Mass Effect 3: Choosing the Geth on Rannoch

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 2 жов 2024
  • Another sad scene.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 127

  • @Kangaxxter
    @Kangaxxter 11 років тому +29

    They taunt you with a paragon interrupt, but you can't save her.

  • @edwardv1255
    @edwardv1255 9 років тому +51

    It is times like this I wish they added a psychiatrist to the Normandy crew.

    • @darryljones3009
      @darryljones3009 3 роки тому

      It did have one at one point but then she became a patient.

    • @one-wingedangel5107
      @one-wingedangel5107 2 роки тому +1

      Kelly's job in ME2 was not just limited to being Shepard's assistant in maintaining messages and feeding his or her fish but also checking up on the psychology of the crew and future squad members. The Normandy in ME3 goes to show lack of preparation despite the refitting, there will not be a good ending where everyone survives this time because the best ending possible is barely affordable.

    • @masoprid3
      @masoprid3 2 роки тому +1

      i chose the geth. having a geth prime is what we need to win the war

  • @Skringly
    @Skringly 11 років тому +17

    Huh. I saved both and got the two races working together. Huzzah! :D

  • @jmck5558
    @jmck5558 12 років тому +19

    I was tali boyfriend, Legion died in mass effect 2, Legion was a really good friend even if he was a robot.
    This was one of the hardest decisions in the game for me, after realizing the Quarians where never going to stop hating the Geth and with the Geth just wanting to survive and waning peace I had to decide that they need a chance, the Quarians had wasted their chance just to keep fighting.
    I felt like shit after doing this, but my Shepard always did what he believed in.
    They needed a chance

    • @Quole1234
      @Quole1234 6 років тому

      you are such an idiot. You betrayed tali and her people when the gethw ere the actual villains here. They prevented peace for over 3 centuries you ignorant fuck. learn the lore.

    • @tcmugutc01
      @tcmugutc01 4 роки тому +12

      @@Quole1234 You must be fun at parties. Go in Geth memories and see what happened. See how their government wanted to wipe them out. They defended themselves. Quarians pushed the geth to reaper side.

    • @Quole1234
      @Quole1234 4 роки тому +3

      @@tcmugutc01 ya you are right. I feel stupid now...

    • @maximussaktish
      @maximussaktish 2 роки тому

      I had the same situation as you but i cant let tali die, so i sacrificed the geth, felt really bad about it

    • @allhandsondik7803
      @allhandsondik7803 2 роки тому

      @@maximussaktish thats the thing, is one person out of an entire race, really worth damning a whole other. Tali is one of my favs, but she alone doesn't make the extinction of a race that truly wanted peace justifiable in my eyes.

  • @player276
    @player276 12 років тому +3

    When i first played, i so did not see this coming.

  • @88Hyo
    @88Hyo 11 років тому +8

    the geth never wanted this war,thew Quarian atacked first. the Quarianm started the war many years before that resuklted on them being exiled from their planet,and the get didn't attack backbecause the QUarians were not a threat. also,the Quarians didn't thought twice before shooting the dreadnaught with you inside,and they could have backed away instead of keeping firing. like shepard said,THEY MADE THEIR CHOICE.

    • @Quole1234
      @Quole1234 6 років тому +3

      the geth prevented peace for centuries. read the fucking lore you ignorant fuck. the geth were the villains here. It was the quarians who were forced in to the war. How stupid are you, really?

    • @099Nitro
      @099Nitro 6 років тому

      Wtf you idiot get wiped out 99% of all quarians and kept the war waging for decades. Are you a nazi sympathizer?

    • @shuttlecrossing1433
      @shuttlecrossing1433 3 роки тому +1

      The Quarians attacked first and never tried to negotiate. Then they go after Rannoch under the same refusal for diplomacy with the Geth. Legion says multiple times how they would accept peace if it was offered. The Geth immediately stop firing the instant the Quarians are no longer aggressive against them. They demand nothing and immediately return the planet and start helping the Quarians return home. Even with peace, it takes Shepard convincing the Quarians to cease fire, not the other way around.
      But the Geth didn't lead with a peace offering either, until Shepard showed up. Welcome to allies, neighbors, friends, all estranged and turned enemies throughout history.
      This is a tragedy story. There isn't supposed to be a right and wrong (unless you can thread the needle for peace, which is the reward for being damn good at your job for three games straight).
      There are no winners here.

