Just Saying
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 гру 2012
- Starring Emmet Kirwan
Written and Directed by Dave Tynan
Produced by Kathryn Kennedy
Cinematography by JJ Rolfe
Score by Gareth Averill
Edited by Michael Donnelly
Camera Operator Burschi Wojnar
Sound Recordist Fiachra O'Hanlon
Trainee Laura Danaher
Security Fred Nolan
Short Film Produced by Kennedy Films Ltd www.kennedyfilms.net/
Screened at the Dublin Film Festival 2013. Screenings at the Moscow Irish Film Festival and The Toronto Irish Film Festival, Eat My Shorts and more TBC in 2013.
Broadcast on RTE Short Screen, 2013.
Text/script we worked off is here www.thisgreedypig.com/home/lit...
90% same as what's in the finished film.
Buy the score on its own at www.garethaverill.com/Just-Saying
Twitter:
@Dave_Tynan
@EmmetKirwan
@KathrynK_
@JJRolfe
@GarethAverill
© Kennedy Films Ltd - Фільми й анімація
Have to come back to this in times of uncertainty
almost 10 years old, still a gem and still very very relevant .... brilliant!
I’m just saying, we’re 6 years on and it’s just as relevant now as it was then.
That moment where he stops, the music kicks in, and he says "No. You'se all fucked off." is just gut-wrenching.
I felt that. It speaks for itself chasing friends that are all for themselves. Following the crowd. Bellowing thoughts that scream out loud. Now alone and looking around. Where am I now.
ITS EVERY YOUNG DUBLIN PERSON'S POEM IN THIS GENERATION
Ricky C
"any craic?"
"no yous all fucked off"
Everything about this is perfect, the writing,the performance, the city streets, the background music, the atmosphere. Perfection.
"The answers aren't on Camden street, and they never were" Makes the hair on the back of my neck stand up.
Everybody knows the answers are on Aungier St! Always were. A for answers,A for Aungier, A for are and A for always. A'roight?
Still completely relevant... gorgeously written and well acted. So maith sibh.
I'm just saying that after living here for over 2 years I am now able to understand everything he is saying! lol
"Any craic?"
"No. Yous all fucked off."
:-(
This.
Was living in London when I saw this pop up on my newsfeed. Played a big part in me coming home.
Are you happy u came back?
I've been living in the UK for the past few years. I come back to this video every now and again to take me back to Dublin. Reminds me where I'm from.
Same as dude
same from Paris
Same from Sydney! Just had a big night and my head is banging and I thought I'd whip out the 'Just Saying' craic again! :D All in all, it's well done and strikes a chord each time. Love it.
Same!
Getting sentimental
I'm not even from Dublin, but I get choked up every time I hear this - makes me love the place, the country, even more, and glad to be home again. You've more soul in your little finger, Dave, than most poets...
This is Emmet Kirwan
@@BM-yr1lc its written by dave tynan
I left for the UK in 1987. Watching this fills me with happy and sad memories of Dublin before I left. I now live in London and sometimes wonder how life would've panned out for me had stayed. Eight of us left, two went back.
This'll be my first Xmas in Dublin, around a table with my family, in 6 years. Watching this last year, I cried. This year, I'm bawling! Fcuking love Dublin to death!
Hope you've a ball at home.
Oh fuck off it's a kip
@@JG-es5dj bet ur from roscommon
"Saw this long whole back.
Found it again.
Living now in the US and being from Ireland this struck a chord even more than when I first experienced it.
A prolific piece beautifully orchestrated and acted.
The back drop of Dublin in the early hours is so powerful.
I'm proud of Ireland proud to be Irish and ashamed of the government.
It's people are wonderful and this is proof that the art is still there.
Thank you Dave for a stunning reflection on Eire as it is now"
Just Saying, after 7 Years in Dublin ( I am German !)
I luv this city and appreciate the opportunity to have made this city my new home !
Thank you Dublin, Thank you Ireland !
"Magnificent Bastards in the Lost City of Dutch Gold" hahaha
It captures the feelings I had when I left Dublin 30 odd years ago .... Nice work.
Perfect! A voice of our generation!!! A question I debate with myself. With 10 good reasons to go and a thousand little reasons to stay!!! Perfect!!!
Think I'd moved from Ireland 1 year after this was made and I remember watching it in Spain feeling a million miles away, I've been back to visit but I'm still abroad and not in Spain anymore and I don't think I'll ever move back, I don't have a home but I'm good with it. I seen too many of my friends leave before I did so the place wasn't the same.
9 years on and I still love this video.
