from just a happy, sing song musical, it's really deep. Timeless film for sure. I hope people are still watching it 100s of years from now on whatever devices they have in the future
This exchange is brilliant. Captain Von Trapp is trying to control the conversation by how he moves around. He tries walking in on Maria to intimidate in and crowds her space. She doesn’t budge. Then he walks past her to brush her off but she keeps after him with words alone. He then repeatedly turns his back to her to dismiss her and end the conversation. Maria just keeps on going, refusing to be shut down. She stands in the same spot because she is holding the control.
That's an amazing perception
Exactly
Hé made a mistake when hé said captain but they decided tó keep it in. Julie explained it in an interview
If it was not for Julie Andrews , the film would not be what is was !
certainly not, but i think plumber was v good. i watch just for scenery, man the water kills me
Peggy Wood was amazing as the Rev Mother. She played a vital role in the movie
welshpete12 everyone played their part very well ; she couldn’t have done it alone!
No one could have played her part thru her and with her brutal spunkyness:)
welshpete12 is!
To be fair, no parent is usually open to hearing that they are a bad parent, especially from a failed nun who has only been nannying for a few days. His reaction is 100% believable, especially as a decorated naval officer who is a widower.
1. Nobody is saying its not believable 2. I think its safe to say she's been there more than a few days. He was away for a month last time he went away.
@@DavidBennet I had forgotten how the storyline flows, haha. I just find it fascinating. We're supposed to view him as the antagonist sort of in this scene, but I was just commenting on how it's interesting, because I think most parents would have his reaction, for better or worse.
Very realistic. Of course she reacted defensively. She knew the children had needed that break and she really cared, so a normal emotional response. And he, same thing. Of course he is also going to be defensive. They were all credible in that scene. Also, she was not a "failed" nun; she was obedient to her superior, who wisely guided her steps.
If the parent humbles themselves and listens and is honest with themselves they will.
😮
0:37 I love how the Baroness is trying really hard not to burst out laughing! I mean, can you really blame her? XD
Check out Eleanor Parker in The Naked Jungle, the most powerfully erotic performance ever on film. It's the one with Charlton Heston and the killer ants.
😂😂
Lol I would
@@harrysmith4780Oh wow, thanks, I need to watch that again!
Maria was precisely what the Captain needed, honestly. Someone who wasn't intimidated by him and would tell him the truth, even if it wasn't what he wanted to hear. The most satisfying moment is when he realizes she was right and even thanks her for opening his eyes. He says he fell for her on the first night when she accidentally sat on the pinecone at dinner, but I've no doubt it was after this that he realized she was truly the one and that he wanted her to be part of his family.
Agreed. :) The pinecone was just the first sign she was someone unusual, she did cover for the kids after all, but this moment showed how deeply she loved his children, and even though not knowing them long was such a special woman she had reached them like no other had since their mother's passing. I love when he called of his engagement to Elsa, and he was afraid to reveal his truest feelings at first, and he said "Nothing was the same when you left, and it will all be wrong again when you leave." I love this movie SO much. 😊
You do know that the movie is nothing like the reality. Maria was not the sweet, lovey dovey lady that Julie Andrews portrayed. Read up on it - your opinion will be drastically changed once you see how their life actually was.
@@mandyadler4536 I'm aware that they were real people and that the film is not an accurate picture of their lives. I was referring to the film in my comment, and never said I thought that's what Maria and Captain Von Trapp were like in reality.
I love it when Maria says "you've got to"! His transition from an abrupt, seemingly uncaring father, to a father who suddenly realized he didn't know his children, happened too quickly. They should have had one more seen.
you do you
@@decklanfrancis1319 ?????
@@decklanfrancis1319 what do you mean by that? It's just an opinion. I still LOVE the movie💗
I felt like it was the right thing just fine
What?!! 3 hours not long enough? 😪
"I'm not finished!" "Oh yes you are, Captain!" I've seen this movie dozens of times, and every time, I can't stop laughing at that bit
I love that line, but I never understood why it was necessary. Just a "human" slip of the tongue for the captain?
@@ARReithit was a line flub by Christopher Plummer that director Robert Wise left in because he thought it was funny and let the characters feel more real
Captain I think you‘ve met your match
Edit: whoa 444 Likes?!?! New record thank you so much
Exactly!