  • @mastermclovin0
    @mastermclovin0 11 років тому +25

    I hate how they make one renegade one paragon, It would have been better if they made them both neutral or renegade since you are essentially wiping out an entire species either way (avoiding peace)

    • @allhandsondik7803
      @allhandsondik7803 2 роки тому +3

      You're not avoiding peace, the Quarians are, if you can't save both, they had it coming IMO.

    • @Quole1234
      @Quole1234 9 місяців тому

      @@allhandsondik7803 you are completely wrong. how did the millions of innocents have it coming?? The geth sided with the reapers on multiple occasions. THEY had it coming.

    • @allhandsondik7803
      @allhandsondik7803 9 місяців тому +1

      @Quole1234 bro, how do you not expect them to join the Reapers? They're the only things that didn't try to kill the Geth on sight. The whole story of the Geth is them being used and killed by other beings. They're nothing but victims, and if you can't see that, you have no empathy.

    • @Quole1234
      @Quole1234 9 місяців тому

      @@allhandsondik7803 how does that justify trying to wipe out all life?

    • @allhandsondik7803
      @allhandsondik7803 9 місяців тому +1

      @Quole1234 One, most Geth like Legion didn't want total war until the second attack of Rachni. Two, if every other species in the galaxy hates me and wants me dead, you bet I'm fighting all of them until peace is made or I'm the last standing. It's how you survive. You genuinely can't look at things from a different perspective.

  • @MatanuiLaw
    @MatanuiLaw 12 років тому +6

    When i first heard Tali crying... damn I had to restart the whole game to make a nice ending ;( My girlfriend died...

  • @herman1francis
    @herman1francis 12 років тому +12

    I'm a writer so i'm kind of used to killing off characters as a technique to get the audience emotionally involved on the story, and bringing credibility to a tragic storyline. So i rarely get very emotional at character's deaths because i normally see the writer picture behind it... But this... This that we have here, ladys and gentleman, it's fucking writing.

  • @0jutai
    @0jutai 12 років тому +7

    That is fucking heartbreaking...

  • @tcmugutc01
    @tcmugutc01 4 роки тому +7

    Tali, i love you. But it does not change i hate most of quarians. If its about geth even you can be annoying. Both of their firepower ia nice but if i had to choose between id choose geth Tali. You are not enough to sacrifice them

    • @Quole1234
      @Quole1234 9 місяців тому

      oh but the millions of innocents deserve it. Right, that makes sense. The geth sided with the REAPERS. Did you forget that? You are blaming all of the quarians for the admirals, but are not blaming all of the geth for the heretics. You didn't pay attention.

    • @wolfeusmc2011
      @wolfeusmc2011 3 місяці тому +1

      ​@@Quole1234 They achieved sentient life....machine or organic they had the right to preserve their culture and ideals...they turned back to the reapers out of desperation because the Quarians STILL KEPT ATTACKING...

    • @Quole1234
      @Quole1234 3 місяці тому

      @wolfeusmc2011 the geth sided with the reapers in ME1. Of course you conveniently forgot that even after I mentioned it in the comment. If it weren't for shepard the geth would have been directly responsible for galactic genocide.

  • @Naedeslus
    @Naedeslus 12 років тому +8

    This reminds me of Celes's suicide attempt in Final Fantasy VI. Both are heartbreaking.

  • @mariusanonimus2066
    @mariusanonimus2066 5 років тому +17

    Why need shepard quarian junk ships?! Geth is badass with approval.

    • @tcmugutc01
      @tcmugutc01 4 роки тому +3

      They deserved to be wiped out really. But i dont have that heart

    • @venomdragon7853
      @venomdragon7853 3 роки тому +6

      @@tcmugutc01 the geth only acted in self defense in every senario besides a small splinter group (heretics) that were brainwashed and used by sovereign and the reapers.
      Every other time the quarians Instigated, they forced the geth to attack back, they forced the geth to run to the reapers, every act they took was self preservation. They did not want to fight or kill them, at all. The fact that they let them leave rannoch is proof of that.

    • @darkmaguire9656
      @darkmaguire9656 3 роки тому

      @@venomdragon7853 yeah I rewrote the heretics so that the geth have more war asstets then quarians but destroy is canon so geth will die anyway it feels incomplete, but they can be rebuilt, it will be faster if there are more quarian assets.

