ASOIAF: Old Empire of Ghis

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 166

  • @wailrimouch4973
    @wailrimouch4973 8 років тому +245

    What he says:"The Ghisscari war " what I hear "the First Punic war"

    • @g-rexsaurus794
      @g-rexsaurus794 8 років тому +10

      I don´t, because they are totally different.

    • @akrybion
      @akrybion 8 років тому +42

      G-Rex Saurus Wait, so Rome didn't conquer Carthage with the might of dragons?

    • @g-rexsaurus794
      @g-rexsaurus794 8 років тому +10

      Even if you remove dragons there is still quite the difference there.

    • @puchy110
      @puchy110 7 років тому +37

      they're simular in that you have a old established trading empire being crushed by a small, aspiring empire

    • @historyrhymes1701
      @historyrhymes1701 6 років тому +6

      Ghiskar- Kartagen
      Valyria- Romе

  • @moseslemann7923
    @moseslemann7923 8 років тому +120

    Punic Wars. It's the Punic Wars.

  • @jacksonwarren8193
    @jacksonwarren8193 8 років тому +79

    I'm getting a Greek vs Persia vibe here. Definitely a mix with the Punic Wars as well.

    • @thebluerena
      @thebluerena 8 років тому +2

      Jack War like trojan war?

    • @jacksonwarren8193
      @jacksonwarren8193 8 років тому +2

      resa naura Well the Trojan war can be seen as more of a Greek vs. Greek ordeal.

    • @brooooooooooo5449
      @brooooooooooo5449 8 років тому +12

      Wrong bro! More like carthage vs rome

    • @liamjm9278
      @liamjm9278 5 років тому +6

      @@brooooooooooo5449 That's what the Punic wars were.

    • @mac2857
      @mac2857 2 роки тому +1

      Qarth = Persia
      Ghis = Carthage

  • @narff1
    @narff1 8 років тому +74

    You should do a video on the Century of Blood.
    Excellent video as always :)

    • @CivilizationEx
      @CivilizationEx  8 років тому +16

      Definitely will at some point :)

    • @sameeramahalekame7992
      @sameeramahalekame7992 8 років тому

      CivilizationEx hey great vid as as always nice fact is that the tall men are the Indian equivalent of planetos

  • @Horesmi
    @Horesmi 7 років тому +95

    That moment when you decide "screw Westeros!" and restore old Ghis as Daenerys.

    • @ayylmao575
      @ayylmao575 7 років тому +17

      AlHoresmi Its always good to see another CK2 Game of Thrones player.

    • @ungefiezergreeter6034
      @ungefiezergreeter6034 4 роки тому +5

      Heyyy GOT ck2 players where you at

    • @rasallyjohansen3951
      @rasallyjohansen3951 2 роки тому +4

      lmao i literally just played as a blackfyre and restoring the ghiscari empire because i tried overthrowing the targaryens and backing my sibling daemon blackfyre in his rebellion but ironically the blackfyre rebellion failed and daemon got executed, and now im gearing up for another blackfyre rebellion im just rebuilding my strength in ghiscar first, right now i got unsullied some mercenaries a huge fleet, my ghiscari legions(levies) and also a dragon so should be easy since i also got an alliance with some dothraki and with the arryns of the vale and the martells of dorne:) oh and i have war elephants

    • @skeletonbuyingpealts7134
      @skeletonbuyingpealts7134 Рік тому

      Ayo 🤨📸

    • @nicklepin7133
      @nicklepin7133 Рік тому

      More like restore Valyria but in ghiscari but yes I definitely agree

  • @morfrido
    @morfrido 8 років тому +14

    The empire of Ghis reminds me of Cartago, and the Valyrians to Rome. Both were great powers of ancient times, and even the legions of Ghis and the roads of Valyria (as seen in Volantis) make the similarities stronger.

    • @prealtezeratul1133
      @prealtezeratul1133 Місяць тому

      Mu questiin were the legion of ghus were luke the roman legions or more like hoplites? In trems of arments and figthing style wise

  • @Hallzerk
    @Hallzerk 7 років тому +3

    hey Mr civilization ex. I love your vids, always short and different than other channels. I love to listen to 4-5 vids while falling asleep

  • @CadaverJunky8
    @CadaverJunky8 8 років тому +65

    OLD GHIS WILL RISE AGAIN!!!!!!

    • @silvertemplar8061
      @silvertemplar8061 6 років тому +3

      CadaverJunky would love to see that happen, but Daenerys is the heir of the cruel Valyrians

    • @ensvenskperson7661
      @ensvenskperson7661 5 років тому +7

      Resistance Commander The Ghiscari were also cruel tyrants.

    • @trombz2007
      @trombz2007 5 років тому +2

      Make Old Empire of This great again!

