Outstanding series! I grew up with Sears, Roebuck catalogs explaining “Good, Better, Best” for lots of their products. I think it made me a better consumer, and I’m sure your series is doing the same for your viewers. Not just for the products you review, but for everything we buy.
I have a Henley I bought 40 years ago at Eddie Bauer when most of their line was made in the US. It’s a little ratty around the cuffs and neck but it’s still going strong!
Henley are the best casual shirt. I am glad that I found this video as I was here searching for a good Henley pattern to sew my own. There are so many crap henleys in the world.
I have a henley from Merz B. Schwannan and it's definitely worth the money; my only criticism is the slightly scoop neck which I'm not crazy about. My favorite is from Pherrow's. While the buttons are not mother of pearl, it is made of heavy gauge loop wheel cotton and most importantly crew neck.
Great timing. I loved Eddie Bauer henley shirts but they change the fit and style every year and i am now at the point of no longer considering them. They used to be great for my barrel chested shape. Ill check these out once the EBs wear out.
For those of you wanting a henley to work in, I highly suggest redhead henleys. Theyre like $15, and fit my slim frame very well. Have had a couple for 3ish years and they are holding up quite well
Pistol Lake has good henleys. Not sure if they're still made in the US though. They're slim fit. They make them in 2 different fabrics and have short and long sleeves available.
Here, your philosophy is pragmatic. Kind of “workwear vs workwear fashion.” In other vids, i.e., indigo belts and $1k+ boots, the fashion part dominates. I think your audience appreciates both aspects of your reviews - I sure do. (Still waiting on Weatherwool. Probably December, huh?)
Great video, and yes I think American Giant is the best one overall for me. I want to try the Patagonia one. Now hear me out. If you are actually going to be working in these, I'm talking roofing, yard work, cutting down trees, etc. Hanes Beefy-T Henley and Dickies Henley's have performed excellently. Fit and finish can be iffy but I've worn mine once a week for 7ish years and am just now having to replace a couple them. Crazy I know lol.
I bought one $30ish Henley from Bronson, and I loved it so much I've bought several more. I love the way they fit, and they're right there in that middle category you mentioned. I have their regular, and ribbed Henley's, and one of the "vintage" inspired ones, all great.
Free notes Henley is very short which I find silly for a Henley. It’s supposed to be an undershirt first, outer shirt second but it is my shortest shirt.
We wore cotton broad cloth Henleys in the 1960s during the beach boys baggy bathing suit a.k.a. jams popularity. They were a popular top to wear with the jams.
Loved the video. So being a t-shirt guy and Henley guy I have a few I’d like to mention. Buck mason has a nice Henley also 3sixteen, and I’ve been doing merino wool Henleys from prince and wool and wooly company.
my favorite henley is one from LVC, its got linen weaved into it if i understand correctly, rarer than anything ive ever seen for a mass produced item, Jake from Almostvintagestyle shows it off every now and then, he could explain it better. If i could find something identical to it I'd buy 7 for every day of the week!
Ive been very please with my Henley from Unbound Merino! Light weight merino wool and can’t beat the antimicrobial aspect! Really increases the longevity of my clothes not needing to be washed constantly!
Hanes sells a Henley under their BeefyT line, that has been very good quality for their price. I have a few that have lasted me almost 10 years. Worth the look if they are still making them.
You should check out "Reigning Champ." Seems to be a Canadian competitor to American Giant. More athletic wear focused but seems to be going for that premium quality.
9:43 the story of the toquilla (wifey known as the Panama Hat) is pretty interesting. It’s actually from Ecuador… and is only called a Panama hat because laborers wore them while building the canal.
I really like henleys, my favorites are LL Bean, carhartt, freenote cloth, Taylor stitch henleys are ok and I even have one of those Merz B swan ones that I’m terrified to wash 😂 I also just ordered a Ship John Henley, think I have a problem…
I don't know much about shirts, but I have what I think is a Henley shirt that my dad used to own. Its 100% cotton from St John's Bay, but after wearing it for seven years I've really worn it out. 😅 Been looking for something to replace it, but at this point I'm wondering whether I should try and find someone to "repair" it. I hadn't seen anything like it on their site in terms of look, and while I find it hard to discern texture from their pictures, it doesn't look like any of their featured henleys match it.
Firstly (English guy here)… Thames like the famous river in London, you dont pronounce the ‘Th’. It’s pronounced Tames. Like taming an animal… Secondly, great reviews of some nice products. I’ve noticed &Sons also make some nice medium tier Henleys for around the $85 mark.