Yes you've made your perfect match should have had a wedding 😂😘😘
No one can outdo the Captain....
Haha, right?! 😂😂
Exactly!👌
"Oh yes you aaaare, Captain!....Fraulein..."
Maria got him all hot and bothered, huh? lmao
“OH YES YOU ARE CAPTAIN” always gets me 😂😂😂
I never understood that :/
@@Juustja she keeps finishing her statements with his title "captain" and he's trying to refute them quickly, as it's so heated he gets caught up and says captain back 😂
@@ProfessorSassypants thank you
Saskia samee
Saskia I thought it was because she’s so powerful in the argument. So he slips the word ‘captain’ out, because she was sounding more like a captain than he was.
He wasn't an abusive father at all. He was trapped in a rut and needed help as a widowed father. Maria saved him at the last minute. Notice how he doesn't yell at them and how he jumped when the children fell in the water. He still cares for them and used military discipline to cope with his depression and keep his children clean and in order.
If it wasn’t the case I would have been traumatized
03:10 Don't argue
Agreed. I think that the military-stiffness toward the children was not meant to be cruel but it was a way for him to keep them at a distance from him because being close to them just made him even more sad about the loss of his wife. I think he fell so hard for Maria because of how easily she helped the family to mend the gap between him and the children.
As a widowed father, he gave up music after the death of his previous wife before Maria brought the sound of music back in which it cheered him up.
Exactly, thank you! He was hurting badly, and Maria was the first person to truly soothe his pain.
Fun fact: The youngest couldn't swim... so the actor for Maria was gonna fall forward and catch her. Buuuuuuut that didn't go as planned and the kid ended up throwing up water
I thought I heard her crying and you can see they cut at that moment.
@@p.a.438 in the home videos from the Family Scrapbook by Fred Bronson, you can see Kym crying behind the scenes
Do you know the actress who plays Maria is Julie Andrews
@@officialchase02 Well I know now! Thanks :^)
ITS JULIE ANDREWS THE QUEEEEEEEN
“Louisa I don’t know about yet, but someone has to find out about her” is really funny to me
I read the dialogue for the Broadway script once and it went: "Louisa wants to have a good time!" and that Marta was the one Maria didn't know about yet, but someone must find out about her." As for Louisa, it always seemed to me that she was a rather sneaky one, having sneaked a "jar full of spiders into the bed of former governesses," and even in the scene earlier where Maria has just arrived and the children are going for their walk, a frog or toad has been put in Maria's pocket(Frau Schmidt the housekeeper informs Maria that with Fraulein Helga, "it was a SNAKE!")and there is a slight diabolical look on Louisa's face then-a dead giveaway that SHE was the one who did it.
She was obviously a very troubled girl, and very much to her self.
Ikr
😂😂😂😂😂
This scene in particular really epitomizes something I heard Julie say in an interview - there were many intentional choices made in the acting and adaptation of script to keep the film from becoming TOO saccharine and sickly sweet. Maria and Georg are both FURIOUS at each other here and it's such a sudden tone shift from what precedes it but it's also dramatically so important.
And quite believable as well, with how messy emotions can get sometimes...
I wasn’t prepared for how the dramatic the plot would be
Liesl - Shes not a child anymore but one of these days you're going to wake up and find shes a woman. You won't even know her.
Frederick - Hes a boy but he wants to be a man like you and theres no one to show him how.
Brigitta - could tell you about him if you let her get close to you. She notices everything.
Kurt - Pretends hes tough, not yo show how hurt he is when you brush him aside the way you do all of them.
Lousia - I don't know about yet but someone has to find out about her.
Marta & Gretl - Just want to be loved.
Love them all!
It's spelled _Friedrich_ and _Louisa_ .
I said that will do!
@That Girl uh no
That was the turning point for Captain von Trapp, he realised he needed to spend more time with his children and get to know them better rather than go away on long trips all of the time and treating his home like a military bootcamp. Maria was right to be outspoken towards her boss by telling him what she thought of him. Cpt Von Trapp's children wanted their father's attention and love but weren't getting it that was why they were always playing tricks on their governesses to get his attention. This was the turing point for Maria she brought back music and laughter which the house was lacking after Cpt Von Trapps wife had died. Maria is slowly gaining the trust and affection of the children by treating them with kindness and patience, and slowly winning Captain von Trapp over in the process.
