Scotts Broadcast Spreader Driveway Test | Buyer Beware |

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 жов 2019
  • Before you use these on you lawn, test to understand the pattern they produce. #thedrivewaychallenge
    See my other spreader videos.
  • Наука та технологія

КОМЕНТАРІ • 134

  • @majfeb17
    @majfeb17 3 роки тому +10

    Exactly my problem!!! Couldn't think of why it was leaving such heavy lines in my yard and now I know!! Great video!!

  • @rotarycomptech
    @rotarycomptech Рік тому +3

    I’m glad you put this video out. I was thinking of doing the same thing. I bought one of those about eight or 10 years ago and hated it so much that I called the factory to complain. They acted like I was a complete idiot. I threw the spreader away and got a used Lesco broadcaster, which worked great for years 8 to be exact, my girlfriend bought me a new Scotts spreader for my birthday the same kind I had an issue with. You can imagine how that conversation went.

  • @keithp115
    @keithp115 3 роки тому +8

    Just bought a Scotts DLX this week, and found your post today. Wish I would have done more research!

  • @bernardoconnor7454
    @bernardoconnor7454 3 роки тому +3

    I work so hard on my lawn. Thank you so much. I used my Scott's just yesterday. Never again,. Thank you thank you.

  • @SuzyJarman
    @SuzyJarman 2 роки тому +1

    Brilliant! Thank you. I am about to purchase one of these spreaders. So pleased I watched this video.
    👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

  • @Adrian-yu6ti
    @Adrian-yu6ti 4 роки тому +7

    Yep , I ended up with stripes and checkerboard lines despite being very careful. My mind is blown. Thank you so much

  • @rickmcbryer1122
    @rickmcbryer1122 3 роки тому +2

    Thank you!!!! I couldn’t understand why my lawn was greener where along the path I walked behind the rotary spreader. Very helpful!

  • @woofinu
    @woofinu 3 роки тому +2

    Excellent testing method. I learned something new. Thank you.

  • @Route32rg
    @Route32rg 2 роки тому +1

    Best spreader vider ever!! Wow, just like the previous comment, I never thought of looking at this.

  • @jodygrimmett3745
    @jodygrimmett3745 2 роки тому +1

    Wow!!.Thank you sir. I learned something today. I was about to buy the Scott spreader but after seeing your video...I now know what to look for. Very helpful to a first time buyer. 👍🏽

  • @toddolatheks.1328
    @toddolatheks.1328 4 роки тому +14

    You should forward this video to Scotts.
    Thanks 🙏

    • @tomdurkins
      @tomdurkins 3 роки тому

      Scott’s won’t care. The have spent millions in advertising to build their name. They know people are lazy and will just buy the name they recognize.

  • @osublows17
    @osublows17 4 роки тому +27

    Edge guard does the same thing. Wish I saw this video first. Who would think Scott's coult screw up such a simple task...

    • @danvitous1085
      @danvitous1085 4 роки тому

      I've had mine for a few years. It wasn't til I started seeing posts this year about striping did I really bothered to notice, and sure enough... I got stripes! Mighta been there last year, but definitely this year.

    • @tomdurkins
      @tomdurkins 3 роки тому +1

      If you see a company advertising on TV buy the competitors product that doesn’t advertise. Works every time and will save you tens of thousands of dollars over a lifetime. And if you apply this to food you’ll also live a heather life.

    • @Jet7Xcountry
      @Jet7Xcountry 2 місяці тому

      Lol I mean that's probably somewhat true but not a guarantee ​@@tomdurkins

  • @jkprojectsnstuff697
    @jkprojectsnstuff697 3 роки тому +8

    This is something I've never thought about! Thank you. I'm taking my Scotts spreader back and I'll be looking for any spreader that has the broadcaster above the wheels. Subscribed and looking forward to watching more of your videos.

    • @jasweb147
      @jasweb147 2 роки тому

      A year later, which did you purchase. I need a new spreader, Scotts is the worst!

    • @jkprojectsnstuff697
      @jkprojectsnstuff697 2 роки тому

      @@jasweb147 Sorry for the late reply. I ended up getting the GroundWork spreader from Tractor Supply. It has air pneumatic tires and moves well across the grass. Although I'm not in love with it, it has worked out better than the Scotts spreader.

