I think it’s important for people to remember that “prodigy” is someone who shows an extraordinary amount of ability despite a lack of age/experience. It’s extremely impressive, but It does not mean they are a master of their craft. Only that they have an extreme inclination or aptitude.
@Serendipity well then you weren’t a prodigy. Anyway, ofc she needs to build more skill and emotional techniques just like every other student. But people in the comments really be acting like ANYBODY could play that polka.
@Serendipity no, but you could’ve just been very talented. But prodigy is not something that can just be muted or as you said carried over and be forgotten like talent. Music is almost like an instinct for many prodigies. Like they can be self taught but have immense skill and techniques that are way sophisticated out of age and can play by natural senses just by ear or sight.
Prodigy is just naturally has the aptitude, the teacher you can hear has the real experience. That's why prodigies still have teachers, they teach the technicalities and the ways to really play something beautiful no matter what. And the tiktokker is the type of music that entertains someone All very capable musicians
I love this comment and complete agree!!! Thanks for sharing that, it's important to recognize that most of the time it isn't even a matter of one thing above the other, but just different styles and objectives. And that it's completely ok!
I used to play so gracefully.... until I took an arrow to the knee... Jk But seriously... all 3 of them are amazing... if only I could play like this.... I'm not that great at piano but I try to practice whenever I get the chance because I have a busy schedule.... I feel that if i had more time then i could also be satisfied with the way i play as a pianist but only time will tell in this case
this ^ Back in middle school, on my band rehearsal our piano guy started with some Chopin's nocturne. It was impressive. Up until the overseeing teacher (he taught piano and drums) sat down and played that very nocturne but with feel and that infamous Chopin's elongating beats and dynamics. insane how much of a difference that makes.
Prodigy: ability to play what's there, to an extreme difficulty Teacher: maturity to convey the emotion behind a musical price TikToker: enough practice to have fun and light up a room with entertainment
The teacher’s proud smile while the prodigy played, the awe the prodigy and tiktoker showed, and the joy on the prodigy shows while the tiktoker played all displayed why all people have their place and purpose in the world of piano. 😍😍
I get why people are saying that the prodigy isn’t showing emotion while playing but what is she supposed to do, it’s a fast paced song meaning you can’t really play it with emotion and she also needs to concentrate while playing since it’s a hard piece. In the end all the pianists are really good at playing
You still can put emotions into fast paced music, excitement, anger, high intense fiery emotions, while more somber ones are slower from what I’ve listened to
showing emotions and really enhance dynamics is something you work on A LOT as a pianist, i would say more than most other things you practise, it is very important as it is what differentiates you from other pianists
Have you played an instrument before? Just wondering because most people that play instruments would understand what it means to add emotion to the song. Yeah, the song is impressive indeed! But if you tweak it a little more by change the pace or even the volume of certain notes, it can change the whole thing. Nevertheless I'm pretty sure this video is just a fun skit and people are taking it too seriously.
That teacher hands down was the best. His tugging of the rhythm and volume/tone execution was superior and created a whole new element of expression within the piece.
he plays still dre wrong every time, i’m not talking about how he turned it into curb your enthusiasm. He actually plays the 3 chords in still dre wrong
I was genuinely thinking the opposite or rather he plays good but the song seems a bit to easy for a teacher or maybe my teachers are just insanely good idk
@@wefo4833 it was a simple piece, but the care with which he played it shows 1,000,000x experience than people who play pieces like moonlight sonata mov.3 decently. His touch was so careful and beautiful and he made the piece sound easy - that's how it should be played
If you can play it slowly, you can play it quickly~ And don’t give up if you’re playing music. Don’t forget that this prodigy might have spent hours and hours of intense practice to reach such a level. Even if some people are gifted, it doesn’t mean they don’t have to work to become excellent.