Liesl is the oldest
I actually thought the Captain said, "Catherine," as if Maria acted just like his passed wife.
OMG WHAT IF
His wife's name was Agatha.
@@SkullPrism idk if they even said what his wife's name was
@@eljordinio7647 in real life her name was Agathe and so it’s widely assumed in the fandom so was his fiction wife.
this scene: the captain impotently yelling and protesting every word she says
literally like two minutes later: omg please no stay i'm a complete asshole you have to stay 😍
The moment a governess/nanny knows children better than their own father does
I didn’t sit through the Sound of Music until nearly a decade after first seeing Mary Poppins
Take another example of this is Fran Fine from The Nanny.
She was destined to be their mother fr
@@manuelorozco7760 Julie actually entertained all of the kids during breaks where she sang the songs from *Mary Poppins* and they had absolutely NO idea that they weren't part of the movie they were working on.
@@kryptonianpowers I remember watching an AFI interview she did mentioning that. I was quite surprised
'I KNOW YOU DON'T, BUT YOU'VE GOT TO !' - You have met your match, Captain Von Trapp
Stars above! The chemistry in this scene is off the charts!
"And having a marvelous time"
😂😂😂
Maaaaad defiant.
I think it's significant that he calls her 'captain' accidentally. He sees her as equal especially after she stands up for herself!
ever since I was very young I admired Maria's courage finally standing up to that man. I don't think the former governess the children had would have had dared to do that. she was not afraid to tell him exactly how it was.
although he initially took offense to it I think in his heart he knew she was right.
this was exactly the push he needed
I love how much she already knows about the children after only conversing with them for such a short time
I think it is implied that the captain has actually been away for several weeks. Every day on their “outings” she teaches the children another lesson about singing. So I imagine she has gotten to know them fairly well.
@@jenniferlapidus2229 and they wear different clothes to show the different days. I thought it was meant to be about a month?
@@jenniferlapidus2229 Hi Jennifer, I think Maria shows them to show their love for one another too. Nice to read your comments about this Momentous film. Kind regards Glynn n greetings from Stourbridge West Midlands UK 🕊🕊🕊
@@jenniferlapidus2229 I agree! It seemed like he was away for at least a month
They wore different clothes ever week
@@jenniferlapidus2229 Its because his grief of losing his wife, so probably explains why he has military style of dicipline rather than affection
“Straight Jackets if you will forgive me”
“I will not forgive you for that!”
Idk why but that is so good
I just heard the news of Christopher Plummer's passing. Rest in peace Christopher Plummer. Ten bell salute for Mr. Plummer.
I love how she stands right up to him and doesn't cower in fear. She tells it Exactly like it is.
"Oh yes you are Captain" was an original shot that was initially a mistake on Christopher Plummer's part but kept it in. The classic films are always the best! :)
That part reminds me of belle and the beasts arguing
Yup, they both knew how to stand their ground and I like that about them.
I think I see what you mean. A destined couple who had a one time arguement with the man having bad temper and the woman knowing how to roast him! 😆😆😆😆😆🤣
However, both arguements end with something more positive. Belle thanks beast for saving her life while maria & the captain hear their children singing for the baroness. This was Maria's idea.
This movie is rather like that movie isn't it?
Except for less traumatic
The way his expression changes when she says “YOU’VE GOT TO.” She cut him to the core. Bravo Maria. 👏🏻
We need more people like Maria. Kind, but firm. Not afraid to stand up for what's right. 💕
"I am not finished, Captain"
OH YES YOU ARE CAPTAIN!!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Maria (outspoken): "I know you don't but you've got to!"
😂😂😂
2:59 Maria: I know you don’t but you‘ve got to!
Me: that’s putting your foot down right there!👍🏻
😂😂😂
I was liek, "you go, girl!"
I love Julie Andrews!!! AMAZING ACTRESS!!😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
This is one of my favorite scenes in this wonderful movie. The chemistry between Julie Andrews and Christopher Plummer is amazing.