    • @jasweb147
      @jasweb147 2 роки тому +1

      @@jkprojectsnstuff697 Thanks for the reply. I purchased the Scotts Elite spreader a couple of weeks ago. It is far better than their previous lines of spreader (if your lawn is not bumpy) and I was quiet impressed. The impeller sits above the wheels and it had a nice spread pattern. I ended up returning it because I would need pneumatic tires for my bumpy lawn. I decided to purchase a nice backpack sprayer and I'm going with a liquid program now.

  • @Neejay
    @Neejay Рік тому +2

    Man, thank you for sharing!!! I was wondering why I had clumped up and extra granules on the inside of the wheels + trails. I'll be buying the red one, as one seen it used on other yard channels. Thanks again!!

  • @donallen7830
    @donallen7830 Рік тому +1

    Thanks...going to buy a broadcast spreader today...you might have saved me.

  • @MsLincos
    @MsLincos 4 роки тому

    Thank you for the vid Tommy, very useful!

  • @CLT_NC
    @CLT_NC Рік тому +1

    Kudos and thank you for sharing. I thought the Scott’s Mini Broadcast Spreader I purchased would be perfect for the three small areas of sod on my property. After watching your video, I returned the Mini, and hope to find a better option.

  • @williambuyarski2070
    @williambuyarski2070 3 роки тому +1

    Great job...exactly what happened, now I know why! Thank you!

  • @davebaer8504
    @davebaer8504 3 роки тому +3

    Thank so much for your video. Helped me make the decision to avoid the Scotts spreader.

  • @DBK155
    @DBK155 3 роки тому +1

    That explains what happened to my yard & the stripes. Bought a Scotts spreader & fertilizer & did it myself the first time.

  • @jonm3255
    @jonm3255 9 місяців тому +1

    Hi Tommy, I know the folks at Scotts R&D very well and forwarded this on to them. I know who worked on the Scotts Elite and can tell you a lot of time was put into testing the particle distribution. The dual rotor makes a huge difference in balancing the left to right distribution.

    • @andrewlucas1595
      @andrewlucas1595 Місяць тому

      Great, but that doesn't change the fact that all these are dog shit.

  • @TRUMP_WAS_RIGHT_ABOUT_EVRYTHNG
    @TRUMP_WAS_RIGHT_ABOUT_EVRYTHNG 2 роки тому +1

    Excellent video! I have been wondering why the hell my lawn has the extra green stripes! I'm gonna try to fix this Scott's rotary spreader today!

  • @garyraynes
    @garyraynes 3 роки тому +3

    Tommy T, thanks for taking the time to demonstrate and post the video. I just threw out an almost new DLX spreader because of the striping. They've been doing this for how long, and can't put out a well designed, affordable broadcast spreader? I'm done with Scott's products. Fortunately, there are options. Thanks again.

  • @bloophero
    @bloophero 3 роки тому +2

    Just buying my first spreader, Earthway it is! Thanks Tommy, I very nearly bought a Scott one (I guess they're priced accordingly).

  • @daweller
    @daweller Рік тому +1

    1st video I have seen where someone just uses the darn thing with no fancy music or talking. Thanks

  • @sjgoff
    @sjgoff 2 роки тому +1

    For the people experiencing "striping" in the lawn after fertilizing. The number one cause, is too much overlap. Make sure your passes are 5 feet apart. I helped my neighbor a couple years ago having this problem. I could see he was only moving over a couple feet between passes. He doesn't have any striping issues now. We both use the Scotts edge guard.

  • @marvinwinter301
    @marvinwinter301 Рік тому +1

    I had purchased a Scott’s spreader with edge guard and found the same thing when applying fertilizer it would leave a line from hitting the wheel. I complained to Scott’s online and also complained to a Scott’s representative at Home Depot with no results, I even sent pictures. I ended up returning the spreader to Home Depot.

  • @petedetraglia4776
    @petedetraglia4776 Рік тому

    I've used the Scotts mini spreader with edge guard and never noticed a center heavy striping in my grass. I use the 4.5 setting on my spreader and don't over lap my pattern. It may be center heavy on the pavement but never had any issues with lawn striping. Also almost every time I fertilize I water it in directly after spreading and again never have any issues...I could imagine if you use the wrong setting such as a high number than on the fertilizer bag you may have issues. Overlapping is the #1 issue for stripping or burning your lawn. Also I never fertilize in high heat or direct sunlight. Usually close to dusk when the temperatures are lower...