Omg the difference with the teacher is absolutely outstanding. The quality of the sound is clean, the subtle changes on volume, the rythnm and the use of silences is absolutely gorgeous. Most people think quick music is harder to play, but instead the slow is much difficult. The prodigy and the tiktoKker are absolutely amazing too, I hope they continue learning. I wish I have their talent! 😍
Pieces played: Prodigy: Tritsch-Tratsch Polka Teacher: Chopin’s Scherzo No. 4 TikTokker: Dr. Dre combined with Curb Your Enthusiasm Edit: I should mention that Tritsch-Tratsch Polka was originally an orchestral piece by Strauss. It was arranged for solo piano by Czriffa. Here's a performance of the arrangement: ua-cam.com/video/abdUjh6yo8E/v-deo.html
Actually, I legit think the teacher’s playing is better than the prodigy on this recording. You can see the maturity and the musicality of the man! But for sure, she’s most impressive for her age
Well that’s why he’s a teacher. He is supposed to be better. Prodigies may be good but they’re still students. It only means they have a gift and they still have to work hard to make something of their natural talent. You don’t want to just be known as a prodigy forever
@@rstyles4208 you can see the form and fingers of the prodigy are less defined and wavering. She hit the notes yes, but it is less sure and less emotional. Impressive playing. It does feel more focused on hitting the notes than the emotional aspect of it. A craftsman learning experience is still a factor in musicality always. She is young. So yea we all learn.
I don’t understand why people are saying the prodigy has no emotion, does it really matter? The fact she can play a song that fast and make it sound good is enough. She did great
when playing on high levels, emotion is a big deal and it separates the truly talented ones from the not so talented. in this particular video, I doubt it matters. I don't think she's a prodigy though. they might have just said that for the sake of the video
I don't think they comparing them. I think they show the differential between all 3 of them. The prodigy is talented but lacks experience, that's why they need a teacher to teach them more about it. The teacher has the experience and knowledge to train other people and to improve their skills. Tiktoker is most likely for entertainment and fun.
I think they all have a very unique and wonderful way of expressing themselves. And that's all that matters. There shouldn't be a competition between them.
@@butterflykisses1984 in order to get to play pieces from composers like Rachmaninov you have to have good technique too, so in some pieces are are meant to improve your technique (and you go through lot of them while studying) is more important to learn the right movements and stuff
Not saying that the teacher was better than the prodigy or vice versa I wanna comment how it all depends on the piece they’re going for, people who say “she can play yes, but their were no feelings, therefore the teacher were better” she was playing an upbeat ragtime-like piece while the teacher was obviously playing a more slower piece where you can insert as much emotion to it as you want, I’m sure either one of them could play as emotional or fun as the other
For me, a prodigy is little bit lack of the proper way to deliver message from the song. Yes they play hard piece but maybe they didn't do a research what's that song was written to and both hands play melodies as the same dynamic as the left (except the melodies was written on the sheet music). Only my opinion, not all prodigy does this.
for musicality, the teacher won for technique, the prodigy wins by a few points slightly above the teacher (plays a more technically demanding piece) for playing more well-known music and pop songs... well xD
I love how the other two are just smiling in the back when the tiktoker played 😂 they’re like, we know you played the wrong keys but we’ll just smile because it was really cute ✨
Idk I just learn what I like at that moment. Usually I learn short bits of songs that I like the sound of. Picture Daniel thrashers “when you can’t finish a song” vid as basically being me.
I know im not a prodigy, nor a teacher, less a tiktoker, but my dad was a great teacher to me and he was a prodigy, its like seeing something you can't achieve but its facinating
@@hdz_editz7740 yeah, have fun. You'll need like a month to completely get over it. You may laugh a couple of times but everytime someone says how sad Your Lie in April was within that month, you're gonna cry again, again and again.
Prodigy is different than learning since you were 2. Example of prodigy: someone who has this ability to play a song by ear, easy, neat, determinated, self taught. Idk
no, a prodigy is someone who has the aptitude to learn a skill to levels beyond their years. like a 10 year old playing the violin like an adult violinist.
I’ve always preferred to play the sort of emotional pieces the teacher is playing over other pieces. Idk why but It always felt good to be able to deliver the right emotion in a performance. Because while it may not look as physically amazing or difficult at a glance, it’s actually not as easy as it looks especially when you have to play something softly or slowly. Getting nervous or losing focus can throw off your control and you kill the whole vibe.
Depending on the style of piano music you like best, will make you like one over the other. Personally I love the song and style the teacher is playing.
@@elephanluvver as a pianist myself, he failed to play a simple song (the one at the video), and not to be rude but his technique it's not really surprising (for a musician), it's the type of technique beginners use. Annnddd normally tiktok ""musicians"" don't use more than one scale, or simply use the "1 2 3" thing, so yeah At the point of view of someone that dedicated years to this beautiful instrument, this isn't good at all :/ Wanting to flex playing pop songs (or whatever this is) in a classical instrument, it's the same thing of playing The Fly of The Bumblebee (or Summer) as if was the hardest/impressive piece of the world :)
But some people think classical music it's "boring and easy", and i mean, not everyone is actually interested in classical pieces, so it's understandable to do a pop song. But, the classical pieces are richer and sounds much better in the piano.