    • @jasonvoorhees5180
      @jasonvoorhees5180 3 роки тому +3

      @@venomdragon7853 No the geth were not “brainwashed” to join the reapers at least not at the time sovereign was around they CHOSE to join with him and Saren due to a difference in computations amongst the rest of the geth consensus and the remaining geth _let them leave_ . Sovereign made them an offer and they _accepted_ it while the rest of the geth rejected it. It’s the whole reason sovereign was disgusted that the heretic geth revered him as a god, all of that is their own choice. The ultimate goal of the geth was to create a Dyson sphere-like project to house all geth programs, sovereign offered them the technology to do it in exchange for helping him with the reaper invasion and the heretics accepted the request, no brainwashing involved.

  • @codet2093
    @codet2093 Рік тому +4

    No matter how many times I play this I always choose tali

    • @gabematthews4532
      @gabematthews4532 4 місяці тому

      All the way
      NGL I accidentally sided with the geth and had to reload (I hate paragon traps)
      Why’d they even put the paragon interrupt there if it’s useless

    • @Quole1234
      @Quole1234 3 місяці тому

      ​@gabematthews4532 why would you choose the geth when tali is begging you not to? Congrats, it's canon that you sided with the geth even if you reloaded later

    • @gabematthews4532
      @gabematthews4532 3 місяці тому

      @@Quole1234 well I didn’t know I was picking a side I mean it’s not like it said “let the quarians die” if it said something more clear or if I didn’t go back and save legion then I’d have made sure the code wasn’t uploaded
      But if I’d known her people were going to die I’d have never chosen it but I made the mistake of trusting a machine
      I don’t think siding with the Geth would be canon I mean if anything from that is canon it would have to be peace between the 2

  • @TheNocturnal1
    @TheNocturnal1 2 роки тому +3

    My first ever play through of the third game went so well without even knowing the requirements to get peace on both sides, woohoo!

    • @allhandsondik7803
      @allhandsondik7803 2 роки тому

      I was this close, but like a Lawful Stupid paragon character I chose to honor Koris' wish to save his people and let him die, unfortunately he was the last piece of my puzzle and I lost him. Couldn't Damn the Geth for defending themselves and proceeded to weep like a baby for a good 10 minutes.

    • @Quole1234
      @Quole1234 9 місяців тому

      @@allhandsondik7803 you're such a dunce.

  • @Hellion73
    @Hellion73 2 роки тому +1

    Well, realistically, they asked for it...not that I ever allowed to happen, but still🤷‍♂️😡

    • @Quole1234
      @Quole1234 9 місяців тому

      no they didn't. One admiral did.

    • @Hellion73
      @Hellion73 9 місяців тому

      @@Quole1234 Man, it was a messed up history that goes thru 300 yrs and worst of all, they allowed the admirals start a conflict in the midst of the Reaper invasion, which was just a stupid move😒...no symphaties for them at that point into the story😡

    • @Quole1234
      @Quole1234 9 місяців тому

      @Hellion73 millions of innocents. You can't blame the civilians for the actions of the admirals. The irony here is that you are ignoring what the heretics did. You know, joining the reapers and trying to wipe out all life in the galaxy? The true geth made the choice of allowing them to do that and didn't even warn anyone. That is worse than ANYTHING the quarians have done.

  • @GL12878
    @GL12878 12 років тому +3

    Does anybody know if choosing to empower the geth gives paragon vs killing off the geth? If somebody wanted to go full paragon/renegade but couldn't choose peace what should they choose?

    • @allhandsondik7803
      @allhandsondik7803 2 роки тому

      Idk, I think this is one of those decisions the game veiws as truly neutral, though the placement and nature of the choice makes me believe the Geth are truly the good guys here.

  • @apocryphaemiya9331
    @apocryphaemiya9331 3 роки тому +3

    the thing is, geth is the sweetest child ever if you watch me 3. They even considered to surrendered themselves. Ironically everything they did in morning war they learn it from their parents, and when they do realize and understand what they did, they let the quarians go and isolate themselves

  • @Tsanschy
    @Tsanschy 11 років тому +4

    you're doing it right, bro!