  • @t-rev525
    @t-rev525 4 роки тому +3

    I put a large nut under the spreader part. It raised the spreader with my scale laying on it around 1/4 inch above the wheels. I also cut out cardboard to place on the inside of the wheels. Seems to work a little better.

    • @TommyTester
      @TommyTester  4 роки тому

      Great idea!

    • @SUPERSTROKE333
      @SUPERSTROKE333 3 роки тому

      this worked to prevent stripes?

    • @bellefive2990
      @bellefive2990 3 роки тому

      The spreader rotates but the gearbox housing is stationary. The large nut you put in as a spacer will rub against either the spreader or the gearbox housing when it is in use.

  • @SageOftheSubway
    @SageOftheSubway 3 роки тому +2

    Well, I'll be darned. No wonder I had stripes last summer.

  • @kurtrundell6834
    @kurtrundell6834 11 місяців тому

    The DLX streaked by bermudagrass. It's a crap spreader. My front yard is now a checkerboard. It wasn't what I was doing, it was the fact the paddle is lower than the wheels, and throws the granules into the recessed wheel -- which, of course, drops the granules right onto the grass in a line.

    • @TommyTester
      @TommyTester  11 місяців тому

      YUP! Thanks for sharing your experience.

  • @sangueguerriero9538
    @sangueguerriero9538 3 роки тому

    Thank you

  • @lfgillesby
    @lfgillesby 3 роки тому

    I just bought the DLX and using the same straight edge method, it looks to clear the wheel by a good 1/2". Maybe they redesigned their impeller

  • @user-rk2tz3ew8o
    @user-rk2tz3ew8o Рік тому

    Will 10” pneumatic tires (wheels) added to the DLX spreader fix the stripe problem?

  • @hawaiiantimes7702
    @hawaiiantimes7702 2 роки тому +1

    So much complaints on Scott’s spreaders, you would think the company would fix the problem lol. I got the Scott’s DLX edge guard and I got dem stripes as well. The hollow open wheels acts as a catcher then disperses your fert in a straight line. It’s even worse when the lawn is damp. I’m on my 3rd season with it and now I’m off to Home Depot to pick up the Echo RB 60. Hope it works because it starts to get into the $200-$300 range for spreaders.

  • @hankmancil178
    @hankmancil178 3 роки тому

    That is why I use a drop spreader for fertilizer application( accuracy is important) and a rotary spreader for lawn insect preventer application (accuracy not as important). Of course my lawn size is conducive to using these two methods.

  • @justinwillieradl2209
    @justinwillieradl2209 4 роки тому +8

    I learned this the hard way. Now I have a zebra yard, at least for a few weeks......

    • @TommyTester
      @TommyTester  4 роки тому

      Sorry to hear that. Thanks for sharing your experience.

    • @pastelsliderz3097
      @pastelsliderz3097 4 роки тому +1

      Same here! Learned the hard way any mine broke after a few months. It’s better to spend the money and get a quality spreader

    • @DBK155
      @DBK155 3 роки тому

      Me too. Scott's edgegard

  • @HotDog88GT
    @HotDog88GT 4 роки тому +2

    I use the neighbor's Scott's Speedy Green. Perhaps I'll find another spreader.

  • @michaelmalone9062
    @michaelmalone9062 11 місяців тому +1

    I bought a Scotts Mini edge guard and noticed a big problem with lines. Why can't they do it right?

  • @eu3145
    @eu3145 10 місяців тому

    How about the Scotts Easy Green model? Seems like the spreader is above the wheels!

  • @tsnstt
    @tsnstt 3 роки тому

    What’s the swath spreading distance on this one

  • @jmack619
    @jmack619 2 роки тому

    wire spoked wheels would fix ?

  • @facebookmakesmesick
    @facebookmakesmesick Рік тому

    Mine looked like norhjng was coming out on 4.5. Is that normal

  • @CncObsession
    @CncObsession Рік тому +1

    Not much better than visual proof in testing! Excellent presentation.