@@duckiewuckie1101 I mean even pieces that aren’t from the classical era, like original composed songs, still sound good, and like all forms of music, anything can be played well on it, sure what he played were simple notes simple tunes, but its more to just be a closing fun bit of the video, as his section is like a 1/6 of the entire video, or to just turn up the mood, besides it being an upbeat song already.
@@arandomguyontheinternet3500 oh sorry. I read it as teacher😅😅🤣. Yeah she rushes, but I think it is a result of slowing down at technically harder places, and speeding at easier passages. Not being just“off rhythm”.
You can tell that the teacher really has skill, obviously, but it’s not at just a basic understanding it’s digging deeper into musicality and how the music itself feels
The teacher has great control over his hands you can tell he plays a lot I would say first goes to tik toker then the teacher then the prodigy but you were all amazing😍😍👏👏👏
You can play as technically adept with fast fingers as much as you want, but can you play with such poise and emotion that trascends the art to a deeper understanding? That I think is when you achieve mastery level
people wanting to sound intelligent by saying “teacher showed extraordinary emotions.” he just swayed… lemme tell you something, first three years of studying how to play piano I used to sway a lot… as if that made anything better
They weren't talking about hand movement. You only need to have ears to tell the teachers musicality was miles above the other ones'. I guess you didn't studied piano after those 3 years you talked about.
The first one is Cziffra’s arrangement of the tritch tratch polka and the second one is the slow middle section of Chopin’s fourth scherzo for anyone wondering
![Try to Beat me at Violin [🎻100 Violin Giveaway]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ctIbXWIHVXo/mqdefault.jpg)
![Try to Beat me at Violin [🎻100 Violin Giveaway]](/img/tr.png)
I think it’s important for people to remember that “prodigy” is someone who shows an extraordinary amount of ability despite a lack of age/experience. It’s extremely impressive, but It does not mean they are a master of their craft. Only that they have an extreme inclination or aptitude.
Yes
Yes indeed
@Serendipity well then you weren’t a prodigy. Anyway, ofc she needs to build more skill and emotional techniques just like every other student. But people in the comments really be acting like ANYBODY could play that polka.
What does prodigy mean
@Serendipity no, but you could’ve just been very talented. But prodigy is not something that can just be muted or as you said carried over and be forgotten like talent. Music is almost like an instinct for many prodigies. Like they can be self taught but have immense skill and techniques that are way sophisticated out of age and can play by natural senses just by ear or sight.
Prodigy - makes me say "WOW"
Teacher - makes me calm and relax
Tiktokker - made me smile
Mhm
Tiktoker: made me lol
Prodigy is just naturally has the aptitude, the teacher you can hear has the real experience. That's why prodigies still have teachers, they teach the technicalities and the ways to really play something beautiful no matter what. And the tiktokker is the type of music that entertains someone
All very capable musicians
I love this comment and complete agree!!! Thanks for sharing that, it's important to recognize that most of the time it isn't even a matter of one thing above the other, but just different styles and objectives. And that it's completely ok!
@Lissa goty Go home ur drunk
@@Tushar_Talwar_09 its a bot
True. Felt the passion.like the notes are truly speaking to me.
I used to play so gracefully.... until I took an arrow to the knee...
Jk
But seriously... all 3 of them are amazing... if only I could play like this.... I'm not that great at piano but I try to practice whenever I get the chance because I have a busy schedule.... I feel that if i had more time then i could also be satisfied with the way i play as a pianist but only time will tell in this case
Prodigy:
“This is fun!”
Teacher:
“This is relaxing.”
Tiktokker:
_”Memes.”_
Hah-
LOL
same
*Yes*
Priorities
I love watching her crack a smile when she realises what song he's playing
I'm in love with the teacher's hand movements,soooooooo gentle,so relaxed yet hits all the note at the perfect time beautifully ❤️❤️❤️
The teacher’s emotion while playing is beautiful, it’s pretty clear he has the most experience.
Dynamics makes music interesting. Although the first is technically harder to play on paper the second is much more enjoyable imo.
this ^ Back in middle school, on my band rehearsal our piano guy started with some Chopin's nocturne. It was impressive. Up until the overseeing teacher (he taught piano and drums) sat down and played that very nocturne but with feel and that infamous Chopin's elongating beats and dynamics. insane how much of a difference that makes.