    • @silvertemplar8061
      @silvertemplar8061 5 років тому +3

      Well despite their use of slavery it seems the Valyrians where worse plus they had other economies.

    • @BronzetheGolden
      @BronzetheGolden 3 роки тому

      @@silvertemplar8061 Valyria had slaved to, DON'T FORGET THAT

  • @rodrigomiranda2996
    @rodrigomiranda2996 8 років тому +6

    the way you describe ASOIAF is great i love it, keep up the good work CivilizationEx.

  • @jegvids101
    @jegvids101 8 років тому +72

    Ghiscari wars = Punic Wars?

  • @blackflagsnroses6013
    @blackflagsnroses6013 8 років тому +50

    What real world civilizations would you say the Ghiscari Empire is influenced from? I'd say a blend of Ancient Egyptian and Islamic cultures.

    • @CadaverJunky8
      @CadaverJunky8 8 років тому +24

      Pretty much. Their warring with Valyria is similar to the long feud between the Persian empire and the Mediterranean states/Rome.

    • @CivilizationEx
      @CivilizationEx  8 років тому +50

      It's definetly a mix of many cultures but I personally see ancient Persians, mixed with a little Greek because of their military formations, mixed with Carthaginians as the Vayria wars resemble the punic wars. But I definetly could see some ancient Egyptian and Islamic cultural influences as well. Like with their pyramids for example. :)

    • @blackflagsnroses6013
      @blackflagsnroses6013 8 років тому +1

      CivilizationEx Yes Persian, that is the most apt for the Ghis. Can't believe it slip my mind. True it's a blend of many, but the Persian is most similar.

    • @tobigforyou
      @tobigforyou 8 років тому +6

      Carthage primarily, with a little bit of Persian and Islamic influences. These wars clearly resemble the Punic Wars fought between Rome(Valyria) and Carthage(Ghis).

    • @CamelsHighOnCrayons
      @CamelsHighOnCrayons 8 років тому +16

      The Carthaginian Empire has many similarities with Ghis. Carthage was an ancient power, much older than Rome was to the north. Carthage had several colonies along the east side of the Iberian Peninsula, founding the cities of Saguntum and Carthago Nova along the Spanish coast. The Punic Wars, the series of conflicts between Carthage and Rome, is undeniably an influence for the Ghiscari wars. With the first war ending in a minor victory for the Romans (Valyrians), the second was very much the same as the first as a minor victory for the Romans. However at this point the Romans had the upper hand, Carthage would never regain its initial strength, and by the third Punic war (forth Ghiscari war), the Romans (Valyrians) won decisively, tearing down the city of Carthage (Ghis) and salting the lands. The city of Tunis (New Ghis), which still stands to this day as the capital of Tunisia, was built atop the rubble of the once prestigious city of the long lost Carthaginians. After years of occupation by the Romans and the Umayyad Caliphate, the culture of the Carthaginians was lost, with most now speaking Arabic (High Valyrian) and identifying as Berber Arabs.

  • @shtyepaancz9642
    @shtyepaancz9642 8 років тому +12

    It would be great if you one day did an episode on the Northern Kingdoms from the Witcher universe. :)

  • @KingMckay
    @KingMckay 8 років тому +3

    Great video like always :D

  • @PCGameNerd917
    @PCGameNerd917 7 років тому +5

    So Valyria is GoT Rome and Ghis is GoT Carthage and Persia?

  • @rd0676
    @rd0676 7 років тому +4

    So they saw the token black people in all of game of thrones at the summer isles and ran away immediately assuming they're demons. 10/10 would bang

  • @philipnguyen8591
    @philipnguyen8591 8 років тому +9

    YOU ARE GREAT

  • @blazedbeyond898
    @blazedbeyond898 8 років тому +5

    Can u do the Jogos nhia history? If there is much known

    • @alex-sv8ru
      @alex-sv8ru 7 років тому +1

      Blazed Beyond nope, the Jogos Nhai's history and any civillization east of the bone mountains are unknown.

  • @jordanhodges7721
    @jordanhodges7721 8 років тому +3

    Ever read The Dark Tower series? Videos about Mid World would be cool.

  • @grantwilson4506
    @grantwilson4506 8 років тому +2

    Could you please do a video on Cade Skywalker or Darth Krayt? Sorry, I know I keep asking, I'm just eager.

