For a niche brand PDM Frags are really easy to wear for me, ( Kalan is a little tougher though) Carlisle is another one that appeals to the masses. I know when I spend my money I intend to wear my fragrances frequently and this house has a lot to offer even for the beginner.
I choose Red Tobacco over Carlisle because I LOVE the Tobacco note, I also own Herod Pegasus Oajan and Layton, and for me Oajan is the most cozy scent for me, Layton is like a Niche frag that was made to please the crowds even Aventus didn’t gave me so many compliments. Love your reviews you are becoming one of the top frag reviewers on UA-cam keep up the great work man !
Ah man I have some great Tobacco suggestions! Side Effect is one that’s why I didn’t get a Herod or RT, as well as Desert Falcon Luxury Edition! Tobacco is so awesome agreed! Thank u for your support!
TroyD247Mall Thank you mate, I actually bought Side Effect for my best friends 18 birthday he is not a frag head but the loves it so much he said he hates me because i got him into niche perfume and he tried Naxos from my collection and said he has to buy it immediately haha
Did you get the 2021 reformulated bottle? I got it and it doesn't perform well - it lasts 2-3 hours and then it really does disappear. I do not get nose blind and I never had an issue because of the skin chemistry; it's just below average performance from this newer batch. Everybody says that PDM has really good performing fragrances but to be honest the newer reformulations are disappointing on lines such as Herod, Carlisle, Layton/Layton Exclusive, and so on.
To me smells very similar to Valentino Coral Fantasy. To me Coral Fantasy is softer, and I think Coral Fantasy is beast mode already, imagine this one.
Get it. You will love it. It’s a 50 shades of gray ..kind of fragrance. Tie me to the bed. Great for bar/club…cuddling too 😊 masculine, dark, seductive. I love to wear at night helps me sleep better and arouses me. 😂
Great Content even today. I have Layton, Percival, and Oajan. Layton and Percival have given me the most Visceral compliments from women out of All of my fragrances. I have the Herod clone as well as the Pegasus clones and Both of those are highly complimented. I'm on the fence about purchasing Carlisle or a clone of ( I have Tafakhar and its not giving me what I want.) Hearing good things about Perseus and The Exclusif version from Maison AlHambra. Any Opinions out there?
Thanks for the review! Just got my bottle today and it smells less sweet than the decant I tested. Just curious does your bottle become sweeter and less harsh over time?
Definitely Carlisle. It’s a seductive dark leathery bad boy bar/club ….great for cuddling too. It’s a tie me to the bed frag. Treat me like 50 shades of gray. 🤣😘
Does PDM make anything that doesn’t smell like vanilla? So bored with vanilla. Creed offers a variety of fragrances. PDMs seems like they’re all flankers of based around smoke and vanilla.
Herod is more versatile but Carlisle is better. Panty dropper %150 percent but there’s a window of the year you can wear it , for me it’s about 67 degrees and below weather because it is heavy.
TheRainMaker if you have a lot of different fragrance buy Carlisle if you want a workhorse buy Herod. If you were gonna do the seasonal 4 for life thing get Carlisle for winter ❄️☃️
Idol carlisle po o hacivat? Need ko po mamili ng isa lang natry ko na both ng decant parehas ko gusto. Ano po marerecommend mo sa dalawa? Bachelor pa po ako single 😂
Parfums de Marly has REFORMULATED Carlisle. I own an older formulation which has an alcohol concentration of 77%. The new formulation I see in stores has 81% alcohol. My formulation is a dark ORANGE / AMBER color. The new formulation is a very light, faint copper color. The new formulation does not last as long and it smells different. Parfums de Marly fragrances are ALWAYS much weaker than their ORIGINAL releases. Parfums de Marly HAS NOT been transparent when it comes to the reformulation of their fragrances. Herod, Layton & Oajan have also been reformulated and have 3%-4% more alcohol in newer batches.
@@TroyD247Mall Some stores have both the 2015 old formulation 77% alcohol & the new 2021 formulation 81% alcohol of Carlisle and the new & older formulations of Oajan, Herod & Layton. The Parfums de Marly reps in the stores do not even know about the reformulation but they have inventory with both formulations. I have been to 7 stores this week that carry Parfums de Marly
Carlisle is overrated. Thanks to Demi Rawling hype train that many guys jumped on. It's good but not amazing. I find Layton, Layton exclusive and Pegasus much more interesting. Herod was Ok. Still want to try Habdan and Oajan.
@@TheBryanrice1991 Haven't really had a chance to really test it yet with the pandemic. Everyone wears masks now. I just think it smells amazing, unique and rich. I'm sure it will get compliments. I'm gonna layer it 50/50 with Layton exclusive. I bought both. If I could just pick one it would be Layton exclusive. It's more mature and has more depth.