The first is a funny polka but not an emotional piece
Prodigy: ability to play what's there, to an extreme difficulty
Teacher: maturity to convey the emotion behind a musical price
TikToker: enough practice to have fun and light up a room with entertainment
right! the other two played beautifully as well but the tiktoker made the others smile
away with you
Prodigy means someone that learns more and faster than others, not that he/she is an expert
The teacher’s proud smile while the prodigy played, the awe the prodigy and tiktoker showed, and the joy on the prodigy shows while the tiktoker played all displayed why all people have their place and purpose in the world of piano. 😍😍
Memer
Oh myy, the teacher’s part is so good, so much emotion in those notes ❣️
I always felt the slower tempo on a piano was the most heartfelt of all instruments
I get why people are saying that the prodigy isn’t showing emotion while playing but what is she supposed to do, it’s a fast paced song meaning you can’t really play it with emotion and she also needs to concentrate while playing since it’s a hard piece. In the end all the pianists are really good at playing
That’s exactly what I was thinking
You still can put emotions into fast paced music, excitement, anger, high intense fiery emotions, while more somber ones are slower from what I’ve listened to
You can still put emotion in fast songs, videos of professionals playing fast songs still shows emotion while playing.
showing emotions and really enhance dynamics is something you work on A LOT as a pianist, i would say more than most other things you practise, it is very important as it is what differentiates you from other pianists
Have you played an instrument before? Just wondering because most people that play instruments would understand what it means to add emotion to the song. Yeah, the song is impressive indeed! But if you tweak it a little more by change the pace or even the volume of certain notes, it can change the whole thing.
Nevertheless I'm pretty sure this video is just a fun skit and people are taking it too seriously.
That teacher hands down was the best. His tugging of the rhythm and volume/tone execution was superior and created a whole new element of expression within the piece.
It was like I was at a school recital or a funeral.
Very different pieces they're playing and you can't really get that out of a polka or meme songs but agreed
that’s why teachers > students. even if they’re prodigies
he plays still dre wrong every time, i’m not talking about how he turned it into curb your enthusiasm. He actually plays the 3 chords in still dre wrong
There’s diff ways to play it like diff chorda
@@joshuagonsalves1502 if you mean you can play it in different keys then yes you’re right but he is playing the wrong chord at the wrong time
@@td_4605 basically your just saying hes out of time
@@jimquim1574 not really, he’s playing the chords in the wrong order, slightly in the wrong time
@@jimquim1574 it’s meant to go A A A A A A A A B B B C C C C C, he does: A A A A A A A A A A C C C C C C
I love all these proformances, because they are so unique and give each of you character.
Are we not gonna mention how good the Teacher plays?
No shit Sherlock, he's a teacher
I was genuinely thinking the opposite or rather he plays good but the song seems a bit to easy for a teacher or maybe my teachers are just insanely good idk
@@wefo4833 nah, pueces that sounds easy arenet nescesserily hard, like chopin nocturne op 48 no 1
He wasn’t even playing the chords in the right hand. It’s the middle section of Chopin Scherzo no 4 op 54.
@@wefo4833 it was a simple piece, but the care with which he played it shows 1,000,000x experience than people who play pieces like moonlight sonata mov.3 decently. His touch was so careful and beautiful and he made the piece sound easy - that's how it should be played
The ease and comfort that teacher the teacher played with is what made it for me❤️
Prodigy’s be taking away my confidence
Lol, all prodigies do that
If you can play it slowly, you can play it quickly~
And don’t give up if you’re playing music. Don’t forget that this prodigy might have spent hours and hours of intense practice to reach such a level. Even if some people are gifted, it doesn’t mean they don’t have to work to become excellent.
@@hannemanisunderrated5610 true words of lingling 😌
Omg the difference with the teacher is absolutely outstanding. The quality of the sound is clean, the subtle changes on volume, the rythnm and the use of silences is absolutely gorgeous.
Most people think quick music is harder to play, but instead the slow is much difficult.