The Captain calls Maria “Captain”. He finally sees her as equal!
A better sign of that is after they finished the "Lonely Goatherd" and everyone walked out of the room the Captain stood back to allow Maria to go before him.
"OH YES YOU ARE CAPTAIN....Fraulein."
😂😂 Gets me evert time.
Don’t know why he’d call her that
@@joewhitehead3he’s been flustered and not thinking straight from being stood up to for once since he’s usually supposed to be the authority. Also Plummer messed up the line but they kept it in because it felt more authentic.
@@kylele23 Messed it up. Musta been one of those days he was drinking
@@joewhitehead3No, the point was supposed to be that Maria is now the one in charge in this scene, the 'captain.' It's one of my favourite moments in the film, and has been since I first watched it when I was about ten.
"Love them, love them, love them all !" It Goes to the heart of Each and Every one of us. Who doesn't want to be defended by this argument ⭐️💛⭐️.
Imagine Maria saying "No, u shut up & listen. U've been neglecting ur children for some time & it's not fair to them. It wouldn't b fair to yourself" either"
I love her smug face x also those kids were quick x
2:12 wut u gonna do about it bruh
Lol
😂😂😂
🤣😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Oh, my God! This made me laugh so hard!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
"I know you don't but you *GOT TO* !!!" ...he was silent there. =)
I love that the Captain tries to take control of the situation, and Maria simply won't let him steamroll over her. They both know she's right, even if he doesn't want to admit it.
The Mary Poppins influence here is fascinating.
This movie was a musical before Mary Poppins was made. Try again.
@@DeepScreenAnalysis Indeed it was, but the musical starred Mary Martin, who interpreted the role of Maria in a completely different way. Having made Mary Poppins only a year earlier, Andrews was said to have taken a lot of Mary Poppins' tendencies into her interpretation of Maria. Having seen (and loved) clips of Mary Poppins before it was released, the directors of The Sound of Music totally supported the influence. I hadn't noticed it until I came back to this clip, which really reminds me of Mary Poppins discussing/arguing with Mr. Banks. What are your thoughts?
Yes, it's similar but I think this storyline wasn't unique to Mary Poppins and can be traced back to 19th century stories such as Jane Eyre (an outsider comes into a restricted world and influences it for good) @@MA-iu5hu
@@DeepScreenAnalysis Indeed! The storyline is tried and true :) I'm speaking solely of the acting interpretation--the way Julie Andrews says her lines here, and the mannerisms she chooses.
Near the end of filming (September 1964) for "The Sound Of Music", the "Mary Poppins" movie opened in theatres (late August 1964). From one classic movie to another.
Captain: *obviously angry* "You mean to tell me my children have been traipsing about Saltzburg (idk how to spell) dressed in nothing but old drapes?!"
Maria- *completely unbothered* "Mmh!"
😂😂😂😂😂
“I’m not finished “ “Oh yes you are captain.” “What’s that. It’s singing.” Soften that hard heart captain. LOL.
It's like Maria knows the children more than the Captain did. What a true mother she is.
The scene after this one gives me goosebums everytime. The way the captain begs maria to stay was such a good touch.
It takes the children two minutes and eleven seconds (1:30 - 3:41) to run into the house, dry themselves up, put on fresh clean uniforms and otherwise groom themselves and serenade the baronessss.
That’s fast
The Captain speaks so fast!
Also they almost had a disaster because Gretl didn't know how to swim. Julie Andrews fell forward instead of backward and had to work like crazy to save the child.
RIP Christopher Plummer you will be missed greatly
1929 - 2021
Maria/Julie Andrews Master of Sass since whatever year this movie came out?! 😂😊
1965 😊
Aww it cut off just before my favourite bit.
Anyone else here after hearing the news about Christopher Plummer... 😔💔 God bless his soul, what a charismatic man and wonderful actor...
Rest In Peace, Captain.
RIP Sound of Music cast members in this video:
Charmian Carr (Liesl)
Heather Menzies-Urich (Louisa)
Eleanor Parker (Baroness Elsa von Schraeder)
Christopher Plummer (Captain Von Trapp)
Since the captain had to raise his children without his wife,the captain now had inhibitions and needed the talented insights of Maria to expose the negative tendencies he had towards his children.