I have a henley from Buck Mason and it’s the best fitting under shirt I own. If you have broad shoulders or a large chest and arms, definitely check it out. ($50)
Oops….forgive me. Thames as in Henley in Oxfordshire or London is pronounced Temms. The town of Thame in Oxfordshire however is pronounced Tame. We chuckle about this too…..🇬🇧. A super channel btw.
@@CarlMurawski yes, the only downside. I just got a 3-pack of Henleys a few days ago and the wait was a couple months. However I've gotten pretty lucky with stock orders as well.
The American giant company it is hard to get a hold of a human being over there when you have trouble with returns or with product quality it is hard to get customer service over there.
Hey Carl I clicked the link for your Stevenson overall Henley. In the description it says the cotton is organic medium to short staple length. In the specification section it says it's extra long staple cotton, any idea what's going on there or what the cotton is?
@@CarlMurawski thanks that'd be super cool. I bought the tough duck last night that you compared a couple years ago. There's like no good reviews on any of the carhartts and wolverine has one now too.
New to your channel. I really like that Stevenson Loopwheeled Henley. I found one, but they appear to run small. What size do you have and how does it fit? I have a 40.5” chest and 17.5” shoulders and by their chart that would be XL. However, I’m a medium in most shirts.
I absolutely love this series but I can never use anything you recommend. I can't remember finding one of these companies that make big and tall sizes. I'm 6'5'' with an absurdly long torso and wide shoulders. If I can't get tall shirts they end up looking like I'm wearing a crop top and trust me, no one wants to see that hot mess walking down the street. Any chance you could do a big and tall series?
If you decide to purchase a Henley shirt after watching this video, make sure you avoid buying the one from American Giant..they are an awful company to deal with and have zero customer service. My order was randomly canceled after a week from the confirmation and I still haven’t received a refund! So beware of that company.
i am a bit bird chested, but tall, so it cn be hard to find a well fitting shirt. i actually really like the cheap walmart $7 henleys. they're really thin which makes them wearable year round in florida on theyre own, but very very warm under a good flannel or sweatshirt. they also fit my chest and core snugly, and i love them for daily wear
Use my code CARLMS to get $5 off your delicious, healthy Magic Spoon cereal by clicking this link: magicspoon.thld.co/carlms_0622
My wallet literally broke out in a cold sweat as soon as I clicked on this video. Last time I got me a Dehen sweater 😅
Outstanding series! I grew up with Sears, Roebuck catalogs explaining “Good, Better, Best” for lots of their products. I think it made me a better consumer, and I’m sure your series is doing the same for your viewers. Not just for the products you review, but for everything we buy.
Stanfield are the best wool henleys made in Canada and have been around since the Klondike gold rush.
Hi - Henley On Thames is pronounced Henley on “Temms” - and that makes no sense to me either, and I’m a Brit!
And your piece was excellent, as usual 🤩
I came here to say this.
Tems not Thames.
Is English, eh? We make it up as we go along.
I have a Henley I bought 40 years ago at Eddie Bauer when most of their line was made in the US. It’s a little ratty around the cuffs and neck but it’s still going strong!
Henley are the best casual shirt. I am glad that I found this video as I was here searching for a good Henley pattern to sew my own. There are so many crap henleys in the world.
Props to LL bean, the Raglan Sleeve style is my favorite. I am surprised others did not try this.
I have a henley from Merz B. Schwannan and it's definitely worth the money; my only criticism is the slightly scoop neck which I'm not crazy about. My favorite is from Pherrow's. While the buttons are not mother of pearl, it is made of heavy gauge loop wheel cotton and most importantly crew neck.
Merz is where it's at. The loopwheel aspect makes it worth it for me.
Great timing. I loved Eddie Bauer henley shirts but they change the fit and style every year and i am now at the point of no longer considering them. They used to be great for my barrel chested shape. Ill check these out once the EBs wear out.
Right on, I’m so glad Eddie Bauer seemed to get back their roots though.
Stevenson looks excellent……the button holing and mother of pearl buttons are sublime. And yes, that matters!
For those of you wanting a henley to work in, I highly suggest redhead henleys. Theyre like $15, and fit my slim frame very well. Have had a couple for 3ish years and they are holding up quite well
Hanes too
Pistol Lake has good henleys. Not sure if they're still made in the US though. They're slim fit. They make them in 2 different fabrics and have short and long sleeves available.