  • @stevenmoomey2115
    @stevenmoomey2115 3 роки тому +2

    I have one of those pieces off junk. It was brand new, and I was spreading Scott’s Fertilizer with it and realized it was it wasn’t spreading anywhere near the amount of Fertilizer it was supposed to. They told me to check the gate using a Drill bit Shank. It was way off, told me to send them a 3” piece of the insulated cable, and I’d get a voucher for a new unit. Sent it with tracking, they said they never got the cable piece, which was taped to cardboard, inside a padded envelope. Now I have a Spreader that is completely useless.

    • @donw758
      @donw758 3 роки тому

      Look up dbcs letter machine on UA-cam. These machines process about 35 to 40k letters per hour and are not made for letters with any foreign objects in them. I can almost guarantee your letter jammed and got shredded, including the 5 or so letters that entered the machine behind yours. This sometimes damages the address on the envelope beyond recognition. They are probably being truthful about not receiving it. Sucks that had to happen but it’s all automated and stuff like keys will most likely not make it through these machines.

    • @stevenmoomey2115
      @stevenmoomey2115 3 роки тому

      @@donw758 What?

    • @donw758
      @donw758 3 роки тому

      I’m guessing you it the part in an envelope? If that’s the case then it probably got torn up in the machine. When you send a letter it runs through a DBCS multiple times and there are videos on UA-cam of them in operation

    • @stevenmoomey2115
      @stevenmoomey2115 3 роки тому +1

      @@donw758 They got it per the Tracking Number, and it was sent in a USPS Padded Envelope.

    • @donw758
      @donw758 3 роки тому

      If Scott’s got it according to the tracking # then then they are being shady I guess. That would stop me from buying Scott’s products in the future myself. Sucks that you gotta go through that. Hope it work out for you.

  • @love101a3
    @love101a3 2 роки тому

    Thx

  • @TeslaBoy123
    @TeslaBoy123 Рік тому +1

    I found this problem yesterday when i was using spreader on a new seeding lawn very bad feeling i smell a bad wheel design on all those spreader

  • @princevillekauainorthshore736
    @princevillekauainorthshore736 3 роки тому +2

    Damn, I had this issue today! I use the edge guard and the lawn looks horrible from theses lines.

  • @A.C.71
    @A.C.71 3 роки тому

    ffs, of course I was just about to use my easy green to spread fertilizer for a brand new lawn. I guess im also raking it in afterward and same with the grass seed later so hopefully it will be good enough.

  • @jasweb147
    @jasweb147 2 роки тому

    How does the Scotts Elite compare?

  • @bv2999
    @bv2999 Рік тому

    Would have been nice to demo the Earthway just to Illustrate to Coverage. it would also show the superior Craftsmenship of the unit.

    • @TommyTester
      @TommyTester  Рік тому

      ua-cam.com/video/rY9Lex5F_9Y/v-deo.html

  • @toddolatheks.1328
    @toddolatheks.1328 4 роки тому +3

    Scott’s design team needs to be kicked in the butt. That’s so ridiculous! I own I guess what you would call the medium grade to 1500 square-foot model and I find it the wheels itself drag more than a span I really wish they would’ve put even a rubber coating around that plastic wheel I’m looking for videos right now to see if I can replace them with a different wheel rubber wheel.
    Thanks 🙏

  • @CoroaEntertainment
    @CoroaEntertainment Рік тому

    Get the Scott’s turf builder drop spreader instead of these broadcast ones. No issues with the fert hitting the wheels with a drop spreader.

  • @geeemqu
    @geeemqu Рік тому

    Which Earthway model is that?

  • @MichiGoon
    @MichiGoon 2 роки тому +1

    No it is not. Scott’s accepted my return last fall. While spreading new seed I noticed that there was far more seed concentrated in a very narrow path directly under the spreader. Same problem.

    • @vashon100
      @vashon100 Рік тому

      Accepted vs excepted

    • @MichiGoon
      @MichiGoon Рік тому

      @@vashon100 Thanks. I corrected it.