The prodigy and the tiktoKker are absolutely amazing too, I hope they continue learning. I wish I have their talent! 😍
Pieces played:
Prodigy: Tritsch-Tratsch Polka
Teacher: Chopin’s Scherzo No. 4
TikTokker: Dr. Dre combined with Curb Your Enthusiasm
Edit: I should mention that Tritsch-Tratsch Polka was originally an orchestral piece by Strauss. It was arranged for solo piano by Czriffa. Here's a performance of the arrangement: ua-cam.com/video/abdUjh6yo8E/v-deo.html
Give this man a pin
Omg thank youu i was searching for this
THANK YOU
Thank you so much man
I love how three of them played so beautiful ❤️
Actually, I legit think the teacher’s playing is better than the prodigy on this recording. You can see the maturity and the musicality of the man! But for sure, she’s most impressive for her age
how old is she?
@@user-dz5lh4if3u young
Well that’s why he’s a teacher. He is supposed to be better. Prodigies may be good but they’re still students. It only means they have a gift and they still have to work hard to make something of their natural talent. You don’t want to just be known as a prodigy forever
@@rstyles4208 you can see the form and fingers of the prodigy are less defined and wavering. She hit the notes yes, but it is less sure and less emotional. Impressive playing. It does feel more focused on hitting the notes than the emotional aspect of it.
A craftsman learning experience is still a factor in musicality always. She is young. So yea we all learn.
Imagine if none of you actually play piano but wanted to give insight anyway
I love how all three are outstanding pianists with different styles/passions
I don’t understand why people are saying the prodigy has no emotion, does it really matter? The fact she can play a song that fast and make it sound good is enough. She did great
Yes!
when playing on high levels, emotion is a big deal and it separates the truly talented ones from the not so talented. in this particular video, I doubt it matters. I don't think she's a prodigy though. they might have just said that for the sake of the video
No ofense but u clearly dont know much about high level music, which is pretty normal i Guess xD
for classical musicians it 100% does matter
Have you played piano or any other musical instruments?
All 3 are amazing, talented and entertaining!! 👏👏👏
Yes, let’s compare all of these peoples skills by having them play songs in completely different tempos and musical styles.
I don't think they comparing them. I think they show the differential between all 3 of them. The prodigy is talented but lacks experience, that's why they need a teacher to teach them more about it. The teacher has the experience and knowledge to train other people and to improve their skills. Tiktoker is most likely for entertainment and fun.
....That's the point, they are comparing interpreations not skills,
whats the "VS" for if not comparing?
😂😂😂🎯
@@nurulafiqah4903 when it’s captioned “vs” that literally indicates a comparison
Talent never beats sheer hardwork
Teacher's sound is so good
The teacher is amazing! Absolutely beautiful
The teacher was amazing he played it beautifully.
I think they all have a very unique and wonderful way of expressing themselves. And that's all that matters. There shouldn't be a competition between them.
you can tell they're all so musically talented despite the difference in song choices I'm very impressed
Wow the teacher is so chill and it was effortlessly beautiful
I love how when the teacher and prodigy were playing everyone looked serious and then everyone’s laughing and smiling when the tiktokker starts 😂
This is the kind of battles i luv to watch 👍🎶🎵
Tik tokers would have the notes C, D, and E labeled 1, 2, and 3 and play Castaways just using those three notes
It’s so cool they all had their different genres
I love that girl's smile at the end☺️
There’s hitting notes. Then there’s music. Emotion. Depth. Hats off to that TikToker for getting all 👏
Ofc I meant the teacher lol. But look at you.... salty
Teacher won. Prodigy knows music but lacks emotional delivery. Tiktokker was OK but lost it
I get why you would say that about the prodigy but actually not all pieces are meant to be played with lots of emotions
@@im.claire I disagree every piece sounds better when emotion is put into it.
@@imperialsandwich3695 i agree with you
@@im.claire - in what world is music not supposed to evoke emotions?
@@butterflykisses1984 in order to get to play pieces from composers like Rachmaninov you have to have good technique too, so in some pieces are are meant to improve your technique (and you go through lot of them while studying) is more important to learn the right movements and stuff
No doubt teacher is the best! He really digs the music, dynamic, control, idea and thought! Bravo!
Not saying that the teacher was better than the prodigy or vice versa I wanna comment how it all depends on the piece they’re going for, people who say “she can play yes, but their were no feelings, therefore the teacher were better” she was playing an upbeat ragtime-like piece while the teacher was obviously playing a more slower piece where you can insert as much emotion to it as you want, I’m sure either one of them could play as emotional or fun as the other
Thank you
Thank you I was looking for this
I like the teachers interpretation. He plays with alot of emotion.