Here, your philosophy is pragmatic. Kind of “workwear vs workwear fashion.” In other vids, i.e., indigo belts and $1k+ boots, the fashion part dominates. I think your audience appreciates both aspects of your reviews - I sure do. (Still waiting on Weatherwool. Probably December, huh?)
Believe it or not the video is already done! I’m just not sure when to release it…. 🤔
Great video, and yes I think American Giant is the best one overall for me. I want to try the Patagonia one.
Now hear me out. If you are actually going to be working in these, I'm talking roofing, yard work, cutting down trees, etc. Hanes Beefy-T Henley and Dickies Henley's have performed excellently. Fit and finish can be iffy but I've worn mine once a week for 7ish years and am just now having to replace a couple them. Crazy I know lol.
I bought one $30ish Henley from Bronson, and I loved it so much I've bought several more. I love the way they fit, and they're right there in that middle category you mentioned. I have their regular, and ribbed Henley's, and one of the "vintage" inspired ones, all great.
Free notes Henley is very short which I find silly for a Henley. It’s supposed to be an undershirt first, outer shirt second but it is my shortest shirt.
We wore cotton broad cloth Henleys in the 1960s during the beach boys baggy bathing suit a.k.a. jams popularity. They were a popular top to wear with the jams.
Loved the video. So being a t-shirt guy and Henley guy I have a few I’d like to mention. Buck mason has a nice Henley also 3sixteen, and I’ve been doing merino wool Henleys from prince and wool and wooly company.
my favorite henley is one from LVC, its got linen weaved into it if i understand correctly, rarer than anything ive ever seen for a mass produced item, Jake from Almostvintagestyle shows it off every now and then, he could explain it better. If i could find something identical to it I'd buy 7 for every day of the week!
Ive been very please with my Henley from Unbound Merino! Light weight merino wool and can’t beat the antimicrobial aspect! Really increases the longevity of my clothes not needing to be washed constantly!
Been waiting for a Henley video, thanks Carl!
Hope you enjoyed it!
@@CarlMurawski another good company for Henleys for the best category is jungmaven 👌🏼
Hanes sells a Henley under their BeefyT line, that has been very good quality for their price. I have a few that have lasted me almost 10 years. Worth the look if they are still making them.
You should check out "Reigning Champ." Seems to be a Canadian competitor to American Giant. More athletic wear focused but seems to be going for that premium quality.
9:43 the story of the toquilla (wifey known as the Panama Hat) is pretty interesting. It’s actually from Ecuador… and is only called a Panama hat because laborers wore them while building the canal.
I’m really enjoying this good, better, best series. Great work as always!
Stanfield's here in Canada have amazing henley's
I really like henleys, my favorites are LL Bean, carhartt, freenote cloth, Taylor stitch henleys are ok and I even have one of those Merz B swan ones that I’m terrified to wash 😂 I also just ordered a Ship John Henley, think I have a problem…
I like this format, a video about flannel shirts would help me out! 👍
Coming soon!
For some reason I wrote off Henleys years ago. This makes me want to revisit them. I may try the LL Bean.
This is right up my ally. For t shirts its almost all henley
Great choices as always Carl! Can't wait until the good, better, best jeans episode!
What a load of 💩
I don't know much about shirts, but I have what I think is a Henley shirt that my dad used to own.
Its 100% cotton from St John's Bay, but after wearing it for seven years I've really worn it out. 😅
Been looking for something to replace it, but at this point I'm wondering whether I should try and
find someone to "repair" it.
I hadn't seen anything like it on their site in terms of look, and while I find it hard to discern texture
from their pictures, it doesn't look like any of their featured henleys match it.
I recommend Hanes for the good category tough and comfortable
Firstly (English guy here)… Thames like the famous river in London, you dont pronounce the ‘Th’. It’s pronounced Tames. Like taming an animal…
Secondly, great reviews of some nice products. I’ve noticed &Sons also make some nice medium tier Henleys for around the $85 mark.
I have a henley from Buck Mason and it’s the best fitting under shirt I own. If you have broad shoulders or a large chest and arms, definitely check it out. ($50)
Very cool! My only issue with Buck Mason is the neck hole seems to be really small. I have a big ol’ noggin and it’s hard to fit through.
I find merz b schwanen pretty good! And made in europe
The henley from Pike brothers are the best
In England we call them 'grandad shirts'
Aint nothing wrong with a Carhartt Henley, 365 days a year. Long sleeved for cool/cold layering weather, short sleeves alone when it's warm.
Oops….forgive me. Thames as in Henley in Oxfordshire or London is pronounced Temms. The town of Thame in Oxfordshire however is pronounced Tame. We chuckle about this too…..🇬🇧. A super channel btw.