  • @wailrimouch4973
    @wailrimouch4973 8 років тому +96

    so:
    Yi Ti: China and most of Asia
    Jugois nai: The Mongols
    Dothraki: the huns
    Westeros: Europe
    Ghiscarri Cartage/Egypte /India
    Valerya: Rome/ The Islamic Empire
    Sothoryous: Africa
    The Summer Isles : The Carribean/ Medeterainean isles

    • @shadow6543
      @shadow6543 8 років тому +1

      No

    • @shadow6543
      @shadow6543 8 років тому +37

      The Valeryians were closer to the Romans and Greeks think Roman Empire and Hellenistic Greek empire not so much the middle east, and Ghiscar was heavily inspired by the Persians and Cartage not really India

    • @RD-un2qk
      @RD-un2qk 8 років тому +3

      shadow6543
      he is muslim himself so he sees the middle east different
      dorne is more like the middle east

    • @kyekimler
      @kyekimler 8 років тому +18

      Also Westeros is more specifically the UK, not the entirety of Europe.

    • @RD-un2qk
      @RD-un2qk 8 років тому

      LagiNaLangAko23
      you are right
      the nature is like middle east but culture not
      i think asshai by tge shadow is more like old perzia or mekka cuz is full of darkness and terror

  • @troyguenther7572
    @troyguenther7572 7 років тому

    You forgot that the Ghiscari have red-black hair in your depiction starting at 3:48. Great video, though!

  • @sskspartan
    @sskspartan 8 років тому +6

    so they had dark skin, yet they got scared away by people just a bit darker?! It's strange, because, even though it was much later, not even the blonde and blue eyed Lannisters have any fears concerning the Summer Islander in their court

    • @whatsyourexcuse384
      @whatsyourexcuse384 8 років тому

      sskspartan they thought they were demons, maby westerosians dont belive in demons.

    • @axelNodvon2047
      @axelNodvon2047 8 років тому +1

      sskspartan because they were known already to have dark skin? This isnt strange when the chinese saw black us soldiers in korea they were scared too

    • @TheFiresloth
      @TheFiresloth 7 років тому +3

      That's a common occurence. Arabs are darker than most europeans, yet were very racist toward blacks. Europeans are darker than northern chinese, yet often fought Turks. Etc...

    • @alex-sv8ru
      @alex-sv8ru 7 років тому

      sskspartan They are Caucasian, but they just have more of a tanned skin...

  • @nicklepin7133
    @nicklepin7133 Рік тому +1

    The Ghiscari wars is basically Carthage mixed with ancient Egypt fighting Rome.
    Except in this case it’s fantasy and one side has dragons and the other had an actual military instead on mercenaries

  • @MaryJanesLounge
    @MaryJanesLounge 8 років тому +5

    Great stuff! Did the wars happen relatively close to one another or were they more spread out? Can't find a time frame and you've peaked my interest.

    • @puchy110
      @puchy110 8 років тому +1

      I believe they were relatively close to one another, although I'm taking information from their historical inspiration; the Punic Wars.

  • @rizkymubaroq3025
    @rizkymubaroq3025 5 років тому +4

    ghiscari empire must be very strong imagine aegon with only 3 dragon, he qonquered whole westeros, and ghiscari empire able to win some battle againts valyria which have sheet ton of dragon.

    • @TheFiresloth
      @TheFiresloth 5 років тому

      I wonder if they had their own forgotten magic, like the Rhoynars.

    • @AstroSully
      @AstroSully 3 роки тому +1

      The Unsullied were heavily influenced by the Old Ghiscari Legions. Imagine an army of 200,000+ Super Unsullied soldiers. The Valyrians were just too strong with their dragons. It’s like ancient greeks/persians fighting against a Fighter Jet.

    • @left4deadian
      @left4deadian 2 роки тому

      They probably had ballistas and killed a few dragons.

  • @vtron9832
    @vtron9832 8 років тому +4

    I wonder what Ghis would have been like if it killed Valyria

  • @jackj9816
    @jackj9816 8 років тому +5

    So sense danny rules the dothraki dose that mean they not going to raid anymore

    • @jackj9816
      @jackj9816 8 років тому

      LagiNaLangAko23 i mean the ones that are with her like she wants to rule with peace but they will destroy shit

    • @akrybion
      @akrybion 8 років тому

      Jack J Unlikely she can change a.people's culture in only a couple if years.

  • @littlepipthetoasterrepairp8731
    @littlepipthetoasterrepairp8731 5 років тому +2

    I really loved George R.R Martin's novels "A Song Of Ice & Fire"

  • @QueenDaenerysTargaryen
    @QueenDaenerysTargaryen 3 роки тому +1

    Dracarys🔥💥🔥💥🔥💥 🐉🐉🐲

  • @hosenOne1
    @hosenOne1 8 років тому +5

    who makes up all these lores?... GRR?... just random fan made lores?
    like in which book are all these lands and wars mentioned? .... please clarify the sources

    • @TheFiresloth
      @TheFiresloth 7 років тому +3

      It's from A World of Ice and Fire, an official addendum to the saga. A lot of it is referenced in the books.