I love how calm the teacher was.
This is what we call "experience"
speed or how hard a song is: not important.
the feeling in the music and emotion: thats important.
I really liked the teachers. It was beautiful and very relaxing..i could heart it all day. 😌
For me, a prodigy is little bit lack of the proper way to deliver message from the song. Yes they play hard piece but maybe they didn't do a research what's that song was written to and both hands play melodies as the same dynamic as the left (except the melodies was written on the sheet music). Only my opinion, not all prodigy does this.
You can see how the teacher has the most experience and heart
for musicality, the teacher won
for technique, the prodigy wins by a few points slightly above the teacher (plays a more technically demanding piece)
for playing more well-known music and pop songs... well xD
Would love to hear them all play the same piece to hear the differences in how they approach it
just play what makes you happy, complex sounding or not. that’s what impresses people the most because it comes through in your playing 💖
They were all excellent, but teacher was my favorite. I got this vibe from him that he wasn't there to prove anything, just to play, and I like that.
You know you‘re a good student when your teacher is smiling while you play
Seeing the teachers hands move so smoothly is so oddly satisfying
I love how the other two are just smiling in the back when the tiktoker played 😂 they’re like, we know you played the wrong keys but we’ll just smile because it was really cute ✨
he played the right keys
Teacher is the only one who plays with his heart. As is usually the case with more experienced artists
They were missing the simply piano user. They definitely would’ve been the best.
You could tell the prodigy had made it to day 3 of using simply piano!
They can be a prodigy, a teacher and a tiktokker, but for me, all of them are pianists
Aw they were really good! Doesn’t the teacher have his own channel? He’s so good, he should make videos!😊
While the Prodigy can play something fast that sounds impressive, the Teacher can play something slow and MAKE it sound impressive.
I loved how that tiktoker guy is expression less through the entire video and then finally smiles at his turn 😂
Idk I just learn what I like at that moment. Usually I learn short bits of songs that I like the sound of. Picture Daniel thrashers “when you can’t finish a song” vid as basically being me.
Whenever I see a piano
My mind: Your lie in April
I know im not a prodigy, nor a teacher, less a tiktoker, but my dad was a great teacher to me and he was a prodigy, its like seeing something you can't achieve but its facinating
honestly in my opinion, her playing this song faster is really impressive and it’s kind of an uplifting sound.
Im sure everyone there can manage that easily
@@Testtew Considering she would be the least experienced, I damn well hope so
If only people didn't call all music songs, especially if it's a solo instrument without vocals or lyrics...
@@fatitankeris6327 They are all songs
I love the teachers piano playing the vibe of the melody is calm, peaceful, and romantic
Finished watching *Your Lie in April* not too long ago... imma go cry now
Oh damn, I remember finishing the show and feeling depressed for 3 days
@@energeticstunts993 Yep, sounds about right 😭
@@hdz_editz7740 yeah, have fun. You'll need like a month to completely get over it. You may laugh a couple of times but everytime someone says how sad Your Lie in April was within that month, you're gonna cry again, again and again.
@@energeticstunts993 omg 😭
They all did amazing
Their very incredible
Sad that it’s needed to explain what a prodigy is
Prodigy has fingers so fluid they look like powerful ribbon. This is so pretty.
Prodigy is different than learning since you were 2. Example of prodigy: someone who has this ability to play a song by ear, easy, neat, determinated, self taught. Idk
no, a prodigy is someone who has the aptitude to learn a skill to levels beyond their years. like a 10 year old playing the violin like an adult violinist.
being able to play by ear can be achieved by practice but most often it's associated with perfect pitch
@@juliat6444 yes, but what I mean is like being new in playing piano and being able to do it
@@cuami being able to do what? play by ear? that's perfect pitch
@@juliat6444 okay 🤨 it's not but whatever
I’ve always preferred to play the sort of emotional pieces the teacher is playing over other pieces. Idk why but It always felt good to be able to deliver the right emotion in a performance. Because while it may not look as physically amazing or difficult at a glance, it’s actually not as easy as it looks especially when you have to play something softly or slowly. Getting nervous or losing focus can throw off your control and you kill the whole vibe.
The way he made them smile at the end tho
Depending on the style of piano music you like best, will make you like one over the other. Personally I love the song and style the teacher is playing.