Been years since we were since we were showed this in school and its still one of the best pieces of writing out there
I have been living in Ireland for all but three months but it still brings me to tears when I see a raindrop in Ireland - classic Dublin 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
So much truth spoken with honesty.
This still gives me shivers every time I listen to it. 🌟
Irelands greatest export will always be her youth. Fair play, once again Emmet has nailed it beautifully!
I left Ireland in 2001 for a year and again in 2004 and haven't been back to live. Get back a few times a year on holidays though. My work has brought me to over 40 countries and i have lived and met some amazing people.
Now every time i go home i don't want to have to leave. despite everything that is wrong at home Ireland is still one of the very best countries in the whole world. And never let anyone tell you any otherwise.
This always struck a chord with me. watching my pals leave these shores to far flung places like my ancestors in search of a better life. They may indeed find it. There are 70 million people on this planet who identify as irish. There is 5 million who inhabit this small island still. We are a nation of famine refugees... war refugees... AND economic refugees. I am thankful that the world now embraces us as the beautiful, inteligent and dynamic people we are. I wish it wasn't the case, but still every few months I attend a "going away party" of a friend I love and may never see again in the flesh. The southern hemisphere calls with oportinity on banana farms a plenty. things are getting better here. But are they ever gonna be so good that we can trust our elected officials to do what's best for our citizens. I'm stuck here now till I can manufacture an oportinity to get my daughter out of this corrupt hell hole. I want her to grow up in a place where her 1 single vote actually counts and we're not governed by a disgusting corrupt regime that the irish people have been stuck with the last 5 years. Our people deserve more. better. We want our people home. We need to stop sending our best and brightest to other countries. We need them here. With our educated workforce we could build a super economy... providing we have the correct leader ship. anyway onto my major point. We irish are a travelling people. We are educated and skilled. We also needed help over the past 150 years. We need to help these refugees from that war torn area of Syria and Iraq. an irish person who cannot identify with the plight of these people needs to seriously look at our history and see what we have accomplished when WE were given a chance. within 100 years of the great famine (an gorta mor) we had an irish man in the white house...
What...
Old OddJobs you are very naive
Love it. I left Belfast 25 years ago, landed in America. The kid had a few great lines in there, very good stuff.
Its so strange to see so many comments about how this video made ppl home sick when this video just reminds me how much i want to leave.... long nites, cold weather, dark times, been ripped off, there is no craic left dont be fooled by your visit home if ya lived here it wouldnt be so great all the time so enjoy your visit its always great to see ya's... when i use to travel i would always missed home but i dont think there is anything left to miss but family.
I agree it has changed a lot. Irish people are ripped off and just accept it most of the time
I've lived in london for 8 years, now Australia for 17yrs, I've lived outa Ireland for longer than I've lived there. I will always be Irish and Ireland will always be home, even though I now have 2. This clip is class, so on the money and so well put together, but I reckon only the Irish will get it. I think it's because we are like one, we are unique.
Left Dublin and live a far better life in the sun in Sydney. Don't miss that rainy kip
Been out of Ireland 35 years and miss the damm place, I,m a bogman from the whest coast but love Dublin. I've learnt other languages and travelled and met amazing people . The republic is almost a failed project with a low quality political class, get out if you can and open your eyes. It's tough but waiting for change is tougher. By leaving you create change and above all you can see what Ireland could have become had not the gombeen class kidnapped it.
Dublin is a different but still a brilliant place. This video captures it all.
When I was about to graduate last year, we all started to ask each other 'where are you going?', not 'are you going?', it seemed like there were very little options. A lot of us have stayed.
And the craic is still mighty most of the time.
I left twenty-four years ago to Canada, came back four years ago, now I'm more homesick for Toronto than I was for Dublin. The Dublin we left is no longer, streets and attitudes have changed. Emmet is right,10 reasons to go, too many little excuses to stay. To anyone considering returning, don't waste your time, what you left is history, stay where you are, it can't be as bad as here. To anyone considering leaving, go for it! Great film, well done, deserves an Oscar.
How are you getting on now? Did you go back to Canada? Your right in what you say.. I left Dublin 10 years ago...I go back every couple of years to see friends and family... but only for a few days and I'm gone again...
fantastic. the million tiny reasons are the reasons ill be coming home. Great vid!
"Any craic?"
"No, youse fucked off"
That line cuts right into you
This is absolutely beautiful in all respects. Videography, spoken word, all of it. I've got a weight in my heart after listening 3 times, in a god way and a melancholic way at the same time. It's heartbreaking to think of everyone who has had to leave this place I adore. Even I myself am one foot in and out, at this point here only for the love of the place and people. Ah!
Absolutely epic portrayal of a young person left in Ireland at the moment....... little here for them but still cant leave.