    • @cephalonrolli5678
      @cephalonrolli5678 2 роки тому

      @@TheFiresloth is that just 1 book or a series

  • @makinglegends1329
    @makinglegends1329 8 років тому +4

    did the Valyrians lose a war ever

    • @youisa1
      @youisa1 8 років тому +5

      making legends Yes. when they didnt have dragons.

    • @davidking6242
      @davidking6242 8 років тому +1

      the valyrian empire of volantis fell as did the valyrian targaryen dynasty of westeros

    • @aman8450
      @aman8450 7 років тому

      making legends they lose a few battles.One of them is in the second spice war against rhoynar ,Prince Garin of Chroyane defeated 100,000 men and kills two dragons.The Valyrian later respond with an overwhelming force of 300 dragons,they manage to catch the prince and burn the entire army of the rhoynish

  • @Kunumbah1
    @Kunumbah1 8 років тому +5

    You should do Elder Scrolls lore as well.

    • @jegvids101
      @jegvids101 8 років тому +1

      Shiku Bah Yes! He really should

  • @mansamusa8410
    @mansamusa8410 5 років тому +2

    I thought the valyrians enslaved the sarnori why were they fighting alongside them

    • @CivilizationEx
      @CivilizationEx  5 років тому +1

      In the beginning the Sarnori were divided, some allied with the Valyrians, and others fought against them. Later those that remained joined together but by then it was too late.

  • @iceost541
    @iceost541 8 років тому

    u got your 100k trophy thingy ? :)

  • @americantraphole5858
    @americantraphole5858 8 років тому +2

    please start doing WHEEL OF TIME videos

    • @CivilizationEx
      @CivilizationEx  8 років тому +3

      I'd love too, it's on of my fav series, but it would be a huge commitment so it may be awhile before I have time. I do hope to get to it one day though! :)

    • @tg1982
      @tg1982 8 років тому

      I don't know what WHEEL OF TIME is but now I'm really interested.

    • @americantraphole5858
      @americantraphole5858 8 років тому +1

      Alberto Chávez wheel of time is an epic fantasy by robert jordan. its about a man named rand al thor who is a reincarnated ancient wizard destined to battle and save the world from the dark one who is locked away in another dimension. but if any wizard uses magic he will eventually go insane.

    • @accountof32
      @accountof32 8 років тому

      Have you done any Stormlight Archive Videos?

    • @brgorn2603
      @brgorn2603 8 років тому +1

      Hey I'm reading that series now

  • @silasnai2290
    @silasnai2290 2 роки тому

    Interesting that the slavers are like Egypt/ME coded and not Dutch coded considering chattel slavery was the most profitable. thats kind of a twist.

  • @yasoum9286
    @yasoum9286 8 років тому

    Valyria really looks a lot like the roman empire but also the islamic empire

    • @g-rexsaurus794
      @g-rexsaurus794 8 років тому +2

      No it doesn´t. How does it resemble a Caliphate in any sense?

    • @servantofallah1698
      @servantofallah1698 8 років тому

      G-Rex Saurus killed people?? Maybe?

    • @g-rexsaurus794
      @g-rexsaurus794 8 років тому +2

      that´s quite a low standard.

  • @Adrian-fz7kg
    @Adrian-fz7kg 5 років тому +2

    I'm my opinion the Ghiscari, not the Valyrians, are more similar to the Roman's of the real world.
    Like the Roman's, they began as a single city-state and had enormous amounts of slaves.
    Their armies were literary called legions. The Valyrians are a fantasy empire with no real world analog.

    • @bias2784
      @bias2784 2 роки тому

      I think Ghis is seen as the equivalent of Egypt because it is the most ancient large civilisation known (west of the bone mountains / not sure if Sarnor is older), and obviously the Pyramids and style / culture.
      Valyrians are seen as the romans because they destroyed ghis like the romans destroyed egypt, and became the new most powerful culture. And they greatly furthered technology like the romans. The valyrian roads are also obviously inspired by the roman roads.

  • @GadflySwats
    @GadflySwats 8 років тому +4

    Dog is flavorful?

  • @sebastianperez3437
    @sebastianperez3437 8 років тому +1

    first comment!!!

  • @Stalkman13
    @Stalkman13 8 років тому

    real recognizes real

  • @LesOubliesQuebec
    @LesOubliesQuebec 8 років тому

    one punch man ? :P

  • @mikesmith8656
    @mikesmith8656 8 років тому +4

    Valyria>Ghis

  • @daltonnfields1442
    @daltonnfields1442 2 роки тому

    This really throws Danaerys conquest of slavers Bay into a new light. They basically needed slavery as a way to survive after the total destruction of their land by her people. Then she comes in again and takes it over and to add insult she's doing it with an army that best represents the traditions of their ancient armies. No wonder they wanted her gone ahah.

  • @johnvonshepard9373
    @johnvonshepard9373 8 років тому +2

    Trump will make Ghis Great again!!