What piece does the teacher play? :o
Scherzo no. 4 by Chopin
@@ObelAlalong it's always Chopin
@@tost. why not chopin yknow
Teacher had such gentle hand movements it made me want to shake his hand
The fact that he is comparing himself to a teacher and a prodigy (that probably practice for years) it's just- 💀💀💀
The fact that he probably also practiced for years 💀💀💀💀
@@elephanluvver as a pianist myself, he failed to play a simple song (the one at the video), and not to be rude but his technique it's not really surprising (for a musician), it's the type of technique beginners use. Annnddd normally tiktok ""musicians"" don't use more than one scale, or simply use the "1 2 3" thing, so yeah
At the point of view of someone that dedicated years to this beautiful instrument, this isn't good at all :/
Wanting to flex playing pop songs (or whatever this is) in a classical instrument, it's the same thing of playing The Fly of The Bumblebee (or Summer) as if was the hardest/impressive piece of the world :)
But some people think classical music it's "boring and easy", and i mean, not everyone is actually interested in classical pieces, so it's understandable to do a pop song. But, the classical pieces are richer and sounds much better in the piano.
@@duckiewuckie1101 ok.
@@duckiewuckie1101 I mean even pieces that aren’t from the classical era, like original composed songs, still sound good, and like all forms of music, anything can be played well on it, sure what he played were simple notes simple tunes, but its more to just be a closing fun bit of the video, as his section is like a 1/6 of the entire video, or to just turn up the mood, besides it being an upbeat song already.
I already knew how this was going to end, yet it still infuriates me.
Well done 👏
its not a mistake✨ ITS A MASTERPIECE✨
Man I really wish I knew how to play a piano the serenity and beauty that it can produce can take your mind to another realm of existence
The “prodigy’s” rythm is kinda off, obviously not a jazz player.
It is called rubato
@@op-th1yx No what Feleous meant was it was rushed my guy.
@@arandomguyontheinternet3500 oh sorry. I read it as teacher😅😅🤣. Yeah she rushes, but I think it is a result of slowing down at technically harder places, and speeding at easier passages. Not being just“off rhythm”.
“Prodigy”
This lady is very naturally gifted to play piano
what pieces of music was used in this
video
Prodigy: Cziffra tritsch tratsch polka
Teacher: Chopin scherzo no 4
I could listen to the teacher play all day.. it's soothing :)
Whats the song the teacher plays?
The way teacher playing piano was soft and smooth
I thought it would be a different "Prodigy"
???
You can tell that the teacher really has skill, obviously, but it’s not at just a basic understanding it’s digging deeper into musicality and how the music itself feels
prodigy: *incredible*
me, just learning: *hot cross buns*
as a piano player myself, the prodigy did show emotion. you can see it in her fingers and the move of her body.
The teacher has great control over his hands you can tell he plays a lot I would say first goes to tik toker then the teacher then the prodigy but you were all amazing😍😍👏👏👏
You can play as technically adept with fast fingers as much as you want, but can you play with such poise and emotion that trascends the art to a deeper understanding? That I think is when you achieve mastery level
people wanting to sound intelligent by saying “teacher showed extraordinary emotions.” he just swayed…
lemme tell you something, first three years of studying how to play piano I used to sway a lot… as if that made anything better
They weren't talking about hand movement. You only need to have ears to tell the teachers musicality was miles above the other ones'. I guess you didn't studied piano after those 3 years you talked about.
I don't know much about piano but I took a few lessons before, and what the teacher played sounds extremely hard with that unusual tempo
I honestly preferred the teacher over the prodigy, he seemed more Musically Mature, however, the girl was phenomenal
Music is an art to express your thoughts not to impress
I loved the prodigy’s, it was so fun and daring and… overall amazing! The teacher’s was rather boring.
nah, the teacher's had maturity in his playing. good emotion and dynamics
I love Kawai.Especially the Shigeru Kawai grand pianos
“it’s not a mistake”, ✨ ITS A MASTERPIECE ✨
My allyy
Shut up this is so old
The first one is Cziffra’s arrangement of the tritch tratch polka and the second one is the slow middle section of Chopin’s fourth scherzo for anyone wondering
ty so much! I been scrolling to look for this lol
it's not a mistake,✨IT'S A MASTERPIECE✨
✨JELLYBEAN WAS A MISTAKE✨
It's not a joke,❌ it's a hazard✅
That dress is looking better than the paintings and I looooove paintings so 👍💪💜