  • @MrAlucard1986
    @MrAlucard1986 3 роки тому +7

    If I can't achieve peace between the 2, then I choose the Geth all the way. The Quarians deserved this 100%

    • @maximussaktish
      @maximussaktish 2 роки тому

      I cant achieve peace so i was about to choose the geth until i learnt that this would kill tali

    • @Hellion73
      @Hellion73 2 роки тому

      Yep, agree...but EAware putted a great efford on make 3 of the 4 main alien species as nonsensical AHs: All of them doing stupid things in the midst of a galactic genocide, but worst among all were the Quarians and their obsesion with Rannoch and the Asari hiding Vendetta🤦‍♂️

  • @harbingerzwiastun7642
    @harbingerzwiastun7642 12 років тому +2

    Geth ? Choose Reapers !

  • @muhammad_soa
    @muhammad_soa 4 роки тому +2

    i always chose geth

  • @liamclarke91
    @liamclarke91 12 років тому +1

    The VI is also more condescending. And there's no chance for peace.

  • @barbs19788
    @barbs19788 12 років тому +1

    I liked Legion but hated the Geth. Easy choice in the end.

  • @jimbeaux89
    @jimbeaux89 2 роки тому +2

    Legion uses battle meditation*
    “This is admiral dadonna. All ships pull back”!!
    Master vrook* “there is no retreat”

  • @FEaddict
    @FEaddict 4 роки тому +5

    Anyone who made Tali cry here is a monster. How dare.

    • @allhandsondik7803
      @allhandsondik7803 2 роки тому +1

      Cause she is one person out of an entire race of mini Batarians, they created the Geth and chose at every corner to choose hate and violence over peace, is damning a whole race worth one person? I hated to hear her cry and see her die, I myself cried for a solid 10 minutes after, but at the end of the day, one woman isn't enough to justify the damnation of a much more peaceful and forward thinking race, imo.

    • @Quole1234
      @Quole1234 9 місяців тому

      @@allhandsondik7803 lol you are ignoring the millions of innocents. And forgetting that the geth sided with the reaerps. The geth allowed the heretics to join them and didnt try to warn anyone.

    • @allhandsondik7803
      @allhandsondik7803 9 місяців тому +1

      @Quole1234 Get a life, my man. You pick the same fight with me in 4 separate comment threads on this video, and they've all been embarrassing for you. Just give up, my man.
      Edit: actually this is a different vid, but man we've already been through this

    • @Quole1234
      @Quole1234 9 місяців тому

      @@allhandsondik7803 and you are wrong either way

    • @Quole1234
      @Quole1234 9 місяців тому

      @@allhandsondik7803 ur the one justifying killing millions of innocents

  • @donmarz7030
    @donmarz7030 Рік тому +1

    I have chosen the Quarians, The Geths we're lying on me while, I was inquiring to Geth VI. So it made me realize, what if these I. A. Betrayed us in the future. I can't afford that. Even if they showed me their origins. Tali fight for her homeworld. Just imagine, if Human homeworld was taken by A. I. For sure we will fight to the death, to retake it. But I guess it depends on every players Perspective.

  • @legefy
    @legefy 12 років тому +1

    Forgive me Tali.

  • @BoredomVirusXP
    @BoredomVirusXP 2 роки тому

    Anyone know what the song is played during the choice part?

  • @oluwahefner4194
    @oluwahefner4194 3 роки тому +1

    Anyone that chooses synthetic life over organic life is fucking insane

    • @Dark_Voice
      @Dark_Voice 2 роки тому +2

      Thing is, Quarians were always the issue, not the Geth.

    • @TheNocturnal1
      @TheNocturnal1 2 роки тому +1

      Dark Voice nope.

    • @TheInSaNeTenno
      @TheInSaNeTenno 2 роки тому +1

      @@Dark_Voice Pretty much this. The Geth only asked if they had souls and most of the Quarians went apeshit and tried to cause a synthetic genocide against them in response. They only wanted to understand organics and have sought peace whenever possible (minus the heretics). The Quarians have no one to blame but themselves.

    • @Quole1234
      @Quole1234 9 місяців тому

      @@Dark_Voice wrong

  • @jwhertsch
    @jwhertsch 2 роки тому +4

    I remember my first playthrough years ago. I chose the geth because I felt they deserved a chance at life and because they had not chosen the war.
    And then when Tali died, I just turned off my machine. I couldn't play the game anymore that night.