It was rude of him to make her leave for reasons that should not have been considered. I’m glad though that he changed his mind, and at least Maria was telling the truth
That's not how you treat children like that. They are kids.
Oh yes you are, Captain!.....Fraulein.
2:31-2:37 this was what made me want them to get together. So. Much. Chemistry!
"Frederich wants to be a man but there's no one to show him how" so sad how this is a great deal of young boys today growing up without a father figure.
"Don't you dare tell me about my son!"
0:07 O M G
"I am not finished yet, Captain."
"Oh--Oh yes you are, Captain--Fraülein."
😂
Julie Andrews in this movie is in the top tier of film performances for me. She's just perfect for this role!
She’s the number one reason I had to see this movie the first time!
I never realized the parallels between this role and Julie's role in Mary Poppins before now.
I prefer one movie over the other
Mary Poppins didn't end up banging Mr. Banks tho
Top 10 rappers Eminem was too afraid to diss.
Georg doesn't realize that he hasn't been a good father at first, but eventually he comes to his senses.
One of the best scenes and acting of all cinema!❤
Ortiei
the way he turns and breathes “the children” at the end hurts me always
fly high, Captain 🙏🏼🕊💙 R. I. P. Christopher Plummer
I call this scene "The Captain's Transformation" When the children sang that "Sound Of Music" song, He transforms from a very bitter man into a nice relaxed gentalman.
Love this scene
Christopher plummer looks like a michael Fassbender twin😍😍😍❤😍❤👌👌
I'm Gen Z but I grew up with this movie and many other classics thanks to my parents. I'm so grateful 👏
I’m a millennial
Fun fact: Christopher Plummer helped out Julie Andrews with this scene, since she hasn’t done a scene like this before.
She stood up to him and pushed him to be a better man and father. That’s why they fell in love. The baroness was just some whatever, but Maria was wifey material
These (face drops) are my children.😂😂😂
"Oh *please*, captain love them. Love them all!"
When I was a kid I thought that was really cheesy but now I get it!
ever since I was a kid I always thought that was why the captain fell in love with Maria. it was the courage she had to stand up to him.
Christopher Plummer always reminds me of Laurence Olivier. I used to not be able to tell the two apart
The thing I like about this argument is how the characters don’t just say “you’re a bad person for this” and angrily finish the argument leaving no conclusion. They get straight to the point and the crux of the issue is that the children want to be loved. Maria even starts the argument not with “I think you’re terrible for not spending time with them,” but rather “they can’t speak up, they love you too much” to appeal immediately. She doesn’t act like some jerk delinquent who wants to force her opinion, she speaks as the mouthpiece for the children and shares their thoughts for them. It’s what gives her the ground to say “you’ve got to hear them”
Maria is arguing just because the captain is babying his teenage daughters and sons
ok but the captain is hot as shit
2 movies where Julie Andrews stands up to an unreasonably strict father. Mary Poppins is the other one.
Maria (about Brigitta): "Brigitta could tell you about him if you let her get close to you. She notices everything"
Bad parents are what makes the world a terrible place. Money doesn’t make you a good parent
The way Captain got stopped in his tracks by the Sound of Music...
RIP, Christopher Plummer.
I find that I always come back to this scene whenever I feel like being myself becomes a burden to others around me; whenever I’m placed in a position in life where doing what I think is right morally faces pushback. When fighting for what I believe in is seen as being rebellious. I watch this scene, I see the fire in Maria, and I remember to keep doing what I’m doing.
This is a reminder to myself to continue to stand up to higher figures if what you’re doing matters to you. If what you’re doing means something to you. Be a Maria.
Yes! You get it.
Trivia: Christopher Plummer admitted that other than working with Julie Andrews who he became close friends with, he hated working in the film. He even claimed that he regretted ever being in the film and he would often get drunk as he hated his role so much.
I’m so sad that Mr. Plummer has passed away. He wax such a talent. R.I.P.
He was my sexual awakening lol
Ok but LIESL'S BACKING VOCALS THOUGH
Very pretty voice!
RIP "Captain" Arthur Christopher Plummer, he was a bold and brilliant actor for over 70 years.
RIP Captain, you will always be missed