Very few things have touched my heart like this before
When I first watched this I was in London this video was one of the reasons I decided to return home. 9 years later I'm back in the North West of England. Ireland has failed us.
Get shivers down the spine listening to this having lived abroad myself, been there and tried it out. Such a moving video
I always find myself coming back to this. Amazing.
Know the feeling. Great job Emmet and all involved. Really touching.
I have just moved home to Dublin again after three years in the UK. This film had me in tears, not because it made me feel better for moving home, but because it managed to capture every mixed emotion I'm going through in a few short minutes. Thanks to the makers.
Left Ireland in '97 to travel. Had an opportunity to move back beginning of 2010 but the warning signs were there. Living in Canada for 7 years now. The amount of Irish here compared to when I first came is astonishing. Love being Irish but I've always felt more Irish abroad than at home.
This is a superb piece of work! Love Dublin
Still love this!
Congratulations everyone involved in the making of this piece of Art. Brilliant job everyone. Get ready for the awards to come flooding in.
I see your point. I'm a home bird myself and can't ever imagine leaving Ireland for good, for all it's flaws I still love it. Just because there's tough times I can't bring myself to leave. Love the country too much. We've left this country in droves over the last couple of centuries, possibly even further back, but we have to try and fix things eventually, they don't fix themselves.
We have the potential to be great, we just don't seem to believe in ourselves and constantly seek validation.
you speak what all young people think but we forget... your a genius ,man
Gets me every time. "London and Sydney swallow up your mates" and they have. great poem an Emmett does it justice. thanks
This is absolutely amazing.
I really love this video!!! Amazing performance and great speech. I'm learning a lot about irish and Ireland when i watch this videos. Thanks a lot. Awesome work.
I love every beat of this.
One of the best videos on this anyone that knows somebody that traveled the world will understand
Powerful. Love it.
Best Irish short film I've seen in I don't know how long. Awesome.
Love, love this.
2 months later and I'm still watching this almost daily. It gives me goosebumps every time.
Brilliant, absolutely brilliant.
love it great stuff
Absolutely beautiful.
This is absolutely super. Thank you.
I love this video... Speaks for itself really.
Simply brilliant. Well done to all involved.
Haunting indictment on immigration and those left behind. I left Ireland 20 years ago - this strikes a cord. Bravo Mr. Tynan, excellent piece.
This is quality! As someone who left Dublin for a long time and has now been home for over 3 years i find myself thinking at times "Yeah this city is a bit shit, and yeah maybe some parts of it are a dump" but so what its our city and at the end of the day i love it!
Delighted to have seen this on RTE. Still one of my favourite clips on youtube this year.
Never get tired of this.
Absolutely Beautiful.
Congratulations David!
Fabulous.
ST Patrick's Day 2023 watching this as everyone I know lives abroad now including myself and realizing how relevant this still is
Love this video, always makes me homesick. It's been four years
This is quite simply beautiful.
Can't stop watching this, it's so good!
A very poignant expression of life in your 20's. Beautifully written and shot. Emigrated in 1977 to America with my family when I was 7. Back since 1999, raising my own family.Totally understand Dave's film. Keep it up!
I was shown this in transition year.. almost nine years later I still listen a couple of times a year. I’m not sure if there’s anything that quite captures the minutia of what it means to be Irish, the good and bad. Amazing
Either way, he's a character. And he's a good character because he's complex -- he doesn't have to be likeable. Resentment or being bitter is a part of life for some people, and it's perfectly valid to make a short movie about it.
Back here 7 years after leaving the first time. Faced with same decision again.
Stunning. Brilliant.
I forgot how good this was
Philip McGrath
This is one of the most exceptional short films I have ever seen. Acting is just brilliant & the script is phenomenal
Take a bow please everyone involved
Brilliant!!!
Brings it home, everyone can relate to this clip somehow
Keep watching this, almost every week
I've left dublin, il prob never go back but if I had to re-live my life id coose dublin, but I'd make a 1000 different choices.
Amazing, love it
This is fantastic.
Great video.The words spoken were well chosen and it captures what everyone hears being said every week up and down this land of ours.
For someone who has been through the whole process of immigrating abroad on a few occasions and is now back living in Ireland, This is a very moving piece, sums it all up ,
Brilliantly captures the complexity of staying in or leaving Ireland. Class video. Respect.
Fantastic.
Very moving with an incredible script. I love the urban rawness of the imagery the speaker portrays and the element of reality he brings across.
Well done.
How has this escaped my attention until now? Powerful stuff; great script, great acting, great production!
Perfect!!
Masterpiece
I love this piece. Gets me every time I watch it
Well done, what a fabulous piece of work.