  • @michaelsanders9147
    @michaelsanders9147 2 роки тому +2

    I wanted to see the Earthway because I need a replacement for my Scotts spreader. I put down seed with the Scotts Edgeguard DLX and it left very heavy lines of seed. I had to go out with a blower to try and disperse the lines which took me more time than throwing it down by hand. Complete engineering catastrophe. Now I'll have spots where the grass is too thick and spots where I'm lacking coverage. I barely had enough seed and now I'll have to buy more expensive seed. Wish I'd realized what a disaster the Scotts spreaders are before I put down the seed. My old Speedy Green Scotts spreader may not have put things down perfectly evenly, but it's much better than what they have now. I refuse to believe they tested the new spreaders. Total garbage.

  • @gmcjetpilot
    @gmcjetpilot 3 роки тому +1

    Why didn't you test the Earthway ev-n-spread?

    • @TommyTester
      @TommyTester  3 роки тому

      This video focused on the Scotts spreaders. The earthway is fine.

    • @gmcjetpilot
      @gmcjetpilot 3 роки тому

      @@TommyTester OK Got it. Went and saw video well done. You inspired me to do own test on a Scotts Turf Builder Mini a Scott's Wizz electric handheld. I put down a 17 ft long blue tarp on the driveway and use Milorganite. I set them for what I thought would be 5lbs per 1000sqft (roughly 1/2 applications). I put in a pound and kept going back and forth until I ran out. I measured the remaining. I'm not a big fan of shaking until you get the last drop. My thinking is just know what the unusable amount is (where it stops feeding) and add that extra. When you shake it it just dumps extra product out. In my Calcs (mini4oz unusable, wiz 2oz unusable) I adjusted my numbers to get a pound rate per area. I repeated and adjusted setting. Of course I collected the miloganite to use.
      The area covered was 17' by 4.5' by the number of passes. Note Scott says the width is 5 feet I think for f 4.5" for mini and 5' for Wizz. Wizz only goes to 9 and does not have the higher volume of a roller. So you ha e to make two passes at a lower setting. The Wiz put out a very even 5-foot forward by 5-foot sides No tires to block. Because it's electric you can't crank it slower; it's always throwing out the max range, but it does have a side guard. For small lawns with lots odd edges and spaces a hand held is best in my opinion.
      Yes the mini has slightly biased pattern to the left but it isn't terrible. *Most of it's going out front in a fan shape and the tires don't affect it.* On the right what I found what affected it the most was the edge guard. Even even when retracted it still extends into the pattern and does affected it a little bit. I think SPEED YOU WALK will effect it. The best rate is about 250 to 300 feet per minute. 1000 sf takes about 3.5 to 4 minutes. This is much faster than I walk for liquid spray applications. You of course have to set the flow of product to match this walk speed.
      All this is contingent on how fast you're pushing the mini. If you're pushing it like an Olympian Sprinter yeah the patterns going to go all over and be uneven. Push it like a little old arthritic lady with a walker the area and distribution of broadcast is affected. If you push a little slower it's going to be more controlled, little narrower and more even (but not old lady slow).
      *Also the spreader tray is not an impeller.* An impeller is something that compresses fluids either liquid or gas. The thing on these broadcast spreaders is a spreader tray.
      I find the hand spreaders are great for my 3500 sqft with all kind of weird shapes and cut-outs 500 sq ft is a hill where a push spreader would never work. Thanks for video. (PS may be drop spreaders are better than broadcast?)

  • @dannypersaud387
    @dannypersaud387 4 роки тому +3

    After I finished my yard I came up the driveway with a long line of debris and lots of build up on the inside right wheel of my small Scott’s spreader. What a POS.

  • @jameseddy6835
    @jameseddy6835 Місяць тому +1

    Ha Tommy if you get a long enough straight edge it will hit the car.

  • @836dmar
    @836dmar 3 роки тому

    Mod time!

  • @MarsMatrix6744
    @MarsMatrix6744 4 роки тому +2

    Any DIY hacks to stop it?

    • @TommyTester
      @TommyTester  4 роки тому

      I thought of making my own spinning plate that had a steeper angle but I never tried it.

    • @goneviral6037
      @goneviral6037 4 роки тому

      Put smaller wheels or huge hollow wheels like a bike tire

    • @bellefive2990
      @bellefive2990 3 роки тому +1

      @@goneviral6037 smaller wheels change the agitator rotation and throw off the calibration

  • @ashzole
    @ashzole 2 роки тому

    can’t you just add a bolt or thick washer and raise it up?