Gustin should be in this lineup. Their henleys are well-made of a variety of Japanese fabrics at an amazing value.
Gustin is fantastic, you’ve just gotta wait for what you buy.
@@CarlMurawski yes, the only downside. I just got a 3-pack of Henleys a few days ago and the wait was a couple months. However I've gotten pretty lucky with stock orders as well.
The American giant company it is hard to get a hold of a human being over there when you have trouble with returns or with product quality it is hard to get customer service over there.
I know you're crazy about American made but not including pike brothers Henley is a missed opportunity.
Can anyone help me find a waffle knit chunky Henley? I used to have one it was a brand moose something or other. I loved it so much
Hey Carl what’s your thoughts on Bronson mfg? They have some good looking Henleys
Carl it’s pronounced Henley on TEMS,
Keep up the great content mate 🙂👍🏼
Thank you for the clarification man!
@@CarlMurawski no problem, love the channel!
Would it break anyone to make a merino henley in midweight in colors plus white?
What is the brand of the waffle knit you are wearing in this video?
Hey Carl I clicked the link for your Stevenson overall Henley. In the description it says the cotton is organic medium to short staple length. In the specification section it says it's extra long staple cotton, any idea what's going on there or what the cotton is?
3sixteen henleys are $62 and MiUSA
Good informations tks.
Much appreciated!!
Would you be willing to do a work vest comparison?
Most definitely!
@@CarlMurawski thanks that'd be super cool. I bought the tough duck last night that you compared a couple years ago. There's like no good reviews on any of the carhartts and wolverine has one now too.
Thames is pronounced ‘temms’ ☺️
New to your channel. I really like that Stevenson Loopwheeled Henley. I found one, but they appear to run small. What size do you have and how does it fit? I have a 40.5” chest and 17.5” shoulders and by their chart that would be XL. However, I’m a medium in most shirts.
I absolutely love this series but I can never use anything you recommend. I can't remember finding one of these companies that make big and tall sizes. I'm 6'5'' with an absurdly long torso and wide shoulders. If I can't get tall shirts they end up looking like I'm wearing a crop top and trust me, no one wants to see that hot mess walking down the street.
Any chance you could do a big and tall series?
Great video. Are you planning to do a good, better, best for chinos?
Best video love henley!
I have a merz bei schwanen and bronson mfg. bronson mfg is not bad at all for the price!
i always thought JCrew was top tier quality.. oh well
Have you tried to Taylor Stitch Heavy Bag Henley?
How do you read my mind?!
How is the fit on American Giant? I'd love to try them out but I can't stand baggy/boxy fits
I would like to make a suggestion a video about underwear Brands , and about the big question Briefs our Boxers ? Greetings from Brazil !
A lot of your links need to be fixed. Thanks for an otherwise more informative video
Plus henleys are fun to steal from your boyfriend 😝
I paid a big price for a andsons Henley £100 , very well made , pricey but worth it for a smart Henley .
Sounds good brother, I hope you’ve been well!!!
@@CarlMurawski all good pal 👍🏼, hope all is well on your side of the pond . 🦉
I like this company called Vince for ring spun slub cotton Henleys. Check em out.
What coat rack is that in the back?
Just some vintage thing I found in an antique shop.
Options risk the demeanor
If you decide to purchase a Henley shirt after watching this video, make sure you avoid buying the one from American Giant..they are an awful company to deal with and have zero customer service. My order was randomly canceled after a week from the confirmation and I still haven’t received a refund! So beware of that company.
Dilemma here is that many of the "Best" in terms of fabrication and finishing are rather poor on fit.
I never gonna spend $50 on a tshirt 😆
You lost at 120$
0:31 “tems”
Thank you for the clarification
DULUTH!!!!!
It’s Henley on Thames pronounced tems , not tames just saying
Stevenson underwear looks way sexier….does not look like a cheap rag…save the cheap one for dirty work where no one will see it
I pay zero $ for Henleys. I never have wore them nor want to.
It's gotta be a henley with the waffle texture or I'm not wearing it
i am a bit bird chested, but tall, so it cn be hard to find a well fitting shirt. i actually really like the cheap walmart $7 henleys. they're really thin which makes them wearable year round in florida on theyre own, but very very warm under a good flannel or sweatshirt. they also fit my chest and core snugly, and i love them for daily wear
Very cool! We're all built differently and with our own unique challenges. Hopefully your experience will help others with a build similar to yours.