They are all compliment magnets...but that Oajan.... Wowwwww... It's like smelling an apple cinnamon pie... (Compliments Oajan 1a , Layton 1b, then Herod #2)
Carlisle is a scent that needs to be worn multiple times to get the full effect. Each time I wear it I find something new to love.
Totaly True one off the best
It sux. I’m hoping it grows on me. Otherwise I’m out $200. Smells like green Jolly Rancher candy, vanilla, smoke, patchouli, and incense.
@@LouisXIIIPizza🫥 hopefully you got a genuine Carlisle cause that sounds nothing like it...old nor new batches
Me too
For a niche brand PDM Frags are really easy to wear for me, ( Kalan is a little tougher though) Carlisle is another one that appeals to the masses. I know when I spend my money I intend to wear my fragrances frequently and this house has a lot to offer even for the beginner.
I choose Red Tobacco over Carlisle because I LOVE the Tobacco note, I also own Herod Pegasus Oajan and Layton, and for me Oajan is the most cozy scent for me, Layton is like a Niche frag that was made to please the crowds even Aventus didn’t gave me so many compliments.
Love your reviews you are becoming one of the top frag reviewers on UA-cam keep up the great work man !
Ah man I have some great Tobacco suggestions! Side Effect is one that’s why I didn’t get a Herod or RT, as well as Desert Falcon Luxury Edition! Tobacco is so awesome agreed! Thank u for your support!
TroyD247Mall Thank you mate, I actually bought Side Effect for my best friends 18 birthday he is not a frag head but the loves it so much he said he hates me because i got him into niche perfume and he tried Naxos from my collection and said he has to buy it immediately haha
ScapeRazer hahahaha
Of course Layton gets you more compliments than Aventus. Aventus is a boxer dropper not a panty dropper. LOL!
Red Tobacco smells like Rids that stuff that kills 🪳
Love this. It got me two compliments the first time I wore it out. Went to a brunch and two friends both smelled it at the same time.
Did you get the 2021 reformulated bottle? I got it and it doesn't perform well - it lasts 2-3 hours and then it really does disappear. I do not get nose blind and I never had an issue because of the skin chemistry; it's just below average performance from this newer batch.
Everybody says that PDM has really good performing fragrances but to be honest the newer reformulations are disappointing on lines such as Herod, Carlisle, Layton/Layton Exclusive, and so on.
Definitely one of my favorite things to wear it’s definitely a cold weather hands down but girls wanna me when in wear it
I got the 81% people say thats weaker than the batch before, but I think still strong
Bro carlisle pdm or Ivory route ,, which one do you prefer as a smell and uniqueness?
To me smells very similar to Valentino Coral Fantasy.
To me Coral Fantasy is softer, and I think Coral Fantasy is beast mode already, imagine this one.
I feel like if I buy Carlisle.. I don’t need Layton or Herod
Get it. You will love it. It’s a 50 shades of gray ..kind of fragrance. Tie me to the bed. Great for bar/club…cuddling too 😊 masculine, dark, seductive. I love to wear at night helps me sleep better and arouses me. 😂
Probably my current fav. Having a tough time finding a bottle rn 🥺
Great Content even today. I have Layton, Percival, and Oajan. Layton and Percival have given me the most Visceral compliments from women out of All of my fragrances. I have the Herod clone as well as the Pegasus clones and Both of those are highly complimented. I'm on the fence about purchasing Carlisle or a clone of ( I have Tafakhar and its not giving me what I want.) Hearing good things about Perseus and The Exclusif version from Maison AlHambra. Any Opinions out there?
Keep bringing the heat!
Nice review man!
If you could only have one: Carlisle or Side Effect?
Both! Hahaha Side Effect is what I chose over Herod
Thanks for the review! Just got my bottle today and it smells less sweet than the decant I tested. Just curious does your bottle become sweeter and less harsh over time?
Would you say that Carlisle is a cold-weather winter banger?
Without a doubt Suzi
@@TroyD247Mall THANK YOU!
You saved me from giving this away, it took me a while to like it.
🤩
This is sold out everywhere.
It's back in stock at multiple fragrance shops.. I just finally got mine...it's amazing!!!
In own both Carlise and Layton I love them both.
When during the year (season) would be the best time to use Carlisle? In your opinion
For cooler weather cant get anybetter my summer go to Eylusum mixed with salt and pepper presios liquids
My husband got this a while back and I love it. VERY sexy fragrance, guys.
Keep the fire burning! I’m sure this fragrance helped haha!
Mr Troy does it smell dirty on your skin? When you spray it on your skin and you put your nose close to your wrist, does it smell dirty?
Never thought about dirty
Hi. Is that pre reformulation? 77%vol or 81%vol?
My favorite from the house so far.
Demi Rawling would agree with you and many other reviewers as well.
Great review...u don’t have to own herod though- pulse of the night is just as good
Layton or Carlisle for clubbing?