  • @IIxGrAiNgErxII
    @IIxGrAiNgErxII 12 років тому +3

    i got both sides to seek peace and now the Quarians and the Geth aid me in battle :)

  • @mender2047
    @mender2047 10 місяців тому +1

    Самый запоминающийся момент в игре, я все ещё помню как я плакал и думал что сделал неправильный выбор, даже в том задании оно говорила как мечтает построить дом, так грустно было

    • @Quole1234
      @Quole1234 3 місяці тому

      You did make the wrong choice

  • @6turmovak
    @6turmovak 12 років тому +2

    Mine were pretty high (100% I guess?), but I guess I did something wrong in my previous conversations and also advised the quarians to wage war in ME2 (hadn't met legion). I feel like explaining myself because, damn, imagine, how Shepard would feel in real life. Some of these scenes make the story feel so real and not at all like a video game.

  • @commandershepard13
    @commandershepard13 12 років тому +1

    @DrNaviii Raan, Reegar and Tali...that's about it for me ( I forgot Raan the first time I posted)
    The rest of the Quarians come off a bit...IDK, Douche bag like? I really can't think of the proper words to describe it, they're just unlikable.

  • @FroggerTheToad
    @FroggerTheToad 11 років тому

    To be honest, you sound a bit like a fanboy right now.

  • @gokunumberone
    @gokunumberone 12 років тому +1

    When I first watched these on my Xbox I hadn't played me2. So it didn't let me save both and saving geth was the right choice. So i chose geth. But when the qurians started dying I watched with my mouth odisable whole time. When I heard Tali cry... Man :'( now that made me shed a tear!.

  • @silentkiller9000
    @silentkiller9000 12 років тому

    maybe cynical and proud

  • @CowardlyZebra
    @CowardlyZebra 11 років тому

    @The136st I totally agree

  • @stevenlittrel2648
    @stevenlittrel2648 3 роки тому +1

    If you think about it, the Quarians were the aggressors in this war… but Tail killing herself was heartbreaking.

    • @Dark_Voice
      @Dark_Voice 2 роки тому

      I think Quarians are third most warlike and aggressive race only surpassed by the Yahg and Krogan.

    • @citrineconjurer
      @citrineconjurer 2 роки тому +1

      That's the point of the dilemma. The quarians are at fault for this war, but they are the people of Tali, one of your most loyal friends (or girlfriend) and can be trusted to help you against the reapers. On the other hand the geth have generally been hostile to Shepard and are especially alien, being inorganic, and therefore difficult to trust.
      Basically the quarians are in the wrong but you can count on them to be your allies and you've established an emotional connection to them whereas the geth are in the right but have more dubious loyalty.
      I chose to save the geth from the more brutal perspective that they would be more helpful in fighting the reapers becayse they are showing themselves to be more capable than the quarians right there and we can't take chances when the extinction of all sentience in the galaxy is on the table. Looking back though I was more cold hearted then than I am now and I would probably be stuck sitting at that decision for a long time before resetting the game to manage the peace option as I couldn't bear to betray Tali or Legion.

    • @Quole1234
      @Quole1234 9 місяців тому

      @@citrineconjurer you are such a dunce. The geth have sided with the repaers so many times, and have proven to be a massive liability. There's nothing stopping them from siding with the reapers again as soon as things dont go well. Not to mention the quarians were annihilating the geth until the reapers showed up and the geth joined them, so you are wrong about 'the geth proving to be more capable'.

  • @wolfeusmc2011
    @wolfeusmc2011 3 місяці тому

    When I played through I was lucky I had enough renegade to warn the Quarians....and I stand by that decision... I know Tali Romances will hate me but like the Terminator if a machine can learn the value of life so can we in my playthrough was...."If you don't stop attacking I will standby and watch the Geth lay you all to waste." Can synthetics live with organics yes they can...

  • @KaelanF
    @KaelanF 10 років тому +1

    Anyone know the song at 1:21

  • @alexandro420
    @alexandro420 11 років тому +3

    You are calling people "idiots" for choices they make playing a video game? You must develop some very deep relationships in real life! How lucky for you!

  • @oskarniepowiem1776
    @oskarniepowiem1776 12 років тому

    Geth say they are sorry for creators, thats the best proth that they did deserved to be saved.

  • @MultiAn0n
    @MultiAn0n 12 років тому

    Legion is replaced by Geth IV who basically is the same as Legion minus the hole and N7 armor.

  • @Muzzly1234
    @Muzzly1234 12 років тому

    It has taken 5 tries for me to finish this bloody scene

  • @fagri81
    @fagri81 12 років тому

    mine worse

  • @edophoneix1340
    @edophoneix1340 Рік тому +1

    I choose the geth🤖