    • @TommyTester
      @TommyTester  2 роки тому

      The shaft is several plastic parts, so you'd have to butcher it up pretty good. They are not meant to be taken apart, but perhaps some out there will try your idea.

  • @Tuyn11
    @Tuyn11 3 роки тому +1

    What a joke. I have a zebra striped lawn now using the DLX model. Now what? Have to use a hand spreader for round 2 on an acre property? Wow.

    • @TommyTester
      @TommyTester  3 роки тому

      Sorry to hear that. Been there.

  • @mrBDeye
    @mrBDeye 2 роки тому

    That's what you get when a company hires people named Scott and Karen.

  • @joshturner5165
    @joshturner5165 2 роки тому

    Well, we should all call the stripes, "Scott's Stripes" whatta POS company. Been around a long time too.

  • @martinharrell1965
    @martinharrell1965 4 роки тому +4

    I bought the scotts deluxe and it streaked my yard terribly. Don’t buy this thing

  • @HotDog88GT
    @HotDog88GT 4 роки тому

    Or you could just use a drop spreader.

    • @TommyTester
      @TommyTester  4 роки тому +1

      If you are off by a few inches, you get an unfertilized stripe. If you overlap your rows, you get a dark green stripe. Drop spreaders are mainly designed to apply grass seed.

    • @raczyk
      @raczyk 3 роки тому

      ​@@TommyTester would this also happen if you apply organic manure fertilizer? Or is precision then not important when using a drop spreader?

  • @LIGHT7CODE7
    @LIGHT7CODE7 3 роки тому +2

    Scotts spreaders are a joke. Don't buy the edge guard mini it will leave fert line. Can't believe they get away with this.

  • @danmccann6666
    @danmccann6666 3 роки тому +5

    Hard to understand the product spread pattern of the Earthway when you don't show it in use at all. Sorry, but a real review shows ALL items to allow somebody to make an educated decision.

    • @TommyTester
      @TommyTester  3 роки тому

      This video was only about the Scotts units as stated in the title and in the intro.

    • @the_original_mathwiz
      @the_original_mathwiz 2 роки тому +1

      @@TommyTester Then why did you display the Earthway? You showed the Scotts were not up to par, but you act as if there may be a problem with the Earthway that don't want to expose. Like Dan stated, why wouldn't you show the superiority of the Earthway?

  • @rph3144
    @rph3144 3 роки тому +2

    Same problem.
    Does Scott’s ever test these things in real life?
    Never buying Scott’s again.
    Pure junk.

  • @Cards-In-The-Closet
    @Cards-In-The-Closet 2 роки тому +1

    I have the DLX and have stripes 😡

  • @TRACKMKIII
    @TRACKMKIII 4 роки тому +1

    Is the Scotts Elite much better?

    • @TommyTester
      @TommyTester  4 роки тому +1

      I've not tested it but it seems better engineered. Thank you.

    • @MichiGoon
      @MichiGoon 2 роки тому

      Same problem with the elite. I returned mine last fall.

  • @dgott7726
    @dgott7726 3 роки тому +1

    No need to test the Earthway??? Ok...

    • @TommyTester
      @TommyTester  3 роки тому

      This was just a test of the Scotts junk. The Earthway is much better.

  • @kalingsaroh3115
    @kalingsaroh3115 2 роки тому

    Really scot is very bad, manufacturer no idea

  • @chadharvy
    @chadharvy 2 роки тому

    your video is biased because you refused to test the last spreader.

  • @Gojira8383
    @Gojira8383 Рік тому

    Yes , hollow cheap wheels. Burn strips every time . I put it out for the trash . Piece of crap

  • @jeffrme
    @jeffrme Рік тому

    All these are junk

  • @IMEMINE.
    @IMEMINE. 8 місяців тому

    Absolute trash each one of them.. obviously made in merica. A REPAIR GUIDE…… $ 90 dollars and two years later, constantly adjusting the dump door by hand, the spring has stretched out. The door has gouges and doesn’t move freely. I had a metal one that I used for 35 years, this
    Millennial era Trump influenced toy is as realizable as a 30 year old showing up at work on Monday or Friday and asking for Tuesday and Wednesday off

  • @amclar2
    @amclar2 Рік тому +1

    I knew it wasn't my fault. I just bought a nice spreader esrthway spreader. F scotts