Definitely Carlisle. It’s a seductive dark leathery bad boy bar/club ….great for cuddling too. It’s a tie me to the bed frag. Treat me like 50 shades of gray. 🤣😘
@@crabcakes4194 have you tried the new batch?
Hi troy i really like the boss bottled/intense dna ..can you pls tell me from layton,carlisle,and oajan..which one is the niche version ?
Never tried boss bottled man sorry
Man this was a scrubber for me. Too harsh for me, something was off-putting.
Ya i thought it was time to bring this review out to warn people as well because it has that harshness. Side effect is crazier tho imo :)
@@TroyD247Mall I love side effect tho, its a mass pleaser, this one some could really love it and some like myself could hate it
Does PDM make anything that doesn’t smell like vanilla? So bored with vanilla. Creed offers a variety of fragrances. PDMs seems like they’re all flankers of based around smoke and vanilla.
Yeah, their fresh scents have zero vanilla. Sedley, Percival and Greenley to name the popular ones.
Was Demi paid to hype Parfums De Marly?
I’m positive
Heard her boyfriend's parents own the PDM company
Has someone heard about a reformulation on this one ? It's known as a beast but i get average projection, longevity is ok but not enormous
yup
carlisle or herod which one would you pick?
See that’s the thing my Tobacco was side effect so didn’t see any use for it but i would say Carlisle
@@TroyD247Mall thanks for the speedy reply, much appreciated :D
Herod is more versatile but Carlisle is better. Panty dropper %150 percent but there’s a window of the year you can wear it , for me it’s about 67 degrees and below weather because it is heavy.
@@paulysci925 insightful view on both fragrances, much appreciated.
TheRainMaker if you have a lot of different fragrance buy Carlisle if you want a workhorse buy Herod. If you were gonna do the seasonal 4 for life thing get Carlisle for winter ❄️☃️
Aw what about Pegasus... Not a bachelor perfume?? I got carlise but not a big fan of tobacco ish parfum but I like Pegasus.
Good question I have a sample of that I’ll try it very soon
PDM are overhyped, for their prices they have become weak with no longevity, a terrible shame.
Idol carlisle po o hacivat? Need ko po mamili ng isa lang natry ko na both ng decant parehas ko gusto. Ano po marerecommend mo sa dalawa? Bachelor pa po ako single 😂
Carlisle 🤟🏽
Is venba fragrance legit site?Their price for niche frags are great
smells like PDMs Side Effect but more mature and less sweet
King Herod!!!
Kalan still the King
How much did it cost you ?
I traded something out for it
Interesting thing about this one is no house has cloned it! Yet
Omg that is true!!!! Whyyyyyyy
@@TroyD247Mall pdm found a molecule that gas chromatography can't identify 😉
Parfums de Marly has REFORMULATED Carlisle. I own an older formulation which has an alcohol concentration of 77%. The new formulation I see in stores has 81% alcohol. My formulation is a dark ORANGE / AMBER color. The new formulation is a very light, faint copper color. The new formulation does not last as long and it smells different. Parfums de Marly fragrances are ALWAYS much weaker than their ORIGINAL releases. Parfums de Marly HAS NOT been transparent when it comes to the reformulation of their fragrances. Herod, Layton & Oajan have also been reformulated and have 3%-4% more alcohol in newer batches.
Damn.
@@TroyD247Mall Some stores have both the 2015 old formulation 77% alcohol & the new 2021 formulation 81% alcohol of Carlisle and the new & older formulations of Oajan, Herod & Layton. The Parfums de Marly reps in the stores do not even know about the reformulation but they have inventory with both formulations. I have been to 7 stores this week that carry Parfums de Marly
So sad! Ordered a 77% Version
@@piboxa The 77% formulation of Carlisle is amazing. You will love it.
@@Ed-ce5mb Yeah i will! I tried a sample a few years ago :)
Thanks for the reply
Carlisle is overrated. Thanks to Demi Rawling hype train that many guys jumped on. It's good but not amazing. I find Layton, Layton exclusive and Pegasus much more interesting. Herod was Ok. Still want to try Habdan and Oajan.
Is Layton the best for compliments in your opinion?
@@TheBryanrice1991 Haven't really had a chance to really test it yet with the pandemic. Everyone wears masks now. I just think it smells amazing, unique and rich. I'm sure it will get compliments. I'm gonna layer it 50/50 with Layton exclusive. I bought both. If I could just pick one it would be Layton exclusive. It's more mature and has more depth.
They are all compliment magnets...but that Oajan.... Wowwwww... It's like smelling an apple cinnamon pie... (Compliments Oajan 1a , Layton 1b, then Herod #2)
@@Gildhattie Just got my Oajan decant. You're spot on with the smell. Only thing downside is it limits you pretty much to a fall scent.
And yet she was a hype train on Layton....
It smells like paco 1 million
Which one